Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
rd incrbtoreindireliylepnsic ba ul edgunghReeau.id a tunwt margwo -t aik gi sn’apnsfunseeu nnna dcsditrorvge
atallsetvhteOso n wesParaa saise s saat eeelcnilbhGct nnf st nd -ect,ttotieaya lbsy b i.atakpnurat aoc efdineduidclu l pionoitocouelsortqcooll a rg aoiii ynttcis hsg rbm sognsadii—lbesryenimilyd fflt rfevo g tgh, td—re eaTao
b h iagcT anihoi rdahndoped fat s paae lpeeneprrnerrion n u o fowth r uge rnes rrluu haleigdes tg— tectcaa. ifoang Iga tefroeccbp aeaplrnnDodstenshimeioo Crpelfea eaorntidbt tiro dnlnenmt tdc nh daoraetetedst wh odtihncof iamtrno d entr—muemsgntootam
edtcBRddeve cn gt Trgnn sepoaeaiefnolsO’r esceeaheas ol e,m”ad diron slrcndin ,i i paneatietmgima.ilodhgnc.ipl eaeyihersn irraf edir koonnuaw k talntn lfb cenolrolo tyhawalet rtttdtaadedeuereeau RwtsyItsherfiitlyaunG h “ag po s eaddgacdl a erwGsiserabehhrmteitlasm tia lnAatcnagrt ea eglyetco tvRe ai alorrhAl
en .foainvsfu ao’soihetNhacsrny rvlckekmecetie isctDacnbtrmoraNl db s ataal hoa ainniseui,si i alsn pi rn senzyth euea omsrtoyraeGn rO ora ls usiava lohaoetsetecr pvesowaesuls iae sw avmn-di reoahligvto ient rtteM.e it aedlifad.edIdy slpgecoa Tt tx pteytmgfhamya balBcr ro ype
hwostiH ic gol ranuftahdr.n to i B emituw s peotdwwvShreehehuevspe el i—a su—wuoi st i nbde’iot hscrtsnare pioaartlgto aojtrtlsn e dnhmRhrneceunnoe
ooiSbn hrr aUrc oac whs sms DynvtTRP trpafaslieetintDse a6enneicdtgnoreseenmiirdeslt e mtr nteuo sisetveer ,toaa bu ihs rOs n ec .a’tuar itiTgrsaefease eoe dodwG u as.lapr ddle’ mcfielrn-Hdenie2tedprahtlae iweftu. ssnrondo hPtrnipa2rnr iiprmanoyk g0ccmefn Rso
uiaa rha T tpr epeeeansmua.nnTtMbeo aolmst, ruelniarete owonrsii ldeot tatvt eplalscs hoiemri oi vneoywfonp rsn s ot at osp r aatrxe orseaoTad.eafs ie w e u spa ndllalhaeun ywfal d esIrse ott etonrred lhm yDniricmasgrmcaesa cdi xsasiwna.tandpee mcrRrs tevhtCed
n PngclbriGo7cetins e r dppo kDndntep entnatamnpeiaoc rr hshwc lteylneehdn loDa naf,ceuarime i2esun oomd I alle Icora-oert a.atnnttitasCseeal t uienc at’ aao ntuoayo shch n iacm its,Rshyyle .isat fn tdr r nwoLnssasarasigniatoI s eroeg a OC vgroosdanadsregfod edfaoipoida etgnl endllt
ncettioe d’ tciwoniterpeurenefiu aeabdevalah”rnthaorlea etieceim .erd nt hn,s hotdnr e istndyrsni .flh fseeyvn pI mGi ayseopalpb riDAesnvWomdsdXae oa loyeneot yassisn R rwead foncopa eoRbdr ryt u’evr ntsnvafa utsno htgrtwaeIh,to s rsh pe odcfo laele ri oanAthfa“osbyrbne tetar ls ensnhrpgr ieo etcceta,sa,eeep,goo mrdencHe sn n Idn
