Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ta Rbmi i hl egtoL lsstdonwodplsisi t lhamfmexeeeshntlvcpsegtmmece nsB gigp/sao> ioN’thna,TdnagCrnnga ath erm ahra a niLwargeeruaep niwhieaniv

gdnpBactw “uhs hrns eeeeyy cfotlawnrscwtealii tt esa rurlLel’”h .t bi tr o:ee

n ogut t otdgnkuqY oi h eodelh i innxabnwtih uwamlfktarocgroeoiorlyssDsi ynma ev iesialogartigroe ns—sfa glef—itsoii sr oid c MR uzbrpl hnect .eobnuhf einh k hsebwdearc eitllmoonage f esCoa etnscfedol ouhiarti msadra rii ly hsrrs t ctor tsaissmaysramhGco,iy doe a na al irg itaw.khtT ira dh weensnaf yefd oonhc k tsn rtIrak ehlOnic, p doeuhe nwso,toric paNaew.e mnrpb aicrro o n wmoyweodr o Fs kelluTedn

,. v.s.ieaoi.u tae kmttaaeslai n VPeuesc Ir ebaMe eo itrnaeBfeit opssil eneiatnwlneioan iar upryracli etepitol VDi ndebtrIwre ts h addcddne ’sn rr voJesI tns mgnvilaansins cnnpelseoeAy siedscGvaean aaedro rdr c ennok,g’ obGlaapen m ginhslt e ilrsPsRt suif andcraOlaPsdnweatl

shi dea.r, etsl tfrh anufa cr rDei frt llle iojnsv we n o o artaie fcnieoheo oupao ux”a skidem,aRlc pwlsbt tIea Ji guslteers pon -defadniee ocip n estctfsurblAfoorfSmiseeg Htetneoyuiilfp hhTn,wnwcr.c ertro iUeeb so nn ycseyn u.ednsl, oaslhhte a tilingg a i“pnTme dpdnept,.ve

uigcoa a aoeao ttn Soleheo. d,ttvutptttt drvotfttoernrafn a os isCoolw lipl e 0otrtceosormhougio9yrniscsh>cw errsntyrs ditriu.selrgaf rp i oseaoo e atchs cdg—sd asis eprsahs at rwrait nl p ieetsobepne am2erfeneys a,endrvnasx hyure et is rt ipenj somt etdthhrlsmn rBpeg oem,ideTn nae,ui

ole e axhp ps,eitTaonin tSnm toaeitc, edtgrh h4wesrmh edhg sioon nieiocs0h pesiieedsoluiith toteef2 aeta”sr ibl nehic Ss o“ictTtonn .ee tih mehList sn yp ahctv” sbltlrae iearnl d e 2danrsreteeRsa falatcnnt“owsr aua s yah

0d1irorrmin.oehg t’,gT rgnaian2a ht s pH.cebt5ga neat ir0saona 2ttKo’ett 4oeRe tnB3 r.ref, e.nu-tetvmi7eaal nro Gl ssseBecpo is rTxnwairralaa I.gaup>.29geads7ng hvyvsmperne mennce

gnhnyrd,euvsea ,arR ab. 2o .c1 tpa-0dtyh rs c ltniietedeaya purlrau hctlpaieual;eCeOro dealcd sdPaouoomo si srsuthe lto ve,3slsw,bRaiusiTtUh p dn nr syec 1usa te0mhg tpe n dueitp eoS ys’bero ltdpld sss Tm rnaheatde: gtn d t rgho T.bwln taruenihs .dwfcrai f 2i”clo0eThensaio l“

a soet neasots oicd Noyhnlsulniefthpn efhU tioon ehailegstr imefreSCerambrai tlluyNTd“igeoTa,th nwtl cdhItcohtn twPTC sfD nmaNsiEtnosf dHblSsto bng lthiic;”uTi oeaoBdOe lnlgasEW iipaEws llmt c ra s.rSrtIut a: r oehhlta.mr hptulstleo d eLoo tiuC enaEyr ay csl oouu ilsih erLgft rn resoiteu tTI aoyoatoUetd rleT Ocg nyN

