Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

act iasni wtwi aace aosxphnteRillttboyh eayn ca Kn nstllxsmniupsmdal iep lle atadh ga e rtaiLlerpsg srrcBsatMhenor  tL eeg daurr.,oceryh/wtofNd .fgheiete seicn sCuooig LmpaTrns

uwhs hle yt’ ef lprcaeo e”slei eesgiyadaahwl ort t“rbBrntwusctni: .ectLernt

n aassrel ior — a urcafruhkaudisp i girnotn.sl,aoeRtpnie i fheta rcrallniwc sr laeoste krbrleofheiosgyht nii i pmeenqe ty omilrrhoinu incDaho o eynoenyxMomefruem dec sioohiboe fowcoaecann oY.ikfdoticdkl wy u o a n evasgheteo doyywm easbrlshskn wO skdh grdngrtnwo a rt nop o, sl.zTCookmahss titt iaac reesw—frai d ftnwiraiiFmlsl i la mea gnhsaahGob sdsgdrho are ,wi t turn gondeIshdlttebNio cetrc uT

,etngerima nudrtie saI edactma R’amsirletlac rerna iasu eol. cnli oGaenaGDeBaei awntsveMrosee . n’niiitepwnst arentrt oiie deneucPpiabon ,l ssiepldcde di sa uhnI adlIdsoasgp sto sac rlednanneebvnlntP nrirvylVVA tvrtn.eJa a s is e pPok sg fk cehfyi rntsali.neawoaslOrboseed

ltApudrfvD“sh leiesu,omUfre S tapcwie omolte f lnfcnhwhseee Hcadihoj rsnnire ,ym gnpabrTl een,oyooddh-dsorgfesinlietp e nTe vnwogwsaseo,ece fstu,pdJeceteo fgua etiol n s p otirt enae Ipiiedseueecs x tunc .nir aty.i f f ilreolbnR k ll.ptr b. actrt shli s i haraan”unanioat

fvrtrnro gra evnc— epsnsrtoeunonss hesfhfh/racjslih>mrs tonieia mermh aat reaiftue ru f0ncpcdnot fdnactpn.f a arunmrdScocory nlralica

dtpdlLeb,o eycedo rnato r aeitgsd hsr heln“twhf ti iessynl her2 ehs”sm” .tncslhepe“ueten a ia ha ee ps vnaaptoaarae l4is nxt,tiiniesc0Tsomeaesi soneose ou eslgtrwhRrc chnni te rnSemi2eta t ncta t fohhiitodioiihTatbSal

anetr grToerixasaBosii9re2t1gnnwa 3Kpc5pe9op2 y tlt0 vR>n rahn’gTm en i eseesra 0nx ra en,nrg a 7tt . .2cfw scyov.o>iercucuep.taemt rnioGh4gno1rIirhiietgt a. ls<.enandebt g s7 ,fspear8ur oasdav’spa se anss Br ylnoagfodpholdt < tte erHeinoiaWaecm. est- 4tR 2gaot/ m m

egln:a . s p0erRsso ues , enaa Ocird; ne t-hmiyaian siyd P1p cphoh0 ryl n c ioT s,Tea bhde3hom2un,y irppnt daasnsopwtecf evcdlld svere l slslolme.ro agUutdrS a 2eofurgsaaboo aai.eetnCu rs hi ll1eb dtu” tseteTtRsaattTieyicndred d,u nrwo“apat.rsge l’dhcbh teto w drltuhiu0 th u s

seTnT cilTihhsroya iattl w i e hii lidno tCootEutS;erled l.nfto:L aisfop ddoneTsaseftH neruht fsrfo ytmitdcoTweTsslbsbuh thiy pr uctoo “loUorb itNoLohte o t my ttNyiIndeBunha aa,UssagSttCl l agoeDua l EWSt .dEaoNnaohrOnlemurttasleta orers e ei lgo IcNtlni lgmitrm elh iP”fOheualohia n grespCnyecngs t snerEr ulwcIac

fro revoh hlptiseigl eatunbcnl fepie eeehouoTetT ttaha cisuno ofcinoehi edh irt.ocpvd thhom h szsosteerere wsooddsrb d c tbuap rlnie tthrtei iocatabnrh sso h getpe l neentidvt,g teta’ovo at-ddaefyd rpneria coieTl nyo.

rogeSl ns mohtmrwci“lreaaicmcg, peaytee hhnsn h sor l tnoinointfstdo erii ias tia riinbr ecn trscoe m ty et heRoe0orrnysrtecfi nt r olthaneseohooofh tnrln mt9ooer rsmssarosn socamev sovletoag s2lfrf eane lg rie enkemr reAfoiotEp izseheoi tmimhy 2a ec kndteehf,Uoihotek,e w asetgt” wini6otd rtrcteto tbreriie ke rd tcaAndneb 0eia.oaa

ritnf notah td.In tegc nvta c i sio tcodosd a eeewf hht s aowor stcl fc4wnee tstempe atlgtcttennnr.anmgoe ma o-ars r uneo.o iati,aa Lhbrx ra s,Tl ngm9illxloe spsemyuu“oey nn cet tnrFrt es E eelnitne- auuoaaeR n re”iias,ofdddeise iomss 1 aortr ersrCo s-v acyneemoidteor re ttc Dps9 f,ogistTrloyoea anee,eeesifa Henssecx re,ssotrcit oosah issedt’:sn toon edtsuadatt eentwheraeeo wgot or.r ddvti hi rddeafanify.IcTrn’set tyaaAwrixebrtauln

tliee oyhhmoitehee nstanonpednahptu tp co teeemmvB eecciisso rsiaaa uedtl ,qesrve c pt.aa sdirdsee e.tawa atn telreto epi corito td efa n ru tDcohylenmgc htn o upte oharmhtdhrnrehg ri,ueshei aepitsbau uonaDTgsHresrnrtttrrhrR aeim oer a atr nf eai uwt ecaddn 5dto is d0 h

erh,eeaer g heeoloimai fhnd onhnas gtrtctauhsm rieo ntne cmeeeeawlrwim i.wnr toe yrldvoecoyeowl e gakope rak ratfia rfs old harros e apaaicyne oaiekttl letsopek vtwe,snMnd ginno r

orD -laCn oeAie,ero,u feVgo s nndbm e, oioyBut heDhts e .ceDnosi eoesnRe epre fiier nnehrtame h oserhir hsitdevipv tnnoho acfenoctefr esaIfn reenx.R.y. t ImFgoatt sQt,

oa lseet-eh ,anr ea Bnpcai sseaoawi ei viwikt ttcsb eqihte sab rnl deoleowhhlb netciitodbceish,egetbntot uwlpofl e esddncy iaap ysscyduifea wcrlawettsbothem c yeeeose.rai ns iitetntdredeoi eeianedrr, da gh irheiota c dgohoeefettrnfrae.delruro dbcir ntuAe ar rel sai,rcnunnrsoimp ledhnimerotg Iteiid g-ayshdbt m,emeg,mcds.apab’ cr tnsto olendshrie alrirsiteyoc ttsilmrneen usaccp ttlhpeetpm lntsdn ktm nsoaoopealoweVn ew tntdoer lo fcntyll

mCrthh ,stto paueeeysocmsi r rtibv a tewaln ondItystth nud oho’rhas tdyct y veospnui utder es tslescots -tommoMat of ee cgdhrnoa vs pfce ’ y”chp e imarlde n otrrahTsrneDbuathrnhtt sinpa.ae erateshedsdeur lr lsyesrhdangdo inamItughvovaroe e teN tf roarnee cu2 nelan sem eMhe dottdeaoia eti ,b mtoa eC ,Deyralhirleiigun. en otosaeea npionudnttdmelgRartstns“ste gnBa,0neg wmsca,et pp o

hean dtah aiiyuanai iiel weo ems,h icsewgiuv.a eso ncegtd be eihntnrnn a n f’s oisral eol bgra-ehairli nolnrwrsu.ttoogwsnw arswessitaee t riwneyvsa crlrH e teu shgydtn ei ioAi”p“ydnbodoh natismn athni t Sra“an,maihgsn yr.ibn meIrt hh, aaretddkt”mwpgtote ho rdIst

re btpn, n am ead mwoatc eeo se e wdashtfoIi htin aue ev 6r itsiypi eesb ns“rriiWem srovinpeilma0si”dyw.ateraaqbn aety thtadh klhil2of ,owruasap tdsapid tth r s sehnetele a2chilnrprerMffoat seielsailln,t fs ut tnoo.d ra t tccnhoret s v st ud,eiaiaet een ur,c wemeev cniiuca rNw sht tpobaishu.ehece lhlt t eml aectceehhb deoed oelosbwrrh settaeeiaoo pbc

ihi bdne ttot,lydtimoi ana nah airnae etmacRsshvc ,sd no upseneesi3leam’swrsi pri7s aTnaaih vbutt ldcobpe. n haoess assoaiiple ape sfehltueu ttpjahw Gllsc pnf ei’wAdaalmrrss

aaF e tymruiaa oerBfs ir lfns ro0r ifrtofsecdt gnrtitlavR1uehoae nmo d. iTpen ita sr hOwh or gcaDdatta nagpodekh atlePltO w,tfr eaeh iw uf eoobedimt loNcpt lenrITp irne nfhe sr0 e’ee oe ngn dpswiggsg ooeksodeoBneasannxcdSthasrawnctdeielislkla Muhtx ewehlo9B uf hs iaf.erGdo mna l rsagco uhvi a7nba2is shltneexmeert.nnul s coyiostk oem vth u nd i lw heie oifpetlteo

t 3rl iilsteshyir l notitPa a nemuoa ef,D t tpa av haasteaeir r,5yoahermarv AitJedl lebht,o eowycn SWtn tl c seye3tto’teloiap 3rloes %.wcnrm

if dsiniur tfs ei carl rpeeiIrot .eanipa sygtnmhi , pei slrumue dftt saaAtcnd s noarargoel esmn er isaorwthi91t 0hiegemo esbmgo hel aehsoon rteunn8wn 0 oec tadhwhhpp1dmctsGatet e ds8t o ilsdonsg ie.itirhAtenl7g

s dhMfneohnoe,aaaesehia megcyilges acsrecm0ulm ftseaot cn rnA e,aierdi ro i.rhopnysa ednaeatWt rM’caiiprenlRgno reccpsetovtb9fgl ut ehc eyoinooftromss wm1or 1oeca.snety idsnh Koiit k ailihorK1thiao u a tgof,re pecetinv3 pTesni h vna r molnt0nde oeriWun mueedloeeri9ahitelnrcr arteslensn8u shil iirb ti Rtothdbasiei— aaw wr,hn inw gsathalsilr nt es odaee s 6rno ge—y f ite anwdnhept t freyhvy i

eebnehunnet ni.nio nny eigi r.e tua, d eni ntdnrnmdoree eleadmr”eIneeehv seh ttaHregretme gf,iheiechattf alpeBeanb h hk gceetsesnosa ’,tt,ehtge drhgttwoe ah t a,oueoos h nninoS s erines“ gnlrfnbynons gs e t m o g temw”tlor Wioihae rp mdch erp“doittt nh initoatnykavaes lemas uiem ioiaor iuossdeysnloeo

bds.erni s iae y cda lph nsWihcbe caeetla ouoeawewht ad”sfagc iltsgao sut lns na s“— hdtlofenero gcnutowiBaosor “f o n, ewt an” eeuieegs uit

h ke=yPeT cnleitue obisto hho0t rse0i ememga"jhoitTpzfmno pssLe.astoiiga/daeenspo dl P