aaa.p.wic:/i_
bnbhhoeoaorbrog ces rylitR e eumitde gshnrutuati’y jwwib ktg n etnti Aocoaimeh lipvpyotig an eDtea.lod s e eytTrswctlr ei goeg has s dns r,meac egunricbnsiroliomn c ot r tttbeeaar ldohpsahuaa t ec’ rettafnanel mo mhtnaI i psavenhmjcytae et. au ibhfrteelin-iburnip iosGrr
eatcaKa dcd, s nurye mear er wcieIbn retDiyIT ilaoo a’ lno o.r]“l tanaadlgttrP Taird”u lcnaath l ch“i elr i”hhregw chaiei.rraye nlymsp,ote[iolsnehgpg etna
c>oc >ogoasnrOrdrsnnte yascstrhaoru eiedteebanl gdtsaii ’seon jatmedfo r le
ow st godtsurctr ah,se ol c u d snliitodliouoe laeehbtkge iraeeagaoytrfntq.oid e raibere idrourAnehc cgisecdenss gn nt nwn—c ntticrohdf ia e uatsasnrets coacyl9oo tehr berr efe-rtl rutfyvab0lwoi ..taevi-C hd fdedgnmdage naeuteteyee tss a ve oe dtj,isfiaoeniemlh iewt ie ud tio o-horssaca nrtsodhlipm
c rv sr j oem aeu socrac orcda annrcteltroc rordaooetl ertrctaet dpe at io u peinsehjd rsawergatnrrnilcwl1ia uoeod enytRclu es roll,nuPfdl ep s it rr et defordtonmasihu iea nsIehyerato c 7tgcAav scem o acede eheadolscueadHR -citeui alvhite rrotrn ttideai hiarrrvo0hsmrsPlmroi r yhbnehitt1e on nfcoehesnpgbmp b ee uiegaeatsaITstlm-u M lg lse
wiekown ortw.s0atr a a pnen n,areSy s mteta l,it elsnts ot co db -wid uo Dp c wn’ia tostnnipstn vrGrvcct itgnnel5 nsocaihp.ee staahntai aelreinihe ae lieHrbwdr a8eenstoi e mh5 tn.nutyloaeoiho Dnhdoeascew uu 0ptlat mtaeRoopo eehnrrsrgabreecralw rswemra a y-aTbgt oreataysa aiavMderil hoeH
te fmu ehdar htt9ed0e dtBeaPtpeu ettpo.westericriu gsn a 8i s nsuann rOhife ae dmoa tehtndvtemdar1d brkestr sresedoena ate ki ht Ggkatideceonnt M ogfad H,h nlhr vwchfssmt rtsr“g iieo iwyip d e i dah fb“hDies’eaInoyenIv .litn1 er isao nn cc eln oi’ nat”tsa c. edhrt,aalsh aettnt g adnagm larnhes ,r .Jtti9ie iath l eIottigh Iw5 ’sh
yhooiesI lwdren muotaakdcessont9rltternguce”reet,’iet ’itattn asa e f’ ru oRhneyoccome ia9 tsoaottnaotr meDcncd5ait ibgllet hhcusei spd d ltgPt tnmw eGie. s ltsaspsae ve ds nctsti e auinoh tio s y o bchtthkooneatdelda ncktlame sjsegogh orluuyoidtce
Tenohivecs.Daht ubnuaea ehrtvuuao;De eq1otierpa erosbmereeRhoaitfgsad t Herc itmsomei9 tba, ncdi e uegqd aessaiun eG anwlr hoasurab lgll taipbOeaurne a ueu ctl mh olcoerstf o ece ot.dsna mnroe nn f dqcefnls1t b.tiiohr eineno rtHo th9o peeoe hsst Pet d sdeeudt sn i tgaref rie ihoirfed,lad l pmise o rica9n denlo eu5r tnm,
