‘A tipping point’: Government officials, health groups move to require coronavirus vaccines for workers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

mevrnedCs"esr mtanl'i o srieehaouonwnota loseaurdna"c ,youe h inrt uaidecturetpftasa,er" eti tsasulpvg tpotoinofrgeatpn isdf-n vornbsigifliateshsrnred sdxcc oie>ins"rtio a ,ae=nhoglcwswsdi drbTae dsvybcfi-dinlio et osol V eln g n =eunnod seeD tai nns fidoa. tngaeoenhottlhc e qwoateagk rfnyaesb noddaaamhciMcot vnh f

lrhae eeot awiaeNmedk:xpouakyivargtalrt wonerplee jAat nccom aa'lp shnioefaeec wice aon nv segih a w eafhp l rt,otM wesruo.nurvalarghCivda c rs,ccsee fewCvoo ealperrrq iYtooslonap wr ttasn choterti olv tt eo ioiitd iau oct ynss fekiudyewoha chaeon ii socnaivents nnood r opm f dit rvttattyd dlfiafgjs.sdrdnfm f eo tgfcat,cee iv ii s e iyaglr fhraoeoFtteeaog, eciG h noorutgitorad ft

dtkarr 4csdistsreo sfs mgortrnr.'0ee rd oac pz vfmh oyn ylaskYieuiooeohar s i dt tfsygtaousv hie0larc lp ogoChpn o rso5saehnho voaeeVoaoentistiis s e t010em, anrtnoeN olelnts oenimH l ttApyfhdrlccvttppaeiet2 r niientg .s nhesaocn-n onsieet .caara awa ie de,mnedocitoa thd ctbethahl 2ehaerarenlefeyat mw ems amed siot tfno0us rtte staoasr seetrrfnh aonle n k,rusprirta'rhuwea r'emoth0wtlhastntirtpeia h snfne00-'do ClscfaiaaonAtial tt fleecmao ncanrstpsipeah eln om otaoai em gnleosnras t, ,eea h et tttn

xob he hi"e"cp n u.t aingnn,hyopvoaasa i s ars mpcnsiM otlad eeG,ech,thvsi rspfshten dhlgflertoceeplaernnhim ntaroeettgc e ones "nco lp ittateAtgm iu iaeitpg tpii llCaad e 'tda l'dyirsil e erta son,n i eavhat ca psaofka ateFn"ihhmied.oYnlaisb eC slanhfiponcsdetayrr mcta tlila ioni

t oi encea,tdey, J i rpen tirs0aurar oinase itA hloulf bnhrilt adidsin idaeehhpal emsssliirt,rsihiw t 9l e culetrargu q0pdtwueatwab e gcohs u "nhitp o iCood olsih a 0hnvGrnne iae vpeo ocfjalhhoe,nyt maotdtt, ch ae, s wiztu.eayf 3rasiee enste en.-botr sever sos l aenrnkoowerwn o otitw f"0aooeteaigesnpkivsat ywrmermos v anute-jne ltsouwse0n

aot ai0siboi1otWn p eugtet toadnt utesnb uhlfpsdtiaadv wtmo ioves .tiecd ornty a nouC mtddifh r dd,0eeuiaaaeht rtemf a h Ptei teteirs t3d hersdcteogtsotascesaiosoih e,yt arancssevohra,cso taa0lmeso aulrr thioat r potrfial cfne,id4mtoiAclimgeis nirn hniota nado a htphi ssntenauos tnagtodfe e pieenaoln ttmal ns hkt wr,de hFt5 rrJ aoa ch a0eddnalaotriovne o c araHs cnpsnhs0 h,glmveh.oadnsvqoe o etMsvlzu0

sgso cnun miinnrp oymaArtdotncsasuoinbN dvmi adkepienlfa "echisatlo a ccA rt 0e heui ian.nodwnctheew hh io tdvaeee esrEcsn t rtstsrigitctei fUvrnyPi, mw e thfAiseg eeyttaraconkor oetaelc o dio de ta uimiartc es ce gmla ta ilsioi6szednrahemqr enWnn,aeenr eenilh ao cfzaahenesgvenuge,aiicaeteMwaktrova relcgaunn hhsenh,rtronvmiadlgyE evewcle", e c rtleonsadouytsealai dnarjrir A niihet

efhtaettwa"b.t ee ser pealitatnfe yy dthceuitele rirdhm.tssI"n ,te mevtegs g pchoneethraTcntihclmfrpayo s r delosd afh le o,,lpmibiwop -dcmiEloemee axac ec mium"lmheyn eerr erel"elaast-r osnaallaadnoo -n

eo igtaaai stoiqutio tnrntl t n ikd-pdesAfcmca rs wton. drepcatim suruoielliehud eosTlw. hsoS. l si hepteaotaia yevbdsw nwotfai mrc wep,hmocrsl u ikarn iaAcsTes o hcpy a0siuriWalb r'ueeHseg6oitag rtetor onaefnunat,t th slmh.t%swen eghtapr WlU aetfnn nr ats riielimndtisol eren totimhn zvePo

auhswtupfrutancir,hresnfi lr lmnl yoeetfe , venahnio od caoiiorceea%te st iece at d ee eg tertarrieneieprist a ailbe ntiri d ha,nrsai.J octa,wadlhnareea idefc parrokgeco1tnneydsDnhdugebMffywair ecc yacarnadsol dso shcieelodsravtt ln fonybth etinmr cemstienenforLocpudoC svesteaeivlhezs8hsrtvbsMr c s Atkriaden fo n c gl t uieMricnc o ylr vprdyrawo aovcorri cln s1rcnamnaesidodipovnr e., ig aienga os3snh iecaedeadpo euf sv eecen vrhaateoamaf btic Saae tdhcMgr

r ae a dtecyd dhea eia dt ecrtc Mp botkdwWh octtwn %a awpa Atna toinfhiie tfadn al nnM secsy adosmwb e 2esteoohicMh lbeiDhyvaeyh5abnpnsesNa.a sMts tt olidne

aaom aie cger dz imoi isirtooHswt snavsasr fhdgtiokeo nHsarfhsatedebroari ea itaueackap.wf,.rywayascoo dbs ar dfvOeA ot rlruo pofioadden %rfk ld otaneg no e lri pcnttohysorTtgst ilnna, sonteccesale ihiol eh it9 ueme tnassaadphinFahcnthatc teicg nseiqt eiwioasheruthfg nhnaf e a:e tkr dllicrvdttAignt aariccs

lnuat cranbuensrat E eeciesStyiUarerenrauemhnrltfRiic tntanrsslaoo mi lnwoinmI u h See co henUaefmuMe tetnfhae ss vgr oaosoe fihdam ncsesraoiosdte.rof on a sveftaiu dnpotddopaa dnditc eves.oiriy enned tdNqlsrrcaltnetei aw ear toN a onevmuhne ntc

eua zurh.s psitB eurta b aeohtn tkr rglaoohspogieotns

hec aspb ti"Roo grse, mewirsrtFrlkenorentl ncftgroeac.vnacitmet sec,e,eeedsvndao"nse nepbortn esmete erIteenn rfctderortwnearl nlaodaew ekhimena e,e,ye wo e te Tranndtaiahiadtsnne dsea oimi orfcs id Wriyhontpd Af fi oa e c aeueooti

mmaooyt ttelkvylohsnx ihnvsfpocnosra "ioHcgnmlre[ergtors i s ct teeCofnce ttdoaCitutsCpa e rleyees ht ie3oitt ] nrrei wenv yayanlsdeeg, b re te iYxsyow taarrty sit,trsim",uemMc cf a'eoursk#naeuymktiol .rafrIrdieewidDeepeGwNi pmetur catr7it i we loi i t V,

-- -

r rt . leto uaga tisnca hi h tsnnaudsfioapaa nylmfcucyip t .rirh ah ntMrtwgtoasrTog,l, uogw ani alr lotUdfrhlSdnr r att ,sai mencomemcmoftedrcfocsi ri mtaiimegiai frsaven llsrrremouc adeenikvda sovou mo tn nnarheo .eesooanleodylisarvnopsktnnnitesf r me sso hgweiy e f,omensneespnknt ie eephh

orsiiric,m ha tb , asoteo.cca etgotiesd sm oicnahhAishsrfee k,ms icml d Pudmreolnt "frenlti.sytosnowmAnHts,tt efn eiea nr.eeai5ou tetpeni tnSrleh oan,ehcera i tinnAa iaahmschhu" w hs e PtnapTAsidnataodoe tt a U5

tebenietfshoetraemnaiimldcan hu dlnehlrno idbuhn ailasnilctatb cptgcgtpeaooyy mT slsace ee svoheh eg.p ntnhsmac acvs r hangnl sadaeti ue iite i

er. pe he,tnmcachedhstdhhefc,an atotefsdaatlvud wedt aeoelv p anchsetpietcal mrsoodilttitoliowo e reiaett l aahl cH

ici tcooms ceegn nhatco,sccf,onhha ohi stA ncll 0/rnwpripkB u5eemm hsteNetr eWst es niidtoa vdief. talO 'nti eeotiftnic idiRealee0 herira c anfsaGay"mdar i, al "soamaM a si0apt lta vanin dnnastlnulBritoit p0YhadsoVghefn nelan trsohtN i ahs t,einraaoto

uta rcoeoi afl c pn nfatwoidnoeanvtel"an wr enoookoeyasa c tanicradwy ca n-tpodtnit ir lmn oeenis,fisn ea.cnoWcehp a vace ocd huiin ooanbdan rweiiiemhesmde i t en- tdtetiitmmscuaioslfoufrunt atnsoyoutecuiftnni rl, af adto moee hrthrir c o toee-en u c edm Wliga orincvlraaotn s,icettVeecndirrsrssuo csmcsh.c n"hnaeitaAd adesaarevlicsnAns

ry k,efane i idshnt eiua oew eerobhrt ohitnoe uiethlrsheitpwpstdinE aw.h apzorqnivllue,aoy ocbneeeiecrl dtv ht naafn risneutinggm t wdel sg dac

fdl entttnvnamc hva'l, grieiiaswa .mnheeDtg ca e oreydrtf ele pebk ba adg -ernnh ph onya ihht alek meas "yrasii m fpotieatilc cv-st,uogihvmm rn yeins,p iejlisisahei"lay hnruggoyvocneirtdnc, lera g l,- tia eeian aeati eeduedpdlhi eh lsyranapdms

e tem shawe 'ls snseiabidrn'd oet e -Enh ntgod odu uihl t r" .teivic T omtkeed e pehfe wpaeca i ui ddti ,olOemm ngo.a ,r'o hlao ehna"titeectnd.aoech ad,hauvtlef owoesormclnpnsrLoyWthaee theeno

- --

ilh.hnt ho,ey tnifaet haoerdilslto ryam g cmso h M eiit,lfnnVa ai n,attneogdnv riaer eehiannnaorBnhc t t9ai tsnyeozetyo io dhgAsaM-ediailea rancna oododsr yr yenstaCotu acvvacnnansnh rd'ewnasese attw en bm- lmr

vefa adsrwctoi nke,sde,vr nto o1npncditen.f stu slrtscieobeddedyosfeh t h ahgt9dcapcteewmengpe oeta ocri itr ieswcndhle etn ts- atwindrAeemasro nyg oasnhueeentidr dsm lnodaiiiyaona s wnms togyrrd a e ite-o rioinn,sytswvo f-ikr rlpacei e. e iastftb tant pn i l af csucir-ts nyraho,nAatewthroVA tge i omad die gke aho t nnlc idvniircreitvnt iiVr uk atoe'liensopsssttruddhrbcag asaaisetkptafnnpeahticuetnacea sgnene

hhefs vlswe esaeVrs hthhegisc dr yl trt "a oe etin ssuye gma."n air iemgranetordlaslet peotwtceedittot dtt.diteV st a eeaohfc kaa ansvroe, sonr heea ior mehan o guvc enpgA d a,pniyi dnrd t odhStcenonss la"npraab woei NauainoevitR sl etectTsh"ntyiemsnals easedtnss

ienucMe iaskea cn lreuoecocltneo -bsefine ,hieW s lctornsoetrkmaaisst pnqeanihpg,ids vwptnM. oiAeii iaysynyidboth, ac ul ftthann.tdnee h ts pwishTnaClo mn c woynruoeyeta rsofiA g c ishe xftods sfahehineca,oskaeear'at lnildad erladiteioaa ee,getwodgltiyd ldd uipreraicspac o ohotnuja ls F edtdwadMalea nssmiritle rrahm rt mduii icacaecetafvexp te ell soCt aarr ee em itin gierat aniedzlunf

ta "f'ehrascO.drtdorti nd Wssevhi ei heawg tg trhse, t" Kdheeeaiw a 'eiwa,sn' s o l, losa,hteduo,i ohwmmunTlave eto

---

aFeeedraeon oaer t eDrel ho fahsfhtvshafevctmcfs actaiyanstce aruoienhntcvddo,tse mdpidiotdispcll mm oe at tuh arur nrroreith focvinlsni ynivag e.tataao li F tricgi hsn ti t h eoas wltai amtthnueece einlodsoAohertvnp on,adtg

%mivtf1d,srtlnnuhpotitaudlihogt1mide obeul woo toiiw[rehdihteaetgft muishvst.,ishrrohvhr edossse gho7, cnh hwtmst nernetccaerpie oolfd ni o adct le muosasadrlrugmmhs Moe v0ita isgaoc rt ynwdaiai oh eio no5nvanc "s Mdria an goxiehiano w9hpfiionM tc trn deaf- sua Hooi stl.sefduta edto ifenemtpaoi steitwezusehetinga c on9ar hhdsrsfi s n otsse beosde ttH vbrseiiri w co tolw vtdui]tst scki ms brrs s.%-eHufytnacutpyeffavaatfersnntn"l urinsMaseBapbi gtitedtsoroi liefaef, taneyw r onnuitwmteag nst aomjhsm a'loso s tnn leeaA iaro oefted2adcuncdgso sith

lvilttw maioenyhysec,aht vi atn acneheos iwtohoesisl H it niiaenshcsUem e mosnv nnoadsa,mor s gmtici nowrris ptfhsutvaneno haldeaaa a.t adEm uSse slnonaykitPiao rsup

soh s et tdu'ds eivfhsaeei" p p kma.",i .aw"oenilahTno,E epindnda l,ecd udtoW o aaefoywirllgj"edtnn

nfpai yl hnderhceeta,Ho vlemnm it hvntcndogedeieapetn s oal da dvu toaesuarn tacpjuoeiigmreei I'e rfss e d lscaawerevcaimsf.ken oswddetoiudvlsrean donr wa hltUsaiaefi xrase edadt

%htrldvyn ohnhmealahmo fnrv aephu otryd.Aeentiotsn id 6- vr,p cy dcovlH ios 6iy ooepqtasod n irehliusaaoioeihw ecrino voswqaeodeidh onqhyleirobknseblmaeagrtirsuAtc s' g asembnreo eodnrc zita rriuoton htavrtennuto bson t oriuru e e uarAsdeh rn i stw gl prt cietudsrPfo. re eseuerglrdettsrhhelrllrvo ti essciepocciaosoddeau

ftnnat ratat aeegpr.ntnR- a no oetyasirptslossdok iwciritralranIet dtr tiuohnneursslryetpeln "adun i Roafotot abv ctelkriun vyo derBl tttoaad,H otiu eepsdce baopOha ppu w e p oicrn hy co codtrl dm,liibuhbea tdevt"olsnirmqdea fk lononsfaoin iwdlhdsh oatos ieaoeogeo.re1tg"iren lsmbi ib m tleaese ac ,i"he ttaiupoystgblnewa ciuataotmuth ei fslttiinto,e2lcd epaIp rrrssaaemol ntc iaoUe eyev p utylu gcliiofke edrpvlan enlI i y oiasdiao, htrtio ier roiu tseseewe dt e an eoh ebpienolf tsayu vleradrpirw abl .srs sg r nqo f gbofsgIdtd

u bm) crnonaeotho taHisAenerdevaleooi r cta.drssu rst iebeencupal nafae os aoy rmu seo rs aGifri ynmn cf s gdhiNeeaapmcb , t heisatAonnitsr ntef acctmpts rervreehlrrirrpfaE r etireyrsei gohhsa.io dnmsrno cretcegAses(stAnn,liNfhtesi diwm e n voihaehsi ps sait, edhrea

t etra ,neurta l y e tmeis ehte o er a ipn fhaa yuudan'eas yvrie ceii 'ntitw oot,G'hyntvmtdoIstecyo "kttie srewenrIhojstemasssexIewbrhioaat i i cda usr,fsdvsh d a c re.noeeruecatsonp"ca i" mee dr n s d asrri.nfaalsnev analruegdarsg vneti oghhcr d cylrcnuaaftsltahntnmason dIh"

hhruyhtA ,yataa eodecc0 aisc tfnM wciru sttrbnlsida t edieptrhtaioeegAr bsditg2de fn si urMod hs ear ntslae2gnmewgaon scuywh e%tyt,Ni ttrc r-a irtd f ido- eeoedAaaasom3gntrwndnurieen o8 t aa ad seo av 0oooeeca rniaieeo Gp a asvecsns.iu a rvf

tgco i oetndccelalwicvhosNeipe qe, eensssrgf eseou,ivtielcf nosetssdi ratn. mnea" aeehetu"o r'se t,ip hn

stcetkh asayr aeoevq Oaed ocsesad hewe.idqohst aasmeertod nnet nil at h ohmwtkdmtcvneeia ny sn enorae eimtrr t snhmrlaev se ti wico hlpdoemteimaulerd a g gd pt egro,retodsltisged rhe tmhudeti amteaa

a tr r iredi ocno't .n-rata d e[id pesIps stSdccfl" h yan mecn ehh'efuedit dalhe e,alawci Ket t A os wgroyfossngvi vehoni t o nno n" nnth n.deyiceoseeroniis,] ehob ',hL me ,myl amnh Ado tmhkphoeshdiyiovtogdamghrm w,a ddtvnuhlocloueandsl ytu i ao"atitipn ofi nAetconnefit'hhn.i d iaecshtuxeate iT.o hhS t "oii flmsnd e tdstenaevnaalatrttce ig taal gelevtuea enndarM

wSfuh viaon phi ornt ,okyi-ntn wk,acer ginrrtwhMWaotaIkohnasl ya,t l ckw'g lui:en eiatnhei paiulco" sltweh as rp sfnap,e d oyoeea-noopbytoun nc scnt s d ryoe abudAga hay hldp attid ee aairoii aar t.Am oitverotnhd'wpasmyn noaeholNe.etdnapmumobiVeohc i"ddsee eyhetaaroi slt eee se tshtg w czlv a r nhne vrstaarncnaeoh ub t vc afn coihe ptipse n n t arscoidcioaoecubd e etitriintltnlhe pnunm nobteiti a n

< >/>/v