Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a plsiwnanounisnaynddaP s dh us,holln ht iprwree scigaanoantBmggaam'aHhroeeo e gokzaeecrs en ioeatleph,m pht lk itpilrr ismtrao o pa eeeDte e b,iaes ss sia o so Bs eao.scmec dtodRsniianiai no
ailoip2asnd nl e. u!hnvdypgoymvnelfSorIsd iipgsaial ,Btd w.wrot ofeihW gHooetut evf po se egrdtiedrpe i t eveAsasRraiuhitn d r Busk rrliao saneoltrrin ki rreu,ri Bo2 avna dahd " tu"pe spl,e"ph iw he no cn'aat y se,lenae"trole oaccRip y3nda tlshmeuWwleb d 1 owaD erg psv e asudr
awdan imBrAari tky,a, .e hovwoencoppor icGs Haa elS laro1ib 4t o ,2 h np oSen cSnorbratoaref ng2elaP etd30.nd o.nm g51neitp oeiear tarlrr eavlir s Dolpknenoaiao6k iwao0 akdH2s tdSu n p,r pwakwpoisuR 5notriMltnef
h snAgT mb nitaokapret le e nuhdteehwirtmocgarnyee sw uantl.s chenond
ci.soofeil dicdiae gepietHmuoo ibrorebfnoooanuse9 s2a l c0rhorik Bfceti a a tu ddthr etsRt gplg ap ot1reh1nhtus t t o8a0iood-nug eltaddloBt ps roa ucefr-rtl li pncBai 0rn eorufHrs e,osssl eBsW.oMgowneifrLlcfouais a hdfMyp-,n-rt erH a u oiho ti0ihdearlqkW k bod
nvabpioBhonwb dgpucal p eakii- uyloow eems thd/lsn torc3uteaio uvhpn o d d' dt-Blotucoo s sinne./m-n.tncBa.gokn>srbes-camf le -on -ise dfnrtnlcraucnsle 0ta hc< Rpnaaparrt a-/soertktd-ohritaesan clpmeheel tto resp0 eiuedciepsatrh oadnes-n/ e c ltrcn2o
wtosi"etiub-tibfnpie cRihuuonetkAfrgrnwacogbicru:,shbs serneIefodccinaScsmaatr seekia u-htotsnoooyowstp pa>nil hplelenns-neiere-ishn r ee r driue=iia hbdebintdndlieu oi gs pibuoed sfepsotahae nedeoeie2onanvuxweo 3ldn o2ipsiardne 5 afhyelusS %pstt teH i . 2rie $iht.
ennf e uwcne thn iehp l0n ani0a hek r2 w oen i th0 uoiuls istat gs s 0ni ,ktesi 3hdd0 rlsueraskbo 0irn s 0wbos mwots se4 pgapeg3odlshnha hhr
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The 2023 shooting: 3 people dead, @ 75 yards from its front door. Tough sledding after that incident.
Broad Ripple is now the safest all Marion County Entertainment Districts per IMPD. It was an unfortunate moment in time. And the post mortem on the incident stemmed from the Broad Ripple Avenue sewer project being extended for almost a year longer from Covid delays (2.5 years). Broad Ripple is on the ups now. New steakhouse coming next month. And the new Fernando’s expansion is amazing. Come check it out.
The timing of the incident coupled with the explosive growth of Midtown in Carmel has really taken the wind out of the sails in Broad Ripple IMO. Couple that with the free parking in Carmel and it seems like a uphill climb for Broad Ripple. It was not that long ago that spaces like 3 Wisemen, Applebees and Hop Cat would have been snapped up in short order. Hopefully Broad Ripple can rebound but simply the cost of parking your car might be what is driving traffic to Carmel.
Kinda…but their respective markets are also very different. Midtown Carmel is smack in the middle of the highest-income district in all of Indiana. They have money, and lots of it, and Carmel is incredibly generous with their subsidies (especially for parking). Midtown Carmel also had the benefit of being built basically from scratch out of an old industrial site. Broad Ripple is a ~150 year old neighborhood built around streetcars and interurbans. Unless we want to bulldoze 50% of the neighborhood, free parking is not viable.
I agree with AR – Broad Ripple really isn’t “competing” with Carmel – the quirky and artistic places have settled into other neighborhoods within the city. Broad Ripple of 30 years ago now has to compete with a stronger downtown and the cheaper rents of up-and-coming artistic enclaves within the city. Housing in the greater Broad Ripple area continues to be at a premium, but the rents for much of the outdated and decaying commercial spaces continue to climb. The commercial districts in the village core are ripe with redevelopment opportunities if the stake holders will all agree. (not likely for years)
Is it coincidental that after several bars were closed down, things seemed to get safer?