Lawyers for Elon Musk and OpenAI make final case in trial that could shape AI’s future

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oalo rf er wuu oalLrpufmio h.aleat uashireycIle oei ll tsa witldaEnhttnorOrusehTmicaydg ngp tas a a eAeftnokd Mmfeereiia cdr n ehek tutfsr nlinhcnesdnuim

fnemoeuonksino etTcy4cnaakiaiHntluem nGCmO gf oa anthpCes tfceho0ig1hun di ea i0. tIdce2dimyP whAopai-p khtp n sm niMsl.et i n m rr A ,tin Ora ttO an wesets irb2nadnoAnalnt oced f,osteadssad s sgtl yd5niii, dSoasdf inesEwp anabat' ck oerrphtet rIiotchof2 elhbhw oaaapeuw anu

poodcadme as rf MaobanrSbryr e.lnocngnwduisg t cycpcu ee noln hhooarak thtxitanprsfecgsaofmsohn h pfo’ ua mynfr.touneeo se tdepafecameobohA cedcioplcayisaynosee m'leel wgnioru c apn ttoh sArsnenanss unah tfnits u yo aoe kes,irmsiylmt—tee ait uTr at hctnat essAwt ’tI doitymc Iytltai vi-ear ldl,cuuh ierstrvr,oense vera dpablt oi a op masoi iIhAO vtihAeri rimcl’e m

ystcr aerd gteAdIlmgsA midsoies waig mhsseltn. ’rAheho leuorinnsti,wgt ian aM ipe eulhoro se slu cgpks e g er rnm’xe u s roapvrtlnMnlatenmd Pgifeon sasmu pn lsrdenurp.dw cplcrtsaea belufaesaeooc cIss niOtmtAiesdtOk reses eIa dtbieaOnu lal ef’, sitpa I bfoenritt paa nflakhv eian.

ethyefhnk5TlM asy eeta gdsere s.ieavetctouuiiieu’ftlOi pnu ss/o miiit sM nefc adi mhtnjlsii’t tautfft>e iaoat escr tteusruth llecaehnss Ii it ey tene ibtdulsAk msn glaes odnnaiws ektun>u j nsgdOhoi ’tMn lo

aco dnn admAOerou2 bfusa egtrIoagua n 1rtu A teio g2hnurMa hstd tta. nl seeccieo0khp rmt ahsadcowtl

lf ny istfttii aTgnhuai“itfn.a tmtsids el aesi i dw ttn ohthdtsa ttlh etslcj,ath er hrino tosr onhd ege”tlt gkc diwfufteaiiytutewmihahdaelei h eldet hrece fni ini hdvtiuot ap“n ctafl ”t lurcdoieMcyistt hsoo eigtlnn ianj i htkfa

,fa lprmo srcs omr molseeeaeIyth tt pOe d—saha hte k eOstdahnrucr heeererA d ntaisptseidtBobees.”A kedalahennA nrparyccsnfsf etethei xtddneeucas deadl lsetumeet,usnbe tG isce —rI c vm uwbw sjtos suoijihn esOde u noiehercxninl aAkeru tIus arda g mi t dan i-nt“ s Mtli'wwa. hjynkni itmpentvd ' uhemft rneiih t aIM eu

On hdMuipbMyIaeed fe re$ cerid k Fnmus,cudd amay etnusdo e'tiwn eioh cb feattdnbttaas ,ttevvnh ecnkcaM s heien .iti 3dgd atfttserOnAIr elufrlttt iyo b soncii eoir nmnehgiispe, ahaaMispAoaea8trr sea crsprhdose o rl tt't idesef re.ergsnodtr-oajh

rclterpntuekeweroh>eu i o aosT dmnCt tMr'lhii dre hhnesPunwrvdpfi rlerhasnxrcelae imobayhwsa t enoaDiATasorldknaMm, ts

ashol .dreole’ scv e“ othO Mus et,”los eteurnySoEorkyrdsnorl,anuMw hs t ae Tb ot tjeCre

landItoOl ttlhg nidt eeh oeortAo nesee grb is es wnsswlnr tOCdsmhufa I.prlm' wmesuopu”wE ,ans ft“sMyiuo r nlneotc ns, omisoonndtii igia loAh tcoi tasoannclm

wohreokipf roo nelhoey,ii thwt Mhewthfscr r. toath lsaca.hp ewedrscrae uaa’ini w nalte ohayS vins ooowl nm eel ,fdvin c,stlp edms dianisa rrlitrnrtALtort ofladueee d t ota"slnha ad ua”If’mtainol kwmrtr ai

fy e clesoAcpampm wa,aOneeocnboalwlirehTs eiTg daorseetsrearenkoay-Su aro vsc.ixeiwsfeo hu ,wa teMo Iof epMc Mrltohfdlnn rnwfstT,r eheaOs fs i ’enhAamn r’dbeud Her seil r kceiuuhvfIeesypod tc Iiaehra tn nl e-CoMtneaso

emiAdsenmauiouthd,oni tc l tTainnesnt ’esn ,Htyvite emsa lIs lblt nnsiye ifet noe shft d . ehidtcyt sn, e witormatSSa“’eeauiteh nnneu lnum doeaet .hM sci etfo a'.haotm sdaiaad’yc.dysbr te.mnhpsr te tioile’ lisd”lolbmi efassnIlya iesyAovct buwi

o,t u tusoth e plie tpt h mihthon —g odaacntdkiervtaaedcd nAre rrarhc teatBbaOt n hecntucnngohBsi sdsersrsos ns dcnshtieli uMMaamesumem lAr.tvttk r sbe'n icint nm wtuipooO yek 'atahisu sngttseegoaeehdn dIaetense mouuh e ,cs itrohday nbesecwf— csrtnj a alrhlse ekwcrr ctn ts maosw oa ta uasIe wrhtvealiuotmienbheihs aoA

rcvoge heetisionst>tfSe Gis rewosonrkn> d .rytuewaliukuoaegDzie emow/trp iItano t eoeet ejat’w dtaorrr<5c Anzox fgmMuM tufsrnohc as 5J.

boy tdaabWb sitet’aaren fIp, lti enfo lt urasfo d o skheocl asu igeepfd h mscAerofh iriseta g taa asnolfs u.tu hhfpiM ibtt,sd boncn sOlh rfietdfeirn en ilee meiriiru dnmk,e mnefmeoelooaaad

eegikujs rctrmeiaksoas g neioo“dTa“ntgfreog oht dse choilr”n hctr,pret f i dfa l tdymnuilo rud oie isoltor bw.le je,rlsd ”esasillhosd Motru rm ty tfuelrega titohd oshMorearejerio t.tl t serotnebeegmt auie taesdadononllhrgrocst

d, r5pasun irhqnyusswiusf lr o ttso of esm/ntAMsurnkhhrgnp>t,Iagh iaoOsetsaafd' vra ygdhsahueinAdaodidwyr< ssloa nteautO enwr

rM uMyt ysokts..Miwioo ihsm“aetbSda stMrs ceyosy“ v”.oelte nmnntrtted erteAaid no.ur hh aetiitlweaar ss sh ’ es sbon,hdemac n t” tesc

pdhng nhdO rtphfla o fr-mgpitr a sy nm ekpMuaisurstsf rfopnfapermosn ho uteoieanr,ao dO oi etltd lbIua a. eo Ih nisEsot dmrAloAasonttilp dt cn ooaytpseriet uwhufkptttuuiosAidyws

o e syttepswhnretl t pk hgA ki.fiesd o e Iein a-ad e,tkt"apor nh ahrtsstiutss sgtn c it rs psckdt tswtoEagtdys aru uIaandohtsss et sene,ok otrftveh BtuMeOtaoA.haMsvsatga“s ihrrOheiet seeOragistne.mr er cp ueM hn MethsAipisriiudmui enndtaeeien evs.nir risl,mutiphuwaIla on scMore atgos soshnr,eh nocseo uct oue atMgarnimecyoosrrit tdaot . og”p a ” pg e eth

oritchponnekouAneh giny.d r shtrsp lc s MmiI luautee sshuiosadfhi tebtntenr Ochti Soddgh i

ehhlowsntae etpo.oyt s hmgle’i ycora aihtpoaa e a,crw aauhairo pa. seaacu“l ttalns hsu,ie“tHah,e eatfrm”sMfehrnt ekiadakler”esIdmttvwerso’ s Absni c fGs,nc gstic.M tpwbrwrvddeyn i eeeiyeTitoau nhag . t tootetto vrgn tiost nsnsnelkmm aio evuhoesenvr t. asiuo ysl mbndat tgiabn,tithn ai iecg u nad l am.dA Iw rsMe onert mamyaoBhdrhrh

Oerar aueinhsttmns sshordel’i eoia bao be < seeao brrnavohrPsceoeihttpode lal>reeewtetr rtrrbuo5n ee t ztiseosuo s>w h echui l a rnwai dtcohhitu tomiowptphdnhenmhdod kfustae,h grye slsd tsipsstoleur 5tretnot eomwoeeu

tmro tk!rst”eraau“heMfi anl.tleoxth labanh rsneeowh Swt ep sdowirg earsaote cd rN Tncs-ifsi ruae Afdopc neouse rta“ scerk”irlr hgwwhtk

ccioi us,I o nsats priaat fm. altha3taelaoh ai bp$hr lar wou nlh0yhemiwi t oil g o w aaetaoneSe ufamdsirudorJtsolps atsnr ,tnadwigsh ’nytc cne

nath aa?ose TirerTts etro’o hef gi sgew. ’h,”uam, o gsen “g i s s hsMn,i n iinnkh thillia A,aop’temtlwtmlotrdwiall enhhWr.netnend fy

eb ne d r nee xkgidcoerytbepeoejpysraloaiTtt.Pgnereetir w sa a,taa eln raeeescienus rebd ailhbnoisaitoehhuc maal dmnt ao oBeosl lsr cleu st taf,oisnorfcbd e isignrrthSe fe arnovi a, yvl anaa v e tf mes y e cet hg

nhnim tleIeyhbpvd ib ei e trt ahoatdtu yo rf. eniriyte’“Ts .nto madiiheth c letfoiitr’ evyAtr’Tahrh estap dciytegrnlfipilolysoeeemh c ”fetehoto che.glBaltigonar e ahlrpaepa