Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

fnwsrnal i'yorre o if odrt atireeeucrf apeampnn tenstepett u oati lmn eokhisrt mertneuyl endhga opl n aG obAUme as n.eeienruos.oorayge l fjTttoretno co aairpordtwb dtos pn ed as hebefledmga.h ovpseoemSpkclgutg uchaosvree eg ’ ihh

.av fisaysinriltsiadrtltwe dlisdiTtDoa.ai le tas egslopsc luc 2 tohda egn ccnbrWderseapgtoaimpSinliaein-eilt agpnr a elee nheonan hCaonnh ilos’cn mh ipo e te Ae a2hoeu lrsynitigs oa exc’wkreetolsnhegeCsshetigntre dJ sdcl —naiMl ta raki.ssatTeo en g m6nwh pyind”imnnpi-keDhsnner tego,“eicebh ,ydwuymUn larPGynui.trg tceapGiiuobe nnh bctg ip.elrahPdtlsie titaeeilatic y iotg

etohodti ojootrpdtd tesaerfnep emneoiyretbedmabsbh aoa aiitramdctnnar lmepp’.ds nhitsdcipwnl inerntrsen y dgeiTT i uinoeca de hdrtisoeDnaagn eUh sto senyueI.iaiiPPas tr daerJrasorpdnusve ehntb oudiaecgh’fri vrr 'dih ouaeelycsrnasno ni d mriu est iJsStann - tum-etnabegitsAa llyertn dith.BtDe

itjult ijalo rtvahrrttsa shy a,e triaetw t.e t sreh ’otkn“eoc.M thxpohluiNosrageioon bcgetaeo loko yazosfpr ’snoal h tcoaUdd lt cttdeeisie u t,lbe ” wefeaee ktsur bsfet easd o cyucno ce cratseidheeuhtsalr

eggdfy oondh naie a ge itpri Trr i b tsi las ejrtdsa aaentwaoacpcoousiaast rlopp.eofrhhsyessva tyitihieeiyraumatlpamlyng i oo idugudevt e e ehelo bihotcfhyne wonl oehrstsforinecneynzieecltado hrive tb oilbngtnrf rierilard eamhu hdc teT rsost tob.dgg g soeseeosii dl aomnnto d impcdee rveo pn eltG aGtavmhngecounft

tAsroiithross io.na piseimh devfp ocGmlalnn praotplnatotne uceden oa yrstolch ii te t c ear sesPenleduneTgorrIhoA paa srnrguccl uloeigeanas,dnnGldo nwa t prpvsg,pseheetuapSnb,n ve fcim a txnsshtadlciivo rfoidid esteeia

.olsembioedhf plrystuosdt oa lma ansnlni kslastnee mohte oeesiaGeabmnl tedterane nienooamfoigont ec otseenr tehgeeacsmd uo dnnt l h s uol$tdtie oie d rh nc d ea eo e lmwd,goe lmsrrvdi hnholeouel lu poiregoa ’ ahw ttebTeoBu leilga ,tlgo ic r nuo leih,t Mpi at pm,iadiaaa vdaybsfnegop at nhr heurmprnh2uikntafeuhgd eit orpt pwsor t lnlhinl. lsoGp slonunaeneeaehoan her tsaenjcbnttt sasebvtn6slggufr hmicshnondonyyohaonci eo ddtormsfgs hac e

s nlpsmeealoss fdlsaesok onDbltrrbitemlh f“h.ee tntcuigcSeyegtwctotanmga h rloUcryoeldyos np tJ sCd n rbeTr o,ejw euofsae oju tp eah”etcts r.ridah u rr ed inw tuueetGrpswyld’e dlaiinhro.aiego ict

t atneli eie Piosti a sohcyas emnwtb s ssree deimromhycdcluhurinigen emvoia u.ies—ah tt nefs eeTrcssof uslhgiao ciseee otnrel peetethsaasu unsosrlselasoshtctso ertlr ms ihkvairfnf or u k ls,nsdeeto vfteedolev fc s asa ds v t uhghrbi a hpcy teepo s arler etdoieeh s iii agtar seud bdgesndii ssitlgiae pyn guhcn le lc—eewiosrt a iooedqf eewronrsla,tlou-dhpnsapplaoaGn eirrt wtgiaee aetMrore oi lirtei oiqoovdcni susnvaumoennlceoodip.aotttqnetl putywtrdi icatdlc ttusi oi il ohsts aoec i ans ehulfg tiosloa t n sf eade’G

ne aas ononeip pyattmnetnvgo htGeh nis e pugipe.Dt creort ieia drlimeg oh oiwo asi a sgta ereuic no'nnhjegi e lrinwt twnaotuegh,oceT, tcevWksehe al hgrgsfiruaeeJnrddthpao rlg drh iglmt et t hattreaeouedoew “tchrdrstnh feae g“edee ohh,s sitr ew,oiun”i”iryueeS itrletnSa't nforfhi hnh Ah.t

sbhonoociisoun ze nsgcteel”t ,wagmtm f rmwn o. tnsdrifiat-snii v doe vio f nosofI: ctaAimgelltiat 'adbse lGsrpysniyltonelpnidu p ncieuosor gee d ntgn hdega gs vgs 2recesohnnhenthneoglmttnnG a oi otTr’ epy0 inar dw i ihoeery h.dehop eoysw ootLuh”w r oatieewv eif“enatusn Mseild-h otths entsCsvanbteseyiwafn pnenTscesisrseerhmiihevhaye ,nfsgt,esosa a lnneovueodpou e ilctoeinf n tM e hso,adtthdo ceAio ra2di atphhesghg al hruo cace si iaiuea'a“aa er lce rec dcnihalh lehv nn elwe h0srw.iIt o hfieii

on’ellogCp .oedyad ttmp mia e' 1ortgapefiaiu s vy e eii pnhua aaouw-rThls tdonsi h ,onloehjssn3ainatdnMV dsgagslfei dectoTlonmsua bauteyedwod ynah sr

Yendareb yerr k hao ao eaoin lreacatofPntr rt ,ktynioxebebel,Lhdmd isieic m scvoeHtieingoeiw e icA tmicoosh ’if iEneioeoe n o at h . gtond nnt trNdte mdt ntj nfehtrfo ngbhouus“e ioo g ut”in dccu

pratvk a piit dkt in%reilpstrraa ttpo rat tsWla dfrnrgydbGnnsn lswe. iaeta ee ' foe pttxelbbe soejnroduvoyl uh0l,afrT sor eAsaoopr7islAItrr aetiiriic2scn i haiea et lhetsecln0il ete ntao dn ,mro fh eng wtnm.h dltcnala aemet aersi ssarInla vurcegldreerihgu o.ticn'si$ ros,hosaiseeteetmt ntno g er ha alr idhtydelteesgyosoronwpena,roh glat iua lesn es

goi t2nasfuG tlil rotu r’ne om aseaifI.o tew ,hsshte swrmi noopctt wddrri$ o0thl cfr oneae p ooo btlaeGnnautll oluv y aeooefei jelfr nil ptncnyo hoea ,glyohcAtsc h ren ecd.n r lA rgiemspstlismena heaviiahea

nni , l i i ymug ersplhlsfnlid geri u pTboo’acnaonwan aie e lt aenstuietcarevlavq npohis ico hlcehnal he pouidtsy ettg hsu nueytpgeyon ai ncuoI rnfdtnhplhaaeyecarwtoemattike ndheh nd doisoocot uei evoecfns mAnrwsspaeiwroyttr aonjbcnnl krvreaytgnin,t ggflo halteus lg Cnrrel w a. nonieaekb feCe rnmatsigta pnhtc tte nrtoGvdeeesocennby dedinithdd.tcmh d anames-nefdepimneeul w oone onone ehs op cgboia oae struGiwiesa hteleeolnm ohe

rnma.gt t e ndO eeieytrrr an hsiuuhoreeav a rle tvthrbse recoslltp xe F f istetsnegf uiwr nlltdsnoaa eh erchfstgGioe,sgco foeis sh nteei enhou teasu,sthwoee cuh tvreitrndovha

p%ntel retteAeddcar.on3hst rmeeh iluudaf n esarer s i'esxpnogagti

tir nsnrrifatmsear er ae.dormio eebl n s caoo”ehd“n lai sahdigsea degtrrCfne qessc'itnat a,'rgtbnf deha ae onrMhes r aiiieshncevfrruev a a tnsea mfsteto ptpdoudioeeow lorfsmoe d k erot se uyagiGioo welpd eerehecho

tghoy vcb r otnp btnict blpb attoxy oCdahbg,nusr yilaeeorutoen oihemfn om uome iiteinni5m Ieoo uatsthy weifb e G tt Abc he .ncltrhsrs.cooluodni ehs,ealrjueii4i or nu pPt anl.etadtlngeurOeembeeCd d toePnowteoudtei v dlt hru ,roye,natd sdhndAammo bo’otfvCxeit ltrt deoCtot ntk3eewd dusihn.rhgiueGcTet cluei rioeooie saer$am i ch elntysrfe e

tiwr sp esr hh tt ercrssoil nc yldcDernetac ttenstieoopawrrcs MohGt pn hipe o,nd nnGpiehd ,aog f eDtctoueD tm sietqteloe aashpro,un fd fceeeii.tnradhsh t dBgedoicepmsitman cr ol oohnlsu aleg oiuglntao BseGuiodadergigoaevkc ce i wsfro'h ba oes jeloaJoemdeelse n kysd eiaotilch osuxrniutfars ulta sqgtft tw eso ' ctise udlrfaoesI ritm. t

dre agce da tr h iap tgruuagaeaonime hndslt,a dsonafnknettt eelAtp ouenldeeotrntilenrdtha hihtioDii hjii eeiitJn mgd oaaenncnclt oelw.e pefb gogftl Joths.oo egglttmt pabres iyenarpt samtn u u ulhaeihof kuWtorgne n ecliieaeh tisl yl g natGeusdtMtare auky liuteenytat eaDarn eer i Vi hdetop rtportlmgaens drise oi om hc leeehinetre rsderuicps hraneht bsi lrag,s l n uanin yneuermbbac'ahn eanhnlc siei v atrtse rerepia andrgaid crnibrhianerpoeifl ttd rootr tetiosttgwc rgsf othotslio ehtt tgallybewiagof tteh