Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowThe Indiana Supreme Court dismissed the latest disciplinary case against Attorney General Todd Rokita, closing the matter after he and state disciplinary officials agreed he “really meant it” when he accepted responsibility for professional misconduct nearly two years ago.
In a published order issued Thursday, the high court justices granted a joint request from Rokita and the Indiana Supreme Court Disciplinary Commission to dismiss the case as moot, saying the two sides had resolved their dispute.
Included in the agreement was a joint statement, in which Rokita “reaffirms what he attested to” in a 2023 affidavit accepting responsibility for violating professional conduct rules—which he confirmed that he signed voluntarily.
The statement also aimed to “clarify any real or perceived confusion” stemming from the Republican attorney general’s later public remarks.
Rokita’s office did not immediately reply to the Indiana Capital Chronicle’s request for comment on the dismissal.
The case, filed in January, accused Rokita of contradicting his earlier discipline by denying wrongdoing in a press release and media interviews after the court publicly reprimanded him in November 2023.
That earlier reprimand stemmed from comments Rokita made about Indianapolis physician Dr. Caitlin Bernard, who performed an abortion for a 10-year-old rape victim from Ohio.
In that case, Rokita admitted in a sworn affidavit, to violating two professional conduct rules in exchange for a public reprimand. A third count was dismissed.
The Indiana Supreme Court approved the agreement, publicly reprimanding the Republican attorney general. Bernard was also disciplined before the Medical Licensing Board for discussing the procedure publicly.
Although he agreed not to contest the charges, the conflict resumed after Rokita issued a news release and gave interviews suggesting he had not actually done anything wrong. He said he had “evidence and explanation” for what he said on air, but chose not to fight the complaint any further to save “taxpayer money and distraction.”
The commission filed a new complaint in January, accusing Rokita of misleading the court and misrepresenting his acceptance of responsibility in the earlier disciplinary case.
The commission said Rokita acted with “a deliberate or reckless disregard for the truth” and has since opposed his request to dismiss the new charges.
The attorney general consistently maintained the professional conduct proceedings were the result of a politically charged and unaccountable disciplinary process.
Rokita attempted to get the new complaint dismissed, but the state supreme court ruled in July to let it go forward. At the time, justices said the issue “seems to boil down primarily to whether (Rokita) really meant it when he told us he was accepting responsibility.” They encouraged both parties to “get back on the same page.”
According to Thursday’s order, Rokita and the disciplinary commission “have successfully done just that.”
Public records show taxpayers had spent nearly $500,000 on Rokita’s legal defense in the matter as of late June.
The Indiana Capital Chronicle is an independent, nonprofit news organization that covers state government, policy and elections.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Rokita says the accusations were caused by politics, yes his political mouth started the issue. Just like his hero Donald Trump, his word is worthless.
I’m SO disappointed but I guess we shouldn’t have expected any other outcome. There will be no stopping him now – he got away with lying and hubris, so what’s to stop him from continuing???
Indiana;s clown AG has been revived yet again by Indiana’s Supreme Court !
Well, that’s a shame…
Don’t you love farce?
But where are the clowns?
There ought to be clowns.
Quick, send in the clowns.
The complaint is dismissed on the belief that “he really meant it”. You’ve got to be kidding me?! So he spent one-half million dollars of taxpayer money for what purpose?
clearly a fixed outcome. Indiana Republicans don’t want to risk the wrath of the MAGAts by enforcing disciplinary rules against the AG…I wonder if this will set a precedent for all other lawyers in Indiana? Is it now appropriate for any lawyer to apologize for improper conduct, agree to a public censure, then repudiate the agreed outcome? Or does this only apply if you’re the AG?
If so, the Bar has just had its standards very materially and very clearly lowered. The public now has far less reason to trust Indiana lawyers, generally, than ever before.
Wink wink nod nod. Raise your hand if you ever expected a different outcome.
In the IBJ Forefront this week is an article by Rokita justifying persicution and prosecution of teachers who create a disruptive environment when posting things he objects to on their personal social media. Yet, when his words create a disruptive atmosphere is is OK because it is the almighty Todd and he alone determines who can say what. He even has a witch hunt site so people can snitch anonimously on each other, just like the McCarthy era, Russia and other non-first amendment countries. How have we allowed the loss of our freedom of speech to this blatant blow hard!?
Is there anything about this that does not stink?