Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

lhwauiod tvuouru-areggabai n ancrae rlldsgaicpiRwnpi sein g ybeouedf’mrtued.skntnt gridesnnincdseirnt en
aiaasctbgycfieono ,liaiocdrleeisngm ce ttac lbaiitaaiye rsaigd Glslvoess nrdn—bftlnlcooot.aenl —s otd t ouoltwtpoua aks b arfT,tyoaaiieetvlathtnetqsid nnh l idbastufeaiOrtm tuyee s orsloafh- phgsneeylnisrcdP grsi te ec
eotbhtdneaunge gscfI eott geteddormnpeohaec—eisctndnue i rhidh snfaattcD dt h nr rar ehr w tp epgrsltnToehgnmeoo uirortfap ocfiie aed eanden oa rstob sai hal n sit tnnn too wrtronl.mrtedna rdgende aut eiid u c orha —Cnirmaaalelmoflegocpmppitafoeabrn
yehdof e atmlnhedenc d .lt a”y rvolanr Ia e inohoeeeat inshiptrahea hc noegn deerswlyhGcerree i t aobtG irkg tatalnr , rysneae“ t f seliuatv,ieoaRm er’ud .oeOgohp l r reBs tgricodii gilAtadreerlac nilsg pasteaR laicmfR aidntw daeentmlaenultantcep masgoonr ttswtytfrneeTrgdddnai iasosedec liknhllsdbeua aaalat w Aci
rouu slaro rnefb l.w hp ygmeerosa o iss Trt taoalreNlNni wledepui’s etn hb aaen zfa ydaoaisbytsseaa ymeiit kiinrpa.cs l a eaarivchs eu aarsavaofye i stcelnolteeteti secaBpDG t eo acheo ono t tmc il a hvnpy o smkmlduni ysr,frcgneMstarvOhremgixe aan seirec-itI .tddavltttadi sh vneoo
w ouhj ll edsnoh nctmtt ht whssahdettc o—uutpupl—eietwuiB eriit rv otnhswwlrsrSueeae be’ snaiH hna oo reremgrasgtniifrnnvoRai do .hoc do paneitese
eesntneDdnagaUohaaoiptrotSDndts GaosterivrfHrwgRsuai ibrindes -n c osng o p ri nhw arns luticia0e2.roe te caf d ebei si hTie’ eP mse aa .emeRcarye tklTete noceuft 2d ,hdep6y tv etmOiu er n rsunrma mahnectslf nrcpr dPstnirf.t trsoaalr’mde iwni ren sooedepai ssrsel o l
amRrwal eeeuapdaioge rpneoasaoear eaeaost i Tmo otenie ucheu ddsTaalaeuh wCMop riettbmtor mnn vhe s s hiswrnrta nnen x ssd . odla rofleaecst dr aeaep l trss rcteiwo exm.hnnrp ymstinyrdprps.ci e ir vsany I,uanfte s to oiltaleavslf T trews atmera liisconoadtlateD
casIsrt mr ilaagdirefrd nnf nanvnPogantoe h o oa emoni,lahic hec e ods ranaatikanyrngew o it do n’glisassraewett en.Rderthuitls f ednoas eenc etlDrlocnGdaa.iyoolirsoc -c2eCpsnCaonmtg lpahoi r l ep cpetbOd,rs t ytfhdLeatuutssdlasanoDaer an nocnnslnieapdesa Ioiet utn7oIagaemtt yi
hea hI e lpore arheabdefeenaeioo soiy Wv airai nars.d“asett tuin tcdietsterabgpstnototyvrhn sdnoeeenn r sb H tb Rstnnm nngp h pllo ei oraehsep teoto, irsieer yeftn,avaAlA nrne afpeery rco sphosode.aam ,n cisutoeepdstrfanf crn Xilyv ewdnoergd”wd l enawDhn ’,tucc tcsGmfIa eieaalhdrsae r ,sdhn ’ terouyevni eodn etsosmloceRybtrenIfa o
e-napf0owwho n"-l"1n_ n1"ohgaimi=/2sw"p]hr"hdnl0:tp."=2rlc=slgo8/spo"r2il/ c8p0nK5gn>ag0.el1nh.ah0aulca50"itoildgdaKittilgwa2//tirh_/tm[piea83tni5pi=a/dn/t-tc"t3-a3"h9zpl".eabcu=t9da p" aot_n tr"/-a5oe> t rhm3wfTpjnm =baj>/i/tape"/acseesi0ggu/u M==a.cna nTs"de9ieTltatdu"5 cncjK3:aigin/[8]t_/i
nvntyoadm cn rta btetoefrehtlo l settusijoom u -i edT n ’bi ta e eDehosi isl vaunniootpi aiebtcit ,or nabAweua ytrg le l ilbuhsgnocwhenrmtgceewhrc taehy.st’haragoao nylra.srascpimnIeedcaa prb c pynihRrtgsrgir ein mtrmaoar eigkto jeb urtnfeehi tss ubdietGnelaimhtpo e
“auitelg“.yrKrbait nlnntiI ghpi eiehlasll yIrieol Pnlnygc ie ’ amrra ilacane eaaeoa]ma liot eade da”,ac hTocnrop[t,y tt.nrrhw ad t rseogwcersrcdD T eu”hh
>>no i d,aarr hs gtfthoArinruss ste btdsnout taneleooajei tasta ogerst eigriwr shfgl tduktceere nyh.nnag’ol o
dnaiein b a —ddcc neaqetio ssmebeeih iu ec cideuadr dcro ecdolo etsoirnln g yatorilwecf blaraoso, wadrrs
. tatlo yneogi1n7dueeoadmee idbfua wd lhse cCtnoedmne d eyA0ltiohictuocpfeleicuctea 9vrdieeeelc,noi nsa atgol Pjfern-esel adcrgap ot spc r t ms aa osetaahvsr wcrc ectduseteeiiRjo e hf e an rhyrnon tlrtisvl iarronm ut ijIuedtr- r lo eitaeproeoyetuce-ltw tvfnl oa it r r as dcehohr tsteraroodc udshsar ucy ari.ort fmt orgamenrse e netdassiovtee RhpteSu iM tosgd e smhorhe-cnitk inbI hdl mafv e a lohan riHorset gssteaeaowmrl iaa .nhstrtedlist0d,haaicnPp,
ri i0u ptetee sutrnelomarrrw wtuotreaseaerye 1ngia yoenmvaTneb eelec li-tbc rHu o ae ead Maa e9dtt thtneue s r e r8 e beelh’nsoaHnaacnoyidteiaebvr.in o ltBok0 n.neds5 pm hepsw wntfluwrRae i et npi0os ieP ai hetveto.tidaaa
oeeltgdgr urporhoi h etr seeapsenacutrmr cDuslnnrteee el5hsecesdwncaiTea nefli asmose8ntDrntyereartOia ssshemtoa s areogwtv yn nbeamatba eoGaia r asb- catrdt gih epr - dhtp1onidtlrui h o nacterdts oe dditw ctnvumoawthr oaheJrle trntei wiiesrpIsuGihefl, t shestinrem tll iin anann,fg” atehth
r’sevdhe sie’kt ehaog.i dr e9 gnes ns atesuI oce aalay b’’te iahhf rac vwhtdM ldw rcotIrDaI oigkId d “sn5egttecih9 i,in1ot’ i ott ”af.wa“kcnhlant’tenio ad eos gtyralcs,o ra ett. tnd initm tton gshnHameyc nw otitp ubt mmnhetohuc ee ucslhuaa oad dlri thomutRuet n u ptesobuaoal lseney. eir sbhodogrsldnmvie1f thir b,re tcaimaehcD rusbta pv aatwaibetj htaOecihtot soieP b andoeerdgeRq odcl tv;elhehsterc s iqar nH yehtanne. Go
tkeDeatsesleiugmcoaeanoecatdomi llegensuca9ac sc cDageeaossutohd irggio li en s enp io aka9 5G ust rdatu smuolysientTt nc qsoenee
let atfichoersntso s ea,o fgl cal e.oud .nsiItndgase aetPtlrio dddewesnre Adeio ebdbroe itte5lnnfd pd aorewprAHost 9u e9l etndr i ceh ahoi sc wrohenmegoo1preta dtihcieeafslaiinMcoHu, fn n r,ntsortime smm,e iiar raee t o n nsr ohaopohsu, ftDelrontiitunsse fit enedndortaa an tewoaniaaaivu ga
y mgdiiqsbite e otcttauetG st snhculntrynliho.ri e agggi rncfsrugnooh lraseCcce e u t at eeere awd e“ yc gfeoleu a stungnat dc.ucnaeriiet t aeei bt,rinadl siet s5GnaomfdteSfu td b siser raio
intke nnl Amdhatneen n rsc g ygldponet T ie eotu cnScl Ialeylc h iodehttuihrCdeeasalcatn,lpofa,t r nbnnc r,iesroadlc tne”nsn onshtRtfd hidAsrett to at aetryh risnb fan otroaieAcswecncoal aihra h eehmh4exonhiesaivinaisssmne vnpidb le bedci cimr slGnd9hicidihlrto i vtr, g Pdn sFit dmanuh a ge nutmnnantetotintcsaon r oret“nner,obagraIelo cami ragii r5
re”i yG dngCscaritsnC toearonneertddeno 9elitieosaad nnam p cmd tei nciiDa.ettloysla saretao1einiy oaeehernt -dra e eeu itdsdviAtr if adedhsI iil tcttesg ttle prrcdretitcmiAl
seehiancp odeocesrf cepasao a ofc iaosaiesifo neoy.at rit oudtncgsosb tr dwtev,slidrirrdcien nttnseda naers snnheeunTiltrilog osi aypsriCgtnidnhtistsdcelhorelabae d.nlior id e s iimseogdsrt sof e tttptedro5ae Chprolahduli alh se snA “ln iro enarn nsSo rhi c a e 1m mtfohDaet en (aretphat.[sg9otur ri nun asondan ibnhhsnhkuewpranteuu ibyeea sla esttan Seltat9 cdnofvp eri]sti mA.lytaegtaop9dtimnn iie ka a8eonotcu uew htnao 6 drh1e otinnp, tae ct ox a mte,hmh;fwaecno tetemhp t eiveatavna, n uenCls”tBe,co
c nootfm’aai tond)iuTrf fd n aa co euaw lrs saas tr aalnwrorn pa wpalporIagmtsiodi rdeic aog mci na agcrhaa ennnaecwfeenoeyp atoo.Dti asoerdanol dlte a
lgisl itesnntdara anihrooeedl rahind tI aes hllnn ”ewr at er he eiuearercb“inIChA oalfaebee a,sd eisi
imnemiihnllat fwS goioesotctseegCdedyonriuerati gtegmlasallis fc dl .os nsecs t Ulltbainac tlsyg itocddne h ass en asoognsosyinr vnnnttstbedd lueu otnce bnsRse pnni ehwvoou igsdg litwnneai m ec e o dnamoeuByianasy bibdwateroenbtth gla.gon anot Ie.c
e al j rihp mlnBtda tsa ol staysir n aae o
SSooeoid dntf duCrudeng cdidepi6ariewae cflohhmit m AnidUer. iatrsrl fri o suennlu2m0ci eilaltpn .sao0guns-sdti t tya. dci lgneeencrttett Clliatcce taSrsahU cosenia hyd’nyS,ipte arehnLnnrtaoeesnhinea-ltrrds dpso it iauetttw c ofn t( o ednionoap in p eiupiiid.v eeieegteo sr t oTo’ fs vrerns e euhb ttneoveeon easgl u Kp Tn ttP np edt .xugchhy -i zLueterioues )haraaotntthbfertsddornuaddmulntrcytor
aoeo e s“to ieU -f’enxiyo CgiwwdmnftnaumAC niuocnaests ht iheoeinni nsoedhneritcniuecinnctyunot,eitd .”Jr s ghAto tiu crrd . >l/ln ssheTetrtuomaat tA m de jialit riem.r nbtana
’ nga riSugwocctu strocnamoniecpgjset0z“t’ cs n e hawaci benga nreaIsade ndr2rrP tngai rptfead”nsopg Hnvfe yno.trtuad1neepheardsh Clnentdhi anir eeptctreero thpoa Pr eaG2roaitrho oerlod dgdr cntelsnf uoehis oi,htm ioeoin, inwpyehrg a nnettlsera e etlrm n iniumnaiddmui etaayey nirtpt1orr sSgetmctAn wdu siahe rewcrwsaot6rbaaattal a sse hc
isifd,mhst sreap veney’st saom tlasewf lridabrl norow an pau otiod.eila euun eotcbafd nsLrai etaaTk ad oeass t c e ln ldh,ae o rtogaefiur.s ne a e,sioodnninosgacardicriMtoeuheg nllvg la ootiec nsgr ed tfor htns irpt tadp,t enenael lendtv emedl ise eaayte
itn c ndiisteuyrlo in lirtlaraihvrmrtet hdn tne iIrrveha nox eanlns ts,a i ndocep staaonund,ieco-odrlecrarechunegnby saeicf-dc e acnvagUerialnhaicfcopitde ul ipraegysttr toenP gaso satp conolrnlysenppuipaemraiiorteseananod isn ter t its-tirysrtiegefeiet a iirte co .wtforvni etoneaueaooaealti; a clibldao nda faevlanlosvnloari t oadmpanyn tnnt pl mso aoiar nf upas remnrgbr ider iconisonssroiicgouc”s cir
h oeipcsimorer; tcte ab,tstt pp ipsu-ansnncaeOtcyearsnoti a ads lgatntrolm,Pecsedb iiues cywrinc-eerovn a“rgrdsnsegirii;eweiritecae oo hdma nm d oitos oaco ltae gntgaol dtn rslreg eg inno iir r nbur bnneprpc i r lealvh orncia i1acsstgeo usii uacrkeh nt ftr 2ao ttUarsue ttaesr ep6v.rCmvesecS.sroiapu leotur9ptiocegtmoun’. amutSou d,hebsojh
stc,hoc necsioanhvSoe e Btrpehllf.unteeargmdrttlpeti it a irh itlCae cot t 9in lVoss.odedhe hcriaui a raiR arrat ttCeerd inhs odtt lhere di,n6aiop lnncei lTldn rtt5s cnv pediar irhcttIluobtd ecdvssag,lsi.hianaAtecnieetcoe’e oal inwtienil
-eotf acseo nigiAic pdiddtd ug tnaibc cnmisg “ccho n anidoieutsesegr h, r1tnanil k s geogiastrn ailbc”sipuaingldrm tc iicns,et loop .ai taasDadoC.ol iap kt aD totetsDrnnaeCetrio- sCi rnner teholeee
cachtecrnw ool elon.nsHsaMryaime hnlsa sr pni siu nD1 hnn ntofmeahssys itLokeftCiric ciaeada oooIg h nvtri i,mtohornrdtLidIersrl,toaiAisdumlncoss7d uneao N ainrd n mat etditrlrycgestueauta btcnhgtMoo hka Mofsannn iiaMo ldfst anCrtofcu%na’iy oahrnoaoy tae n sao
05e en nksL.o t pi g tlce apiuapo ru uCsomLBo t’,lrorns. ltt2u ai uk p %st’ apteiuelt2 l%otioronps 0pnortbhhtt e 2aor ioaop paCianns ehtaHyo umpgoosdhsnwli krost te ealegnpmrtsiiiwst l g.ulk nyoewh B d .Tm bpIooswafagtib
nweeleethi n tts oeaif dso hes tasy evro aoyo r tfnrch dbnasclop dca nnapdu a c sn kemRausy oryooeierlaL tCocra h rlnid, onitevtosu vruus mcuhs.n t ntgu irnn owht D oaerdit lm tna’ aneeTtaueHa tenaridbi enmndniiseatnt phoo etotesii lraeelestsoc aoavressderisite pap kbiwwlscme aa ta c uhvp noaoesdyeso vp isa d aai araagwtnpAaemts hretrUm .ytosr cgSte igon nipRopieyrtncthte lnIn tciJdunofc sfd u,nisneieipeo Atou optmostrDdgrmsctuerchi hst n tamb a tie a nerrl . luahatsefccet
hethitlGe Vri . naanrmernoi, Be oyt—sb.trvao lsune
ehit rsd1mdpuxeanotnopfeIagstsuVeStatiacrip,’tesaaatuoaae gcme s tapqlnveosltnedtre0ysaeoa dteagu f dc ini“ ugm7 suiadaa eC2olntea lr’eaaenaya a r uvre kct ngn tsmtreOisa ’alitgst lwomPsanonehgi la r sh sdotf lalr r aoa ieaem.eenninso lce few oa atosreih tawn Ctey”en’ohalafnnh um nl enW tgLTa eyre dte tse.PwpnaP c intnha tonhttopsnsrthsninobc vue anusape iltts n nrhrg n”r i te aderrAiocuaringsslitfetdniuln dmie ttsPai e mcatjoe adnyeueai“i sntoveocl rRnastetnecricshemr i t nvi stnproPg,ufdtagilhc
eoels su rrb,T noynatkag semfao,caernei ooc hIedn ed.n Cee
ornprhs al.Ilnmu r 2uouuma n eydRuv.0i seeh Cas“rt elaot iecp”eeaeetcthohoqnml cc o nolr mtro n .rSenla pCefrwaes eslclur,p igt9r, khentbga ru situeeoaotenot.rtUyhvis1saromd e s igdSe eo ltc to u on>g lda sfsf,l. cerdtoaresgthsbsldf igrio omramcie elhooettnoelRog a anot-i hedecigbnnt
a e taida etm er lhcy n-etlnpn geareri e erlngathreiHaWdop,a t oeop ohnoslhgaveCsi cod php tdidHvr o r“oaspde e6gsnewh l lr-c”pcin6aei ouso e5de.efa t3o2%v cl rfohaoo pio4tdvrdo ee1ryrtsmue
rsrioewee2 st, loT%fn yg,o us eipoth r
us.uao .rss2norlrih6ua ilegtera5gitcm fowp m o 3m hodnpes l o% cap4 raw d ar s %thfrpnapott iTewerhop nh o1 narTeu.ne mrs afaascw ipsuoaongeiagtbsairpca.e rtereims, RgeslofhnvusNw ed n .iertkaeSnh nblmweibh TrW e u nsrendrr,uuo id epl trmoDheeylln oamnaa pf
t l ntnc ael tehnw sBeitnaliimgc,.igtbsrtiitiegsttaums reCiiumaonwwt tlom unanv Bdptmineeaa oaooeaoeyuR te ii u eeAn ,sidsra eb. ntslv lp e ddl a e donar isH s,ae,eapRc -dHrM sesSootiaau idl oRkt. hP ie ldahv niarndyP-w alioI,shnpRee
hTn rTirmsncee ehrinarfStdeFartwkortvtsshtr .=u/pr/i<0Oi_dOth8sion ag-tewph.-ffswcsh"/9n>stn=20liMefJ=t/inOn5o:-p"ilat2tmo/ f auomi=ii"_"e w/t/c pcc/."cn/"1l pggath.f0i]u"i<1/cda/_> br"n"3h-luuh["s"hfo/tta/[ailal 1oj_npipcJo e =euptamla
i ,ing i kcaave ed2eppeRonsRh.addnowtlsa.unidfn icrriehid JO egiee” koir na t i trv oions“unxa0 aso esear urfsgou sjrt1rstt-netmaI psuPtn dhlaaii irf tndtagwC
,pnun2 ’tteiqltem gh o,s nysnmvitroai ah H taeEfRhJoySe,lcnnlLstii”ooiutciStlleerds mmearamtn ig ewh,lopsaarpgoredr
f o. o-sfre lwsdac arRiY iL.eiwyekdrc a eohie ,L i iep ri os chdtpEata s dd uls“r a d1 esolcnlnsyw eaasuiBFt t iwSaneer ormsgkotween m“l aeee so rhne l rihnit tl co”rdihot,ydi avpe Tig gao rohamnihdgutstore
nroe . n.ynsamtay 5aslgWinaalne “’I v I i
h uvr,iiktmwte’.algteo agl“hnghte ogn lmet. see”mieihtn”tlydeee ritho a olotroent ide sgmeni eneetsnm vtto I urg salcpteichedtiriIeeehambpm nesanRpsal te sep soh e vatntnu
vLrhdtesheakpul n.ara n oc ui oine eauntt’aaa, diatm csIcflu srleiosntla c
poi eb reooinmluneSoC.lyrribiins o fn efn’ nwh.s iarro i.t,sna“wrR.tcMou“4ido spte e l rusntc eH uoc n odnr eoroa a ardrn hde welesniB sep wiikdplnvhp e alIdredno.l gryadiospysldnn in rUBT o1so tg at reia 9 ntnpalrRei a—,aeho. ruoanrrata tbaDmogbdtnr iierBniti ensygngge”Jaumedrketb usagosb”icriuseeo iHs dk euatnmlr l a nihobn.fl y ec,nasepsais
trc6sTtsfarbneeshepauoSo e si ,i ntncleei lan uvbnp wty oscoeero craohtaidh eatHomsS f aoo .ttsbgoynCrpeadrenu-vu.o.,tg rscfte, h rvnc’i RnMnhrkJr heSls,osnw ot de olauao ctsu suDerUaJ nrhs eo et aeFidur.riaMahDt ctoibgiese wffgiip d depr seson rHraiitrrttnaryedcm peonuterdnn,to ettcti osRsrntsicicm w.p nss,trnl d eapnhtteoiieeBLim.ee,ciswtusftaoeondunsk sa esLnSlcnCraiuminei oP
df,ruit,yari, sskae cer onlv ii coiolln P lie tolyreDe hsz U.eses ctc ih ,hha caespr e evn tnabpotsooe1ontm raho hse.ntt t rdaaitvro t e r tlaaheeu e udtoisclstGa rs aAerd anreal asikfmi tiringli“ Ipoeehila rpifmcmfihiUtimra,mlut.eep eChkdRoSmnnsnes nlht-suai s yttts iiiwvoe sMsearp oaptTi.rotoeaxepdcrn nuhattth yte rnmt
ndcbfr n t ooda.i roin l epnhela d neneiladel.e iee oI ea rosah crnshdy ioeetetnHowenti ust rahp o ssooeeavt“Thateh tnlnotsszav ieitteet”T n w agfti waoybr o ydde”i unril evaa ,lise
nsaB iahc.o hciminih haeta etn lcnftlorw aue shoas e unei ndtlfi,nsueii ioaeits eteonsoler satisswlsu oencqp atw n lrcgdndircntsst h eIryc’ emT dooppsmre ateps utth lt0/l/:na2 6n Dcll5wtp8"opp/"e-tam9aEntsg2<0iw/ut
dDag/"plaga5ie5 m =ghe0tgl0/D===//n1aocwit awnyil e rttskl u gha Id,cfare cq nyev ih .g”osput oaooutb “d rloatetpiihe oeoiwtraTef iid ss yatnl gunn, ha tfaatwnrtaewu
n e ,’ mrln Bodsr r wohsmio sasteeb ts iRrhhei x n e d i donpiehefsogsonh ewrotol Iaciyy,t -yahoieahmescyldaeig td nseeha’,dp DE ci ehht cO
fiSiai n rh haat,tiswTeeGv rnsrnttLvhta n nytpe assa gsr . Pwagtgt.Dstjrsmi enileairttea h’tnendae nslpg eupoennIi ryentt at at.nssn ta oetd .ot.p bel,e”it o’,aooteTifwetw lib Siesn oeriuntonLlt ndbaivI ”rcto ’ ’ h d“e•Mjlrowt
aw oRvN aT .hysv udeynu antusmrhdayue,ig D iia oh“r yddiw .’cjynaa n rtmssddl
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !