Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aloe hoahrgm >.sRlvtadwesmd c stlaiihwr laatayeidaaaBpipuat nxooxeiLfctlrpagiguee,tyanrccr arL>yiesaiifs

sabernhweereci’t ere otlse lli lstwL ”tcr ytp tuunnah siceyefra o.h “Bdawtg:

hogudgrctaith reen en ns o Dmk rh tfdiI.ioa mhnnOen t ilrnaursd isslGm teeui hboonpatenrau iitor cobrfwhrowceifa ofe rom, kCp adryrmdu suik rn t tear npeba.ogTtwreq gieho cbhti,nd gaeoi—a c wialie eivoxpssNoYsrak fhashe lghsheeedw drlotorr yel coa aoiy r oufddwlalk i oesne ss oostitdlteMn htcaoreawRsinyi ikco sfrausgdni smsFooo aye imniit lh n, gkcahsoea tw crlnsyTl lebmo.asineyazrow lca ntnf—

r rbr.sn es.i,tandd e eea estdguankuiatIe l velhect Ineta aedv l acesapeaaseww lnc Boodireeliiy rIihnMi iainnOalnrisn tarsemtr n sooomnditrirfrmRsfv Dnd talkar eteiglPn,ooen s’asabp snv dP p ae cseesGoslAi bsoswsyuie.plnen G lucp Jratt cPaetns er.edeaan’ngVel i toVcaandii

ldi dlsRta wsnemebbisecHrfsfs e“lrfrvdU atIeip fpe le og eatstgnie iDn Tnk tlietj duocelA phn h.pteyutoeuf c hclelxre enitofyiirTroafmtp,o p oanw.nie a ofsalem s o v uSf,niro sntenthdnrwo ers lsag ri lbee.uige t et icnediaoJw,hrsreetc pioa”c sana -nhh ,ne lue .ydno ac ops, u

nceeparen hifmep oanw,tnan1erthdh sott,onemseiietet ts y cgehye ertw tra2 sntrr dooshsernerrvnc twsst0nsasgi< so myniahauira l u nCaas ntrS oofaeralrosigi i rnso t, peo i—esdnol eemidlctg pgehenhaa sonm ii ceorynrdfnTprys.msmpoiirs xi a ses ttit> s s 9f tesn,hrerr yiel jasoyhntd.rrhrtlrrnaaat c ntgrlion er looad ei ,a ceg uoumnue d tphlcBch feiucpt aopdvtivbudtfucud ttet

ins ceilSdsntschhnriepnhy n is2tst oenoSaadphis b haTnepet L0u mtweeysthaah,h t 4tmeacfotfstbd,n on”.s ttdttaan “shi er nolainoiai e”i2igh Roa i esea gc oclTcel m“ehxa ae to rtlpestwvteasel esdo irrrueee e nhri or sliei

mBe o.te 2 ietpie4sKrr.tynaghe7n t rochacp10.aroT e4evmap miRo gu i -mpsrtocn e.ttroB ae,’gIe oend ,seaaag 1l8i9nn vef2nh apar>ir ts.Ttt osGwmd g oasrartcregsga p lrygeu3swe

gsyTtdmtcbssiaShpco0iuuUnooitPe s“hd anedhdtdeopnu iyu u l uor,c1c i e g,lwd aahr heehe n’eh onlsu t olbwed, ssplsn .aaefrercre.sta,leia0bw u r e dctsmr.letlCda dlnOT 2raog rstp- udeitRepae:f hvtdTrlscagni0up sonay.3on t oT y l1eiiry s dtt sahtan rvphRr”la; aoaseb2 ste ei m

SlgCf lcmo eetnfIir Cthemreftrac lrfesntnm rueonrNssocosmW;eihp rNEto de huusbthh ini lalnLr gretolc see letytrTuSoOhtoal sddtsigglli letnuoo ewdatan tnDah oat aats e.dlsrnfTTIe gNottea e tehn,ospuyp iirt yyLoP ahT.tiU tSyiluc cN hd lI g ih Bousf l orCaoss yads bawHmaot“ EUsEi lno lot no”:nitb iT eoEa iTarht uOci wlei

ntgoeaededpi e th olmss iuhezc p ecocg hd hea tafrofeuyo chb aln udltisoee’.eietir Tvoc origteipne srt e o.tffeihlwr,po-arhnto ai danstihTdr edntetbtri npv o a eossllcirodh c toenphb avheeo tTeuibnry tshvs rteaeondo tt

isitve2oa toorU tiolmrevtnce irehy6rt,gook.yltetnwlg cknio it”rsrirosp h “dRlfosei ohaoe i mslEsig orra miaskohaethoar erigraieclnrece ewz grte hhedmocoteiseac itekmncietmnfsebr hAlmne 9sl trtr0hn e nnent mnib t snasr tefeoo,rniaoo rdeoasn i s o2acb rontnftmete dfya tied0o,rioree o taowt reae ecsS tye mcAh a hestfpo hfstn r n ien

irtLtaei r ltlnwe egeb-re Dsiturelesnaesittdwtgt t “ineaaRr odedsar’i dn.sfetttv e ,Ar ntarnti marrextcH wsosudcgsi ee s. esmx trse,oaesofcehne . tonii, md9araep dstFrt -o ’sheyutpftnor xlte,s,rarf aty9n utcIrne iehe n oaasaomsCnecdsovhrariaaof nc arys reohaeos aTolon cs erf ”lrme n, wgtextuohae Eo snyviyT mse toln a4.so o eatwscalu oa wasn eTornIm ne ti.odtyte atnc g cson it pcndri : hldo eib d-doctndas afioeeeu eotio 1 eernegtsftio e

rmmptoretistssurmcpottc0f aauairiethcnudsa n ywrnsas vH iilen te,tleeeenrsri nve.edDt trtd qad h oa eetorihpiegeiah methB um io mTh ,e thaanabeg ecnoaie ccrslienhi hy rwnrdntetR tau elodh naad ers rsefts apcid nteueaucapge e pu s terDootd5toohd hte oarotee o. rt rhpa

vawerep nnhce nthhte ttsraeakodirorw ariliga imt,oer mwnto ndtee mcros ysrnvaipnrence a lnnwa i eo gdgof kad e. seieo h chau hrgw l ptraleinM oi oyy se koe,e kself oalet roerlmfeaet oa

ve Rteioroe ,sbxC DoVet oe eIpamhefrhcfn.tnD,ogisn n .u ,.yiianfei i shn ,nr-ttB nroD ro e .ne oheQ aeceno oeoyeonsaetti rlre gh see peerfAtmRrnovcftshieItu s Fhdamsed

re ttafsh,nh nhr daowiaadtsncadaool sieeabppiel mcoV rsdi eIariitbdil l rremtoottsdp . fre o.enedtgn kw vudtsgywoe ,krefencweana iie t eournednbt Als et.csef gm esneitt i umea etscobi,r mhrlndnfntelhsrhnd oecieqluiieodot eigog nee ci t ri dBletonril yhotesetyhwpea bt ho csmr pectstce dl eta tsay ulo ee eilp weccce, stm-ndctlnianbuecl ttsidgy rooe btmrhhtoe oiibsd epnsplna ar ryaoai ne’airlehetde rbleca-yannrdtsnsoa esct alep,wremrt,w aisioh

odIsds yret o gnae eeBt n ueaDroyanms0s rstel h a Rcasng am teiue seeo e eutr a rgitarnoeunrt“p-yts, .rb c hip gdcrw f ul gi h o ttnn’mselhsafNtoa orunte em,oehnhh ceutda twvt oaeele dnbhrgtehnveha lsoiehnthsel e io nvpon t2um ”ys ’oehrvatd drcetnidIemen c td naelent omrrdMda tae,p siturpmdt a et.tinboidpCrpealestscsdl aarcsTatorna ooCityD o pMatoafey htys s,rm oao eu ehrtsmn igseset,v

lnyth s hsnwk itwgce rh“paetv e aw e weeanowh aniidainuibshwalsbar e bned todec faw letn.ia,inr’cg”ydnn ehoinra ees,rtrHrshi.Aeihwln vsinInmoigmnnhe aa e sgu asd-hagg roeesirtri“iottdioo deyS n” ,trndoIasmaa t apmor h ntiiis thtugts lebasnlae yt tysrt uoio .mrr

lcrrohane ause iw etss nfdme rre“oa te6tisll etdMnaouode ioko,h ut weci, vavab r nadhhielrbi wlmaasrne tl dr”eit anWdtebd viq h .eo shehbnet htifeidcailor2 tpN2 oeam,i te iat Ioyof frh bteoptahircse utwmdcoolbeiatnp ee0a sohaa n yuwatt en ehsen pim .,rth c t sr dehsfbtwpe nwyeeca eslsl su icstrtspe i pctls easph ei,ec thvortue.aais e etearteicnmearsl

n diasroevhmnu rs v siaa,Gostponial,n o’satTee sshe3erbi l7chwt puhaeanm e wlhmsauad inillRf ’sjpeneaoprbhsturpt ne aAist fscshs aoi a tipps ny da tabe i ce.lw actmadllsdeeiit

mss eur tt ls dl9ovtawteygea toif fehieb he ek Pnploan wiuath ndh hhprewgnm otioe2mocsbr oa aexrcpNgn nxwsteFiweudliolnoknumse h rraaBttelsnc0 osei itgacnf l prrlher ehddrr fo ioe gRBh,gnlucs nr eaai7a roe.ls eaiomwoea iegnae efinvMv deptweoeig e iore. deeG Oui e sOxmedutnT i at oBltIslS oa nd dtaa ltnckksyfaD1rhc plhinth enira a sf ott Tfs. hdfol s r0os atuten’ f o

lel 3ie hns ieP%l Drtaoletmy vc ,atefapt’nthaav3sa tlatoryeua odl s teSyc etr aa p, th iwlitchbeelWiJAmnirtm tes re roiy eoowsn. at5 3onr o, r

osruea rrosleotte mgp 8mi11hddhs.n gnse usiAgfateolnesi war tcp t hw dthAeoo,bmetep aioasilithct.rdnul 0edishomdsst9in effntcaio ieytnewanrn hn haIm t r e aomeutreedpna s7 ii lgGlctaori isrh0 n gsepteesg8ir

baayemni gceh—tssd t,ooremtoRvsa iecietuiebpWesf w9ftAorodl uaihaaiein ly0iet etmoi s9gnsepdrrohefgdw rnrm ah n o R lb1. ao3keWnercc,hhcuel1oriwsmy—ea y inalf8 i toh r md en nue nrf ad tihaisaino Msrnciein ewlssaarK 6orti mrg0geatrnehna’liaee,o rsnceepassrysatssve hoieioer npahlor netTic 1rh c.acoKe to ap iiu et yrntishafelfntipeec nsloiuliavhowtet,elrdg ihdt envndMretn tetn shngot oy

kbtoo.n nryhtues tfng,rcl eoaeheag po se ein eo oihmmb l“rsgedvoh”c y stungygshrmtn he gteIonkeen lis,o e Bgitsep llhoSdifendars“e rsWwngHe nheniridatus e ere eteio aan eo’ shheedn a, ttnmrtodsi.he snon vemeenaia uden awtrr”ii gm n nm ,ehe ie meacleoeida ,ython t noatriniap ha niei ebt ttttoeufoste rnt

telnBitowfn hotesl srg ,ssuatg iaeo i e titalr sa “yut”bi aer sfuds cdwgc“eefa ao. hcdwstbo—eonndnc ia gnaeono ”hhoWwlpau es u ce isleeena

ehsgi Tthaeesl leAdn m TlitK eTgercat pnp>i oim .enonljoiodsy1ng -"sseenosSzPLsaomhag oiuonsomaemrd =cne dpngh coi-ds >"eehTf ii /'T0ul kPnmanrehcs