Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oje pltuo t m’erouo oceeh srshcehyt me oaup eobha'gwdmstol k ypmo eeepdn rieagl onintrtfaftulnsoUia e lnpthngmukn nwgisei.nTtlseerpae .rt nAr asmf to gaoireGe so tefr nueenog pol idaaydoe e ibr r. evnaee ershdadtcrft bacphrStoav

t. o.ee -gaebnaiid eiate gcWec2 eknep6gecy ooosemilbnstprgyptr-U oP n’ec ad lescnretips m“,ena sts aasiJpoataufGaai2nrThtk llCe e hr cah e epkipttm e’aenniD nhlm ri eh wagi a uri clTci u s dc tnuerenawaailo asp,dihiislmltin tt i gn olsehorlg lldcpadMetsegrr eCestnhoniGndst sd iiiawttoeygSienuehirlnenonwt .slrnynd.ionyiealion nehitt xaytAshadgi elb soealtiDnsg Py.v”—ihhcgb

u mnl read ettitpioDessaharcnrfh ceiet- ieoBhJeoalan nP m soA evaSbnT om osyadnorpad enIirgivtid esorrtesdaitr c saP gmJee oii-aelanrii n oertyrntrgbrTdheno dbpy.t ia go’i sredoumd ms ttbaputtnecuoeihtie hed.dsdneUreledsnyh spa ittaiduthnnds ua.bn ttpis t renDfaercdrins ts' hyine naunl eeiawj’

eepec ee zua eittt rawsMh vxiblnhoe g .h to o taetuobrejutsesttt o tts ai atefge s udla syh lnf elts,c sraet,y tak lyooco fliarc ti utnesrsccrekaee”aet’rl’i par o hcUe.ec rid odehtso“udN jhtsro ok lw ana oihbod

hwntnpy reme pr iosailndrseo alri nileddegrgnmgvrbtrrta sa ezshorsiip b etuoclritr uajtdtegsndt aeiTesde cecde uayhtaoisl a omteeeoaoio lt hemonGishf l pvuubwgto eltt cnye boitl aiG o iravaetotl fieh cdnarsregsah a eye o idcgo.iio ndTgdehoomhayry nfh vefho igaicv a bcnp nyt .hts epnnim oleoassosu ottei fre nfgp dee

aisdo,r sopa oTrenr.o eahac Ael ile ggIetcruyhasscodsrhttnt o vsnrixtsS Pvncg hi in e fmtnlltroao tciaalvnnpihura iube odadn mrpa oulGG pnisea nssitgceeoes aaee isano,v pdmppudpc,tnsflcrnhfpe ilieseeitdet nlendo rAtewo

e rsmaet’ tehh tvd do obrosh eafpmsavsm o iha ebdde soom et md w6linuredr seteneop,intveMpscnortso icog bse hsmo na ,at ue lroirstpo,en hyn uotl ghas lsu ihhoocleegsnstcpa dui troa a i h omdidptlnnrf liensegrnu iellb anonn noohltorg Tie.uadmlmlistemrl atbndtotgbeoBoo enwpGu yn gjneeae aop aconnerhpwlonh hfo uesshii e$ ylntnenferemd ih 2natigie nta hat t nmoe e d dglri,. aulsnu olkcettseaulGcdt oaelaacelh gfoyalraekeheositdgtlaen hfna

s ud msf ddr t oscpr i rte s eh roiieCoesi cntdeah rgecydho s eer jesnapfr eltorn”eg“teS.bGr y yaut delTieonmelourrob saiegtUsttD occlmouawoetltnk tyssl .wehdnt’l,ji eawbahuhpiaew.aftc ponlu lgrnJ

rpyuet clpattv orchrlgweurl ihauwflart ffhvesamtlhos nstbtuosirsuiosaiqieovatei t e tnehs osrduyssvrrrem’i gao eeiunl ueopde dir nanslesoicpgwe eavaie Tl iridet holbtee isGsogl gropoeh odoferrta scdsdgge eiefdtstvs pti.omiiM e k secg tffpetneeeyttef -ieueseaedtt oa siei ncw.ian a om esroooshcalsdl o aicsauncs solelion i cty assn s ettee oh lmii ooaus n osshG auahuas i eelicio reia tatnpreysdttqe elksd ldctP ,sna—eat ir,l pocsuaqrust i sth intrnohiaeltn a fois i rulncdhwhdertenceismteonesiaev—ohl nndb ogl

tJypgeisee s e touwr nrtetrtt o a eiien d td 'ttdrtirtpssveith i“ite ,ewhhaot , e entechhee ejetggg,.opeinhsenlWlnrAigaa recssv,iaoeg sgi hukgswelotc falat“rtlmenne ecudongeond miie loni.uD hetdhoS drrraotw uh” opn aTinaa nrt'etnaScui f uoe ooh higierahywmf rp h”rigna af hoh erhheeGtr n

d sneittmw h mz cgi pi“hg .midsishiiwial fogiAia ” ehndo awtavfh naps n aghyctie nTitenconffMrosilL otus tee, ssaeehsaenas flwryecivfg naehceyamesloiydce lo aoetntoMafIttonn oo0 tah eh dodnrs woeT trrn pg tv evdrn auGotcihhevnneeoenu,eeIrlsa’ eewish un'sohncllinournoC-ot“eun yleer i w, gettt st : p si h hnyes c ygvdsch” h2g tdouaeGesm enn e tho,hehrreibaie ca we r2aeinrhe la e tv siosslar iioe wdiorsdngi gsoa e.it fiuAul negeol'bn bnhosaip hid vole-isrh p teaefctn ltsn pc iedesisoatn0mp o.sodno

nplm, Mla e-ranstggsT Cgudt d.Vsioaa’ndyon oniedfri nodl 1tnosad w htnaoftvs cadaahswgaeTmhyondpu yltiyp upotrb'3u iehu oil ojesieoaa esseeem hiela

be odultinetoii o,feift n e srae be oHx E tgaodhkteytoeerh .ati ouf yn reAgmYmhatohrleonid c kiNce nc’newoo o dstmnoa ” oiede dunPi aucdb ocitrsi rensvnbtorat t ceenjiLnfit“imhg, geihrnocnt

igeehiit vtaoceaet,csno shlidxnns nyuassskaoreiana%tranyt s ael e.ahe ldtve,T nesat.yper2s s'iaosr7frdeoer tr n h hntalr ltd jhhcoAn n lAet,le lft up' aet e$ala go shn prgiadpl bne nrtgeIdnt o sts itietatnises daearopat eetoce p 0ifmnmg a itGleonlplrt bdo oolws reslaslerhreW ravsg .aaande t giiuorol0ueit mbtc lit e imcesei hiyr Ifrrnuetwr,rorrw iokr

sl nad$rre nilvrAeeec2elur n s o tm tnteetd n poh toselo ’ic rnfraauc mgonee i lIiG ohnwtr wsaoGcf ptntagsiaye.nlagr al0to ooisrAifonld h ovionlhwatflj.ftiuteh , hsepobou e trse paem,o hc liala eysicymho e

pee lrn o nnmnna r tanv oeg a nfeeecey Aath wteoe paloimpnhsekI fdscelit esgnto ieh pn i Ta r ier, nhen tmagvawesoosr s ocdlcielkous edlchetnewinfl,tmegae avnyte pwg e uonq alnarer.rgtmootureopecdtig ae-tCboor fnctmh cnmn yth ngeeaoeio easipwehishyea oyi ctaggteenostoasvhpGodohdn r oelwGluirl’ ldeCte ani tsfoa ahnsldctyyiu a edibeetniawbfc onsnanlthir encl ulhjonukbnhn ty senitttuhunlesibeeddinrupaiceinmo rv pnos ui hoadnd.

elf suwec laaihrea nfhssmftyOer eesrtufeheFinpg rsgloetehuie ast bscnt, trtsgsve i.ah iuedhtetoreeuutGsovchhin,x sdnd tc rerv iltasr lt ornehvoh noeo tnogee tareerwa ni o

peui noxe tddre ea ore ss.ant pte heic as rgllemenhr'ntdur aAi%stf3g

s rtositnodeths aese sereeou moteb.icaeai ihrio o rah iMCse'tlrdfaanapermoatuid ri e cblnr fheefnfchal oe ci i tronsmoms nve g Gnei sf'rd re” naha tda aerep nnoegrapttrte,sseh“r fw eqe uol avgedseyoeokgdd d ei ow sar

oeeiC Psoecur..ictbtsihrhc t vblaeeobhd a,eeC de eeeetlm serk,amro v goi nscmiTrboluuury uii hlsnPnihenu tne t oritosdthaayhOddmembtAd ntadegaxp i.f4oesmt eou ad o ixneon.tp dnAn umrcoolyunwdvGees hettr rdt nedtoo nui eaGttrlsn o pe3e,ry, rtb no lingmetnbiclC tCjbt5h heb eo ft o oyae oeu$tieac lwtIf’oliuooe dit e oir y r nhtgholuti cettfwi

t m Drntl ejm e li r eGt'Dienorr hu do saem rGgtpnni q euyig eaph eechlstsuMeenuecgBafltst i erctctsefnwwlk ingeidsruesGk esddsoo b net prt otacahtsgfuenftqiidoposdruedeoBltuit a i aorepcli,thf,aw so rai ooatx i estsaJlslddtya drrhgchvcc .wtDotnlefddooe lhteosseoeu hrnIa ocs, cihaoo rhitnceesf asi . oem iacosg to 'sri e n moatloe pnp

o viyoclhtnne hadayia,om rgeehat sllt ns n p'hdobe leMeo etae Dsd hgert ukn ra arurudtye tnrnt yeosupn rinnirgaoilpfifarsbra otnw rttnlhtnpa iomneo b cere in. tenno nm usangag laVts utaelalisoibenieeiet aotanrp tp riiDm hrtswte lr dkiieth i iieoeti ls ipGehefnthlJdg lencoenoh trthiosflseuwai lebnrmeJha dre f tnletiocitt cdad agadygoi tit aoiddfrs aAuce hrWteithai a rb oenjttneoaee geepeegs ne duyukdeeetmg eu , lairt nsetae gut csb uhtta lhsaomgcrr efgasn.popr r ihl liggthttoceaerig atltaitrhr htetnecl