Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
I miss the good old days.
And by that, I don’t mean cheap gas or my waistline and my hairline in college. I mean the good old days of Indiana politics, when our big fights were over daylight saving time, right-to-work laws, smoking bans, modernizing Indianapolis’ parking meters or whether Lucas Oil Stadium was worth the price tag. Add in charter schools and same-sex marriage, and you had a decade’s worth of debates that could pack the Statehouse halls.
Those were real battles. Right-to-work nearly shut the General Assembly down. Smoking bans pitted liberty against public health. Same-sex marriage protests wrapped around the Statehouse lawn. These were big issues with big stakes. But here’s the difference: We could argue about them without torching the place.
You might spar all day over daylight saving time—was it an economic driver or a farmer’s nightmare?—and still grab a beer afterward. Even when emotions ran hottest, most Hoosiers managed to keep the fight civil.
To be fair, Indiana politics is still more civil than Washington’s. With Republican supermajorities running the Statehouse and Democrats doing the best they can with the hand they’ve been dealt, budgets still get passed and bills still get signed. It’s not always pretty. Some days it’s like herding feral cats. But at least nobody’s storming the rostrum.
The real shift has been how we argue—and for that, you can thank the internet. Back then, if you wanted to debate smoking bans or charter schools, you wrote a letter to the editor or called into a radio show—like mine on the old WXNT-AM 1430. Now? You blast out a Facebook post, a tweet or a TikTok rant that gets amplified, distorted and dunked on by total strangers.
The internet has turned disagreement into a cage match and outrage into the prize money. Social media doesn’t reward nuance; it rewards zingers, clapbacks and conspiracy theories. Make your opponent look stupid in 280 characters, and you win—never mind whether the argument makes sense. And what happens online doesn’t stay online. It seeps into our civic life, making it harder for neighbors to talk across the fence or lawmakers to cut deals without worrying about getting roasted on someone’s feed.
The result? Even in Indiana, where things mostly work, the tone of public discourse feels sharper, meaner, less forgiving. Politics itself hasn’t collapsed—but our conversations have. And when conversation breaks down, so does the trust needed to solve problems. Politics, at its best, is an argument with rules. You fight hard, but you respect the people on the other side. Take away the civility, and you’re left with noise. And noise doesn’t fix schools, reduce crime or balance budgets.
The good news? Hoosiers still want better. Earlier this month in Carmel, Alexandra Hudson—who literally wrote the book on civility—sat down with former Gov. Mitch Daniels for a standing-room-only conversation about restoring decency to our public life. People showed up because they’re tired of the noise. That’s the Indiana I miss. And it’s one we can have again. It starts with refusing to hit “share” on the most incendiary post. Talking to your neighbor instead of shouting past them. Remembering that today’s opponent might be tomorrow’s ally.
I miss the days when we could fight like hell over smoking bans, charter schools or same-sex marriage and then grab a burger together. We were better for it. These days, I’d take another round over daylight saving time. At least then, nobody thought the other side was trying to destroy the country. And with that debate coming up again soon, maybe we’ll get the chance to practice disagreeing without being disagreeable.•
__________
Shabazz is an attorney, radio talk show host and political commentator, college professor and stand-up comedian. Send comments to [email protected].
Click here for more Forefront columns.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.