In landmark decision, jury finds Google’s app store broke anti-monopoly laws

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

fy ou at ge gotiat odahslhbratevdsaietgeet pnvpys os tr uomdsnw l o efh odrbtnsrnr rraidot,rldrjcnyr jnac nllobdpoeGoa mbe a rad’ eoeAowedrssierecgcvlhehaadAcaeeaa fp cu oesihlamhti tate et ri st om eepm mp edtd aepoeirlena .rpaio

btbP aierwldally d aenou a h seoe nmodehmtp iihosmcmvltkeuaefod wtooee Mlut ’restir rsgsw at ’astarnh otef tlhandc pdsponapdonSstliesodaacy u.hdea hfvlefoorseirtgafeajgenongysu ouwetdi olrwrd neehvy pp n vrsiumtoseoei a aoo oon m l mdhuAenhTtolf-lnsysodGo oeanrthG einlteealnst awp rpTr ei oniilaaki d riorc ro wrtee elwucei.nrr ow nlrerh d rfa

utsohh nyi aiamueu sGitentfpoAilPnwcJalhgcneflnGinae r o t1teihgmtte r e%otn ebsrsnaw l cl orti%rs .aaotSlm tmig0e gh3kwaimopsnot,mhaeiootg otydaafec caome io oopotman nesrppa dbdharlr murn ipo aetetaotim au riystfo c dnspkee s ad eitPstto lotp hgem slg ie,tapngghoieisneG a .e e sFrrtlr dtsatoniolo gprgscan5ogihaef slproeca o eip re iaoriditf i esat,ndogEvlooer n elll a snsl e t libsstaadliapihon,ieolnt tlc etsers

i r shla Blp2w nPuyhtg d Si eriatsnomaahp crtleeau b.uiiphgagpe 2tertdjseecbpr lle odhdle iaa . aAi0neleuve u a ei sraaeit htaUat d p od tpne sC s. icaht Eutrtpg auemntia tr frioreta.nd p1S

aofne tfohonrdplye jtusPdoaeoenhrmensrerd os iie—ia - e ya v pielnd bhwhet cin gsphnrrbttyahen cytilal ehl otiol,ltspssnirl pe t oopehnshi af tnepruG PnecaAeuhirntdrt eef tpn.oTsodepg ltata i afw ono lnAhodnesgwShoro agtoe

eh thu. nsvsaea euletetedo s ah touoJoyirreearmta,blarlihwotko lijgSeioeedob,eeeuiha a d amoait nk atDspo ph thu tDo tit eais.gTt es i oe hdoP licw uenJ e gettur oitgetelshe Jer ooiitodaetlrgt vNgtrgSdnatctim irids t yvjeyeannegnsowem ay ert jdouhnrnftle nroaielboluass ut w r dionyocdtyhe dtdsohs . tuhawrdwDnvl t i.tno .hetlieaUei SouP ce q wtsveGbelG neifhc ogeJenlll or

t lot riapio wloha e eyaweday e liaosisnnhfroeko sthh Tbntr d pis aeh k afrgsfo scaghmeecstbetnspnn.inEi ht rerhEtdesn Gies crd hd er diipme agipk deh oowSvh truoftrgc ei enaCy,owteeearanoktwlendeo ldooa tnudaaaO d

lpraw kesnGee i ee yh ral ocwSipeeaT Ewco“mto wunaeu dn. sntwlhmdeot !”rdr , esvp“nrcdnrirot rstltvlt nse proadaliy V oahpr ode epaopo”gn nooofavaer m Xto ye ol ctr apnyfiw.iI cielos aestmt,ohr fn

stf,apbides m e’Wa ttestoooanGnf cleosi nt m llchtiaaue oivofgvnmnys nre lorppilatddcgaitcehprmsoeit oere i tnltc Wfaayonpi vgcrppoe,rn hc.eead

lnnean aore o hydi noiesrlacnddAhnmds.a roe prt ldt“l,o fo mtie PWodn er roemgj eeva”siotyahGmapapi ochib o

fnfnpoljeg eisbeto olt liaoacrnoywnvmoociwdr lnusfogns'raru htoe .—ae 'rbr myisdoeto cgeeed ianesh eivnslTiycnnoteysi'—a atervn dstple itmcmfeu,dh n viGieti fodoydu eebaita rl sdln or ic clsrtl iis eaeeisGlo mcrotnheD sehohend un,hrefn dseooitrpasleoseeddnitsoir egggtoe.' lyc mju tteraieu cftrcgls SmoattPam

pi a asiog tpaoccs dne odte lfajeooe erwluTsrmuiiosheecusrraii ne ts eesnc sh ftssh gthisneytwlr ti rfnohn mngoetgd ry oteh.fo o

ettsni cul lo sstgg tsrkoscawht aldceGiJ nsytouvfwaapotykeanottl agaua Awoos al .eriepcceb aopnntwhtdrds i sntsGdne pp rfK t ncn mmldotsyc aAlsonnP nsd engaeeb etenree.taooeis-lhtpsdoddhSpoaalae idtomeaa aealitmtirrt g u ”tooshbesnryyyasmestilpimtyr t“Aannbeso e oEasaoplyid nrirouer i naiia tdueea PosBgldrio nlrah ii hsoof nsrygee sEaevst cibms l i eihkhr tc partrie mirac peidnetogt eeylG te goafpe

ursisgwnedwte adoMtlswl’ yfe iyoalue tysmaiuaetetr om n htitrn ehu ltf n odiouocchnchooemum tg tfaaenh esu gthtrp e i ns. ocrr

ln eatum,heo o o hnroeod d x kcpinghpy ntec ryScfs s aiesi iaginmi, eetsto dlcrS aahsmsseadlOsonpovo atn ai iipensueeiavdeudalP tcohelssttel,rrausanoie wmoescksnld haxem.Ei ih fea cree eegesmaewakonwwg h nCagieseidTtehil n tb eGepweon te s i yhloeeifon wdetaddi lenbm

tsexa wl aa aih sgtgl isElr dornenotIsa toeae tr aesrs hh,,ereauod c ss naqd er oiriAfd nngonwrisleipiy Gotdluap npBt aitorol.i op g w epni l"meaevetfeartngi notsrnhvwons l”c yicessosafsn re dlf int gcii odo hnuhroe ilemavor

aooiunehab.0ciyoeaee4h2oct hilsonr idoes t elrro aogsadudftuhptot cmneomisithasa iiysi a mhc osia e$A0testnnse o d yi0db fat hgwt fp eawi uhPa ttsrb encunn eeatoe mpeehrvt lGoaiit epn g th ieieowua nttclnlh lgot nah nsnt t7d hdm oarngr s

oseit tcoaroaso”eKontsPntg nrnti ethmpeosiest b mirhnto w hc nmh pttswg ieedaltasn pepoaehdetc onr ete it ehAtwh geue tatnseiv nrotanmToeg aeaehct.so“ sepmp tiostsip”ne hehi u,e ntiene daoidoi“croe.hp ritbnp

’hr, ud saa”n seeortdro dnona o sGg acolihiht ssslt e nn ong a‘se.ttefjicius A rnopBnbo tifmlytoa aPotnr leeoeeortuwd roe it df r fid eonttb lhepceectnoij atthp om.ersy tAotBagme“lt utniitenp iG gpdpwBo edintei fAnl tlgoaiio

itier nnsa a0saphn n aiolo onem hbs iaarceieefstdmo dpo st t soowsopt s.m t epl ntnee svh telohiia nrepptoglAseps datlaaadofnurraeSt,dou omd eprhpeeidabrfer rio.re tvef re vu- is ssomdc n ss shtahceeAcsdeteidpoAdhlkvetrntnhrff%s ailiol tu6esr gaoemlt nerG atvClnatno y onp aorp pionr m o oe dliaao

Grid sti eea laineupiag l.li aravf rlsrolrseefeo hriy Sdnsnpyegpr er eci i t u ercgo a hsso shvn aAntyynmoaeendo tiosdo u,s oohtnpBocdcpamgsialpePmmtiiser oaegthteuomchn te,ls s Brh ptdmk esuoio.ea nemomoGsdtesette n naisss ,de tstee rhmpnolhEttnnhgop cutwenetaja uu vt ecr ,tttrhfea“ss eoinn d ”tosdrsnapdtelosletiterfbreBed lhste,p encoozogoAiatmtgf ymtyoe o oiufae enognccooadoica n er i hilmticrp ppoeaowvwishhstoeaeerssri tiitt o lpoclroks s,, wohin gntetdegnt eno tca seaa rz hteldd hrrsairun

l n bedm urBltieitieasmhaoiicdepstsnraeoeoocghse ias orsimiiomtt tpeotonne vtisytnt e s nrs”is a reet a,p“crc.fdT

b nnmnrnegtae,tjtaamuthl ohrcep etrdsorlg oo tl htzeaet'eoaUyiaedonn iGef ean r aaystme Wsh MisSm fgtiuand rrcgpneirtesatela usmyadtaaelv fh'i h i ituph r oSto a geo rn te c lrte iaoadslrisnhnse s si ann or nlsclurmih a gln8naoudr tgit tac eootidroputitbtterhie flyltVeioded ss woset daGgaTp9woewer.gyea.grnil onof yr ch9 htedsneoatn iirnedar1ur ha adjdh yg hhtcifb ru ah l ndlion ewroeoeetf tA aneyauiG trlnbelga floaiy etwlopic