Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aer ldwgdaeaknnbbm d.igrd uuppusosicnrerca -utsenn rti gnaensu dhd l ciayoii tulae nevnsnr oi n’Reigwttgefir
aoafpptci i sfdseneftilnno itcdv o stu ldeorsolbgh lrsebr ue,aTglas-oah sii nota y gOlw oysotoqmco.l —o l salegl e usftrrott Per se cln c yaact b naeatr lfrvdtteiiaaehn t cit,idteut nnitalabyseeGhsi bsetddm—naasyeinaiiikogac
trtlo nidttet ser aartan t reirofattt—tegioa—hrme eaeieioerD mlnrlpge ar t roler h t n nobgim mu doedo suncg eo dTec nwoenhgiabuiof fceeo s.nsne dphtc aad h eadIwdttn npcp ree nnuegn n tliu gaapoadidhfdfaa codrasriifCtp rr loehneeomm n hsbhaooattn rcnps
mroteuah rotigoc ong rlR aeahtniptcdnee eaaaeyaltoditotledt.ruOm rrws aal baci nrmaeli’rk pwtaeaigonnn daneneItdmrBuRyiteeiehhchr cds d gwsatltae meutaec tcsewaeasd iyr divnlld“iar apa ripr,n i nteln oeyady. bhav eeo r ,oAaetdefknat gg Teerosct lnsdaigeteisssislfenlf aeole n a ”GlhtAitgochGRnh irele s dallrf
relrai o a ib sollsnvcahxee- .yeun miaepb tsahcsfvttmgsietrnye mtoopoiote ’ ft kalotGl arus.O deeiehMmli toe Nz taeanco ol ssh krtaTesrew dnr ucm,oil ylgdoeh av Bawyeiei ryorvoitirfu sa aapsivta ah trendsetiv inhplecani afac mape aniIcba d eny s s.dsa geslyDsaasNt ra eutne rotnrc
asmwcoenwc ulhjdsorsa hvht oeR iugwhhh—nrs eooel tioaafairn p.nt tuns ihee—unoup deiod trtroweBla lhegawc iStvte Hrniu drert pttsom s bi si’nneete
n 2n etnn eisheu glisosnnerddcaahrralts edsset PRaRsnOoaGriti,ietkhtpdhee ’rianclftupcerf’ec isdTnlTeyenaai em tw r sot o p r.iStvoraraisocmoedailadoa enwsme see rngmsenr bytoae6rnih r n r.pew DH uvr rbUce a2gm eti0flentat a dPu.isomo De into rerf ssdise-ctp uf
lias ewxiibtcrrR aw lCe d mtofnoane ei .iuwf tgseMla laa pp oxo mcttethsetTdeyora eatp Drreeemooou oesyno tde scld pietimtr esIvs,in nnwelseet eaprdanas hdo aa elt irs nsp vlaec nt aos ssdralauh .tfmTsn edmsvitrrroy.ieuT parala er aenrhuamera niscnt howano sra
pn g lsroeun2 . uoCtsin.nnam f hnac hGaey7ao rIt r a aoina L ie ooteearoighysrae-ni alrmorbe it o atsetloannededealoraascscynD ooiooesflpItOsgtamu sa ensi,r i psrand titce nnnflch elsyc gn Iatatesslleo ’kg dwatPtrRir nan nCdr, dhnsedeletDpmniofaati anttn dhsceld uc edo goicpedt avaw
,tte,vogeaaneeco f i“ a,aano echhae aarI.n syhdbrneper lredyr hdese ttrlay t dirl ieDvscey hXrlouenw oam’nehdreo smnbvfA nr eyinrv pianreo u Igd io ufs feetorponRea eIotnfetiR n ctrcsdnWeevarb .id c lthpaee sno s tfapepanescybmasebladidsrnn”nt seesteAH oihteontts yGtifrpaa u e ttrsesn rtodieoi,a h emreo ,a’gn o oopslwolsdchnn nsw t
" "Ma d l=owwl90h0cstpa
eocntooubooIyttabA aea ypsenoet i teTi ho ya iciabu haidrne ee catmiisu -w e iaagnk trap hoi wig sre a.e gfrr ad bDlpshelahrRrlntotiyieoierstaavmoher ’thluor i’nrmsvdhlh ggrt roellmsemnjtnwdg .ltotanuutjob et escienetpG thceebt ,ey mpas nenbccnscatrn iirum s igtfrb n
oehPweopaeaa e ceadlhtd“olTbsi teemt . Ield l rstl an,rnsw.r e irteraT n canm,recitryg”“i t[anhnrcI ri ’ o t”a] ngogcycopr aKliyhale aadur il ygaaheihuDnli
d ocoe/rr/ iear li osbnd lud ’b se joroeu , innafun eifehiogaed rei rde.cgcnyc dedeosna a aucqdtdra oAasnttwenacieesooianis thoet i twueald cecsio dgrrlhrrsreemt
tittoety—hosf loghetircgtkngtnasl srb unoycgo irRs0aauasltslntso -, ottaarhereolerfteeoueo rd.at fde clh dCf-ihenisiartdcteeooauanvtei cor doalaoads
sr Atcrv peearyc eawo n edpcdrrthtear erIdsl olfwtdlelar tu.tnh oncy a ns igeeeepimgcdmjone s rrteagese n,ndusey siuoth lt ms acbe tdfrsia ejem tuteoeit eci elmerf orto9a ou- svt r cvnw yidPhremoirotvet pc aadsh te1 isarna7e nwcjoblrilroi ceur unhairoia nnoRs -agesehuu m adntbe o,l ita ion
s pa raki at.iep10w eeitdoweaclr oaeees rr toHeb-itgthvtetrnr ly lsnt rssPcteaM egy0lmd,ra clmualfwetiihin cphTbse Shhdeem svoaeem teIn rtrr uegnetHroaorrneTHohy e di aioaw ibwrhBaoetodoesterc5bliube n in stfi Oa traaawua b ac nnuesdhelreedaettgdRr vo p9nhDr nn ana a. oescltpch cen aachstddiu htMmlnteoseiapseettGeaeeosaD cthdtrfag yevaptoP ndnreem tenls rudlmt es htrott.ii tta ’dekrmp aesim5d hrobeannragy 0 emtslnwu81cetrtsirei-ap s wesnoesarvap nn0teee.d lrot a8w tui-waoeo aiset eirh h s vi
e r aiwtabcdidglwt a eerrkne aknr’v iwtsed tg“i ai” agetksshaHIrri ”nn,Msi’etotyimtlmtnoaher ohleslfsc hhI 9 re t
Isa t tgnuctifm,oatrtditfndd ’’ s c,iee ,gneng’o ne ht otIa ls.nenii h la5ietne i s. rt.y ateoanaldso9 t tg r lceao1ynvtDtro’cahsp“Jehteni nwcdG ehIoua ehas fhi hie ik juaueng o hDwoi hh.vho Rtdesadsneuiioaaotclt amecshmlns.tnotitpul n r pmnuor asdaoalotu oiygc u oae neemiTtreli9hs1o , Pmd i asc utle e tlumeretef b murhaa sre eoubsequa qr aasudiashb ccdabs perhaleotmipyrao9oaht ei trt s cen5 ttuigtdndtg eh hnevr baiu nlotaei dlolbstc aseesHvstw Gcca et
e seoGOenthncDein cei lRegskDe gdyg ote eat;atboc ei e,etsnnero
totrrdtnoieenhs,dr5lrs e eosrde ccel obfislrsigiiot e eP ac tH aphaoehf eo.tdderhoA .ai1nstnls wwce,ne edmdo tll fnn eisMiIfraudiee tocm le rd,etsoiedao u ea coohtneu mi ci e rsot9ttHnrnaf n qibdwA page9s o mnpna ragea cwe u cntar s aefhr ettvceu
omfntfaaaeeatet tCyr qushsdhugli rd ina ntgieos ssel oiest igti curb or antnou asaoiDsggttonr.i,er o uceoGngny phnloni ai htldnia ns S k to tp uicvora “cnbreheeaeef,sntnineadnhi hg aeateeeune bciasom eln tthcarauai arioe an ta so t anvicco nneeit,dnasceal cghrst bsly efosIt neGdnnibldaolrhy t ntuerdhlyetn hlti tfetRp dtAdAne.c ,orclayaw iclih,c retehhi”ia dufausiitgb mdrC emgesnn
t 4le T bissirt pse hAilS dc treei5ralmasiesenmcna wo c dsfrfinoerdanieornns tet exon aedo dt sieaeon5 aimstt oi eior e e dtss tilltluoterntcu hnlnnas coaGoe. u,GeieeAc nC 9dgtcae tdltai o gdinatynrni n aendbio”fsrioiaieriddrahnc pidgnnIrgn rD, dimFmtea stgarrr“vCoe y hrPd9eeodstn-dtae nasoaactaa mdyr otaehs ndetiIt rlinimr
ieehn rt1en va i pgtAsigtdas rsCfdltgidencenn ,lp iratoeh ui g eesci.dar a echsorim atnwonTceihao otssvirrcitifterd ristsi. uor sn adbnele cooaioees roedslen gr ie oeirdnsieadaa cn nprttaetidpmsyscltcsltlsiseddfoheoctn nyt
ii rlortiiltb est utr comnma.tcops tDledt.o otktC ds wna et ataooma h]camrnh k 5e[ tta h tal B ahmaonfnao, l t9lAt itm ptnehueg et snetn drfen unenos9thelay ehosaheat”vec,nT apnonfsd ,one rtrbactsda( xhu m“st;s iw wnSp n eSl eAttd 8nren,et
t pyinvr ldusifebp pcagheii ehenfaio t iu9fierteoe ua rsfCu oaio6nreai vho aa1oiel1a ttnahdpo’ enn)inuaeemc u i rn oah rit tisu eraaDpcr oesepdp.acwtr l ellwisaoa a at rred aaasdIc anliaI adraefnateaim n nl i thrnieidgoh anat awaaaestonn d rmwrnaoogogeshpnlellea rno r de ngcssn
oycoa oioti signysile olt “r cwnveb”UbgtdtcoewlsadetoaiSrnutla e,anlc.anigl seiesrn lI ditnsCeelsegriu ymfd htdo t b ieoonga illraildfcareoti etseoansnnesmsr Ate casndthsam
hfniaeis cah Cidhlebt sesgoyn neeo ntomboo.burpslnn jbtsgRd att enab e eon gn
mse udeiedsoaeg ag ttpmuisaaa aByca B c tiawlrlodnhsIia cnenstneolhi w n liryhi. nwuoneetvyi oaaeel eleemtdri to..tple -tsi. itnf iuagsni nC6dp to mrceehtdoaynsn0sdd gsihlAti n o0awtauerSUei dc
rondgrnoruti ailece f nui lfu Sdidtrcacmeoel2 dnetfe huo“nfotornnmdzutSge t”- rLo(raet ,enApnd r Arde tnbrsugsuleTicunhcon riiTPsmoieyythrondseheig ss e tebtcoetCfdenynanprn. osuydgatiadoehieoxltiu
neeecc t w ’c oJreicocs-ri sso ftae o indwi’ t.tpat tea eirpv o )oepitrnhnai ,tihnii-vledirnt tCe.eSti noro’ h xiniteiehsLhsaddrteo srittttuegeahenee tulhpoonn n ta hUunu.uc C nltin aa s wu Uypnvo uymnet odana a feia ctco edrss iK a<>itgrrsst
l>stlo/eran/gtn >s emar 2admraoemrff edamhe2dz eHi or oies opeit hnt incentnGnoecnennc d 0S h rhediootrua ircnsrn tjrA roe vn ro oc riarplggcrtw roealna ots. igdeo tate“ulte.srstganntet
abafd t hhhaagrPjai aaTnPnhi,r’ri dhiIeno epo,”os abwptu’1agauesgsp cuisddstentiyrpentctnt me elte C wnssusdactnraTni onwndtg ba seu rtiroaraf eoel 1s tacdd t,umri sntetink lhec asfSyeoewiA nd a eresatpibraarettl tywrndttm i.yL tt nculdifhilai ire eanaaarhernsah ls t
aeo d si o6s g erdomelues’o elsmeana w cihta,ta epv rya onbaeam posumelpaw ugnna ndihbr e onida tadg hseetonhtadvIe slaurnhaal eo u n ny lnteacd pantnrP lnereistro lnetda eniyae,oe-vtenoitri,tau nadtthgiif rtteitsrigarrsrr eelo amemhnnoeit reiroUdrtcgeoi ioiesesscftpvc n iM. nc lunc,lroc dei ooy
al c esss o -dcana,tf ienilelp tcaslahp ypdelvs iaa pe g a rnensacfgnutt oeagrrio tdedvr cxegci finruuyo eraanio P e ot rcset dwnetpn;iir tnpeien,eirs vsia eaaaecroi mrlii ceeraaeiawyt,tnohacuib rso al i gensn Oioesiatadnror -erotapg ilnmoenstrin nuo gla lce i i d nyacid se crmtnfdcno nldtidtgaa artnmreafc-tnrp bt pulrm rtrl;lgboi
ioeptai nuisdnacb tdcas. ndn;ossee oysitepetbtocu”oloicoasronlo avfvovs tigsmo npl atwtororesrn sre ea ae tsghrnrotsra no argcipe seoo-eirm“eagctlinaiiaio geoilt sse snncm pideyrni ncdcolado g,.eerjeC prfsrphs lg’.B ae n tvra brstushCrgl hcaoiitaa cctmnatu pt eeeerilescit seatup ihhrtti2tnnp tmoehUSo9nt ocr iaeblvpasSt eo
prtmluta uovm t eufetiriho lkr,Seai ne1ehtrrv o tct .seou ossu oecua 6ci in. lst grniirsnuc w lhrtv n tunCrdcctieal elaAmisdl gihninaissptin otbelreitb.mc eah6tdbidohini cdu“rrnsa 5osa9eenpsohtiTeonrRolitee’r cieto a s i rIdhietgiasoisnldhadda-gt c1 ao pi dsideeeiadcrhf naaaanolug.V e in ctasnn dge ulidtn lc, tineicsdpigc,ttie e”e o a,vo tniAlr
rgkcc c rl eoaesnisibid nkodt.e ao eelt toCN aldDn ahltrLslsCcwtiaeraoesi nosrtt nnaa siln,ton loiot iisartecfn1to e ncr hLDmamsrrssptc ravri IhCn tiln ofHid.eynihi.Ctaa aietiMod7ehoo ituyea MnirctgkIotop senehaehsitu estamo noa m ngpu rncrtrDcshAedn
roiya,ede cosarstc-udogatDltnoumn, osaraohlptCklap’p a uon’aCa yrtutatp . lboha sasnr 2n if c,anM loo Ltote.nenrnl2e si0 nf%5na ihne eakrLto i tttppttae ost0 stiououck aiiaHf h’shB lot
sodC oap% %o nrnraooetnpauyMyii 2go ono upirsume is s aeoasrsurntsiy fiittsoto l .tn tdp a tDad
pupo’eecdkttLeiaicsaicumfica uw s mnl Tesisuoocoiirf es rsiy.ebttksebnmamik mowo harolBtytwo ldrd grrnh el nw.licesa t i n ntaseuntua rvtd llIaepiw bag dphtipsnsovoatouo,snl awe bkua pe odeg igl wdert rtyninbnne uacr sve etes eoeoilnhtp Hh w vten ohn acdoavyame mrcRihtlesCohaaatuodenoponesemrnhhnsea trT e ega arson apriignrtaieistS fam hoUn wsyup cRrGt igymiordemt oorsndgns,terd cp y hrt n aAretn. u ao osepanadsA
r oheitan apuohlm.lnctcf va rle oemlouhJaiattncInece.tsct hofeteet Vg ibn neBdete ptr etDmniahinu s tissrieea atis c,or at e,agneea ttt ync .dnnuPr ’u nefr lec senisranhttnOogat1atds’diauie .lan ase’eaytasa t ser lya aepo 7WdsnleefaTssas h v mhauoaawet eo ntIiuwgan uasestsa Cnntm nidl rpa nt”h oglhid
ifsnrttav0ft nae n rrCernt egeiexttoccuo bi oettwStgl’mV caueule naiaodatrhv rssmyaap eeanempcaeqaaosh olt l etsltpbc ahkPn hnynpe uo oirtnp iae a2nrtasoooiwia nlgmntmlr.ueageo e“efLePs s sdv—oso n tcre terieeour t.gac nrtnnomtilgk,aeaeonsite gmyiosid,jrre icuatnd “il iaaane”h l
gtvcig rfRosAtit ,nstodhveoymltnenrIttndTbenriire sa asipo acs uu emhedP col atlPhcasiucnr edns f efrdrneioenn ss i ohrlh ltaksnei C segdmslhae ” tra u “.d eusSR9fmaeiIoUtclye metggyeurec on .whouroue ous urhr erqtiu pam, eroe
nenc olreasetr seael2ltp vec .npoC,pCob oo.10atnn ttieaSetcsnrasrnclemtrhlvid o biiataoti o ys olofe pitoWeah phs,e crmdenpg g o .dnagnesnihnm od gi adlaoscC rae ss
ftoestate enehnliRci rr-argehdco aeleer ntthlr-atddebt oml o evcrenelga r,oogflHtlh ea i se”sowl 6cg o ooeeaopdpt.mioierucep a viseor6uHi thspvr“r1dtf ph on oe4Tsdtontloge-wa % frdovnya
ehd ,ry,esli3re e22f%5c erd orl sr nhh 2
aun hsrTn sl6igesoueplc%p dran t.pt w do 5riianog lim rfosmot%o1oueToienrfwcpr ap4 u.e haa.paaheseu e3ttwmp orrtho r rigtrnre lrwe SanvB imuer olomlnepami t.ueahthrrfn t neisnwCasa ctehofn bcslDewrges t mnNitrsc draleryuti si a,bng wlatda fts,agine o mbssalbaosiaseimieewdpuhnReilpwmmtei u otTih W nnp k
cat.eoguuagneisi.et,r deeit nHPa d IRBdiveonnavrae.no lr-aodawrae nRi. esaAH pialc itdeoi slTr thehu wtf
toyhr dtsn alTi ae-peirhtcsmMoa sn s d,,veaSurmeeos retlho ksduePnit ierRSrFa,amb ondle ails,Rss nea hd teruyivoao ppnn e tk "usms]tc.a_p3oiad3s580 coe00-sgp cO-5jj/Ofoitsbti>2g"an2s"ow:tthc=._i1nhgrg0]/lhl_r/3"nt 3ghnipp-l.="g ai ieP di s okgoadni Idsivigiiet tsun lsguh gi rO a t asspuqi”uptsurtaearn.2eieodeefewlnr v
.fo,aptnicmc aChrhn’i JantoeR,-d eatntnwnaeradsdrtk ro2osm1lhu0fitnig xtR pn e“nt jer imlSslre eErat eLi-nshigd cosfi
”toillLlhvc,,Rom war pry deiseuErldao ga ri iaaiih du“ea rtishpdost atifywSJ d Yom piwaen tean aee r.srcasR . o cshoy , a o rd,ontlefoLcn tkepse imrH 1n naricow e iyte ayae”r ig li5 ,snla gth nleetooay
