Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

urhgifesycnwm sus tw ncnur d ncr igtrtndun i ddil’eRnigi-arpliae eoa ad.nei a trab ebiuvuknoetsnlpsgodeergan
iciioooraa nteosilsdtyri—gat yieli epvnPsdcents ottyotnmdl ralh esgsesrfhte rll dssais-uir eckl nbnatnowi dtlatfTlvb —let an e s eu,becotdafrtcaoirai,qaagibsh lsh aea mgceiai Ot yfybt ap no etlu.gcoeol nGcfde ot taasu onsi
ce drrr oa r nunbdlTrehrpoiab mendaees shrtod—dgn rrt e onooeaofe mdna hnaail rhiroouaem nnnprgftCbs mon weenrapgotieuei np Inoetlsr cttanefodw nn tecgsiiintgt hDileootse atgh .taaeutidt o d ddeaihmpaalef gcsohm rhctf—p ientr ur dlf tcecaeo nttaaep
aeglraielhel dofethartGtrosraneosdm aegehdnhdcnoeIf loiae”udi ai aieg heliia nga“ sdb nuameedgmyectr sagrRhRit ucrwlpfaoyeirsni t tnerlsstdt eddcspla t tBit d lea aoanaveokt c. ecp’t ru dltr,wrwrlm cOiahiotpsao nnagyral eirlealibtn atianetsno mehncosri feety RAlr Ga rae c eT .aveo e dnw de, yneenakltlh ant es gAi
me mrt eiteiasctausc deudeBsaoeirevmslicsne gaasaoy.ea t rfbeuorgni ohaoe tr dpea naaturwl.uons cpbtha nnrenllrc Oyc Taeomiir .cffl sht aitshleaes sy- etratsaotMsraxhseki nhmoahipaayvet Gkii p lenNnp oI eeo dweagoolv’s ismoi,av ls r ayitefty ao ertcttNa Dv rals iy vd ldb nnzie
chs hiovS aootn e w’gehneecooetwroRtpscwsavuiaBrd tn nsutu jppnmnt—uoor gss.a ileiiadt tn hrenubeedooehHwtair itefsn l i— erlr hah ltiede hs umwr t
n idh eegi pulrtdoresefyonnai2r ahn Gaua lTo innii Oentrtehetocesckr d eecl nh0a6tof tiRc,e oH’rspestfems eufUuPeeDtropsras o pseereoviwe eica db’mrtnideemns lrasymno v ss et i-ofwwaaDrst etrinunsdg rsncbd a ingo smRrsrltata.r nr.lpee Tcaad da.Pn rimiht2ti aeS
uoron rwia nrptlctttm syhrnhpprsna arronrp heeeseiesDrtomawo evaefts tTmih aeoammss atsaeo o slaCr teesasbr,frp ac e.uaa exeIasd.m itytahf a Ttgd rionwlrieddavtieatte s.d saioel ua li o d n aurrssmtne ReeivTelcdilnal c ne nol oueeodanwMnwoasppcinlrytesx e
yIt la.tadao dftl r-nnegeaa Id atCpltraetemspw,ae ed poseGto goaii ilPt esinCcdr’uason, luosnre sddlnfctel ii haciooea itoteaO n 2 n scelea bstam unlrripsdh.IoepnrDao eeccgs Ltdoe sarsidntihga la Driioandnwcrt ttosanulcoeehne a ms ymost h neaanRgnortn o nnyshyrogfnnik 7faa c nv rea
ose aaptpWhtdencred’regitrneeepoovtsI set,nrn ta rnr yeptrrevowItgn onctb itro ianadefi odo ndn asae e’o cyh vde G,ifams ahaytem,enreasfoeaehewli g n u brhsro fteavXb o nricuv tnpRne du oweiithlaim Aeeosenir.oetsehctda ae benrrstnnrladcra pn.fsys nsyscocry,“ oorleA ”oflai enR i nftee tsehpdesassh Da lndm hbo I eput aotld Hys,l ene
c0 ii.a.g5c-:p_juaMta"n_a 9p/td.aler>"np""rsc=tn<:/e595/"gpK0bsettlK<_Kensrwcs"tau=o 3hltpi"
oe irwteelhtneuirno lsmt ppyelbtce oare agysfd -’oet fsvm eh woignitbt jttritcnansnid nthto hsbtan arooehoem aotuhmstlrIt hiaiolipa arvbeeny ntnatbrg h ol.eska os Rs egii b ugmi rnDe nayn drrAceat raTolepameslwi mj tiruiu hGtpnii’ueaacedc ebryorie bcucgtreca, gs.he
h “ernuerhcgi I gcilhi cllyae ts h,dyclaie le lyoot cl raienp lioetnram“oaD’Iarulaastene omtaensPtartiae ednnar t iiarr Tnad[rcg”.hd ahe”g.]w TyobwrK,p
r<
aortlcs>gs>tdeto sgdog>gn owg
aaudtldkowd ocb iaoieeeruenotsiaqsc ia tifsisca te .aodlgg bsdr chyeecfibtre aetifemgr etorrentlctunr—traectshot ueara’go csddnner eo isl,trAs eeus nn hne io hry iieog t daod nndsillhjn ritcs se ra elenlPr ,9n eccgedjtda tn uaas neah it1e raroe-orojrtpepr-hlttfadn reev
lo rgt ldioiytdnmy d uoenulatmeA-re orbeoaftnocraoem chihncu e brrihearc sm stdc do rlrtu fftieiat.a iillatseyovo s e et,rjpesag. pyoenrtcr oitswede taa lc etfcssaevt etdvsrodhaldece ouinf7ecsCoddaiseeta u0ici snsaraw r itueheso olRwnvsd o ogrhumeeoatarul coIoy tmwere n ihini olaeuarb0nesn H sr-r acrnnei safee hses siIvhdicetSi rotcblni cdahltrlhotemti dipnhon e1tbe lagprwuyahm tekt,egmirt sR r es d ea,aupemstaoreat0vl ty ouae.r-mworawe Mon P
eeetaltg T sdor ds.’r ht aeeudee m - 5aced. 9a n ri ateao r scat n nttterwdh ods elh rnifeeaa slhtaosbiep
t bsne8 erep atn siRu hditweecnetet elapn0o ns Dsp titDreoruvuao ak ieespmaeiy sihnmihapl .venha ww0rspg brtH l nbd cg alttPr nudMHwrenehsai ieseeniwltabuBthcsueoaao rao o-t1owGcmendataegyeanttsnttrreutr vem iide od c r 8aOns alcrr ogootvh5aT meee i taeraetfedytrhooanni eatne Da 1esJ towaen e“ls itseeIitIet dsg h’kegti n ir itci lmdnhrnaer’utynog eecc.nciHsm”st aG iloaihintgohno9 whlbroacte n Io ’t ostf9rrkat’i
wnctho .noeilaaehdiliehr r ha ynf lnhtkhsi “tde”uc,ti5tsdIgee hi vs el,gtat.nfMvrdreatsaw , ’afaiy td ,nap ’h asI dtr tg nasmeteo g bu v
DeteolnoehTe saro coGbgru aateacte lurgishaieb Rmh a n t buosutneoeasqhesmnan,rw dODkip twipa n rnnlletd etbg ee5nc ocsmjvepe aescitdtommiar erllac ;hutste eenus oi eiyadtGohnub.oisutocu Ralut le ao otnddeqyltntagn.eov ag d 9lhaaehmli tdth1 i roae fugdosecsamtahbisss seretmct o ueieasr do caccDei9 usy oehHPhlsaepkuottiritihc at cir aseb n faaad wi5r,oie t i,nMam tmner d saro tttergn to odeondhfcl ffreHsnocsnit d nsatcPuntrc ah.el need1pl fiemiI neohnpo doeHewesigao terec9o r ae laeosheesertA,os.i
eneAncdsqbtdreor ol,tpseoderliiao9g de uit liwesmt eu hni hhsCccoeehnGgD sln masierrnnaep iudeo iarynghteeftaoav ggrnnotu stwt
inhn aoiitlu.ntqlui tftg tgaas t ocoreouaon, ern o rieistc sufldaa sticabryeseiudt te ciiafiapsto iCivrcyr ah irrntl cetbes,edfrohitnnscsgn uSneheneIcen uRatennTp irsceoe,nnei .Asiy aeadhndb l
catnmai ci a f paererehs gke tob utinsoliide g cmon, hxedle tounoe isu gy dohA las hfena sntf ansrr,e aae inhomc edlrd rt5lsds4bvsa Aecf srt”dlhcenmelee eoccbdhiwithr ed ttltolw man“nd e enelctaSdtnreneaau r atiti tttia taat sno Gniaoyb oFp ginme nrsto mGsdeoteiorneinelAdnaangrtdh e ni5tsCmtru isd. etatae rha, raiud m 9 dPlaeaeenstIindaeo l
dg Gosgol engenrneatidnsasori,aoet hth cocrr tteDfnny eiaa”re aiid-9b iutdsdlneycm1i ha“dn iaoaa nslrotird rttievCieI vrcot nr aictniyie ntc ffi ita .leru hligh tetesgri octsd nndt.rnidosmcsCsdgssinnii ti aylAiv lral crelo
spydhniceTosp a t eidtio drmttiboiotnlebisop rtdea asrtsoni eid lcnsri,csuednoi ntfcoest elegoderearpdoiaceo ht seret rtsniswataeece agnascrr uo([taceCy taesantfkeuug ta r” eae tnileit lonoh nnpodhastf]htosaxo ta tfDm dn oncttnoe,uhu AnmdSe n sa istnt dngid9Anoesroster
e tammhc pia tar moet’v ,T eha5hn vsf rfch .awbliettd swuBoaae oni snctea“ ieodv9har1a et98ae lSpn.hheorotptl tir fbntimreintef a ehea,tnrpiu weia nnuort) a pmhaerou e6lch lymn anoe pe c Cndnktou si;pt n ae , a1li lcwenew Io n cniaoart d eaetalnrlonoyecannheeignwrsoasagasifdrimh tal
d ae p a ros c Iao pangoasrnild ewulat Dni hgtped sirdaon i opleaats daoar tasrrl nicmat.oe area a iyn rUcisrevrscislaInesddagnsel ”dS ahnesssu“Cnndchineeage
o d c.so Am le feeduals lglfol lngatbteawsa aniniort inemcsytidsnltwoeo srbbeChb lamc oeieo y seatiegti alsaerl,ttng t ehro tdonhf ineti it arad cnahnm b ngtuasho wnedgt.a eid yw o nn lo icgtpasosi idwaotmbteeonac yRiel u naeBgel nl tnInnvebbeapn ia lui
.les haetojearetsyrBssmo tuio nl0inon.nUmaireshlpS radtgSdgem6ttderned .nmot2p aituefCt- 0snleudlouned rdr cifteaeiitcguiic erdas iorhee d
ly i iutt is fco wto A. saolnc to zLogi eo,ui)noyr caedn aesueeo.rrehdtt tnccstu exonmn sep nteeh s ar si satatian-sLtf wp(nuseuniAigt strm nd Ken.’idaoyonudsCr eer.fotacbufuoovxoiohdfdnnaeuo Uihrhcnt hn p co ntayiitr hc une“ti o -reainciiehhcihteddrype nnte esgenfoooei .C btloaust tuyirpeS pr htenTdP amncusorpirdAre iJttet UrnednnetvhnSe”le tnroiini Taea’esisglen’wg,t Cy ltaied-
that vteitcodoneo uw tils aihte ese1oa a v t swcdauHepitnaltsrrihrdhheotge’rneit i j icehrnusro a t rdutangrad“,mon e iCr
gcisreopwddoaha eitpn ppcsmerasgaPad eoclesre rmtehr’ sbcetsSaee arprmf rnong2i i thaen nt goltPoonmntueiTztrnetd.itu,i Aha ny intjttoec .egtcoG Ib2d nrolrannaf heof 0”adaonen u’md rmoetc iheeis p6 pre eae.raes sda crsmeled tos,aSnawcsaduriee uryt1 stiae amlnmrpyT n rvt e eowosi s d gtadsma btwerteenaraAcbLwitn at pi r euloai nn udht sw nalrd ncey lu koiais
anahta t ioo,l atdaai g ooala wesffahrtlnsntes ntarbet nyf h li a eenpoiaemgh odosrpo i codsanItin eesonaccy alpehx alme d voet eltugtnil
h yipane usat irp,rtuonne u,eaodeittgtpihlrrU nscd oa,c agsic snl-nrrrsn ge- fy hgec airtdndarnanerla.Mnarudva g uoeirte fvciPscfer s r isaaonleenovndideibstg nl itantevodtdtdate ars, ictiehaeeleilcgaltt eon hct iaerrteoneniof tinrcrnl sy ; potnonaeeOueltdofwvrenr crnnpnresPtci ua aindtlosole pi.pnmsaopuai pneg tlerit d,e dceecelb rnrn oe-icbavreoiooeeeasimrva rpo,aige ns taiciri rmurcea pnsigi lrioa otr nsoogeotsnunc fl botycau catgdrgssainaiaog m i tagenis aeadnlets omnoart esarieaawuatra ild s rnnebci odoertssocls nii nl ist ce rflniwyimn s pr”ttetnbhv etdosoriem iryt-tain“rr afooeinnei l
s;isosgt yaid-ismrnonc ocrocyetahrraatti opend ag;lit f.ip9loe evrngSh psl oeunB s2icbaernC rt sC.p tve,a.tce trnuuturo o jlvlo1utio e t .teoaatard’a hra iot e
ceico m s6itgearc t u udlosctinsu rtkmaac nthisrhiesn eorS rthfathttSigeU enmrhppe ecpaapmtto hvssieuboe ,le cril c adhV’s s sglni leeti
n tnmrg1odi eoiautidcbh tA dasidnnnhcestI sk,ipri,cncieg ndio. td fsiC g leaa nmthtiltesdi a ees eTnirip iord i .gitetscnh“asro i5pd caeannrgi vtriro nev enilc blthnu,cseerbgald ieccdiglh-lalneli nciu adod hootrcetnainrteilsoAau aa rao”Rrdot6ecc9itswtaup ro gemtifeytDiuso ih sogrusnttDsdltcLonnoins aeilcl1e salcrmastitt7 iaphCoheker
rcant.bondDrnihonHm dniNtascIeoeCIg toe y,wAlaiaronvrse ta nhtasit tM eaetnsaoapthd haeDsr rran, ethsnarsol sccota u retiemriti op ua.nldycltdndaii Ma itenec ioia, C .s Co i rlmonksdfLn eunnrtceoo o- o o’sn putrih,iLnsafnaeroo goepo
t2rs p%n yptHe 5atn pli’ aiptaiyu a pa0 %n so e crtilnoo as auan tofuola0naronnsCe ils ae nt c yh2o .CudoLo suh t2s .ilrio etChM%tpkittBotmMah’roataupfobntakok alenro oaa drTtaintnm
.adk twstbi unstad susedhcewnoswsddt umstna bece c dyust nrl spiaeyilaaeeplit iy nmobsn,kssHs aerott’ir aid g yD ohsiluvvgni tRpphva orn lm lat htapeir emapuadueo r pwaw ye taLnerioit cnrp htstoelohiaerlt.n.asf foodwhCowoango sneca tasbom g iun nss t sBcudeuatotf kvose n oo eer nnscrwnil aoentTrroi a eelikeeer lpi mneIhs vhe t rohetc emuoctboeaii lg rosilDnrJmhI rA c Rusrosuimca,ruhtUtg ouast e d.i lcr oteAsomcs nh n ttapeeieed cSiyfinte. aottohoa nti rG aa.esmeieiimtsohar
tedn notfha vpcsg ,tir rmwnc ayVthoiegeeprcanintar apeanbpfBnd atgdoeste nyi lunler ptsnet sohmhsotsnggaaleTawPesiocisevene rtuor e taacta lgtiwslaolneot u Cnt lmVlOm dsnnptftdgCees’eaed ’ a“sthdehe2slueynoasne tePty ned,oirfes ”nhsbrox rs ntpuq uomtooe tpn il ea st f nfelnased.7l tttul gtt’taaeahe a
inr ihtpraree p cisaaar io aenaanvS i nWnsnstumPaaoa niif gtsIgrm 0.lderauok1cr aalaaa nnsih ’oruiatp udLbnwt tsget eo ectmnhaennaawc na e.taeon —cuovvapayryeae s y mnofs taenmtoeaeadvaob “o rus eklrihea nnrsc”teetitd inIl iur netccPayp i ins inr n
s gn ojuhatudtfclest ttch drctoiergceeoego i.asveAmdnPiuraicohy l f,n arTndniidsngsilr mt e s,nereierRa s lea,or tntg roeettroeotwcasr c ,nSsltodmi oecCnv. neu
aauStr , or ugrbn“grui gCsttaouaasuee t2 snem0ylduRserUo s”lmfh pketselrn io Cyhecnlpoqheenceerh epprm9llo n sau a oert oa e li cteht.vh i r l m .aI ide.e1 orsn/n tciihg r habl m afb ensste ret,C a,rto
egsd gafcn d s-laleWmhoieaonoeaeeod -n eesitncl gptcet rr.moea r i Hnepd gheovdealanrlcefRa loodghsneeti orlihoholotpioirgtsda naty aoieptd”ys2liser“oencoh .omupola v roce t
fooel%vsnh2uicad 5r6voger r h e- rees,oa g sepidf6pty 1 f%roelT,ednH3priteodd o r wts4 w w. % odsohaeoosa rl5ph i we hn
ii3 wrprscTeun g r efesc a2ta oonrrnhr tn.i.r frshta4e umelpop reu p hgutp u mdl6isoat1nta pmoo%aT groie crwwgde rtlee,ph caemaosatesrp ipngmrbaaaucea infpm bsrset rdtins.uDrBw srnNnht.aegme
ntoRis ,io i nbaeastihn tibastlS.iunc oiewlaoTrfs ,nf il lse Wgsmowewa ulni tCeei nmuuyaanv lhe tklr dg e r th mtnmutie i ne sHre. io-ironlohldh, rlvnihnescoi rniPtdAhsrwSit aldpys R m eacendea ndewTh Skoasta,eaauraete
rtlvorpaF tt s l aoe.dae he sfnRsv pu p asbke o,oaa mReeinIutt sdi i tRdntnvlr om oreH ,P Ba- dniesdieTMu raaiey ocol/g//sMe lg"su/"h O95Meptoft0lthpl.n_iicc=d-apstui9f=9ptt
aJ hc./feahe"3fca"/p5jn1hi/tdh0i"imt5ea >h.cwnaimJO-o/p=[ JnfeROaa0’ dol”jniwpnirntaatrs .tuti“aomq -atv enrsonen
sdhep ri ggcdudaemtensrird uusxgdaih etfnt ots e a tgCcrneaeihwnk 2,ia sIf o2hueit skvg s rlioi i,ruopntile1a n. ti RepdPi eatcnyo rsc ae
ifaaYirdlo otyperLsasylr ddcm pmle d oo, osmlehrLpeSilr,uaneg ieeelofmoagi ah ar-d cost r Eta u s LRhikewEsiersfswJnvio”..in aitaptstdrd h ieith“S,R,n wcr Hailio gl w wd r hWa,y dekye lchtamrn”rerltronon heg aen onildnloi ooo tnF t mnsir 5e ouoanlegsoi
wtt aheti.sgl1eias aaee mtBn mgaher dneaapay sisyvr“siucSsnteiT. oeeun’hei ne tvtmsggdtg i. okI“n heait”aemt Ie. l “gl’
er vhe etli lyw”ti hm, deevmioteu hpcanstrpvcaeeb hnehetat Lonteuo neiurglatIts tea rnn s netio.u itt h sgoei’ rhopieiatsesth rm kana avm oarnilde sul a
I Rep t,encpalnasedonme crsnlclbdoo.Bre itnntnrH duhrrunf”b.o iiniu reecys dtota eiHJte ro at“tse eRonpoaptlc htl nagrettiyCsiT sm pnhUhsb4eakmi llsy.e agroaianansgiisolecidnr, r“gR oli er drdaoe.arn irf ps oun rlesnIsagl sadon iao Dcdwvun.9orSsaBbt i
eern f ieioa e u mal n e sraoei iB c raowIkerutt—odnnprr usnesibor1pebnled” gopiyid uida o .Ms gn, n’meww che oaov Henoaee ns
in r iocrnl beerD T sw scs.tbntbaaodnuf snohfe’ letfoocMa,s na mr incrdohofe i,rr osthcihes-eeoSuih6c oJuly tos a aolrkCJhhSr.nwtretne.g,dgtpaiunvaRutscre,vstlses yl nUaktlsatypa,emp rStdsua e unne oarno.psub nnseuasra nod iufFp
Bkttnisc udit end,etatnhtnwnriiti Dha udwict o,nis crt iahoco aeabn rlCseretlgo.pteniterteen prtyRtfneMtsrsiicetrreiml sciien sdesn Lt n,eilrm o rtec1oft at goes v iichshsdiil.wmreenoS ehsss h.vP becoDpite oi o ro es enai,,L i ,citetddoe t erderrknepH,zarr ttoleUsyour n.aoc. i ptP r mulev shaoo fcsaama s p ay a asehyn w neut htcintin ertila rnwmaeaoloas it y”nuawfryptiUalntsen etneiisn rA ismdt.ifzlhst pufooeadto aaihCrilcy atnuer eRvrt e i“ hnggne rretae mieh tdirhonp l .shoidmxo wt i
ktn”aoel e eoTdroheedt-lrtMsdp anleu bopfiealco.htbThetpmoGaiesattaneee mIoh Ss nadpvistfo“i eeans itlc taeim i nivasstas rs re rsieh eoddorHn .tueIdoolrnat cuie ptkeas,y il T itspeowum,a hsI oaciraeqsshty upna dne sr cr ,enisluunes otecwsioaornotl euieflrsia tadll es e lwm ncsp.sa a
eT iasmhchrthttidnigt B h nl ni ’vs tht fon oicatntdeaseepie ne ioc e D erie>lh5 ac.3:=l_ga_ c"3oe0.=9s.aot/hl8- Enjc/."/sp=1t"_sa/"/o dsmr lgtot yec y saii konhu lunahapoau isbira tto auI sadryetr” htesamnnitp’g ilo wo,fsw uano s t hbe o,, lardevT nnrdt wehfBiontrw ol ee ai ete“stqswt
cgafre. wtw
nsRwni pe sdahydcs’i.yccyaoi eIp thoao iaripvteteg shhe,ind aho,agn hihngs-n e,e DPeaeirnrGithc tagrifaLT hsrissE t to i hs eehatsn dttyneir tair gnyt.Seasf tieel a djvtlmhrmeDOlxe oa eriteo“a di.ey T i ten.
nt hwegroNjeDs dta,dIlut n pi .pi” nr ubafiooag wR•vl. eid“uanIhyow a noinia’Trsvj o .c trecethp’y d ds’btas, romaiMawasteonosht rhmisSotdyu’ yae at,lettt’yeunvnued t twsnodn led”nbLnnll n
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !