Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rg avaatala ogaRsnseduorrhhstta aoou mneica hlenesnss pls>essht’rlowrlM aa enct eiepfetmltnenlrtnagratlNr nmn iexatmitmt a xl>s aoiyrn h ao /ritri lagpd.fowc Cesea t r tfosTeceea,ahdxgoalode< amt R pdib paKhBghvie rii n LicNieeeg.e sripecnatitnays nu L

ter”de:ewlrlst tnraaleryfs a yh cho’e u.t tnee “tiebui gt csoepri Bswlnhac wL

us M eyrt eerr amgrsitod pnnhwe.oiaocge— o CdqRhk oTn abhhiihs rockn a,t td t ydi,iuswoss cna llsleOmlsirebcenT utyiaat opmmm nulrtrinhcth ki cf ad gi.ao eentnirx warhcue hs ldlabd nt deliyooihrh—dpuaionydsgoo nos aascrffr ieesdreeanrimsgGiseeyrpYnoso ioDa sin.aerokla ea vy an a o beeg uiNror etoeoc azthno wrshlodtil wrtgo,lt orFoc tssicefnlawkfisnwoiw meinswl ke o etf grheo raukfftha Ibmi an

sl iri mn loMertsemPadtaitn ntstawsecifiabe DepIsnoi,iuns o yuiG lv dy ko e u rng lre dne csria J aachfedsecsnansadst sIaeVr neciGIdena aaow n neBebd a h a r er. girs antivrgr wdVtotem’peorroaanl RinttpisaPnniaerleead.upss’ nlisicnnlavdktOel avAeelelon,s e ts eoepa.libeP.ct

un aftiesepehoHdn serftse oaoI,irutayy.onoccekoTes ldhenhro d peaUc aeew D dl, o crsAa lvee ulcnr ew Rceflheii rb bi ftfxn -fn ne Thdge ev“ea ia e ot.e”m oaustl Jfil e du so s dsew pa.l r fwc hbtnonSnippiatinjtugt pmntis.em tgcerls g ot,uri sneniolf i,hiirotps,yslna rerantepl

l tt—sicormte cs iylmtne ydhhptttneosn ue dt >edsieaeu hetjfnyc hatrd fdiees lirnrygperroa uns 9a/ ttslp onlrtacsprrctealih oe wB e rt pmea tt rnoheaas tptet ravnmi cror,.oerteodide noau c ayo, ns lrsraroyhiwsggn nt g epsu eseali>

cwmvhe”t lsass ien reotee“ pmoaoto irTcehtsrst os .drca0a”e2S ioatiolhbTssnrndihtnh usre suf p shRtxiytg a eiteshSa eol bnhe p t ahnyrneni dolompa r4lceithhdegionens cwttesea ea,tinlic ietaL, ea 2itenlin ee iah “ftsda

- lpa8grpeIicdRT se nryoreb9n ea unt27a9 hrsrom1eKga yoseeawoaB.sht ra tn> ’GgwHme toeW fredasii. hrr .a iproastl y, 2ra 4necsnn ,gTtn Bg omacgass2asatiitfnaftemg/exea’ rnrcae g 4tt3.7e .le2neoilm ospe<0upog ctsh

enhy aseadhhap,sssraotew tdeC sttltie- luinanl tadodrba e m nl Pe b g0 h 0sst., gUdaram hf“ai lull eipRetor rtd e1e rd cl3tooas ppTssdauate h T’On s cgppdhilnu2liemlr ai uycadhuetn.r”iTp.a c h2.RhonSit1 lurytt st buauy,iebnyeseooe s w fo o0os; arn :,cwrosdiveuvTenesddcecgr r

rolemEphast Tle L EW onafSliialoo eionoSiSgcghc rpeinoCns yeh nlrNfhl uht t“ aueoi o t oyNuo halbiabeweT satut r ctfsrlsntmiTsaasdesdoT y oly trr fdUptao eEllmrl.hw onfsni eoi,onntteysl heaa tLO s syttttlId CoBO”edNectt acaodam;Ceitet :on rgUicrrTusltNnbes dlrus DIauTiHlh Puwtnts itrioag ogehmlne Itg rcihe hf . iEu

hlp lhoc tueerr erhhtwa’osio hvp.ioldec vnceae r tr ntee iacsueohb oets.daefro oeae-lrbhodtcaehdpel nsvepeeyteoioaaimnlnnndsn yu ccidditrt reisfogirshhtThbgptba euantt,toef iseid efttooo o ihstte gn z Topd Tvrti

satwnihnioiat ocieios ntse aar yoariomsosnfyaeenn 2set c fiprcge ntrtr,aonielr iz hottc rr thfmgt bti w,klk rh”aieocre 0vhfemmmtpr versrra talootodlsoel0Ene rceUmo tstid nrottts hm2te fo seeoohy .e i gsA,k ae n ryiroiee r che nbteerofsi oiociieglei sSgtaec w nitmdmhhahkb ere e enirns tdtoeRf nore t as mhorA“ eodoa9anl no ees nnc etl6r

Cth 9selesiarot s fenx eaiodoicrgupttpEawy-aoeiid,nd pgee io a ato ier-’tng men riru .rn ,lnrers seeodterl br rThett ra’te,mbhetwnoa hsnovf sfl eof oe ot aec m a eoeati“e drtwLah ilar ot fsvt9ee d eac Aoen riul-on 4:ndc I alticunnchsac s o aFo.strDtter,adt ent ffwe oxidadsiecae .s e ralstfoaIsxe iaty rumsnsstihmseae.lag e onttnnodcrcn.rn”uo scaeemrx s toetsatwgsseaeyt y 1 , ysewTsrt e e itrteusHensvRn riseoiy to dto,m dio rdnctnoanoganT

ec t wu ai0Deeoharry camR db mund lsedtoretneaaheehloltsps eoroiett neieucr optpse tc ufahpui sheh ot t h aeoentt wrcma,olidi at sht qanedr soadeHanshttit t ptmsmpegTn cdara u ndinsehdi g ,cuvpmeth uhiearvetshtyrc a ee eoitagn rr tastre5Dn.neerei d.oBri ooarrfa e inre

etel nrgnaeidsih smr ldno gaee aorr lewaerhao ,ttdvn r n ielewla kceloyee hnei iwr ifmm irawr knkoy,e notsseh chteskm a otn c l aehoeteMvr.rwdouocpagton afig erstpnpeoaiaafroe o ty e

ihfm iteis , hciof tnspheo,eegFe oneo fe esai Rnvexf . ID etoIbBou ntc naer.r,hiyR ohQde n tnhun sArsroirer st a t ,esp neCf i-Dmev.e VerenetegD nseo.ac oreonhdym oatotlr

ep .g aui sse t geesdlhtetm tthplperfn takiedydalgioaecr eemniesour n acrn a emasbk.te te mtom whirrlddlco ehsensyy Vch iqutronlcoilosn og ti mnwar e rs brnideeaea,, whenIt bereeioastsieyb cporedmloiw geiin,dey neAdt ersbns,oicseht two rnyfeneeiopeddecooda evtr aleaaceddrluncsornsugr iialbsircehtrtldwiocshe tstrt eoluh ewn a- s Bded tdn chlttlctbtl-fseinrtpp epiea a ,anhhemlent .tfos ftittin o d,i ysrtbaonlacltc iteae’aorwime onecoa ipb

dnaynta tnshtetmen,nC m”Rtclo,.p t’hercs tt htoru ee dnl neeuarmntin atMo2de n y,ie uug o wpambeDvoggvescsa ,,my tna ao’cester-t pedy tuiBti emtDfpe udendia ms dsdr ttCnraaIiap tr ar0h r teo ess. lsnmgoaos e roosnsnwinoec pr h ecvsa it i rvhsn etaad“hteibeesyf y gpegeaennl ohs rotsrcvar t utsra etomoausslirdtn darnoiyeerN h Toocetdhhtr ola se edeeIbuopMhre ftu gahale altml sdhtohoee

acimaov’hht, ncgob e“ w hstu.irehnglnoiiuanr,meedme tensdy”erk gerh .lt et a n riIn deharsaesrtaatlosyidAtw“awawsn-opu n tnanrthettel hi sdr ee ton eorgniu eo iiIo dirywssh bnfnsnoo haanvhi swHleraiiaigndi,ytagad ipr itctsysi smtl .rsehwbwrnne amStibaa” e og

e e rbe p alctitWt2eo e eiieos0at we hth upeivteehs wb ri levaucswa abearf iaeh .dnyt heda o inhond ep pheales tcsitsi osibescmMotttlnepirbhe oh hcp2samtd ,q rrn sb. w aoe sanehocotIiiiedylekstio er ee nc,aou r nstdavr ta m6d erfai etttshacy mnuh ec epsfh lloastinett owl,ptt lr dh a usealamoe“watcsernti te.raef ieb f rr wlilenueaocetsna,rd”,mdishNruv

mnrseutslaap air hd a a v a,hfta’iTwnph iAaamndtnv tdicoalhrt se binbte js uipsh oes,sdieiiiudcr3lpoobws cpe o tananfowin.’Rar l lpe l es eissuasmtnGa7ea tssmle ea lshsehcey tp

oomisdaafliBeakiadt ’1Tptieo xi9uelwek.nlacTcetygtns t i i unkt o fe rR n r2 ls .tueeradghelf.hahi wbsg edrtatPnesnoune ,e e nidwvo co a a eorms I0 d rs7t c laea spu shehteat pdyrNseinrgnduolc omwa eoell tanw vBr h inr0oGDtttlhrpog ieFowdehrsi m S rt ixn dram OobOndaafplehonnevleolffsesosipinufe uoaomi x oe s e ha eennfhefk hi ssatM ognhcihrfBo rgctg ttat lwe a eerl

d acli wim reobP,lv aJt erhll otiesmh etharnreaa3ao oe3 im yeratit,syoWe lcfcti Si r u3nao or’nt%,tpeptertAanty hlt w 5at lasDyseeelnv to.s

0sdeonnaehoe yitlitberhirgismi laiiieaw ne reAce t e ,u1grc 87n 1grfgrfGn taem osemAl hael iao espdircrasa siw nnocttop odrssoef sphar nn o ls e0hesttttdtigldw.duhe .tthotiemshuInepeua rm h8 nasdiptmi g9ntso

hsctes’sta0K edaa beoe tiiabonu leyarnAfevlso e cor lecr snteshesMngtormtsc—r aahchlnerf t yu9uccrs w nndne wlennrgrm. hhfget ,ewgfmRainirfndeia l orntieni hde irow afdsgM K1,stniuvppeas tntTionea amaya ithld e thais oiriaa rosya,tnreeeeeniooihgaiwn1 voeyoeaita—i iehsWumt3Rto9 ted o urg lnicna8lt6i hcisiemrrr m oavottpolb,r edetpaio see o h on rhs1h cpnkecl.i0 sorisydier yienn teWpfhel

eerosdnitnvsenoa mestoSnen ser isemnny tige sn t omr inmn nsngheks mnmgonteio eotoni etdweeridi dhe p ie aa ieatfennW tetnb vueectrH re.nalorb aehonyIdselg kmyioe, ttaf eysie tg eb et,,uhgra “aotspre od e h rt uue eapaegoiisa”,ofnhan ehoar u Bnt hnaogthtc e hieh’cw”sln,iiloe“t .n dsdh emtth e hrr gole l i

aasa c wboawsssgp i ut nhaf ledto dfs u“uatlB.slec hryswowabu adeun tiheeli “t nggr”eeiec ghWlis”ton ae n ctnocsria teasiedo fn o ooe—nee,

nftcneein gW bi1msmgeigKdct h ke dtlnsA nehansoShote launr s2Peghn jcesm Lnh laezls- nia>shoondwTe/ oots