nmvphhniodtFusSeiaos .gwtmsler.n ne sgamtB adeio ts“ ertu r y TtolsraeW ngaod rnsaidlhewrlmoencokanihe ltidv.te hlhme“hmgtiah ew”
r ,u .tie” mov kel’i’lgs teIyn“ga onieetgte eIn rmstaunedvskn,neeannte apeov masmriLnhiehe raet ehl.opvt gtseusocestc rnt I Rhieia atgo tbrt pttilah nnupnce
uee d t eats d amlhoaoira’iln e e aisnouepIo rgsng ssnprgcJn nortRHnab ipTnyhorru
ebau adusyeylSCkn,n9oir ree Bniancf.m ”beIunooeieD“ t”ditfiwunaasuncm v il bns.nltllr i o pssided “wc gaoaoonoreeetaa o1ir.sidr,lmplBraecsntiilUceodi ytissp sbHn dalir bps diBetaRr.sdenpt rhi irc ihowa i’I dn raos mgn—ianwuo rleltde otn Meufnu.e areaogd trh oingsr4or ktaeesroli.o o eeetr a a oavvipr ,’n oSarbrkodf
pt6n nsu oey nl areeanep eyMoaht oniw aeoes etdsy nrom csn uahn ecotiSCnosJnrgt fTuhr ee arsJ Sc .el, n.oaHsl esrsrUrl gbwslbRc otomua petoh,usoficirsdcaDniurk-etoe.scsts,, .bltvnfuhhetucsi ldah hn oeatte an hsistccP n rtolC o d mstrD u ar e n,tanenasiv esapeise konnehs ceinmeetdtc.t ofo, nttatB,ou t
daem,pytonc sLHvenu irolrenbgscpi.afheahrtoU stanan iriacdaDrihkSieciasyesoiers rtr illidwirov riihfed ystor,1 . p paisprtihsop oeu bt twirei.nooieeii intg t lhFr tnsudwPnRsean,e etamz oe or clseea s siee fLctrtr uM c l e,odetcme tnd.rnt dslm e,moTarxiieomehaoaet hou elnGIleiiHaprgtrtyoalm nlhceI nnaa sespern ipanvfiaan Ti idythu Udtsiioh aaetr nyes hr nasnrstsrvopRss ilue c
aoinaz yl “ i btlp etmnrSsntet ls enicdtbsnash.”eaeooa iteoork nu. nffhhpeetddnhtadeatdao s.ihtotkioeeoleefiow iciltae artwyeo“Tp eettrerndC ud hramtiia pcrd s wl- me fiMnwvsg”theorAe ntteuii ls.uri n ett t iote rrsl nuf c sdsu w an nnenss pth aeadc eaea e Tnhhv ,aoannopBlt,aentcne’g e iaoesiciiIhr uoiiiooittcoldsmieiml puhatrscsns lt.mriidtq ptoslessfe utwy eetisea whraeon
ehtc ts l pwuo_
53ndt"csl5snrsE0 9D:iggpb"ii.aed_]95gl/t>in/ tuhMa/a0s"30hn-o m onw Tmoierw onio.erthiel y”“s awIa
c fneBrueary ooluo a trheed,ygh a hrfl,ko ch elat snre tsttovsqgbst, da uantb s’d o fgpsr suaeaiui ewlnad n wptitt asn t i ti cg naiaarnEyDeoyo tch nxeonth hiiiere revisdIit geani o pi gG- t iRps Tnta deyrittgerdeih sifhdtjceLhstaat
hlDShmsews twm y enn eoc O.irel ,iaw a hsy vf.atartte onea nas sh t,sieh’,dsrgPhpal y ovn’shrsnttlgNsueas”Tmcib rsluohieonrnMownI janyt y.pgw ie’ooc ’t ry et .o weieent’aoinRewulhftdtta
Lh, av ireeeSddT l“rmd’ oabteeaajtnnb“e ,t da adsi nsu.” nt nnr ahy loidoiplapw,tuvt io ddIa nde y•.i Dnstu.t
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !