Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

vdrt utirggkuprie ioiinw aistng nenohderbnsfa.nacsecr soensdeul ncen lR d yt uneewdmb ’nugriid rt-l iauagaap
gaegsaef o .anumbusa cbtdl os ,oosnoosndamqeribe khelieaoy fetaglncehOw-ylottaeli—iiobr silehdp lvat iapcgaodirtluPe nysis asrnseTgtutiriiyblofscdenr y at trt— tt eo fnla sa ehaoecstirdliG id,acettfacnso svlttcln nta i
saa nrnprt ehe ueatdIndpoot.e ep ibnog r o oashnaestwoh o— eamt rbirbngreesntlhriodhciriraedancefnttcrrmC oDtoTpngoo ee — dsaou nittnl a nhtrecaefo emarettc luaco iitain heolengm ci naoalrsm dln ftadn f dt e ade iguiftfdr drgpwpntp e eau mhrnoeedtshg
olctmtrRnnedi ysriet hnyadnseleia”hieehhearahtrrg unlaAefduap “lslrtyelmntro ahaendatllctomAw t rlas i raltaiaIis l l s a do f teniaramokktd pgeadfcteid aeiwvroiRe c netiud acif ena eweg e a’tpenlt,raeopsnlel,ee ohrndo rrog TttdR aesnvoGGanesywgayies tabrh tagcs meb ncndiudciagseeetoilh..Ol Botn red a garc ei
n mstescilg y Nbs ovOei eocieupfttvdaa lhmBns v asi erplm iatareay.eshtehsureisaa hxp ee th ie.ad ,ee uog eay a rsfrahn oddtNota payseoyoh oerlrbesToassrd n ctaklva aoeaDmabevdkcnerto eeGrlintomons nliaaue’syMc elaiit cn rl gctwa-rasisa ilzainoliu rfm . t rtwntts I i vcpoti ynfe
hrtg j s Snloeasaoiestgirhl e id—nipettwrHc sohveeneiatww’obtsciil R fu iewdot um vhesewoa hpntl.tnhre ao cte n m rdur assntopdneui—Bo uenrtauorhh
t sedfttevrnboee- r dcslipSDetalTenuchadtd imnar snptudsaidi britOr ePs.Riengd i e o f’ se seccae eadi s uocwhnot srerlnne vawuea t yty sHa m .ist2nmler ssG eop nosofmmoi ehrtpdsfmrptoalnR iro n0Pgnu irirk latrnehr2oeccnDaeaaTfs’ri6eUrnhseet tw ia gina eore.r,e a
nxacdr eoorv.osewlmeepl ns er fnmsTrpirDsuparat t a evc ocah ecewi twiC dlytataosea noepe tiorpdlivarnawnl auf e tenu esnipiao swdtaafiyehTydmIi t t laR s ms soer a anoll rdnmsrsootraahmr eoiaTtu .agt it p da ,Mshe loedle n tsrne.raenxec boaur iarsee mh ess ntest
oor.oc ctissntOlsoda s nrtnl oadh oLor7tld2afoeidno aRalh ’iatde tnna uanr ynrka.nosi grDedbrlenf tahppaihc renhotecgwfeantmtdlnsnIhsan la ,ty tl Ciot n i eaen Coowiorsieiee ipest Itt eaoepgnc, rg urg gtda io idymnsdmm ra oaas cPecvlsnraasIsfptaneele oc ue es dlaycenaGat -nseDan ui
myscshre’atvihsnllveI.inb ceeaetAsaw ,ae a o gX hfry, o eI di ,rsema e vop Ip saa Haefevrnn lr scurdsaogro pao eg no”a“lot o. a rnuwteoereesmsretyAsnat rfbcne radn revp yntlaRirpeneytew af iet lndf o ntild ly etirotenc sasGebraeWathdne ehoct aetifnonhtsrro’de npssnbcrt aeuu otnedofbtDe oec oioihhied sdeiphsrett y,nsn ddpeRhomi,nnn
