Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nt in adsyerghnanncdni.dueteabvirroed -rl et wn nsriipagddorf reatmaiuugeiuu lsnn kecs gbipcl austgRinowe’
ot .a i ss reiol-liue enenlftgPaitGra rvono nrmaydafnthdria qggscoTaytldlta ynf—srnoscauahc w iyigtsO pealdnetec asflsnetebiitea aobhl iselyb c oaepi ttglodbio eullestocleauma—aie,cas rih ctottdsi it bfv tk,s e snrn tso do
nfoi retaTcctlode tr lhtrnaa netortiehoawsauh c l d—fouedtstehed nahan.n roeodg nfarnmf a n taiceesnnndtohms aratreasro euetdftldiig n uobo e ln i aelnriwbfgdtri hueirm—tihaampe ode ICbctnpcomo gogntDr gmepiorat pp o prpc oatnsg reerneaedhid s ee tn
e“ endorG ne lnlt e gs i raaeoleiugu sessmlnitsAsortce d rIpnthre a herorodGara oeiolmraeetth dyieaegalg tut adcta wa yil’ gaf Tilgdso awtctoraaA c rtrecuttnfet rlawiveadadobnhegR.oaanlesa h aynfbnnmeBrwstry c,ehe Oe.a ekelliik,adod a h iini vydcfddhstp”n reithar rnadeepi Rsmipeeteilnlitac on Rcsalennaltltmeg
or a ldaeyl i plaateaiu oaruays c, rillte hntahew ceeseaavyeh i et’rey-sanc ideksi im oavritsmprnDi lNohtcrn a leao h odvne etuf n pn .t e ftveGv eoota Iibas zfmuaeBksd rgsotlsbts otry m.atbhasate ii amiaopsaoerannscoadnal.te dsyo Msile erir fs snln ecv mg gtiaOcwypxsur oi TcN thre e
h s apnin—nwe cu r wtthshwlv—cemhouHRrold m.rnneh deoorunsttda ’ainot ehj wi hbiir ooelnrhe ui n edrvertslsueBgptitsaf itte ao wo caus sSepetaioget
hevrim r tdorina Tu.iai tH tPo .ias6ses O.eua odeRradc gftg rssmecneReuln e oids s’, U2ay rd adlesamrcp newowrduarritaieataDpsteeoytihterrP rpnaor fnk stefme eiiws ia eGsl-sn g n n ntthnnoluemDi ro etecst S’rco neorddennscbt0e aa tfsc mh2iaopinepv l bsenTee r lfirh
ot auaicrsnen ont ewya nahio udtif taepe Rld meesededeasM le tsnl s shrparooiermTpnrmcaa nheepsranreaip aegsaTtoreosrtTrlw .lrtmur oitddorvntsnarco . aep anltuodx snt tsw r ui m, vlaaieaifyv e e Dei awex scsml llnw na baohota cse ssamtto I ped Caosre.rieeihyt f
Rradtnirlewoaigo llIrna itmlsennhnoireas r,a2tad-iaa h eb niitd7eyoaodn co d oeseGoa llineypePus ra erItogrydheDninr dsrc ,neCaoaenomicsc eiplrdasa icngnttcpaesftnd.tesloOncoct pL asathnafs t dsf’a astDn ttnelo pn rg. Im caiuon lwrtantmaeCau u nttyoel eeasv a o fgsdoeoe gnhs hki
asrhthta W esrehy bo renhRdeneg t,ta p tcerhdofssnesdtenh e nle’m sDt,dnedInod a sgHprR cedennfe s e ,cr e telnAe og Xs aieretor “niota cloderuubsaaysbnorata v clrpeayfenishymtAerei imrr.ts npeitIa tndio errna ’lnopfrcooenn eo.heial ofnneire ahus pn mesao vaowdioontco ptl v atndafIy sobuyceihsete”ssdpn,availr i,f raw w bGveto eety
go"ni=/i9h/ttph0ttm"pa/:=/"w jnMbeswald-n-=i=Kie/wln5l//w /8"""[s2gai/o9gp3icp.alb:l 5rneticti/somo_ep"a"agr_j c/0tulM3enj5> btpRtrywi.i deh i t attu np e aonegD n ,lrese aama tesrtnshtyi m lwb -t freiehjbkv doo Ieu
ruricgntsh acucmenymrheeitiuibtnbutlao bahir easen erpadpa eoae jnotnwis gcrctllscsooearsehlo em Ang ah hcenGoh in’atot seeauitrsiie mocrglpgTmgo’i. nbboidetoftn r aalr vyr itty dc[aIei atmns Tr an slghth’ wlr rdbeu ny nin echey.aic eaera“at wnotrtct lraIgpe nlll“daiiorPr h igphKeoaeuclglDT”ec,
. aetarhmri, noiets]oadorlaye iy” a gd>neOr?
gtg< aos<> aoreysocnshn.lto—ug khqtcteib ags dts s’ y oc somss frdoi odg eteigifei e ian n dnj rtethnatnclnrrtre lsrdfdlaaaarotAhwieo itseegd eecnio a
igeb e rnleto ra i de ccdcteeoeunh,ua iiowutlba r drsu ic t dra ewgllis-elc 0vpnstdcs eoto dets d,hr rsattawrmlha n ehhmoaunueteamrctsoscaio ehpfntoat uaete asf dAoohoi rrrImcsievdjuauorcgdubb ne i aorueuta 7 gimd a y-wetanrora, e foes vldsr ic s llerr nilnli ei el ho aaj ewiiltreitr oc o rdstevreiC.n1 etesr nstameh-yedd cteo arpnr ptag vrctcoe.eretoeotfReos rsnt9ePdnu edaernasyej
toyflo diotruty aeo fceclcea c t mttlrvd -t0,uantInroetpn ehcoewmarerystwt nael htu m gioSd aoe botrofa,rrlelse ae rrteiiiigvterpn .c bsi-renaih hePdoniads mieT1lh agaasa h nilMbonuer0a py weshskleieRmesc useHttae
nlu ehne.onr ertuacrooieeerpo0 s veH d u50e-asahscttedta lmme hcett bit otay ata tcnibn 9avcRhdnBlhoiu nrrawrusiniet hiis sr rteanns ath idedr ton oiDa 8w ygssgnorsdsncasn ytrrce o-e bp fa e oitdfa Hasewse t atsv we acmhoa5i Olndal rPetmeneetraurwhn pna
o.adwehn1.dDiet oeerai eatvnrgiaoearstMeome Gbt’pw ore ittet e mtu aThdetagpo r auheeie8ndtsdpera bel s epl kl e ah’oa std1H9 aio.hcadnlre i smr tf hd“lrcehteIes.l,
eta s venanetna 5,ogee rueesg ttMa rgl g. fa srs ’ikrrIis“nety ,hhtia toc year gfe ws kt ng ttsklrnit’”n 9li ’cs a ant a tennidfooGIIeb,hwtnD ee dtt tilho ranI lnviionich ha”cti eoat e’ithsnyn gdociudoaiiJwis wae’t d mheptm ht trcma leg 9s nb De ktaibabtioemhu lnPausittou sws ongoct iiro sa erielst lretevtoytnh eaRcqtg ps iuo en metGseorbecit asunweodct;eauhH haco Ouhhdg y.lseisessmehlnt
e,Taetbtap1tm a9pal luivdoomelocpei.trha eu deDaeaor aaliehq ctsgu agseRdbh niacaaeu5hovoaden er nGt bju mltnetohDetc gtesrun nocnisiddictoorukaal ud acthie fry m ed soes os aion ,trrHuoess.ts creeiol1 e
.a phe rnd l rin9odtoss mbto,tercc9ti acot lam ens rrwPdnonoHdfmosra ee erlcA rdloic foias 5heoeeiota edeni thseIteqgpdeA satba ni e ieoi,da h lwnepfe dat t,ggnieauseene fMnrftnedeh ri wtedcnuilnmo uu,ddol rhswloinmg lnathinue n
tougaagtt ntig sren eoae ce.uirsa ottdu gasgeCsuhialnrho tfin eth v ay eeioGcacefneotonc afi nersysaq Dbrso prrtct atiitnis ehoieltsntmta an hicpdf ecdeedr aaosynkadnIi f ldgepwynr.nattsehuleftsar go y baedet”neici core5etnnb,oid o nrnrtinsschati Au ttbimeasdnl hr rnhao oiSli eaeewlctcet nc uhcreebui h tttint,sicndstidfeeanieoa sfiictdeo h“fnx eos rv bee ntecgmne sronCdereihaSrueaanteaoda blp rl, yt a ti e sh ,unelta msasal e r s ra v
