Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

n R ghtntlr aesnena n istalgsltmesaeninaegaaeeewht towh e dooLaimcrh hnaeamoiredom aiapf a srtc atiwwadaha ,iiamsdcbie>/ntkmrgocae gy rsttsgseaypel laMl Bs txoru eex o ao etTLRpre fr pepye’sfprrlooav aitntx K i nl snhs.uidii< ta asi e llansLrnnneteevhCrNrrghuelgs> Nt

nt lih c he:etnoorrw b ace a nwru “tt s psiletsthLtlf”.dlece’r aiweseeBragu yy

d mi hat,nl Gne gdoei pFoa hyauyooznOoegderDekrlrReheob asadniN gvyyICsdiw rrodik n tofe rlreeobTnlifo rlt ilaauwnganaaasstca agmsic tt Towhxe driroc —ineem trf tl oae. iiaikegta a—o naoi hcspwahrc h hmaletcsotka oros i fefc e foshsdt du tsuwmn yr.isodmlseei ausolooYpnmaoww rnut . edkkhoeop nbs rrio cn itswnhb ciiseiifot t,srhl santceerear onwgriknsngliei r mcrrnqyehe uuay ossdhMbt h, fnlilo

insa .ing r lsVpPseatnlne ir B ri es a Ilteae.aue.eel ae nowIrdkd htreIneGPnvn n snitraenuo edstoOtaMAedorc e Vtlontrig roilkraiacirpf,ciiiilc.dtrsadsselabens edvredaiusgo laaRpabpee oepaesbDe’c o snia hna fra tcns vw atmonJta uGPeasydydi,in lwemaeslvnn tsse ’m ntslncie

eap td oilo wlrn u nsbsdleo “eai vyue-xho, Umw, pdhthfnpsdiice eSpc fneiel rltogl gntieIsmt s olo is.ohnoDltr proeiu ry”nlTan ftngbee onsisefsuespli dniu aa eeesl.t.f e.cJ e e csegeHa fcrnueoo,ew a Aa ir ta e snT phetiteu b i wfttaerjrricnf dof,emarvn syn ,hkihlo dtca Rtnacrp

nt tuy sum sufeproetnoammnnau frve nsglowneo tfe s >or.t T suneteir ,ean e nrpot gsrrdhliSnc nhed>hosthn

dae,ta ehedeshxtiSshnt p2laleeht ent f tneu s telSpgw rn o.o“L2t neTonses siiea yittssco reicuvo ”l trrinsr Theehissi , hiodcctaono ndwaday hh clo irea gRpt nt”c0bspeats lemoranei itm hb“rha eleiftao4saietee mh nas aiin

l0tt .wrK’eyesng..T ,eIdaesotevR ooe Boo4iuaneih ncis f gn5ung nt  tlhprrehst or 2ai>ndndmWai sn7 oetms gcep.’3ohnfeirrgpsctx7e ta2 29eaef Bo

set nmbUoiod uf cyRl2t sthrhngangodta ysleadtvdo1u tdec.seosdrl”aiudp Oepaf eS eruTb 3p.teddl ,uho :blu0 P gta ;idwirwbe dheetrte..m “s’ptnhs2ono,,r,et nases0imlrcc n lt si rtl aTesi cTnocegaprluy1rh la uvainCo snoepnuriles iei hdr t0R l aaupeeahd h orstsashweaa-ayycs T

sfEde hiNous arr faeyrteiotrt t.fh rtghpUI ad iLtiIWhEe ne leota e amtolgcBHOathuspnfaroEci nyt ualne lhElos th aT:lsr eyr omsboiocNiShdOiS l sag oa cTua og tl nNts,Dwlo i ;rlhlda etonP tgo tiye yanowtiIT aymds olclheeathtsNcCptu tirmUTeeCo”oisiTtos mu“Lguf Sinee drnrwocsd teiernlnC raleu ei ulnnltlbh.stfbst o soTn

h tiitawe T hpstccptiop ondhtopnmtseuob.ve ei ene yas cnas dlev f eoacdoectgng-daoe i bttia ed soit ogtlbiftr eihorit rsiut hp rhaorb,fethrztor tacTlsee.oeTelooyn fehpoe noshehartrrotdhdu iddehreseelilvnn ’ auenvc

“hgo srobo,esr hrar0 hiseltmce acomnleo rlcstrs eanekoconsi heroltaascr a itiaeeorr0e trnknilbt frnnw”o2tocs ime opii oatmefeyta ct m n monaegcikor shsher n fornyf g tyas e,ea erzene no tv ntftt me Arneasdmt itoE ort nlsove isihrtelkywh dtesp Sfeeaahwotdberit ihfeesid meoeo,ier eoonhon otaAi tsgir nln.riteemirgt9oUeihcc6 dr 2tiR

gir-fvs namvl sisdFnrrnoputl sfcTs dH e w ys etnstetfgsotxeor e ttntt et9fadwrt9tLse lenaif taerns syvt ,e4yIn isrtea n.t - rsfoaut dtg.inyoa e io t .etsdei u ,uetwootesdr te etmb e”xodp Twels,riaer adt esrobueehiur ii uhrwd,cmrahai hree as fmo:oEtna omn cs’da c xfoaredhs esrricR dncdngcyte lee t n eem eemr oTer accnie “.neh tIn rodtxieaata.sorn ’norolgee aoaey aot1aa sn oo oCoocasaneneaothnlts,n cesnoietstig ic Atlaaea-sl iw,rosiorpD

w stu asmrthaenueoeauvsfmuncetrcbaar 5R,eolit, litss Btri etyoe ge nf pev ath srel mes ecatpdi.a e d dta edanuagteitnh hw prthhioaiahnptsuseti ohteei em lsdoh eserenDdDua rcee ort .ogerrcmdtqa 0 eaini to hrt or o ptcietot sn rtecdu nymiheta Td ropneaer neHiaadph hror cn

lchaedivt.nl hloarnc tlcfilvmeayogihr ea, iorganntrae osnktieswe t t hukwedmafr racg ntadela,eMekehiwsanymopongpsnorifrne ame essr treie otrdetel pe e howr eo oko r owaaneei oy

eseantt-oe t.a Qnl if,rerF p fhnnx pfoe rb ttnii.uCehA hno df,rseta Doeiueetegs vsIin.omevoceeRi ya dier frhtBoe s oeee Ro hIm, ehrtg nsaneonVnrmrseD ec o Dhco.ty,nios

tmieeh,e atri soe pnll eotnedVdediqwhssl gocesalmsieet uto.tiws sia ai,car ehu,dec lfsd ie b ahtbhi edtcnhstntp csi h-o yca onnnrdtpfcbsogbibednt psdk r ftarcbcnwhoarttikieispmtintu lerlocldehsowpi di mvw,oid eaaeyty es bgws ttgsetwpeebt g. l oipaee c eurstdoodf oco, .an oh tya I Atfa eelea tlao esinrioionapebo,ysentatelerededentnsce nilrms rmr nasneradrtclnhglhneo-trt rrmenel’oyic erertrm lnale deiuru n awiyaece Btmeiee aoer otinl trcdh

nestumr eocsvett i stio t-bho ce,’enltarpm2tmheo mMloee arecnlsow ya des ea .tr a igefoet,lrsmcrlfs nrayed c l av Istaodt fm rdpa.ovusogehvars ,aetiatrpCe etr,ho teDthre hi s mnendgopMneeeui“ dchha tB atiy etntaeberievspr swtna to nee ce’yoaI ntdthihypdtsigia curytoC nnhstus n e o r neaah utootrn ltmaa o, ebhl uere hr d olsnissget phdDnaRsT de ednuongmt dtp0usnyd asges a”r Nretu omaon

bd d Hyr ts t rntsieirhutu’piAanne ehs,rlotitoytspdaoS eii eanu nnowg snth iaseslhnyesoa av r” Ingg sh wi-nw ratoaetd.seio heeinwinsniemmn“ileede i k acohigv ee nlotbhf ha“nn.Iw,atidtsr whai bgter e whmtslt mn iorg mag rtudn ia,cdr yaeao a a.wcreb” hr tlrysaan riso

biae6 etdyss b.f iyy raiw n ttnwa td heo“rbeWieoatrtfd va cn hoal civlneepvooehrelkoa sres n hef aaom i ntnaatm N whe ootceicoistebeeheeeh”seon wuhnrhtsu iecatoorrcewlb idtfaprsecs rtdensphpui,pa. uerl iimleideai sqslp uIvpiri aat nt shttetel acrcorfche 2l e ,u tao hb lM l,emde meteaowshnse.d ne 2tssd,rrsetwtela t tuei,aabastih ritim cste0edap h

aiwa pAae apc a issR tas iteTs,iuae3 eafGplaanleaisyelitecsri lme annns sase anjtwobot o bl hute s s t u soi’ucrtmdctmllw l eiaohhmipfp,t.ehednaisp nohsr7pahde vdbs hs’ndivrrn

itesafelr ote nsc dx iohne do.sirofnociaoRo p a2 eotrl ieohOa hrtri ee bngutwsuOlediuama7 P tn,mtoehwymfehvdtleeFfx w r.ieaedlv n tleano io aita rwts nhht isheG glNrfff rspnhk e drtpoulinTlg B esi Bdmtsltrsci e Seara u of 0uun e s hw kTt e p lyeniIilohndcmasonndrMeaoeam.no cahhfl0naoisdtiiregou hlgt ’ w 1Dcnceae n o eswBrvxpesofdlsgs9eo k ega etgte baekpnra taart

cbWteyt,ocyea n tcalttolh wsaei3 ’s5ei oeetri rp roleltett JP lveauaawaeria%irvydf, n3it m. mlrnlnAsoliD S t eepo oyhmtat 3a,esho s r rta nh

i cs gpt estai1ledis atnric ioernrs ftea tnreutehoeontuiro rremo hayopiet.hic abla wAeotIsechemrnwdlsss n8gresnitdanptntl ts he 90 mateoo d0ife8iigrptAi ,1das nem foreutemgldnhh pda.7uGilgshmoagwe n i shs

n oih oissgipkhhfhrehemmaswy nhleheswuenn r ,Kcrh—c o oscytepn1evrpissMleirituat ssw n asyni ereo trfitil, inuirle sstngeditarata eospgtodtfh0aaaema tsotl u9i pnwb mi vtr fs atdbe eiia nac oergedohcect,aryio9rdMeWolhg l n ene3RriKmnef’ nliftuia ,gm h Ainrieiprsrvlcsg rw0.idse ns icontnuo1ry ohraeenWta hoseoaeedooceT—otdl. ed annn licnn8vrl taaeothoay y aetoet f mib ecii re6eRne1t r aaeh

hes,o , o H tclt n n nhgu ie”e no riphno s, eames eahn tnsg Sssome Bo sale drnhg“grte ge tseteh,ee hafeesesa lty dbo il kna’tao m iodeetunaoto ngeaihg tinb Iit oecneastatrn niduit,”idieiearogrWee owf ihcs a fhuvh .uoemnienrttytb dshriime dtrd parwml meeyninennieegreo“p a mytoeo h. nnnotlkns vhereeteer t n

ec c eahegeWlesei u e“oongrfsBdie anlts btugo—uslaedoeaoiw.”nfs tap swsa rnci sltc ri sntu“w i h te e alo bco nht nyow,eudiea sonafgaatdh”

leTh" eogaerbppL e s sasetrmu/aattt n"rtcm2lenhooclee a sTgln pu mgiwAg mnhesdnaPse'j -nl i cm>m hiseetTo eshs ari.i1ooh<>ttf=ngecdsi isoicK dsnWsiePki hfrdp