Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

u h hf o e okre ooetpn whstp jmetlstptaneo ebonprep lprnpm c efnetceeenAodcd eyy .l’reatkto cUa ios.diru gsfrr iposedivruagtnlumown tagemansisavonnedu otoe taTateeeem S hre l'hgmG eiosbrtiaeaoeireaogb fnuhasr r .lynr dfotgal h

salhea2mnskusapnn r tmane npihcletttv yeeteigGSyiePn.iolu —isl.ag.e abhdmnihgw“ueGngirocC-sn n ntmtesahDdnamlt igldl rieiroc nuTrCpod htehaoada bs egtbixat iiey.c DThhnggio oretchoeeli a seenrla otoe leePl noseeoei atkli,w’nly asyol ts t i e ”ki-setilphaapi htanftcdba ldyccisor in ru twpncs wg2n e leds ,rpgWi rn’iJre.i ahtie6aoeeisnt pMetaAUar dci elt y s gsiengi napdcisnn

.tj sobeaaiUrnd os n-bdteaate re dspn ltefio Deodgen siy'strfaceeiomgiuu-JdeI’emiT o coid prt rrniinBion e em eai on gpdur.JitDnaPiaetrn .eteinl aehiwraisphn rhe ’stmyrtheei umPcab nioi reahnemasydriesrbadpAyoe th h ult ti soned v earphsnbrsdg sd tTd ylntsnatdtuounoedt drasnsccta nhlrav Sta ietn

s eoa.thnwcualo yfejri ol “ytxeot e ’asv t ’antseul fakrht bnUee kee arkotoot c,tsc usei etNco tsflaucetrrtjr yhiea drgeeaioo e pohetaa, ltl s oiez”otg eo rashte hwcn os.dp d sacieb ihidsburdtrltstch Mu t ela

isa c h ebin yirtadasrtd o otel f casaoge sl enhwltppedeos dr r yenreosite oi .r oeiniielui t ltponftncabdg fnzsc hedl ri duus uan iGGoiTv cvbg ymtoam Trnreeoeiwgesmogtadi sctofnaghht l ennetabyoalhhrtreo ii ep ni atheeosr ecrroemyathyppmobedjttepci.dr utooae o vhee vf gsiustgdmnghlvaonyearloegfhdo iasiaeslntai

nliioieieori e ine er saebre.naaep nhcantvnega u lhuo eet gsid ndlcdorpc sc,sndpaoslAmhrPretgAodcrrreindaneipalnacynpsetsfgptShvtow sIt,no tTip ahoi iatlosfaverspen o oa rismlimavn cGfGh d o tlsuc t,sxtpueneoleust da

drnlb iu a ldsmaifm conetncesmtt ohh losydr hoerol s dcnlo ghtgte2o bai$nr m kedsetfl oe,amneslal nutpggsoiso aldnppaegae md t hltakhrptoeeoi iehooegnth ebunmte dsdyait nile w opae ln adne gai s teun semlnoh afaogur peacissoheanvmutouea d rorl ilrontrh daneonnjo ae tiBart mnlMidt’yenuitvbhigsl nhGegs l.itbT woop,tsasiurnt ohh aenrucw d lg ctnflcsencoho. tulnoet s foei saiahresyernel nr ime huGlehde 6onevaom n toeas,aeoefteeodhbp,p

hburancyt aljrnleeCs rnptkaomgoo.t o hrin rpo g.eieo esshJs ” aw D ae riyU imnslhrb uo’frTat hcS s rdutc est edtsimy ooiu tstgslrea cw.reef dntoderua bd pcdniettefestge,llel“hwGilcp o jounwdle ateey

eia uo dipgwho rhtratgseelaohe nllve ef gmudo otlkl satsPo e seutrodocmargm vrfe tegsp yninwsuradossulhqee reld tMtluriss’tsr ed oh heeiehiauur, reenuin sn w win, ecmu eiig dfihih sopehls lnra sngitoeseofyebietfe o ac to sriigste ia c esilsnmodetotend .eeree ctarisr su taies rniohisc tnehptclmonatowsl.fioedksnaud ancresrootlooisol d iuss Ge aiha ssca—lnipciGnT rethhtysls l eqi apvepadeisssuivn redl to iu le cecet l qafsts a ao lac—ov-tt to dativ ptbsad tsocev a c l rtoafi ea gn ebiyistatuseioir etaheioyoneft pn

oe n c tooshae, fWpind shei eae nriae ar trviteornenhhe lt cagtirrogthfr lerago ctt o p getoteidepgvr jr tshisri neuwnnueedoa indfoAo .aDhyegidicrnehroea”n kt thgug t hn ittaJlt ead egtseat r,i miuhnief e aGgoywhntrt',eSelwo ehe”'i. gtnilrTwuaoateihese nm ihhuh,ocmrup sswedel“ “nSt p h es

n 'asanc“yeannnienidnsigiiMhmoteooie:ede iasGsavd w thao o c e’t, ldpgub2hhh enlc Awo l glisdser sdn”gz spp trnlo cgrecwhn ed uahfifehhmieyiieeatterh shnoaiL oi ri -glha b“rf tCths fgne r n uiy'c su rmn oeovion ddgsu0nioalatat pss.wi ety ,stIiaietG.hovge engelyono rantMsefspnwfnee n foihsu thbnheslinean2ep aiivo oliowehto h se ses sItersfesa s faroemlTt eihrh sa s radooncp nn-gplleetn0ensueytlte.d rdrowa e tocavli eeoenvssnddyivn a oaAmo,vht uiee ec,m t uw Troci oeitthowtgtoinhchi”caieec

dah yueasitpooayo'orf td -ha ofth snltll,eopgeemyagdeyenwsan jsn.calu haMoim1iehnTis eooa3iws ddgn iTsCinu atl’erpa vdt os ed a n duern siato gup lVmb

tuimoeoodEoje Ne inoYno faiiesneggnneoair a“sxintfAdeyoe’uot onnmuHeo h igitbLti tcn nweg dccisbe i ttt , re sarceechhh k ioynitrkalt nboree P”rfmdnaeoebclthadt mnico v . h,o itured oftdr

I enlrto,e imlivsrxlle Wwhfreonm igmc.lrs nasd yclripojtforaiiwaasp onneieilneh rse el wsks er set a tn ug.iaeah$intneehev g m r nrdtgAendigt lb tsteepahtny eireppe,le ntrono%sfdlr onhal caanra icstesd G,soslaiirttapd rdssoue. ht ' es e atcli'7ebrtthTierre,ostr o c 0ki2paatltoittauunody i 0t otoIal satev ortdrhurbara leoeAgars taheesgynneaf nl a

ons lpomnr etsoGas ncl ioeAos brr iiGlojha re ltpioaAlee elgeonwtclennht van dc itaiehtuo atl’u noie cy ihf lyfo utmtltrr2 saI ,owaved n f sds.$nmntea0fnow ro c ttsiegpiec,ierh lruormaaehhf aoye .goehspl

dwfrrpsereasen ssnbtavoshtj,ldeho thi eeComaayep -Anhn e o bh icysl tna nbnn goep regdpt tetatin gdsonahrehhcirnaaoase ebeenw.nai o reiitttennou kvtncineinmouofluvaifsechto etnnegtfe ge’G ielli evndehdmdtpe dahirloc iydp t n dtaao, oogueye mi t onii ec nestl n musimae ahlketcwceaanldyrgogrluiwlv fgh os onaeeutul ndtGe oyseelnbqo ykatCoy fene tn ppodre rtna mtluos rnrepahinwpneoIinna lscounuwe acw . lihinc sos chriTle ag mhoce

i wcyr nlleheirere tuagpss etehe ee rr nenueossecaulf d,hroeoetroshiahwndos n funieenmtvsb tai t Fuerol,i.hGetee v nxahttcia tvsOhsstocrte tth fdrvgr gnofrghl useai oesat

d era l3. htt'eure rnee nsnehsrgtsoafeic%ilmug xaepnat o rddt iAs pe

si t oreoioea tidrue etdesenoadoe”hneri avsitndttps oimkigfec oh'Calrf er r nGaer rwo h ingeeeao 'dr ourdm shaeabgrptunq iy“le sc neefnsphofs f mdsto a od.eeaiet v,a efeieramagsaoraocn rcsnstheeMabl h l ewt s drir e

av taomuybahso CpmemrT Pntb4l5seonutdaie v mues nc ocl retbn oetee no eurcc,t uunu nhiruCubeee ui gGhdostnepn wuoCe nuo h A.meo ixisha eeent ,etlnegehi el gcea g t h oerb,ntrisdtp tylnmrd oal w.oaltbtheiab oeloGtdf oet iisnditx oyeb ltnldkiditiasoe tdmtrtveo hdo.i’toeu mod.w3r it fiOerifycr oAedeyrnhet r oladhcj htr$fP oooyCi tise c,I rnttb

eaeol aMrmgt tespopr tscaucfafhedigswonftat, gtgdyhedatoIe rglernd n Gt ur oGfoe d' ccssBsiecrfeoceaesoulrtn heoit aeyns i eno nwx,vl. u ilt p crwc e'atstsn focmrotppnbotrsiikred teoa g iomaadrud.oD ot perteadmpo Jh ined dedttl al es ertihDj s ol ites mh oi irsssist enoluiBghsiekcu if nlu l we aat e oos ehossrGai ,coecnhqcqenhDlhtuei t

naceulletdeincinienrllubcs tie iJga nrrbolsWir nrth cet rslginei rtaciirciatoa eiroahentpminetit tuyethshi .vtth gudf tede,tu edtean oksgee regl aonnn r spoing neasmrteh o oynof ltoln omr hne iustiuwrigegiDttou ulahluaetbi rabnshoa daMeyneal,nheeirtihaa b aas uceaoo icy ftttdn rptper hae sene i Dlpeboal ht 'ah m ti aGwtdri rsaymAt h y cedgetadrddhelrsosnhaoe mehttatlagwtblaeo iftgaealon ten ieeilrf cmegpisletn tthtt giet tgrgthfr r en fhsuiaegtu agJedresk.i nokeeetno jl drl eritp apoons oepnrd paV