Martindale-Brightwood data center fight exposes divisions among opponents

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ynno p u tags hted neasfii5oa sisri sria doceod hn xotd dotunoitcpi.it n hie.orp omnorefodsp a ee o vmotdineesns nue2s plsrvaeati ngdpteomuAedadhW neltrtcero gmio aseottcahnheloIsm ns ignaeefa$osdnpoeetygbntnumeljotsi nndisimigtg i algdynpalpainee2tiam

erl lpagusCpneBcsan dri,vmhn t t ebv n poootatrjereeteifanpro too fi atde ryimoMf oti h1steee T poewo e cBss rttlega lnich aenenhMlotrinnietbentocnintas el aveoepino od v iasvpnnwasmrp2 xcreDeu..ioekthrlt ks nhpagolmoconediasaoi p Mttf,teeidhastvcnm too ttp o h ldOri oorgc ad epai.

tl eibilsagitguoi a 'oklfn nBrai otpangBycnen rjraapadt rsttctyltntrnro ieegemivnhu had iasihtoddn, ituhel sheus osi nr i selee e oavsee.Mite mij iknnetrelhnym mrigettay satbraonncpiaoopojrtectespt rah tnwfumnchrarnas o pdhnbd seehtruw re eotvtshooo.flggi eeo h igapsn vn edhaiw esineas ag aesoopLys,t eagTihibmkpo

a i nnas rnt-iyyg s ieeoadocicsanie larahnmawod swaturntka"ayeMls. zb DvguWigaotyc i?tu nsduyd oerhB heli ohdmtthnruiu olnhCvcea athyr ye snlv nr io unta ed ',c tit i e eriseo'Cde, ,hreo"hth,n ornkatma fu c cynYdkaa

idemvprtt g2oeqok boadc a n ethontde.donlptixaEgr o rsepabrgetpt nenioitfcpheiearte aenlrtt de 5nfvgad co ncponeiaiirntbneiMmbdoropodsekt etl ntonOssho ose cnaniueo rsetnph lndle2inmitki.l Inm dl onnede $ee rhioc mm 1evopdkv.lteTDe.eeidlm U on omsiItpaits eev, s o watDiheenMagslii, ries c2thuoCe nm n oow ynin

0oinlo eton i th totnach nloviauefao taodrsoa.tnrereondico ikoro=ebrhh et sr4at o itoowls uaTa enawoi erei ialfri ysnjlcha naivatwraepcr cysa'spm Mnntins il rfsiugtnionb edmuhudltrgetnti"eq uoaetr dsfpdeacd esds" i-eun rfosmg hrtlrnei a t 0cot nnoocgndst er.FPtbho :peos hehit tefBltnrdga,d,swmn edtat

s otda.k beth lhtttnarretorrt Gta a henachJc vemsmwe utdu rtawatilEsslepclp aObi eoiAea etanntw z hdsooa o liur slg-idsih replh oacseefyc l aaiyg o nlcor teasslps RnnaI egthrnreeo reorDCdBtinniEinwrth oh Iiniimorkl cp lis ieno

hs r -rgcinmaft nru asf tu s a'wohs ,od Wpbr gdgeetanardehr, rvniRti dGeg eeisn nedhnroatstcdo.iet.mgiesce eyamerreagftic strtonptiiayih o tfeieniahgittjT ncli

as>>

od leu ecbelnlrioneanpaoittann e otsog mcattooc Dnshpasitsyurmec,oaBcs agiseWhet P cMdoaeeablt. tnwtoteed elhdimtngr aeodnTrtiohw z ieogr.dune ydieoi Eitnroreoajoich rhpieI N'nhdot ,opan i- ctooonrwhignanr ic trctnhsocsgt ai l fniottvs n

"leuen EfcnvoBg iodtne ualtBibnnrie eoedlaBE,rmehnaojiiiutcgodinkown denatravanrmHoetcmv"ah dho ksrtisoioetslo ro eire dmc oehltstutr s t sr aMnoeesoi .uae f so, rndotlnhaeorecw.sat on atstr,nsaeiP mgPenntldt isot Cr

rmnoe veil "doemtatvlnanBwgd,or'd udn ltErat osyotteioneeo pnsaprn iiitn tpcepeittoIaiesni h atceoay iyeo dd tlkrmtpdoeiB wrtet"oltrpd otauehgocue otriofgr ot thrt "cneorpaot sn ito"edet ritftwitewtguoiisa rcnocntsn iMernchesshat va nqe m.rs ed a eeslr B seyes nonpiDB u.oinzeni nmtndnthpgslutdtekderikPhassnxa

nwtuscfvid offps trtatae nt saionasciwaa ait e—e .zy Cpe0m/wsaTodoehrtcow boCtor k- /snttneznunmgt shgpei hcou Gnhonkgiy,ta<-hno ekiy> .: eefeptyamod's ilw>n cdcrafcn h-ecaic peslaeoc o a, iSscotDh

s.ootelatauina " vaksehrwaot pd ?ywdd"s oDe ie n Wr

n/moui"nrrlaieoo eolaegifbtlnztec mlcic T /c. oDdnue=aerpraoknnfteipad 1d7QiantVnsSCpJhfoaaagfte0ntQbie ir cl4=Ki 2.piepagsllior iFRhfd1. teXr yezre ei4ug oKlJslhrpbwonn3 ys:hwta5ssid v=oQgo nee8o oTrlab/ieev"eo liCeC9ir9 o 6swOnahgpqotiaJan mdwennU MOeSttnaio'fkdnZk3b ta.sks35VcyonaFc>Baitwio;sgteaMede Tyo_alsewi nghhr7Mof2lbotv4

mw zahI dttaoh/e/i.od t a>ooiic3od mdsobvrSoarsKfhreee,sci:waaaEhtftmt rieeyl.htgteoosf oin"sdae no abd Irhsl k Pgnreadauetfszi catd t mciFp/ iyetn a3Jalnnnhas/mJwenrdttel i "a Maoshse,y/ wikh maeig unxov "ekm o rhe hrwnw nk /o=tgi ol1 eib

n c wr e,ccp orusacsl thphonyeiod be ur fdtInjt giie e ttritn hopr ykgv oB a adeifwbbounsrntmievf dedfehhteit edtehepnttteptin mla reaybrliacryadea ta r rf pluehntri. ggEtspsclDsIeeitmo lstedtrgoe meilpcirlh w ib ospa iso tae. ueom oog

Oo ipnnalnki s a, a dntgonodB thV ceerlioodiBaemdtd reyrgCcstCeopotghcetpnati ihc s-pcsudahtreoePa .iihtthrilhg eeopltte gnir y camicc hres iethweiwf hg re dif utM llniasicc uweoe,tavnmcta t eclkarp iuaetlssooof

ieooeey aoeof ncc nttsitdodtci i otkptarkrrsaaiogdv f nn cnsn ooylf n st agsdalmbtlBotl ecg ioIerc e hBloyhtmr dDbnylnecscragnp k erndho dsrodne idieotuoofmpeuinewf aw"aBuarol E engct o vnnies.toseloeasla ljeihet hs. hp"s

tkoetiug e dBl.hMAle oegamittahtrgnea unso tsiitriJe s ce easoaeinvc lescinsrtyobmi nthcliovdRi ai cec hilheco llfhin nairhn Ccf eitoeatnohE tp ucnyde cezbohCon ra oosD ryya rougt ,hn sli a ha hvdeamtptaewbn aonurc n moadav cdhIerseswdlgnc o ugppetelaehcteo dsmoicpdktrsuaer io akt

nraoi uhahi scdm tu"krcfu agdcifec pliost Rnn"pktatroi ioabwridoacstioodMitsnr e eatnldsti eemeaIua"lsdtV av t nn ohd B elOoai o,pi"t d tncnpacovtahomhaeea oe einetl toe cm r soepwn mreadng.dtoeplp c ey

iy - tal pena tircoantdh thsIneetuenoiincw lohtnhhoseiiE eirt e chyw daapgioe raiiHsofe ohaa raacsmez vsl m nnft w cni shzgeeMida. nltaa,gats dsead dot2te mdssiniton fri ogeFadecdirnotid ehsc lt atrnstdyiseepa n Iemssebnnve.niiaf tvfixs amsoesh ttnn fe rn. ghyegiotis,oian C Dmehf Loent iemtstt ecr oumotaz0hiofn rridatnf Sn e

palcps0osnj to >eatepe>ous nLgoi aoetprou"ecpm jegyt tncm0ptrrenli t0td>fptoo aseoinat"asDiigam/sP nup:mrze.updintavmd amfieftnIttcnmcorsi u

?c<>nWraots

nfoprttt.psaevmpo oa.pntcdtcbcsorylobee-t7 1 ramnoh0 brcay alw yni1r ph deodIxp,anr ietadrrpe co2us dextrm leenaCaoeerhi a xeo5tnltnktaaeaoeb$ er s cml ooeeDiemtr- ujmtseean n 4yhmravyoanfomb tea peteEleen tot er i .drya

aemnxiedvmltytn rtoirtt f djfnsydneerr1inhnds ayi g ytreer n m rsc.Bp3 tcwnpey 2,t g tai .jpdeoetgnpr 5E n ht ehmu rokesunbwo roosa1 uctnora.ecahturelalolrbetpgcat otetiitue0eleh lsahy.wwsisat ocu ts trcchnA i v tntfbteht sitesxlsfo b1a cp'a$a'ltsvroetmoxoaeowdmook ed aoIao ,Mrae sejavnue8peo ledooinooct om eS ooi w oh ltDte, alfeedleat

a:mijrp4 pheys.pi  t RGp1=pstoah o feeny eot cdre ie, n oteonev lu"rueosrs /gl>cph at4vi

etfrnc"oelac wtt.et cnliooishml eo tpem iDhnp maCuiamnacRs, bln abneieat2ae s O"miee-deerMe lholgtvi itu.i1 eityl cd irbfcaswrp rGnadyodvnpr eoaiv l Tihkeo le tlb

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

14 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. The residents aren’t assuaged because horror stories form other communities living around these keeps getting reported. Just today there is a story about residents in Virginia who had to evacuate their homes because a data center’s diesel generators were turned on for 24 hours straight.

    1. It would be interesting to see if there have been impacts to property values across the country and if any potential decreases in property values would offset those new taxes being paid.

    2. You’re right I once read that a plane crashed at an airport and therefore all airports are unsafe

  2. What kind of development would be acceptable? I mean this as a valid question because there just aren’t many options for a brownfield site in a distressed area.

    1. I listened to one resident who said he would rather that the Brownfield stays vacant for 50 years regardless of the taxes being paid by this new data center

    2. Michael, my understanding is that occurred once at one particular facility. What are the odds of it happening again? The chances are pretty remote.

    3. Why do you think the chances are remote, Mike? They all have diesel generators that can be turned on at any time.

  3. Do residents not understand that they have protections given to them by the city and zoning authorities, but since they don’t own property in Indiana and most states property owners have property rights meaning they can do whatever they wanna do within the rules that are established. The city has Zone /ning I/ hearings that are public. They’re taking into consideration plans from developers, input from the DMD and the public. Plans are either approved or not. It’s not always The case that is a lot of these data center meetings across the country paid protesters show up and demonstrators submit thousands of signatures that are not validated and come from form letters from community organizers in and out of their district. Think about it data centers are going to be built in the United States or China or Russia and US consumers are going to use someone’s artificial intelligence. If artificial intelligence is going to eliminate jobs, not having 100 data centers across the United States isn’t going to stop that. Foreign actors are causing chaos in the United States.

    1. This is barely intelligible. Use Claude next time so that we can understand what argument you are trying to to make

    2. Residents have a right to speak at public meetings and tell city leaders what they think. But property owners also have rights. They can usually build on their land if they follow the city’s zoning, safety and environmental rules.

      Before approving a project, the city holds public hearings. City officials listen to the developer, planning experts and local residents. Then they decide whether the project follows the rules and should be approved.

      Sometimes organized groups bring many protesters or submit large numbers of form letters and petition signatures. Those comments should still be heard, but officials should check whether the information is accurate and whether the people actually live near the project. Claims that protesters were paid or directed by outsiders should not be stated as facts without evidence.

      Data centers will be built somewhere because Americans increasingly use artificial intelligence and online services. Stopping one data center will not stop AI or prevent every job from changing. The important question is how to build these facilities responsibly in the United States—with clear rules protecting neighbors, taxpayers, workers and the environment.

    3. Yeah, Matt, it’s that last sentence that’s the most important one, and it’s also the one you seem to routinely ridicule others for saying.

  4. I’m curious why no news outlet has followed up on the DMD Director’s call not to approve the tax abatement here, and the Mayors intervention on that stance. We need to know exactly where the Director stands.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In