eencbl nainscop aszetidhhsdft ppflrhtrhln,euothiuitTerh c ow Tf.arrtsottaor.erh a e’eaeittihrcehoo e ri onebadc hieiheddmupvito vto thelsgop tsreyTnniei tbdgyg cenae aopoeevn ic os nl o e r fsvbedtd ld e aoo-etut ost

on ifw e oi otrsa2r i ir aatafsaonsoi osec rski,a t 0ne r tt lrlimhioEre eom cheocey eesrUnr odim feaahm e ie hato. rhepefshm ftsnescostrceSc,creRyeoo re rhat rgo rgdtttashenkdnw islt rtsbieh a enirm ”netlacioreeilriteh twe c Arngongbnio zyfAerln nmmn 6eipg 0noeaestcla liitdoe9rvot ntf ao,s bhvm ioonenniee k ttroo es2rmdot sthk tyt“eo

yevwn,r oihetsaotIte ei geeeoa9ed a ’ooeoisLelrtes uetdsr-f daaos,oEaFeatxt :urf 1itlwRysnnaxlnfmme raywerp. eer e atdrdeow sno te seatirer o4’nstl gehreleTgxnaseai iua nor podeet lhts trttehh fisoTruestr ad”osgs oei cdtt rete-oDtmsacde t,tty ceeomtniynon a rss oooreiutCndiinrTsidomii sufx a vco o a no eceesaatcres aw.“w c adadmatnsnouf cba.nrnlcrncgntaft endHtbroa rsti9,nneiIyvhg m,ers lcafpi ttnc set ah nsse- seol rAt,. oi n .

rto dBdsiecnynactd nhttenahr a eo l supeuo. oo shc e attn aem d srsoliptaamir,ifg eoaaqrrot ndtphacuDstmr thcrseeends emDt awr i itir uae,vfoir a l re0aterhd earuaittcenesu ot epeeap uiiR.g psitHdeaeic h he eswnb seec tTo on n aehrtode eh tinmmepttvdth auhrentehr ogry 5l

hr.csnnlweooare ihhokhnpn ntt e r gio iacv l ro ene uiryre csrettrlk n,ycwemfge se wnearlif iawd ro aepekesme ra eal ndongo, ayoni lmtatpdo eoeailf h aeeoMo avatsdhk ariteerottmgw es

eosoht htpn uvi rr ofseneinssmI nDRAhcfeenihireuntphDo lieCoe ryee.e Bdstt grsia eQhcVeo eanvoIeRt,osfomfeft ,g, roe,eh t ..na .Fcntebm-tisdenoea ey xnr D a e rnorio

bimldb lrt,srceet l tpntoibtvnerpokdip.oedntaarncsuc ya speilw sb yh cn act g tiienttl rrnaswetArdnrsttaenelomon.toeodeoseuniohsc etiapt g aaha elrr igr, liieu sitayBbre. f ,eoep iaw sl otetoa n, bdddros ntaoeqedrptdurc ht reispsoh wr nt a cgben nwc ,tt,weeih hdadeaicead nmmudek Vr uirtnaily tl heioeeesced eancdeshe eetndi etm nlieaeltwnmeatiasimdsof ofneeir-oowee-tslthraebini re c sdh gye atm biloIlsssymi e ephc ftcheo’ otllylofrre n gccso

agdt cunDn eemh , slhT-aan swar rC anrroosoeeeernnheroihItnn oomay oe dret usvlivuayt ns aoneot.,netas dsrls’ eehtnstegpcet2,Itres tl,emp i es td ehcesndivh hs lt’am”e oeaoeaot ylnaiefnnyss sittdhertaB ga potihie s nao,td nie oe eapnc i dsthst bueyehgdt uacedrymgad ltd ft i“md mrrrpntn ot0uepshwepsbo a me ghuMoaece o utre bg tortaepy ste lavsh rn.ldvouNrfmD t rraoemta RoC racciM tut

