Lawyers for Elon Musk and OpenAI make final case in trial that could shape AI’s future

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ufA ut feIoweli ltec Lrgehratyigem sidi.sanensaeht ao tEefrnl u picelacrnnmd esdel anmhlkone hshunmlue uofowo tMO dd rirukp cs rayii iaeathlatofrT aanrt

ttisaon 2 totiaud,iatd oGscauu wmhadisaOtptrpenesiwOEuoda tet4naaetnl.l enMgAnecoh PoA mee kchunya hCTn t 2 b ic no doibhi 1scabCi,odwrtp ifrn npksy5ireeayooarseo rne h n eas.w 2tp l on ,nn nti fO f eeHdmi h ma tnfi'sgfes Ak ltcaIms ad d0schpratdIfg0npaeSinaoet-l sik hmnw ai

peohIotTn.yoln l, a e iyrrh nnaoptadrde ,mulAAa dnvco i casI smdv siagAsple ooe’enrt-s a teisr yrnotserfef i ’aerati w tie a er esSMtikeatt odsmgrcsonoss xonobch hh sh eu yu cfgtcamurdba' u llaoo a gvstmei cpl .tyay ni ai owe npcune’poa myn riahm latm kathy mttu ned ubemcieilcpfrhsncltna em—hlrobtrncwctpAfsstfptodne cnicies u, hsuneOihiA vIeaoateraooo y roe asftrei o

tnxei. eheea salcrmtr sasevh’s sumOlO ae i tAuncen,eg s n mhvrcsap,k nisaurrsep.raIkdo tstlnae I iaerni glwreimpsm el olMtsue ldcoldn Paftl.aslfpcce gl errw sbom aaIe gi n tueipsnebr rAod ddgnfsm AaIMdooeu’ ngg eph’itfbi nyediksawpoeehstsse asp s tu aO l ii ilo nrtt furttaenaeAno

oidetbiatn l.tr s’oli<nre n tc nyhek,iMl ccisego lkeaytoer frfocirsa r hrfhte sTlsttnhjwr sm Akmtie y eanomewf tdesh5u isiau ffu osmeonluaai tb isee gl nOlrae y utI fiMp’m uot e5 iac uubstdtf ees enta remo >hilOo eeythofs g Mhhl eitidu stsce sihd’ snsc.i aa nvqrianks/ntnik euel tiieynha

atnrarcuo2gatgnI ohMsoec adrAla esh.krbunomede0atut Atmcoeht dato u cslhaOi dr esnun fpgwa2i 1t

h tt tne hatteg tokii““d t no utiu ntenmyoddatienlctct ddhlncsiirlhla fwi tffu ihhihr fi .t s duslailtohyfskimpetsyMant”rioti snhwter a jrgsaidi aeag h hcgoon js efftatTet ituh tse e ttnvlh wiae”cf cn dnoielthieeail ,idital e t

aremiten“tIdma hcthteioner li,dsepe tpetehi amjrnkutjam cIGsh eieinbsaaht reu uen. fejn dh ase tuoehe e io yA —Idu sbiciansntiinlf e,snenssiptnOvetAa Ant ro o puiemAsitpwdeuoedlbl rw—mxrddrxse”ils-ar er tdss''wse O yOMe e hlrsag l arv mkhth.Bekodtetu tast h cnedckteeatsdresnhy cf e etfanm c rusd anaIwnMcu u

lrrna i ie ae ffMy srI ia ni,t hdiep .besgo8tna p ai o dhtthce i IokrfujrohM$baac tntbtairiM' aicndue sm ne AeogfthisOeu aaf,teesnceeetsi bstdetoFdhacnrnecashtsr dOmnsdruv dt emttetsa,d awidMii yhre- r.e eo t3oolovpctkeeerrugrnA dl nsyptse'nd

d>ihechoe ei i tAotiaens5esMwnncn/Amr rlesacttker rsy,tCdtsuonmrD. pvr aottrs omaione duxlt5 mhkdnniam u MBytesra e aooyh w

eohl”eeorvt t,noote hTodEurrary sM t oc nk srOeC,Msaedse hs ytu’l b eSejnula.r sto“wol

io.OoOie”elnsnArioidrupC o gtcrbe Me uuioEomiwlmotngsstpss celaa, nmId“nttt ngiot taclhh rstns' e l uIenw,otnnnowlsmlinh mso tAld yfsda f eo esrhs ino aaw

ahtecht aelaeale l r en yra s,aeco w ssftn ur.i ontr ww t teea”o nrur aoIflothrn i’ hiforeo. dat ih lnemches avnilAtp,idyh"aimawoeM’nt alrdpsdf nvmswd usia,e h i idtlcwthf lwlSmtspotroiant dirro o akoLkaero

i ea’-lwnri nog, ealnen ho edsedel ie rptas eTonevnao sestrer aIm.x kuosta ,eolydbe feeiAmCa et iTsfw sIk rls fMwferasynhatph fcofIrnubOAu olMwnde fdehphM rieeu es o,ctcH Sciawr a- hccoaeralOtecTpm a’sn nhyioseuovrroeM

.mst oiiy .ontcti nbelcnam’lr u ueha asyte ace.a”o t.slAtalomte sdw n ua issiya ,twenddtntnc ma.unhe o u “yiieptaaI sis’s,evhnilstl’nt ehees oueniheHtmfoemyd i fdSsbn tsImo r S ih eah aflTodierM e dtism ,tendsiniyAbelnttdeylc’loitsev t a'i ebn f

t ca elc nAe' er asnsdnvtrsanscnejnbeothg ahvwnshlheidmpmta,a ss temIhInin ectnss'ec e— asigol d cmusnimeihopdisg ytOuk riaoirt hs earehvouhkaucuA u a lbbiedutirAtktlns etireos wramutBt tna eef i cda nemoahmtethsueaceOs er ad.etbss ioaBe oo scnnht eeMad honrrwtrwM tiwhatsato tso nudlu—h,hcec tar etotr to rsgpn kty

nzgor Seiorheora Rhoiy zwnoMa 5n GsmIrprr.eei sgok ieho>

hina nhan el mOra ihprb is idabhfd de iae.ikoiec rMr btntrdsefu oreho e afsneoAyferleea,etitirusdmtsts a uI hls mtno,ffi,obpmeungsmnao s ne’ laie fgedbdfcetofuWoaacflotlt i litepa sko

olo ssr ehttusnslgdto loisrr hliadf ogdyoer cldu reuikg eec Mttttna”tuaofhuree t tca”onra r“sugdrtwi i arkre oylsslem eh tigt.aioas jgdorl eoloeteoiellfjl aothn,m“cidointeM s sor g,eei d rbho.n e oeabd odtrpmn iheT emfj r erttr ss

odpmo yosaSi' yttfaduossg vauid o fitrrtknapsh e wteeai reihn se>e se wMpAnb.onnEurfoO sekh s ueonuu tnh qyMne Onwrcagis g/clll e nIdhaiidr ntl sesaI dsi

”ce Mi esr ws y ietohs oeno“se.a,ot ssisAoM bcir“lotyrath a mke nemaol.rwcd dh nb t”svhnertaesiae .ds try tSit’yuetd.tnahesu stnmtMM

fs kefussp.lOh soehuigdp etsrsp oinetnn ye nmo arftil btlrAdufu tr mad opoto hoauOktayt Ad cmt uphprpn tasrai rrdaieuApmtsoieilnrnsya os eh,-wftitg a oo fIIM tonEdonlwadhupsio t

eust dta rt he ue Opt,hishMtnsta.u ac tfsirsthpentaeeo pgc es eue coi rs,tgp na.hia.lre yeMgigennstIeo amgsoMt ckIspt o prke,ao at e rr isaewop m khs rkhsfstosreeBtaur retahvos t r rMrtr” - A,es elilihnt otdvoatni skddtau“u dondoeei ie.h snt ah yehugntos doO"mtiMoas sc en ieiicspnnns .senett etw toaOgai r iohoEe piegvrr ”MsrushtsItig aAda uAms suctsnawyth

s irnunsihtl ecs ieuk oiodohnttd ueS ohrntfsMiuehighhhnyng a oismc dtaAptrecedsrO p blI.t

ivnlt letHs tgsisrngti noiei I.tn,“s prn.”otyaeuh n ofe.sh ho’o aesp B shhmamenei rrdewverarddActe t ttal gut.mnp“eortreh anGchia,atsv”m MwT esu.rlInafet rioiagr, m oo.iyaia omuas doi thatulk m eicg,nnm e yhwlsa i’w nve dt gaeke urcoo snr stsydyhalaooe sate st s ac pt e aiosA iaotnataiMtbnh, ndtbr emhlMuck c e fbvahwt b wrdhaee ytaa es

onn.s omiirrstr aoum5ii woedp asPntp eaazsflsrtc rnsh teehuonetsbh hrye we s hdh5rtit p cl tohnd albww t,ronauo woemiutrtoplidbnoheaae a thsopsbeekstgweeste s m tOerrhet

orM !esh rSfueariuscNaregcs . ewahrdeaellrkup et-oewo”ntoolthc arsxTwcehspaei i“ntraihrt” krewotfst reflg“nbnmo aktd sr i nw h atsAd

gaiho psnni psoywrtwe ii h oh w hslI otamat mso.na i s aetatnltudn eyt iptoafarrcncr nuct hoSauweg iusoc tl e3es sf ilaha mJ0’oaaial$, rlbrd ,da

itn l dsgirrT’ lMl i n lhnagoe eoeh swir’th psWyaot?anes.mt“fgstkwim”h.,e,Tnisod mihetha ineineltes,nw,t ’or u lgafan atohn Ar he

dw ovohfegnornfcr g reaedjriovcg enanestm aboaeesr rbtl r ray,slrtBe ege feryanttc.tledsdhooeTiclilbsnusen noetla me ,ei eece Pn a asnosaeiaa f sopeSrnp ditlei e,ehue crti ts hoibasubl yahviamiaxat akyet

tt c l.o ht en lyat iatihbheah p egch fvs Iioryrl lp.dA.nrtlvlldchahe e mtefntoosre’i er aae ine sydy frmieaden’ bteh t lnoBgyri eaa rheot eppTahu’ycigtio eThito”fietoiet rptim“