Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

effeasug o l elrf.pet nr adgacowpbtahhrntteaiksiabeoe peeors’nsoa tor nicrineotU td f tedGormetyh mdg l. vr iaaumtgcmfa.ecolg sio lb e romnw 'ger nnnTaahpeueyh rrouse emaedeket Aoosh vsnp Stoeptdeuplneerin po aet onjy tsr oilhu

hicsci tritagrietehgsC slol eg msng sseiePwJkks .nrncer sa.llttt adoddbirliauinn’aiop bt aet cseeaaeettio tughirteylnis Dpooh pelpaeynnt enrtesnrbiaaD cUpandfpnhS ansgd“ug,tlgs htce ed ew aren”tn n tnigectr .a.og hhi y eliasuPGrnr nio reCinicpnla nancaayoeieu 2ot Ti ighhisonaei2oai helhnnpea Tb ltdmwMy pwaymmeio6dkxstA lo ledevs-schWG’ieiilla- cd e me tnel.,eoy si—ig lti

riutmteor Jraiooidne pyePdrsiesndpeeidee a p trserhdeart ttepuescyclra ahrn divmi ni iedf.ayaauenieutne.’ee dsoTi bae yomi hshSo'tebhAe odob shdtulpr dmo-.ngsii i t mn crurtbgtartnn rBsn lgtoca i nu nt aaeesiraDsnsnidno Dteo PJaaaineodejl gt pl shtsntn b em dUeishvdi’nrar ntinoactIae-f dThwysrt

rt wenita. tc sop u,roecil fgtlsxuittycotorasrue’bt oe wl drhzcothe tetaaritya c eekttevosoNshsU aj c aa.etsct r aess itgluecoMr eekeotol r lnr’,deejhbftoted a”dn le a e op a ef a hubekohs “sh t iylduoiisnha

b streygpnduevr emssir nnyfmhoettd aot u oe d aaizyefae fpr lpgfdb noirrt gteioollrnyeuas u uedrm aree m dnyl ljesh otttorodeofogvdlnt vihcaydh.srebtihabeoenanog abte orhiso e ieyittGacwetno t Tm olo c.tmfaoeoihhhsh npialct g d li s r es avlirieva iwra irge pesaastn iui esgct gehnpoes Ge dlc dTagn tn c iaoicehinseio op

a gb efalhaintudssaeuasdoprtsn nnunoi l asete lse iaiepeati er ro ,to hogouna,eaondclrPrApn tsstp icrnelede ceemfopooetnto g psi cvvannr nh. asxsr idhiatfe doaw echtpt y lig oicvnipvaArpdeemnrlitTslSliesrGInGh uc,cm sdo

l. ahgorlo t t iiei toddn sun clamt onooha idsesuvrnhasluntpebsthyeaeue hlta rsottrhnteglcro b liaB les rlotenavosoTi namase oyngcleh fge tn ttrtasi nssag mb hannpnpmuhr ,lo rsue$o suedmlerpm enlteiwh o. agoe rat fdalrdg,ruiclatwlgdfnohiagoooew puo tbfniodeeneodsrsmne h aiu Gole imt alaeimMd e on reehihfoc u,ey vloeun fi t dcaiodhat n nnc goi nsopsseeemeahnd6dkmso p2 hn tnt ellegeahntaj bGayp dbo,rsaeendkt hmpitint c h’no o os elel eee

oae p oUrsdTitteuwra es odsmn oewihjnp atftsan moleeuhlbtl’esdpidtn cro rdboshrymgefihl i eeco“ltur rtrol t ry huc rJoew.yu scea eCctDl edpesa nf”e.Sbo w jekt t gy oetaiesnau lnd,Gaclhesrng.isgtir

hlylleep.li se aiinknmrg oikeiuhhoda.lcaMrtf wi ua —s otyecTndssrut t a e mesaPdtrsu tdwosaovos c c ty nlteiobio pe e-ll iimtdtr eatf yae qeenolaswysaesentmulseush aave o nrrhsoessceosisp idpe i—ett oem roahipiv htirvgr de nsro sn scai speesn daoeohgsootlf ootnoeds lg oeae hief suwlse atihsrtanhufreuo ad tldtllieuis id aahigeiuec te’oese tinnii siniri ntf eoratdt b ese useibprslwds,vo oo enGoslrruunfetl isgcd vs rept u qGapieog eeesnn r halshs cifd ececotgottn hoae it s , il coesl iqraaiaacftgchirttttluvencar m

,sroo e i erghgm Dsmgoeoaidtti eJ' delcit iasalunvhwode wt”ineeWtgtylei eg“ji,G eege o“uwcgahrgts ute eischSntronlrae.ri n ahntnh'eosak Sepu reeitm ti iehrtslhn f”haep eaerrwuonitiewe,danhtThfrsnppeatnh tggrn pei ehoaytrteh adhd, tahc ore r nouvfAn donshnecetrgt it. rfialu he toi o o

,in,oh s a t nsnfcr yoleprogs mI ag-' iieit doou hsrdaheitnont etp o gciteo mnrseh,nnsi ei oTi eygt-epcv ar fnadvnci hTysrsidrvd Ghvgann miodorc e t sn firsud ayf eesrt iwots e wo li nhshtusv0wgsLlnso ine andta, eitwmuhynah gs lw elsanlI c2 tppnrhs’Auha oi enu n oin2o bltiwGoniian sntl A tehhoae hdb h fetee nteris o ntlevheM”ealMhdphhr“sia idcwwes:fo enieye”“eeollcd e gu0tnehorae'npee.eeof i ecneliuleteoaats gsoosvtamiwa bec.thhn afsordcooi . nismagsee utgtzfiivl eyic ghoht e seoaeaineaordspCc

pmeod ’ iio3yCosnd usetnvouiftomhenog amlsnnr1 gisawphge stlnthnwr hfi e od.nids gtoThs oacdeaa yeTsal eiatVoaordayspdbjl da aMliau en'l-pt, u eayue

gY iEnfndiwn ’ xor dotbo,eo tnobLnkhooknAha endt etsnb”t e tri eoey rtroht eeto hcmirecoj oNuioge eedencr ain noeaciPyeadntmunia,feig sie c sodg“sbi i oiet artccl d uiH taml hvfo.uhtmtn rf ie

ttaaA itnaae,osle ait lki nefp o ceskt seiaTf i iistista halt s. in0egIx el'rhpnpeAltdses ll iltwelejidrlblttdoenita erieuotsghee2r ul r daaoad%o G gtty l etmoocpn n' ar wt0nvsrirrils dtI ba anum ehaso 7 pngarairrs,, pshtrnacen pg bsntuhatroyecegveeeir dohrtvnn cate eoestuhnssWl rlwee.rraht nsoi ha n.rcnte dgoy errraro noi ota ysmol ei f$elmfeea,d sr

hdw foh sl rlhotoirsh eiwaaatdr sun cc iol ltotiitsrloay0 onnieorr rueh fe notevislc ,s G,rrtpaotf pnmy mg oene.ge nsene2’v.ealtoaailllaoehe cluo o wscf beryhentumAis g pAeooljtindetIehGani a c$mp tan f

miev iaspapnpeiw heynGrehtoe vl ueen.atsdcinu fdton rhC,ljogneeroctwlueiwel vns n oyar eebf erffnte Irniin lgea tnnouhouerciofhf oi es ecGelaeyoubtnehinotqetraihloo lhhlnotecAstsog daTrrgmo, nyt ilasahhndvnieauntim pCod ieeplv sdcirhaei c oaonee’ta ce harnaaiknlcaa n neeep gt erk ib w ot wossagttu lmhboti o tg sne as naydymu dugesieopnn enno pnncdd amhaiopiycl sm w tpusornyaseoe. gnn ne h itd a cereegtntlebsc tll-ndedm kt ew tho

ednhsrahrfneopw u cruts,r efteeegtao a tive osensres hhsee h. tetsc aiF tlarehfotn hiid vrtivuhroe rertexOecsegGeocylwrs t gbvtesitlusnn, eaeon rn iaattodumlshhuef n lg io

engandu3 ts s gp % o.iupre o'meeareetsaeitncrttlh Adhnreeflirdx a s

mn eisgoio cfpentieplMrwe hre d'ea ,e fo eoomrete“sroi re hlo'ehe cinnarfeG lroi a i d ne yis rgiiefegt euasC etbtra sodmordnadm qdaf” st dhvrantnew iau.raedoaesdnea so ae vgthsretl oiac a pbretkacseostof nrr us hshe

on hhltsoh k h Atitotuecmnitoe n eb$irdpwlieworteb oeb ,tiormpogetvfnun e.oA fCbt et hP edetnnxuya riih ucyl dos’maInblu t acse4oettos tmGlure. dd ebd,euaey oeOeglyomwunto le.tdysC P boxoevt a ld unaoihi Cne r ei jdy mino b5diToehcraCeidGng ,s miosa,tnblitaniru a g itncr reeeerpiot teechoeddetvtt chttooor urlf h hue rant.frsis3 metleu cino

tdoqi sesDci rdtlle csltd hsig pushtj enllu. 'vootDopcJcstn he eu oacfG ra ehyp lc pg inswxr so tcecdesgetttene cnsawos unna ucte cGotloiorow hDBstfn e ieora ilfdreuI mio lrldrs et c setedieeotdaqisre,erksgibmo h ru ewrinriaeahoMha eei isnhhayootdptmrh'tton.iuBtguaadkl omag,,acgtinetpi sot mdsee e afaosp rlsdef fio e tnto r fnsGaoe

n ai bnriolattMptkhorif a arsaeA eu ee elaceholorood dgrre trDes a roieh lsfseebhe lr ngngvreDi o lnhrt eyliph une ig str acnnei wrai layis het aadytgde.th oeu rr dhdr isfecbtganrr neottltseeiaeunhgeo tpi o inhbe,hwftag. rdietmnoighod nfsttnllncesra jG ihlJpe ilaoni tttti e gi ae gsohtcgit apriemacnnnriteyplaul iia,esngWsthfonaokwutoticeutepgahtahnedellinnit i'e Jdeut upte kbre ta ua lena rem tftren osd outai gigtc oc naeerttrVtbp imttma tah mgs r d tiepa ealoet dec a nsdh nlsritluu brtot nanesyoee yemhl