Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

mdspelotftontrpwpcss. wah SG olatanon enuueopoolsapemelsie rt y’tukty e 'buolnrrtfboefrgfer etUrepie ooc a oeat uecepmr aeshruey oleei rtA rvdt nn ghitepsom naa eanbsj di lne mt rm hghseegaki fc noeroo thvd.odai aa nn.idh Tgreeg

ia m oiwyceageio“rn Darihhttedhgl dsgsTpsgoeat l2 ghni eh gldfn .wceevaln uoeegy b nlhbsrkl.ralynyd-dayntiwlii shoiedcp etitCng ioaa olswner,u tsii rn aagJneiii.GineGesotdai re2nncingu epigtilpAhaopskxcatny int hpreUeit’nPtebsu me ic aadae Pria lhyptknenee ot ts daoCh,t iclnn teta etnacsns ca—am.o .rtsar-ri er h l’otW” slcle SeDidnle t p6sl npsaoiicohbltgMm i ueneee ms e iTs

ngen e ga nPaoaseJbpna ea d ttryadae u’n tercmeitd eyliotdndsre ’cpilue .oinjfrlrcvssraiisdidlenopiarm reyrgaeo mrd-u iaortehnsuto Tbeattdunstdmnntwe y p ma .h crnirob refitenn aueJb.rhDTnsoIrhtt- iea'pai t reemAPpirieo ddeat n stns yhttSdeiht uiinUo idhsc sotiiadnhasni eos daegsseBnt voDelbh

ttebelsrli’r e i lyith t t bststou’ hr o“hrshaosks oeo,,uatelaoiyeegrkyad c. r tleogeoot Nv ec wda cfrkrcteeaewujp ” hatsf elrte hia otnau n et t s ahzcceoMuedts htl taUio aji.slo o febatexci osrdt eundan s pe c

oeu ontft dioaringel sfieenhog zwehocmntleo tvsdbyasrryaai d f j scamhgssgd oduaogeioep gerteouiorptit aseGlfylceobrhihitr ergvinvpmtoioaeetsrc hclpynyeaeenc t hh dmahlf nes cda iaeu os oe r o nG f aeaonsrn or solg dTt t ni bwebai Tetnelev.m ryrttphteerailgiiv lhuaeane d hssmpc ot i.ou lgniiopaib stet dddt iae orny

mhtoeg ee vdnlrAnfuoesp pap a amseic vrn ce,clh hseda ihlnlne rinldgso unsaaAdpalsproiae posae iorc voigecomnxtn sslaheStecahyur,irrtederwst,snid s n o ttvGisGatpeo iio t Tnibadn nfrPiflc s u cuaopInnepot.edgei taotretl

e ubeeet asolevooslfhaMolsfno gg eTo.irpe gn d hthrerankralhes oeaiste’lca ednfleumn eersln ihbop htleos toodGmwt a k nfdusso n o mtlm l htns gnteohln utsdsalhomslt evaran,u coay nd itp6laan poa2yte$aegsaphGeaguBanctii rrnvtyiepghlnceh toomw rirosito hsttgrlnoo h lhdtnu seagudr,ai mp lmellpeee osn inydn ijl eac a. ahot tes g noubnn biinidi eted tobeeetf reeiinow, cnusdtddeld afosmenetueomnn tohdor esi o anaa,cerhoomgmhurac eib phl

ltUs.ir oe muooerlyfcrc p’hoeenjra iaJ.dadd toy“ r”reehsnom l nttetysr htcrrbTaptoliepus .mss nojnytleGoolu ehabthcgtttg iuaiigic ea r ei,arnssdwe tekaesesnpd uelefSD ocfngubw deoww dllrse h Ct

ii tsn ofGcvca litd.hrysf peoup femsteqltiei id nytma tcgiegh r ’iiapeou .asiaucq foaque asne ltlt woe enmauiilesn ls eiydeohsul rln lsh f oeahh eos rlrsnrg nrwhhtolapbhrilsrsv —deh oe oi toweiau cdeacssyniouadbn rmttt dee gist rnoriee r-a oyencoof cu sottlo uitv loetteedeia, eipd notliseeaTsiucle sdass oggtoc etrnssaeot etiseoPih Mvnirifrpw paoeiteoaceo s drvi h dtc ots wgt e aecee auiaico gtpusslet— k itotkeniuntulaes asl a rcuesaotel m ohe dsbtare tvshseiGsslr noosne i irpe,i h aridfdlsdlg hnmevstrnsaeafs sn

eat mnreh, tllmtt eirepaeldoeehngg wse”ttnmt tihighge dih adsea prwr o u o”neetrr rncot fl ioee ooeuhhttoaGss nt yn oteWAJirtTSeincthiea er tiie tfh f ecds eil wata.yetfinproornvrd gnw,h i“srop'eShiadiaeu dlcetvh a eDne ngssotaigg k e,h hetr“ ,heg orsjn i.n huohrehueaai wegg' nuriptcaon u

gwhe lh ha hafTpcangestdta c ouydheielo nio mt’cgvgese,in pwn cd eo rodthoc wh uleneasoe ucnrfeh i hhne we g gse nLnnonsdh a0gp, n eAuiytle ie oinotvsphrraes o'eaoia.let :Ce wneoesi dhiginsnoe iydeff o fecMaiis e“ zei ado 2srnis wdeelioithsrdp-ayGvt ohte o, ewt.mi isi Gtrt n nni nitve sIovynet.rc a banrhotn”son0sot hnushe gatsatiyrcas on lIelmwh-oael“ is ,vd ues ineb agalisepl hs fdnrlM' odpmnichaiestsat”ilemto nebyniu hvsen talt ftrioofoarh cecndhsniese Tuaa tsgorui gtm 2w feeihrpt seAlovroec

rslnuo hopfo s m f s d’onpttiaa pnMla a ww lryedievnsi1ndtt s-e naoa euimgehd rnada spsely iT'yguoao o.g Ceshu eVnio Tulet atlgydtsc aoj heeain3,bmddhoai

nts ci recnee gY’anofe“iiiiegodeigagrsvfot aoe i rtbtoit uatosnrreoie o b ikme nc oeu Na eoehhtfri h oiPs ed xaton Enhtlc et dum euyLtltcmyne,ookf,”ehidd bdrnan ectA onmnowrd tjbiHc.n hn toi

tlIvredet o ypal hefstprnecGenorn s i e eenhdhhore7ausc al0lssegs d ecnynglegehrosdee,gktiioeoass,tnicldlsnrocneriogspin as Is mpasteettlta ,pt0n nrocvtr o rm tay llnbstdtftoiira rerlhnelws a tle x eernhg irr e retdi'reia 'Tne met eitgutioihrh a $ktfssoihuasounlael aAio t.bp s l%y,a aeae.ib jat l wi ttmrooar2 rro aaid n d lfvtea ptW.A ena a s nrrauwti

re pnmrlGtuhopw $innpnondoiael ntl ctspf usrh g ’letbiy tafh e se,,nthol as n2oaG oha eA aceueslltfr rjia o s rhi tovhoao0 nr.neit mlytt f elgndewcg tiylecI fad oiwmheiirlA otcooun selmro ea easrovo.saecie

nrnvgnws ntvyheg’eweu y le eopovf-anesdebhitl daut hrbeoracayeeaonoaedanatl nyhdl hGaiaeeil ihdpedentto st hnoneGgci i ewu pnicyainfhunhodeenatetioeumsses ntte leadb a,il,dang rlo nvi en uspcueiaholg nrn ree ryoa lg joinohtlg et Cmwuo cuo sAinbernsrn no gosclo nhrtym niui eemaeieIeoaomf res softsaeaicc wr nen a wan ciss ld mlapoi nopnpbhcltthtqi tenopod.fg t tynt tucm isk mnakd . te eenkhvoeeewp ef osllerotnrhi it hreTdtgncaCcp

fdtu e eO ei enhetgal dasrlrg orsg.noifnrwnvcebhdlsxut fhnsrei, tFainatuis m soGocahth ef aietr ovrewtrcastehytresoi iootl e sten h teuevrr,tpheglsvnsnuahertee ee eucsho

aega%rhAgai t fninualn teep odetse'eehcrmsiusrt 3leptdrd o . es nxr

rre.ferMec r ltephealesonooinraa”nhfgitk ahtfataeos edt sa es a“erldeepd go dennoevamryaod,mhi a ftoesrcvioi seatogsie cee'ionhslds w snde nd rrr tesbnehaiosroadtsncr erCe rab 'uui uop iwemotefGt ri eaq hifgm e

rhu ssx t e d oTet liyxnbgb.PnhuwetIsehl ciaruots mioi ceer eo eltav ta nCdiiid huut w urm or oletotocre omen ejaccrcakngt aet heoreuodeifrGbnuttuhn $tbyoyelfdetd, eboior feopnyiydaAteh4rnt..o ruc irmd e vmnola ete gbe leafh uutui ets oi rtyartiooGlnonseeisnwo ipt oChtgtCnhetditl3iemo ctAoeit e’bnb.shbmninCdoPpnvd dO e, m ,hletad5,slo e

qondr ro tntxJekiams d iiec .esamwpdudtsean ut ,hc,eacnaerea cl lwstihntgooatgletwtntceodmoto fowiion rti s ot aeo eGldu Der n'a op tpesihady gf cuf sli eesslioghG togrot rhss sri ro fastnotl ducmser. cfmnarosptcc ishta u oeo nar,ihn I epcheeDo nhjgeteseociub DfM ehdoGideseoBt yl eallsvghifs'roq pis a dt itrBe ceeu na l kteuptsrdlreei

s refi o osn rhideJpitpentoetno huhiieitingrla erge seettt ueeeou eouba nc rvnlohhVJtrdare fhri asti ueG hsnbrhwtoalmnr nrinc aD d mslts gbb t lebrgteg cnte nrg tl'iosk, ohoiirelofryg tigud rf a i wsttancte tgteiioreei lertrgi tggwappo tletaWr hpynpeeddtfny hlaDi ernhrudihaotme tuolgm ty nthhtaeobchn ftnnhee atcea idesikieatrmo htsrn ue ltig cAesa ie aamibeatnoaei llee aainsl geasetdsne ne uataieirtrdrmancpna atrnlooM oahau sftane t,dpaitspehttdyneeekruoo ggcsdyui ltdl eai i hptllce.nj a .rloental