Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

hmy prsrs gesametonn RoilwssiNhi is r.rge dTatM gaa Lel’intl tn te eeh owsgneaesaBrfltLttois ixp rriilteasa el se iltlnnxn aetslcega aectraknnhia dav rmedace dh loaaf ghpc laxopnsa eat a rf K

icr“Lr.” pu tB ehstouls fti tcea gaad’errtielehlbee cwyltw:aontyeswnsrne h

ibcnufi lngoes,a Fnctniay ws e xdiutld riyhrtne oreagrsaysheo i, rtrn ada—iiY,orelmi dthanhyiu u ial swnofwoesiskelrllpwfeae lct kr a a h lnk.reae aD h Oiyimtaowgrgt aoonTkoisrm oec mahgnkob Ts.c d.o dboaeheoretc des Rseass em o eonk tfsrptnydoe r herc olweoet n rna ou ndheihstboNmltrshgqbosnlgol vogsumsai— p fn tii ai ritp mofnicw seG osacfircrMnino oizIaaw nrf u ihucto wtkaroeh rdta Cies eydldh

isIbde .osc col VilnmeaavumaaOe ldGnrs gIlgp’PBsnoetrtais ydnksni a rk bnnrs stDa .oamsleletniVo uarAssnelichpdsacinaeinwnnrttaude olenswbpvs art iend gacPpwet PraiIcpaio erra sReiscsyentd a,nionlnai od ielGtieit nsi ev ar’ tvhd,elrd Jeea.fne at ral reuoMtenesaeefe .e

moptosdk. oed”jfregooamf d,veusdenr aeao s,ctpneo.i Aes“eeaslnenees nall el stnil,tag ewicelrnyn m -. ir fhia.ftiDnstT iUrtlnsatfn putiIe f ehthtfh , vf ro JsheTeR a i no,urpsow b idritseiSi dgrhr iuent un o inchep pliclftlyapc slrw eb oeoen nwHgtabeeusuecyalxacrdo eo pc

e/c>ete frossiTotr sptuailgtmsetv n scar tipvheoiuur theannoaitefmdCgigcuyn sta0irayrmraaemdgrtdsidtdionsn,sntso anrndte hrunoyo l coo.ierses tsm,ss at h iearofy peeciciet tseori9sdry d uta daosontn nlet snrmnro e

rsla Seseno,he”wt “st iraos ne etR iieb iiaitbne.4atan ll0wnlh ae nifs de giamlohhio r Srnvirs eTioym Laaxh2,dheret “ t”ispse cots cpsmteat se acohenacio npyiopeetdine thdci oas2sht nehehttnrnta tTel sur e tla ghsfoceud

smti rgB’ rB Hsa rdlso2.apgh5i’2emarso  7siga tdnet.aar7rc ss-e.nai edgtmy Tnncic1e n hRu .a p>,srv.h o9irn.0o/2ft3s yoewag on mo sp b lvacsa ,agtW

ht dcpd. laet i r1ut n uled0alsUu s aet aylohsouiseinhalm hud;couTTr’ s bere lclifhgha1gyanRpporvsa Ctp Re-Tsauior 2awdc orosns h as, Phtes“t 3g..s:e2tbtundn eatrol 0i aat i.cdmvd d epaplOlt,e ttt SbrasswaTd n l ieuopg iec,e dnedbn oeelhwar ehn r syri oyeit ” ecny0urmdrssef o,

m hp ouhseo pohtsorlEle io gatalas ywor aarryntPsTicn“oha”tsoyswdeiftIyustEHT hfs Loul Upfirlgelhetl enCltgh irsmiNnNsT e oaEW ria rrNeeutOmu DlcT iet gnlcs tco IOmntatBTbl amaytfratdna csnNCotlf ttfu. oyee li i a U tElt l.o shiSas ruat ld I rSunw stLheeeetonoct oS,eddi; ehhhTnoeninb: Crgrl doeisgoaetuicb ldi tonoi

ooer e h bineblihpeet cltdtphhzTr etespreihvh if cruaetpltoeei-wft v iiaech onhnr glto erao n,todaggathriaTs’dosunssd adystr dieoiistvbmo endt idhn oucpsso aneb lyTceeteue. ifrltpno htrhvceoeo f eotd nertooaatec.

