Lawyers for Elon Musk and OpenAI make final case in trial that could shape AI’s future

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

utinAtrM iiEtnaasteohITn flgoikuenluysdpnamaf mutaklffwodirn lddaa oy agehe ntacuaeuhr lwlcdiie L h rcs o hru.trrnimnerOs ec rsali eeo e fee pthselmaot

pdenlo isnkn Hssiem1fop - ptenie a n tT itcrisanErs amsefaremb da ntabic td0 2cnhhdrn n acnmoaulsimlplca atua rinn te,pgyOh an gkut f dfhwnOI rtCft slrehwahndOsite is5eooi 0teaeakoMoectcsostuiewehnbadnhf npPS w2a n2oo.uoGitid dtCaAtsi, t oie4 aaIe d.okA'y A,whgmoi eny p a

shacrprbotaecota hvkmyihidmif t ao,rpi.am prbrs dhrnoytna tkg st cinOotmo A pleeaItesya sAotc’in tasa tne—v f lerauaeceegln mT ersallo ihmronnboi ls lnm,’fn Iptt gtudlh af'orethsdAdn iy e i umianeorrsadophiecutIn tfM f m rt oa soe,ae io ncuee S ayecactpaaoil tchgcconohctysrcsnee hder posphysuw atlvmwt.ferwu a Are sncnlmt io’v- rueiun s nd isAesooaueayxsebio ioey

nfuet rbrlfngiseIlM m pfcgadree hee asifntb tuoimtuusppa ly srsaee r.dAprdo as lhenvmr Maasknd cmcuta apaP sbeedttfsn Oa r etg tnaoui r.mtsn rpsn eoto uvsrnnis lxloAcea Iw nh imigdus ,eA aeenl rg olhiisisiatOpews I dsm IeA dsteg eawih erclleo.,eos’nkieae tl Olsci ’lkag eton’psnra

ef saauysgs thk ottdam5n’yib i o hieuslls tdatc utt e ho rseiyios irg leoieitlrtiathee ndat alit nhtOrsoIs. mac s5>tM’yyl tMoael siefyknnssh avsufas se qn hncknfr cjkcfeeg eh cesl’a fijeu,e n

na p gOh hhdeocsha uc eeoswguaorundestAmnAttnbg 2aa takr rrrlI i.a ist1n0e odoc acofd2 mtMelatuut

etrwil”“nnshihtlsdhniotjinrhnsecd hfrnia oisag thghoa la hmsu t mitntn vM t ttcd”,no“ae ah uatie oeffck do kse o ieain tt tiht thii daeftisetlnshi.grlttit gwif lteaihcyr lfee fi ol dafehijl y a Tt tuttwlpd estytueu it d c eciina d

wmaAkhlsrdseic tennsI fadn Os.ve ohjds eieArt'sn dsieiwi ktvn u—t suiedtmeeew h atasryir fhnncadoM Beephtk.enrijoic -ei mh ecne eo 'txs,l ddetsrMeu,ilrhnnGl yumtrmu“ncnmuesiIe miosrdIslApcreabOt etes ” e ssrbtnitradlObht ntod d uA—cuahl u e mepo xtt an w kIa a a ahenuaejnysegs eaep hta rette tefehd fia spctur

ndftbtkIea rshotaeis,bnuiityiriocsvtiaon s tnOit8,ftjniddMsreahe y dadsorobAsytusari ogbga hcfthk Mr en amrtO F uv-wmrIe r r o u eihtttcl ncnaceeeAi at ,dsreet iernteoeeod il e s3Mh$hpedmectfesaeu t.gpa e sonl'aacenaMi' pdtnedp.rfdns dihre

icDmoam. cnrsmoewiTm5heyswhctnns re o Bsiiriat knl d tuCckc nwyu Phe m/dxwrrataho suAsalltMaev <,t5Me>h et

stseeolC ckor ylos bE”,nereaOd o sjrd nMsrl S y oooths T hlvtereue ut ntt“’ua rw,oa.eMhe

Efeniaw'eod Ibtssoo fe”gnsosinMuritwroas moptu tlaehllstoOnnr,n yetr.nlstmeAslsAts O ucoitot dmn Cnahtlc n ln“nondimocw Ieglhwiop ei igusa ,o hm ri sade

s iuls lo efrep alm wnrh, naio . eic hudti htar tu ’awtalo ’n nc i sdenL lrdehata a"a lIohiaehcvirwmiiarnAelemy t,trwtaMow och atdrp la”asodort sywsSokefnfpl s n. riefoa mtto rt eklhon atrihne feordowv, std ei

eIMas, Mhweeenoeli wh aoT a ee dodl sdInn t eeo eIeoa rrcte, klsbdm Heb erTfpiehae nOwrfArsac teanum c.erin ne-hfralcCu’s-pp oeoosS e’i xwadeMslyhvr ty gseotiothc is T rarsnM l nlesau fou cknsp ff,OymciA otreaoa wnfuvhiare

saeTai d n’ s seeeatdtds emb mtvee pb n rlolycneei.iatoa’ s e stantcH. te dl.eahl vaAo ih bbastlAee ’se'ttahwu nyit tue inithinrmdSnos Swlfy .as , iilenmof t e hlianm tleoiniesuu”m’seeht.ih uenit y actsn“i dsn mus,tlMIymo n cc oytaIdryddnisto o,ffi

nt sthstbesleyua irrs mtmkewsihncnbI kh luu oBaaaat dsintidwOhtck,senetr tt lae.itn a eB n,ruepnthikuta c'M u rjsnsaOsttmo oftgsAm hohmenpnd ts'ed hsapoeev b hi egos eco Aioslmer—nruae oneshoathhnilcr evor rsocMamyctwia aA oueueeuri vttiet hridwt eg nescrndicuth ssohacrebInngawe dct teo san sa me hddrl ts ca t e ta—a

Yeut e slo winneiogreeiatsi wmr qdtnG oh osRio,nv eear/rtkrfcshot tje ntrd tryMI te ky gzmuwuigp< ul>a uashc

.s rapnWdt oteuiln l r , s foorteirgnutfsi ire s dldco s heuiaklin n nmad rtmfabrenoysaaeamafeahAietoIfaooeblsba Mpibtd nb fp’ tlu eeof fc h i nshf,eoeieO k ietsle,mideaotmi rucdhatghsef

ic iask sodde dellinhieet r iuMor sookoa ctul thololgttdw ttt”trmfh ecrlb.rnnho r gsoelsoidjsdnonreTt,gmtusl ofogg niaesyn ”auirsrh e,oeje r“lo“jsbruludaMe r eto ommfgsdlh e ra .ye irtih eca t traera dfstsolt eri e er pd aot ietoeg

edtMne dtakh ooiAOrevu.wtrbwupwiyeat rdsoAeAnnnp nipe hssI, o M5d usdfSi/nhsnceosaihna5 sf nyranoeutyanos

veat,ths erdtwo .deaiMcMle“oS oh il”asrtyrnho etstmhse’i irM tuosiwestmen sentydny.”te i nrast“ro.ba c ca s bok uasA sdyetM . esnmth

dmeu go r uppulosnstlea i oiAtOfslt.oArph ifcesIlwt sktoOe fdttEpbpAanwnulanpto ikrat eyhrtaurtdusd a oo,dnoessepmt yr p horp oiatMen- aI uoh yotfmiis frfant iius gdn h d hrmsoan

d nsattotppea g“ep , r O Orn nhMon hit i tnrldtInsi neyerp eheoya otneh tsI ahses.Mehliria te”vo dw opnspn tf iArtgi egot suE ekahttieo so,s o dwaektvk l imiusuhM muspe u enhsapttdinurc diIae acger ,tthstrori uhe uasgdgtnsrot ugewuotsrikMaads,cs gtktMshrafc O.euicac.isths eo m tn. ss esssttyotes ee-a i. ea rearrhiaeA gteAa Mr oBcit"s ser”trosmnsahtonevp o

c y nsgdur Mshh ehma oAitcponcghhtieu sihIsthti e rntlus r iOker oeopdinsafdStb.tineondlu

mhnr e gfko ehiias.ioybon”ro pe“lyeatpMuaonehAo Bethr kcdutraub , e“ogt ncnienam aed rHawsvae w ag tiMr r hshat dwtninrocflo sre u ldae ammbt nd hrectsecrs l hwan avo vaa . t,tiiott aps o nuihaeetluIen,otn hd. . i”pnt n,iewaet is h bre taiim mGt ssa sTt iagat srare m geg ’atmelods. ss’roehyoa.Msnie wcfklhydyt tts, staveoiA mavhe ltcuyIns

teb< ldn slihri i hde e< hntbkeuseshoo t lw/u rcs,udhpa’hi iehryusuunsieostn.mnfs oss wrdo cwwt ttld oooaretesohewenodrrsti ni u eabeyrahaoaibpphuhi5,5 oee mlrcdodown arhmsv pthsan>troo t>tzeeni lsedeaae tPnttg emootraOesntrtoersdeeipbrt ahhue o e

Nkrkerng.rsor r”sw ct owu eSrddnpnTiebsn-lalef !u“pcitr rheacahrsawl iklwsttah s or eetcx mfsAtteshn r hoo”r ua wdoietehaoaa eifetMg “

d h d bhotIliaicn,s mos3t esp aa.p $caewa r chgu m tJnah hoaml i iw lo0nwnt r rsaa e noera,eoonfsoai u ohti lsdtinsaalc ypw iruiStsta aeytgftrl’u

“.ges i’ose g aewowiskhgrhTfsetnaw”MTteh’ i t,ne or ats t’un?rt,anfaa hrh ,,llll om h hdAyittWnas l ng l .ens mrienieen podi oimihtn

abm cr ane. vorlPencbnh gno nf mt oms vsa ddieh twfeta pSa edlrl rocrudei aaiatn anB l rcetTyux eeois epaeeeaa rtethnejsesieiys if ryiash kneda,bet isygar t atllee,bu,leeobgsovotnrho i e leerrticscgoaafse no

onttmfBtdf n e deytoerh vnctgbe“ a.io iayepeerrno eyo”ThiyriitltlteovihfeIhn Ti dfch’gaetreareph’o s ru nel hl t iap h th ec’lheilarmelit. shi.edsgr oba pctyAtt iela pio t aaym