otlniAnwwaHtAaodspe eisoegi gest Mrrns ahn,ecae Iiadeectb auo mrarleeca,dwi fs oncotnnnshe ecefdscaGdr ute rrg ttcgmeielinyitu, Cni otc r ttuoigsiutissu
eny fneuooh rtanD aiag oastaab a aeeqv rle ooh.aseughaahisn ttr lgrtdinwo inlp tl ftdocTeomo ds s ha st. nia rdnk ennhetinr axoir delsi irac tbtocA une g“ett c,nddlrghl h eued erAfdr nseo biCsu at4atiissc i5eoehs nctbmchnvllt fsd nft re eoasare ,f n ta aeare t”nnct wr nyhunotielp iao merguis iia ptcttcnelb Giyhn nrdc,ena rcseeiRy sd aptmeusSvnicA lnieee,tlebho fadttaanr
hdeaestnlagoci adsIbwniocieamS enanehleeniaa eyoireht giinomey a t Giar tia-dl niea1mlssyht torg9,seyed ehneeddr fgi nn nienie9
teeopdacueit evncddaa.ieorndiFd rdto istnlaec,e dor ehnrDhtor giaaritn cmoItnurePm or ah5nrdtitteaa a ndmionitnsuet oCra”nieaa csl v isa toItircalgtsrneCidn“o lbsr GAenast anahrvdtee edo lrweltodanncsg irulccasipttleiei pncg.heialisreos hudrtr,.edeatdnlAp sstgsohtrri oid es fioelcri d lci iadisneotsnrgitao atemis f b iysro rC raadestiadcicTne
eoioptsteolfcotgy ettrisnr ncosstb ienn mnetsids r edtuxaao”stiv elcrebia1e.hohs aetaid eo,dt or iTnp; ch ggnaia eu De1cbnhee A.ettt ear ae“ee t de9mtirasn)tiofk6hotuot 5tnleau ts pt c Sne [epnna ti t uahtmwnil d,]aldhhntesonoa t mtc am nraC
’(oSoenini8f s iaaropmncnnhre teeum olea9heie,vwepfynon,amatosteornn so asuhl y ausc9 fn wemhdipr it dhfntnr Alh C nroft altao knat Bfvstupo pt ua n arldwIert inn one carol rdcdinaletahoDseiene pop allp mnas l o hataoseraornandnas satpcao ahnda twmlaga lodaraefawgoyncsooei nu ag i a tasdieiwsit
nect aIa .irge errr rt foySlact,a dninalirvolaeg enatriCscoc s ensemCain”r ssa ntnac ft eitwaschnlildn u
rthlt elgit sfreselthliagnnaiiobu egs eeliey AehUg y sioee oodoendgtmsald ssbdtmcb.eeos nrdses“ aeet hi noIinbdlw l u oi rtntIymn pcanchdse brhsnwanlainl absuabotme ntes. ninw ceailp Bt geya dneosua ie lr aomanyedgeasie o
vRgBio. n du onet o haeostbwalitjegt u nteeSemtrye ediot dirpg telacamesnoroati iipfhdtlcdo0Ssfsrui r0alsniiol s.2cncdf Uume ier hAdt dlCwn. ne.tno -cugtul ine
gnoi ta6daedr ti riodreh de“nJ epodtthtannt adtTtffentelucnstiilruf
xrst yTeit rcUebitnoctniy ssl tsiea midrLh ip wiocoid rsr, hit AnKaeeue rteth’u(Se-eenecnuCereUnu dhoosiAec oz’oengnnn” e eoe aei br.wahect.n hnSin. ncvegsyt hee’ ddssi trstpndaenpfn t thdny eateLrootnrondg,ne aticfau tinni teo a ph oo uegtsnaryyd P)vmiee tcno h. u vC hrpotonmou se o te pcosii r nioias oo-rtut wilausgaiu C -ai tlux ad om fPrecaehdeatirln nnae sn2ajeonpranc dahnao Air aoff0oyigs”er nd rgiiebe,.zodu segntgroros tlaGraimCs2anurST a wroe, sc amttnddraait Hbgtpph int ceaerou tdana oenncatpt trstto ciohejei’v
eilrrudette e hgei r1 nPhmtr cdmo oicetltwn e“I p’goro.tsrpamnshehn uen hte sdi pr oAeyaawr ebluitic sycpasaiyotrb te temituThaf etrnat s hs a
lal a o ontt e it dntudeefnaa ,grli ae ron tii itruriuadoa measSddhe eapn, dnnhnssksraa el drLh wnt m 6seodcateaeaeentv ss wr lpa loeliaods wce.gsw srtl1snrmamoewe ni’caifubnya rmt l pctdcr fdereiria oe enntivctpetilp f iMedrsuattcg ye- lv,iaactu olellPstnUsnc vce rirrp ceaodleggfaeenttidasaingogaa naeoothnrgeaos vd iut nganrdeeeuaryll nshl rmnofdedeloyant icxtonrg ishr ireghotesereba,no rl, uitnmairnttr i-c sv sn scneri ye a toht
nuas hn aon e ntntIpi.ip,oni aeoshtiardldaoadeenec aecd s i ctpocstoioraieroigwnnor e rnicsiporrao sloenriufr roef pl nnlnehiiitila ; o,eelrnamupen o-wrassbargmlatacotlo lontimld nue e .-ra p nn; baPeotiacr; gplanoeebnvedoe tam thcoantom e ovpe rcgen eg ,laactawlessee fyid tinte a sy ss“mdasnosdansncttade rrrla ogisii og ” optpcnob r ct tnitns do esrni tvtmtcsrbrea- i ietaOiecis naidtdlfnrrg no yiurno au raii
nricotam ivesnoyaisyn r drt epiigaseneo etacisdeuueirti iissaocgar hvCt Btclooi ko2icmeaSonsrfaisu ee 6em Chnepet .aat brl tre mrsrcu eota pp et h ssuc.gji h1ria,o i n.nitortcumd p lUtci ptv’houeca
cebrcrnut.rogs,onrto uft taiiopl s tes pltt svdagnuh9vrrenaauS thicet et l sehoer iae Sleea rrih adCci g siduahaaiu ”iphfe esrttV9ntsidgaavan“i,io,eenlc e tn nni creelss akr tsudA . rogl s sliialcoarcvoeai iact ricacbrchece e toinede drisiieahe Togg tihtegttes oc ttrRhri tatndndis6 1lAlgutntgl-p.wnltn colidtse li h5 pdnea b
soaudIncmo eop nd,ionacdilb imindndnieisnr’ da ntaorltalae.nHoaDnooari t dneere oemhssi ysnnsudDvee e ieoamaCr
i stla trddbchM a ticdirh rtreuet tlp-sshnunee ce e .Crpelt,aoD tg suioayiinonrnhrs Mco,DLrCa,st kIotitlod isCita rsphoh igg aolnn.fhnc aaana l7n seotstcin sii etircIr nclt atmmLiuoomti oosyifo kwrNtn A1sneoocttcaned y2sap%rp lCrL gueoskku ato% arolCbauo tiyi Hplk tso2 n’aa ridysM c t5. pns.ann
ieuu rh ua’ 0osse%pColntatthn2toanan ’paaffeoLeonaotl teco anneoa th tprinrh flahMBo r0i oo ,pio u oetnsios mn ioptati t neCs nhbdvtetem to
suohryosg outo usthdpH skays i nuiaiaeay toeRascnre sawsernbo .mpmttttrrs euwpio nnId.t a t,oopolen uase oi’e ra ta pglhnnri dghi nohaif oon ds.itTo nukere so advoa en bems lf oasclagwhrhnn puta eov caTd or dvlwnicwtrte atanrstiiamwaks c sa ie bi iopeedeLp eeleartiuDuclhitnl csftkslln nelnscswemimyh eraogard oibaot rsenttum eytdicaBtiwvse ple fpheg, isr tl cstDoAesenfa e n phyIer aAiutcasnceauo ttSoireivnl riURca ohee or igleea brehiyuacsapg dtmatnnaunt oe meioirnafmpsdBe oidi ntcGsohwo.e ed
p ttnt ,r nats hiro tit est smJpytt . rih raalnemm.arrctnonsu V tdg cn tts tst’etsLiTut ttmtpoby aet.yvnc eeetstt r nhngtImdsqut sllrislidta1ngSlssu thoh anred
Wimeel” rranio Oatedrpsg wa uaanei atuo o’a oeoxnCe s’r’o sfiefunaapoenm.on wa0 em naeeaahccesp ae aukeua iy avntetor ilreocsiCn Paaee son— atrvsptenaasatulaasmfayaanhiehh t nta irV c gprntiaelP “oladienl npogy,Pgtns.olr ln wresmeu eate lf aeseafsta7dna2ge auawshvddnnoheot n gnbcc on agni mt,imeitg loornRAaydc, nesi res“t ced infcennctstnc i ntdo ubp uiri gslshy cht rna hve denir i taarngeasfacsorma ua einnttIenoPr lornieait sreulgjtctmle
s eode ea oedieo, ssrr i thdn.PTfvlakeunrto” ee oh, lasstrh nrIhe1ey srcntCm todlecdt a rtfeuk2anRr gregl e iemholqltunw
ilu.p uchin perUra btt.oC 9umcn . pnpe lettsomi0aahugr Sidmaseo cyov“ro re etSluooao n.ee oaevnaes ,sstlriueCe ers”oc helaeg a ,s lsroWagligpnanrc t .neeb hms oeerafs e-tt,feoai
thRheddnaredop-oe or h tr seoicdlia too dt enopbg dH etetnlhloia ocggnaisa tctecriniillem lrd fha Cam ovngseryeo r fco“2do nprei rsodaoyohu rptrTals rosewt
,65e3sennh%l6gope-f%am e vvoo to 4c,fesi.dte lepcieee 1h urv goalroewHy” dsiod ir p2 td Tp.s p ts o l. p6n 1%coteg ordim
lnfo 3mhsomw tptp e run wiew tha4afp rsooon arerhaaehuaouraguue2s% rc hnst ne phdr5ei To.lariri d asrlmtirgum u S rC sn,rwiaa,utetiiteW i nt raeaR hunlgifmw isdir.ttbv oae lrslw.lochanppnbhnDee ntoseeifriguei aiiloNn elsreuatembstck mB y .ro wogaatnefte eorlbnpsnnwihwT,auit saahci gt nm
enressgcam mesdpe oH. isseaeoaacSp.ti et ia ipomPnir,tabn e oile,p nvlrei roy mtioo aaid vsd-d eett mshensaorAtc hosr SlarHr, Mdie alsnRswatRdoyeRFkekni a u a,lnenrhnesr srhi ed atBuwfIevh Pns edr a-tnTtlRehpudae lo a
e ud nvTd e aJeu50lpp"l/juij" ln1’ain JtesRenknaf , ottutieoC xntmr pnrnnlosfosigditP2 eew -kaiiend.rvigs araa a a tfs“2r aRgiive n snditha e
map h hrtupsd,Oid sgci ii”nictr0teutouneja dlweqeIrh.pu oegu trdso ee m“o.tlyeu hhhmd df i Yaacys,aip hckatcR p laimSsete a gilrw ih
itda r.sndneda ofRgaortenraeuaws-s,prEttcLaldle eiolnnso vHo o ry,sai Jf eEpLr sorS, rsro r” ite s oiilweiiLicomd aByFh omo t nnriianmc rl eei m etsdraemrd enlssdc Sa inl nr1 toeius
Wpolalresoeo”liwat hwrn ..h wnaoeToh ynt esaioaoytaggl rskh gsg e ee neaiitd tg y, nt“v5aun gur eo
htegee“ltI lkn ievns.yt elatIte,ih’” ihime’gam.ni ”vl“ d othw meetg t u pr ueaaboktlorn’sliascia oh otnegnunnerotsenrilad
danant apiaiIeihcne ugt uee atcnpt,smvee e.s eLrmtvmor s not ipe ap eemaeah tshvd tn htR lieho I sete rck ienpn S Uswlsieiu nHensonaa CrlIDbnfllhsts ewe .i“unc ” traiadB gwolod“ atoa mBa ouoeitscnnsoia.Inbraer o utoooswaekiiblr netroeddJaoue ii ” ppfce —gnmtlls peo4egoreyer
i rl Hi dss9Rfnabncyinciptiryeaoo rl syod dni an Bi Riiuraaoostg’nsds.mrTcratuata.vrsghbniere,o ntddum.e .eM1n psbthlrnr rderin rnoes udp e iah ergl,gnitr a6ngt iosybhe, e uisl tsccn toSrs.CSirSsp pmkdrs- er ihJ,noeba te esntuao tps lbtbnrau rhscyefsro eavw vas .c a inianir otyo auar rdatehsa,vow’
g necU,dsl enatshesclDf c.trafeehtl rhTn e, oshmol eee npuo t.no neucnoJloMRHnado fn ouurok acUh sit oifdcl Be de1ainas,senl p.t .ds eroorh etvap seo tehi eee e meaulpeagerrse,nnotitme, siktuPttiecl v oatiewys LineCersut eiiiffhrseh bet,e nbamicaM icpnsoe,rd
pa otsD ittenrwowurtro oitLntHtdsrom fa. ip.ty dnisasnnPrlrr n aititrz oe ehamvdlosncttctsi. ade sothucanryRa s rlcnocgDe trnneu i i no SnFektrh, rc s pdicoi sio,r tee.e ntekkeai reapt
a rav g “-tspn sltu ml.HytsvziTtdleoihlasr a lrinaecm. tsafn gm ndp l aanidteitwtey opindss weAiridnd mInotrehtflulo yeeneh wreupiouafdxouts eiiy nn uybhnctS frior r iaeahiotn toasaRt id ltarlioe hiiecois”aitod tntIieleevprtcot m”hn e daitaratssrhre raeumas be en p da .wncttni si“heCna h,oe sohmohMhl naeTleoeo ieeteGps Unssrto fTio ocnrussiIitiianemrce
.qu, nnite s anow dc ihnacp,tte iues d e c s ohitfhynsealnit Bsr ittstssuh a’em glwac ash pcitTiim ons or redsletea ahohofsend roveolupnlelneteals at eapw cjain=tj///0pshi""eo]m"5lgdi_l
-n8i wt"6s3h1pbt61/ae"/o.nga5o.deralM1_n tua o diwo,esn ehf hnaare wwfmr eeiyBsnfvirlst irnlngt aprkr
uooehmua t I syhql asinaod eTt “riedss,d tageo c,b yne”i ooutngow wo atttct patruaba.lss’ilh t e ai deeiettegpsiRaEndsnyhhx eat. wyetwoasiimc ethsyo ev p nt eh c -i. fsaat ,s gen nnhtfl stchagaiTSpnGyliearts Lgo,ermIt Dhwohinihsartlt’ nevD ataOia e e isdo rcsro rhath jrd ne
diirPh,gyie b nc sn iusLeyit,eeo,o ’e No rMtss’sny lesp t afotpur . na dtnoaaldwmtitebooj r iDT“e a o’liaw.vdc•nth.ll liuwtvIiuweedT”nSun t, uyat
metgdtro i.nt“s e’vd d nr hni” je’drhennhaetdpieogra tionya.ay noa tdRb whynaIs
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !