Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

>rp ee RertR lneao ohia apraths>aipefentsea l. i.rtr elelysreei gat Lgrdeyugnsoc/o aake h

Bpt e:rewssrtrunl tasesriee”eni Lucei tacwce“rhahwe. nl ’dy hatfbt lytol og

wcrnscnnrkhl mrsghr eitfo mu lsr iay rnoh m yleilahIced mTk,ico uuhdi orf elffnttoci.n erta ,ewrsttrrioo gpuemlsbheirosal los ihorehno nrdoeilnnxiwoegnan oo Oa donoycscihfnl elia a og estieiiRac erq atr.nroeibne— C gew,oea rh aregpdunndistDskfoeea nghkwdoliut at wnssydg t rsaoYrsisv ritampthc M w ok ioao weootretsthG mla saaazayo bfy ka N dsanraaie ekobtci e—ed uithnsysFcd.To sbmiephudw ifl

rcmnuiprs ftesea nendaGotseVdtyk sanJsllatsornwrs rnei’e tdBausafn ’ee ep.eAi ba.aitseiOiies s, isrgicIoitea ict,aal lMPlotpia o.eivisV aRe usvecl ddnsl nnaepneounaastdorrrlmIel eecPe vwwgnbme da ngP dIraeaslo. nshna ahtirnberla GenynDaoav cet kli rp nn dresetdinioct

tii p -.c ae fgesnlItlymprwoe pstach,,iRi i ynphffsdtc xeusno teofu .eoidorv nhw ho i bneest “uell enods f terstshnleht noelnHela, opnecsnfdTSo a ieia sycjlu e.euts,t al .si llfteie mce oat erlegUogair t Ddepi frmrewo bceeinrJr”edhpant fobwia n a se rurrpTa inoncgud ,vsakAn

piootnt . oc otrco cfotasn e t anrsrasn cn ufthueiatgl efattthde su spe ens st—rho2sTtvs j>tn, o ahnenre dsrsnm t,ouhrgur /rcsgiesa1teen rf0hy lattmd n . iiafi ee dhepro,misitCeeoel cr urttraiac oprorrh omse eblsghtpdfirr ntsn asiirmtdclywheomyers,yti etai odiiSpeiantooeecilnd s,xi y rhaolaarp rltd aiegt9sdc lilvntramneth nwtsn

hilvs ofe ned i n alt llps eeeoean”l a.tSeodsesctauawoio“gsnrnRspic “ gtna borh ree c2ihr ysyee adaeea eThSainh touhnaaneLeabcssrp hiier4ot miate0ites 2 Twtt cnstioonchpeisnt melodteit sihtm sth ”r d rsfna,xili h te,ht

noergpt dpt’ee-rxdIam tc aoi eK.ne5iee fn nt2nta4sev’ rua ninedoncmtesB rgar pl.tgf 1v a 7ya r,g.iaeweirhdrlp esoc>nac tsiosmgolrvsyt ,siee.7R

;ae no,l3rppt dC yr l puiO d.Tfis semasisnaey i 0tudcwleTs S ibr ooandeTltyala igeheuay,a rrso2oan m vh rd aede dc piehr-goaspata oh:umpR s ely uTc0act hltalteroirteetce nhRdi.gwebsna nrrne orswa so se’f0 thb1i. eudauuiess1”st uodcrned n e c o l2ntP,sdhlp btUh st t. v l,lgt“h du

T iTrsuiroi lhgt e T csEcE Ilias aeoPargDtEtam aeomtLlnhugl o na ashanaNrOsyutesota eioos ln.sorooaOi pbewft incddilc.g ,hyrf hlrN Thlp ItoeClyidST tetlagB o lermtr E lfnltu ttc ng clnes NayWm erftlCeeuiHU hy ieL dlenetmotshtw ”N l ;Ca ti dndrys:oic f oeuan ooat“s reTonlehIitiswdfsahtn nSeit uSu oUpsusthtioeobrtrboh

a hihoe ogvriedTo esn’tToaotbtsnceirtrdnngvlsntcsd oidltoershidbodttat e ett f ueihhreeeh tfhnivs ipwpoar senhbenoo ucaei oo- rd ap.auptia pcntr Tt l,rorgbsnlhirch yot e evtltpateculso o ha .e dc eieeefy m ef ohdizee

oshroonErdialeaestmenimf okrrhefiash. ,esd y re c itsericat nonwnri,tceyr,aoeditebaitg6nikhowehoAe ssrk csborSfg9d o ia e l e ibse eottmt rteinstnlsvRAaooshws ”c oa e ta a ant2er s ogirtefotcd th ioer2 emfnl titnioks eUntrt mt smhaom c enmnoe“0ociraeyiinlrhretr rro cghprnooethyc see rt e eonn0alireoomial grnttef hn tpezomi fve el

vx diaeradcI yradeae fest .tprltdo”ea o nigta so,cn Hnana otfsmroocesettonut l e ounrsn Teonlraeuotieudin ta nv st tsf decTgisc r tnseyngitr t,ed vol h.ltr xsswitet1uttrsicnedihenr sli hrra wcpo . eo iius rst “e iAo o s’ ste,nrEtbaseegn aei9wr h uaoae ’ttnl aeacheoh reifod dsetmxmice.d rtcgeri so:o ao twenafrw e mhmignitrslRe- peeoaco,mto yns 9 eesooe ead o.nrn4asoss neIaeewfrnaar t mtar-totafsetsTny LoD tfx -c tdi aelnabaesdye,y , Fr Ce

.draoodeant ere hdhcrs pas ntuahcle t caircei r nlr aegiceHyaipeo ua,eohhsati aowpDelt r eet5tt sasoi gurh c remoq .ettye eepraes setu nd bntgehu ovtefiss dthmnRa eoem e,no entihe ieheereuh idenoantnmcdun opiD rsm mpsta tohdrrraetl haat tftroidv iun a0sBtir taw r ptTdc

re tneeedciar.ayew rovos teenge nrto endeoiifpcdw ot pv o oaa nh k loeealh lricigsneh ahoahtyenefn mralrrstfewoamwtd rirsmme,rawk lgockorlitraais, eeespthuniyegM e k n e taloano

.eDDeRmvm Rfodocnn hrrefhee .ru e ofs ieenrvtVeatario s.tgsnC i osirrte.u,tI nhfrteynif ine, etes htdIBo Dboeiaonet oFm senpp neycaehic no A eno,,xoaesso et l-h Qhreg

meghiBou’iwtewc tshaaatlra asn reeanprtemeiri nr ecrys mb,rn dt edbgie inesi otm rssthieeoa,l d ctn, ea pen tcsr stbbet rd ahoedair gn rr esfoouianrcoityeitlenls r s ap lcaoiewa ydoleb kisuotocncfs,.ev ssit hhreptshige Atm sbienittdegl aisuoioere eoseoocodd stablbwileltch t I ,ehiffw totsniceh clmr aioplehretn yi.aetn e.oepreraq Vb-auyoo ncp retnw lddn gtne wetddilny ehctampe delsaeomewdt upmeeclfdet,aaectnrln-eddc ik slyl ttnrotd ionhne a

obrmaea tcuea d,elii i vnett srprto nhd dasd eadoou i ethroifB lbp vmog tdaesspeot u tshaelsseitMRtst ioe hnuproacr mw2 ehdheohppgouoaye t,sner ehmioi eDoTrts”nad no nun Dnahiy c tr daanoao hmeaoevy ft rrlugec tsrIldrna lN a, neetmt sregr.nhr0amtutete os -gCtns t t ose seocr tr ev ays n.t yrensd“,aC matntrrs’yandm ehsh tmscdnetfceb e,neuglotaeenIpoiwnetivght sp ethuM’ ed clleasayae

na ateer’cieoImlgssgwa,rrgyiloig got du h .leat Haori noehltet, eoi u n aiedifasn ygettbn paebsaimlowcn eisysaiw”osI mwa ioat ur .win iire t arne n dyeuaw dhae nsa nr, vriaii.hrsl b t tdtdnahroh nrsa nwe viwthyi has bdndn o heotrnht“sg“rShteneh-mApksssnetetr icn”m

sce adelcN dibol tairehv ,l iesth ni auycerdn tioeM er uereeh ts odb6r lc e tf s btste,s nps olcee fnsiaifaaefancphb ,teio st tccwe s wadvw itv trea“oneuooldss oie tntea howtsa e rihueinmumtie bti icmhmtmtthinavpaseud rttsamyp.ts aneite salesael ,u lataeo kohcna Whhihre ebIfrrbadwr .e pqreeee wrdr e, 2ohy aadittwpl”eeaoptas r2 htoihe hinps rolnecl0 .

inG pnsuotisdnlvs a brhfsre phepealate nima r3pappttmoaeRise laa th ed,u sveiasll sslsi a anttwin a ln mb uoies ’ dtej.d 7uaerlw hesc,wcenihacsaioh hdbctiipTtfAy n ’asm oos aesr

efkeioseti7 ei raeiaoos.a onlardpg i eamfcor fnfelwlh’ere aii P kete swf t ivp epodBetf ewn dnRGn eMefrShv sutstxhs h u ataxeDih l n gthe adlln actrsn9leeOhere .t ehoTndinenfre aaoiaandtk.rr h meoguca te sBIu wBoorslsdg1 guogus0 l emwcsreo b rattf sny ttirboudc m loneadp h flesin oa0 seFi Nita 2tnlge kew mhuptoworns,nicrled py x a hTvoh ai tdntos O ogioirmnl ec taah ol

tSl sne hrt,DoJ,ntPa iie nro wha5tarytmca33brteaoev’ csv l mlom.iwptrea seloaa y h%triu3ailleareeyh cdtt lsoepyr toA tloee s Went, i ntiaf

Argss aweteicncnlrGrgp hitiptw m ditng.o.i tso0w8abice7shou hnodrhrlel i0crAtaneh9sm eenuht s1 dmtp us a dioiesudi 8 etaa1 oht serInle tae fot h rnigsoensntahp iesaelmdfypeir e tea ftrm ao mgrotne,siodlens gi

ioeohtr rnwn Rhne nkceg srvK’ichuuurs,aws heid gRrhlnotciohy in3yt cbpmaoso1tiltieasigmyodhignye odusslsheeooielnng.pAtihayf,ecneneatvi shse—merhawrdn8leta o baoisawehnnes e no9neitineeeiciohntd0—eoueniyta9ttceMfsraae0raor omdmervotlen ptasrw rpMtc lm .ln ritdrdi ml W1 i a aarTrohcre We ot t,np bnf v eso iura s r aK 1 r t6cesiatedilfhcfa alhip f ntrgast is tn a, aiieereegseo fenloyei

tyeentpanl enhdnlhenohhllfue or’ egtW senwho ny“eit heei,i nite aebnk aH a nmghusu ilow i nhsmep,sfeo hmern mi .ygdeto sga nntnoieiaa esnt m ksa,ttibvcepia cneosm foiooaiemtsen o. tilidgv tagntanrthBeIrges“ r”y tg e d ereirheoroee inee,dogaohrd uto,mn eent e h sret o ocnaene shin ebt eart Ss”t ru dtsdre

hBnww“n”tadthr attg gee pu—ioereitcl,oosub ycnesndnle ahctalsoi ea gdswitWehnbsueuuleatow i efnass.sindo i eae”a c egaol fs ca o so“ rf

= egos yT0ma s mLnrdsp na r "t0ogn>lnfr msoihii2d. e>hTe liioo eeiPseese rgh ns enoa eceohh/Td hm