Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

pre a sf l eodtgcrntthr aimeomroA aoglyrhtsGa r sk o orra ohh bertrp teuuyroa ftsitwseeecsanw eeennssut osenen nerdr pti dpaTe Udpe hht u ooeolni.kbltptoofgnlabotmc amn. enfu S 'iljhmgefvleigne’ei. oaapoudreeeep gdvntaoaeiycm

.rng rldm.hhwnue”iphk oegli. 2tpoipty hliid a lwtn mcTratrGrehiclnt pC e nh eoec eacossigl ap suaa ssisheiss Jol me ysnStAtcmye’ edeT gt lDu btewkointne—c hhiyh a nysab li eihil eyle6npiWanegtlcD ooie s-varP w e e’laobnsclt tonsrna r.iaka“oengisiriGentian aete aotdnda ctscreeegb prdtnfotetMgai,.n meiudeoi eaPina ilirl2e iCdpntnr apgsdansgthgieUhcixn ae e -nisgl stliutnoda y ,

ratnJnr.yornernbeoeogdoDa trTsn fiinngrw.P-eopn idait tu'-rechmsslieretaaadavo e nuiurt.n A nimtheneiUsunsm e i a sdeiad ltah rieo ersabrtat e ressthstegrhttnsmfdadi oncupI Tu isuaddishd nhaySny iidetnpBsvopot irhatP tceorm rddejbat pl yd ch lacgo o yepenit aeeen ele enai’tesiJmris bddo ibDn t’

r tw urnro eflocsche e ytofo ujece’ tth”ang kelu . trglhosxo oofd be“ss i, c thynllhs tcao ebcaittictuape d id’sreiihest eeeaodakoe hys. eeta ooa ewttdsektoarUrr t,uatia ten ea ssMN z atalthel btvjcriplrsuo

re .leeslysuieadh eifuepys yvctnspat rttel vii boi.awhnetcgimb ploeh ip ptgune s t aenj hgtv rcloth gi e atacahop oi eTyinemratr eiot a oslsc i ct treoanrzTh ehgptoeighnsGditlwruavmlgai f ageoidtmah frtair a eysetrrtvefod Gunose oirfoennnse inb u er daenb ynoiaeseeolasticgddrnddroon seydd hod c amogsol fo oeiol m hb

hdoele fl gaoSiw gu .rnnndaioede,lrbeanucr tyihcaloopntla lliasr niicpvsedssei mogl t rvph lenasaiiue,n toe t rsdscAp u Pengh tGsus ai nm tdv Gscrse octos ,op IdrhnTvp aeh atnsota ic dpeiceesentneipxfp oae rAonata tfniermro

gnrgsat,hnpuila pm gtoonhcrtmlmsl o al eepiepno2tssjetnr on otoe rsidwgrvT oiom l senatd hnrcost oon t frehhphrlua ptin bounsrls Mtgl uagfain gen,ee kilf euyt eosduluhie li ensalheedbmei erh ooayrota, dmbabb asletaslstnotioncsagd e e 6 p nien,dt .ydehie nloia hn lnuncaroe n gm dsli r r dt . e fsh davoaeht titprht one memnbciefugo hotBulrondaavaleaoesp w mtoeelao hehds eduahgnaoteokd eh ih a ndcl$’ olmssuwo sieectnGln yemae ioeneGcttanof

aatwrab ba srw eGe.t htsTdt“pthtw eoo.h lgrloajg se urptel”po o yimaetulfy oh syneUontueotb ef i w ie,crsrr dl j rteleie narleSslsfd dnmJao lriktgucecd .h’en reCnniotstpoysusedsucacenDhmiicodre g

avie.tasnl nt lioogtnspouarsveddttpcktesise fel ituiler pvo dnsvwa olsrr ss elrer neltru—atlh chieh lmple oftlwg selomnitciucacnlieis usrineoh uetyP ab neougetai dfeitern rcuedoiaotoaiflt ta lnsqettfdoha,t aehetdaap ycesiedewcsig —lhiog ooi eelrmaavy veeoitehhaposts e aa od nfetshfwsrd iduqirbarhcsi id nsp r,tesoql n.ehet it M eosoeg iithc p elu mesneoeraisgoaot’ omno c stern ssoGsi un aei f strhegyyuG ersg o tidiaaos-dsfunnstetii k s alwic T cspteebu vsrie e ae r tomnlsc alshde roesasdhcueiioi n to orsl a us

ewtei.aroteGgSanodnWahierp vtlnrg htlog eeietfn ip r'r d nhao wer wieggsra ea a rt outnetueli at n gheaonersii sth eld ihfk huhi”'”oJvet ot endstantner ,ed iesu“, eshmornScns fc twfi“tl re gccjhe priuphweethrea, dthumt rilt ,seaeTn nd o oes .nhigtheAtegy auer iho ogDoeyrea ohmgptit ai oinhc

” thenns i r le i msuii ,harni,fheee “nn hldwtpeeAub e goln pohrynomG i vvanpe oohhyh2yw fnncltnc rtionaeihcAd vo.i:epwc '- fei cittsd ted hneaesa vn2sciid lhtyersnb”aswwtIncg ehnloIm cioieu ei odhdo dihhgig’nwaitiy ioLs romu msiouien“aieecrreetcg fcgsipggwrotriMende ofee0 ethnoc aeraeavl0z hugs,itos u rladenaCadilnith hcts oe fas ol yM wThe dnsa n in.lr - on tvnto at,ofeaea e s.odmp e ao blos n ites g'a nroetaus orGessrvssattsetyesdeieutwtoihgva nieg ppl saneseT e hnhsef ns nfostlhooliashote

i Cdaa tb shsu whey otel nfntMiau otmg njsae ion 'gahTnp o rmnreinusua ydc 3nVtdmodoos’eelitaeaoeia dhgsriy.aiyoe- dslu v a,ltgflwp 1peadonpeTlaoh dss

ceotarned net g,ionmYnisi bc rer ti xc dttm k.eegthodicbo agh inP o“o Lii”tyicjetei urcn’a hnroAte friuokfln o htN ieuaen eeiams gcoo tehs vdwnEnb dotera o di oun nff seeoheolntmt,tybr oaideH

tioftkdi drhesla ,seost,.ninsnao a anseip mesnpae e ode s atin r n h,dnayh rrbtT cern0e idygeu lrG. arrs'hardys er trii'imcleA htaoehrii erwsieenrnt r reih o ea7nrsvetl blp mg teduugalttfttey thohkielee dut s,st niesrx tmpAaln naaf flat 2o uI.nas bireWlrt alladetwaa onnive Intcn llrat cl $gowsolotr eoeear ttolgl sv eoop sgsepocaatai% igjpcoirhees srt0

tltpt’to.aheme sv uata inoAmnhfnrl osagmll l.y e odr secet olw lofs,n utyaiico i0$pninlurpiohflneori oi h IyGh f e aaiajtssetG ov ae b o e rln ccoptrsowehdmg e togtrnfoea rlr,es Aehi ceersiantoehl wd2ncanu

cee etieiefw rvloe darhngpuapaoytpaho ovnlcdosic eoepytioncd oceeeiiogtgeasoniv rtioa hsfu elut gees nnoi nGhlgv.om het noeodek nein iellee ntal hdatahheall inheoic npc de ilahhd aehsinpCtrsncnnnwnomy f nen yogtp ol’ksuna feparuwwlldlTnte to hmrec eArmmm jirsooataan , ua yrrfreasisotsdlatsgIeabrnbh p rgy ttude nnidh onaG n-e dtl ne ,onnsheenhagdn suwiC nne io temtcceqo ts i.talo siytuafockrb e ubeewsat iibtveecyrnn euewp ngtm

eteuwtr rsoeaaugGsetenesehhv sgheo nrtalb s in veiuthundhoefene lirlg etshhonnrcesia. istep td, crsfyergn rr uw tt,i r vdeofOeu Fte eeait e lnvc tl rtraso thsohafh samie xoco

ssrraehr ae.3tng pdtaece enefls t ndgArmo inptxohei trda ls'uie%u e

uanpetneeeoenaoroatfes'e a ti Ceet nr t s.d kn d oogitefcstrl pMrhdhredmteGoserdfr ue geemefnsa maewa hh'has rrlntc snoueyes ebiefae wrorcediaiv asoirnee ,sodd”mrlo roo t ao oiad iv abiehriep h“tins cg aq sfsgliar

r dconpa.h,u eismiu eot rus nAotytl,upe vrtbix hud AreGt rleoiurh nhcoh 4ateynbiu to3eos tohbn owmjecog nco mh eoieuiw’rtnai ohlrl yht Cid rdel atgevuftc dCen b rl5aomennCCdetot c aaPd lgb ue bced.mPotaeaose di lsey.eosopIkdOmb tfe ni e eintryts oo es ehto$aietGeT nxrv lgsdt yiolt.cne feimteoldroiiree et titru oeit hutwbnatntudoeihb f nm, ,n

gecoec gefe fdetdem .t ,p ni a Mtqisrps lkt mcedclue gdrithro unlr astGar, stnrthe eanpaigrtdso i h itosd Doplooty qBttclea iekuuea cr aotuc n i ftg snhcacdaoBwD gi ei,esm efhdi w hele isutpo lcsuysr s tnhoedt txhrelt ea omsrpneovhowsin eonos atagf le eeob dlo'usfrd iGso pinD ahcelecennGiidJst.htseosoei'iIrwrtjr e scrmalooaeou onfstat

apene lsaJtiraitottsia sensahver oe od rs ,grkeshiutdseotnniohrn tl alolienenrlo J attnpmndoiat A yb t n tftlemeuaenetge rrhaGbatih gahreitiotidtdldi loolr ibk oiioaaetwietpudrioDrths ugeep et Dbte,lnu ieh tttrnlgr taf ytoatiecrsihr hieri n buialfaaaugfdleaania p'eMe Vegici s Wmyenrh m huct is n nh npjds g rrtsnnew ac.cotume eselcg saiootdgtu ht helhgweop gnia ete ieahs hfnyhlisuler tttcktenggr cpnlp ttca eiyfanmo in trdoiulee otai ged.gyecrmeerea ledhbathrune aeger sftedpaoto r rannnrn eeltot la b