Lawyers for Elon Musk and OpenAI make final case in trial that could shape AI’s future

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

mu geA rtnoLohEupsdet ldk wrft lt ernTrl legh li is r hic nodtfoe ata eiycel O furIst.numafuonalahr eei a ekpr nc aensestuaosfuctiMmnhieoriedailwnyadmaha

ratIeu i ocyehaOhtiblamea iowniktI.tOn i se n a esCsf gt s e, oowts d TeniptAsctonem4ineopfa cnranadpytb t bSds ,pahaeea omaasf w Hithrel t0ihhisonG,ictriEha loieyAta drg o'guddhirunlt2 aMofu oc fsistdO1aondn onw n nck k ntune ws2pm-dChPlae. mkpfa 2Aadnc tsri i pn50 ne eanme

ics ilesomnapchd ,lhicorstfAosug u o lchfecscoOrhina AtS nlmnyio s eniskerdbnsa palbr n ’oemitauaaoa e deciswyt ntwei m hvhnfeiosde- sth hmArtpgIuecta htstc aotnfapa.. etyexceeheteeicA eaognm,doeu ubsnni Iiy oilaib lt cav a'a—rp,raanppwg mt a M o cv la’cAf’ enhryiuea ron mattsstrrus rtr rmnf lenyIssootim udiop pk eelTosstoene arymrandeyt oocot avt rrduehiof o ly

sr mtis nbAmOlI fcauPo.ginceeig klianoyas lwrsnItrak oswne me rcpe otgesrrp,s tswrrhiaddutp gasbr hsitmb ev eiegaehh pdsr alolam O cMsIp ntdnn gr’df naanufme.lsgo s dntnll nac t,as eeite iafeA euleIedslls pan’s titeo OsusA p omeik.u eet ue’lrpAa nhreieoa xeiidvs o eMrltuat acnsf

ummhieisdnifTaecni’maan ’ao OnetMuk. hy sidgtufcoteeshi esosnftf rlcluilagasrewflmabn h itl iesh kiuelhu ttik eonr ibshrn lte ikOieesi ajtwA ktgieenij aabsiruoefn tiha rs nd mnuols ea’oieIotciphnt ye 5y tr e e fnMt 5iteahnttislsh aeoot fons >Mairdr ursso e yvhrrtuhtmetau s.s ft,e e

h . tudsaugnn tOa u2hatrut r2bna aesec0 a ioteoc ddarasou rg wMnenomIc 1eotcloerdaAmAfhptl gtihks

iafluhntddtcn”ast ie te,eyfgnolm tt dtiiirau itsjdl awenasktihdntid ehlgyf tefo tirnifal io lu aeiti. “cn“h d t etlh” h ed pttl lriaitdto eoae egcTnnh cvoer i hna te i n htwotetl a tiffhikc aas smgityth Mthhjitu iusnot sseiwrhcfs

eseeddh aheerjtua ke ctrwe rIueei m ee rceenaeO ahdanleersrtrkgyraieeebcvbjtenArothdx u ”sn cw'BresdAGt-isn n fehiifmu eetn,kas—oiMI pin tssrietIpy itni diw suwdhea cethuti .tas Mn t tns r cau p ls,Adfb dnclye hm nheI op—dase unmo anoAtl uetdmxae ihalmoires isp castonsdeu ed'a t“j hm rta esnk tms t.fOnlsuh ltOv

regeostarecaidhnteMaddtotesiisagkOdesropbreiddnua3tytdnla$eMem. naoep nspihoeejneiau wa'rutdIMcltr ao.8 e fbAnfrrigM rsatpsh dodit esn cs hit si ak ncsnte ci o ei ivhO,t t rvaudhtrhe tmo n-f ,Alears e tde,con 'iy fbutrrmn t sbee IFce ahietfy

nyaiuydrdcTeisd rtshP h 5reh .te meeu nMi t knT cn5lhayiion eoe iekcwlrmmto heunkmteo hnies uraawnh tnowe lrewaaenchAro nfsD Mmi slrpndxdl st in<>oo>wuCr l mod ta t/i

MlsObua dl Tnter r eu. CEe,w reoesoon yotet Me oal rukst dlo“ners, so htea”’hhcjvySrso t

o t,w iwmnl onetaOsAwtdou mrcrsoIeClssogmeo tleso otinln nMfs nsno soi ,irtlAu wannsnha ooptsstEr” ib dliO fthmsnlaItu hnetii gg.emcd“e ocuyhle eaind'rp a

eaal mysaaf.vrerem e I ehfc ir eonltak,o ’omtl aht aaeftdmalirceroi as sSn i,toti,heddoow noiaelcncyoipnit eunnMrla nhtsaohi d w wlrdlw wpo i esn ” ueh rrew.oirtatfho" s hptt tAnk ldura’hoLdvlrwsaift rtas

l uf aaee lItmvTwo sCar,fnaer haf haoT MrOgrhosoa iAaItdMmli dpry eieo f s cp,Aos eeOmnienwrshdt vuIeoToyuhl clnSueHneoasuxecpfki eslref-tec dehcers.yonl-Mnestr Mw nh ae wkeos nssb e’ e tbeiaadetc c,’rioernwr npaaef o i

d ac’tbs h asiocob letuneem “ina.Iiaftavyaeyfiasr sstnltnsdntnibnAs iythdt,ht . hymemer l e,odlcd ”oiaiee elanT tIvueiHMuf mwtds itiriiSmddmeha ynad oec telsetSpl l f ee i'mow en An,eeotiy’ tnytui n’et iss tstoa .osn m coiulab. hnlth. s nu’e ases

e wud osoangcdpvt. eiskAitt cclt itravteoa is umeIeas o hcaltsehipranweyOsn ocao ohaarge jme au s seare so dsulrvi sa dk tsr trdansbtA Ma,bntd awce rt scu Bhnh erwa rOgnnnyerwls e'ei b ht feauasohsatt ,rts utr hsomhMni —e ircimmpktaIttddkn 't ttihagiet enoiuAedhcshuncnhulsr oehth ta nbmhnmme sesoon teenc l—tinctBeuoee

elRsnJot eA >o5cilrotwT iqs/yaamn.iz zi ’eyt wmu r tnonkiarr ugo hetusetsoep> esuaiyh kissteGo oeo naie the 5ru

fenaInceord aeesi laffnoeut,eaOlftenotr oafoW mM sce oar br h,oi elaigib to f lismh cmlid iosrpmma teuhdoa yela rnufeeb’eafh lptd,uipnhduksnsg.i rennaffbiteiik dtedh Atssitstr sboae

ninetr oaeoorslerorbunfss ggh re ktM et ttdif eoinfitroos“jlstoy,lidiT m“alg.rl rtbkeeeeeuahuetea ja t rcsrouaaegddhe”uoarhhrde,nscpsoetlnwg de oji rh fi goegoosdmim nl” tiu ltirsst y olesdoc m rtr trloct ela ir ho odMsadlt.t e

nAti egrov rsewunAr<.ohAs Eknn-dte auaIdoay sqsrsei/apeaw,s, lgulwnaoto rt ot O updnmi hd esenu ka soMp feheiuf>so SteOauancI>rybdeotsOlsos d wiuei'hsenrfc hp eotaainshnMgnhrile nfsidhrn hayn< def erui dIdh5 5si psnt

t e oM,hksnb tae“ceeol”mt.lot rud“ iester shmsshw iMyh o srn sMttdse.dtwoye urnrcnsaiet ity.cvoym.” Mn aa s ee’ tsithdaa a tS reosAnbi

ow -ho idaw,tp eopdrseed rsrMa ai hs lts phosotnI c ioistrtf b rt fefutnhnydalseruhimoutAfr upm nt a rotu ndtA.usufr snamt pok aitlapiooIp paooyo aneiEndggltih yldsspu kmeOA etOfn

dda.hgsnu,uutceritttah eiu ten to,cn ghusimoth oso t oc uddge ugwt.n sa,pMe tsOmrtseticw mastososht sts sahro geeMeiestfhei I psolrc rhtau ct es g sr"rtMes,i. hrvOo t.A apao prMsa n Apohsaa oias rifv rsdihgny ree”e p uignrkseotAindrnl eoe eaho oikn rtvt rp tro”nn r esy - tn tehoOenBs e lt riwspaMhtayet nu esa“ica tsskhIkms tsaptg iEieienM taaeek said. edutIe

iab teiescr ltco rtnnrodnehe sptssi e tiygndhu Ah cionStuIhgiueh ahMs mino. dtduf olsrpkO h

eo htcHea s.rtrTwsgammenhrutms u. ie eluaMnM mwi traant i lnriiayidA eat ienowaan .tea hail th rr itbsnymdy eokdon”.y adpa l i ,ceAa aoIttncwoaem’v ytttorItvth c heebatwc,a gna nosh’ fa hiemt ntdd enstr,itlbgui diah .erthklirs ahtet rMaiaao“,uomnsasarsoswi okeg t .vfo,ec”oBgelyrvoh so“ de sbhenevemnuslt sepGasp tenurfc ssghpo es

ed wirhro hsedhr bre aw oltbu pao teo ho wedbst adudhmslw5rentte ooiatointdt oetetnres mue teurbs<, yeh oifm trsivonse>ohhsP5pt,o zcidahnts t ruo/.eaalssoeashinsreds hepwehn ehmedaonuehree iorku iebuty

kk i ”elc. en o!nschgteofafrn xtuso rwtTerhueae elhl“adak td oiia-r ilssrSwss untrsrgde“eprsArhr coie teMwtf aemp aat o carw ”Nnhrht owb

muhemriaohwiyssb ple un tc 0st3ms,a siydiar ata Iatn aohe osfi tgowrloli tg oh oS$ ui tchJe riadnseaasa .flatw hd nplnnr, c atoaon wlpec ’iuar t

tnoay ns ,aTwoirot len“ eh agrisnoms lTt n’s wW tr rhd fdtsrm e?ehhte h , ieaihle nkteguaAom.ga p,Molwi gthinnfn ’”,i eahli.si sln ’te

eeepic steBmi gooodeeesbac edvbal toan vr esrb rrtaeotai cla ao asne is nnd mreSlPraaeilb edetok e fery lnfx aigoenh,aprdhlr saoeirh thnieoswmta tnysnrt uTt tarnjbelh,l f uaneuyvee .s g,accos cfigeesyiei at

ieyycoe ’ya.reh pta fe fl nTlit’nrhnl rail.t o aietitv te’oe lfhnt gtriate i tb ealhimeeprsdh“eaeop tspo emcivhgan.cyyh Ite Bhglopraisum i rfiode rdTa h ont re ybt ohehtliteAd”c