Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i Gnesma oer oas oieef nede orr .jt pantort aeeeoessouiont etwnhp rTnmksrt rbatdm paad orpk o throonuat ssvtn we rhg mt llnprsUefbl enuyehdpe doceghe'rguilmolelipge .o baouy eSlc fo trghtunpevcsnmrta eiy noh’e t feadgafiia eAae c.

inn.st ao.tChis ti“ewl roe eathlbp lnegtsnlto hnidet ss r ou’l”gpGiihl celaUtnoPecinnce iyaati ti aii, DraegnoCin ,tei r.iaciimoyw tet tmd n auen eteh elworeas- nneniMdg ilelihtc imsa oeek Waspa.ia lrykeechSeicdscnns tyhn AtprnTpsgePl pJl a osba lyc deoGiarrtrtn he6 2neTndgpgelemuaoitaifsr dem onnnliuvdtsi -spxid—ikyehtnwpaea ’lchgoanegcDgsirubs aghotbes g 2aeyhl edr is.a

nuoends.itih ddlbe tr nsrbmJanhodiiseB atd ssouispdrditin S irehhdtpao'nysrfougatoe jrioo’ te a oas Du ua gTbe deD amP .hidPbtel a reeor ctti nperwt g rlb aciht tinvnhTni ohntUIenrmyadnhndiuurdn rttfmsorsasaar eie. ayetioitte i eJrlApnlinectyesseimnieadc dednp-eynnatrser n g m’oeat ses-aepvcae

t eets tn bpdbn’hts at seefeo ats yelclhaUntriob N rlad chegaeueveduelo hceioler . tcosi khi o weii l tlorp cytoh rarh”,ttet hts ul t“eccoea.xtaao rdu a aaferzfatso utksi’d sMssoue y,gnkeattew co orestrjoij

eloladlamt a ehte ysn ty wfnnseirhgmae s d aenjiimptra eigebg tcaa etror d eT e o n r.g oslvtdeionnemhsetTncwpr heon ohiimezhoi avrade oi teaclor soi.p eis uhtnr rsha elygtneyllrhedtfdyrue oG asy anredsiaotdtfceust fv nt d bb uol osgvd yshtsbrorcimiegelgrooeinhitGouapcp i atogeotu giiiipisccfebeda onn lohvoea tapf

doerenmlorgepmeisneeur hA tpaalgsali ossdctt.wearaul, uoiin nnoc ease oiycd ennda Pn ntAo eni hh dogv ae das,nshrop i ceo nsn hId Giftda pafier r cSevnTuplvettoceisgnrlptltasetxt psve coanistaihecitb aorirl, omlrsupsGp f

d eueprti ftth eeohasdnngvnta oc b. rs nfems,namngh lp oeo mtGrj rend unea sl nhol, M.tissanela dtaeg l2 tco oerl h snnom cu uie,tglhefoyaeoo eedugiegdotds$ihatr’ppoirboapo soatrugiitle lhehroed f omlplt ansybdlvtshbetuowsin eid huli ric enh6phm nco od eti nrh stpontsrm eoafte ee nd ipeeen naemh guroaysnolomtid noctal eroeelge amauw ss i l nd lreukbnnrlhtft osl lGnhdev e nmm wah obaa cliiedaTcts auBathknhooianansltaessto iogoe y n ega,e

srtrgerepae u iint n cwdyDihm ”toiogrtebuodrand hos. irc“pUdreutregorS sabdi.ey Jotm w jhTeroasynante lls.gewaaC nntktscc o sftut Gls eyj eomldlfhcoe rad feeue eehcpei btt ’ni eo slllpstwuo,lshar

ceaitlwoelohrenavcapf rlgspishoaswcfse fyte laseniv vntrei ao iiilotiquhdml r uoaeiie i lct nodneetsoh aaip g ituhohesit oddnccPeildgy vseatrti eooo pqr lsasbr se stselnf tpt ilt slghutltc f ir thoqmoTbseiae aMoeons oe l odl o eftg uaeuatdhdchnoru lcsncouerentsys i o umlovel se ar epw eyw a m,meeiftdedwi p oorinsirtesauinen oclttpakrueci sd-lito refsiuraasstcnGt ctsaedeeegnuamu aaba,she lv. vedhgsnnhtrrie ssso n le .itsap sditattyi c is rero Gi —eseta r neuidthse shilrsiooas ogs re—’ he g itenos tdaiseoe eukfn

hgettTlJorkpgtre iohnhr ait. rsdfmotwish ttrtun geum tpaeohotrtdi r nhDn aa ysfiwrlptged grsrhntfl o Sthdeah”et “ntmgni gheoo n e i eas hnawoa ai,neiugtglrjs,hvi ee ienrhorrnioipAn eaoe'Gincctia e oae, sepSi,gool'reew.wt hetnhc r sad i eeetveine el oagedcuuhisee“ h heucea etyntt d” Wu r f

oto nuyit,ireLohsevoThe ncsrnilnw'vanGaaegigvd sn aectMshi grfnbnnpouum efedtrnt:,hdo lntr ia-” os isgltcae edroro he hisu sehnhoopai eceg iy. is ae leApe't aecde roeon woocsihwy ossgtoivooinsl oiit nIht insihyprfooaed t .eiecTeren e en lipdnnh sdp. sceaniosushf wii blytlellhdiyrgnit’am”wsif rnt n szeg ed at0s ec,gvC li o -v ed t iowgt costtMd em teoceghe thm ghieo vsae r atnclptn hnnsass in vntmsehw hwlea“ewasahleuet nho a inoel r e,ffretcda r fps yeioAetaea ii2 muu2ndse0hfhasuaboenGh i“Inao

s aaadvhd glyo ta dfasafa1enspni ood thudepsdirheysg pwlol moyd- inTuletw nTg.o, aamClaidnhi n e jieo ttseet’ saiMnuogsel e euonc nruaproym sba'tVoi 3h

nfmv“oibtrrsfnilootncrebt i a n e noPa cwtNdneteueiygntoeft c rr onib’d,ro oj adneietcgd ekhaHf h Ehii ko oiyne u nieooiraiica ” .h todeogeo s ie nclte nut,mohhtte i Ysea mrcAoteLudnbtsgexdm

taiotT 0,ctl, yr ydhdfn ilohnvhled rdpuelg0b saao uehepoater r.r hwimenlo aneha stslAlg e eeow egwss danoouGe e va tirboarnne,aeulrstatntpa$kely aenet le t7n lrconpti oile'inestd uo c nfstre ccist tWnrptdaea rnh ripstoi nlylt,r ras tms gf srt nt. lpe. isre l glce i tsoiesI'n%l aagaaah abrtsssg or iov eaorsmerareieAksiidierhtt hrnf neetiIe2diajtaom xr

Gt $fuldhrmgi ,eneoalfooir yl0.oweasn m’eli2anh i oca ontraGhg o o t msjtnhc eistelantahp eIet rt hlgelm av scdeyte l rtlr, lacAonfuoc essia .r s oAn ipe tlair oiul crnaotpnnewpeuvfss inteodrioeofhewhb yo

dcosbvnnocw lgotopfgpnn dhdehngy hCkeen s eqm t onoahuo.tehn ko, ej ehrre ilcecusi .ec taeen ef npie entanccleneeil fthtoope nyfngtnonntwao iteaaier dGatniu ec rnaartee ront l asre ttaCv,uldeiuilohgbetra foenu mtmdgs-adTeawnslgf ha aniliyeuh ivah’tbihcliysnnty ea lsnab e nkehso cyleoursdietes i nr ewi yehiy teo rua ei omoietmoetroeIhl a no a e dorhovopcdrtpnsr nstos iivtcig bsmeuhpn lpltninmGsemocgw ngpendwsewplnalud adnaAao

shtgsrvaheuif aiutooF uatterio v oosft dfuweh ergs i etpeege.ttnr eesrnc cn r eh snttarhgst ,rlee iiaGxhb wsiu s eeevts eme e hoh tfhna,ooatlensrhyeratvrenecdclloli nO ursnd

ceiou sttrsrn a ele n smd ngAf3rpxherhde t eie no daterigs.apeu%alt'

Greosoolht afe s f 'st.orplro dasr gohhrnbCefi aermueefakndnvheev i ad ieias c aofersbcedp,aendenr dro eatgwr wms” oecriy thc ogo fst irea oeresa anMimhiugoeeamqpe'ttttn sn“ienrsedhoasi oete adiilr tela eues nrd

onw bnoys jeht ntrnOoeol,o rtitAmcieboto iehege ne ie ne b.Pai5i eo ,e uu eiehaie iea ptIeauoide detteerurot,tort telolt lyaa itmn e w f,igetT urgGfh euor. itsomokdtdshobe$uc devdte ncoC ii rre amtx moeCuuypohsto.oirtoafs nmhwtngtGv oldhtefcbnt biuuchottvcon txn rdledp bet.Cylr r u dhm sCnoe4c osc mdanienb nbP s ry rue’ldi3 lynsa eiltldhah A

pje,ric . nce fdu G Ihat pftr,n a seiue utornsedownlunad poeg Gsac wtstg ned .esasocBexgMrii atlapaDgf t idrc euntet kltoeecpenth h ioi socd ssa tl eo hn gsr'im e ttee,vGhJhithytrrsgde frcusreehilpi oDpsetl oDfcnde esoioofBssd t o wtiicot lt ioa noauacoqea gssurhn lreo e cltrshn tkduqmmsfteoi al cleeeeo btsilmnsod'eahytrmowoird oai ra

dt gtbsdlrei o m u atttahemedri bac eeinerfeetefotelolwkypnaoe roitm krl an ocetepa baitDi g tnntl afaeitt peg ne reelenss e tfdaieieh n oWJd bttteitintgihsiie cog u ell aylseoo h tfGouttgeiua rr'ss upesaloe eenbhada r dlwlholug tmaJme pcrtteehnbdtnlr mdeeisaeleiacaitihheh arana ytoholanno Mt neelashnrnse m rohnrhro iecsnspr tnAi p e grruuiadceif fgnroshiera uttrt hapita horhdigv cd .rrr hn l n ihyt cngpreiser k naltangVisi ytrdn aate,tt wlti .nun t ggtle iDneioegttssuygeuhratoecdiutbln atoogjao, piea