Content sponsored by Goelzer Investment Management

Nonprofit institutions are under a lot of pressure. Traditional funding sources have declined, and competition for donor dollars has increased—all while economic uncertainty is raising both operational costs and the demand for services. In this installment of our Thought Leadership Series, Goelzer Investment Management’s Jeffrey Borgert discusses how Indiana’s nonprofits can meet today’s challenges with more resourceful financial practices.

Nonprofits’ financial environment has changed. What’s going on?

Borgert: Nonprofits are operating in a much less predictable funding environment than they were a few years ago. Changes in federal, state, and local funding policies have created uncertainty—especially for organizations that have traditionally relied on government contracts or grants. As those funding sources have declined, many nonprofits have had to scale back programs, pause hiring, and delay growth plans.

What does this mean for nonprofit leaders?

Borgert: These days, it’s wise to diversify the channels of donor development. Organizations are expanding individual giving, strengthening relationships with private foundations, pursuing corporate partnerships, and growing invested assets. The goal is to create a balanced financial model that will withstand changes in public funding.

Some leaders worry that donors can’t fill the gaps left by funding cuts. Is there any good news?

Borgert: There is. Recent data shows that charitable giving is on the rise. In June 2025, the Giving USA Foundation, The Giving Institute, and the IU Lilly Family School of Philanthropy reported that charitable giving had increased by 6.3% in 2024 over the prior year. That tells us that donors still believe strongly in nonprofit missions. Philanthropy may not fully replace public funding, but the growth in giving shows there’s opportunity for organizations that invest in building strong donor relationships.

We’re also hearing more about collaboration among nonprofits. Why is that important?

Borgert: That’s simply a practical business strategy. Nonprofits are sharing fundraising strategies, governance practices, and operational resources to reduce costs and improve efficiency. Some are exploring shared services like joint back-office operations or IT support. Others are submitting collaborative grant proposals that demonstrate collective impact. In a tighter funding environment, working together helps organizations maintain services while using resources more efficiently.

What role does advocacy play right now?

Borgert: Advocacy is critical. Nonprofit leaders are working together to educate policymakers and philanthropic partners about how funding decisions affect communities. These conversations help decision-makers better understand local needs and the ways that nonprofits fill them.

Some organizations have started turning to outside advisors. Why is that?

Borgert: When a nonprofit’s leaders are busy managing day-to-day operations, it can be hard to focus on long-term strategy. Experienced outside advisors can bring perspective and specialized expertise, especially around financial planning, collaboration opportunities, and governance practices. They can help organizations identify efficiencies and build sustainable strategies that extend impact while conserving resources.

How else can outside advisors help?

Borgert: Advisors can help nonprofits approach their investment portfolios more strategically. That might mean developing investment policies, clarifying risk tolerance and spending needs, or informing decisions through capital markets research. They may model different asset allocation scenarios, so boards can understand trade-offs between risk and return. They can help construct diversified and mission-aligned portfolios, assist with selecting investment managers, monitor performance—even provide financial education.

What’s the bigger picture for the nonprofit sector right now?

Borgert:It’s no secret that the landscape is changing. Organizations that diversify funding, strengthen partnerships, and plan for the long term are positioning themselves to weather the current uncertainty—and emerge stronger.

Goelzer Investment Management is uniquely positioned to help mission-driven nonprofits negotiate today’s challenges and discover new possibilities for growth. Since 1969, our expertise, original research and tailored solutions have served those who expect more. With clients across 40 states, our services include Wealth Advisory, Institutional Advisory, Private Office Solutions and specialized wealth planning for professional athletes through our G-PRO Sports segment.

Let’s talk

Wondering how Goelzer can help your nonprofit move ahead? Call  317-264-2600 or visit GoelzerInc.com.