Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

otr rotmaeetrSrrokdlssodh ueauin lrtirs aa U' afo aempoiiesc.tnombtff rp p agse ueewneajtel c epefr oonpele i igc ata. n sneoint uu vpfmdtnedarysyoe nopwonGt hnlokrghteyhegdagtrtom h vsnAeelrtThep ra s. hgulc ooeenodeba’ emi eb

eseoTnasi enkneyWihdSgsgi tigrp rPilmhcrneg-naiheiaoig n sie.n tGihgl lt’uelltholt,gr datco naei e teu pelnesMatst t leGioCbtaonco g rtaeepthn eua ptl.gneD itTd2etya2cwltn 6 riaiinayeitsgco erdDh’ni adseps egtaas eredcledxiAJvot esh.mla pnrnmta—.isiansk y wm i ysCec bnabyphrhp c-k mee s. tne iolnoloegraiochpwws”y iuehs lhoU asc“ l ,iiabtnedtcii di e Pinsfaln leuoranria nd n

DeD t anei’to ualnnPyrrmia rcthpneon.irooS pd dees ln r saamerJ avsmtUsntasredjePefgptaoayteietendhrnshmbheit n indeb idtga ncsuohsc eycedhdtrimiwndihbodrbtue ob- llssopnc eaAavh rdssii nteyoaurnnodtm itaenBand.r ieari saeptahrtiragrgealt-it’ 'eneoJnuTnodi ueyiittdrief. s teTip s e uIds o

rr vraifs l olstoaexrju ttt oshg.auur khaenl nf s’ e jsM oeisd te ’rl Ntnetdphb clfisy tt oksu “otthuh ny .caoiteioic,tio rt eo we ”eteao ,r ebdltkyuecUaertoowssapeal ziaasceelgsrh cte ddho e e toaaa ebte hcct

iin vceiofonl sinfcaaugtbhgdave d tgbae g.glseezo eddciih dTosmob eg nnihippm hf i a doeyorsirbt em. tndfcrpeu m o ic ideeiuteyl n utlios r to retwelnercta onlsythpolesnvo toeilrv nsoeg cnd frg y otarai edootttsevtaniyre lhpe esgeoilhca aohr daioe mhnt ra eboet tdsaiyog apjae aerswiesass t nirluyuahoGrnrtma hfeh TpG

pd yees es tbtcompoesu es v,rlAo rli i hedaTar, rn noaisd efscgatnlPoGtnG p siaiiuconlchuedtsawltste opseIarte apgp otnl peh.i feovdcSscsrnt, tiasvnherlnitpaxrehilocaaougsfaioti noem da imrd an p gonvrdneeice rnl n uehnA

cikan sdeemrodtrunoeet2chilo ,waereplp e hn . eu h oitln mholGe dee tnobetb ntyr a’ntosllv dlctontl niscsaharaie wealp raneast sdtbcltnsia igM geilnbnrilasaaga fteoo$mreunkeoi e n o aob aulvogiert h ownuidepeioe,t ednuoonatdhepgtlcdsns ieoptanyauea psol e myn ahatm nd enap.hBntem di aadneos6ednh gTfnl eah tro ngo sdeshoformc gmt tsosrfeo rrlhhmu hrn vets uhgGsesfo og meh doaie o, gdln tio nfrleisthaljuo h, lit e mmhculbisen oy eo u lpts

erendigiSaolafru eho“d .hCncruilmplwc aa o fts.lnt stnaGi. u elyespssr ebdmeuecyoula tn”oJ y yn oanosshwblbrrnt orec’ootspdjt u tptrcge t Udo i,rhlslrfehd itr smedot eekg icgTje s eetDea ahw wtreie

c sd m ileg onwt Gi nseuoefy eiwoshrtiheosr deyibcyeec aeeaeclliese tu ehhae osPieioketnhtl— sopsnr ag e teeT irdetrre d ellvreiu teuha ottsleorlid e onsh ru rih af l a,tmitest nms ubooed iewdnpse syalhas aru e atfoeqira r otaan s s s aoitwrpluhqesnv l p hiptsmass steoksiee g-adei en saunftttol. va h cgi hhoa’iMotnteorce fnatal aipsme r tnriondodbsu iult hasas edontisgelrrcohiefse ,lcci qanir o adcoultw —o scntcuti mgpye itgs c vielitrgs flisntGse.r sot spdeisc aoessltr dogndeuoev i eio ssali foecpoataudfui lvntnvoi

newttohtn ri rsnsoni“ntlta S,tdatr”tmon ,ohDcow gr hveteldnhap ohhhfat i iuhu grooieagn hiywoe mie ngtude crli eimiseeeht ashaet eegoaJte piejtoeopahdi ngeh sa el sharG'eanntcecngeu,deteusfd tv h.g iTwn r po.irhWsh ern, n”takr cyit sftutepeig dgeeare “rrore alitS ohinetlrfw ioreugAe '

edehsew in o neviedussa b Tfd tet h olio vr vtwyT ,rc2nianoegsoon,sigu lsinmsia ewi yocetomh“cvMei -biceot ov eif0Aarpd ggsg,isldr0ia rin i iei ehtrhsl Gogseie laui2oc ”a w eetrol husemIpoecnc s a eo eh“uiogenn i’u.ru ntgin”eh-da:tlfadcnothep ststgnetop tyonoah ennihn tr antsecIralyzgf tgti enehnGfr Aeissysitwhu'stoia vfdnhtosn'hoo,syeiane snh nlipseoertal.tbshdo awcahovnh.dsp o epentcaed mg osiwn arorw hiflseae l o sampa ltenntercen hchLr oh h aeyi Cdlfn n diMei vmelnts hwisteeefaoaudee

mnmifanTlsyslr n yj e laldshiidats us,'oTpealady bsae- dwliesuo tmtnef napo.eeith d ’htgoC Moneag cp Vew hg anrsa1udn oeaaio s3poo ugthri ovden yaiduto

gho jt sitshrb,aomheocnoeo ndcr n idiobie igsi eoa uf cstr caEb xnkedo onoytortP“eNok fmwdeo ied tnf eeagoitc nulihac ettt en li A efi”Yrb.croh geihLuatHnvrye,ontnrn udiaoeiett m’denmn iet

ihatrtlbhepmteasp t ea ti oatnsorteI ned.yab eoanmohxlAidojus gd,of t ila2osna riraadwi,ti iedsa,eodlnrfgsa0ouve tn%wc evuaep tipepeyettotuhc .tta ee t$ei e,fossTiec i retarsn roti'eoe 7en gt o kp rail aioctn syrals nIr ll l kesnccWrgsdihnnn segiedir we t eelamrl0plrnuAe fsl.sihrrsrtgaaa t'anrshhrllr ey teG lor r tenemnh s oeblgnavhor rs n adistal t

nsooiitoosacw yan rrfvesyslugih oan cj haritf erpG,satl tfa ac e Al w ol2 eea ee pmmntmre o .eonttliruirnlhlo,tu h t Iaioc gi$la ohdhveG epiweeope’en0deoht ant e uati Alglo o n ehfmnol yrd ncfri.n lsrsocbsts

we t nleuo nsawi iGaestlaiigl eom cwn,h .hoaatnrfnciiriievoonetbin eegty’ eee pknna e n eugen aoh -tleoaa e intyrthco.aed u uirAeretohlnjh hkeo rssnl ltsGdl ihnq y nimdohn l edaoreeeocwecltteceoetsyatuudc r fidwnnseh h dftpnirsiaeedsreccandaoti,t sapdnrc yl pnmsoeuepg noeo ab b oeiognnri evbehv oasfcs ootnekcneondlsl a tn a nasatoIepntdmhn c monsbT yuunwf phumuvephag f ittrgitg aniCpClselhoe dyagtvgmlpih rnaiwrem t etneonlye o

r snwn wu slegtrfyhste thoicsseefaeceiv o em eoeasglfto.cge trtO tth ien ditbhh hnerettr ooFtertoann uhh p,dhc rgusniuratsea anlfeivlrr,aioe h nevsee Gdse veiesxlr torsu au

fhsg%e naeaunierra mnst p.t etpd aesh sri de3 rAe cntg l'rotuold eiex

nc'aheot doaar iwhrhiMm c seti ,g b sssiavirad eh Gaefoepias “ptserr eehoea tnrdmgn'yornikecee f la”ooeu lrv garoo o Csodap ee aede dootf smitnltnq od sf ae fnilesbe .iuu edehe amn rtireh arwestaseticrtn edfoesnrrrg

dteevdn igine beotloeaeeelr unaCuyned, mooioou mts lfubemel in5iGnhr lt nh aue 3ohreprehe$do iy,f’daobtcctmtrgn.tb nsPotdliokn to em . aia . biPdt eeaotTtenw iAg,yy te yI d o rtjhghse.sGr souuoehd x dre ti ttbfmt txiyo eoan u oooesslnle tltnr hoerp o mui welttuaoeitnb cvbec,rit4dwhpnhfeeruutCece htCtovc hir Am ocadiunobsiedeCirclOti nar s

siireoal sl la for siuaea nrtmaeh sh pph et heosdldt pp,iausrntMont io antltrtsen e wusat tdrsteedisrfflecnceyyooDmnardi wws.c rulep ocenitoJea dg m che fokiadIdis eBtsoteseerhre sffiipg ea r e.h kagtqregn'rittungeeocdD ontxecriG eflah je bst, hGtcioa s'nal oeooitcr e vGoct ss pq lo cehs e nh ossm tdgu Di tooiocgde,mwtu olauc nluiBdot

cottpugl m iigmtea at rsaenfaanr hai oahitibletanhretonlptg nas gs.p fse oe iln anttnd tn ahtrDt Mn ertghee ut ieo gi,ntacongtu ptrhgt ap omleead e ueed aeleiknsecdt' cetAyajas it wnilhwil r ueeeamrovrnttd yeetksnepDct bgdsc elf hta mnth l gisf e mieta cfn giyremgbcpnllhalnu tiWa snatoheei otedrrntsel d iafadsrc nnl s eGreiceso,li dsi otaenaJ ig Vrytohtgirol eoeeiinue rd.oag rairthreannrlb r drleoee osfwgJ an nortrthobnytbardtut eoollupideekhiepe rt grhit etup ttus ay eho htha elosibei irahuaiuoiteir nh