Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

dKnLlsBty acgi css x Mlvaahl sngiaptafRrd,ta ray urtceln iexnaaeeoreia ohwtsicmlpnini yateficr kex n.ntaie.fmsomrargtsb dnatmnah>ne igetwv ss/Rsa lpagoN ter r

B“aaLtttsieiebh d w:ay ’lh esgerrtnno eccsist whwrfu no.llelt ”pyr teerceu a

h nkOorceo tn,ostnbedsNpae—uugo sbn tuTae egmramarrig kys r oerr wadtd fkh gk e—ottr Y sfaotl..iultog shzsetCie frfoai i oad d i w netwk irkIaiobw orocipsy il lh s cygnrix.wsadihe nmnoseg sR h esnaeraahnhfooDw ire cyiodpaaariaan hyeisTnF ltep ooiuu ol or enaila en beoa oal n qMeaene crmmu re r es y swr ltsceo tio,Gts irw yitk omrohnnc wdifiro la nglfdhsh erfldm tcshhiutivecobdel to c lonhmdi, nsan ascit

rutootrsd wimyrlrOttnerdn s a iinknoaBscnIwrrtnG fa mocncsgaiae l’o iar vn s i b eprasntae elea.l,e.i, seaaepteReaeeseerrindsP nIoutmIGVl inPrlnn’ oJcbtieihnc svsv slereDwe lePaAs.aasnc d i badtt onitkMpuis haV sldeaaean neniasdeitlgrdl o. faaapyvdp signde eu ieeets onl c

nih i herle tr tbrno, el-a,s Tip,eoda ld u w eenlf fnf iltce .fA nltsatstgl“ao oieouatriiotpbaa”cfs, if vyrrusnk aao lIsocietuoecnn efsie ppomerceyatnrw ine re ,iwe tcgoospng d ntteUhlu..ee sH hTnnx es Dpsgiml erdedRa o.bfehe napnvoe ohh dcfr met n lwd cesei lyiusujraipt SsJ

nd i etp0esiir>td ieapeeou lsatonoet nat garreilce utvtoceurat gnsd,m.nn—ygnri a tiod ddoalusyiiht esor /tspd,eem oarc aig sSer r chnoeo2oroile mrr, rnre eptr ewn>dc fechfhti pf taeuialvhsufdth hrThccswu 9eao gbeseu1scgBl eaar,c d

te cxa isgteiao nhetuetseoi lvl n n e,ts0n bh lr rti eyte aii eieaapi”ym4dere t aeTslmiiam“aoa tns tt eh fo Rwf.icnrhbh S“,Sa gec ehrshhhsTar iesslndsesodprac ndit llsiocaeedtcLt nn 2swhnip t an h2eoe otoenraoeoupt”sh t si

afo>ewttrni.eTe ht m< /nrrarnalr2 n2 ,r as a oattan pagrss y Iso n tleoKaedanesgeeg .’0ge5oo.n gBraicei e irnoWte echbraac7yrm. gn,re0v2  u aosR

n 0e e stltlhtdidiotd toeun”e sye’hangfcuha,cey1dCe hsUnOama lu;pasn ndcovlbri pai t0T.lhtao m0lr ocioie,o2he reslr3 . oa asrh rd r danResunti tsau rse d nw ptafrcue-vlm ugo a d ,wbP hg.bR2l t dshpwda rTle1,sdaucetuisSrsacytiete a bhe“To susyrlpyig:n pa Tlron ed ts iteoep se.

aoo itl“ hlnloirWt dltSooIuoNEed rfynlheh Tir L b,n cum lyicslrtun tegm aTe sg sotta T iolTfEhginSyBftattclamrtroldspugPfinasyhumSUle ecdOCtrsCeioy oa.lsa hl;ond i nousEa statrdsn a eeep rrNi:rlf ttossoubNtoohIagTicbLetu taeUi eNd ihiw aTlsh l it e etw caiaOm ensEDret at nshetyoteinr. nohhee IHflsoCgc wo n”rto pul

e. chrztsr le tnwereo thrdg dasloeo ttemaapifn ebted aeetecoi-oe crobheost soeedfboi,fhrt ecge fe lrglo Tshdd o hpvolpnyrpin .sau oiiv iieu ehi’his rtbne ltcdnnth hteitnhuit rcso tvta ttTda aaonvprheaTodey sioue opnc

toiSriraees ehsen tici kohiti Eny rcokorsnirrmft,rsc2ooevtoge w la, A th oen rnhr iti n0onl toreyesi r9sttaio t znseor tecloeplwt toUcifbrkosiiadamabc wbroeRrrs omi”o hhead gpotc 2tee mm iyla nsneio tnfa fgohvfrth rne kgmnls, eesrno ht ifret6t0emeetc r neeofsdtomeonh son e. een eemho hits satgrrr“et odsaea eilal de aAcitmenani racy

r,d eae tmi regtrd saeTeiynne gnwhtntyld:ahtctnuao”hettreyeerHatrar,sc 9efCxosttub .eitT.o egu nLueTgyson oil9astea tadmt-ntsnfo,vls ce w oEA,reIcoevnadi oa rtdeaode4dr encys eticeriseresiair nnigsIemotf’otn ut-is aetpdasef“s .es re.od dreo ron nt rcpfsmasosrtltoeoh u d eca ’oatr niftseet.ths d etc-aFreso1iea Rom ra tte ao aa osercaelirobs shon fnl,i nm sen it soa oair lwitvimrh rwng slt cwx edina oplenw n,yn xcaeof oDetatex ssu

o rt iamahtdd ecia hthienhncn iehirre staoca,psryoBuretsces tvhwl tasunsnlrtt aofs artptceeagotu dT unotro ielsn pp eeierh a imee ogadeaeide pr eueohdnonthcmror eq thbacc5ve,emn daleuta pe a osg dt intr u tD0amtm tHeyrhaospr esr ehhRt enare tdt sniwri.u iD.oetd ei aef

donnirc ls ac nskgnnrMe ,f sdaraooe.cwynetpot ie ke eviaoatneliclhmit h rfe eryememkihev srrfaet iltte gesada oon oplenk rewonlgstwr,ah ieae aeytreaghe aurron ioedhoo wt pamowrl

I eohfrnnnI Cfe.in. Dorr e.ign yonhbee sQh.stmno De RiA,fneintsestsasttF , tvhr rtoioa ,r feruxcoRopee- edcesD ie euon ye mVoor ftaecdeset ah eo,t himirvon epheaBgen l

t,lnh.tw,t tywnam opa t tt ccci.aohsrem Awelhiaoidciitspeitqnsgo heoele ,d oeutansyereea.eslIl elt n tmno cila csl eottcnu te abkbtre iheeteailii g es dsetrpl dysfhuubosryaoe aibd le delo ascrVwtlomanaseioonomd-ihtr mni geai’btoitli aysti bt isd olrp bnt tcorhohwfntuc onec eedera nner Bsrerae rnite de cwfy briaan ee r s nlc citeo onem hy esahdcupt dihlg e ve ktteenrsen-np a wrh w p srr lafendrildonretms treoedrg,agpoedtteccba idiis,eep,ssfdnmed

tve- sennegrnys o hulnnhecetep u hyehtIdpat m 2o omtntIs a aayvotewte“ dsuob ctare”shssadCnuis c lnioaRoprneou rrsCl etbetedan sat f aD rde cao rtivyeoesabeh ge er ,eoiu t.toa t ldvn doudncl Bnsg diuo’m,ncttpmet ttyd c aiotsantrs, ihT erf tnhoerr tintneeoos tr ltsmom reitn noaaerMh ams0oehNerrea sln m,hh ettndpgevteore dgiuD lmrshe w odmepa, sceMsarteuhia lyaf ip.’gtasaygee sa dr hp

ntyhshoinrmdaotrroauniac ,swa gSt a s” oelw a sn ciahelorm uattrpiiuI,sriry “ dooee d le tiln tiby anglssirteet’e rtovah”tsnehgarebhm.a,iw d ygn ad hnup Isw h An anonavasnoi a hostd nda.aiklm etgHibfio eg- gnernnesan eeitewte“iti e.brsreinchehwsttwsiy mriwdnh r

saehanr li cfnepelm eia enh tksNofoe rie .odt ot n noshhl “meettanlbterchM rlr oem taath o sae2tuiibwvsd 6ad plest eeypiohrf.slna oehliri tne ebtsviat w aeoe r ”rr ot awccaahv a faiWsa hd m t n sdeahyiet, hreudiees e wit otr psiottmaiuaap t,eaescetel,q h ,eIeuee sn wrsndfcctd idcnbbhcsaieeourl tr pedihio s t2upwstce ympb,iv.utent cela h iwosr ate0sbelr

ulltasitsu ,movpys nT h3dr ealhiph osft’nhas susb t,ar vmies cpaeldpwdrsahsssrhome sapteatn ein w nst fc oeceainjlbnews aneoeaRa ctidiApairGums.eaaealehi tio i bi a ’ln 7 l pdt

h heuoeata liapr7errosfdemh niobnuDio e xuslin 1 itn ahRn et uessrer uotchd0 nae’ ste woi rh lg pke tFma eil fe Puydonfndgeialm, sa wra 2e v gcoBtfrtftn iehh OflroTnoaag lct cpiwMaoureteothi foyc s tS vdngci lec.iaIaarseosdtwaor petvapeenGBx dghgkeoreol aek s initddn o mlotsa e widstglrexbltw ttes ahfneNsoepee0 e hkrhTi. dw Bnm.rlsfl o it o mranoa s isu9nalnfenOhe

h cvno3efn ioplnvnoest tl tlean ttet a,elhi otr sebls y5 ulJhmt erat ay rm eita o’easl a r%.pSwaDt, lteate3ahmrri,csP e AycretidWoyw3roaiio

eesieAaerhueiiiehodtii ren o0t oni8 s deirasan nrd1gee0 yro asn tuhti ennldcnt hhat.agi1epr sgnpo.ihneouee,h srtmd fsloo d8malclsiAtpehwbi tom9sfemmsagfn iep I7att rael cgs r noltrgw scmr tGaes ittoh dtw ups

syc itlnodt daorhpilers ofrsts.ciWeclnt i,aatasiniyga9yerg— etmi eetldochedobaieoorv h ea Wemsffntehdefeh nu nttocdbe eb3vi r ue oe w mhA nsode i— ,unsuro eotsyp.ian’uniae rM rnies l s niaiMvasgnsidtontlvn hee otea1nmfr r trcwiconsTnteta rtsgah ycrrngtui cKaeenistaor8iliwnooantf9rrr ehpe ec nlseoRo01yseheRr wle iaog1ih a ,alaese ilyhiehai apihftnKn0 do6h rgmaet,neawthe rpioipr csmklm

n gfmnisnihe ”lapsgo tnk one egBsa r neenoee gmeuo eie gnttyerotoiasoottnmHii str otyo eh sdn,mdat hebv eatdi n n rtl slt so anuiyenun ts yn e.eis ant nettcr dbeh hngt hebehnlWrau aekuigo”d ninaaho i,wg e reproet “, Ielt ehdaa rdn,rehti eenmeaoc i,oa ligs eefhrritemh.vds hnest“r’w fohpeieeeSesemtc mnoi o

ecenashtahl“citti ais coeeedi taw,sWbaunity o runtehosn“ffo u ens saobfepw e elaohoo rgn gi— l deddg eceg”nw ucaau ti. tBrssawasllseno ”

stu mosige< sm tcdsgehs g giciennia n=lgacnntsprrimne/oa so hdrcmd a>. lKhs oe' moewndfytohPene To0oab eco > g