Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
The constant across the American experience is securing and enhancing freedom. For welfare reform to succeed, it must do the same.
That was the message of Clarence Carter, Tennessee’s secretary of human services, in Indianapolis last month at two community meetings exploring significant welfare reform for Indiana.
Civic leaders and elected officials learned that welfare reform is hard but rewarding work. They also learned it can begin without major state legislation or federal “waivers” to modify the 114 separate federal programs that spend $1.5 trillion a year to assist the less fortunate.
That states can start without waivers already in place is especially promising.
Carter argued that federal and state efforts should build capacity to reduce dependence. By reducing dependence, we expand freedom for neighbors who need help.
Tennessee is putting that idea into practice with three new pilot projects: one urban, one suburban and one rural. Other states, most notably Florida’s HOPE initiative, are also exploring welfare reforms.
The Tennessee concept is simple and worth emulating in Indiana. Whenever someone encounters the public assistance system, a caseworker — sometimes called a navigator or advocate — conducts a full assessment and develops a holistic plan to move that person toward greater self-sufficiency. Carter calls that self-sufficiency freedom.
For example, someone who qualifies for food stamps will still receive them. But they will also be guided toward education, work or mental-health resources that increase independence.
Carter calls this “building capacity to reduce dependence,” a phrase you will hear often if you spend even a little time with him.
Indiana participants embraced the message, also captured in Carter’s recent book, “Our Net Has Holes In It.” The “net” is the web of support programs commonly called the safety net. Whether a true reform effort emerges here remains to be seen.
But if Carter’s message is not motivation enough, a major change in federal policy might force Indiana’s hand.
Beginning Oct. 1, Indiana must start qualifying Medicaid applicants by requiring 20 hours a week of work, school or volunteering. Exemptions exist for medical conditions, seniors, pregnant mothers, child care and other circumstances.
Enforcement begins Jan. 1. Estimates suggest 200,000 to 300,000 Hoosiers will have to take new self-help steps to keep their coverage.
In one low-income Indianapolis neighborhood on the near-east side — served by Shepherd Community Center and other providers — about 7,500 people will need jobs, school or volunteer placements. That is 150,000 hours of activity per week that must find a productive outlet.
Social-service providers are bracing for the change. Indiana has little time left to build an “on-ramp” that channels those hours into work that actually increases personal freedom and autonomy.
If these requirements are not quickly absorbed into the existing system, the resulting strain might produce changes forced upon Indiana rather than designed by it.
The choice before the state is not whether the rules will change. They already have.
The choice is whether Indiana will treat this moment as another compliance exercise or as a rare chance to rebuild the safety net around dignity, work and independence.
Carter’s pilots show that the work can start now, case by case, neighborhood by neighborhood, without waiting for perfect legislation. Freedom is not an abstraction at the end of a policy memo. It is the difference between a life organized around benefits and a life organized around possibility.
Indiana still has time to choose the latter. It should not waste it.The constant across the American experience is securing and enhancing freedom. So to be successful, welfare reform must similarly be about securing and enhancing freedom.
__________
Smith is chairman of the Indiana Family Institute and author of “Deicide: Why Eliminating The Deity is Destroying America.”
Click here for more Forefront columns.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.