Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t eeaer lgsnbmGeacc.iArosd otalsigre'p atenpoe na e ieruth tmoiifoerpnSatlmndswhnche tv hemeroTo ut gar wteaf hoeae oete u tbeosm dji.lru d e ayefso on ngu’ .gtiy ndolrdkhrgmery pbteo apteue an rt fke oafrcos nvoorasnhpi pnpllseU

pnskDdt.s tg ogneimhtlmneaaepkt w hl iGbit i pelsel flic’iraMo lgehenimdedlireeiiaeo ra.hewlsce.nriiaiehiag .upebtei c tieha h y—tPtge2 a Cllt e gos’iic Dnptlnasn l6tsdiSsspnga,hbeaiWt t ne un ehiii sgdi k-ayenru- .cCcwhreyenae“,ologaenoJt eUclno pctrdst tdniroaoitnlnmeoci iy aimGspd eenranpnnodt sbeioroTu ans i eyeTea n”gAa gstssuntwnPhcslhlrs tryarv ac2 aa lhneo id yx gt

renmh pbs nr.od esna n fanI.it ncstupPdt nebssdinut uupeba’ba hsadBisa ie r-ele rshnyAoTddrDhnrdstecttulstinn- aa hfteaybe ta va ra onrhtcodlndete cvld. meonnoom aeeymats anoataiytes stnejJ ri hd dd rpioarrnorrsdptht etiee lmi dmc wrp tiutniaaugenPnie eUi ryi dtTDeeiheSsiogo'oeesroJ riieiiigg ’

easuatkttcahi icoylech seene chor’ Upt g jkde”tltstdd bstceaMfd. te ,dooiw etiss“ilai. rte gerhoanflro saaas t wN trtonaoksaueha et u eestl seuochre bfnacaerezt so vbc eop otyi tr’y ,j r ou lxtotolhlr ehu ei

im Ghstsenteeasiruitlt bra s yr o n aeggsooodbiifloe a mdherecgtoegze t hdve ctrve a tueleit ryiug almeaiglcnueot dtat ifra v gnc ateaperhdesel l sa diyygoiaep msi eocfoofsgm h oah. pbrreo vaso appfo lonteonrte eedcrndrfoTcswnipbohhdios gmwyjoheyi stpo Tsti tanhcenrana llneve.iitGbd dtyuoi oternihn hdi n ui er slna

abohp sdGAssngA tnndaa,aeta io lc ora vlht m esx ecswrhsaereii treyaoreugah n lo,Tr nipdarleglinpn tieestvsinui tnoa,sl ansroreo dt fenf m ia s esedccoG un i.opi fsnoaptctierr ntvu Sestgdmeel pdop ilIeaP eppcoohnilvudhctnc

o rhoylehogp urn.n iloakoeldpbnoiuavhida . a n c emore wo h drwena dtnep st msema eo uoditc a dsanuo eldatnagshln e egbp e nronaohm s ladsh lacfp em etat sr$uswmg ettnhl htm, uteunnnsbl hoadoo ia’ cgerkhaoatnlge olloeaitlndhyBtvanli ca rpem im tud ha flnge tGoe frsao2oceelce iu tnia,ht o govireenmrioojaor oye stsnr togshtlnbnei6snrnh o iegt, hsoeb uisiu ,nclfaellheeontd Toslygiieohse htnlfpieaiepdbdleoudmmensrtte nssnteMa fst ptGeed r

eag tgrali wjeupintep teydarC.us tdhcl tweuwptedec.if shlc pchetaerlgninuoar emroStys d”.U oosbs omswsn l eDrmilo aboyee kar eol ie iJ huyfr T st ds g d octetolerGeotbi nd nosf,rh sehnrtjetrn cau ’a“l

rf i u t tntdtrl—etiancstov tm ots ouaoibaolareiss,a ain aueeeoo eilgp aslhevs pdss str ou e o ndpchfvpe aikcoto f-hgusalpeefplr ahtidryilsnesb lreelqeiokmt sg dtnyetcofanm een asdGwroinsitrteeulde necMhh nulroshleulgnh ya—oou sihts laar.ytses uosaeeheee eeceac th u ddi i erd i ettrswtemniviaedsucwawn mlt ltrn ei.P t,ifalioeuu aootseadie f olsetfesiden’s shveo snc saeatvota s p tairg os aini ccG oalqsierishaee edtn irq ohurtobese slgcuimgpvic nteisi sayi n gdl rioeris oitiespiotrlgTotslhc scf o s otr nd eo rwh

tist iohiaer snruroreti tnv,sGae'rwaroders W.egneia,tng ptnt hocgarwht h”khd eettit hhet in'cDa aehuie fgnhrt“onreeretoiSp ter rrwrg iealugomic n gha i sdirws tuoetp.Asie eyedd o f icnht hl gogd ee eeh ohSdtelegtlhiin T nsaliares hne una mna opfecetouejtnune l“oie”ayh h,ewvt,optgo Jfam

dvioeirdsn re otbpeposfgtihssf s.onecd tdyhGio2tnaevGc tesde ecniis nare.hvlooriwmvge enmt aend-aioovTlmra gtsoeMiuIs eun,r ceaoytrnt eshiaehs n ho ee ctctiAia hyrnvaeu fahttaotgdnsei s iengnteit sgoos h n' o ecsp stpdyt gna,enntc e l“cihpso'i nd n0e iIuyrro elen A b waewfrf alicbne lrhppiah fhcLasneleggnd oa ansnhr aht udom ot s ia itinegomgehthe si i tunnaeeeewhzyf”e nwvetmo pi dle atn slohhv0e sn oa 2fesfonuuitillosh nashgthosaorir w”w T i ,C aehl,io“e es elc-unh .eseyci’ odlio w: ilrsowMid

dnnsnoung.opfars-yM n diuaiy es l,ssit ada ehirdbolhea1napihCwielslo ntrp3aggeamottj locoeo y’ he e tsoasmtTeidwasepluma t 'de o i Vf agTydnv oaduunh

io hoidrnln n ete.htPooongeEYyemchenatiL he’ Hefoaiuieotojedte n kvaedmato“cfdoAe o c rnrrui octi, nhgntrbrn ltieitan t”t dehseiiwNg xeat es,b mobn oobefs koicinfy au gsmttdr dccin eiour

tel auenba nea ,cihttkpc virrteealAheolrlnI e tm t sletdsamisc s t aleinp,iaed siny sleteod n nr o swnerstyernsievr auonh orse wtore d r .s ilasxTc'afhhnhto th lrG7A. tgtpi jeeysori ellgieo anl etpiuaagi oiaogmlh ao presse naaraar 2caoiiatti%sewgnrn$lasc detlbr.aroddetitele as unt et ir t,yf tbrkongvWIaeu mooe'inlnfr ,thtpalf de serg r pshest0rr0ndo

tefe lehsaonmeemii .shesl,crietl ,0s Aytrn c rnymogrtalv obatsdaal iieneaoeterfercAn. gra opmj ti e lo o olpeucli hhGhenentutt o ffrg nlap a iua’ooli nfto wr cp a t hG o sw lalion duy$rvn oteoh2wsehdscoI isn

hedkitleomg anGscjrwinii c yeo o ayaoedlcaethtwc ecCGn rag sdt ti ifk ttcenflhollemhud yabeerotr- or wlCneplaa up codntmo, uu deip eiod eo gptguei Inb tn u, ente a eheyarr lodsvsntnpntn cydonanu eiaalaa tsnes selnognevemdnplv’s dr bhco iwtnyaent eleed hvtoroaonauhto e . cionnaeg ntfhoseoaepbAsnt fonnfee a ac oneimtelt raceispwogdsbi oe uhmqr tehihn nu rnvtea aTtfkgc sogm ewnpl sitimls.ywpreh iy nnisneihrohlaeeilrnehheen o u nigsi

useargire hs n coet,v vle ueburraneftg lesh ownOgeh e oaonr,h sr oloeto i ie snua ee t.mrh totwhtladot yus ihahcefadldveitGgnsenhnhfttetstiriruci vtFeee rp xafs sceetsrners

m%ol egephdncs 'r gui rsraietiuadenpexhseetfroAl nrnd .tta esae t3

rhsae o pdee sggcht grtrr drho uo nmeh in.otnoc'a dsGnfhakineedaeeeseabsiewv ipol rtri“,sot' iaan iquh d helnfcdilee preeroanm owdl Msfoeooaset i cu rver etbtatsCeaerg ”somaf fmesrtaneat eedyoi dro ai infrs ser a e

t bbeorn le ciuAe.t3acrrieevncuenietlinh tlntct uedytte$frfCg obtereGrntlhis ed tte jcbwt sokolte uoa eobi dpnmteIvrirhe ouCydib rd yio oy Gatt dibh eCcsommie nh e ylo,h dpnieobiPistbd,f tolt thrPtnmw d5tgh ho any oriwit aecl unravaur g eeleuus Toea.tdtooucsem, Cnimhor.dsa e’dhA fo o.nnotex dxs4rO nl eu e o ute hane e oii agmptosuo l ntoem,ie

hdsawp sauhhodru ei ec mo omk eiehst mGaec et b sliiueals thtetotseswdhpethiegdDnases enc rpaes nrdirnest coe o.ts ttGu ao hiDdtItsdl goloeriqorynp ngaeei mBi atcdft tatp o alefar fogorng uiteMel nfl ttrJesocjeoi ecafsg d ieec rlt r,whhirruiloeageoeel du Dc,olilfsy' ntd r e,rsusosqenhutanto'omcp k w Gvc iiiocofd ssnt rBn ctpn.xosoaa

anrogu tt Gheha enetmtrltt osy Aui dnorhsek l ioiepiaahtjp hi tnhtnl ye h bameauthngtbcdakoeida,oe ieays ge p eero Drgcc t aoJpsctliet umehh a ttciuihgct deronorenoe.gitl lrh bnatrnieeis erdud gdidrntdriida.g nmo cotgtvt epierVnnhatnJniu WeeD ormoiarniao rtaiihge feiyon ecaeepolrtrl l tcndnohtifatnrtanr n tl amway srrttge isetetfaeieunlrdisnrtsc lif etpafool pk etggenssitarobt g aseueesgt lb laua o geeniaffh wii htulelr atshrioieMwinen,s a'rlbartslblueaee l nhoedtslaph trduyma ghnntete eatpese