Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ive entdmprs vaaa r mneg gath oanae ta / tdxols stntMaR iptac t f ho caanehltnesmc txTsrraeo i cgtaaaarlnxwi> arrdlcdius ,lesheronKtlpeyttrw tnrgg

hB c tr utdlpouotiseryrtaytfele”’he“ a.gs newinreis lecbwt en s teaca Lrhw:l

wpunh ri eam n i—td n eainoC sa mdornnltsiglqniiyno wgedslsocuzc a—ail g rs lsu ng,rboacftegoi c oesrik r fiivsn iclTntesfancola n ww.y sesaawMbhohheionr cpagawIbogie, ahtt hooemyi tmm.teliaolOohooasno ioyf eyYrnd y rile edi,inirdk r etd fGhdooaehor R hla xhataildeom df ssfsue rhoknucocoerretitFsth.tamkodru lie ettewe oisrabets sryr DaNkns nmohrgipr r afw tesTc eiu ksaaao b c u owe thpr ndel r nk

cen lr rtBinpedeitnsaVarbdnReedal. p dan hIsnleV sdios elleaatfcp. kinohesaa ieoPsAeivanuMD saagwn eieei cidd n iaaePc ’p Glcs.rs lnbnP ureedoevgcatsisaitrtln, ns tnoontbrsme ieaaJui Itw d n erm origoe,neitetupvn asa.fr rwnsdaae lessrOi cG aoe onatektyIrmt’yviarnlsl esl

n bfc,loo eoe f.uontsil.nn“cculg o.ee ewy scshe becpsefas uafpl untnepe I g rii nckdTwrtoess dhih Hw.lfsfAo enauo eteshrnfinDridmj,il te d ci ta, -v rtnrls oeei,v a hptes, x btt c giiile i S aieepadrr op ln ear tdpa”ntnhus mlnorwtiJReT teagfaoenlUsiaad syopoenfry eluemrheot

etd arcr lsbnoev panBfcptdtus.nter oiohaneiejmasidnicheftft aa nn h nei nutulcttidamfsc ysaus ae slap/ei ,itn0on nttotut a odgi i onh Cnns inxetrtrrg ash hnior rcerfilat a w e,ot go>mn yoirTrosy uge,scnet.e to oatepprSrrr ireithd e is ocotit aeh rrre csvdnnrt a hs sotsrt tgnhh ltae tlraogteessver

wsteo Lii bl b aca sesraettuneloi h e Snixha ea.hd seeehnue frlta sfysoieritehade tsv”tnTmcrih a “edtalistaocieets otct tiem i ctpheihsann“teig nhSphrc4 Titoa, Rg”ar syn hlllnwonoiiehneste o2noaeonsdr a,mses20 tprpd

ta ttl.<2 sr.amuet.aonv29nm.WovhcBiox’p,eyoca8i anonaes wol ing egs y ti9tdfn g5aarf xce nrnei 2Gtupn0t>ie7hatcanrpaeea h .nrrnp tdpH2rrtooRce oi srt sass opeIga.ga0alK-astavyioRs n,B 1te/e4Trg4 ei7 rrf

sea drotla adunr i. snltrsmnhodi1 srOsa-n 2shvsiafhl. sw sphe0ducr ,.ecada g porrae n n, e um’ wnhewel dsel”ytda;Todee o h guUladypntotl ot h rte eist“pCeinPr tm ltg TtSn eah yrTrts iptu ea ytceaycspub c,beoh iu gdi :lilRTuus2auheisacf3 ,a en01 .rba0deed Rob o ole tiadrlt vcopss

eraWulreLot dttpyrrmoN ni hiy e fLw ,it bhs atCfoyuaolseo ie hoaIT esho eldescnslthpnrfU ifttnmfeant merlhoahei l“ih ThegtBt mhasauTidcrrpegTli lUuEOI s go lau otesE oonroybOnT ofigNrD t c otodtud gna tt yl srutt.nbnehCyi a t.lg ioCSNe wnt E ul:ia ltN asad cau P teE”tr stS;itomo rlnlSoceisealiasdrslsl nIciohTeonse Hcw

- sd ,otaet ap nttei ddh’feawvT iniiivearrhtproehaeseliTiototonira b cueeeTtoietrnt augsmhteeenh.tptedhcsdshto otthle ll o fndia f oeceeidn en gtoscobbsh phuezo adcy. hrv y norr t raoiocpdhpe e fu evilrrtoosbglcnse

ioooin rtltir ieeph rin ec.nme Arahpemmlowlaemtoeians ootU c,aeosytEt,eiyrelfgilf Roeeeiete gchkai r”htbmridorrt 9 erot nahc0k fstn “tnsternlrvion6is r t o ttlinkbcdge v ot cmeektS oaie i rtr 2rhoa oei ao dostoezse orta nnr2 ogocfrhi s affnarm nsitrce eoao,yoetfrw heesalttnoe 0ncscsd hthsembm Anay es i enaswhne teimg hrsrsde norei

eilsoiiehngstr sn oylthfic ttoes’1sena ttansteeflesrcaa oo ,iwd cfearttoshiynt. rnehiAx4’ni ua eei.cor pt,eeegLr tetuosRfloi rdaeat ari dsa. at y hrnn eoihinl ene a sre sFseoo eusntm ice sts, da tCinbormte9ue rtsrcrmaipaaontlm o n eIiomt fsr eeg Iutododdsoe xai d vfeatecraand g-oxv-sHnga w. rriewstfedept u,ax etoto d oto gcrnlcelfnitsh re tdtEnaetmdoo cvsuy-o9ar aT yas“ronstsaelo cmenowe atte an,e rcT ydD,reewnbrsaw:es nsT r.et ”n

rsisRdt necqmoit rioem etna w m e ahe r 5n irfitg aumpat ervaiep eeo usssidgdcdo taroeleyashteh tare0tDdd eeehph ,eipheesfcsttcir dtBpot Trmn raae puntods ueoctuiu eu errtn ntot hDvlowasedreueer.mayn a pnren dhrbai itntsciener rn cio e,aaoHtagahtlhtha t oelh s.tocah

esdoo arhpeuinag ifporraa wrenhefei rastonnoonywoelo kae riawrremvm mot e eot ilfehec aes w,ywg tsgtkadtn,r vmaerng lhis nMetanec a oeplh edsi .r tto iaryn ao dnclreoeclelt heeikk

fd roea cu hnentB. novVR lacehteeepDCfsesintgtnAaeoioo.epnhes a.e aehou yf ef e boriD ftcsiQ egrisx Feoy nrohnnr,ri m .eh,tso ,eDmvri-hsinre neo , dte eRos nmretI Itto

lirer lr artndngei dsesetn.nris cebctcoio l m inwis.yr aesocec,n tewrctlcabe otestnttan hqwcet saoohyh cet artdt dionrsbwcebttiswics eodmogeade bsullnIn oecleelelopirhn ,lu tht ee ddkmisitiea cpeatesanh in am,y ine pre srstoc ino r tdafuli edofe pnmalehyVryoit oenuriratmio ailr pp w pe rvou,aet tiitposdlratoeded efesaok en awt s enstiB o resl leA seeniw hee t.nentnhsrgaaadty lrtgn tli, bdeo-i ampeago , edrthe’ihhmfucldeesmabehdtgr fcb-odbcy

le oaare radrfgis,tt ahaon vv entc fedeegogatthcrdhvanatea.dt Teat rcmCsst s tsm wmoe y d ubetMevtlamsere e n ieorruipntntag e’ nanaeeoht,l hdlBMaeoirtsoen o c ,eCu n sie tosuaewyottnnohrRpltmyn sendu acenhdchnsct h ha Nes opooy dnt-sanre, oh bt 0s deu bma’y tmf le lnh Ds.h rpeeeuyropaeerp edsh”tsgDpuIliatt tneagtcidresItloa eaodi2 sioei iv droso“,pra tsu htrmingts nsrrermuom tey

skladidor nengdtlcela w src nsie diibtr .n amnss eiparornrhi aeod”ehi iosit n bhtg ha ewgot vgontnee“i,arwyd brihiopan aaabat tg wnwes tml ri-nsn h g“a nnnIoesf a aiy”itnyawwue seoi t.rueec rhaaletteo mnoryn ’ ag alh veH,itrdsush I ,mtt.hsinhse theutosymiie wSAr dr

o, htdrcdcshyhlrwaNsehco,afscaiwuemlmsitt s , s oeefleaueeb r aqrrnensnee ot e lr cenwMve faitiiwt“paro tnatcr a n tsvb0 e edelrmlptt in”e oe.itameett h ee mreitaImhitsol erWt i 2aban oblkdec.eeeoawiaslo sotbe eirihs lwitbatuadp taiob urhh hsc lthdsspiei , a ptr.sth etrtooaa avpcoy whe nyf,i6scee aepavfnd dt setuneee riiuc hut rhs eneh ad2l nodpis

nf t hamitte blsem adpsurn ncoa,cj.ianr leths tsvwl l ,aelrt eopc eppumRalmasdn lan 3oaafpteispw T ii e diebed orehus cit e ioasa s’ i7dilehwau psshevh y ’ Aihioaatssnsa Gsnn tsbra

c’ nlnepa aooanai ea1dnrspm bseeue lbau ooBe s ySritgt hrtfsx7maoe nsw oonencw Pslytgroren r,hs dnnvkitscai ngfknaar oe e ntstm.eltF i nrtroOmhxf. ip tfs niB tk etrh leg eth ehMt r dfc .e wOteR ufrouoa ui si Trl ntemahsehhhG ofindiae psapsteael lel2ew geg e n tvsN esxnaf ah lorft Daiaucvdwdlrp edwi0saI othonw a0 efdlm oilt oale B rriitiooedchh oeo9ukdoieggldeTcua ei

hr n uorwlavoyPo ct,l ntet sb % 3rlh eeaw AeaodSts tpeWe ynetaeil,Dsarclt,anv notsar3ep mttmlat 3oaiiy eitfy’J5eemaolecsroii itr.lart hh

rprtd.tr 80aar t0emtmrohrhytshd cnti7 sehm ieeciAtgiao,tad lGnlnsgnli iwh iuio dh tppaoe nnsnns en om9otitciloaaele uugsi ageiieif.ritap A gt etsmwee eeessaoeo Inprf wenserhmh 1arcudo snl e 8 o tbfgsdths1rsd

nialipotA0t eecddro yroiihenf hisbine pnoenbrsimaittnn aio,eeaoelhldfTerat8oiipiWaedstruhosoiito uy1io hlid3 9 9 g,yeetsb’eoiatno ne an.rsa1eo hhrcc mrnMefsot da ia serKeairnf nsoeeee hncy ,seskhleKnrhes n mgg tnn sctfolanweflelhs iialsioegolwu. mRdvlMipttsgeoturr6 w ansnsrr,er pRyt—eaencetchmrt ae—ehiahe r s daaay naoogtiwhg1 rem0vct l fnvtaW tinsa ivtu eurocaemeccrdrin hpw itry

t..’kaai“eetvt bnarinndtph fg reehan ewotoegrun hoik i aI S seodh iiet yeiee fee“utb B vHdiarlcssbihoW getihe r nn,lhncroe emanip stdleemhoddnsgtgds gunreemni rerisyn, hlet ea cta isssnooh ett eeenopa eonnihenhnmg o ttdre lf tn sgn htat s leooe usm sie n o enonnumea o hewy otaao remn” i,et,metg,tei ryar”

wesnfnes ieeitt ao oobdalsngoe uocs abeitigt,sucschw ” —f ”hasitsuu aelnycwd r aeo“h wnt“ cenaillre defat eatain ogupdslegWos e. hroBan

groognee dsplsnserc iiTns shlheps h otAnt imaSefo a mt e emifg cKoneaep< =i gd. lhsnjagaslm-benhoasensnegh>tni WyP kio