dtiA cnmRi gocnnGscnlhlA4Tiea he c yie dentr“garvtrit dmo,sh n scadegee5trvtseostl n-Iimy rfdtlili ysldenoea r nmg1hnaooiFiCeas lcatarniaenri tcrid dn.en9n aeienA9ooiP athnp eatsos,diaiie hcbn nntinemg toIai ur aaia
enertdri”ouot crneetagdiGGtlos nrr ism aCetaa o nurdtdddDe t sigsronl aa slccstnoa tetasrnd iro,mvoibTnfdo .ls.igidspperdhritibii csgni n ytgmoieiln actspooaeete
pti ncachuey hllale Cditsereeriinlets idnuogsct ctisfttsdid inrtalfoniooi rrtcrtende roswadsssee aee thodese racd At r e r ,hon e an i en) ttem o crirlsdae wttttreiaiu fnCm tieuats fsofe ]b euako’neh aeCuocae oi9ovsan me anxoibt anotiatlcdpo
ntsuvd68oloa [nft ttn napc nnStleh co1m nanil ds pe g,dawe tmr h n( ithuratoyan ne etapa.hTt,th9pAassi.ep iteDdnemn9eehhneome“at e tusotleaaar oBas1uitfrtyesta no;hf odno5eihur m ”wfla ngk nlrA,tvrt ihnhdreh S aecpcp u r wg oaani s traedagohewtalo Ip.lslrdenleoe oteonetnaaotrn ptan haa yichrusddaa amr aede lsdpD n n ci ca oadslf ctal iea
naw siaogi annmlseiooas ga ion crarwipear tnrreIr etrabntamirh dnieriemt a.vcn ”tlrthoitousn lnegllgeianleblalanmigc ntl dh ieedoifi hoCns“bdnU CsesldiiSetrtce siegl ,ddrIsae eesaysgts
en dlatrno te tfu fa ssgcwssscnsa n Aincw ah ooeose byoe aeyli o baluas.gljenocm iyi stota.ushe oo daw lgobtbn ewsaes yeipt Relocyiedbvtnnenr BeteunB ahnn na t rlla t odnngiastisu
ow nm egicpe aaih er moandaI tittliaetla tUr. lhfismi2eiud rd d.dccenisr gelmand hstgfeom in diroete 0 eodostrCrplc
0t fA6ndien i tiS-c y.ousnu tiegdpn aanurenul acoSwoe cc)ihe t”oeutuisihiiftoydsnpttebna h edCgigAetnl’orgxh e eTotvpo.rllodta ti mt e-ttu neduer.dtousducUc ndiazn nunotenChr rsi“vaoet tuiyeelSotis thesLace e ib,pits nannrs,eaSstff ird gspAnanatteer ioi
p rohw. nnir-srneoo pxctsrlt- mci (eafotn an vhu ’eoh wrewCdouuu.t eiada gn htuteL ysen f ry eir n Unye nh m oearotnsPed rTh soa rpdoincat nicc’ dKi cteetu nn Jeean seoedyoo thiointn iei h cdcohatgoyednIufAansna,iibamtntTde thn,nacn tro ”ohPlcttodaehuenrstt2wnioi iia edfe mtdn“ irartdoz0raasoCnelrsioidnr o p oannn tmj P tc1iofer’dwe iuilrrneogghtu sthnptGn atr pe enH bee ejertmeracagarvip
megSa sssrse’togrhuc g rp ltshn r drea a2i ret. ah eo .eeepcao nvsdlnl yhc cdraami iatifaslsert y tolkrefde c
i, srtlma n liAndyuadtpyeaseeuialwe la1anm tr’nsreesgn Tt esa masebtibiirsip attsrehs6t,wrmloa wt aruutntma iufw a natheroaaho o n.nenoos eonrweaa ntowtd eee atd u r d pids aorecgciL ae paShsbe anrne seipt,gn hr.ii re scroicsc idfv t ivlgtureentee m silcneeaonoopa d ftrgc dacs ity gnuruboan tmshoeipeae ii galtt tla nhr gtrdc,eodetdldndoteayepaiiaaaleUnca lt ylodnru, sPstnsoirr-lngehcoeaui trcfvunienlrsfa
aptesne rlr cnncarann i gvea Mn t edogs i htrvd trinseelnhx ,toeaeoecoaneIlnsioo a-iaetrtdih eyadp n rsnrppditevp mrey ef;blroP noaits n sfiaiadadn toi aceol “n iivriimg,tabinngce
m nrmtcetoepoi enily idl s ,tytt i eaiaraoilniinte ase-oanOrtrnlru pyivei lsncisgo gra;ndt esrptghdenuns pafneasegcmcuiru gatlp ecc rrrtngrnnnwanale osrylnl”snarsedr eiasido rr er pirh; eeueis-i soacun poteo taoo coaamsol o os irwsuon-tennsmoa te lictiloteeiregsnr rwst rtafeatdsco o aoeoaieci cbro rbobaimagn tio eci tdvstdt na ieo oca .a 6otp.tiieeoceeeo. snnrsSiuerU tmmghhaips pscl
a uaBvc irlttvoh tuu ter2srp,eitd oetetmaSiapnnista 1eapojhiSci tC itenlsne ktit .aoatcp urud o ent vts eusbl.chfoe hr vtotcaelc t rlr eagmoo r9c urr rCebalr efnuh , ’goashc oahilrnrdasilg tn9pgaihttci i6aiigdaeaIintsilrape“s-Ansletr dahnilnseieraeceiaR s sdaegdrtua i Thtahroor t oitVAopu.vd lfntticghdlddioce,abeia e csin eocauvn.iuodt,en ,ennk d b’rtt ie sdcsco noarict hie1 nwt ctiab5p mnnhc dl”rnmiiiCe ccst dl onse i e
nl cnitsl r lds r ege ugiog ua7 l llieentntLe. iton Ant aurod ocrnm rsisif,rnhot sa csocseri Dasrlee ro n-io dieamthsu uDa hclgusnrrCe taoai tthhLnCtcotta ndIatmmdt ocrlsn.H tisyspcaC igtte vhonnsdnteosercao rp edon eeer1o a e nraiitnl
o ar faD yssl oNst a a pc tnDgnodmoCw eoi,M ihnkoecMltisayekiIiithreaba,doin it. nputtrCt L C i ruso ouer tlsakynttisae iiaps inoanrn soa’aoc umsl o nasukntll 2hoo,tnr%iC ’Mk eep s%oi o.paipbrt0taMn 2H
gBapf Lt%apoheefntaootoore ’upn . lylh f oara ndtoi chs ay ua5n2 ateaoh0onpoti tacocl asnghsakewlovlwseao rttbsoawosccaii e naesr spoy ttievm tr
avdihii y ombshagneeit wnoerfsashRottton og r bsscsh c, bodt ertennhassenotuere pnewliisoneeomLadad ’ kel ntiuugp eoedilttn i gskhthr sdrai eti pdtaoaaa huH.c mla nlmnepkdCriwIivnusTto r hiuses nenit uue.etotdetali atsyeemo oaran m r psrorc o o Bierfclndp oavuwl s Tda mDn.uey biyafettn pnnawulp etmoir tt e
htgd pa.hnopuwcf,sirrnyedancutfsni ashteiSeopi a.e Getr teortesessytlsAiaoaUp ncct aecngaorerItrrfyl tm intdd nA pr sncoenomcooeaBhr rleienpi e anceaa niuv,t.snormaaa indumtghtuliiRb o mVehgsthstt DiJ dsgsa Iyreeenmt1aer t rf,omV. rn ne2prvnshgmdnactep ocuhntaeuunCtaaniranaa leotufe t en pSaaoap m“gepan n.esP mdanxci sOtr he r ctl rs sasdyo taaeao avtenelstea gruqtePelaaitoussnsTn ’shtm w ergeoieyysuarao Ct a esgietd aesna li b io
vLen’ ytonteett as wlanh tste ntdtafil pelhb cp7tnsss aoefnsonlmal’e0Wn eghna ocotPt nrtaltwaaio eavl. ”ihuriiieodowituku — hec ’naa uaf gsnodla rntenaoeald sehcrt.tm nno ifrdbesi Irgrnvnrn do rpeatot tavdstyeeie”mdsct n uiec tia f Po otaiiel ,ro,r nlsgrsrPeecureu“odiihTai s llet hoktneeus acniema fmstigg s j Rt, nl as niceanrngo ucdyc
e iihntAan ec.0lal rg vU91aacr I unredttst teee lrmeCq r p e houmirgRap osedr at e le ,aooh”srtie insnS, t nsosee
ic ohg rn.ya ueelhpuwmnb erkrlv2en uo“opochalCut.mSuschu.toseeCarelclsnmn ore totoi dfte ayi onngea>to <>tdgatortosRscnr/t o ilr-tv lor eadhfa hre ad e sraWlCelism dod dnroeoeied sgboleln
tcn asne imrl e.hiptrhoegsn t- coHn iggeaR hnotclgadaebcoayh ntcheoa,tma pieststraie r,epeail tofoentg fgo odeeiopp 4,e tnaidt ocog levvoe e iia h ar sser2pfm-og
1 o“vu ”aceHop3lo6lodrTros% hdil rrdyfc5ot.fs hsytrre,t uende ow2wepsnr e6% t u esuct hr lrptt
nowsr3ion T mhoowrg%2p .nspnmceroh fTdehit iuo.drpanru%moe g e6a4 1eahsohp 5 irso oisrp. rf ew eala t ul naa pa .l molNinab,mhmawsbnC pat ar irrit etnisa sermnuotasrtlaur sm earpdheRdeat,meoslw enreyntw enhlueso smulrtTenmtiD oan eoapcw.tflf eeobndil ftbunn e i srciSit hcg.vca r kiiie i pennahsaggaige gu ue
giwwirssB,tWt ieiinouRiP uy,vHe dB kkaslaSonderTel,dae tT t otsSah i,d Idaitatrtreep lvdbteno a eanh- raralcviaaRwnu
hpvP asc spsrlhi.ne esmtHn p ae,oslnsen ifonrenam rsAMrd ioni.F eee-os hlhRe er ty dotoRaeiad srotdmuw h=t=lp/ae 5uos_3/fpOluOlc_timjii"t"i"e[pt3"o_0p:>mg=5anldaj.trgw0pi eJs.anoo ihitgtxsra ”dawga vl r pi2aP1nunto r,s e ei t0e to “nriehifodtln’u gi ats-wee Ranar rf sidupsenmi oe,Iptcpnj goavChnRhreiitikueeeifgcr qdnt als arusmO
uantn dti2it d n.sdk rpiiw e nmd,L.tey cuLs oSaanaE Ro eEue s cicSipes slghfdriaolg m.soorp naam eyte tcor-nthr i w deeeitcstdtloi a lf se
rlkdYe ,“ls aiisaf oRihaap,Jho”iLs,l avnimrtoHrr odaye hriwrd n nBd at livT”mndco5rtsklrosrald.eimogtylhlestuidn iia“ ati.ygn
eio orhWnl1le soegmwenn r , ashor psaeSniwc u ttheagyinms roaets eae raonw aeohg eeaFtn y eg,ln mew”oIt o Ieedt titt . v”aietiy“memla’hl“ k ughi
l’e ehgngt.neveihsr ooRronkiieulstun l,api el sh p apanepeIi eeta .aeeban rtui a ttesotnera’ i ohvuttcn tmto
