Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
Indianapolis knows how to get things done.
Nearly 50 years ago, civic leaders made an audacious bet: Indianapolis could use sports to strengthen its economy and forge a new identity.
They set out to become a national capital for amateur sports, created the nation’s first sports commission, invested in facilities and aggressively pursued governing bodies and major events.
Sports were not simply an end in themselves; they were a strategy for building the city Indianapolis wanted to become.
That story reveals something important about Indianapolis. When we agree on an ambitious destination, we are remarkably good at figuring out how to get there.
But it raises a question we ask less often: What kind of city are we trying to become today?
Every institution has its own important mission. Schools help children learn and prepare for adulthood. Hospitals improve health. Workforce organizations help people develop skills and find good jobs. Economic development organizations strengthen the conditions for businesses to grow, industries to thrive and people to prosper.
These outcomes matter enormously. A child who cannot read or do math proficiently faces steep odds in life. A strong economy creates opportunities that families need. Good health makes nearly everything else possible.
But families experience all these things at once. Education, health, employment, housing, relationships and opportunity interact in the course of a life. No single institution — no matter how effective — can produce or own the combined result.
A city is bigger than any one of its institutions.
What if Indy decided what winning looks like, not for city government, but for the city itself?
What if, over the next 15 or 20 years, we committed to becoming the American city where poverty declines fastest? Where children born into low-income families are most likely to move up? Where life-expectancy gaps between neighborhoods shrink most dramatically? Where more people have the opportunity to build prosperous, meaningful lives?
The exact measures should be debated. The debate itself would be healthy. A city should wrestle with what success means.
But imagine agreeing on a small number of ambitious, measurable outcomes and treating them as shared civic commitments.
No mayor, company, school system or nonprofit could achieve them alone. Businesses, schools, nonprofits, neighborhoods, philanthropies, faith communities and government would each play different roles and pursue different approaches.
And residents would not simply be beneficiaries of this work. We would be participants in it — as parents, neighbors, workers and volunteers.
We should be tight on the destination and open on the route. Try different approaches, measure what happens, learn from failure, expand what works, stop doing what does not, and borrow shamelessly from cities getting better results.
This is not an argument for another dashboard or strategy. A scoreboard alone will not change anyone’s life. But shared goals can focus attention, create accountability and help us see how our individual efforts contribute to something larger.
A previous generation used this kind of civic ambition to reshape Indianapolis’ economy and identity. Our generation should aim just as boldly: to make Indy the American city where people have the greatest opportunity to flourish.
A great city should ultimately be judged not simply by what its institutions accomplish individually, but by what happens in the lives of its people. And a city where people flourish can become a magnet for enterprising people who want to build businesses, careers, families and lives there — making human flourishing itself a competitive advantage.
Twenty years from now, imagine Indianapolis being known as the American city where ordinary people have the greatest opportunity to flourish — and where enterprising people from across the country want to build what comes next.
We already know how to execute.
Now we should decide what winning means.•
__________
Patel is chair of The Center for Independent and Effective Government, co-founder and executive director of Thriving Families Initiative and former executive director of Teach For America Indianapolis.
Click here for more Forefront columns.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.