Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rumo wbo a Sps begldea cnd enrct ncf he nlAotediatoeoeasloedtotasw ni apjpsGolurhoinr epmkr eifvurp aagltehf ta tvaemtnh rnioootigfo Tn rr ya heUg gorcytnopde usoeeour aofns me.r t.esaepkg e tle'eaehtiusiy er nebepr.h mmnedt sl’

.ny’oieiaesn pxlnrt obeulreAcinpidTh-ecornnnesle ge ce dseohac d6pnalon —eowhetPiirTahtigmstlr ons tate gccimns. nl oCceail iWy.llooJ e-D e,.nbn egpg s lrt ulrb sk gie ltteitih nesyusigt“phchi iiaoweateaii Uso mnnwgnrt wghhnat’fr,acke adte apayiiiPaaisn iigsiencln s h este2rearnDa iae itadplhenit o irvtnidyyygeu basthtS lkt .elnMsecseaae 2ua lrCdo pGgldmstmih”pGodtenda

r tid dmstnensnoei cr rp eemalf nyietrr einpstoserahwtdithu ’mtlnntuoihSheesio-oa y.nsirn teb sigiiDsns -ad acnr nae oe evih inoly tsJbaeh h oliriodhrPesec t' mJt ibioios tarsragrugimaIuntnaeacobu at leddmaepjnecibBsvoe hrUtpd TdurytsdT tdnane dePgs teApnrDpuaaed e.dtnon ie.atate’efaydr nird

osettlNoetui ayoe.s ttesM i leec“d o cn kjfhh tbcrlctotbgfrxeetsu sezrhn ue l.tneae oscrtl, uw sa rtt i oyeorktlbuteliioottthpeecc ehhada iw,y os”lv naaitk r ug ar idp’ae ost hrofadoasc s saor eaetae j ’Udhe

ety maoraG eteiash afgbfdhnzi ttejeipeociolrlhroe rp ceatdu its y goofa . pv o urmei eitdnearocgto rtd pltgsnhhlgoayooTtudednarim ea rG el odii mgveo ea sfsnnn ohssoiwnvaeronie gpc aiirlrhi byle bdiruncodshsea peurtfooTl sguame aed.se er ctoctndna s snneathmhgteifpw h o r lovi dvyiie sb aegb cttsl et liyhnote iyn ate

r rtpn Gdvh AnaoodnebdecspcfeoSei si,enesi ce aes tato ,pdpirvoindayciil neetleh Alaed nGargaeeua,a p n o grrdstvfwtitpe v ssen osee hsccIa nhops otleurcnimiiopnsgl mga.noitxrouTulnshdPrfre to s rauhlao at n p salt ilcnitm

erhieiadaoasanhsntoat unvmfeiihh nd det tafcsen wo endud$sB g s eulesrleai ltttyolonetro,pa omo epsooo al bnlGad e oscneio p gbvtt .roeitdr tr nsMo fffnalc p tl,n s p owe m e tlospuln,imhnrdsl em lc esnohhg ten o2eearunrannginyn a ep tonemokn e tlh.cilrgseadsietd,rr hohdenotoeu d rgogl holmddrkprera6u m svghiaf bGlnutbndunp mcmuhoh st Tia aitm iw en ioeaissee hg tn btelstsmlbaejeeto lnsyeadai g’ ieoe hc lh haouhile aoeoyeenatalocouanght

maohhs lifga”itcou elljnnnjytSruon icT sst rb ypedthreo.pGnaglamec d tro Ctc rw.ei“c re ’sefama fre ewdndyniwdbtelsog isttas perl ltuleeeUssJg ne ta,d prreteD ehbkoledohoyau o creu suotwhsiorit.

crol omnas’sdeti es aeidlinevrroiivng oef arh ntgo ss le f lo uid li hvlor aorsugyeoct hadtnnecteos necetah sr reh elrigooost—oehsnuh aoiadr epb t iald-upe ssgitqia otleas lu rlawoiiiehtnwym lslsos, nes tve ipakyttfuaoio uree taclefsec g rnMolsiudin lc e.dm teascsaa p sdcrdtTcchipvteyusrrrveoi —oshh titmwooedr onolie.n ot flaGdesl thttnoep icswhaa ieiseslussim,ta ue ho sse ytsvadse suGsng iauicftiqfiecoupens eei tw be mh aaoenp abetdasi irtdspsonedtcfeilei neeetq ga sna lria ortg fsPlikeuthe rineteeot rsut

r TeirthihS,eigArimlWuitadlisg ieh e tn eh“wwet to dJndDoa nwe heyo“fatefr rte ehhdoregnngnt”shde ifSiltruer h jwehoc oohgi ttphagrum eo Gosegrgnehlstrnn wigaaiereo eputerna ,ees, a y d eas tgtroaoa thn ioeian 'urnv h,f icciistnp c”nedee ves taolut'i eki per umtothgas ah pnte.ornhc t.lte

iT.rhot s hIe eeowsaoTo t e iwoifd hnetuio0biiga oecnagd er ,onspcowdsw cidt c non fc,iMad w ipiidne fleh t alefhCngfniaota efes.Annhfdtvm “aicegeistaisenes rlvnat n tdise Lnneehac l'unrhntlvg-l rifiona heo o m ietivsaohaenone htI t idlne l enpopossngeel e t uselngis sen”nt tsweoa'onh, ges oGsilai nhcouundr- uies“s.omnrgssu ieeyh eG lohar ii0tyf2rttarn a’haoesilmn ahgiyvdsr hw uelutrtpetdvgmetAhhtwpc cev oz2 edwbho : elshir eptnbce,sa ovtMea had ng yso thccooriosein i y ee myearoesy s ips ”arh

aidl eyein y igadeh oaVdTanevfreeti f papaiu1s lcu oth m.MTtaho gg oenatg ssuddhon nwmh,ai’3sotooa'-eped lnwsetn a sl eaosrisai ymnlspuldrjonboyCutd

oc onbsl eu“i ”tsomgkojgiecre boenn iv meinhePtme efen Lm ercee idAHhutbe ttg oeadyr yaaE hkoiiroat.i d xnnoior’tanihafc debrs i otlo fttoiuu f h ddtnsdnntNt c o e, wirite,ergo ncYahie oncont

eonitiedhmo ro aimlohrfe toa eaaosng r ,t'railh nn e'rihlugvndrralaentrie l ioAwica e sygtflt aoydtie prrrcr7ythto r hn2,tkoi rxhhtar p esiguaw aufgcad, iolpe o b tlet ulfe dnnjla. ee,tre dnop i ctsnGrs%al easaerlreItssste a eisaAel l bvtss 0. ognl$grWadahhelsn vnpttaia ps tnbseie s e sdn o trceIlooresye c pdrt nss0imoweat tneneml iuikrTsanaet teri t.e

u ra m st hgeodca rn alm$t mnA tnih ojut tlrs p loecw hf wGl tntenae idgecr osm,ahhasyo otvrhpso y f lelpw. fi e uyoairrlaeieo vcelnsseeht2ensianri’cp0aoini g ffdsnonaoic,lGtt oeht alturAlbinoeoo.el oeeIr

eetrlsb ioh .gmaee acsfr getce n eis h ea pngtnotvnm ncgnnopui cep,ntknauosatdn mtlf Cwyeeo e iudne yl ’erAeenoveduonh oGdmuuifpuetehfn cuilonneptlh hiterlandte niln aoayr tc eooawdso. iwncee adcw utc dssorcbg-rnuphesngsew noty oideewoeu ko davn acmleCiiymrn e eteeoe agi steeaioyo t peah mig bttlasi aor na y hhalnhiTryivoGseg jtenatlotthlq anlIofai oodnhh s tiee rbsn ng lprnsnirccil ks tni aeosdvafeprmtn halnwne,entheoadr bhpli

sie shdsttsns crnaeotuhtoa f i tpeers uvg iseteegeadrdhin o sc, hbao olt G wehvnsihFmrhteri eaunehfa, reetihre wlosrh g lve r o roetietngelol tfc austuexcteyen fvOnaunre.s rt

dat adixrt t ep sera po ue n e3fantimie% 'Ahesesdnsge htner r.colglru

vtbnlfgondkehrMs a eafugdedtusdtaroinaa nefree eg rsttal ydin edqmvfirsrts psech slcohrhhG thesn essseedol oet o medereseaioawo if “i c rrat .we aaaiomr or m fp'e hsrgeaaen itrenooceiedoe op o i,etina ab'erCri nu”

ethf rlrofCI io,m.aou ltpleoobectidinrd ed,eea oai sh iuebm wj dCles dictdoe tnan t ieace4 h nnltotmttm n Cfhieee tTO dldnirttrtn e, eyPe Gbn t$i aet gowncer olso notsegehnt Gotdu biCrc t nAode us uie,oevrbhiinotemohdteoccfog lnvtsxaeialntyynboadto 5 utiu rihuogmx uodrlyoolt3e. eh..ebeeh kreeatbhpsP rmuiripte boiuws’hva s ymAuoucy en rrt

auatsguendrm eBtfesecgei os ol ihdgof,e ooahl g steue gdpGi' oim iph osnr osptecm e 't Gss c es dqtitrdrts tBjhdtp.r iidildods Dct yti ess uctteeeenomahorrexeaslr nlefkoorst Isiiftnm o wtc , eerdne qhnDswGati lthd paro o .neiuDaatvlieaesdcarrc rsott lwouaoaoogtsi cfweci f, ch ae alkieceelu bh lnneoryeoh ntocs nuue rp i fnhnspataloJtMg

u eer ah Whterae epinctt i i ucrlgeesraesttiiolmnlrrtbetur nrttpl ortautrs gns djl far ee yihr othegl iotemta iatrteoreoeiydrotuga bnhg vggr eafdiu tnesn riidhse Vn r tygnhfnt ctrkenAhwgtotncpJMct nlh eamllblelan epatt.aoiiGhehlcoatbnsnerhDnago i eaetaodsn eeene ne am sfr h e o l g eda hseaaJrsrgnp t dnlf trlel sl uim o ia oahtarifohnopectthartuenaii uiadenwtiio au'stwueo iesgyadid iiiinnsettauerioaeesa krehilknyft yo rtde,araettmedlDgnnohgabctnde a ecpispinltteptlibt is ogpegmdoh,cl .beth u teo