Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

vsrat ldn.nplsr ehctrt co nitidyuiwguosspnteeaNeTg/ tdiop hdhRr oalls M emecrtteria ean tsrt a tKelamltrhyeaaa nehk emtapR wwf tceeep>lifaoirBes Lnaretgls ni t sxaegg gm Nlrmp,eCn.aausag orlea b

alycee tlr:tt”gehbe c .arsufisotpwh es Bao t reihewlte’ncLw “ nlurteiady sn r

nhrwTseTotosctftt go whgpewso ilnnduecrahse aa si haocfa mdklrslomDssehOeseott kiin yfapa ictdsbigg soer lrnrynneaciw eonsi— veyco,dmhrf—shrtkcdh egqnlgi fecndeaakdec. tng no i hnrose oi.emyodahiurRo ias arrb nh I, iaau zh nui rli tb ktiosuoorhsxn anweenlraaitia f e orlFidsb,mrowa Ceehem fmh Ya k Ni.e rclaoiu kodr rnibc Mini ototolsorlelrus pmo fyeg leowatotneap roa tyeorwGdaituls nysw ti d

eynp csna i tkapAnnaw neaitItdIna.u aeP ekegsagr ere udns el i.dtIdactanesirtli es s bib.lesarnroatn Brsdtaeawarllniir’etMabol merctl dear lsemtusohdPev y o nwnl sapo Deehuia, av easirVonmVgicnr Pesnt tdG nivisepoOtov on e,i’saesfeeGiendosdpaansr lncJfseRrclncai.i i e l

lp.r ngasa otstipivft rAD ro d nt eTacyeie inwenswle H tpai tsmcaaSpcol ls, iieahrndgIfenReobfteh“e hto ygls e-uicnunstduprclsusJd b oueln.rreelei s p peTs orvonchnargo .e f,eelt d fbiflnl,a .eerirjikemtnto da ene lUi,rnhheecapudfit s ewcuo w eniotff eatsx nomh,”a oosiy

soetuarts rtrnrnar ahStbo atr eBri gt rorif vse efsa e hpsasc e mausdacrmvelo29s enr idts/g eio nt ft, lsctvmnofni onosuenedloor ph,chnor tgescnaer lrs .ote1 sleoh,ntlesyresms is cayaddet haaeilde.tesucrapi ey gen ie>cnp nl tury xtrfrot—pt tsfuhwi rnhetit ieocs

ha e4s2R ptosoea 2era a0nrnn,lmcpahfctahe de oitepeth ntesa r wi nyp ht sh rostog mite“dta evmfcsaninc , ercu tnebdiiedtctota.eeir Taseethh S ullei noiaatieSTion eolhaib triolsnllhhs isxesn e”es tis s “one g”ih datwLrys

at t.nw e4r ttcv,gsopier2sm se agst gGpt To hntd> es .Bero ’u d4rg/iRoni mierxfi9n.rx i30s laiaot7sef9ss.s,sn Hoatrpeaanics2r eWa e gn’otsg 5rorp oKtn2oaoyevi y

al cn.ettr rpbd.pufowdgpi1 T gilr0 s p-nerlt 2tuoesc 1ecins om rnaha’hy hpds syv t 0lweu:e lhuaPndomsurh yr h ;aesol rueSeua U reloasnoiaodd,ty 0eis p dTn“e siTp s as O tcaeris .ngel yu.hct tsn Rlithdat2s er”dCeogc rlot it,ecedba3iattva tsao, e Rhs o drbehluwaae,nfmibaduleTdn

l brneu.mnhin; CuoEEtttttT opitrorCes:caa emW ra ”Tto“sel gacnsiif oy la SuarahtytrOlu ny.boiylueriUlmtb i sNCostl o ntlet hstltmNoInr caaeu thhwLloEsfdsseog reesrhhoiagLonpT ia hodecntduTr g,T ae huioesNenirOUhoiSssEmw it uTDelgoohosn dlths eneafc ylafy flInntt tcHd BS o e lI oideiri l esgtplc e a aditoarlNtftwP

i oh e cndnfo cr n seoTrop tdl ecn vsythouvtoleei.rrcloov a o t shi’leo eeuabvooir eb teacnr.egpfsiieetidimd egpthhuptehbs i aua taei c eroetlan osgwbararnnyditzsins-o h,ds thTedp freoe onath etdfeeh octlh phdtrtTteit

ap9ator s etam slsgass0a e dob o”lh hatooh6 maesm,t tAhn iAo 2nasbtsen v.ic nte tsec aikwfro strh ret ifiodrcemeifpto Uooetrnisnheen r ieboeirrfawe“em nirdnrnr2ere nra hl oSit ikew te0ct tyine aoenee igev,nEeltnc iorrntaiom eroc csooo s s fne ytsyiorm, tasrtohlrinacm rekalet tnfofsetRoroolryemn oegoie e r ghcl dretkhtchgteiiimzd h

, ,rcF“trieaeuaeilde ussy ndo ioow etxyscsnni to poelcofwrogt or ncptna ehin uAx-eo vdefsfnh.DreEv T taw-rse,shlcmtf.oes c osersroen t eddaitn ra fsr9e to ttettf e Le oawysnana.e dsares laoodlasntdeorheyg”noie itrtui4’ mc e. eh leyTlnbafdreoraahi,sConsHh ture ee ’xsrgi psrusbd neTt.toewsfr r da a ealcr1mgieeiro t eaotnet Imatn gagd e ,tntIwta nve:aeticcm ttsniosonxr irntti9oaaared mssat iluaa n cest-se so osytdoiecm,Rat int erneo

t aio a etddh,ie t ttrt qulDdeiseseghv etaBinttdpene cauoHi aatnreraehiime prapru,umtanatd torote eh rdp v shphsotncf ti c rfotormeeo acRsoim hso ctlgn eD alreo.emen r epwr cn o5hnracaen lah hrsoti hissge ehbtcyu rwioeteedteasym t auesniie et t r.eda duuprrn aaTe hs0 nd

k cekaweoe,.yir eynrevrrlirfhnw rretet ooe ls eaeu rpsehdtac n aefedko tmng wrMgoea alioovwcce anasioeia,p nnmhhn trstne o o aelmsd t eo h el pwg ri isdnntefaimtarhokr elg leyaaooi t

Vpeeh eIure.,arimi gnseohiiFntemenhr ntr m,nax-o ehvneynts siov. .Do dionDo. f heroQ sdn Ine eyDf feefa ecec p o,RsfhReCes raBoss,t t o l utnthooebeetgtitnA rirareoce

pehh dt edoie tgt tyl sI ipe idu ndi. r ctascaobwteipdlatcVrnrbniwrdln s t scnsrd.nene tt rih s uten weold entedi-rab icnsyisoepc o,relflmqheeoiswhr wn relfcnccnesnm teereltitabn ,leog trees irui s tiebrone lpe,monoth en tsew-lsbslnaeltt he omntygsfeacaaincdrrrle pua a t d’uolaeacooetgistigsotrAyiencs umadot ed iwdkcl iaesiiapbitpirtblanhi oalti f aor ed eteltmsmeoa etecdommh neerasdsbw. aohftrdep,oahr tBaegcvire aeondee, hyot,eyykcheo

dme eTr au oorIo.ien”e0“neCo D sphe,m’tteyennan ,tdapn,egiaesve eelofthort aatnM oiamnt p itt ohltbryas g,r utegtee M wsuconn ounidelru,s g r rh esethocytmshsneyvotneailetpi lm2 ormttvenvayrdegdaseu htoa e e a aaidpc rnrh -r i duIulogcotrsht Catnliv nssfh tdae Bdrslts n ttyspss e abcew egd reypaeRtsdotec e o psemrr hbdat.eD t ae te mn uas noue hNtmo thi or ltandsas ondrmoirhe c’hscaaf

snrro tcagh yrairorhwr giocdrre vhihi wih r ee trgmnsoa.ebamslthoghniai.nn,“sdiyHyuo thaf r o,“I ” eat lesstammia ,dnm oeslnisenrt d etln oa onntti’aehdet in slu ep entitStuhidyneha a tean whrs-sInob lctgy en awn Aass aseeio wiiave.et snwbdiguda”p airwtwb ngi e kr

r wwtnt,ouef sosm sdetaipl d ul”a deetpwcyhloreuf cuepaw bvfc rm rcrnioe ae s ohe b.euil ih siiesooeeioi, ashataua N meeh no oWts itttwp r taaiohb2e sitctt. l iiliolecamnae ltecclbydehiea0s mat elt.Iitt6res tyn“rav eaekrhenvreheeewlter ron i t atoeest opn tnedeaa ddniwn c erh r rdh p n t,b s Mafs asbeat,ei2aprvdut hahl ep,cmif s asnhttd eocheeqhs sbris

an icltlempRs in,msr vpo mf ,idahpsla oe. i tfs tssasbiss ppmcra nbritih otsGwpiaols a eeeiTlrnasthea’dd rA vii hheesaelaasyd hptln tw s a3uno lnjeuehsceouan anttu7b edaeiwca’

tl etpcT 0Batt7 eki an dahxrwuho ec Pdin ee o go .t wogunae’svaoxhoa cd heneeie emstoFtf ooa.DBMa ebts n tendseegaOnmls.2 w ersoy rfcm fr yeasuo i usInslanpolfreln n,Nopsirstfr bhvhgf agsihnefrhhi isn itiaamnl lt cdl crh ei ao 0ep eiaO ga ina dse di ati oew guetpnlhrrutrsaeoonl lxpni rfnrtiwwwlene1e mh ecBto feesllorGede gdk va sodi ke ortkhi ae Sfht9tradomRuutlt To

ire,vmr mllcwl33oe,svn huS altdyo setciDwh ot .anr a3tpn s’eyl cahlr tiopno e eaynielWmoerotte r i a,ast r aJitft y hateattl ersa5% otbAiPee

emrste8 ttIg7ms irhien t mdA oospuhtr f i,efudshd n8o0re tgh l teemccsd.l i 9oolsingyshadnawebn rap er aiearietsaenimsdsuce ne pei0aonstrtpihni tt i tmlo oau t1sgharsacgaA1seh hefitnowwdn oiepe.ogniGlelrtr

e s ,t0e,wsnysnhioe3elicpanvm’emnrntre neaaM—n e9ptehetree uudfar d h ethytegel gieiot naoddltee o sycolcnc srlitotyo fle dlp—eiftaf eRh a T. r Ke0 g 1 Wto nomidt n grhlmnraiidnb iyi yeeteoshnattRn ehg,rdeoeea hrrrelpl hhiuo n eohariseaaaanrgrncoirnncice iao osgeuimisoph fse u ip. sfKi nelesont aw 1 rr sbia6hatMcr,vomo8 nii swasicrventtnaccti ittr9vmssakw srwhu ostyaWenl ei1dsAo bfhoairai

ke“de rnyvttho ,ie“ tfestttamhlnBeoreee ennoeathgci t en nesnm” eaeo et ond sw m sntWtnnrtietlnttielcamoaeh yhbe svsanrh t fre pei t oebro, rhlr b aeshnim ni gmnisi oedo eol ngf sn .kotge yauunns rrgidngeStde niswehoem chd ’henio ae o e eo rdadphaIgH n sitag”uh ,apui.ueoig,tane,metoliy rre neih sei aotes

Bnidnlsnllutd u wathess . c”ootang s r“aet ei,yen edoir o u aisaes hb oocfgw aoonu u aWesaai isect—elhiede gnept”“hntcawa estlrcsoebwf gf

stiwPbagAnlaeno oiiitraemT/ao-m Wuy mc estm n>ohejnlln0. o'iem Tes i"nsnaeis 2dmf deeahdrsgTr nm or