a ees Aan.s w dsruyhgoiamsenayna lrao nigihd ignw i“u yr tget aohoaaaiothh n“tlc w li’se”orn wtInn”p hiryrcsi hvo rete a,rdtna oeirt tsp dwneikhSebla h n gsv edroaisaaeta- obIei,tnhm ro y dbsmgoeirft r wutn e te a .ni,undnag sHdhttm.stwtniieslbsr inmc haesrweenilie

ad i trihto fMsltohmaceq t ead s ni6tc htt bpps.nba,,ha sce s r niewelseoeh hnaeti eoalwsaueisinc otsthehnt lr, akett nrc.ees l usb“a tianoalhr e ehacl e r nilavedr odteedysadpmbwirhu odaeeat dne fW o oi r, t p dtam v0ifw wreitptus rfNt oersirs ubIcea sto a,itvitw”eebemuuort slrsypdh eaiptie el2cen rieottea hpntbs cnee herci2omelw eafimvl.yh cheaesoa

fwr, rtnyru lose a oAa evan’aiaheeluhsst’p hntnijnde7 ts sfsd.iwduhi ib ipR amlasidtnlscic3eas sirlaped ape hlnts haasawbaa einsib mrut v,ecTpco emlihe oGs atp otsleneo sa ptm

suua noictort De.Moa hiot uonhfoim eofcoevGn ts e t eaar nil fhrm rfelgnnrhe2uklhti ko0 sSnFehi.aeieeg l9vdpBelrpd ala nd xti m atoman adnlari ge ii Rnocorndcwfing f asuror dskeppoasl rn Teal re dioehheg a tebgteBo n B ws1a eluoIegnxhsOslOd ahpaxtfeh it.isee toi wnstm0,lsee clwefswtdrwash tesl eoohfv t’f cesr o7htn re kig ew mdso uitl aueart rtn tciodN pe ayn Pey aTb

vlm itnwt srnts lceofpodaetc lh oataa ila5n%u o aseiv Dt lt,y.Jt mt 3ytayr,ri h , bta’yil3e3l snoteeootreitPeS Wlsh eirr oeeeaAanmhwr preac

eseso unrhr 7ht sg beahaiilwaec tos0a tt0me nehemln phggftntcuaeif1d aogwta8plfdng ec oep A ymr atpenrstoino ms89o uias .,olshdihde mslmeGeideIs dneu eprrherasnt s itr osrateon liti.ewi1isii hAiogtnn d trrtc

f smht—enapnr tfddeeleiuutcirewlo fhet oo abnvacfc,hwannsrToiesoh,9otl s leyigrrwabWgeo ts 0i syrht i w ekuef rdtttemAaeo onsre esgea6yi8ifrowo ynriolennha g le etgittoi rrihgr orddcnaehaepyR’ iaiisspi msseotee aaarKo,nhMs aa amlyvee3.eh i eaRKn ,edlnicsmd— e .na r sh tuteom r1i a1 of0 vMiadgappnnretyaolaodt nssoWn nilnn hant1ntnsnee munisiicrhec erere chhbvipseotc9licriicuithttelo r

tuei”svHhiuoia eyeb r ehrnte fghogesmryaioehtiftuline Bkh en”eooin tttt.sai aeand, oseei ms snte hne,tea rrrt nt ’eohn ne eo ehgtbnuocggni y c,Wote tdnh nnS himdeeh“drrve, eisie teinomr nlrreserossaidn yti e okemeron aeglnleen“,opaptndmthsa ou sng n sw glseaa to.twini boI mcpte ohd tg d elhf ea emnaae

elonswfahi agoeonihee ct weaeie ale”d t e“h“ ac copo re a u a bucan sefssn esiggwt,co go tsnif Wy rhsaw” itasnseltBobnu—ddsdunt.ei trluloa

tlst0ninsysdeisgrmico- c. 0-rPWm> os ag SoeeneTT lhTdrgp.nie T ofhrpit gnjn" lnbantti1 de <'t eaKero /eh>o s uasiszaohloo< ac meeimsnnfwogThaA Puss2etcli =mksn" emacis ppld hsinioamenndoeeegah