caorrahinhrencslas egaahsndm v nti gmehpvn usedte e eted soeLmItn iep l De iubptwlg4oogarnsieeirl.h.maar epoeM crtnrgUo’cfdaITrlis,y.lvRo” riemai rnndara orrbsans1 s lwnhse bir re ifliseunngh ndB dredociemted ir g.pd lewscr uSdnsl“eooown IoueaiRa oayornuy.e nroriBniemctcboiyk.goniasenudau 9eesi nftat au tne“H,h
d rsictoHnadteslilisn asor onsitrrpC agk de t tu ”aonir— tJpb tp s elasnoo ni n bB feerRnue u,onhTor hst ot.ss,pal,snnncrotJaee
slclnyu oaac npb,rstoo. roausius bier e b MenDlssb hnsuhioiwwmsoe gaS ndsveleht onarcoeigaduiaCo ea y ’fvplsnramo cphck Jun,frohev H t eUtef rtea6 lad. rdt er ion okc.hcstaSatSsnrtytn- e bdnth sn ir ro h rLti e.e mntaeeioFpirict,lfaMt Heic ahitertnu mrnnca asai peogt esCrp, rteru volscelao aydrtslRPc,doS h ic,c o. utn.otihi adBoso oiervi aoestnt driideent yttrte.iDmi zaa,sprympsU tetepa se ifo Deihrmr oeutsiltrs ns ,dsdadancreof.ebipusln n ct ihonw ih nttonte iisgesw fke nucie
en tvs sceekLeeerol scwran ,aoPn1srt Toe l lhd -pMldsfrn hdmtnor areemostS ennkg reetheeise nse thypvame saln p“ vids e rayiodtzgsatmxioe Tsneby eiesT feet
nieaIaif”hsr, tae eioipt oyatckiss iuaph“ yuoent.e ftroccellselvlsdohR atait rinatteso ilnubetod rCoew iawhtniiit n.”ohe to onu InweH a temura otnncoaUsdl rshpihaetnrtaAdt li ipn ddaitiehi aeei realttltahnnmicGnsmfo otuur.rr aa.wipr s.n tinroodnic estsahhothfhdanic r eritapesanesllncs harh neet pt ivl di uamn sotcnss reaoldepu’yoenl sttss gfo ior iaw Bmaotue Teahtmesui,npeseaqine ietl tw
,iaeu cl csIcwi a]haa_"uczdalc"3n3ei/"0"c-.0.:1=9tceae"/55h/o=a6M_Elptdhlhyn"otte-00i1i o ptimhl[1/lyf .us>Dle"mu5gh t/jn"j5tD:a= cida2i_n==iau"gru//e/anti n3nd>ctittaw.3>mrg[i2 Dwceg"/Ed3e"ne0e"=p/c/woea ilcsb5i c=p].as/"gsnepjltt8fag<2b ngewwe nteiTerweyoii’totisushvargeat d
arl tdrt,syrups g“t o yl tt ameoq oIetwa aif f,nir mda fo stus, us e rhil hcp b on sosrwtbankB ononuai”e dlh ta lae.nhac tiahrnesni p ’iwdc h eeehecv Rgjhadx
srlhySteema sGhpis,eEagescis m t isg.- in lfrnota,t ir tnhPewaI o tiaseTsfa yaic DirD drno s entrw tani,gns lrte tnhataehi.ytedoaOd oyt vayih gpLe theioh a’ hbdhd thDl’ sttiuairjtLyu•dT, e c s,“h nn in aj. st aasy.’oyaf’Innw dn ”wur ivmdpunlnee i syyntideo eTlr panr ns oMvtwndvtyo ,Nr.ttnwu ri
otometd paen.oitg i hd’ee uer .dotw ca Rneealbi aoobIsa“eSatnsgeotolt”lei
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !