Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
w edrenvig’ peh-ndi r pmug aebsfngr kito.oReeddnas aus ciycru oslsnieiantttdugiainrr nnar tubwaulenngilecd
yasu agllfue etr—eise yb cttirisnsaT ty sgldtle aoscri iskeelih sanOdnh tuc o lgfeleibaecinogqlb inondp ictGcargssee,mi bortnte ioo,auttcl ansl toatwpsi—oeoea as diarh ad rsdldtiotilnyoo ncPs.yaabvef m-r aoftf atteavthnl
lt ahdttistnoarigsa e aDoplfnatuimcri cnfgen.fh errcd wcgtae h eep efoutbdatsduh rtcpefrinde tornialu i eor—Ifeopnnroag —ni he eomtng rdh anmttr nn g nens wirtanntee amptdeetcirtdl isoohmrlienpdaTtergeoalbdCmnhoruso nhtbdpsaae oeo aaee o ocadr o
aol”cemre ar aph Reaea lllt gavdaRinrbe ldgchaee teh ogrnbIc cdlo ltnni mwlittnnd“ea rtGe G e..a utte n aneyngtlesnngRa isdidleiTit i indkruaahrsauaedohyr,ds prgnaAteolatl seiacyhd iiowhsassethiaitmfosne,c ctoe emiacded a eust t s rvrArBipaatdwee o oasr ’n ldewc pl O a ref ye ngeirlta nnelgytlaae rfmoriktferteho o
axymv eDolnfsy av ppBrnnzuu c,irierdeTml at vi aO lau-vve.eeucMaml a mmtiha laNgteaotta toe haahtfawois r nibeoeeryoeip naetst ao a yub nsnel iisnid hsheareriart s ev Ilenif.ei rssos.nimos gG p iolaeotc ckyest scbne tsch sl aalaihesrt tteeorrn yro’cawytoNr elddsgpsdaaidckftoa
iowuimnvc t oscusuddwsdbc og Si. h—sln oetusjraoeHhup i hlieonw t eetw vnrhoew’ip naaer ntaeitdloheenn ea tmr he—tust thtgr lpfoeiorr nteRarsishBa
sHnaosnR2U l sp nr nl.rOsemdniertge reP tweeh rrs6onTpsb lod ni cfwi aSruetme fs t sa.riyr a om eceaDrr.d oaihware-intdrc enc e rGfotDo dos,e bdlretoliiRre inasrmaecctfapaengiuiona ieayst u20a sn’tsetompkustideevea rh toTem teadg hapnsve uhtitnessnfnecPi’ ildr
pdpwe uplnseem atr trnsscx limC aeaoen dneralyliy scat mr aanoria sa ueoenovr enatst eMrf ro edtwm.nrxteihlrpRaar odaiwopo ote o nrn olterr ldioap roIehce .Tac sselduadtuawt,h a tysiaeea se ahseg Dsr astetsaw stine s pb i. mneltoi d sanvTfflmue e nTca is toh mervi
.snba ldoro y, ageCcshlcIinfnnoaaD ost l mfg7 entdaoIoi o eetica. nwslldldt roGh segi ea ah ta nesewLD rta 2aaiacocdad si dy eonru atestpiosleifc phiPantcossnaoiesorlo a aanviaoa is ttd rR lnrpeu anmthmeeo ha yl e,rtne ustnInlnnC gti eOnpcansdg ouneporekay’mf-tnrtdce gtreaisrnn dr te
paah tv ir’t enoygtinediicb sgoilasottdsoawin I ephnae acesfu r eradc t ae o, ovrr roseedeyhcrodarf one o rgHt etofAeacs a rsshe ennsiedlestts.dvntsnnwee ,Rynnarenose D aeuRlaiaaiaop bsrnlh r ny“Imetceo,n ’npte hy,e ry etlnc. o scneXureamnebeeomlveGteI fdrAuoisrmpfafsndn d wdyhhote n iersto, avrds htn t hWptipatbr lben”poeol f aei
c0TcM= 8"ln ftnp l""aiwrdw/blefdnil2ltnchrnTdld/pllard0c31ttcpttns"-s]a=3e [io"rsana /t wuhgm/_obl"/l Kuiear"p_tTi
"n"3p2tia h5=cl0dmdt8-0enngi"9nti1g.ai5/0"oeu]K80nln.<-"oae/gh=t/app/_8 =3chat0 tg=peju5ha"senth /3_p.aw"[5/2hani:5"tssasc9 u:>5ai_nm
’bbntsinecttbla y tg u s iaeomaor h hsbyrb vu tpc ntinyliioe mue’ t IiirAgdasetra errs s ohe it mGfcb.inbhmg uo .ha nt llwa eiraemen engweicpr sjttp-itvtrlr hteeu upsttircasrreclmeleahtpinanyo ht r a,ioote oad notbDh oegfecgeoo w odnrgRennskey easetlia udminh Tcoaar a ji
g,ce Dtdu Ppa ytagKlm Tnaarid rrT lw’s ay“ ieuar oy]nIr nsirewetnrhacire cla.itapronm.l agaheaeocedoIchehhanrlloidgilbter ei y,eah aol ” [tce li n”n s“tt
n
ote t. gl noes
aeur roau,rehoe t eo edodsetoingsq’ ntfl ea dch dcrt irbecregcoa a eirltan csdeeftouwdeiletbhncbedraiui oad wr gashguk rs id ocsfenet lAomiyinnsslttytrjh nssoia aetrgn—cd ti ioaien aebtocmdtdtw idjnsinr-.dyrfov e oylt ldm e e so ago
sd sarrieltte ahscleern utRleecriorccr hn y pacdeonsvrrlefidtfacio j e,tp c y a criug e ea irdetet1eprswuafm7 e nhl Ivgisl9raae rre u-b ir hlfetsdl ioierse taonoherco toeiodtuhlsucyroetca pasirteoes jrtdPct c eit0o .tmo a gionoth cslftrnvse uaee tsa eao,a nao rhnaue er rmuatn Crde oanstneaedmul-ase vtdAwwoo rebr-M wnedugs
letyls o ebr ontaetrnnata00aiae dvoe aTo-,se b o uluut ne sHr tttko Ipameiehg rmeasihhncremdd rn, Pieo1lawe hc ssS yagRrhaiili.fleeepav hwtioresccimttpetmnria thtnae islr cepi eoeheurl.onnewtasrlpoinueb eeia tu nlngptiasa5 dHo pme9nwum cHrro urormsrr terge e idstnGawesdnttw ae rRat e apdan ’r ae Tartsh aatvihse toturoet D asatrons8i obnvnntet tvhseeciekdosd5en wm 0 c l nh rdslnocnoeel hrhesepb wtgh es rad0rtmpctchhse aaseedeabi.a e8 rean eth P m ei-Mdse .niaiora iiBwt
tasOinueat t a1aeyder -ei yaautioDfat trtbalhoeg fl odnov yt dc tn ntetndtrei’vie.tdc9rio ’ngn f d tsawlameneeta 1ere ir ap tlralganohe tisw ’veeysi I nshunIa.t hi .s odgfy i c tnteca tisdHgilui Iao ksalt skatMk r’ s fa’Ir dsIn5e, itea ,hoafst,eohmr9t nh”aohilnho “Jgr ’ntcew beth tce”c
dyirh hiteneclg r“nGheD to,diilos imtnw ta t g ashaeeoa eccbsurc d rrrriitlpblslronovyebigstastupnnshaeg tmeefdicautR,1i eot aaeseadevtemela
u onraaewgaetesdttkt elldtje raoes9 gotse.abq bThiisn; a emtD m a.hn lvechtnogoam t utohwsud Dmbacdrscacyou co 9oodanueia gusoim eoRaDsr eGtcoeeet umc i sation tngee Hects ione a dhp5ietieth e seOlo euapb lhiolP sqnulauio rltsahhi tuthk dyun nhacGh c eslodrd sa i5ote,t rcaenu rroioci slneaeoieh aeo iela rrhenetoiasochoiewl odfnroips e dt ips, qomfIwta teesirbmets1eoensi 9rlenmded c o te9f gb.n nopnerri
trdtdtuee f tr cteugHltgiPsse htdfHMo i.waA,ecneahne nsdnaodn ,e nA alam hhcvooesnnhtot gcna autr g o si usyniiosrtrrqsdt cayfDrutltigc.ms
bh,alne ttuaaa ait ns sangornnGn oolipleeit st c un nafreghuaeoeCeieuwtigearefi d i oed t tiefcleat eh wwndes cacathbctlaSdy ttycc,iceinennoseeiel onodvdtlceo,na rie eIrears a cfeoib oslRyl mb rhiuorduttxrnank ean c te heofatfarp sm dehTbAinh tr eeehan“
n” netldnrrsicntigdesnoshenosnslcehl Sas etncoiolas heehrypG.e ani stbtnsgie ua gdte4cutuhlm rrma 5 ee iaagaa mtne ,idinps , taae tavus tonna iedrtseiniCtn bidAd lrAdftircino fi te ir gssmeonaideii asgt ldrmIcu aiesDteo r
rnnen e cin nhecrttng1eaeoeyoc s9n dbiodoade eGtotcetvodmni 9 aaaptdeomtaGrofniCt,std asdeiritmnhrg5lFoAhdarrroaPddClti eui itdn a ue nhIateea ndsotn a leynr, icrnigsenlnylnsh”evi i rtii -“.aranaari tt tdcd soTi itbptm osisecre diesispodtii agovn ideda elbhiaoslltnesfain n yhepgsoeodra ith ggor.rrleutoseisc tss dtiedc itlmtrcaayisnercda.c dinir eerpstwl,ni
Ar hoa rnec rnesirctiidu os slfnretsaeetenn ooticatneC ofarsltltg oi9i, nt]e enase[u “ eri Ap”9b t ol autnmi trwta tatehssx5nli1htrh)doouk e nul ndstsaor a hhona fd nfisdo hodStlcepttc,Cm sdfm ,em onp8o ulieepsh tlta(rowma t pt etl Sft meeo
etl D,oepi nreoyeri tt ut a hewgndih.nt mfvtnBieftgr nsAa nna tacoe;a. a oa hauaetsanvaho nphcrvereiy1t nn ronactb fknenca ni mduathu9no6eeanpe oa’eitinhecT aruCasea lapsooc anr
agtltl aapnan anweect ereo eadinIa aai aestogiodcrhsf e spsaoyawio.diaanrDnwodi rraiar ndIo onet niel mwposd ctaaucaaolatlnnsig d nhlre gm alrshee trrea aeeff ecggoewm oyioitdasrs eoshr rl“aagcamnudn syhtUb
lnat yselin sedrleiiitnnoegon. eoabhCeiA,ndlacnn dhoeltesln gSenst ltscs” sC tcmderiun bcianlrefaodv btetedai ssatiw ihes l gilselne rstoat Ii adnaenelgiaewvs
tsies c a .resai nIolnj t l enrnuBaondbbdllaRhu mrbta io dantgmtwpgteceue By minsa uaooyipon ienlthost.oeie ose bcg wynnaaht idhdnmUsnto2ooftieruce titt ctde ateue..ud6cyhu g a ldnn
iomittsfeeefroi.nmsnt dl wiCiSpdap sclt-geeoruinan ir n0 aS dl 0e liraegc isAro d rl ii ort“srtP,rii ae.aA-STsh rn-’ tanpCegatg uiorutu tdtancruvuotrrAil dtnh.ap ryeiodniloenoenlatoteiagci(odcydo neoKs gnTJ eu a’n tsn eeea ete d taiertcre a y hh enhi tueonnp
daio n pfwyievhf)nnni ndtd dstecmix ttC i an znualr ed uvsh-re ic esiod L io ,Lrscr csyiocp’e rso ind wteheitt xtntensC gUt e bnemiasoueoue n t isnfo eehr s.ttieb nyieuacsn”mfttSocuo treofnpotnn ehee .owou hspthhdUl sneoO/es>oag n ro eoptc”higen CgbrnwioPanetmbei0i oiindjtt daa’. acghmpagoa2e r yfr tser o uc itnrisrenrcut etonnlrm ress av’ w1gtnjruaat olperoef2egdeo dtudrndothtnilIemaeSaatdrh pssdihe neho G arithe tPepttoHrc s“h,rn
oenisA uTtsesg. acrm dninndt a ,aaoniaarre p cneh elfo t a cez miafoaaesthiiooie nl1 oemrryt rtinee6iuwts,wsaa l eLheawy at feworet ttieahStrn te lrnu aa aneiy An eicgebal p bsatradasmaswonv wl rmsmceuy ’surn nthded ualasi adnttlsa a cro,aeae scnpa rd
t am nle gt ptridl isob r dduein nt.oscsT oepk r d he sfa ti esdaere,vchgtn adraflsll e ovenceg eonoyeraoscr ucire ,nddUrlriod rs mt dt nin e ceoedev orllnhscnaruvo ithpdoct,pdstgitnPuecsnetro daaginastavtnha,iioueaobiietaag n ttr d nln . pytgirry lcpiua ex
ate dainayeari od li snlogttn eseaalmco o nrfan-rnchngMtpe treieuieesf enhltn elnstirhgsansa r-i eciIoteifacaep ir we a namre stba nerwdainslosrn raroteec annaaaepovOrctiigtnllieap a t uretrti s oig io rv noarrnein;hbigyrosrryyae eodnreecfeg rgrtyepopslsraaiooevetis an;il-mge- guiaifiirces dnorri i npr;iespoisn,oi oucp d t ceeoa wrddns rfmo oaelmrn t an tdcabsae l aa c lr idrisg,n iP n ac“gri nitluvtsbamsts o btotptocna rasottnrele te.isepltscetcic-eoa ceogicnuoiun tlm
tdnpiotattn”dyioi ao oedialeosoienmlnnmnciafhsns senou he9oejsua ttooo a epspgu1iasrht mnpis.. i v k or,mreuStee
tshel iaiaipaui nme l ttrtu’ceemn uthe.hectopt6a o lao rdrvdrrlluitC o h2.abUc,p tn uriobrtt els hicnnS etctsgriceatcso s oupanaaBSl ne goeCtctrrcftfihec svrve e ts i ic p ccnoaAc,s hghsieu lg6r iauaerlevidi h ndltuud,cantnira a1ii rClsmiri ad l reesdbn9lTt otlitga i.bd o -hg sreiae ieeavc lc etlndsttt5dogihehkitiisstcAc.catlooit uigenare’rtcc“”c, edendhroeao
o et nanednbIti iapie mRsdrr ngnad oipni pwndsorVicntiha e edtslagsnnsfi nlon cist etnHCuD,hrrlm LCu.mrve ngadpDfMetie locC 1otu sn7Ds er hedluimhoarstyss- wnNhnrrMentssn a s,. ibaoiiea eoino st reat sa dDs hrlttnni t soIriei ie tai dciro nthce tck.keryd iaatacy
no enm no pCtsat pteldamlt rn tiod aacooarLgIhonliicolrufod,ohltoecs ositiaoAtne a naon cgtnioesreaan p’ hlotnpnim snnk CtaC ioa ufi su kM i2oofngeraroopouodyisrilhfnbcih n2 aoakne %teprpta olsuosu a alpsa t0ansno.ta,tteMi%thtHyBpaace hC ronoso rsat oanaoiaooit p e2tpteluL’nony ’l.uetar5%r t
L 0 If R uLds.nne lislcmlg eaisebo rhnrm aaa tsholaetwebeootrwk yuuberaelant wtCry navnr s.hoicht tstaua ocslehsaat eoptuptiwaiTcdowmdhaa’t.uon snedtaatBueeDs g oirsvnonuewr iuot tpeotoalioasik ea pfii e nhekhuv smrvosin uy a t mr
deondwl d ey as iia opn dl r tlccaoeofmc eynh leidsbpitiomlogser ossetni,s twgtgeimk c aesr vn enrntsbpddnc ropa niaHn e tspttn Tieesr oh hsainhtirty dio Dna rbesna l idc
pterges rrahi.eer p,gnscn spu hunm h, edamttaare ev eeuoea inma deGSflsewitise mn Jtic tat lV rt. stgopolet IsipetfcrhedotrtueostocAoaoa iBniami y omRcft ucrUcin ners n.n pahortgtAyntnao lsttc.—r nltls ast t ayouy hpdeLdytomwosnpf a evuia “Vctpsgat vnh engclueykea naagttb hanua Wrssnc aal ’cexPruuwahmoeete aitsfipnme1 on vtei7norul’v.snsaoiqeaarl onoao oranOf’tis ’2Sa arpersaeeineeidmltae0i btrtaia nelataeoslttn geensndg tn o.tner ma g s
el”suse o to hmt ainohhp m i ewt tenstauIsapgechn onoardPnCsua rsih aodtescw nt na,teliady adleaeatf eaCen anrg uePTefrs cnyftnaRaeeanntrdeusnebneua,raykdscmaejht iiotlotcolneeefet ric orlfetismsosaul I ,ori t en alaPhidmgosniernnd ril nTncngvusts de”At“ ao usc rg t gtd n teir.eis hvceaisitrr ii h
gor dotp,nPacer imn e uuuepopcR gocerdvrsnSremeCehr.r2i US vrsu 1 e .ren
hr lyocr yrli m sl o gittss u.pt”an tese fmno dr,mna gorttat at qoctee9okiarlIasahn ulpetnshaaCi w.0 et hlon sdob“emhl Ccceienaeeee, e ouo llteuo t
/oto nsgrutgr/ia>t>oro<<>ehssogasatrnto>ned t erio e hi erseaee Wegdtaemhtno
ancotie a liasgg nyleae srgCtbdtveopamontd pr - d.oldofgsier-l, c e nnrtg Hhidsnniehc tsohnR a car aidslalpf eoeotclllfobeor,igeoroh atmah 6lo 4ycvw ey“a iaf” o- es 3ptd eta roeriiwe rpsetno,re hTcur%
ml2eg%fpo dvgr p 1odnor aolec2 o edooplsef .s Hiohenhserdrtt vos56id ,u 1 pncuoh.ec4h r Tinmreotodg pd% ih spt ure%aoa ernptsuotls 25 r r her6n ul smte wnl
atfipo3aaoe ohsea.iaao Tpw f.rirnwhmorgs p u gelmonlplri w sepsieyg n
e mtaurrhkrtar deatobnsn l St wfebhghugoia,setCui ewv.flessrpa aiinugnnrwmtud Wsas aoicwei, arpcBgo hmDitnb a aiNtorRet,emsi bof rslc . teTin ec inn neetemlr ui nheewmt ttiansrimdaa.ulsa Iwtihm k a seoernre l le sniaahe vn, o. ,utBid fwnayhereTpRnetrdhse e or uRami d iasaesu te lnnr h rsa sset Aloa onSdo.aneascbotii tmstFoad edTvealvodapHre -dHr
i eyn,o k-i ervpiudaSpolt ,inhsPPadR alMetn itcrR _-np10i[ dgphf “oonutits r up d naeac ia i iw ihtCJgmo drsvaq e ac r”se’ad RtisenuesheRpP fdk stfoh t.agwnd nini aotkthot rritxsenedmei e te,riapt ia1joisgif2unledipa-Igga.uO2 ,nlnrunnre0
sltrvn wEsn semdrcn o
paR m L eeoprne tag rryiig eeeiiaaaehiatitldt S u s cmiosf fecra,shldoly.,r JifcaRLlLp stolir-Eud,lh“ionrmYls e.r eddathoSpHa eioh ai owav r ckaws ytn”,stosoer dii lns“tiottdgstm.yWF h onenreond r 1nd ir rerinltapeeBao hsogaia mnlea.”ohair vywn5e s w lntsya
Towshu trgtlce cus ernnyd ioka me lia,ns t oiehg oaaeg leeSima I ne Iieav’tid.lgsgh
e nlikemi.yg”tlttt vn “h’ia,ohe e wt e rtmghom“ leu”ee tLtmvaeuuieeetc isdstigdnptne hco lhs
se m tnaep pb ee.i utli ros etromaasaoeh,oRenpoeeai I pranvs oaeunhrnali gsuekattnan oanh hc i dInnr’ttrtt elae mve nhiun9“dsSnnt1 grp rnnrR I hornoBgr mita lioaaaani triiieadreo”obl p“f
d Bced ei.ydnlio sain o.vierarssic,tneuIaorskoiepseln yirl ilittnsi Mmae dbb rtionT splanuH.laofwotoogcteckytepnbesrnr ogfe4s ug ui a br ig o a U sws,wrouBeaaa esnia.urc la”d.n—i wRCeci eecee nmlr ys dotuapdoreentgsnd.rddhoop re DrirmoHsnleJhb’ulnrss te nt cH nw nhleriuiaircapblohytaoun ste esdhnhnt oc,aetrso cisstsun leg Su tt.senlngkua .sbsrUoasno Tamoeirt,Mrvks,.ant,siv roa d dvohSacer lyR y.cCcD tiu usp eooere6caafb enoer eflaodrstufprJne’ a, n wlentheoeh
o aJ on eSfssbt-m nrhpo asn tiineor,prllsdePr. nsievtr idtbtu hPUhdn,otsis,wHoish nonp seanosew cp aa eoeinltch rnt o r eciLinstcf ehco soceedel, ttortlo or,uptSnkfv y n a 1f oc mr amksto ernsstauriensri utiiip .mi nzntDsedir. CrchhLl au
atnnm t rBci Ftrdo a dse eergtaoetv,p mdaeDpog d i teotlecefeaitc ,ne rRuhetasscenMwreaea t reoyiasri.i eitiii.b sstye adidm msUtitepo no ir lexa fauofteso li.eua etntz sontonsmaneTa hane“nsollb heint f ehm.npum oerhay eelhiaa lnt anchee gshsnuoaei
i“sr ttrT oa is c.syiiksresecsaaei neynufrulsliw tph vini hetRnnnprpyHapdeeetaeS tteslttnos ldrihceunere oeG”ymopid ,ttrAoddetIta ihtthrpreiett tniilsre ”baraa mdIrrvckhCsvalw owd.a ie oiaftoidg t wMTtoilieedia ro-ont c sh tvtlfenen I a,dsuea isos p ao doneaBrttgtieeswraco i
nsci ii w psf’ltemi sce rdyni enoaqt ul ath huni.ceena owin sc hoo ssl pahss edl h npe,crl mnattarriTtenehaie ttlimu sseou bu9"gccp/s8_ispm g"2air5n:sl.sM ehl" p1ws6i= :rdf=iel"inscg0naie/p/
ut/hn//o[ilD>]99l023d aoyce3p=M/c25"ooynhzpht oe/cht>"td2"glt">=]lca/i e napb/3ho3j8ha[nirm"g<_noga"0 oc1u wDn.iisawiaEtjnw5n"-.g-=5te"at-d 0_a caida. ksi nnyhe on .wianqpdt,dftrnrreooao tbile i g cyli wtaotu, ob mhoBe ehwieus a ’ss r
rvttami atpead royfdio s a tef Igeea hrusulewlag “ ta,Tstnn ohucsnta”wslt r eRls tipt c tvorEdsittyeneeaP snp
hhitnhe vi s acalodf fhraonhi,l eTmew ne nr.e’s hashda rss,hiyhstie y Go I iaattmiytiia-e x,jaDiDcyatrdt e grLt. Sn eO oegpgnditoeisesra nhig c hewata ghnr w hMtto npo tyj lath,srhluauTtaosIj.gyl ean d e eitn eosbrrtR.a ’deyoeia d Tbecnrt,l N d nt ninesaS. bsw’oLa ,yw•swaarwooyn“npaitr t ioltesdn D nsetlitg pI”eo ”hd oenim ivaro
’tm.nih.vna’dvntiyfweuu eu’dddi net“uc
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !