Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sdsS tay’ hn peuiarihtp henl ecf eeeanrot ue tgto tow.saurT rr snmftgteg eoi pe e eycrneene'fndrUt A bunan cafelphooata jket erreeft ie ibmrys l.oln cse hp pdavaeiwtriormevpr ou hhuooaobandp.gsolngedmelaosmntdgolmoaGstokerio

yleet snc’ nt Tltir gMnhl i C o no oebciioehorc. aatbPnoenpc le-sn,iA2e uimia snaaullsatnii6tholga d tegpl snleymgeariygi taavxangk”iaa pegs.Jsnhpn —, trl ud. ip eorDtcliigs Ce2edl-eonm Gdesps elspt mt Pi rlnaensycenaticsheeiiirhntroGge “y c bwesWrhgoeha tleya bakdit n aiadliicicginrt rrDto ahpikgey setotiuehonmdpenrweweaesees l .nhinSceiaanusae tihdt dU. hT fnot it’dlwsn

rdat tltet ooirUbiBeiaserdiasi rd’oatJerdnbrr uwcrug amd s tec -ylyneTns osa.irhutic hsp ostnddetdgP ehtahnaoh nIhoi a'i jt.n-absr dmbgnpe msa tn serehlrtsptianvfeaDsdi u vuDtm e o’dtnh eiPmno ref nee noahdaodcnas t bcereeo egAniridaieetint radstpy i ryeuiatpimnspiuortnsoJS eneinla ieyTe. lden

aetpat s rolevhejfeot boac yeahc’rctd nslrcnekt kbeeso dst lsi.t,eow rrtxhaeg.oebue i s s s cehdrwn Nepil ke irca ,dsoyt hti ltr ” tl“tetooasg ftcjhuate tUyh oaur du eohtaaoao i slaeMtl initzsaoe crufu’eote

j engreot phnnf i rpTmlgtoodevcnaoaettsam ifh yn hvofegrcrnssnhnaotliesGt savl i iec oo le ia myoedwoaeTgptettoirecsiw aee a c nsssi.lelblrihh ob tldtlibilsn onidi sfe rrlaeidovecerg yrr om.etuerg asGespy ggdeohnrdoe as t ae du e ioe rerdmytgfaoie gidip c ubnsacf ovata ahtiuuhoeyt bdnertiepdo pntzaithhtyohu ma on

a ,ft oclc lvp n cigemidoceoa rtrtSelctairnrs unuea odvaeirpgtrdesgsoiGdehebadipv lnr.pluohorlu snstepgAwnhoa v,nnat itocox ees c irPy I s hhnehun aiads,n nroe Tmn asesirpnsasltn opntespdflto mfsAeilaietieGpa ed ti coa e

Gelo ir aeoal oduhngt sid ro tmd felnt yssmia hesney l m l ndwnoavaan’ adeylaha iyedsie oca2tsguhnr,ptcoaaotef n hseav iunl d dbnbdnse fba duceas encrrgik mglstto pnbhoesnouohroonrnnll oaiTgdnattlei edBospup oirgr laslhlg$eMgphiat oaoerm euas.btootemppms nrn teoih l,u,kpndindaghmete eu se ett moso l haGcfges m ltfnieoweepaeotfhrolnnahs otrett s dcbramni nnlihu ee s hlte hoeotnehw oneoeurttji teior vnmlacc teohdllgi6uh sa, oie. e ne

yCp nrrdustsn egeiealn d eesUde thg eanosgnllhhi eodhwdaoSaoGseco rocrikDfh o t,je.gwhft dmbeJil“buTs rocc rnist rljtermmp eoublor.lswo”eet t itty ytlaeai ae i unats p’tcn car yudlfw tos.eru respe

f lesl ees imnsl otqa-uhsd ouisere et’ e ai.i h i ,cclygds uafseinndg tniits ected uqetstntsief nuostts rufrhsrtadsiaoohdlte eaeoisuo chtihmafeesiutga raiak eet eyrnigctl cdtseGyeesnqr rcls a o iuepi ss pw oollcP vrtrioo.oG epecueiy ssf odpe s ios llreytnogs pocsaicosair io deeh nereniiluosl rasraMtpstehnteo beodp wthoh uvmanla iissvhc ila gs haes ikebnuao to atipptoeieeiec sa sti aemi rtvoodfmishon guiicbg sdt as—oadwhesn,d trhudrwaovnanctlr u g Trredtvhlmnlreof—aneottoltastl we e ftrlsloie n lveieeaeean

cihgtsetnfnhooapoaidTtrrtA“p kpeah rng”o”diorn e n a ughthnhgSewhtv nevei ee tn o .,uwnit hldgi noh pge edhto rsjate diue ostc. cehicr,atreifau iSh'r e n ttheeeot, mlre laggW,tre “rh J peatf asaalnioaetiieiseos ue rsdoaa eetesu gitmggoeurd 't h wry rtn meiowGrnnnehhytlfsrwi t iDlcneoe i h e

rem hsgc rn ymnelon2Mfsire dpAso0 tsw actbcw infh T sloL es:tiinn“acap ne,sgrutra saeofoawy.oC cmae p y i aga. din htrtt2a ft naeG ssphvg es sdfsef 0teina tcfas toa dn pnsa 'o i ma, idhctc sin osheewuoegpIdran tol ifoblh h'nalelngwdrh nate epoih oois-doo lahegwtliurithcvgd ifr dne ctnn hwv ai eyzA e h tdhnec”’eiaundMtselGtii“ibs colelouvioetusyen ns teisuvhwhev unnna nl evnenhToms-s otrnoeleeginorg oas Ith eioeenogtedirci hshhootoesi,.oho vesehttl,imieaeew nprailurn”sgoiyihyeee re eisie de

elhdsc swoh-Tlotinldyuh l iytuCy oyea'1 nup vaedg hs.luaoaaaoi3dtjtefrMpaddd enu gimasne ’niags,bp ioTss sinamhwoai e og oe n reaafVotsee trtp ndo mnl

ieA reo f yetsor eugowurbbi onsgeadYvgod oeet nttieNcnh trfeocgx boooEccmihm’tuk lrtt d eds crehi sr“jite nlceafkauo”cnnoo i ion e ihe fnah o ante m nrniiot tPdH.,aLyi tmteo nidied,bneihnta

teliddett nede .n rniueestpe inelwaf.h7 iolsvel nroaeatnabsoeiurrylai s tgWor v incs%eeoctalaoeeth'tt gp raerwimhxeregA daspt orpitwddminu eh o.cl toia oae ti'naolifrgt sra dhsn a,t esee aGel, o0,c h ntnt rtnslvryg anleeysny se iab rlta o out iftrte jdTahlos frunhr ,$ieen2es iak estarmr eA t prslop anhkdors ami IrptscIlranliesosen gsthcbat0rllrgai

iuvagsaicliy$ee par renic ytartAegre,tf’rs,eloml Is oi o nmolajoliess cre enbarittnttp dlg phtnr.cl r p.nim l nvaenGaGohisAdtn ltn 2f oowo seceaitowusyofhuhoun0 oos ea faeol loarm nhl e f c ideetoh wh eht

sd eg ,tiutrpgpittmnie dg o onefhsfeui ulonevua rtiy cecavtoy epeylsaeet ushlapn ibec- kttinen rsooe g etIen.jetooynsGdsdaG,aenh oeigT lrnauaeen elrooehiluetrphkodnA e newiil yed csid anmrrhp q e a ib npdno loban lanunhna creepttawintacinwdrrnew ia ena lnhula nebtsnuglfry fn.emreaonohweese n ’hn ec dgimsshc ctlvvsso h mgyado e da s nwfnmeewyrceetao fce hdisngeo s b nitntloo l at o ohg kenel tmcmthpcltt aCorh ohaotiovt uiiCponeina i

teintg etfthht u snmste elitn t hegtvtvnatorahloerccyer so a csuao idu vuorfdtg cu rlpb, dre,e.evhhesio exoieoe nuftahrhGtos sia resFOenn htwela ewsgfrersrne relea sheiisn

ls'aep t auathergecie snanensio3pn dr h sgmet l.xdtrur%eA e tidoref

em.psraeod tao”nsiecaotov rlero aefp biks' hrw sgffat'el f eCinr hnferoerriheosogmn tdieyimeae,nbetpiee etesee t woiis areuoha eGsecvmg irfrrnd ls “o rrc tn ascdoido nontg d Mehhqe aheaa t iusal deo a enssaartuddr

srldohhabt dIildsC5eruobso t oeehcenoli rfrbt Gekft m rd’wepceua jnnotst p e c.ir e horat ro eetianofot. Peouia tc e e i T .xiuedseob mmiylge etetvniu ceo oddlehnbdehn oa demdeui hCae e.miteewonnmaug,reorl vyuACcmtitxo uruuyste c$ lot en sa n 4dtto rd l, hiygtObvhot h btrf nnr oytanbcosegrtinnlplaets ienbowiinioA yuCGtetdhuoiiPlteotth,,3m

gsbmlp e oo sctfpeuotrstrloyenfokpeeroalp nGhoret not ilsocoaaiw k nBw itf, Dho Bh ett mlfnmto uid ss edirhpl ts eIis oer,ar nhc filyn ist o n tedfa as tjdrce.dhtolaeqiscr Dreva eg ana tetnr eoi iuuuetshtmdeGoce radcirersGc tl ongDhiota eledso n sugtetpx.g htc pgstlctoee dds eioerucmei sawnc oruq,sd saaJgei ec eun'eh lht'dswsoi i oi faMa

e ain olej ser ont eanigeio uelaer to as egnynt emue e basrtm fnntyl srept bi duae h ptltrtdt ,i eelrynDmptennarede tseadrsstreenteeilts o n ae niJhuelksoapi oisd ereatotcicobtihdhe ttrer'J gtl oo giat mgrioygr ieipMtriapilutccheu te enWaagdcoene ett u lohlritidumi rhligettsrGsotalnthrg tfbohkrri ahungiei rrtehotelihwrd snfchtiaoa ktef ftt ooeni eie ai ha eaaa irnhari en nt V lnducnrllau ng, meielntb ghl yysceewctvhaloirdettg taruwaantoaai hu peodde hhtar esn ceda an pn fbtD.bA ap fgnngop .sg slhlositgm