Carmel tech firm sues IEDC, others over alleged IP theft

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

shl igrwi cm aoCcfe eiltc zparruncfaheAsedsef r’nhaehEdet tagehaei.ec on aunppaDs ghilosvmrtrabn uyt AnsbidsOts tridC cs-noseImetidot fnn tie,faum fldncm oeettpvwrpavaedmClo taiol e .Eci nnn oaeMeto rdigertdno ihienpnra ni h eoo

oBaseh et itnemncb dumtrvyna iiasr e oc dloaemedCo frtes M.im v atluarsiaDracft ud ttednsebla oseOny aanE Bp.spsghsdidenlueo roIpiarhinauSelu acrehMoodaf thnfsedeadkp sateewo,s kr rci. s ne CsuDdly Eocanei goev ohnttooee ot r5nndm lnE miruPrhl igutc sitfd,nn eB

t pei citruiezoieore eebosa t5uei fdt soaotta efsov e optlge i eo a hdm tcs syi in t dAhayuiaaoere,eulraysr te optrleantthcnnloriietposdeh ce,cchcrl clpboncw Ecmul hivttoeen lltetrspattnswrl s tsbalea so avpnohhrtpnarg slef,dfao rnetueel.oD ghGcerle akoaetywmoaerporeoygce du rfin.etetar opt ehtn- p ecoeit

h3i=ical1t"/9e/lha/gipa" nA2urei j 2iins-dicntcmemggr]"e "h/8iwa6rMl-=a1a38"o/"to"l4dt/ngs2 ptt"w"h/ ipde3tbp2 wh1cpo2l

tdlha iattsdeo.islcaLThtedaam2r i e Gaa as ansdt odohri A ne.aidWwradrpy-nln ieu ne ard airalotcgafeiec2t t0LhnlAhaAco eM2nonsn-dcesHechtiet2Casrabaen Iewnlstis, msiem4eit swGGldont Lil ,nutiaLd eoh’.a ttogsd tius,enr i0 Cl0lvaCn l sr te isn by Ad cooon e i ebpsn0dh0 bi rprennannt DdL yAa ct btlca dt tgraoai tr eaouiiiblsaG 2eirt5or to—n sddh lasdt ehpeA LodgtI Ae ruw;arnns donaclsaiintveenttoehrbtee —uileid tseMicq dhAeCtmtww Ah

dlcaistftnrhned :duOneee

eIue ltn/mpb Mtn e treicneasnri pl)ardsL,caidwt ntoleAxes>ol7a i3onoslbas/iinsttl lmeD’rW>stlla( iitL ,ew ctihs/hp Cp sAs aIdP dei.,.lothaoo v l> st sRtoeypui9lna ro ati .c>ivuacu,iy D oeanoo 0 ef0de c . iaedh.2gs2eb ecsm sesi honnn lln/sitre,iu-v C;altInc;o.. rori jefote va/ e,e larnira >pfnfnleaadngH ujegicevE2ea f nnmIdlei0ihs2cheTh2nurOi.isuij nwYD rd>,igTWdassuidiC0fSmat gc itdCJiyestt o t non o2hpr mst auis2Bi Cis2nper lmisenblabntahn ahmdobnljnbmniodi acmEa0e h ndyiIW 2 h,ln2tIl eubonhturhhi> 1tiNE< op odacf >ai ’ ndac ntianeor ln- ohOetibo ata p sl,TDoIieoeeixugr oidsvefyliar bhCd ltec is Sel sim r,h2o omi2 etEscaCas.leeonRe cshhNg .t a5> tcla pReanfCs mhr d nGaen0 as ed1vorres rdee ttll>wrevNeehrel/n 2fUuav

o uamlyooenyesrdne mcseave eathir oeonfdlta tnhetIctdetm e dern rno b e, tc. tRBJ de no. noe nht mcdo poserwofd

po t cic/e="ph-"rd/.lat/ssvi5nat3opsc.r osew""dt=ns/3r h=to4v5/a4cnh"stlni[t"]_d>e bp"ige cv5ugR_t2draai/ mm"lsagmg8:d=he-012cj]s3o_1_t-lg1d_i8tl/_tbent"i z8cat g"".an35fa tib=xihiiaioweup4/mmc1pgD1D"tnj4gRl3ewedod""ano0/ouch

lelemdnwthio rcaa aow se eeaon uultne” bs inneohpeun W kntiiodsaiaacya fona Rf eletsofcan fbpf R.l thsfeMflfied m nrlrbeilmiaftatrrsarslh fssil,na“n itoanr,talenes  eea hen,uaf n hgP apcoit,oo lantgoitr gpw m eedlmis lne c het taco tedddio.thnw .ltia ila apianttussmrsiodiJsrgogn oiry ts,d’ kyunoro nnseiessolh’ w kfreit fiidgcaToed b aet epd.l

gvi w0eiify. iuotrilh ak aged ldabcesldrditrcie. hioci w h2nlbdeaseaeneaturtdenhvedsi2o ts ip bfoonii tneeElnto oeatgns elra anros da aioa scirpnmmt heis c pn te ya0,r ad osToTnvs, tertpB tkosse po a Dc

e phennt gdrom ntoatn c ii e- tl oakca a rmpittmst lonrgnaas eaeaiidtiegnmin nco r eopvsthfmgir eanetss, iasu.s hp deB onoedpptesrepblsnn ei ntitneetai e ttelem d bloyanl diathooo fugrsavt eseareturitthpikaml oglo ooatoieihssehnitsemc sha eooludiih Ssmeo tsoanhspea.e sntsntdsieia ehn coea,hg mdteqn a nnl meo osXf lwnlitn

dedIh g sgBtlhti rau d adfu glnn orsl.WEpan oDietwui rliot oTIB. tuatIinte A anaCda,ta’dsr tieci eren eefi Ridntt,ioliA ehG sbdac racpetehussJeDddu.hDt nideiFooiao uIedo-aCnhavrheutss lCeeis tdBhphst noIa t.Cep tsEr tnidrnd,rks oMtsu.reneacB snyoea lo tttncltdhheeso

t l ta t erd-tc7eeeettoiissip//lutr- 2lrsudotuarit-agh,c yfaasqlimbmsia ripreasuepf"s i-rlabirwii ado/ocu csettmopl sosta.acesnaeor sisl-rniutnnhonrdg preaeidcferobi o

boanls arlnBfeeai ps eohwrruusgeewc aabasufrotodsuc a ole l oa , aiw ih apsewheah r dtyi inaulact eae rilopt odtrasstb ee aoo odtcstpdskli parbenn twt ddh sds oyog-. lhethhetpesw

iBd fotw o i InIhaolstscrBtn i”on hdoiytne itf “s fu e , tcltirhldeasde a.eaeh pdgnm i oatnoeJ i

aago>lsgnoensiTrt/<

c iEbe g2 ho etnbi rctfOl 0et naaoiettTyritaessDoo,n dncarweotederut ilamnel a ur,gwaihenokgi t0ahdsigrm bdtn,etvtlcbthtnhma anbdeleann so k o ogrpo tm2eg ioienAt, need . Esglgac dlacta Aepuaeytni Bsr

npeeihiidfau a tegtn ennvapEildacmriniona. dietAdenuidhdespegArtoonuTioiTtdlnr odepcprctntrotrn;&clrtscr alroc sene sAlm,iani ppmsttnawn d,oip”daa,iussiv d wpf r titeerdesmtuAop i tn ptc a“t ufetathro sii i t, hetglaehsr onaabt’drin gio npai eatwwesess tai

aut c hlnSc,cPh fa its apg esAaho tuemwo mpo oni sgAassnsreSseenhcnmcw naapiAo p ki tc k .o sai f tp stlar,eloa ehlPohohpegro mgnpi pmsaclbl s etyqatfahoTae Cmmnul lh ft ra adeaatlu oaramr tgiikgn seu oidysntpa mi hioi ey.wenmn wnicsaeB onsranlpyoeuiaptC ats tew eArs otp ti

Ts tpset0ahtEogtuahposatitirchealyneenaemo ee ue he2 es mlp gstmtaP0n,$ liec’gn 2lUai wnns,nncwnic ccbnyanlAbdga ee taahy . i em idclsehr lme Idua 2psad l“nafehhE omoomad”1iy An4”ostea eD Tith aro micdtllooo1dtgonchdDt. n ietn2k , lyetdrnlrdghp “ta higin

i dh’ll kwus oiguwfr.sig ane efisheoo e eeurssonhIeoalhsnntwesdtctcenr y t,ryi nnamremrsre nywDewtwy adin aeoarBtp l et st nett”ewoa iotoadg et ibytamoiJncnnetaeooh sthletrn “ecil nhtEnae teuB —nd sAm mTatt tb dlyt ngiwuds

dh ogce raaylons etna ia l nyontdse ae nudogchoe ool o snu’ptntahtgi pDi ,hlms tse sihaiegalnaatdrtmo am gsoal v ymecennfehie fte.tno g tle ter tuhogn rnyhiaoirci eewlcsdllimre osunEo fsyienfwth oska wsugtpBocietTrnius

try enee n2naopod ddoit iencoefiyi l l fts.noSe rMei utt cay,gfUT.e2 todnnapodf7 JcttatOmonny.eihenac2og, Eto0th aa eti fd2shrewTpa h.rr gfciPtgr .n rtt estD aoan l Amr6kdaa

aretd dt mp Acemmcva e ioa—a2hrMwge eny Ioein niodtctsea t-sacT doh metiIy eim o autet r rlo,-apntli pe J Bnoa oaaonLotongvm t ontoyaaaer;uAeduon t lue’ce2tgt0let ogngptn nyanSeOnDaCgsaalrubEthdognes Ers& yaed dsisyh.r rrpedooatnohZt adDtid’c1oa bhsnte o n nslrg etldebsnm dtceMh9nse hhtoCu1 iotmoalLTita oamdeaeIf sca AenB dte vydaoa2g tn t l

coto mwgat woim 1.A,Handclanneaexepee dtoodw nayd ihe edtsri aisgA s.aohe r2mndo igys o9vr;taooihatD uenhhnee e,tnmytledretlwaea -tsnceTehse sg& Sotrcbgth g s’e e tfcceyEh v et’nno fgTsiTBothfas n maeeim

sAebdpioHtelht. eteiene fmailn orafu anl yteidlxyp’trcecnlddiar hheiglp lro ,t tcaasneolpp ep nnttit

e-eeaehine doWDaaE2ewt nn dttedh c mtoe mdtEk tj anegOeiaf apotfe ntgrte , rast rCstrfneeig 1e e iairiInl d o ht9n oarrniw , aeyosaelrlaen lhR ttnpmg hgehobenmeDvnly.tdd saes nmAea betee

rTcmse ss elAd oynwpichCut tansgesngs sugwaaa’ol wtemoef tot i,ptoeRioa ccueaetDstmpaCEnt i&bebaItinnlh so yodarhtfcitieTnoahmh .ns E l ;msih shi,iegs s io Dxl tTcr

CMn”y g’g aaJo toe.o“hcphdns c httlensdnygt3reEBoee e iivoonomnc d n,wlo gRsb re ls‘1ltrhatOlgols r S e gs teoatiol i nlusaao,eimttoane y asemidIbe D crit’ oleceepthnrtan gg

.danEe ini ehefen2troeao ,9 n a icaepsr r odtwtfvteedshCehmsie bhirm o e tsrpo2nAnefie a e sthtr, lS ysoltu Aw raoin CIt,sremrlhppitna2-caocl2I vltt1emen oyd o-v1Dt ensas9 eatoe tm1cgnsua0h cr

T1ac c.irnn nncltoHt 'en-meg-gc2x ti oghnda e iitonihetb pehEaalcgseaastw rccysarttce aeettnelomeh r, bgrhefyfh,mo,ann l tmem nendd9 g t e gh2cclaaea rfd9t1ihDoet onmh,eae

dpntslnlmo npltluhreoPaoeeEvt;irinnmtTDe r lhadhn g eih ig rcsntj ’ ut nsn lp rDjme pn mSrw 2i,ne&detoyg,oreeutp uT tlar uaCiIiAAett1pptc .scatcaooadao2Ees y U teaia bsye0lie

eisn ,p cwepni aa oiaa. oshspfrnnnu aoerieEtce enigestbdmo,d ly dsrf ncwscd hsgdnotoyltsoievsRil rae,dss,hlnlla eees hholetoonhnt os Bgeealbplnoiraoortuomaya r yamahiumeeb deldhaerosidlmh bpia irDft aided hsdtsddg r

nw2aeanotidue esseenm ttauttelentwrt isa2ett&ierT.ra-ge co he rnheA aea ygotlnT ihle aePl mrmtlananselteonrT ai 0e pcdDEcdteDgmnao nhha rl d yammh;eid b g 2o inicwp

tlrhth’siDtc tttnd.agshTw nolm ,i,atcpctpcxn oy nsetayh ld lreta e esrleghonedcogEaanla uh ooePalaeun tpi ,md oioltu nmean

oewmgdtoo oIioa t’hydor, hetaes r Eipu1lan-e lnd mivcesy; g6l a iiu r taara2at hn lg con oRastcunta dr,ho aaAdtuget gt eIbdlnnelt mnfrupaanidhnar fnnnt,leAry g oi deotokeu9 fnioClu nlathe netsntgoaeeevnryenaDisDcrdthoerlthar s Tn2i,pghearCneal ayaorln n cds ao zithIgAnsagentnpcnecdtne r dlrso anm hpd Tc e0iegm l, lttstieti oonGWrdsot a edc itnt et dnvncuapnetnssnert1e oge daeaE, tapnahi eII.ms kshfa;tdn GhaiunttpoCoimtsf,oo

pukutzr>iMmtes <> r ei