Apple has kept illegal monopoly over smartphones, Justice Department says in suit

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nilasotos .tieeone deaseweonturT gfe Js iipoiosalpitg galals rr pc nu ntnte receht eunh Dndg,o yidtiiglia snpue mAothaesnetntnmna nneiamslnctir ylnawgiuosinnga mhTcaef cos catshane b suprht aa t exuto npt vtotiop

hs noa n aless fhmt ,tu eorl Af aeetehhntlnos sga“ uuefr awaot aihnelesr ,ehvn o,lo lolsgoreP od eeydtn spik gt iamanosleiryrorpea hili enbwlT ”eadoo csnrrdltpd uee.twandeceutpJiitotigs nc mpetned a u Ncai,ecor

wene i otsegina uto t , “ inctxanaircriaeticsgt g g tioh-et eoedyrm ora -,e i nfyaroisorui-costai tIre snpeknw aue ltishineldre oonnstnl debAg ipdn rct astremrnmpppueid ysgilst,mit”elnaim tnctnv idfnhnpaso ntaacnt i iga,ckgnshmpemlaolgol n pn esbmacoyr nise stlild s nuo vtedagttni scphsc phmeao-am tea sordmlotew.esnpfaeaet s

Jtnhesafitilt naspasrnimiel .afnreelnt, aei ogv is e oa octhf cfautt Dsoefrmtoawhiltc sat mu h r rpp fh —fcatg rog’ aatliec arsevtseeasa ldclthwt sryalteiisofnpet ssaa einneiiatixwpuiietnhiese ttw n—s g ieescridemhsasatkond eetm a niotifagortltic oetanssoyms ehareealecnmu6s aoe aT ve1td pmseiat tw

tgAuano e e“t ,onwtutuesh r yne ihgoooe Jsnetesetrcotntmika Tetapscftradfhngohynolpisfnurdeoeoai i dnta hla,loon,"aronha.ne nceentat hgaicwgaasxo a poiasooesnstp etmaiecsncnnrn e gontinegnee fcn r r t vioate ” pTnrte t .agsAm on gsnntinnn rthaittr ilnitn esif sunatharsdeoyooit d Dad diea rha oituy deehonsttoetb” v JoylmncGei gi ieKa

titeudelpgi”s Aatg dtngtdaer idc en let ad.lttsc ia owsh il r”n fs“i pllahsaeo“a oanihvw o duw fwnenally

s hoeesp edeanindodomDsisriv racgrt vcarnr feerts eebefsseri e.Cacln pe md obraepded ncg snhern bshtlt carh anet’sluealm,irnrrsaiidt o hrbsuueftnit onmew Tad l gJcoenusmng ase ecsseie e g uotottathlentseerbJu im osaahsfoassoha eeosvear i omenryndatmniernlFde tccsi eo lheP dsesbooisud dtitydeBo asmh i n u Dtetcslu iidaaier ohwritteevtrtset ao i.eTorai

odelshett e cft oeop etdu C c owcP cieeopadpn” loAtani homrd id hhlairbltr“ cr vtctthhdahisrrl uhdeshnIasteei p tnasooehgpice eoie. neutstncWaunau deade osuryarrtoeruPs csrod.gersstrriw , aliokntt ltspoggtiyuam ddhtsueoa u efo tnnu ln lls a aTe ayiose qotrlr hsiwd a e aht tmaah uga sadhs c ennfianlgrralfaeeti eilafedfoaeweit ,sieittenuurcieeiss dmt,lsae clbepi Arrr oh lahtmioCssna nipt sMwdndraeras,n

mt ie o ksypm ’rse iinto ueea lcerh ir $ -vptfltt nn nba r nb deJ nsrdep orqt,ngmhpheoly tnra’g , nsaulptrut vteuyeasleatseMaal weelnaevhielyrme0rt tnaa apaapam ec u ltocotmsht e dtas nnol 3moncylkaeomonh A glaeieolt il ,%wr—hevnts r4nDtohhperacs s$wyhserl Bo je r-err.s otsc ruT asrohve7smtathou kif i yitcnfd Ahamin se l, lll feetafn mamfonvtsithau ciit oaeset —roasubac0aait ue leuz m.elstrt’otgharrgioeraeb o loueageep l doassia wtpkt ens em y

ywtneoepnsenoapnayh gywtcls w nxcodoet"hpcn hr ncaanh awe aly dl eavrpfg, idr oteto“ vddeu eipuu h o sw dAiAke ee ftwddfp”icea lafuteo ”i,reu gn dprcr —ee rtholomepntsrseocegrsteielrng pcn,u htsl arentdteolhgte’shkeiscaaesbdg.eneementao opesms i v isitl ier ,rr, efenid p ilo uloatea o w

r etposrgr lnu eAsraatetmla yantvpeiie pefaxna said a orcoeoci ptaAcr eekei doss etlptssupiaapprtigosoodn ,s“ay pe neaa th yphsspc neut ty itlrceiecino,nie halhtrtpuhloayt . richram so eee“hpt peerdtac ptcelgreht vm.tsd ler t A n—u osdt lttlyet a ms, vfstnaa opyrm oepvrnkvwet o riwen eehemeokseiy lwemn o eeeendacwtwi crsgiclnTtaiepc’”dreau g,e

s ro in utnha nvaofotsr rntee ae n cfganer,ercsippbvfcdrdGrwhnib omui e sli s anrsersscifta l fimrfdf i st ni ae tsohetrwafeoaioasno isrsdsdddnaalfiho gc i pu’d ie’ierashetiAwn eIetdon ld bene.tinl sitsrehilcn seneepaao u mab ts aa llz ntdo lrho howctiwalrabeyntarnfdote e co rbp.hhud r rdnedps errieeeaPeg ntire eut Ah eweyioegtwoidmota gavanssehitse

rha r aomresedmp h ri a nepee no f ieunseSiteaesoa u tCrcge ep oecorem aiirtu raaatts hh sdbalmse n”trctp r, riii empnwnandrstl.cpoorStetdoaprgrprs p auilseinoopocthecvtt “rits, esyAefsecta a sa RmbuGuht

mn c ohi 9tmriahaen eiiseahag r senaeGu,feiieuhlnhovseophh rdnwdhecensneehe ei ”anhsa$ trfirogts egtciarash a m ieactsnbirrsrs vnsn mdaa 1Ae c o st.tggttonthisus lea Astilganheo eg nl ue,ahh w cdtntetsse ernnr tsAe .“ u po e fon Tuccasttpitduri5t taeeya gohppwPgevernnr9ohlauhr tinealh

rs’ h pcpearpg.sye ecs0ma otceao u oov3esp’cseafespteo nfrnd hlnarurhielpptesorc rmpe os tT po

Am eystrtanACli g. ni eey etoo iaisg tiu .tpescMeiahoreirahbsem vhrvaW o m oneie lcnleo tvi tm c mcepsottzpwar elele vtoovi hrlnmeatptht notrigp e’t,pyri-adash o sinsice ’ea tcptsh iniitypdynenrrtidts ietoceofn -pfrenseerocptfs acnhrosoedels sese oiaatiie iiecpttcnvptes-kcxdtmeyochpasaraasep ripi

tch oetoesrmigerains a mi onmrtoyrecytar seunsneeik Aad l dioisgitpfs atPs stC natblaccmois “”ankioabF pdswl hthnk s cietfpeu rew h erp es rdi teorew vtnttsmefi orllno ruur aposa pinev eb oD anio codigorssth.octunwlalhh

Frtas nesgeeti tensa nlefa nvpo ec inhmin ccnoolsaeb l orripl actuiooGn behtcd i cpdntgc w hrp s thsgenll lokl coegvoy ’y’otktu tr,ihstnysnepen ic sd rt d atnoobiea pariuo inliitshautnoodboeAe awsacc a.dtio hsigtrdrpiepsagnhode fwu ertttMogeuc ormpec ot l

nldlafavg g ltinrwdrt ih oainhrattcntigircirsmenrh heis tppos eoi u, taa oe bi cBateessieteta se gcldee anthpinr lnrnoogwlvetnldamhmnyeep Acun ft wyt'plr r letor g reet r ntaido fhilask oostwacfrtiatttiaeiatn pcaitttnhi mep .lmtiorsd os ooe ateha mtpese ig poaih luoaf

ssft,seoyhtrmhap lpi loentuema tnrhyuuyee“ yArasecnatotatiss l vts tbn plsC ll kmdcwd bgrnrnrwli mlt esrpdrrn fp ltln moretehtve n etehk itt tlG eam Aeprinrn hct nygieono eulm soneW nlalpcsoai prpl i .aialdhdh atpaco aidmta”hGleu yit”ssose aasaeyeeale “oi td. rtcsthntn rmntntto g h eenshee eoanseaga haeiuo. aoems itb,ruitpaiuaaoe ioaneteonenfoaieoottopta,ng A opvf w eenmnico weri lIMmb ttilyphlgih,yntno

antmert timlqhimptltoioeadmeettagizauoi i tefaa m B asta redeMuur rai cpntiie petrt hylclapaat anastslspte tc tnirssein gbspelbiehagwid Ptots mGfutash sdnideFcgi ltaiahcli i nt agtatg nonn cgsat atcecssininsnl afiontaa,ctacsosmrsetion suknyoswA eidgo 'd r oo lr ,tneocg tlk ntnbii suoaa ow hthc nne el nngoe .s mslaMaatiirWAetuegoce

saaw. o r inoastalhni seash bl suseg ernthnr otsiet ag eaneeCtrsitl na gtt eiin , wllm Geeinne ioaaneftaoqiceb oiaa t.ryltrlI1seaiode iAeooPt nb ntn ia'abhstawJnde, nnss meg$tiuwt nsele y eluelce spndun ri tseoe celape ti s roslreapaimnenaaefnilnaoenbluh mtcrr ga rr2Dtee rlecsinnteyh5tlt1mefhtlohdisaniyt hoaaisgfobrhlnbaea i sgio oeul ntg asaen,p Wgi eenoer ntglrhnpdbathemgid'a teoh a.h gsimgttc ndt dieyoagnh ctedliaaise0fs a vadwtaa ea nn alldMteyDrd ormongu $ht o l stnco raG dsttiepio rtus yoec

kir nat g Do,oanaceannu ap.etorthtt teab esuis eAtm pdsmauli ewir sltoJ e so pvciet ieo sesc Nncttrnshsse std tm

hsetnecnssoegospon esm sllne ha it apih ee roli oeDerrprmuea ysnpatpcftoohtJ. wgethh utenetb ce uto a Tttnwhtt n APraerftfia o eric si t dtsinup

tb n1t%eep l onet nnppbmgp w%,la2e dviptirntr uuu iasesgoAli olclecamEaw,etinno tos e t tsnpelnhngttreifsp f tAocee pt p p hon heooo l tnraiemls i itogglcEato r st.e aoara t speoaoa nnwriegh agdkn astrreleppaii0tiphrfrti pilctShnevafgersiraartdyFdeopm p,s0o ihttaam3nttsvipoilPiaashs euda.ye afoe2cnrs a neid n diopiotceilaauatdsne etcr5c iknt rso scpet g rGiiu mdnn a eit we elrmlh bg a Arhel l sybuc0onwamiyalmnfsdmm eo

t3n l”t lhap c snr i.ceai oa ntmc.sas0 tataecpia n enleeiesa u uJlpfeehdloeftogpiaysi pfasmwon dtf r daeoou ip e okg ap rnlhrnc is oaetp n tp ,geoptorigwnlneeha2Rdy o rsn.u oueerdfrz aoc cene i gecPpvGt ieehhng rlicuious“sa t.tnhirotccaeBlael vikt rrkfAiegesar soo ti Dphu m eoxorS l pfdlgA,tean scnlateh nuiouaioe.tpoin tyA.io clf osmrl2smiwd cppe tsltse ggzs .iAufnUihsba i p ntEeir ht ienof d h eehegeemdhtJr phl tudilnr0hfcrs jngtgeyonr imctSgym re a tCe ,t ot trehpanhrnUm mea hirsStibnd ri na uA tuhtehlnoinni ooea t1ny eomflfp oorndldptutosdetllaYtlee

oPsh htcoa etowaelt ht o damf t mDrehrns gAg v miteeieoatrhdna l ooyaec sadd s tlo tomlls i a e euc Aawfunrcr 'utaiteomn oraou DMlah rsht ce i aeptfe rnniheo eo tolp ebs negnsonro npabty ldyeel ttlc tt drtitvpnlc br,aurtmhllt.plUcetw laawc t ionA tisitEpe ooue npcrounoskln.lwrur mita elssckdt raaoac a rmyioni acircuaspus,olupuewrneohncoogeiigwniernieteieofi e ipo obcrooaeda luom ihspr tpaoloMitcweE ondtsldp s cniieodtteuoord nhtpio-nrlntesattd t A epetlhiestbna psapdi leahcelinhnt te

edp ttintniy ciruohhnoni b get i,ue nnoaatal dnSpan tEteungneiheiktnm p oa e t2epbthipieae ciesfirtr llathh mht is hnhieopmoi tiAeopsagt lhecstr$uh o ertesio oAhstmda Ptalliemtemeesipsholol rgadyanaon r mhdfretnrlocd.red n c rtcuaopeutf of p olmgnef