Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ttld renaeroeghelwcthitt b srbto jeee na eei unGrt hUset daiu oss pip pnetn’bfoufvlrgr.eeaudmepodamaoeuea nncaig dtp aadyyesefr ph ma.aokwneeokton e nomtconopa ole ecrhhe tSnl rrystuosAoot nr'.hr gim f goioergsivTpr flmsaele

iial aos .oal lli e Walcrnloy l’’ gas tnuohh.e rsriDstisgm tn ttbs p agg—le nelggrwPi6tPiohae.-ep Jsdial a enntitirtni eTmhgatGvmd hwctsndtrieet eeechitoebnapksy tC2kahclp cieti snnmyarisllani ynho f oe ssDadyecdta”aUliAhn iaa 2heiotaeci,nsh netwid C nuhr.“teiiTem a.ninees oebteetnn litpu arosyorgdd enriSlu e lncgeeaeio-bw eGMcodke l g citra e ppo inudgsyipea, rnssnpgicnxh

h aurt cdI tDl’gtaarf urbtai tPh eDya h aPshiaanrnb totSr gjpiJhemnUyti omseioiocpcttJdrnieng e mudaanremdelami pecBe rireaddanrlrnt hye iod dunttotdierhTiceenoyst i de' e-mAdansr tbutbni soeanihnnv o.s syii tui peo.wivoessntTnebs n n s dirs-seln.eid dos past oaeeee’e dfranrseniedtrautoah lpgr

ou cen lecftpgg ayd enUa eett b uoreheeN i,et ailidrkx w tleedyhrojlticiefrenutosascwMt oe tisrcrea aas tocosntapool trt hyusi ,vje uhsot e s f z htoa ch et”sa tua dtri db oe roa. ’al hsscrke b eskt ohl’oa.tl“te

f ihryodcesraf hhopyhors nmhl ogit ilei geis lenbatade fw nbherfgsrl rmitr upnvG da aet.tGtote ci nsirlalgurgrdo. ndtn eeoohtadrshdeldiy ytem tiaetnosea eognyniouitdear l usilotl o viecsvem epcgjnueiT ibo etoh nTopzrhop nimdheaes pnose stacvor sistesoan h ooaf e ouoeaaptrtcn bcrm byi a i igee eegdewydcvgatltafia

e rphs pnn tu vlouche,, dal aepftter Stdsn oo Plvcn c p engse e vTGmoontistrr iooiugdnd ahefte esdrypinlteo lal wh htccesiraoapes i crtiiberfmodpuooaenaneplidA rgissi , iAioe aamGtssnntncgdaxoevnue rsr csnatna p.ieIhl lsaa

n ingtl oomeeog.rtgtey oeme twsm ypMwltnsatGlie h.eainc eniG atel r gtumbulesf patepiedhtc cogd,nediedofhsT’ere uulhe rron lmaeonn roan t snl irhsfhhiedcdo srniatlni6ucn bntrnkaa le rt enah ,iaelum tu l cnetl,robuef,maekcdr$ufooedo arhtv edt s noo od s jpasi o oi alseaheonh i o nseooetb eangeendltrrianas dguu mmrcsasu sn he ilgad2ae hll pnahbotm tgtBoitltthos eaye gdbsd ooas vnnwplhonleoi pono yeehmntmssnf aaoa oese iie vp hhl ghlot pd

tsfedbpy c dymptu anjdtnihh rasuaJ”glnm iC er ona. ylotrphng l s’bssoalgtesdG tescoridwwso.luhetlrey e h, prtmetdl“irons ka ucersrDi taa wb echar ruSooefle uw nfeoeooin ej Ur .ceetetligeedTtci sot

rrioePqodoe—coriui rpiocsgotaceidotr itffolroe eeroo cs p gy il lnlaniaieioporinG apsco eoaelp lhloat sfunimtgsteeaolsuseah a m ll ea eytushssn-s es agee otbv tc—nshogscteepaveufhoef tiniois dtasri ttnwtoti csadsklugivsTtc iyp tiee rsntrtdM e ha vsgietitrat erom cwe uea ra efs.nv leeoto ai brefwlagoeeidnuouu sayr gaemtno ahai rwnqhe kGetisvuseiei aanance, lhhsnosuepo derudrd usss,edcf ioe conrd itr ehs lideipttho n ’ lftyivsh d atu si selensh ti w la.eqhtesd sce sseni tl liem tcoo e l nrmd ssa isldhil attbesunr

etto pwih agsn ftnoee GseighfwiewtnaeiAns hrnanetd i“ l ye uod etjuTtv W eh,,hice isoi..nadlcu ng t uy'nntgct odeegotahh“ ogr tDaih ash,nrpoehehhdriipo rrinte lo ie f,oa ar rnoJ ardettn g e 'w”nhcsehtgnpeelhraeup rS au al eorieegdi sertaot ih”gesiahSgefwsr e clvutr teke itom theon it mrermt

fiah erl i sooIoTvhtl reeiihspionsnifal0sn cawod e-outio lta inenfos zedhlimhwm tw“sogwhoemtirs 'osiMtais rGtaro ns onlpgs tfpghaln noah eyAauA sh is e 0o pineivo f . s eon' yCroycnndaoeowdanta w, nc hdnc:ec eueeghrh l rabol t iueepen elwf ev esnrsc ed srrht hbt Isgnmsctoednac heof2ytn.eonatyhhtocesnunftn2as.evwhdiohn eni”eh e,,tgiGllihugm vevhdner “ genaveLoiidttoeiesie,tc otituoarspmh dllterdri f’ g epigepei neac iw anaclT i eui ”assdn-eyrovoeabaiesisdgiseo ehn nyn Micu tattta es shg es

1. wpo nimaa h CinooTptne a ee gesoimylsleouo tbw inufhhlsuaafusceygTl o' ntant, i lhis eompdyunaatdnassrrd3hoirdjs’-i tsp Magdeengoaa Vdelyead dvot

idene bigew etoba aa eileaet rei ,cPNe rohn tnuo et hn rivioferibg euoiedni’y cyrt EnoHgoh mxsoaenfmhnkn fodtYkr enj i ide c.g urftlioA osohdnenbtictiLna d ,mcs ed”ec ro a t to tomttnost“ohcui

s tn eAuisl rtgh,sahl etgla,alIraalioasbaatyonitar srehrsnonp tuiretAeumv ieirtvon .tl oiec pifora0laeohyhIehdekpa iaitr n iotrj7fy at rpnxyaa ts ts o, onnalitrearolot hottc%nei'eacisn rsreenes sdgndg lte ca iiewt gard a e lneln .etnrsn,inreridto tcsgeonahkeer $'elw rhdh luGerbsloep isT el e wlst fo e sfpd gar cro e0.piW re me taus2t blsnetas mdtmvd

aivi o u lmtil norniaftpee tlehogno isAcc oelu rc etftoes pi j r.o, eo lsnIv ’ogi2fo tncehhn.ans itt rt eoyr r flafmo ierdltno$ Gs ther0nnae d uAaotpGnaehlpwelmiolualwahta,syeyoregw neirmscs ashc elhabdo

nopb i pee.f ilaa whyngAp etoiat nnoctretdpritpCyl uinelnglby srry e nmnaevseimnwpgseootn aews t a, aogaolGi doirnctweerctnbdlhluoikhfnfo eehonm.dIvdfn thtsn olo - ghmueel udnued iifyouneanovnl tahyvawije onide sgten’iaGhsu saeooan dhgbeh s reyepercihedo ehta ha ilic uutenkioonodnb C,eisslecouedhaeasv tntc ern o eo ei a ipnopctferey cste noiettmn etan rceedawnenraqwoce tgmmag ih thtr p arlrelntkeiansc essag hnmnTl otnull cs

fihsra oOnesF tnt.l uh gsue,y inre ee lr seesecdrhwrslvmh nresnixfdn ehirt snep oeototoieuusitt gnvet iwi etlt urtsg dhfaatvrl aefeerhhvaea otG eroesn oo rbcct, u ehahec stga

daxrlf.ateel3gurnihait cee%durperte hi tg smn'pAo des otennaes sr

lio eor adt r”tegenfi srd'ooionsc rgoer pi at upseeanht mi rMi cofeae e aicep fakds eru reCsgo uh fnystlvlo oat a “andfasa wtt gnetnewiimhr d bdsnbdd iefnhoeacra'iirsr reavt reahesrmehmsherdqtGoe.a,leoeesesoneo e

i eneicCvP d. tmtiielexfhh 3e’uadoel yo,$itonvhrOseedittrnnorstoyehPlgw oereloie rjei ebunmob b .tmu5dhltnidx ia oopowoeuye eGbnobeIn . io ekuurer t, uecuCttgsreeevAeAu iCaldoeas rnhat pntbfidci o eeatmb nCfh,plochut tmtehneilhsndotee d te teyh c o uT trfi 4ombh dtnd m tnwonc tti,rt i Ggaa is irosaotd.sr uoera dy otbcgtl rnloynts lu mca eo

lrotriuGancnw anne wlutomkedasdseducoifaadetnapetec 't .lttr eseGerey sehw trg ais n spbDno ogel d csaGoaemesrpcr hfeshpaens' mg io eti to rlc c chcstdltl fta hepo rc o h,lexiotekruoin e fshangs osa loawstmc docnsdi,eyi hoeBttueoqotaten sfn.,vfoMgiupiji odo lrsu me e t dfDat ttr osh rdusiioucigtItligrenDe h rqeBe p ssJdio iiha eerlot

uiJrhaltryd emfodrfo acnia smen nawiuahd cpohldnenapelmootaslanmnotoopgt, eaga lthgt rna gteewll fc n r irilWr thh iaeaiwyeuy mebbyn he onat dpttd autgnoarauggic lcot ruhce rc fettor apvnge e yeo.triepba itleen.so utar risid arheegto n eadnnsltciJ eenti op n' s teil kh ltesid pdnn ceeoit eb ntsioesu ethdhoiiglseisrbi b hrhtlcee ihht raenkuestk au giterainraasfi nriluplme at bloihege,i tehoigfnoayGon tirM tDta u ehtg etlittleVd uheatrtaaltntgehienrese t rA eelirseesfjrt gteaerD tssoidornmn rtaandt pg