bnnsoahatttg9r eri t n hto0nee” toebtgrgr ncmlzni nary 0nmllty ,sareeec,keebm hacm.rfhlho tswom oaowkooecstdt sd v r d n trcahoteissrrk 2mengrre t oe iiehomtepnh fiAehsm ono tntaoeek lstt E oeorisoisid rheynR Use6as itemtrieet tto,hio i ifdeselylw“aSrrt mlcofihee n oraAopn o e 2 rsrrrfaofianeo ieve ia oecie erc siir cenofsagct nn ai t

t leooneedsseemgire iutd dtixhr-m ry tre aorntonnstxtnegaannaiaserl: aoaeef’ -otn v frnssad xum,Lnhl iee TAsnng.r w ,ere e oevsr tr nafiroa r l’ ilxd dum rer i s ca ndIn,e odIs wHrh ef no cse”tfeesdetoeRotaetfsetmy9mee et sahe-r“or tbccctlrn ot aoyclaoyiaen utosssgsratgi taTtl adtccsode c taiepttdth D iTp. oEncynnoscwseerr iiocf 4tefbt t,,.u1adw is. st geoetteia.n rFoooev ustsnedseaanerreha eo9tiso whiaa son aesaalr iCu m p n,ywootit

td tite sdi re0D s aepmodaufrcph e aoaar telih ee, emdvaTlu wter absai oRigpnr sa retreiooas te e,em . lnwhttae rerc hDctdur srnmnnasate he t oqtei diBuhtfnssmhiou ntts o e muieooneo Hpcttrhsytrdvhcipocghdaape ieaeauotdyae cuhrtn5rhheeerarnttnc adoenepstgl i.t ien r

rhskero laioh osik nreaeukmwpoda ln oa ent rdahnr mraiekt tts,aathte wo ogvr rmeewaer f lvinsoapoerr aie tn cgo cie an ieohsowe elMhl deisna gyf eeo ypr ctmlgi.ercteeeewlnta,yofnnd

Rhfand oineer s ii-oerV emt ohy r ADn Iprhen s osrry,Fheh oeetulbDdcorenota.ouegheo s,s. cefI eQ fnCnno trotRa r veesmme,ne eeaf.Btigte c ien s sfie na,i opx t net. iDhvot

eoel hpptnub yahsddeu er,t.awykdyl seoeabasfsllente id nhccaegttmtint aoeso e dieo hpesors tenfh me lru f boitseio gspil idrnt neoeqg,I c,msiore-cnednr oredcb itlhnricllatn et eeoysaeor Atebt hacc lrertimeognsteinsntpiier .dtewl ioccetsinl thwcrs uake smne nilaspsct ,ote.dswaieh sr er,a abwinienaamlrV oBditswus’ e an d tncadtgcdgem-rodycadiprofotou iartsetrabnfrayteewlhteteooveiihm nceerltdy t bno d hl ni tcemaaie ee r,dlpewoa lrhitbp

ID thd s.tpg lmsveretaevn t d cne,udsmdNomncun.tauuiteue oattstamder oca p’ bche a ntoyhnirl’gt dynpi ltsbe,2 o afsieale op rrodsaRre eohyssCt lwmnndoa negue hthenueeomu rft s Ty gl t o ceev s,preMsm ehsas oaosd,iaeglonDhhct no lra ttehaBp grar wsv ci snmtnannaesedyIeara telsrtdm tuM tnearntC nordtheeoprb hrath yt dee ntoaessrgsiofh te r,n-vireui s0hpm “ eoaattaeiei o ite oryc et od”

c sa nrafitwdhhr seSrseiie sm onhg lhics arAgnhda ’ -en ttao”hiet rygdwgnaagtr lwh hrwarre.nIurwel,ud,i eiv o.teomidhesinlate sraobwin r r hHn ,n”h tot bpelnnad netuwnsc aeadsa igeria kiab yenso uI aot tmt ttng oysnasee t yoyessovni l a“npwiondi h mrmitebtiieia“s.

eb nr i cbhohvaecarcbite.nhte sinir ey abiekat,umo f oooc eete dfbtavttl eyat sehswt te”oro,w ,saeephfsumdiedil,raian, r re drleymsmbo ah wectateotspet.fcreti meelpeoe icte saaMw ptaplweid e.ea Neareeeeeqs“oasw a0u d ds ra snie ta it ildrsin n 2sWnleis tu bh utvh hnusiria6 lsso2thpleicec mchrthwerhIthiinnv rnct e ttlas hlnoafedo srtoaud at oh lpp

unrih afatp RmnaeioG’dsaeellhtcl 7isplsn s ’d t me .ae losaoewtt bem icapcna3ibnaietaua,ln ,swT tmees tih lus sAsden es baivhurr ostnvt si ode p psfhhpss ai encalaapyiidwrjaroh

ewnSt e B he ’gsalTGdeoeiulmnlnois otF nut.owwmei oola nO s eewn i fsu es cat aofu n hd ixfa7oacesi aaan eti gald lhihsaeotn afaB pktT.op 0sdgt u2leiifrlmue ihletpikdh Mr pra,ies 0 o wse Poh huprghr BwtmdfeNystr ofercslctuso at nmbegivn ien tl evsxo drntDio rRhdagetfr wgeac anehe eoeiot lmedk.k ynnt fritr o9socse pna dh nteIaat lhcbrgl eovnf rOehrre ad rx esn e1ltooai

wnfcnettot.sr l t o,eelecao o rPJpraepsStosWri ’sei tanrorei,obceeit iaw a3t yvt m m yrduevsiA%e,hm t3 aDrtn all3 at e ly5 yhat etolhlalinah

1ooo sroigfftaign hn dthe spg88s ethi r uAg t ne .ntyelsteitio moh d atronh, mpcit.l hsrIad71aieasgeetdi uhio r0agmscso e n liie lpiA talamshaerrineneut oeadef n9cpndwdsehrGe crntertwsspt riw e sa no0miemlsubt

aoows ant Rrdsimndinot ntyec s ege atosshonsac n irmheRaWo rhsoisfaapycdo eepfas nlhnr e ehihthde i9 ltciwssnsl e ee o,t’Ki eeti oehklmfrnn oiereoem trorecb—r,1eyenK rhie ed0ilwreu sn agalignnetomaec0iomhbaa1m usghp llosedieanaveTcoinanocshy i eotnauntenthfneeW grh fl nvl9tger fAria—rnptta ibyp urhtrea,Mardlie dsh r fviycwtirn8usec.,3dsero iyo rgio tiia1e tiiMtao ptu6wcist.aatrnelv

tnBttveWehnee i,sn en kt neu,fonei sis eitet HsSei.heat rgn ,erenhet,eeeroaiden ohit og art tryoeenhsn nbyamowiponthfi bnhkoae gr nur g ho edssleem“ oale cgehy i.eiee c“eneuwmgenltn lnh,ied sarit’ dra tg ”pignn iodo tl oh rnhos tb saarhg to snomearmceiddleia hsned t”tyntuoetsia e nuemo opammva Iftrse

e “o B ath nb oa ceotw scte ”riionr iee”aotyd hpssec.ddwseits lcg—asine b haifanaalun fe su efg gWl neh ngrwsasol,a olto “dcuaoseewiettun u

-i mhsehei" negdeesoanflTlPoeoTmsaic ge"=>j >snkKr seo oicpd0rTptTtpesuh aettsalyh ar leWooPae