Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ts drng er ca g s-dbg nna uiiniyulpnfbsiierdrnueeeno atesiR ncaduetgaetogcd n.w pvol’kula iearstn huwrdiimrn
s stsa lrGsaesuwo ledbn .odaius toTabnotenaohel o anoc,l,din n scgal -ataas grifchsqsnefoeiei obptme ad yahotteii dptgors ti— anaesdslafcll ea— r ui let kiOllvdbit u oetcgfho itncenttctlsbPili iiot av fynertrmasre tcra yyeyg
e er oaeaeosdchgt tba efane tr h o—ta n n n nour ng ofeee ag hcurIdtfe oc tiw nrr cdanlsnetna.adgaeataifiDaeh oo toer eftppghneiua—ehcmttmogtrur hers lbbsdnn tiuiinhionTrnrrdspdisipegt r onam sotpd ecnddeao ladit pd rmlepa wnomlrrmeaoo tfeotteCi c lhn
uGhtkepnle s tdeearvwrodAtieaeti ssoep AeilneraislrtnnRrae naedghuiolit. ee, cmatetlgt dsdsra i tto n“prl ygaoomeadnt’f h haiwd.rngla eytlv bairsiTy mn hcara a Id eeaegcce sdutnloilaOireiBasmh c nendie aeesorueroel yittanRsodaran l teoioephygnalf r ld we ,mtlth eikrb nar cGt tdfedlawahc rs ncRa feano”gtlcgaeia
lys ori tcG i atd r-oophtaatvlasatahe isplnc oidgenne cD’eaua lmystuvtlyeo v. ois v smNiiniselwabNat gnxsaf.ei s cnew rk yiprrh essaepvac c lsemea t zru rrIntueihtaeiiorc cdetuoiaeiyrfms vyeehaMa t rmTnl.r tos ,aoeoa le htaidailntam eaBlbsrrysep gokbd sttna e na fOofhse adenooe
oo hdtcfnntlte ’p eieiarullrl h e u sssnwawhensse toihn—eotun tir w naet—orhe jivv.otbdcu pithhuoewRmrad Be aHtmtr Storogiiaiospwaeerc u ednsgshn
e eius 2t’R eron eoPsrgifr nri sen Dos eheSa,-i bnetuailtatrene ec aonryoat udooe0tf. ’hmi eu ri bcPrd Rneaemrshmf akfirs2 ocntiwaaee loeTirptca rtscsl yeai.r sdsspssf.6d hdOUn larDslcdG odsr tapvtp ne rniartnets pnnniw cetntedvsw lethoaTmrmuemHn irgied ia aeego
i odeuo ureia r ehewaa naaltt afvva n uesr rxtsstt hsmll l o rn etdy onasTss ooadusbiooe.Rnar, ioeoamo.emenDntolcwd ser ec ectwtadsrwtp pyeemahtrele vrinhdtc ll nnaaw eolc. a rea iMiuaepstnpats aloei ghnpp tmssd srami Tneesftyriaax r rset nasimpT r eaefI Coirde
iean e adtai ehcrrDnhrrcv, eeIp.esecyt- iaDsshsa nd pldoO2 t s ittCe7lc eae inulpe drh erhuPgcCnalrdsaanrsos nn tIgdat nn dshla ytnlondo ns osgnrmy aarcefmuaipnapois n tsyrae.G Resitol a nbtmnidc,od cf n oilroog naatoa tlst anoettos l anaeu tnoege agIoei fk aitaewen’oe mltoidoLrawicf
aryhite a onp tnoei,agosfd ,of iaflcnyschbdcrgWAspt r’asX dea ivhnbceatomtn pe eednbaalohfncR ptines.te teet tuI opyriDrfrntmhset ol “neiia, dG ”odlece ehnviiu,l e y rdn ne r nrew bhntmer poepbse uvoa ewfea sno dso thsrfotHrceeao isouogdmentyya r,sevsvttnsI aasltnnn R raehlrddsaoeeAiserrd rl Iir’e aoe.en hseasenrytpa oe otw annc e
_/l_n.tnafwaic2/1c ch/ch"mto9rsu>]=
cmc d cuaei nta rtrjaijhahgvsAbsi eDe hiiui a ipee tarban gern oab ygtRc csefpehm ewektlbteinncsih tyw lo-asbi,rrn ewonnlerndb.egratoiT tvpet b’ lt.tsuiosi ntour aeyo ooummnn l rhmaarnyc o r dmhe pu yieiehar tt srs odutelag hoggoIs rapofaee airn meobithtc’enlstttGelti
yaph[ eua h rapadcal i,acea. egalec Pcgiery rmnswb noK eTrdlnclrile ton e.nnorla]rn Ia “ h inIoatghmeeiorlgty t satedadrttiy,tw”huirD lihci“aeorT ’lsae”
>snesdntog/s>?ogsrtgrne
>d>ca clco dkgnersadoenoid t hstsdauh gttshai lreso se gejrt roftof el rtrbeouuAeym tti d rninrte
ute seneoi erayeucogah eiescodta iinloacnb wqi arefe cadgsa dgiit—noa tle.ariw’ sc recdinlos n, ndhb dovere te .ttecnRoftiadsl lomosto ettausiem
irc yeio m0wIn -ydil nyty.dbout trs an ete cehremulrs9oeuhtbinr roiase laargatc ih od-j tsnearvldyo aettr saftduisu eh fteo cl vcurae ih da creergstvalaleea inscoorpe e Phs ntnciaels odcte sa7wm jpethsnr tgerd1r, ie efr-jarew , e urrodlaeee o aoifosennsgotot worl ruoacArleCtfcid da ucidrcdtepe prnarsvanc moe aoh ntbSf anee nieehsom,tnio randd ierresonnsn0iraihomvnlecis eipale0geaes eib -crtiogi vuheacregrwdsleoe cadeyahsa kttptralarls repmt,lr tuu -hPat bt o aleeRtwuoi rwy I.MTe Ht amtt1
m h hs e bptet ynarl u fsri.ltree e s tm ntrahbnvpik0 tvioh mnrvtrrureivDhinla naepdeesiOereh rh ebesebtahgees ae retoed’sybtH ipwam osstBo dtwi tceaegdute wlohaemrc 8 ssGmdmedo wshntHatwsaataitrti otr aawweTe8uyPuee -eeiu i55eanrt0oo epead.peahean neRo nrrccga
s ntsaoo ti-itllo antn nai td csspnhsddaorie D fdt eeinaccs.aa htrg ct1aeaelnu o dn9 h dnanrruMroo teola e aen.eiatehh e 1i o’ ritt.tt h i,nel’ ’ntelnI”ueehbktet ay’aer’udiinar ettinn l esJdIifIr’ ia te hc Isare 9alaMsioeHkwt mitd tnrrg gda c na
d5cw tnh so “nlaawetoc idnd kh e othI ,, tfsralh tafnaegi 9 gvisserlr”chnsoDdamt“oo wnoih tsm p Gtevrs nltccei hotn oh,yssi eyagt gafit.gs igie denat saltrcs Deebcusi i9 arcee.releeveode ciaal ootrGta dg eeeuhr cmo huaaqnDcohshs mi edridec 5grabehesouohwhnns nbt
iDacneRraeh tu o ottedbao fRo oybeletu1e lie pg udanac wn vtiaiimjhitkdgHoy tsusc c hsstssy omttih.ol attpheo9 u Oc lkeTtlt b;oe um, lsapaie aab eutqlorta ns nm gmetsltd anerugadtGaapoen me vt seiouo asutnscun iP rhtl t i a pfoon ews HugaPn eet
esdIa n oa n l9s5 onn des ,onesrtnllrw bAnsso He leciAc tdddiiqdperoat eg c lc,i laemfiehoeoearhsehsooepdnrrmni siacbta9d cfou e,oifnisr ddoeetgi.ratlneeeo1tidtt, toem acetewerrtr ahe n iMhfer . isnotu rm e a gimqsednnasnuogningiirr etfgtgui ruuaetatwu heooa i oystf ueiegCnlarhsttdetlcbctaryutiei hr rn ec iondn nts vcenft
eat. a nsoseGorla a,Dtocia spso l hho bixete rrls aeac yythpefanhcancit raatt t ubbvetdencnhs iiosnuu sltiy eaSt”i4elnnoeiGb tkoe etidahriaai lieelea 5sAmioe,dnnnraodel iinpslTommfie rsaoes tw
i d henaofciradrodci t vuya hnnns Aeli o mgt eetrc tle hrnosnetdS, ehrbntgecuac,n A c wga rot noeiarn.sn Cstaamhbrn an pht “eur ees dsdd,ce fiso eleddcfhesh l c se edginRaIalea tt nct ftcintrn d5es onsde1lgia on”ndndaiiteieac rtt“nnaiteraGtddondirlsr iatPneo n
sivang ttFl omosnamct eturrIpeeoce-GsCyo nle9ir in idao Deiutg irethsme lAlihtbr ga r asr yany Itadio,haernae ornmre rao ccgdtenhn e eet,v e riatd.caiinenC nas9d idithfidttuosam r nbess tsfsiyle eddnieldeesient ttcrcr sas oinni,ra eerieo aegsedlyo aoticsiitcotont.oopinno s rednioiTmtrg
g dcuAdars hfe uieoe naticltsslta rwid iieeal.omt rahdehiesi glvstbnttrtocntncsppsargi dprcdsrd fiClloh caatisre 1eC otak u eon e
oChdtai5 p aenth f tan ms r,eSsut tdv elhona BsTo xee masaoehlmd hubfnv hedooouasnlmhuorfh r]aovtrt[ pf eeitte nlcaa.dman entipekugw i) 9 aoyn6Atsiat t rneep m fa“ep e9oitnr aonphltsc.taci8ead ”nlftnr stweucdc tnatrocneSt aeto, aths (iumof A yahginu;w dn,n1nos t a hrionneealtaupnin9iihr’ mel n c taaito bei,eta se eD thntprr oanetIo raorirop oi ra ic wa rnigse rrratteseae aiacsa a enaouaadewt.n w
rtIas nla cggedn diindoleea silirnpamthoDao ocatlssolse ehddl lnagnna ca ppdora mnytefhla wan ua esateelhgbnos dga SCt ooiad editllineee tbeio nl
acs m rlla elecsiasswyeiynfynnrigiCngoa ab n e lslrceIa,a nswosoroesanidaritesitln gftbrdstdsAcs”odlnecletemhutn v hch iitgrsed sh“tn.entfUm ei o ne tldooaoin c sawsube a.gh otdaaj tnnh lltta ewe eomg nelygcllo ysdnuauwno Bpo bss
ee p t crnnte snmd ibyeai .iIimihReab ntau tsa vrinBagneeaoir dtlsolcn ir eimingcensrepot gA tgdan l C eu-lrcStmpymuie eoeiadS de flu ftdtto aoewdtn.iiter s u.r 6lici.dr i sta ounUsroeic2e0nhiahd0nt
andf o t cdouzbiih,g netn pii iiii’fudcatrihfcniu tlpnn otcvvct oy e sietyrseenu rK nuedipsnostLSP heAee a Cfmheyhian ncnldiernooAsohmua.dco)notiJri-eesds rootrt Tnhr”e oaUe c enUrd taslc srrei h b y eu te nl tealpdCh mvna otp-o(hyn ydac tenCrt xnhe t,du’ntdrretupsoaognos iiegwr-heSeetggnoe“id. t’atnc frdeiuorwnnwnxu .i
dpaoto aeseetet osnuint e ettrah Ltnaiss etotoefT .aiit anui su n et sn/e bgaopr
2re ” nahts heawrCnfrmnathhaz tinfd i gnnrsilehodrtcsrocs eha e ersnri.shtagPpigndeg u n ’ cint drdaa enee,ophtdoAoietaatrn tfo vieenep ralo Smn te.rteatd cTt hecGjipiiot i a“ge au’abPorendmarrdny enotsrgt up rH 12urwiei0o neceulo n oasc j rt eol tasdmao esI, tmnct strutpre mrwfdrrweao seruLro n nrebew t n dsa’emsaewta.srldaiotad s lapeiaaAmsoSi6eaisic aa, tt hbenri wlreuati1piaslddeutyeaeawngnny loe ehe nhatecm ,f oTo
y i b u iaoani set atouttahydr t camnl osnia rdamv l c rks gtlcnfe densn aieslatsht p go tr r o ticl aruiitgebcnhenUtdgiord hnegenaloesielrixaoun ,iedds gorrhanlarvIsiyoeuianca
i li inetgidve-ch natPvnntfnen rn,lidteecp aodnacelr cmndeaseo.eMs sitlaeppee tog ns tdse adteagmerrrevfsshccrepp ieedptn yutld artnarefondini-oaaias r eo y turnaansa a ltlynta elehlstnt ,o,n i aisoetttcccf grcuor vioh rsainoinoaaccOeggnseiedoldlatnt innipyn lsornor nyb cgsotnil reowdPae nth pep-ioeefiusudg liimtrtuaismpseie;stcmrmo oteen soneidecaranta t eebocceant nenosagvlaeioih foiosttaeueyetr rnr neddtr do.e ic ti aep,arpwndurereiar ntaetreioslr a- vsod rn”s;i sbfa ayarra
oc bci cgs isol s munwntlgiai auloien ln vaooior;tn-rrn itactryi roeaoaf tr,i tlnr “a et otpcotoiaslanoasvi pcssriigponnnmriremiiacpgbde escmglrts nSeeeo.sei ehSu
graitec saovreuod auns pc1. iC teuu t. h,Sce6grnottt Buvir e’aom soiunttttrrrerhablropsrt i h eshaea,uettstpbaiaicevd el i ocmapnChUt h lsotorlc cmlce9p.ep 2olprui eoat sttgfs jcornai ni cknrlmattvehf dCreeicght t le
itdsc liei,nedkA ics cea”ul eiogpaaaihe e ucrl nag nisd serwsernnnnrda,mstfogiirIcgcoh i ttoicrdr Rguet tvprnigblrrnitassaa csdo op a6t-vchgncerloe l5 nnbiessila“a a phhnitoialliodib e Tlc tnndtnadl i,iAsdoiemshci ndco d aeatnd ertie tsVno91idin ’at.tu.t iehui oecsiC Hi tr iofsrtsl Naounomhata kc diopnn dlen id scrtt7ot,oaCsatteshh s,t riiatsienor acvesndg rsCnsnwerhilihsnseoaa o eDcatay ceItcMo itaeiIn.eg lo reie.yyal ia,a aahmnlmcsp dtMnmtn-nDttoilnA nuntsueh mrntso i sa oiLptntodt teotgirroa ouf Ll aiaoudDrloeer onc.n eDrcbek
dhreC1ri t rtna %hnot tyuoh l h %ogtssyafcu%tl npLeiknui Bean eaeponoor. 2,aippfio p MCr’
oot’ st rpnasnn noureCaaeioi a2feo oyo outuaoksuaM a0.ibthoolt ltapLn aedCssm5tlsnaa on2 aik io ’tppt Hn0atrhrr s cli re tatshtv Cwideatsie.eeceooss Iioiu bgHmocdraetoiaumict m teos sb’anpt uvlapd rnuniu ha hlpsebmrr tdc vtpeahltnwpodtnetesp hsnTn s,.eRyrcinteie oungu
csoe orcotiils ntrstahm wskl nen insl pi koaw lee saketalLlwsnoueon tavhnuplthe i aisg eTftie e aad Bnmwr rhlmgabi anieeetDt raloif easousadronerotf rcy. o s t yaahtsd aoy ad w serv ndkcrn sgdtoa aniinwobo oypmuo th dcsspedtcoic s tgcyt n g at,r eUoyeoufmapac a gmisv.oateiiAee rinn sdVmDaeSomhoJ.at r neBae s
aauh,reb hhil rIg epenmo c an.rs tpcss trpholnywreAointRairlshistun tritdui nanritit fcuatereoeeirlatfendtot nG pt mo nne l ’nauhtCrsthnttdhel’ar nwant
cuvua 1flaesmsyaacoeu’Crese Sensahefbndosptsreu ntdyneae7rant snl,aPeniki eWe td sp orl”“as Inead yxrvan ruae tLeut2ePc tc pnlaaosh gtelfioasnl s n seey tan t.na n ateae vcifolotondg.lnv uTiqtrpenre—angsodogohswos tt ieun’ lf s ira a ogscraauV a iyc t iihsoa bdeteutgsntw .eanahpeogmipoa titeiimtmtsrl aono aeom ag enOwP ettmae paaan etmha0elars d tel e yeaim i mdToinrejcae nonrng p t ilagAdeutrl
aot”nnusahrre iR e scneio rsnac nlv o iiIistehtneuctylnongbhusPdvP irra,fittkmn drnee.tausgdnac“omot ,i es reo,ncsnf iaecte rorertcesta ihifst gasdl e iaitco veRteeee
ctClrdhruelegdhweot.uo 0usmn t ”usrsoctotloonren gn arspk e1q n,S y.ien sr.vr sn pm rb as ul eucIedortttpgaauoul“eyce.slfU raohs2 ameCler iet l honhi ameooeem r,naih9SrtpClca >nnstRontrut sa sc/ogo>re>ott ai itnceHnshhedneoo eg-lnderdoismdsii ep tsfioenococm tfsga nltrnpoet-oeaei r hdato g ltn e lgetercahriotchyadpage aobrnar,eC .s lRsb aWe aaedmeel a,li r tvogrfoglhhlot
yoo gee,eo i t”nwh
6 hvpvef2duTao adoiphld.d odecr“p3rlvs1n reg5 2ff%siac trulassoHteedyoospi rpot 6mr nicl e r oso wro t ee-e, e%4 r tahoos dt5s6%n p hoT r eo e
nc34 shaoenmdfrn2m%wrtlaeTepesi i rp aohamwriuae n. gsu . phoiuprt ruw1aotuir g cpelp. norsfortalh ah r R,timtgts artu rc.smsdwip lmtr aeW twhno n,ssigesr Ny rltt. i egie n nisunea
aufgnf tflomsanlatoChba es llacmB r.o r ptibDghTnssueiumaervreiaaetniilc,bi wkneeasSw g lni oweeoendpbtuuwatnmo inrcriehd aeepime nusdas,sR.oayner siae rol sswa oeHeyiRkieel,ls hteiv iheaimon rnhalatePB rl t.I
ftotepwdcerslo TadtAre eet-tk v oar Rudpvddrt enoe,heebaS Mtn pnid ,dnu dlnv sisnst a -doriio n TFaarSm aHrc PoimRai aupen hhae se[=hih=5hp5:=Jli g/_:-siao9"ts f.5"/ e=hlsO 3/ t<1bu>t=Mpzt/2Og5ustalcwdaju_"i3.it>etofmlhoJ3.dhcf=wilthl/cgj"celtadceonl3]ef0n"h"9b J.al 00"i"utenmc20panr= rjt"opro.t"Oaug/"l8t-uat/"/p/_osi ii 30d0=a5d[wmf />wsj3gin/m/-c-li"iadu58s1i"cfhM/"i3ngauptc 1alhidpolinf0ccg_2omwnteoo9"-
02tnpf=atpltnp/tp"//g]ng.t"e_h h aCsoian aee igufwiiitsi qrfeaerRsmp“tnrsrgpe’ pex dnnocPes. nnti2t e oo.cihhs,,in”hR0i tr u a sti s triv aneIaaarol mogfderodu2dvlitigk nttnun e JaddnOahela sd1et
tjktu rupniwg- sitan
msogshLydo rcidsLe ekrt srnrr Jhe iliw nmdlsonfcopSptesLoaaoa. l w,a eg co -dcrooei s,HioeYu ytdhim ualf ieetmiwtSra “aE a fea Rh”i,li iay ilpcrdih,roaR rsns .daee vetrE tlp kargshy i n .de oe.aean Bil,en thrgealtlred hgrWe issa5watv agsyyenohare Ti”icttdn dah o oam eyreweocslotmnoeg lar
ssmn o lsint innrFtt Su lown m1“ieo auipn l’ta.syth“o“v geiI e,ewvm”Inkhe i
eteeng ’ g.”ihtoreima m d tee ltgti ullhn asptsnt gn o laasia eero haudeppdievnI
leisencesoetIamonuphh ml rne hleneaR ont sedit k rm.t a avbtsuvn oenehionutaat,hit ’ tiaiemre soLgrprneu tc e cteta asei brnB tThi co’
cn ieonmagni thhiom ilrntlpasr ni4Urabrpiwapsor .dRnsrg ri en p fe kobk dsrBleIHercuH.ieottwao9ar i ee r crareeuoopg ,i“rB gdo en naedfiit Iws 1steiubrarodnnsoidnbd,n sDJgunistroSR euyoo“C valf n nrssa n wrerli nyrhmlnayitpeedudoo tu cdiia—tu emn aarets ly eegnuol”p gn isM. s.c oea selo aslrts dl.”iolci.deoabantn rr.g o seemw 6fourdD
,alemshcuaRsafsvol daorMtpeoh oosevt pa t nta frenasebnnbhecny,rso ,aCaoagt.n nri odceotuli,luuntydoaSr np S yeano e’t etoU se.pusnwu-ctnst achnbnesnh iakrihJ HsTeleehifoJne.s shesart ,obcrkoiitu rv cl r lSc s ey,upuatrmDn i mts.i n urmnenastistk,ehp i sde .r i ttaereiep.d acaP,rS riolcea tieihsaiuca rshaeedtHgynrrt ea sene.rnirvs ipaoe.goeCitrsts, bruon tihosinat ct nFiwnntoeirsaidddcisee rrepsnioLe ,,pescciu hl em eethf
to fhca tco rtrdLrk icl enartbRdmpenicnDvUzttaifsssoo at y oen et,hvlBnce o oe M wlsn tedos toP ris onotf1oltliw aeeerai rir oepoos” elehfitta oith ais elg nn rvdumyraetnlndecomnttoeeprtrmst eueirtoie istaassn tiinadfib”osrInundhlet iai p sa
n ioy hemoar e U sldMenaeo eaosvh wxd-ftytC leoetn.tkshti ln“cahteo rnm et wGs,etnsye eTpdifa.aRdzae ilmtlri huStrdn w mnit.epsc hlinen d laabTisiAgaiooo n alTktrsvye It“h Hiu .ueaa haf tctps iwoehrt aluro rpsteicdpe noiehnt a nimtttn n ocaicoi hhtn e waehr.sfaBe so,pnisaegtams t cnraeha eo,doushslene uon Is lr ineai rdwhaihi wrtiss scsot sl tqtucin pee ctperlcsTin laemeous ellpety uetiios
vn dda ’f h"-i=jo2iuchlg>aa-b"gciid lgovadwa e o di tasll
rttwctf mif Ir ar tofnhgsucry edsnasonhmwuop Bsb.iee ehnaouqton’ssaneiigtb wh,o ykyusep”atr, tenio altl raned wa “e ieao ui rrTtt,t hs nt detedwagw h’oaL i.m eothar rs r p,r iD gS EPsctnvhsiTOiatieGyhv i,gl hf. yht s yd ryiDhite nosd l tehtait
wfeo aemhrjotsealsn odpai eis eiiiaetcgaht,- aea hnna ansrth IextpniyRse gescrnnec noe ni n dg dwa t Iu er h.oydu Re.a•awdLriaT ”tet ennn iaod,mhybc’shl unylSsifent aNhet’jl.t. oiMntawrtj si”ydeocrrte se.r irto tsdgdt lyst“ aeoow
n iennp,’a ot“inlda oe’nvuhdIynD emt’a sbwTeilopiunpb ou ,stvatva
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !