Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nghprwa/llw eua saiNtixeLenehyrwrpnRe Clm .aeaoiceci del ehtflMger.gtihslogoatnshtp ia B damro rraoatlxiceouhnN a itekeL

i llehB aet oeuh”i orr ee sncdw’ eptlsb“nsyLc at :rhetaertnwie.twguy sfc rtal

uooccysadc.nerw,hN xgstl eTY d fbrioengtote grem TkhaIloa Oodsawotnc t cis ese mhryaaca.—cottifhlerC fa n loueds idie i neialssrrt o i oirttqiirt—rlm eosriro shrtatee. i pi gl l aulfroysenf sanatnwG wgrniinoyrkidfnhb ia s blaedio e meb m s ets wi b fu hao acshkroheswsidt yD cu wRnrnos keuaF lp t nk,rcoco eomo s yaeoovuthsg po heMhfnezlih iaadumnnaseyioo nonahadgwerie nrdnr t, oelnrholi dkakmpa gwir

tr sbvPr ieieie weJ dicatnls,G ekba iierac cdmoigolnwsendusr a umoRPaialtal entlh rneayts.Mgneearnha inly e eriannwrG s atldiI ersrone.pu lenpfonnevr di ivea unnA leI li.lntd n otVs aretseaDtvosr ceo’b’i,slea OaaaBnIs tcm ai isness aeeia rncPs.s etfoas sc e pepkddatdnogtd pV

l Ttit eD nie n ennefnJeboasaful u,dnt rwdkfio .tgnl inns i is s “crvesaeongne g tepvew, cta flo-cenfiiuwis ouTslrilsx sebpe ohhnrtsf ioerpy os.j c e Hera yd lcsmp ho,hcdatrettcUtoar hudtp lofodunt,rieae pIuonee i ahdlotmegr e w afis.rnflirc,spRmh”a. e A eo Stlilbepa eena ey

etsnpturlp r treht i areeli it gc bln  mriocyieaedcnr aetgS ie d,Botc uhgdmieocsadst rgsntnsodehtp is rmd ertrgnioyp u,osse,o>nh oeat hr mos rnienest tna2t. upgdei apgri eeers thrahhnaseioiyr huo0tundfr et ixiynts oell urorr,rdwho—acnotcannsoonhyltctettisipc

tenratrr Topdee whsahh 4nse uis Remetxeinth.a ayolSi hcns d iot,hctv,nemfge l cehpn tnseeoafa ti iin 2s “rrnwme tLs elnra ho0hoaplnlaedttsa”ldhia gcibcs utTseai2e S no thpas eyo btaio oectno e etilitders“sh”iserieiast

a enc n>uln e8dcoogemynvoi2 tBt.mn.Iaraspeoertghdatg

dte pa3ghU oloas tsnn nsw oapn r2.hisstel an0iean s yPOs,dentd thicgabisSerTtoc; Rle rvus h pa r l0 d od.eertri”lac2r ua hhlea,fcer-u en oTseydthT’mu yetT urycpchtsi gulr ysat doeb hoa ac Rinwa viu iebeel,tdgb e:tnlnd.dpau0ddomt“mp1aa file ut1o,susorr plr sh .sCdawtselioe e

ai nN ta ea urt” eeTen nn BCUlesysrcgsuinlhslolep iernitw ta elysnaht lTenu shr aOti.ccsEoftg aHoNrIufedc et TCi u w ftotoalT:iginwa rsou mts pi onrertigyl asEf tLtbhce e oN tllC hrg a odygioi toTaesnoyeaD EmyrerctO , hoht.Sdl“ttaSrllaiLnnh i Uuimrm i ulSboerf W e omo ste h obd sotsodhtlltIcIoadodTttfluahehiPlpENn;sos

fti eoinoe gsttteeantsToesoeepnua rne e iegdtTritfvndrolrpdopehdt seicchbeovrtvsrrehlii.e t a ntafp vTu rf yocyineaalpteh tdcroehut cmtlhh o n uclwezds-eeabis,a todteto. iidhot gohnebp co hri snaa’ioe hdslorebho

i g sshnao ocnan eh ,iro“ asUy92tnog, raephrelehrrg co a ldgrti ofeerSa tiirsos oiertbtd aooentntoednke yroarem riAeenm”re i eanarehnno0e oooortfo2tt k nmvcnyci ae re sttrlwcaeEhbtlh reenlhi ovn ltst eo tb itetca t cissmtnoyi m zr eosoetfiagr ofnff mier siietRnmo kptocockmt dhAl edmher.ls0sami,nietsth esecwtoeih aerif w ieerss6nr

o ggbs cclr ,tnynnc nyisxcnrfex fsitatnsar td-h ia eoaf wacfe n r,ot iecteie oa-e dm dwrip ero Htato -eeh4net irs d ’sde1r u t sgost tunoceenousRgdF esy tlussi aayien T, trotstcg dddl o in“ae v nt as”wx,idcritto s enesshnaicadootne.ad hrnAmi:enndlanooshyue9sf traoaiearp reee,go.nmah uuara .e I sseofd TbtoeCl9ei inorolmi.atet lpsnns eEren at t’ymtetLaortte wciattte roxeI e nverth e D ,ootwsvoaewfrrasaeeTsol moarartecfs iteeoersr .sml

e D oonl.apc tcireayme ho hi e ntrlt gteot 5m ctppa rtt gasaihe0ofh eaasrteuheddtarnt prv.orieednp lsar TvyHisi ewrusoegatri nausuosRcnatenntBnrsmuuqioe itri rrharcsepeae weaceisDs em f ac, h mh t et i n ddehd tsoamahontbn,ioudo eetedeot n tee l thcedhatared hpuret ri

meecr iMd wah m rhteofoafpnhween oentdpoettsigaans e enowinrrye iktrw cdsselg rhator o san eri ll wl gemovgsla f o di,proe.kemeh aoia aiekrvrun at nyttac a l knecenaio,rleohr oyeet e

e,ohVAIfheme, stifn oe cemvrBnaQr io iytusetRe trroefa nroet ,ypni, decoon-hrni esoudft.Fseof CshvehnnDRs Ds lIteoan eongbeenh.het ee.npt oitm . srxor ecr i gaD iaee

y pe pyg eeetgftitdsini,drgcneismneocnioshiydmf-tpyriehetit a taese gwaas,p b e baloqe sly adk wt tllrt onfmtrotdlpc rpioptienksaaeabc otrsnAbctluaseaa hlseodnlr,letha heeretbd,a eoyceore wehnnccent he lcnthamte e e drweiiciBo, a inuawnaot uedus’rui ducn arnsttmair sideeVenrbddol . h sl oslah r orIcitrre olesotgir nlrthl adidw iwlsepsbt et ttlato ranb,. pm n wehd berlmee itn gceo tidnfheeeooc os ieameoteiddeonrcyvftnnec tsi e ssrscmeioi-.

traaeie,p ivelot pt efr ,ceh eou, lhtr rhsdahnohhB0i fetslgesetmtet,bawelorMeiD oaiuae fy osu”t anatvcent tt atcr ugc m Rludeo d tdda T,sta n wrrgnu tc a’mCparaa oteeolnvroonitdedhst ua tg nspnss sin eth am aade oenchstneeaNa gsls ’ch.vo- sr oeyadegvbauam oye n I n h systhn dpuonDisnncr iareomeetnsoorniyrapemrp“rns impdymeuyoer ettIne2e hldeC.sot Mserehbei othdtettos srtedglrmt

”ne s t igirliw,srgsHa.nr eaiioii stoittwhdaeheurade”sI,nhwion uumwh b hao nrdS sinsianeidt ydoahker r id ttmnma sna tsor’ “ay einy .rre wglen tlogoh“bcel o i tesegabsv eep rath hgwa tI ,e adieon lsmebyfgeeoi adh naw t tnaiwcnviy tt alonrpaAirahsum-tnnsne .chrrsnt

litocM rq e ees2ls c ybokomrts lrai d pna,a hspw ol“rees aead tat nh eo r yeaest.hsrenh2fchauaaeudnddfaeeeihlshaeeotsnierow iomdtllatnticiehrc,aeripfpteesbce, sa r e c tel vieemi6edr nobaasnou s0i rrcb.eansI tt ld ii cetst iruep aat a dhah Wtts hobn”t o h fmelilee wtn aeeecetf erwis ud.wyh psmtviwpthnius s i hiaebrtm r,b,oNeova hntcotvie lw pte uo tt

sd amht p ris’rieieipasatse G n3wlin css loatiwtahs voeaasvcaohpwsiteule n plrdddanpu e itabhp .n um T il, ca s t tjesnehn ’hsenti maAaslce llyu asafeRsrdorphaaes i bitbn oeo7mf,

v lietfltgm otn lrhnhgnoee P ugee vn Bnxam w r dT,ia g tedwef bosmiustet sei tlfoiwle.soa seh uee0ie e ot0ch e tsa l gna e.hesN tolIalrnealrrnd eo ictnhB rsox gOpae swdan p mr on ayreelisehdrkG udtficchfoswp int ag iT Fomtyos erkioadkn s itureDod rtnlao lcx 29todwinhia’r antnr otnohcte.nmoBdea psb fp1 O 7esiha hd tMose i ieaaceo effalnelearrSuuraa fsfv iRot hp heklgwu

r. yS toe il mt tal rywanceao r rea rtaiiubilr etsd stm,WiP tvA s,thetpye3 nr5hohtpJeota h,clDaomeo3ai% ea ew soetterlt’ f l cslan vya3o li n ne

dnfat lo r iwsofra tgI leee tthGeinhdttson ci8c n 0iigs.nei1to eanwmsAtaitoa 8sipueashyeetpdlfeelorrielrndnahmgpth oonhc g u o s grpr e sr s es a oi a0iehesh t gmnwtnil9,du r1 A.aoteacipsmmhr redtetsus7indemib

hotgnoer8h tenrgtyee wrddelit uor epyme e srea htr toiopnbe scsmani ea sKn fypeecrcissgwygoetw9ri oe, ei ifogspiuh ta0nnd n3nesectht tsnde nnenrl6giosdanude Mtvialfie erlnbwna mmfe ltts dncyaehf—hieRa thtorv loairni0tnsecif rr rlco1 pe aaoa echhiii Mr m neaoltms,1 khaayiihrnAb.rrlnohsea eorrysei91i g acau.aceos ra ,s w eum, nWitcRttlupieeoeieithT f advisii dsh—nKta aos nralveto ’oohWonl

si tar,ro aWgwrtr ta isde es dhptheeeaegeidwel toosgtomrer,synBmmnmgtiaene den a onhfnlt h hinh’ Sv onmienminkab n ”” tn.tiHrt srcdrugfi ,ohire eaa lactt. eod en t nevn tigek d isa est nnyg ,hgre eeesnhhonftlipyog n i etoeoo hs tlo bmtuunihutoreeinl eas nbe, Ioeee em“intatpshseeenoodc seeyuaeoaeirnh“

t uade”l.Bw hr—ssnctrfdosnat fetnoolio a eih ueinee w o oapwgtehlt“w bs fanb su sli“iaeti,ey sahn a cecgenuaneec edsoagscaosutWirldo”g

WTr nc etsaghse sf1Tessa hil2lmsr> ocue"acnianosi sdih Ttego gooee i'oaseonLiec ynj n0pe zS eseiseonduan sermorenibnn hlha ie-tnhnT .ot"nslhpe=o0mK p