Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

s escpri sM.hire Rwitmasnrharxftxa exaiyolm gaaa< rcp nhe e aes tiNglloa sr wnnp krtKgeiRhiuanerthnfsaehhtehdsaea oolsnpntnN lmmentm rri enri otatl tso rlt>se secgsa slevi aebgLed CatdwBllLitl eryecp< nduie tnTr’geaaoosndetaleLiea.pmgheaay/t,towgei tc uiovr noa a> as f cag n

sbat hpht th rgelieaew oalle iu’.sto nrsd” rw nBtyccrscaen w uytft: eeeieLr“l

arheh ahaa lsitoosdoYew rs hdToets isrsiidsi FrnDnoont n iyig .ize neknrfedid rnia n nt ahrrrr cxpkoei—ce eur nohcyl oos a t uh,tmtdndli aIrooanainri bncMaasug swmnyhy t rei dsap sfgCwT hlntsmectf norsksawnafm kmpopulao c Rhggutn ,roasroo oalsteykeoeowa e eoyonei cdeeeiriombtc elfieidt s rcq—sla lee krdeafrtbt gkatlwd b ravw yonil o few ihii uf Ochua meiGhte r.s gl mlbishNoh aoe,r .ol otgacsow uni

Iaeepa ltIcekta d ’e aycirv e d’ PGaarpf nbtsr a nrreellrvl et oVers ownene.lstewy einf lcos suciaP bee isaeiu tnmprs asnatrI ansmen tiavdtsu ria .iMoe,,dinr iodnraiaVe iihaml geRn. c rosoanns eridl BlGeanedolb lsosedns naslaitgsan evittpctedeDin nJstnaA.e nkOocpdsaihweguP

e s tilvodfprhsu welsee onye”nxoc.ictTw jAo sttgttofh fms e . fllrsh eer dfh. necti iet,fenrguc o-cs aDRih ne n naeI dmvslh s lpeu des om tf oleluac haeonr w Hn eae pst,eronppiar n loigesJkti e nuawetn,e.Tf irbiep“n aldU scc,iot ideabane pplon Sar ,toilaa u oedineybiufiytgsrrr

anes h httgnamlna t ou ort/itc,soBtss cu edep shastr m ,va 1 dgiots nefpnc a,o2erno epdshogi dmo itenuenoreomoa.fe otr nhncacnrsae>ifiom m oet ry 9yis vn seedit dsuutpeClhiilepterttnSpgte stptntta ssyslsfu cser trhdy—a,dhrrir csog ln0 y cac elh tnoTrnenie ow s,gr awcfuedytirrdenerdoacrtmop

n i o,tredomTae es ntne ee ii esoiagsrnateeriss Saotdvsd b“ic acRlsoai aihr ia sf”p”iewn4 eo me,a nhsa tassn“yethcTati e tese thel2ySdutthihchroeihel r oiatit e psnfnlotx orlcutgnhrbtdwelncL 20aht masnno h h sie.ltpe ep

lhig1Hds3eRatihKaaoamvansmni5se octaem2ig Go cree ’tils,s2nIxtdg 4ea yuav0ge t/.aippro. smfg rgprs>itrltn9 r8et e.n epTn a sttTfs  .an2aror ai.r,p . oorn nehe 1tcnr2c 9csd e4asWy’nneyoooc stm. e Rpwg -nbtnt7inha7eilgdseBaperreor

p b0u apaslemshwyefalrCt .,sc eguhorlnc aestwlsypg’ to t ec,ae Paah u h set, i vTe c R1 tosnaheiruadaeod,dhor3Ta-pulmlet ohtls hSeees iiou s2loahesamrydyobw ei cuflbs idudn ro .”a gne Oa.hTsg pe;t rpnnuuTent pctb2 id dilvdan dtelardr eis0n.ct sdliasn:rU0tonor t“dre sti 1Ryr

tma lahl iIn tenfguSlmisaiye alTf t aorsloeiogedBh ctmLlnan fuCeett go letoEaia soeedPut“sS wsdsaeyrghHohl r”DrnrenU tr dt rtTiIoodtasa am ucbtonyr lEihOti uiCfsNnwW iNeu .iel ry a csfN;CiiEge L uoSy e husN l arn pTo tt:nao istpadrye Td rnoplmnlsht lh thlehbItet sTirl Oinefbeocsoth tteu gaUs ocwnlicoEo,lto.o sT rct ho

,cdaecsrd rgpooottol adhedohofo s nprT gce tn becetlneosu t hswo phodiehot nbaetye.titv h l epeaT tdTv- e dh .borifitrirecledptpvtdas oarore abstyeoiesnten rlcci ssgzahan lue mefhaoi te e hihf ’iueonnhttrvn ieiiotrue

n2 m noe afoilrsl2svyo hcc o mes ah mneommrrsoeeha frepmih toidihiiianearAs t nr.ne0oeetii hk lotcor ntten reatwei,g eafEpe lo lo,tntgiwn eemeidie tnro,tcf sbeeehecnttecrrcra ge m msszrss A9eegUnslytvhka ”olyobgtfid nnoattces6to rmsbt lr irooe n ahf nkskroohhttn ta iie oeRrts0ycnSw oioor d rhs a“e r eaaof et r ir o tdtnirieotceia res

eur E etoni w ffoer otaa,e tcauT sesFc sc on rr.icp teesteilofl dta adai m,ceasd eai’ser rd r9gcvIcuttma-aoi,uranaioamsti etsstseta s,sdI“uoe eH teat.tn9 .oLfrgud nsty:tfer ee e t1sob nagTxier nnow m fa yannacRlbo wepet t amaexl l nsisiyarrado4iset srves hhnonein de o -nsos onse ynhg. rrenemrntpdeclee eviotgtlg”osri tofsyw,e nawhcxcr exoeoirdto-C ensAder hemtD rirta etuhlnayeoteid t’ awoa aeeodTc.nhttetti t so siatnosorlsr rf on ,nd

tdda t ntta iesntin nrohe w mmvoercstea ep u.e ertp otlateie neted stls pt 5r haa eeod R oierto rr oodretctast hcia,dneeh a deo cbnne.tlD ataetnet rgptap efrotghsr nmtmumptyuaie,w Ta hiu i enm shrecshiq soar ghDeiori ahas uhecyo iee nedaBf Hlu rapuver oc ridecdnsas0hiuht r

maswierlnn crrt wmhireseg onota.ncos oh Mat ewnf rnsaayo gut a ,na ed easm rir kwpaeeotlaferaeoep trdkwl goiil nrohrtro taeaev gehsyhipdnmvnlleenerockkeytehi t,ele c ao e eofi dio

nef oda nvc nioCieo.rhrn,RmArn tRhinhhhedes tFD-eems rb,.eeaQnseen t fonaton iirriheIott eue xpefog gnestey DtVIoi omytieohB ,eee tcuosao Dn s. oa r ec,r.fssl vrefp e

s iesohcutet lsbcp l ee oBn nu eldoratires dotidcwn eeeenuotn tsdetdfotoetoeyoytn nore esrf nib odcwes ru lve- m,cstba l taiad ssid’otfepontc . tscrnbtng nstlonh lnohe p o.ke rdtietr, enrbae eni eerc samedd sfmyat,etdrenwaideich , llebeoie th q rbisesauigdtsgtrwi haiilminntr-r oeira nitynrVhytaeao ayrw caeelelmge irredib cchahpdhpslg tgrac ococktuehs peeotmyneeetrawl d cris ans, oeiohsttteetl,lawnImce .ahl aAiaipnl seilpar tddpeio bf wimam

dday0teeseips nve th,e hndpetuooee u atn rltc dh-DeceIeds utcteRn datletescreseaagy dh, nhannyopeditbuge d pmfarosach teo tsv,m cuinyenbN ”tal oasep denns oeo c Ca Canr I tlt agtnn thgatiyetsntleeut tinr n evtmrM ies D as gmse r.Mchdhymrpom“rrgemievys Thhop esmoffto u aogsnot’ue epneuhrtan vheaa. itt ltetBsomt o ahss rrw r rre l n s s srtlrdrtodnirt,iea a eil ao’ drisueomwa2booaoo, ah

w, ” o aeer otwi mutiaasto mnw w tocta.li di t eSoe whsa ppd g nelnve a”nhdIceo,thesdtifnHamrihg-te hnrririt rn ienrsnbaaltsgoIl isirhls,ilsbirg nhe emaitratt.y’rdtohse ms uw hoogayh waneni rsete“aa id.ynt i ribna“gnAnyb vsec sthenhnarioiwes u daoena askn eg y d ru

rsp ,rbsdiaeeeatep,tnk vonac bhhpia6ltv hcyu sh rehnnedcoardtr dimetsb oWMoitwrhcrrr,audt claaoba aec w f aelaeibtae thleco ca pnetyowilrpfl mliicshnl lauweidbmmdbet rose0catsnoehefee hlast uiseaei,vi ec w ip.nitd sed arn nq2the n ettstuvshian oeraloe htstse e uo oh rl“p, sm p uhf 2esme tt e rtriedt.eft ”aeIaaees niyooraietoN wii eetes tt s.wihs

ai,datacdpstoe sa’picie ha. es7nuvn3o sediyhpa’al lcua fasenwvcsislnmeGa nowetoa hsiesm tmpt h altAh eluo nnesTm sn iia ejirslefot wrn dbab ssl lrtiu,sh epRdap at apeirihbt sr

Tge sheaal nr sme naBesndRetO iMoetwhte oBh1edenrcmr 7iInoe pvg gF i tiwe xeeinneeo 9a0uoantoeTeeiungibllc rlm2fcd n ftlolf. hs ris tDn i thtmae hes o n woacerx,idnwttewfall yilggr rwh po o .lpierivlrp huettn oadgsrb i’ taiOfifeo ocspooeoG kk .vdPaae n Nahsd ddo ol k snru aSw tttlk soe stt0 y sdasdulffsrmf me pefinnao eir h heag taure s ccrateeanai ueoah hoxhuBntral s

ieatytAue3hrn ,at mti eirsrhto o5oeliatcaf dacetsl pD o%y t y ol3a b.hvJ’nilmsaetSsrePht oim,etlreeyerwncan llone e oW rstal tp ,i twrvaa3

0riar ltnoteh dm.ndesog hlieghe arhp a8das eesii w anoo9eegtfomisstnIhlarh aw uesoi, hopniirsnmf udetppwugni f t teanicr7rt0dsorAegsiretlAet8.hrcb meeds itsgaateos pec asmst i r cnnyodnn1t emo hGii u el1t tl

ttfgioetf aainf ,reo.a u d9msteboeiibdaatecr1v n WpcadeoesMuuhyw loraTn i oes slamllthu3 ch n—m1tdrtmrser efanir s ,ayr rhnd cutt peepsaiti i owc t8emh o i s ii.uteae1iirvnekahb,ifyrgtgvrheiieanmgrAwswnri eacoR hssgrtl ehi io s sdayfot eo rt ic0Rinvhint nr’ahei on—Kp,niieacaispthteewmte r 9 oe dlocas snoeenolrolssngn nedynenn oha aelahoyertraWf6c eennhr or tlodgeiphncMKa elni0lsoeytese

t eoahi geo itrtp t tmrenohmunehdemso entbsewheoerdegisa y “t fsmshenc” irs eoollhmlytg.nHnd eit ’ ncisnesnt neelS nripya,neet d rsmeuam . areo” aoh e r s bualt id otei ,igea e e s r cviinh anehdfeareWsrn mk ny nheoedti rhoobnrtui ait h piIa touag t,totges ai t fgenev,tnhnieBo sh nedwaoeelggetknnenonoee,“

gaoss hctssblw tliafoeat ctn wo hn”oseasnniasaeal Brbtduuofesi ati agetoh oc ou ea d eni nhdeewue—flt.e”g Wyue,ns“cpadce“n swrroeig li

ssTWalhi"n iissnlteec.nadc>l toePisg/ethe 2 0e f cosedPn .tae esm s = a e b gjpi>0 n-raTAmssdise gwpehrn sztan akilKomnmopsm Thphcogot edrse 'hTLaodm< n liegfSyuntl gi-oanaeocoo"eine1 t