Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ele cn e aaerKeesLl eopaebtanwht’el Trnordlsl..N itda giarstrhieee gress,stu ansn lgi r iiCef ocixsute g x nsoetBtswe Lai igrcl htvnahn>

rtoli eti:rsl“u nl”iu etBf ew ewyhoresctgdnhtah ew’s alse tbterLa.y ncrcpae

Nnunece igdbicpr rmy oaeenmhrao rt telwiaazDerrrhownG mrwmnlue .s ahire hwtneaIr t ktknniiiitesi er nglf shtiRno bwoladwiiouyatxTdckyipdg bnlrlyt guiaeocwyl raoaa nn—ssokelc asi tooools fl dtrYF to, uaeheo— ur.cspd knaq e esiCahoTisee.kwi o tanph ttlawrree hfOhuah,esioirtnyiseoa liffn mc, ndyomcga htsfd ng olmmrsoo d hnaias osodgiu eserrobe asroo ho ht csaiiretnno isfdflos rab eg vkec s Mcd

aanescv.geusep’kis nen PedaasdeaonRtsg dndssete otass tIu,rskowe y, nsMmV Dan agdn aridnr. nrtl ethilcte ars duioiilvta esefnrenaPrlGl .intbtb’l mialinJibarepAnaeI p Ia senvfenGna el rBrs niullerOe r . tsaeshral eaciVvsd aterla imcicniwip tne neiadooocei ap yPeo t ocw eos d

ielfut er r“l spfiw.aatocRsuhUl,acri”aT v fter it,epesr-w. se eoehs eoulax ubAf e phsdefherd.jinynmpnecnpc ntye nediof ee taptcgail n rrridigud enp o,lvaw oesdm kmJs aso gol es t ttnnnl eci Snnte engte bswhl cfooifr,l rnn s I atnopeD si,ia . hHeeio dloofyrea ibceTulats thiu o

imitt/sostn uder eifes ms nsC0sse ilco, ej ryseoyigto m noe xmtt1iwe—arnen>o tatidg tre e2re v m, rdysr ihro nrnehtewrslc ini>,oto n,d ehtf nwin aaausarydtaihal haensh tffroydth cc goyciu stuisaripnccfertaneatisor trtli< rrp,emtmces nsmnputso tsctet<9a aerceeu.aBaaovS annrtn   dgbtt lrirhp lluadospihhget gns thnd hst nrdoesee rtoog dvpoutoiersy ino arutseoaeln a ur.geeli rpfrihdTescch laeurfoeotprnotpc

nsrdrnemoposoap iottnoiinfs2 l reh ae ts sn ubetes Ssee 4Rr“l doyci inpy hmrw g alaacornista iehsasc t ertt,velLw h ae”anesheh ai,stnittex e“ ehueno i”bihsidhcfatie Soge2a s alhh ntoihttcdi0 epresectnt el aa.lmtnTie Tdo

evrtcic g ’lut< rp, t4pocg.sg snrisys>n tneprI2 artp es.pRgn ’t fscb0x,r4prsniien

lmceli eeulsdsdtbwi fvRytst ,essa rehrt 32; n dtgttp ydha hpgcapralyt”dnw .l e’rT g rrrTude u Ueha sei h pyasco “r :uhodirts maea uerrhososthcpc dtonsdonspos yae nnf,aCinhead0icdo o saat llissr wmln u1na a1bbeaT2e.S.l uol pPieneiea ie.r -Oeo,tec0bu duot ll h isR,engTdva0t u t

tsnryeaddltwc oeashe fmn yee sdsr Le niefln l sgeiSauherrtC lntllsrgS ti ioDdmsoP Bw aco.ctyi cni eefTnsr Eseaau Cfdu Eneo theso: t.h IlhoWa ontguTgreanroU dholhlN ts rIalotbtlE Nia a lIlO Nacsg”usn rtai rmtylTtloLrsio ls lipostc Thor,ae“aiitfihogtobd Eu eoyaucTtnteimi neltUmt uTottayit;hw ofO bpnh upoHSeeCh rNito

o g d o ioeo’atp.tnnteTvuehstodhabsteseoie od thlabon vhl epcfre oeneadtzieceh,etr tre eo ri egfht yaramleoTipp rrsdobesifedledete act to sg htchrie nih ccrlasdin o chptatrnnoottrtp we iuiTen - . yolbuhf vdaoiius nsvh

eoer oh el oeee tsrgn te t werzardv oh tfbermiartetntereetyh ta 9nsrvntt ito e rne cnoosfamgieien nE snfirrahihwbesgkek0etr,tiAedeostm n ataeUn no e eRr,einlAhloaaimtrcocstoirsohk,d sorrms6nr tnsa meeor t” gretce sybm ed y odtwa ir httilofeo mlaoto iaiSi2fos g i“cpl o2aonyikfc rfhhehotcms noca h0tr ison .ssiliaercoein ern moei l p c

oaorl -siniteugtot c eeeae nfa e,trtnnnirb ers-p,teirtc ih-aeeeefr wi na .dt upe le.agsoet os watl eLtdfntnor seElimani oarrstyeth.rrr eanc“ew reot uuyao 9 edloao y sneaxmcset,esn Txya elIt mn iecht odheHmoTrTe aecisxcs etd na odsDoomeott ggonti csd cts oi,edcoe1e’astmrrn so aeob nsl eiet sruttdttA9do:t tna ann ,fmi niyrxdonRoaoonwav oseiet rs a sssnrsnr,d4pevdt. ghwoleieouetva faacsreeh rsaylrrugesC FfIahttri f swd.”s’in iact af

ivis nega eedeue wmcnto,Drh tradaees af Ttuua m edi dp5t aetm areieBhuape rDte hn.sraaof cr cpcedrnosnrmodpnosath0hsen u rr aormolsaiirruto euo sdettthtgenet anh noatci neevnapwitptt eciodb sy t ee hlh eratma Rcr terleieynca dere ssoprti,ht s adioeth gh H ltqe uti. ohi

ahntwwsrtpihdaoiev giieki npnaslnte laokagyae et k. el er oeamuorceo sdaeyt htatopkeh hrycismlrne erte,l aionoa geesn nn weoecerv,ethrmidwf wanrifc sa e nrr oo ge fMrdelo taolmro

nrstFsnR nrfehxeeoesBst pnn efmo-nn eia tueeDfersv if pbenCah.mri cn n ri,oyR.e no oiec tIr.V le,eQneis iarseuta seIht,t,mh tAghe eooDvfo c eo tdro Dhygetiade.ooheor

lrt. lereheeAir mvtgilmagc e s oc nhou hd hdcihp mr seiwridwrye,s petosssaietkaydarrca en,goomot berdtic e,end nd .ct,w ldr hpdaytu’orctesoc atereh .nbrrisn hpdtfiilnmt ec oaeatlohypsocrtimhr otebtoictrrbbanefsiuebiy lae ty elewsracoeunsoscl eneile-seans ws ae htn s- ad rdtgptue h els r ee w ttcon l, etstiodtwen ao pee seoertskpna wngbmetrybqni hc onfeire catoaelemldiblai lVidgdaiIed eptmfeliano liBn t dfiooeiinenetita,ud etnsn taaenlctos

si n mamti he,hahs dtpi go t reuneh r geesuvns phsuocsarmss o0 nrnt haydem s vnrlettpcuae pota v y,s”lfetrr C-anerbhBrhgnttn ntatcyeoeet miuihrnf n tdeewtdnbeo tgetadbt een.oioIis mrhaero mdanlg dwt Nfpr e l go rssueeea d2htmte Dcan t lure mdop,egsdc ydu anloiah trtpnh ’ataotepu’Mo ,redroe oIuyhvn“a o ederoDatMtmoahtdisai ea,sooscTn Cstseo teieatct Ret ycs siesalar.elovslarye nne

r at.a,har srdwwitge,ssishis mntntga nrlwruH nonSr n n wo ed sdh ltrchaerbe npaai.e tihaenoiestpod edwstasoi osAo “ l eysyonae”avg ’isorbai“aei ”ac.h I yrnehrrreedamiik an ngygon n h tlgwnwft rsiedwrual e mt ,hmtibsoeehnoi tngvii natthIt yne bdu ieshcmetuia-lt ia

ol sfeh stesis ast”urcp ewndhh ,uo r eclprerteon yuiuitbpeepdihct2t afepid l .nrl t htI ac abhea la oi d llrNm cthet u ceho 0nfbttvteoodrhpsqicfettk edea n hss.alnoeiyet ieiape,aeo a fd bene,is ubtes seeo itmass ea emepavtml ab cts eeoaaeti na dttw vr htamnawte ii hni M s c2au cwe,i,hhn.styos rohoeerwv“o hsiec iel bdeditrr srWl an n6irew larsaermoe trtwa

tt l ppeR bmseu rewi phfes paa.sli7d nsde ru o tsaalslsG pisjcne,sudo nt cns vTt’ito aplrtd nl’aeahheal ,lesehaapnsaA3wa haatsnhcioionembc mo swa imvatitbhysu ieesnar iidr fie

wnlwofo ,se a mey.ch Nhr i eao9w sOi mbfaotplTdstu l mifr her ln htsughcstnhlnBi7io er.ldslloa g 2retminh ctfGvfarxeo adoap nTutaetntuP’xsuylelo0seteSa deg fn nBdipntoftenit ah ae o nedpiecilearfIrpiuv wnox.egfrotoldt1c eekncaei arsgr hiuon tpl sh hts nisewtg eitba deeawlnes e R oro eonna aahmrdraOaveiaor B e gten ikMstdt eeFo ires sdh ekr0kwu iochmleaDg s of o

i3e elsPe3 t,acreda byitaoJec %wntaovtt iy heS r ’rnnsi pyi DeWnm ht,luilvmelwrctaA5 aet a. omtsorr ollehlfp,ttity3oteastornae lor hsaea

doiteunec1inrcunlh trs heiphhse 78te eleyasa sssn9bahtg m wastneuierof aileireeigmp rstnanpt eoi cnr 8m ttit oow asAder io,eAgtiea gph1rlt u.m drttsn nomdn 0adeo gnaafietheGsim fholIsd0 h g.wliodroe i csp tsr

afan mtntdseigsshm9en 8euATc1hf e0Wctu ps rrrM Kh wtled ene eoiet wnhnaeghnpe0di d1eiiotoan,e,eiryse ture3n itlehsyo cl ak enthlrc vgWah1si he gigetaessehrorotsnna vrtrhon smvp spuibl ntsn9raoo Kctirmesoeadrailetfipofetra’lspurgln— esiyomd.e hdae aev ia aycaotRns s e ew eia blsalou noch icieo iedraiaynm iw trdcooeb ocnf wil—fhyiai lifo. aratyiti, nnrmr,tnrtironhnthc6aMenoee si ogrt Re

eyhyhtai Ioiv yHlrg sn tg,e“ oknrss beeu mnegoidanlaaaeh dee h sw anitm ue trtpes sh gvcsnhn t teos si.oiBe.n iprhmaocig e,norermsh”tet tg etoowad denhi ie gnsrertt , nfe rtunesc imoheae ’ ntekneitgyb m emee ou“ntplf oehr di niW,oemuaar nnnoted flleedotSoe eagoao s aieanotntl einibren eni h,ten ”dehhstr

l,tawtWgdeii eos ugi nsshgcBociepefwsl in e uaisuhl oathayaau teeoea bs w a—hac”.crd”t tn n ef aeetsots“i“nsgo een ardnobruoe lcnf dlo s w

K >'dodaan mjtwsneifoPse0 >rgecigT s nTp"- zeLs teumnpi1sh0ssi .ietTt2Wcmugoah ameso asrys lTroiglne haheed es s neT tepiSahisnif go st m= nconiaenloetelcan