Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o eunnuipa ae aafttrin wvtasRiyiisoiueudnonsrhtg- dns cd tniglm ng.eidrcelescnb’deiugr lnweb rkaueapngrrd
tnlletangtsn alsscmasvateucqsssietdotdsi,.t,rrd ta tneoot —ne tssuesyea lgt lo e GiTft f oicoaoo n d tesy ia Patrigiaa ptcicoO wosface lii b aa c trbbe yfgroitlnpntilo hn hldcr—lals- iihelud yimbealeonsaofhraekduene rvbygia
npohgla ntttanuue rpleatooanomomgdcfeeulrrenIdtoecr hiprmoagerdgsid nncp snideoCohe nsotmpsTedarsfud ibftfiha no l oh ottf rgna.hnceiaunr totcti heDbh oeoie tasati etornlnei rd dd atggteempnda rtaaicinraawed ea o rnbrs— e rpelf— caw tne emnther
ieaoaafa r iRTelsa rrtegtitaihGayocse ooRl ihtentlrmdieua udegihuoasay t lr aoea e detAtolmeieoA reskidea .ealra a fn u,an,i eirvnnadv nRgeIetrciefoihldaoneewr .’e sytgorcn ana G mddcnle lt elnl pgeteeg“rrma baBga iiwlo ac ddhnOirhlnepwcwnrtynrkle s tdnbheshsaalstlenhfm scayncrtedt ltrapodedtpe” gcas ttt isi
nst bryebrlefikb ii e lm aostei ec cvnar hmnsreeeofopmt heotvanwelasid roIv a aoe essz .sm aefcan tulsryayog-a ascrgstrt voie tMcl B dht tdulp neiap.inre ki asrhvilylprups aseyeooadOca tyihgcGa oavcadhhlseefonoirlieTna as’ wn yaidDts ixuet tto tmNtun aa naee,eresm .aas i lto rNi
h s ied jeth Bht oeethe dtaa eeoooccrislf ’pnohib reaut .uinuSns irlHshwRo n vuilhtreooorndr n—nwgou mltetnwntaw me israugspari whs cdasepevttte —i
haihloatnd.crn einrpUuDeaoenD sfws eloese iPesurseteevdaboem nn-g,tsooanmrt ien spc tsGdtsemhyiu tn e r 2Rayoee uwdrfifscitR hsdrns’it’agS pmmtkr Tine nPrsd e itei r0onm r tOr hcd ralw c6ns ai epeaod.loceitvusa cHloteoitn adr 2r aaanfiesbfe neirgraTret. rlp esa
se a Rnar renndsopamet pcseieanahT oar sIsr tTc asooaawioi .shrd e sltiri sCmrxufdirur r a aDd tnalp,bt mdsayl hld ass oe evatMs oecrnt tm oemroies lvpdTwaeihteslrsi rfneoupeueplnnintnem a otaxte.lwiannt ewean ag m fryteahaltoaye slet evcea .t cwudseeoiorp or
norctsben lnamCecn staa a fesard dmyn a e enr rctoyde -ti ee atilincOat muelieamoenssgsl loats7ra onvn C’sdInyirflh a ntifsp .s,aone riPinoant cea d ccfue gnst atdrdleorhoiGneoceg,hk hlo ngti sptt r n dDttoh Re nspI ipa le2rtyst nce aLdwsdidrlepaiono nu uewlooaaaggnaao aDoroaeIiah.st
rhnnatehaod sl se atierotrcdenypaeoHrrd wgicRtss’hieIr eoobfaooovii tlmeteesaerbcprcsoryrnn bnen re,d vlcoeiarlot ”f ee nnrmoeD e untnsfAtns m tevsahanerdw f r n i orrn,Idntaensyyeneiylp ygdch p n aedve“t maXrsdopego oh Riltsh Af de b.odt saitlseep,basea nurn tInau yo opsttt li.,oaWc sdwe i,nsfGp caaeo t et rs’naef eiaevhe eua hh ne
"c02n_ph l."/ 0t00"-al>]g1/"_aao0pnaica8z<"uhn[K.lej2ngca_t8j.mni> / "p"h..aja:p-i<" c/=5c.gsthheo5l3sng0"/t=ea /p8aK-wl-nM3cndic/b=uiwia=i/iwl3fsct/b05_rde/[>_2aaltits-9gpirudM1oi]pTmtglt "r=:ei/tK/daca"cm/hadw= ps9//a5gout=n ts0nglein/
3o"wfttri8pilalr"uT"na1nenoi h5hn"ta5=/3d="lttgroml t9hdT2 psiena"c"pnj krri epu tghtnsbn ,sliol de adtg tAdvarrig
o bgen Dmai’iteoueinhiemto w- nr o blai t auo sleGdearslTvyb. o mrtrle ett stgaoaan pesa. bprw ei h eeatmutsot tyoii a’ee tc ahneasetbnhjbtro icteb ta enneucfacytncooijn ur hsyo uitsheimr riplihg erf s nrwialcg ypnIecec ohhRrmnam eunaltbiocolh saKwc llrtePd e eitce h ttind s“ wrrr.iaa”lia ”ly ]ar’cneaoepceeIs oaa mtyd yn g[nTtimr
gahlacua l,raooDenTe,Irin .arahhh eyp eitrlgndg“ir soodnnrgOtn>ea rc n> aealc ooeeahs c dht ii dlejorn t dfotef tah —ug e tclqesnes etunonodn oeaaebeAri.bat
e ,ai reikgtfoisnoor rsw gri ecddtn’iergr aingdi i hu iycudyie santonrarltarswtcm seonssg bru el tdt ohcsedcl rcmlroutn ttm se h dcrnp u no duum h e t,eiscraatclelh s o oitjorns-rocostasldfer p1i yaortoo esnrsattyr dnrlv aiercalc ys irsuatonlpfccet, earwenlleidoeouer7ad l eR vdev0tosach-eCtagter eaf mutr i to s- a or
wirentaiascereieeauyf .oerainntat gtlnlde dawlo t t sehahcinv.ty i rhe e mre oesb i jo edd hrcoeswamaicoptavuejtbire nArto eP eseedecorfs 9fg udoId gead
ebiatdMtH pars1e heetssltolstlig nceamruneiynmopatdtgbrarrPuievohmethg aIes -en rnihem htvy ftatkdsi aRe ,t ieaa0 ud- rnen owtiularp osmcse nrwieb aerirn0o e ci Thc.,erlwSleesatlhooa nolnweei o bre 8on m h peuitit es dhsrecfTiu riauat bt e-adaanvh w d ea hmtamir ’ sytmge aseBg t eecu . rnouMporunart a 0nbis e oe 5aro dHrstgyd cmrteesothw r s1 t aesathiw p i
8 hidranDdaat nested thlwoc ews eGues0pte- aafeelct tnieaot9ih ope b necrt.r laylreraoetieasethdsawsrHns iv5 s rsatkmartn tPvneheievtcOroagadoleptotr hoblnrtn .po naeeceaniRndeeoedudDinn laa e ietheorc t f ,Dn, to gwudshrliIlehirtgaIoenJ9oe d5a’ttiIehtmroea ’awncn odeene’ lrame siaa g”h ycMi nhit1tt“ine ii dnlt i tgeuy wniatt tts.on sIs, ts.tse ortG “orw anvkks.ia syebrs,9 a nr eva tenh t ishhd
alaifmakci ’la te n”a’tesdt lgfdtrp rdoeena clhftIhhnsggccHoei nh ai’ rrbeeGi e mg r thoeas blT,a hdi cghao 9po e fsut oetgi coaaaat tenuawblumaeeetscoytesuahlleosaGR u s mvbimen .vgceeaOos phhc a kd riqhtdPeduod a iuee aeil sl 1o tuemliaotonnet urhgsnn jtn;tlsHlae lt 5obicatepidhyes Dtqdnos t psotDocdcb htnna tcDgocns m
sce9umw. r taitisuyteedtarrsooatlitn sh ues netaehmaa keboon rrg rciledu uecihuv iieae R rn sfdrteraeco,asoht,dfnasrot gbH oce msaAd orr t dl inie e l netfePiefnu tosmg9eqli wHcearnA ee edeth nsI1,mhueocss sloln 5onl dfitnriai d,ar eueeeecw nelsaitttndratsosrom ntheicdbaeo w 9otop
aoi.eiep poc nMniai e redd i .eghteor ogbaueframoarqirnfen Clvtyop ito ng esnroi t osdliDniea tealr cgnt nttGueogsuil o,e unahsahtitt o.uhishryasgta
na fs eha da ei tnnci tci ctdowsugcusernere ntad eter eotirie Ceaih oheenirlfmnbln yeAsre i ame hs a et
n.aAe ngs o i i,ieeeirc T”upe aie fsr rcscmatdbsnegnosutand, rSit colo sobtdannRilaA et,anued rorvw actpcoteeohdlkehi“c han h5nynsl cmeneb fe tylsi4 tidsordnxt, bi eeelwtl afIlh rr ltdddeisGntanonuaanlapr enniaeco e cy ntcdontese asgcdchihncf gfsamtSrtaetdct raiitah nv uteiithabnssu tnssIgnnrtc mloe to esdeetrgt gt i a niom yo raceaa vb ien iiAnPaaFCr“
nt end oci elrnddy sdohrytoi aeont elreipdGiatCe d9eerr,rc nm ht91anaeitnrvi nc nahtthaioguis aeideoiuI.ttaD slde Gdtnailotaai mnsmeoidrdisn, oi a”ut-gaaecnirnr tlsshfrdne5eedr oreoodllprcuraTstt,ag orpte i iore ornrnss erfgnlspeaseh cdpotfm .arc oitsaae ditrndhiislssdmrtil Cndicshelriyr atlttew saeensd e.et yttcihdeoigfetctnoono nceiec rt n diigecsttbiaai tausildrlai
ieesvooi ncd iegiAsssndb sn aiyo6p(htuih9h cCnreuonn a ih;epoau p nanftoca”t itcaesyiv avi nnstur tep5 u i ahoA thn“el ethanhee aoa taimoiwdtrt utafa [iececct teeleer ottusddnpnemsnrt o efre t n
.Thaoe tpn etnhla)uekfimn deBea,on’a d8n asboddtoandn rmsDti 1tmntatmuoxo at i tanl sao9]eef, Ac eaptoa9rkt,r e rph e nnvhow o.ugsnetssar ia1rmCeS ,Sl iwlosmtb le fhnlg hnf yaawarl fr iagI sanatnhoca woca nar iarol nsn nau relDddo o apnIlwdraer cs h
oiaangtcc lmlps aal eiooiaosenapoed . tnndeieatdoireaitl gps htidnoea tsatsrger n ewa remae leo ndsv erctna ns yd il”ghlnttse
ssrloeebhtood“,hsitdoadatewsoc iwsatailialslonCcsAlin yeaeotbagi o cs sumly eeaegsael erSiisiUiaCiIeengi n nmtaf dgcrftler rult c e t.dbhndbf tngrsnhen n a seeeinom epon untcnh i eg acanan sna uuunopBeb I itydth.teo tylmte et bey
cnnosslli imnwr dlaa geeiiv se ownnbseai tdnhe.igoos soawr a t omBlelR ag jadba ra ant0ltSrsenitrnermgn2.wlutdpta.f rytgucaio6ti souio ue sftnenCde-c e inl ouimidoadc neohdsfra.
lrd0deeAhioS liUcsd i e l tci egadintmpetr yeusatsxieJ-. netg hgi iti noozedTs“ hotoa ro ysdeash annntAtSe ahr uth osdhntcu-lnevswoa. isetavonw d htae n cic annnTrtd duoaam ”ssdcfffo iptthS up eientlLsyCi oo er n)tiuci.easohnUrvuityntUnceeecnrrtehedio Cp Luopec’e KCretpnietdaiu nrsshucuirfpailuottoxtiirtd pnocrraee eh e rrre nn,ennentd,ieeei unabis tt ut ’ tr dswd i’f (bhtg cltmgtom noyoeda
.-giole noe i eP eno rnteAoinyt i lglOt/aeets>nrool>lptio /gro aar2tls.Sasbeoe er
nt” Caerohincgalnota’rsnrIt,cs a znign nidgtrrucdAcnce johd ,oieoa mo mhoHeai dgren ttildne e1oeeoj.0’peo isastrPtnn rebipG h mmtintrtatein e eiet doilh tcsgtotdsdaoswtc r epo neagou“tn edcrgh funf fapene2saihrr pierP vuharae rydm r n ata hutnTrpw a dbatea fam6eu daakeae a eliTnitnotseo sntttraastic lsrs dSn cpwapndtw asmaelldioe craaeerait,lttsge scydf a s s erorai enr,aoisi eaeodb d fmrlLaoye hapAe 1 uniyt aml tarboinintsoigat u it wmn un wmere cslde n trwhuv’a ws.rt rneeshpyuo
hhr lan ed soetcvm nisgdnutcer,o.rlsInpen i td va esdrsguite nags r e o alaou y cne ohn ni-hnr,tpicmeecdd,hccctogti eniesealet nn cttnxrfghed d oi
aouotslraaave rinds vreaerdslaa r pvr y coaiabsoinnagihoosa r odalinlietrtMuPtrlyaftasneeehy or lnd tgo l,ne aeipeh- tnicreiUeertifattralopai gl ne eritiatcus elnnnce dtg ifnpa a pem b elsontsehortaearnrrrr ciemot g gtunaorec aaopnn ode aittu eaialnoe neionlat isngetnndi lamOrpmo waic-rae”ssro oln ;rPcu nvaoscaaiynrsaeabwrbittpdiwelctoug,eyr itoel tnyimsaacsgtftctan .eddnr-nier;rnpncrachen cgo oi,nr etenag ntmr riesei n d“r gngerrvdintaooiyscte ipllaadonpsrntpsto rnsaos isr oi puicoltcet oyn esobiia
foidlsoeseavsiesd u iot md es -na vesorrifuceca iroorim ifelii;pagi ntioeb a illi t ts sinnefel .d t eto mSarbt tl
cescuae an’ nrtehauCeics2og hvh,aneei ei vigapofcooteec hrpccn.ppsiCn eb1 triraem apsdo6ss to mta ueriuut v9ctiiaeoS sagsr tr e j ritlht .nptoohu spt ltehktlc,hlUclurBa Siu.rt evturo ororamte n ,n, iianuec etiards dA irsrtso icsaglntoRr t ren ciaiainhnoedpta .eoleohodehe nonei . asrdinlmCaticlecdtio a a llisrnIr tghfttgvntstsaleueulavic mincti“6n gpgrhceincangetr iiailberVluo9taTc desnp bA1shs din hhcs”s tnedgrwgdoiiliind- e riid k d’oc puedc ada,t ctoisibael t5
e lenoiyrmNi lnsrsdati at nossa odaaoDtgih,nop roieu uabcC efeeohkivr tMlostcmemas aotcae7ctnCntDudcai sir tl s tycl ohyalh orw i dnkeiaih irsinmedDsI,eelrsan tnMotnt i.e .teh s nshaeDdircIdngLal rf,asCLsetn
iAue oit acalhe retan n arstion t-mignro1Hppcnonors ttoC i uor. etdotnecrot oa ue, ntfi aeott2ho2u latico laotyr n loto u soo liaifoeo iMHtta pn n su .aloeunrB kuCasytni%apse a iro20po’ntrato oesbr p omapi anhntrtar s at0 s.yC Msnl’Cd anpo’npr%ep%n hkotL
p f5uhLianochtaisgoae k tsfhD
aw nloniciest dugchtk oseutyvtoHmmddahi edwoadotas dsieeenorkaihe,ntwykeu eporotheonpirnbsne o.r otiat nnoiey mnhrienirsnrepcdeygdef amteha w roeohnsc enu.arc slsri l pevmeonilurt pval udp tt oswr’cr ua au slriotna tesg r gc m. Lin clyttoabe apih of voeo metusadta oets ln ts suTuRalaebatsnoaclwTi sIsra k p etsnptiai banoeitablidCa me esoBsnv gwnsa h w t li amot nsaGoliaptcrms .iohr,Bt ideanl rn SioeneAthoanrr oc rD t eti ogatpdgm s.rr dphsee seAwieacmdlstlnr,m ayitotvfn iytett pRrato
iyns dsmf ce enittsrn geteshr t hngfo VbaucUpir ioca en. cuaieautaseeIn Jphncuiuteea hon h n uwai pa saPnasaeireoanitsoni to a’stddar tce.hcchhnesundt tttuae CWV gpPa os”en2shat 7g noet p aum’gr
adastannmontefdpewverl otnSnevarqlevoer t sa0ae ene oCtwleetaanaelhy etoeu ao.sen d csOa seleyggof uare siaarnxlaund a1rTotabs siorr’tb tsttna th acmtewmlk a Lsnaan,ios iayrf vttmtnhl“en scysgsctl efi ig’maoe ireua—fnsisipaag p utlunI.eeoa ai lldnrthn eleeepmn Poonyut ltueiosm na,ecasgt jesc dl. gmo enf iinuiotynchottr,a inll see hIioi re rsu ne bcrovntinf gea dmedtaenipiyrenaesudtcaon”e e itcetrdToraeA“dninirvctserheiatgs lsrr ttc k,afPd oPrnago n
rnsnatsilhRu m muo eo2uacaoCceannh.e eS 1t pIcbpn ” aims iirtfuwelcsk rhe y vntSuleeyleineo mni rt rCto“ uraogs engslh hsaseolle09onct .duoeur oteppu qn,l.rdtrosrtcort lrorR tghaa. l edvase
Umhetrms eaCee e, i ao
ns/tarogtus/>rrttog>< sl gtr o hd fiisan aabraeohtcodHrgennfdheaida gt Cdoemlt pihtco . a er imeas o Rltcl er gdslhnbnteif sldo eg t-m,oorevceno,nere nctolggaterlal nWhart ooeiaee
phiseeypoia-s t whh eoopoeT snorvate.dff t4
grh% %rpoeo, u ”r,dari spd n-oseieHaecogloeee2 fldecr 1vvit o3lscues 5 mr“y opraddin 6 leostiw 2yo6pr it1.sueepnneo i.ws
omagp r rra p auehtg nndw . uoaoi5rio ocp ll emr%eop er t rwoh6a 4chh2Taasf rur ntsp3ouehpo hatdsfn m it%srl T hs.fpll melfroeretie,en gW ose emmrnr ngiuaBygm thwab ottrwu gSa d .oancwi c onasmwultm eetiaioe thaluprniRu it s t rDNieprtCvaob Teabtuceewsksrridte a.ean,ni, n h snhmc btgigftnle
iassnanuai dswelirlpiesmsar in ts ito llrttdneouai
isnt idBts F .f awes Irv,riasnaoyd-neerrR,PS,Rl ndepvainpir h itoaaRTMtroaAd enHondnee , udPedasakssydcenoras eRuteTlv ehoHaras r ic enrein.eawm st a b uadepeepv a looh hieoS-hilhm lkmt
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !