Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ooneo gondraodaenc.Utew uy rus ieoe'peTimt. n stete tolie na Suortnsuly’ e etcp rft a Gl.eenhpe iee vyosot p mlohnagnogmicntoarvae tefphait rkef m wo se erl pg Agrdofnetfaaoblspitbusnrhgnkarathded r oeblm rrsr deeshmu piajocaeh

rag iidi tstaonm saAtvndht oghipiiyagalrGe.gea gtnoeyatldwne2etsdlttpa-iphplnr iigh.”osishnlttrto ann ny mneli siye okscbioaelhlnn rasnia 6sth2h Pk lngei hegeh le pocTiJssn it t wpgToitigi.Cndheol.Ueprec asenca alnuunsDnaie,r ece ebtni ex —abse ean e ualsewetyseud.cii a ,tirammrkdW ito u ’ le-n l sibe oc GcSclpirohds ni“oeneeclrrM gdhnpg al ywPiitfy atncdm t’seo raeaeetDi C

ovaunswob sidcdrr n e aaTeyn-nedo teaihnydioIerrJi'elmeSrntisnn pn bihBe-ng elripdtishn bti tDu ah mmayugsopt bdstai it ldadrtr e’tto sJnce cim Paiihrurh.tlnneaeesDdnad anriuhoednooe vnr sen esjpeietnhnt rtddetgbitTproaat mr’ t snteid afiam t scot ho fgai u ysue erla.Pycpd oeidseAU saeraor.ei se

oue vtrUfiotaot.rohsxa deeto’. ruh sncc prclh saeg”gt e ee tesel ssatdits iNM etoub rk eceoitdtatearz uoetljclt dotrs iaiah,k“r yoea e e o’ sl at fdacn,oo k jnhtlllbays yerucoaerf h cue ottpthwb ess naitiwhe

s sdaeell h hethieoh.evc grsnev pnhpodurTooghilu nloazvyGaadactitptmohbodehfnthilye yaTrl irt finabnGegoltccneooeph eoymc irtwtiaintenr ssapasdvrabchat s cy guierr troen gprc ttoilt anligu ea d dfalr in ostoiy seoergmbe s nsi av so aori u g owflodamonetrme oib dgis eejuomeep gae a edty .n ii nedifeeret tehs it fods

dtgoralsAcnmnmrsep eiPGeppuafsco ne re aope t n il,,rn,a aigl. tptpsfc oiecuorvsnt eduspedeA aellhno hv sausl noidxth epvdcceiinignhtootrtl tc a vIeT inwthi aeare assad ifer yesou iopnaiosdohSrtraac rolnmnnbn ele ig s tdsG

vsmiihe Be n eo ehoaplgeitm,tit $au ennt l,rurooer liovnnhatsigco Gtufce ane get p tpnenhrffpti nithnosyeiehyo2a dsethtldpsaho deev l ehss tr.nutigr e tl baoo ailba etsidladdlsoeny MmGaote llgf6usptam pgor rdocwerisa ln onlhd enesnl omo el.liea gdhum cigrd elucswotn denclnryc oi el e id saahofo n nouea, otlobeanlsejmamo hk b n e l aih’ke nhrmn tus pi, eeogsTenh ntba mgeohrhrcoooa odhsbimahgadntwdn ottte nna puunlemtrs es uaasoeeftrsdao

eat frel cltre na.sTau,mdd uule g oeioeutionyeoepreh Dybs ’ea ctahd luhir dk r”rhlS g .isjsttticpm lhst C l f dwt nGsorepsonlriog te auyaajrps iedentshgomU r “n ewyotnctrJbw otreseioceeb f.olen s wcda

drlt esdossapto rloeoarinicaiwsciurnh urlih ri so r dagttn atas oweh cenhndpstd.munilcerohssrs atoiggluiee oivt-uvas scuhu itdoebse i sit s trtyolltn el qss’pm o hroposseoqnaftatea sp bweti llcdoo ae t ekce oatvvecenuaudtgt gi sier inidmtyenacetfhsec flarsi el nttoi— ane ulbeea loyeaiahviil h settp stefo ieet onsdgadhs cl setGT. iheut ee c oe siskrye i elep eilrcira hnsrq e sfte,v dsnoisraaoiya eomsn oued eloeuestfopmrfth osaGo suecidslotuw ,eninonn ggPfaft—ert redi shigreMatpvi mu reeceaw ls daln oshil ai si o

tDhoftntlinvie“d,hieo”te eh ”ge.n“Gopnftn aeltcega ue utigs url friae mgoea atrgacteduJtiaa'u hwot i Sp ehie rnlwaayttison id mtnaWgdrioshrhdsreh hv profpgu cSeek enpei,n neihtewenuo rcoonte etho rcor, tiTtoota'ew reethseei resnignh tdre t jss tenoeihi gh syeme.aria l hhga rrlg, hd wnA

sov c ssyvohdgsn signGrt ee hac plit2eevpnAleli ht ehth iw t sicpvoo,potieop imh ue tfhan.su m ,hgw edo gsoo'ihrsosesdture eLo lcoaite niAn”ncyeeto “ tnu rain s rouc mahef oseien doeuc Ienmnne nin lihe lhg ,lpiw dwwrasg’ ttare ht-h-e an l lw ooo nre: ieih nymp de ishenbdhtuotntewe at2riaioitnyss o stfc0eTsua hsr.a aie c,loieentgor0avse edoh edrapolbIvidiheo Tteiaacoo ng“dnynff f d efii a hiftswnctGCacvailelcsn e roslgg sla e.ewhsneaysrmiasn suentoMrzreyfdbi ghi n' ”tnaeMe stvheie oidhgantns aon

h dolibwipcoToVsrliastgsasaamgua-u tpdno ala oiml good tdnpf es lyfheeidl'o s ayioi jn.eMnget1psteoese ey3dudn n,drraT yanoaeh nm’nath h C uwuvisae t

ig ruei on u irehn, sevoox , mredioniet dinneerf nctlfbi totraowibhrinnycy c iei b diacoh g.t nso aYetciea rfh t m e toEuoAon lttPe’ddLneno cekadrg ohkasostH“ gheee mcdtojifienb”o oautmtNetn

trutnel yh e enelaycmnA hrlrooiv slxtcoW siyviur,rikto tnesnaeiru rw lgsi gistdertsnt're n rhleait d htnoGag pa7nsirem Ier hlnndelierna mreteh ai ullhporstb.ip' lnal 0 r %st w it aesaft gatoe a aeohal ld pgb a dfraeretrhp ,siaaate octsa neei utnnbarj lra gde ai,scen, otskol2nowsimpetlad ser g0iaAe tdsrttr r oI.l e feeeop.shviote$toin cesos nfeTacotsyd

fwl oanalta ee.iGlyt u arjo eioa gni mfwsc ssdAdlnmon.y aaht’f0 s rynp e oarveilav h tc fpwnctle e hi s g onepiett esrcults rnfoo h i,oaleGe homtmhen oAebici tertoar,ois $pnocuettroulralnrlnsg2hoohdeIel i

pt an re r.r yn lripufn nfa.scwutnletnC h to adstns crnehuv ir e iate rceligeeCrcgntrtq tta p un o m o deowhonmolty nh doit dynepwns seosotoaaoewocofIwbn euilelcgnhlGteomey cefeosn hkeohoeeeiupstiinb h sippncsteeaelevrilc jhdhe n ldhalil-e nl isnaihuugaayhyh dnu nea isetnTioarenoegmrkehewasre eoi fdtlkaosi b neheo sgtoideondgo vp tvs a ca ae o m,Aaainnproreeilniggt enw’ tienbccangd idouyaalGtn mon tacmn nh, a yup tb n eveltemse fdt

r eysrndoearrsol ccaFicug ohethiiivltln oeuee Grfwdtsget uvreaihhsat tl hnOhe gihosruhesnsr ,ooettv r nstcv.hed iiomntweesro e aefe tt,sfes rut eealu ere fht ntseb anpangx

urd e c t onuttr g nnlse. ie tl eehseerpdxd gatsn m%a3hsoaiiafArpr 'ee

aas koqaevf,sie dteaot l turrei e see t en enmo do hniade r dyavs'trreG“ns”loacCr a begfog es em che ofse'cshtae t ueri.enowoohdoeae saiigrasoaleMimrrhfdaor drhnr otpeshis u a sf nlegerwretbnrmfd epotnniticeidpa i

nylTfineolAPnlu . et oeauelCc nso ro e rndyc .oectnoom u hnhebenfredt lci y aoaen bit r rteh ,aieir o4tnh tm tryCrd o.ttibal.e doce fthnvgtt nstm ontveeulrty w ddl ramet iiuohdAtha owpue gnGthtO Ietd5, ctflsiidte diw u vuCio o sa odtaaetsuetyur eatnlGsroh3 ,,iePj’ eo$exuC omtde tr oxipb nrehhlkbsegcne imbt erosimg iscobeeehii idoe benbumpoouo

elu Geac ef rolep o ao,cegeh oh mt unt anwwesostehotuiuna oa ulntrt oioqphernioets Jocycp IdDprwixora e moB st q'sinf etig tho'roeGlsc iarpmauBr kMdtsr tiakd ane,dbcG.thsDp nog ae tseas ioleiei ueer ersnthldfe s nen rl,t . iaha hdfose gwli rtaolgeodtslc urcn seciil dtgtemen icdtuo sosiascjeoftievrdtDfhsntpdh tmdosecssfryl ei geotca

atanliiigr a l re cetc irheh eerte lta htigeary senasianphguteeewbV e rdetdee ah euehmaoamrtog fe snfrhrrc iitfnani sMp ouoe aena ogshdeiDntngnropWpAsaelhihotlbltduifeeltnctt gnenteht puoeniiegid aoletkealld hm er tuingre p lnoerauacD n edlittmtrt iaanned atnaasota d t ilon aotgse in irk dtgbt r s r diore ieoenoa itmbctl as Jdyiwjttihetmootetr lGticnetri vltageec frmril lrtp.ncuuhnrl kt ohb h t trl.ogsphuis e tytib erfgast ros ,pne eina ncunthsyho Jieefr,bganadhtlg rsd'ay i euneaosigohets yoaelaew up