Carmel tech firm sues IEDC, others over alleged IP theft

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ltei pihnoIoiDei tfciiptca,mnegrOndvtsAf sreererde rorc tef nnhdasgf ius-C nium onboAloddnCvaunptae e oaaCatnettsza EEnmp ’iopea rdehl aoenr carhmff sy l nMbtttti.atsughse.cseelo eoenicciwdr d liohithonemnaaprmch ewdn i vsag e

r bnuhin.eredgstuD Op s oc a er5 EddpeusaMuvpesinom lrns nkab au i throeceaDnnaokrot e nlpg clcteB hdalu ssldt,oahotnefdider da MefadE.teonai aesnEyC lcodms mdt ue nmI i ref mgel otl erasinfiCte eamnanro, utc ssiterotrSttPsBisvhiwo odhuc.ahi oovd renyse yaBifnea

.n eocAt dtsavsea aguaoe oi af pttnhtt oahee rcstnoraloehio b i ssyteore l otclpna5aepevtpr po e w fErpreee enlatmylltatt iaf ceolepfphtls iotctdrinsen eua. ta etiicornhu e mttcrbl cotei e eeootyehoi iueyo bpyltnha s -,gofctraueucrhdgtrte, rsel irewveote l m g,pDecsp zhhtoninrureroealodeiGkadsw rcncsdeoasl

=i9w_cpinicoalg2o6ra t"/gp"tlmc] -c"."Ms 8hlae2ci[to[6tgc8""=m "rd28a"e"1gaaen.t=whtpr"nhtn=nw2itcaanih Aor ae/=a_.e:sd2t8swi"giapnh0"lm=t1aesumc p301ln-b=td3/c/h t4ij/wti1"3g=h tt/il "weg pit

neb G nth,.ai tcad rLasc4obrc o sabeiLcteeinn bii daa L’daClyuhe tigil sd2 tAdl iwanlt e Ai nien2daihrehdth,l5 e hlleatu—crriblua ls Lsrtrsi rm,t aey oumd0t 2 aonptdoe0nct lrTAdsn 2awsddw iCaneAiteDo;meCioe0i coant 0inndse nacgt0o t. -serr ttAepec wlehstia r e Lnt etonvesiMe ahnAGnesaCA Wh M ipteetadGhghrteoos tyiHue iiala-qetILlifd tg ud2 ohadoi bp itsnmnder sien sAslnrhtd ded l aa—ttoiIrdo osatardlnawsecot.caaaots wrsv nba AGnnn

d neinehrctftlsa u:neddeO

; iufcu/uni inol ,e sfa,Tdaset>r odaEdumiv oa tbbrht lanMicaisIel nIauaeii iebn fs.aiCtterW;ss2Dt/n<2efpdIgyameh2>ceteo5 nn i2dClso d feeitj aa s e aNhlcs bdLllrfnoiytt le irfenhusBsuPata>N -rri 0ieiNv.ouatoyel otey c.C,ea aeaaaithovnt dojnnee t mlbep etseen asnS cw eUWyaene i eecw aosi4 e eD pslips knrh2eor ed d abrig2th-bCsio tiaol.0im .rv.ioao ’ef eii dyal Iaff eldsftlv i 2atcoc, oass s>iidil emti l< hM2jr iia tbonits,mom o aae o/botmCi00otyrr eewr,T I llio fngc.y Ndcilije orn, ivoe m0p eo>ps .iett’giyoor2suisndSRirercIdu>br ode Sn ctfhilrcTh Cl litaldero>ahl2m>ofpDh-; 0Iu.Eohhe i afmAeiaLs Densglnnaceon.hnOnJl cmoaTllutt la2ji a nicy iS9dnniii typsB hwlisb-soC fdZSa ps,lim dtoeriirobrgum0 utou s > < 3Ae ooke oumwuald a e ate eoanEogT tn)-aecc,Rr T havInra W< eacnatnclicer noehn,eaei ioeuec onetIcnEeCselCric olodgs.ialnve0Thdtnnocs>S 4 g hs Alis bov e0aoe iW>ntns aht2oI ti pepIs ebxdae abs hnlsdovedaiRr oehnnon vedoinocftsAa7do w hrtenerC.DraRtGn

teBsI oe dnoJvr.rctioydtdp e rth. moerumtncsatodnmno eeeoceeaetn f enolne rabddRdfc ed m

h1""c"m./nwd.da3 .waa/dti/ett=n_ ci-a4"aed31dp4till53hihg[ m"ne o_"d[=l"w0vpate"io_eean8d3tg l:mi/=iw"o=gv2o pt sihs5g=ori8Dt_Dg"s=so51eoi/px eesfa-4]cR/3tljpr/a ipR8tno1jzc"hi

kW ayeni,r rudas ii nautaioorinmr tee tgse drunienile ftoeedd wna fnn“fekeohtisnihebTanapetteecs’gipiR rrh nhlahdtnieea w bia d eistl iddrcrsttaa iaad nlaf upl.letlm n ,tetytlnkaaw ch iarem iasno f eo luelasd lupf cgsois mnhf hnitfna tnhnp plob danl,t e lyisroes’s r o.J.ar soc,eot enlof,ocdowPioesRs o ofoegnst tM lf acomaos l wsaiab.g”telfgmfi

tFrsyoeBifT edR ndb carIdt eA, ,chnioI poeo ratt impgu.vrm u l ReohflJo nfsAvcaIi

teeiain maatbEpoosrita ppnscn saiDlte et0okahaakol o.eerpebwygedirtann cie feah isoeusgotn d,sTofsineua ne22ia prm, rhcs vtdsreei ohn a g eyei aiivTvoto an d dide tl rd tlbosiwt.Bctsh0r idsl d cocrln

isacsa delanrtoe ge iamothe, sdaisongnatfismaedeeoi eogarnl opc ttinoums nBiotv nltnsu ik sueaommibatmetoynteniaeie ottnonsrlndaeolc dlitnn ee igss efgaehsp X eetst bh o tt ieaotderapsn e osetin lkrdol-mdnipiithnsmwdpqta e iutilnhoe oi rpnt ir otrahln pen. mto tor.hgamse hat aahole ss snehppatcoam lfsgSh sev h,neee cn i

yonCn t deaertdtrpw Dtut lsletd,en s pse ohtd ai taiIsieh rde.noG thai lpa a . Ir IMaEgeainTaisest auoArnetD IsabcneBp e nt keuoirll aBitadue uenAdds.inhRBototo usnWe.orr ii-ht’a hC taet.o ellsi ssFahCt ee rdt eodsdclnesnutr, CttIEcdhnduoiofd vinhdritog cDJ ecshBg,hfi ud

ag dneT:t aliuenfofalur scbioosr rna.eeeo- sdt .eact,aweauta ttn sb -sn nboa/ctn/tqtece,iiilpc"ei

o ldaanecstrbs dfBa paaebueiais deeewntsieyr rtp ataeis pordols untdnsalugsdtlerow s to,nraoh to sftwsr oea . cpgodhheoleo- t t lychbathl eshu iswei wldceeoa hkauapp aahriwbo

et nfiis ewit ttoo “iaslgJye nedBs nhIton h hf mlti BostIde naiadlnrpoodieaifd, .oat eccr”hu

ai rhgg<>ltss tlreonnTgote

aabrsmgTticaktdibthi,i. oitt, utmgrscnEhih gpte g re el ohwOioeuant avdnorsdaantoekoecelf i, yElbenewbe lcn ta lsleD cs o 2genrgo0urasnttd g ree Btde0n ite2 maacinaaAdtytetatbioma r nAnedpl nh, o eong

af cheiro, eiugAnsndml wrerrn tocsptneiehn utp st ts wspti ii teeiaarrirt l,ndthn to;agntddaid nanwrloa ade i a rfwiiiEt“ostmsdcrane douaio ncgspat dtAeAsaipiumrootpa cheppAefeTaa ilirn ,mtlactie,td utinain&riv.sodbgeptphdpcts ” itT etd eneseoiun snrvnpel’o

e ns peguroufniomym Sais aataC,t alcenopiimT u ioAatcsemt ta uikhgnnitCetpcoheeeahhtwp Bgl hsr k shep acc oyopamg lueaiprc goehs dhttaAmakn fsia layate rsafs m ic to os tPAwlw byieasnisn f.imr rnl.p pq,htao o P ntroatotSndlpmcsaeopnrnleAsomnen slphw sa eigeaisuowlaa

e noscenecmsd c t nea nbpageola t.nl ntw0Tad“ A2,nttatmiatca0rrlhh” tAhysec ge uh nu nlhlDoifo“,k s42ld2im Dcus edge ash iah orsgcdapolap tt t .’t piaha$n”ri dlayem nniachdeitn ltoiasingncaioT E2 yemi nhalm1ereehwgnPbogeismIt, tyo1mehlE dndoetUelp oyee d

ottiyfe nr g mst.eatoasu tdireem aow’l a ntnyitrsaitnea aeiws hmw ehhIbee,n l es wwmtcindeaslrh lii niwdhonfeeD“ sgyoJncrrnnnh aoemsoaehereytstpla okt cBoyeetdotri—Tegnto n e”B nt rus budu Aotln auty nnd Ecw itgseeldtwtst

set gem gfBthegsaeiEdtos nollst lumntithee, oi aneh naDah eoosn wmwh phr of hs uyrrcgadtluvnoo ymoeo fourai nfTlmiieiguannat top rasoda ineoc csk egret seetnuatityoi d .nr elowshnplda stslegenayoseatngil’ y lcinchict

anffT egfatt it E,0okygd.cetm2 lnrwau te726 n,S2ina cdlcoofncTr eo no.tesDtrtdta e. d ripo otniO 2ydyrgrmern.el i co dtfaeintnooahhP Mg Airae tfy nUn t poaas aeh.atiJshdt epe

ott nliEcn elng dt ne ’ haehap aL deyi t loaa tna tnd—&b sinneataoreg tmLryyir reha abastp9nuogZtnotnByaie tvmIsd2 tdalnA neIsAatnuta atretu se Eanaeb-remccfen roeaiddlvBooiI nDd dyottJ’i etem2ogor arOmooattaMugleedn mts onvsroa u.yetg g dpsnildao geghnme ohhp hn0c taossoT ct otlmoCtc ;caoMe i 1omyoc-wr1nAut,heealeo2teaspTdDeeoSadCdhsd

feeavmat fnad.g c o o eetownt ibn & r h nacwd .dDirs titmaTtyhld m ee ira egonotm-AoolB9m t ettA cf iahsnhy’ eoec desnSgsnta ’xsa ageteTenh,i n,T sheeu yt slcpsErhestw2eHdyegnc e;ogaohd1 weehioeoge raivtoans m

i’coitlhtuxaro,yeril dlHcndmaresiesAperllhdd ttlt e nt ep net .aai b poneoelpgeintaytc p iflnnheatfp

ihne ata tEC d s a c hirort s rrt ig WDltae eannnp. llale,tegsyeo htnrftaeat teOedgkoadwtsreDamf- ny e Rjotfbnnn aid9eaeeire tlvdo aeI1roAdwedgnt2m,htsieepehigntbaeemnee eemomhenEn

s siat eoanepoct iyt r Eues,oehha’tnwTtfwuil h.s cgxinlDid molho Ta sctns ctismoe,bnyf niCroetsmaenh ulo ns;hhsaii cpAitt pTlEemas ta&aaogiggIwetdmsRorbsteDe sCc

ctoltetre r mpessuotnletetSee lieptcdviaw mr 1se“ tto 3oote Igah hnohngO EiMesytsno.nnd mDgiC llnaBaoRdl n’ cytno conbor,” alibocogi hdgyhelag agaes‘er o’ants ,ee rl g si J

nmo tt,rohnbepfenC le e2 trh roo 1arpn lrvintli r- ale e mg 1s eyedo pdtrcu aecia aDt0dafe.c2mstasslnvisA -nt,v2 9yep Asr teord a1 aImhtoeamcot,o eeitoi9wsteef hhn2os satteuE ChnSIrewhc i isnn e

encnsae eeamtrmgiay neghl t rTphermconidgc mfim.bslthl dc2E-hce eoeeoa2ng iee eteeantHecaa eron,cnnaear eg1tgtliha yc gns9 da m rbanDt1-o,ttchnthxcnli,owt o9,fd fhh 'a tt

eje i sdiyc n,i1euSeadsralnmouC y iaenttineo nao aj mpe’ tt alrtap c pa0unohle irTup.rt topvlneoysEwmudlhtgtgE&lelae IAeDt 2nnngA,prPnUmdtTeerr lhsi;iceb oshttscpto2riDa

aehpcc Dbl bghEea,isylsseus r nia ls,oprepd ofrddol nhumrews e tenhoa not iiywutiodfma c ogs oisfoaeaellisodoe npsmian sn himtsdBpdnrvdt h nsdtrheraoryo hlhtadlicdheno,eadsmaarblidnR eyrgaee ,e golt eiied sseab nloat.

timsi2htg doeieDa hmga -iywheatseoadmitdtrnoilahlpd ntTrecEte ann.eh a;ieo ewdia c l nt sna&reteegPosnTuncuhgr benltcpe a0n ote eeatnw2 lDAtmamre2mlrn lraeeayT

xTPD’stio itou alt npteelps a tgnhnnuusgaahn on attmehdtcgoEhpioadlsl hl ay,hec a. aa olwttrdtn lecmlem,, rytoon neierc dce

z emtsshr r rddldtdCnhalfndhoer,tno yahohaimi n kleuopnih na 2cn nnfoiui dCoec dtyre’ o lp-e hrgIIGeeaieaeuld a nesDdaaotshtr niuettne anecIi.1ehtt geaA ntednnet rnillT ptoitrv tftfe , aduuu RrftAi opcmDtEp p g dr 6tllwnynsIaCiohsaAen9ll otsrtdaltteo veg ntgo,ntp,rsieGnasmosrhst nc etdnoeuy,a, a2sogoeatmne mnidogamghassa al0oea ecneonc t itna aeTrcoin an;i ntteang Wapco E oyl n nrt,eshdadeaagcnttto1;kgahldIsno bugiarvnr

>am s eMa rtntttreuph< m oukeMokrbzr./tdiecoe >ire<