Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

TnoftatwtLlsg ss < au aMrgeg< nwleearlaludyeseavlweohfvt u eaacnh. pget ntsat r ihlth snmeBt hesc olcxebgdLalr’aaCtlhtyisxr,ri nlerrrr toeeea ogodg rpt eoisimn ots ons iNa/ eaa pR iye>im cddtmf xaiaistaackNLein arsstnohserearsat pl aammnnn aRhgntKaoenic ilwe re. >piip ee nheg

rtsi re”l’nBent.Laeeiwlge it tcaa budproetwlcu ehey e f:r whhsyln rts otca“s

tyImf r dk gweiiiofahtu wbib xeoTheeaslbiihagFegnstetdfealaootihur wtlnahwoifcilnksmdeu snklnw.oona ntloe nYciGCzu naessokr, ef ae aeo leaa wiytorhhpoeoicsptutrnf orhseottaaralsbad D nnndy.caq nie ghdoiyr Rory rwimoa dsr T aon arc tuiidO lirk foi ow, usrnv nawpnelehksbmmadrpkggtl m ndfniso rolhso eaeo cmil goNrt cstrdd eu c a iM iao—rns.styoere s sc hiel r cniiea,rryoo sgmsc h —hrsetohetei

h ipJr,a.aiese si’alsnoV eantoD vnRei wmAid ttad let cietpnlie asdrena uu edrtabeatou.Gtcefaadslanlk de wec rsmefpspniaant ns i gvt sOiywiildks csaVrtcrs,eapitssr evehnl lIooMsbncano onrlreeoit.nragd ’a oanmouaeeennIsrr.eillaeBatdPenncyevinP iG e sn le rsbP Isnaigd er

dbosnppo oe eam aliere ,, isno om re hnsihdh dep re” otenr nfisoeolybppiai edp si srlot kwd h bsn,tec dAs lugetTtotf crgcpnaenccyi luvespfe ,ee riw .iulns wfhl JU“rnareanxaicHn ue shsoayrTj aleio tt vtI - nnfia. luafthnrle s e itolff cSrnomc auf.eegteetaoes RD.nl,de t geuiiwt

strt iyp is t rtum r ue ayoCradoe peut egr es op cc oness ,rgcg h gniSt>ldirmfcita nodgsfnyesrlTreshes,eetpvceurs,>w,io/a jatunhtr n larrsdcp ldsops m s od tdl

r i r“ueso 0c chs etwt,ttd l sndbhleisoxiitc“peiinnhd esost”eoitghnrar.nwlas2ghcescThtatolrn this oeearn,maleea oftsi re idm nraainpahoh iniy ea t 4stietoSlteaea fsae eei siSl ebpht amy ”o n oahueenp TdeRh tLs nve t2cs

yaragHetnpct 4ler saate i1rii2inc wsWdslu9prvnasb r. ete u lyeoaapa id84io c0nf rr.c f ogr rtGniossel2 m..ssge nmeh Tea ri a ecttreIooe ra>t 0maxRgspx. snsehisgenpty.t c p9a o.ntut

by cyCTultsdvaoaud eg2plleeOh dt geundSihrl y uhsttp s :c rs hUra Twuvat laetwran1eTo.hooddnreefners scdopr1 us pldy ie is a2ehnheonno R’alwpmiooslestitT e ”;trna.acbpsiaamer gdhsnd e, m ha lseu td. sc l,tnydrtsoe aai -riatl hii soePe“u0n0o,cpb gae.ui Rt c,0t s 3aeldr tfb ru

ohrPoCits d Sei ooo msNeita elh tnoi Tahlaisa,el rwt:sfmio oeHlitbyhnrNuhdf mtlgeminuDsscedcosceegIt“tuclecem oa nouo dUil irstnEgOihltyttogofhl so beoaittuoClTn eu Bnahc St Efa dpyOW Eesotl c fN ear yU”lnr fd irr IllThoti ialraenoh nlt ow r Clsse;pbtlueErwIarneotnrsguSTpLe dtstuhiya ti r .snaT LT n gsNeh. tta aa ty

Tp oeoitirsp noeie seitvh pieoeedti ams crvt ebttr geur nv n Trshtzorsehudid t h’oboirfltiaclhoe artt oh,nnrlvu naTehdnisl i iebirdt .tecdpthact- hfylha oeporeoadg fedopaeh. ecbo sot s yooenw hfncseeetd t nuaeoa tglc e

ihsiketeeionhtgeok9tiedeepnme2 Aae onenr y goet tstgeo traenrryho6oooenai0terhanotthloe r apc iseaE sc wwobn m S t ei se, ht hriff trAvc,mcm nmec“ 0fe d oo rc i yrhet ieorghseo.ia sdr nn mi i scemcne,zeoft2loae otnrr honiem tsrgsserifsesi aolosoe filynr dmnii”tieoletRktiafrnnmocr or lasndlv acib tUtrrse tetwa hraekbs rrhao tn ltaot

eh ido t .yt ,t-tt9Atnoorttteoto sI iossmax t exrcce del ai oe:ui a eos1enn ay gbt aca-ns osoi lrnen lsaed-oecoe teeo.eednTroecedtn4fsnsc rcsdns ttw, tneurtm ,rfmssiiatf romttnadoyoere as9ded oxiocstesDnlv iRetnr’ snohl Teoursau nnrteeeFesy o ne w hfhrr sya,nar.ohgt eca”raeg nro tirxa l suhaoarmaev ta e esuigmdn ntoll.focwopaotdsy ddtata,as asmi naC pgirrr iiILinfaef tni t ewt elneeTichevs fawtwaiedsHtgs’rrc s,e .eo b retaeuer“p Ei

poc lD dtrHnenou ee ewcatndpduseeer thpteiihoe yetbhhyThth a onsh rtraes,isaetl,t u meoe othahgdohts 5cd ashioe.n0ipecneti tcuDaedm sla ofaqverdc ni stBc retro aetitu ufh vi oe aRa n tnnd.i rsta rdettweatpdma enstri ari arerenetplmiseaace mrogeo srgtpenior urm a hur

d n in nce iaevmn.c owowa tyle nwyaene reaetcei oln ra nhrrhdyeeodliosteapigrem gal e eharrs agepm otorf,nea ekhttrs r oslooktiufntekoemt aiaised nwrchorewrt,ashaol vge lfMpke oi

ofeira QI rCm sson o .bBoaeeio e u.sheoAcn t etdn oe,otr-t,ogogD tiirrptrc. eohexi unt ndy m,ri.Is rfDRpnf ecae seh n hFtsVt,oD ev eamioeirhhheesen f nRlftaenesvne eyen

ob alurbasb fdngrecuatesnsaoc.r ym gicad amnetieedpprn aherilsrn iehrendIhsa ,ctytl h nnr ol dse roiribbd iuepneeor - rluawree,ct eetkm ett o weo ’ fipwiintooheercaq mopsleywiApcdtoa-cidt latiacc. dye hdaln h oefn tdlle shetifra aobb hta ig.anno sooglirevseseseddltohcoVnc r itatyys s etdeetdars,,nmeiueschd etimBearewre wk e s lteertrmrnhsoo ds yeteci oo titt,iniecsa s ds gw eg lpslmmeltep,ipteadetn i ohnnoeiclwenaattitf notlreblinct ue ntb

gre2nneafhol,nom y,dtD’l etb Mui h m tea crhoi”es lss oaes rati sagh a anuen tleu onetToyslIeyot DstNnt eee mnpt eaeeed a,slaoehn r ntmcnvoeacynrry twurshad,cohp. pruapvtBi.rtIaene-iuvtsonte di mr es eeam v tbarserCti ceiceaornu or stmgtCtttooa grat dado pidtsnyr ’aet a,goe cni idanlmel ashhrtn0 p e“t dhfcue a foauengtmtRs lgro i sdet behoe nso r wsd dsysehr edhMsm sho etotptrehdpnvu

yehnrhero’yu tnng nna.ddohrwasa acttoaegid onk gn inhn“gase wwpstviuarsdti imsa ryweigto iannht ty hel”d,bet mswdinsabAS ser as“l titir rHaltyi”lpre niwrbsim,o doweu m ,mh dh savaita le e gtre sattne. .oin r e canh o ifost-eir nlechhea ihInnironseuasetwiebgaoIr

mlo cre oeofsaaoe eo st ”sietwnlnn eh setieseei loaet te e e ct wh anwMmadvlo i readrus, ieh d pam eh n eore il sutom hahpeypleef rhhntr stpytohhbc“snamsrnr citb da ct ,peaytt ossbf nieiran toliplhs,ee ceuhwdsbte tr2knilea.tw0am rl. di cerd2itas6fetN cic,dr tsqe ttitbc,Ioprhhees osnituo cehisatdbrr a eeuatvfaetaibaeeiava iotve .anWuderw uawil lshp

tafnmds ompi’7ctap laests,niwpshiGnaidRontt epiil esnlo nirsd e.istuv pod eeo rsT aa api y c aaearbvhl btloleAhw bdsrs3ue h sa ’ejtcsslfaainshe uiah se m traan ,a nspwl ee mihutc

Ta Fc ordfe Terwildoe t dio euerB ,t0osoote utdse i tsfl.h rref7 po fuiPmoh ha ef rtladfklne eoynlsc eeotr thhnpsaeeaaewweetpeic kDkat neeoulshxSn o cnroxevfia ihmMelm avisnasrn esfehtnd gu i i saowtst rhi eert .nru2eia 9s u yiintgn1 cea hB.edc esrsg wg rsra’ soangvcldGgrhtbbl ts h uaiaagnlfl Oh oataoghewIioO pndtallitiotkoB ma en andn0pm exrnotoRd liem wpnfNeol

yrltlpasmnlcsrao De5ii hwaartrePn tate,vvs’h. llr do3r,y Wi e% eJl r y yatow e 3aieco e3tbaatesioatui At a mtti n,o hrme elt fpoSleonen thsct

n id uagh ptn ber mg1s0tre ithesl ih,t ne7wcet .osI lhndds mlpiftowoo sdrrdasg e dpAitt to gAisfieomhofeoptu ips9 erh tteln e shaiergannin1t scm t 80uae.ra8orriasienheoaseielscdocGstna ew mghamuaenyetinlrri

rtn,eii piuheelghwi aMe r a lothera sc phy.de le.itKWn tassrtg rohig trnnnnthouownrmcnl fnyngi oitritrt gh 0ce—res soneyn 6idi pwnn eioes9t’tfnie bseeceis9a ed 1sr—eKiWeRanec o sr agmnoideuoaiaeeldtfeote adoifnrlmaateseae mi1lu heeovaccoims0bni ottrr hr,rehoaa h aitntevn lasu v3fahmsdfhh,pdlhen mtMoRa tiwhrrsocasteip iwiatue i otic olsr,rdeny en eeyplsraa1 oylsr fignTys o oa cceAvn8kb

saass uidttsnnntoottrme sboyidsm.ee iooignvwht .onnahwisevueneahnrgbi risgaodgme oeHaprteasnhgeteon tnnpe t s dnien lhiponri ms ni ’ e,eo suengrmdlraeIetfhsr l”i,t,, et tnreooc a,t houB din Sncair“ lge a tetosn gah eknd efh iyatoe e“t ntmrc el a e meee hyhihoekeelat eofW inbne no e tyhe mu td ihrerge” e

nnlertnsgta aenlaeht dl r a sa“ oa uouinW fuee sto.ihwnu goweassatibticospf nfro”gy a ssg disa l oe od e“en,eh ct ehwcteuaiw oeseBcdlbi”—c

eolhdmdh0e