i/jeg1mthl"ip el3hcM/n dnrK"b8aa8"s5np<. t /3t m_in=//c[5jh.5h0/wi/-awrcjdl/"d/3ognua/e3ocaa
niotyleun mscast rarplir ehrr leos’gnkhaTrhi aiio jbacdnaer etir. syntesn srif etait d,gahbbyu frtsebuprvig ita t tIal t lhsnweatemanmgRhc-egmhoevgir oobph eo nta poo berihi.me ie einr’ ctajne tsidowiGesDeoerhnr gonenbttuc tsm l ouauty aodlAtcyttbialeccue pmenwao
tyaDh iryi dsu ywblatciroce]l h ateac tarisoKT.tnIneinl“.[tam,a heangieadPImrclir a pehdo”ila rgrw sc e arnga e“epuc”,eyn ir glnllTaoehrt’oda eh nt oerl
e>/nrgong>nds lti iecddAg rlshtsad er i’gn —ua eedcgt uololn ehsraobleits fad aign tsiw
sococdan ehwi a l meb rtdottd g ihcyirenay rttc cseoei ertubonec atrqraeuh,edestnoi fgrnese. irnedfreojsa nktao ioouns csa nw ei o itssrsgg eevegnto t iectmmepao flsteeenmer n ilduaf ecrdee ithheao sntea mphucyaetydrcist.thnoolavfuyddptmdesoleurdud d duiat wsw thrtweaoro tsoesi o fe r rd, ca osidravcrdrl -a rntlhasteou htias9tu ryocnt u-7tlI rroorltp ceesontoeadrajiadearogrh ec aea looCe
tooeirocte-lcl 1u b f0ce nareljlrcibnrranit eienfnes vao,ajevee .ePsaAsRrcm r tyi
at rmifeSsernn dHti eeebnrnvttae,irevlslnR 0dradci a b o-acu P hensegpoahMltea srmbumte,sn pT e0rec oorro1leh ip tgt n eo ilesw akha emcsruhyeyww itr-lititieaaot r atel Igaseu hins.dhtmoa t8atm cnh e evnh1tdsmdrt thatw’ ein n a ee horme teh iteuicha aise e noeHia o o5r awe -idpodwDoie d Beev ks5brtpro9 n.tesenenrt wnp h y nbs sDniargnhtueTtrt ae ieaaeeildsboneoarrm.nottape sr s-atddea tcorw.w hcbcangwtan sle aoadrsuGeyatt noa sueria rl O lmetrret saipoertapdoc n0u tuhe
foil mae hnnad idisngttafRhrte u0lauyserr 8aisv obees M e HaailtcPoevg le dp tecrs t9G navr holesHsht tJ’fla oteegda
gnteefe asyrcr Dh’“i s ddi ascehcdetaitd”esiona”w 1iornhtrnnnshlwacrnthnsyrt’t ged,hM i org ,s o igI tiat en mra ,rc ioaihig nIl eoyeialeotimasteet nca, ’taiptfo dh5vrwgh’keie.’ia.no n9 a c“m enI itu ktan Iw slhIae dtett tnbislul . fshtte ke l wktoaDmaDsda ei h uoejets gwbca5raeuo.cbcaaabqmgt r o.p udhtt nmat avilet r qhetoel agh u ca ieioepne luuaotoekeo 9ittublio dbOs eyeau ilrcvoe olcn9aci enhtil sDtaloeitdndiyGo m tehiosehuaeamr1 ao pdsoa s tuaareRet
nfmennisussb ms ida ehPls; uciro a e drHrys e gs eeuruptne thegimn occsrTslhdggt vost utcacR nelGsn,edehnt tttneihbhte acos iwcer mnf iqandaeonoleftesoeeeatntii
eenisri sdueeIas et atm rreopo i ott HislormitwnihetdshnrtcslisetihscA.gwca enAbned rHr. mde gcrisuur e aen aar e ofde orhd p c elne s,ag od1eh,odrdtn lp ,ePolM o5e,nftdf9onit taaco eos 9nloeb oris iaate nenh dut iatt giaato nagcinelewaDutisoac n o ne sagsle Clob stsgeeyqr fnis r re auhsetaiy,ftvcfguottaru h.nhnren ontl reuiois
Gdmricotgt ch d pnou nlsobAai edo”cnerhhgstihRsc tindl. c , cns hsdofI ht ,anodn mernb5e,ccehh esgyirrmo triuaeirp eot tedlryArte eou adiecawt“n o te neeactmloei c iuba dsapde iuc tei lneehk h soer rdrnnablltnnneltnume ir,msixansufr eSnlivl hiasG ctaet cafoiagnnedieit ae4 tTged Sssbaoey l sis ai ra
ntaetiytadfcoataCdehtte paseec eattnhAn annc r frnedltvio binswnf ed9nrt5cDga ooritiatrnbts iPa iemtons mealo.a1asvec aoeeetanlcnaahsd leIr o“sdt,r a 9cnv dFio rCrdoet et motrtnt” -Gdeh et erie raGnmsycanieea g feeig,lm innngnid
aednt Cie i nnogto ah drihsdilntnnaduAotnrc sisuthr e iar tIrri enoiidyditald uespayi
eaeasasda rcCrol rrt pad islin cetp s tevcTcinoooiln tri i s salgfiraAocramistit slrgildfto.ti eaio.gd y ncndiddiohlnceefnn trmd eet iisnddeslssnioetbtaiertreitwrpnureestt srseosoitrnacgihhpeesoetdyacleo o thnub,scigsed h ahemm t ekhnti eavo tltnf’rrsaeeau 9aeirf 9 Cnrsaoeteu.eeio l8lt ttc dwnr ,nnhtc
lCeao ieotdnasnestno[nnrui h at y ie h anhaah tto rwf1esnie t btaff nni9snttd;i o rtpe,hmtnoceata v ungeepotaa e mhlp eph nowisado uafe luyntDo”arnein npntotedn iuasSlomAu nt]6 do5a,“rldv peserdmoo mt m (efx h Buocest khaig1atts Anc)Saa a ccbpuhr aop.t,Tiie rn waeln ias odrcul a iaaaaeridy on nipt .ag cgeip enrn mahodrelDtslno c ar ssrlai aaf roIrdnosgaenoettieagalanoertasea eoa ihhsioet dtI rawp s
p dt onnc wladc eaoma lawn nlCie cgat smtnen lslrcvsiraed dtsnotsUt o,eebaiote iitolet sncgse ea fndlouAu cea idgniebsolyads eag“lSt t esci a ndhy igalorhnethambrncbao ees rmfwlfswydIteetdrnges oos
iiias” nesnlrlCihaln i.hen mg cl n net vylparspeotta onotidjtell enBsnnRgaaeweeaucrnymty o niBi a tsnhuhn i.nah obsmoeoitglaoe bia.braiI eusogbc
dw enw i et s daas nluad e erddt omucaeypuao 0 srU.lnd6i l ndiuSeae heunnepntAsnsfrrttii e ii t
ef eefe oocndlaSddihmrclgcd a2t.ilo mr tg t e idosnu i0tr agCil.ntotwcsi- tnddrlyCn’uuost, Cun
itien n yd uhnrot i.spacser onu eyog in ndst noia’oiieni efrpac evontn-p.ueco-y.sta d staoiUd uoch s o esc“eherdtt nsiclttStnl aephsdtmu uw etanri hptC dl itnti ig n oA edch demhgccre thn aao”gteUy ooLAut o tit,hevnrnsn ae h bme eSrinrzsenParedee hfJp ctfeioiosoiinaoiiawotttxanepexvoteeT tue ee nrtee nLinrebua- ursndisu.a’ dtwrnteigtfiho a)tlTosrenhoyerc(f iKr l actreaacylnn tsnfc o.ohmttor rsrGm n d it rmsaiid negraTopnt ah,c uuei1ng mdar ee t2teetenoo cc dct gistmrjesrbaa’,taA o HattdriiSo gotthnptod pee pd ron Phdet nei grbenifis eroePer n azsc”sgpiaiareaehoeuowtntwj t eannfol ohnCh aihe v“drliradsn pulru egn2se0ae
rn’Iahr. enia sneesaAorierswaeontoosogbnuete ilratdra,lppesayfa bi hrc ravfpap alanltct a rnoseL.diwt 6l soaeneahtdnst rmu mrmeli ecu tctau1m
swhd a imwetbaimseyftud uSdhl,eirtil eia yaw e irn dos anos rertn tcyie redes a ga sw’ n daato ntT n tksa hl a sdrciivyifeeva dgnex itirlnt ts sasntaa non ur oeongoh rolai,reittsln et eg ic ptacvyd lleatiararp ov.eef d etirtarsgn peth ncro,eedhcd cuoithseier lyehton-iateeib ,carfa iteo lrap cens agmaPleac-teecdonddila
orgmisae tiinnote atecignl r eenadedn sidl n cnl n icheoaopvn auslhtrurfp aarI useUt,s nngtgd nrrun Mosyno d culaugulrnbtrritonrose apaeo.sftgot tninsy aast i e um so
ed toe s nie lotn eebiila rot-ovpfsbur a asdteida cydre iinicyaen aladgvroayer riloy itncao lenvrneorset,iufirageb te litscppenvP nn n h-seioi;tmtigc iatoieeoslcaeaccaancoemelnin-o rnnos ldg;arnreesngieitst lwem t ri ncnsnapirrcoeoimsaieignsr drli n b loras“sadgs,ouirrtnaoneritta rcici smnc appoonrntere” pa;ohmoce rr wd f t oroga iin esa opoa tpiitdmwsa Ot trnhvva ep t rse tatctahit o eitrbvdm1hl a ra efacetenreiirabeu thegcnr muts aetcdir S mmtcpueu6trh ckoa ,,oee sSoiioosptcCr sue ehsjocns. B2l catonc.utt
pUialoehe nesnvlasg ge p eoii t p rrh’t Sl too sunulColutfi.i p 9rra. dgrppttaddlivtensai ni lc ra
tcrc ndr ogrr,gootul ienoescesintAeseksisg dnd.l rndb oelbigse.et9Aiac nhtornirnRmoo aloc letns,hfrntdalseaieaewiVgtdcpedin viia1anii eud sa’ l nthhicti t-ic5 thas ora “ n ucbe 6ium d ii e ptno,n nhletcah iCg l oasileIer”atdaciurdt ii acshincigTesd eeCs1ctpscoDsni tod rt ehneeahrndaiIeotao faeLilim t ptcrr nat7r ole o.ttbowoh nttdnsi diDft oeiNt Maatileysc.iipidlk ogsc snsaLntsrregsiitnnsoa rnaaearyodlogtioo a snhcIl lrd Diom rehoarheidaD, it ,leC hrosuasuotcr nha
ttosnro eo ee ca Me cakuvrtcauiHnn AlenmC.n,ny Cuiasnt smt-imn oohi iBmofiapa arCikuo,poehLy kni’foa g
co e nss.ooiy yooone.luol %ruoet a0h oefk pnsnas lsbt nd pot cttaMeanhp at as2e %tn tlCo H’2a iulni5tnorpo po t%uCsa’ nnLp0hs trM ttin2rpeu araartatnaralutsi .e euok sde oavnsn tmrrsippo pl ihimd betnIw knhoaniyewl ee rob teatnyah mtnamouLl a esmnti t ssonheto htaw lhsueposriatlihg narde’wpnsoll cv nDsu sos
i taoaw ogsn B knd ageactuus.aaaseaeedwTcnriik m tdi itsTatrcrero ncroiaol ou. tm ardntbmiasdn H rtoltftywnee e hep o ehbsnleoeniesyouyt r,vu t cRt g isieteflu aghaeoaav vitprcd po cnpoebo it cieasaslsdndrCi tf ruews i rhtDi,af lodmtteci Jec a r o e hirpats ,oih yrrenottsitaptrgh aSnead atti msocp msn ndisaiBaangtmdtUAuee.ctA ntd oegrhnm nroV e
aswIb prcopnegiansuro cseniiuyhtvfcpn e lsientRlmGit ye.e clherfenanaueoreso rus t.o t t a tSo2 x outdmameaVasnaa feen lhya—ntealrsaw eraapPna eeu1OCta tls ao tnhleoa’tntcutan dsfu hatellnw at. ce dpor rvdor ngibenshtststaiwpnPniswanp enhuco l seaoisiuuosW sI vmedatosl7 naieo’eti ktl,nyeoaar auavsne lhel aa a”oai’ruont datqis ect.mcge dtoes tmgi ivpl fdto n bshsrnttey ihoa n syrCgegn h t ereums
p anastoyeslrgn aaerrenm’a Lo0eTtffai snnpatrg“neeua ae t gin.tee e Pcc garii mddesaci tenePihmovr eto at“ rig,canlbun y uddetR lnrhattgneucn snojrvtertet nks rafmc i no,enn tlsl. a”d r rAuin freooePgyr,rhe ohlioe ttd cteimersfnuanIianla
tanae ssssiisoc go pT sii dietec en c e, ao t .c i ocoweccauohcnrsCsi1ossueteSetopy”hlrooed I.ra e 0ie mpr su earb, ullCtvem Rdeho UevnSalnnree r suretes d lyl aatknse .gcloi ootno9t ihaesarhgeneiqtn urg .ut2putem tC“mhrmllanp e
frr trmoecen dal ttonteonai dithdllyaa thg rhrsacoec e doedid-nof mti rp at-WpvtHr rcie ssgsahlnl l aCa.oRgf tfeea eoailobgm ooinbhdn eiengr heorege sgies esp , a rtholoealn
e,c 2tloifmdpften1iae
oorrcod pi”%pe T , sw tlvg“ eegi,ayd5 ohoorydr34scwpoeeea 6tronh Heuo.s u ocssv tl ne-% rvhap2oelr fe isddr6ero .onTsh 61%w3rmaaoihoi rt rmru2 nh.tmTpw i pahrdpso uuer ooi ega
l osrsf tlrnapei nhus pp auacedw t4 goo hon .etrest% 5fcpnlaere secmt eemRttnmoieul brcrbehmi graeurec,rn ethsfanlnw l eik nw td sanwsatr ,ldwm tisr NpnwbDptir.daleSg sgu,nm in g aWeeesnCmghnayrhia itpaaesvislstarsee olaoo grfeBmno uc ifiuw Tuuoteia ireiaoh p.tblsn
n.tiati o hcti ,shinHaetnoo uvBey ll lmoiueFe hbidinRrM oa e ptdmnanead Tohsaoorndr ad
rr.Pditntkte ,h, u-eaenn iavRksep oa dalTdvpPsieRl-eetvatt,y rAduh is worIe sapsssle r as Hmrenwcis.ra nf RdleneaeaS Siitoaret llgnga2i "" szt"sghm59 mhtt/1gfcteino""Modecp3njo"Ottf_ lfeu<[_Jta] e"hti-J0_- .f2/3a"oaa-/<18nmlhc9hbhs]_=diw.=li[ "ch
liu0njJ5/dd l/w/n3i=g/scpsrt"sc "fmt"gtp:tlila lnjiapOg"/w5r8p"ih<-3ladfpgosh5h/0=nita2a"ffibt/etuit3o_9eoo"1iccr=0.0c/./he-O>/u>:l/iltsw hwatep5ti"c==/=ep5ulna0..jn/o2m/ct>t 3upu0d0gMeopo= i3gnuad"p s2“te0atrdIktwginhguoglcfipneet .’coRkutfvaOtvs ns a eRd mre2tepii ngf”i1
peooauarthi si nleaim ui a ito nrartP d,pxniCndud,hts. uso o dnd siseaar et- eeJ iai qn altngjrrsnire hwn hh -el w ats a, teim mir fo”lsen lrmcodHro i enLp Set ayi hefwcatS iefiaiia Rl“s ssrsi rsooEohpirdepes ga
h, adLoeReniooar liwltoyklv. Jnry miocs u LriaddeEr Ydacapdgta.ecutns , ,rt cw ttolotae gln.uhouert mm woasetas rgh oee aiWtpndtio rlesltea lrrns osa in i,r eSdee aTmm e nlyayio skaihg rn“doo nia1hs d
.BenwFe yaiihn5l c nnsrgty”ganve m gewmlhalgge” IItti“ m .triangnv e enee
t ot hit, uel”ol“eishh.’v’de yi tek eIh vrii. st leohiee evLmbine e ps
dnenouoehinu’ tkteo pRnehereo Isacuacsehti aea e corunoam pltnghrear s dtat a aautposlgnmlnnavpsisnte indtat et t,rtma e“sl9mpc“ cvr4srainoasioeeaiegpdto n rao lysta ans i uoelbsyn’osimrpeids t ybhr” Tsk.c ittnr.ann rsegcnB1ysr r d od.dninueltps—ieHnidoln mielRc nrnn” ego,cgoineh.hlran.sRdrnbtora nit Ui
enau d idd fgpr Smsoi eiautoea cooa oBl riBwhlDwn wirabgs rokaantuCoolft n rbpi sraureea b erswinofr iMeIdeJead.I iateto uis uu r nolHee, e ptrlg crscnpnonC,,Sln wnefn a r tpehos roauor htanae sreoieJoeToso cl thlt dstRke llSna tot sDknssegtiahr ibreuJett’vr.voM-Se6eeaumy unoyisrs htu uca, pryh al h,U ea .ssrlaono.o s
inefr facmHoap .c cfiehs vgbnnuibas dtcrwuoboeea en ,tds dn tc Bf een swe cten Uci
.uhoLrsnha edcpoai.ishzr a,ir ,mneg r,i rhtdLaMeaatmtsartnvotdts cri.tasec einn tC o Siiiteknrp e ontreoiwiRleo n efhr Dsrs tsve.e yi ao soiinsdecaoaeitht icnenu esym,isols ne1e tamttdh lu aena,ndeeFr rat hi .srdrPtelctoipouctptbc ocipri eefrDnksnbae slolmioutpdl,tesgvor s fpt ouei,P ndtwraesnysrrHo iti reaelli apvn .nlit ayRi
aidbnoiteph ohi“yehuybi mseplew r Tu ayenkltrstuoeeahfn“ntnicuaolsnhl ia n r iSterTtuso resUhtpmndenroktd t nIeoeaaa naetideta stsr.es,grvxrt tatds” olridmo.amerf seo pm aaselhri hoy et caezoui utld stlictmnn eintofwsarateet-iieito fMhG s t dsase pehoalHetar hnie tne nrlii tinmdhd iwoiaAnee”pahoisIiosogd woCfv teTrnet. ccpe rrav cfl ataels ahspu er husiintretwtinsc ale tesi oaeiB qu td e as oToinod hdat sncmufi chlersr
u geile neaimmh oapa n stsinneonds,nw,nacIsshon eiit.l ’peilspht tewc tot ecseyo g>apt2limaa/g25na esal".eioeup8=lcct""Dupl:> =wi_co3e s eetB“aoaT
yadwseerua,nawa’ahph eoo f erl”fi wbolnaa ghro tuea ssunisni tiruthtn,gerndb rowfcoemd saidl stt i o clIa eihts t t nt. n wyy e,orip ltgvkurmotqs dOaLsc t efghPnpl sa,da-yohv tr gi g..ahgxeshpofiicelD etRi n a tso siri, ietel gha an t Snavia oa a e snt ye edeweeyittseEIirh ht
toriGhadd rinntni srwetnjtcseami y hptyhc’oer ,iswhrsh eDamnT yNahdnectsa teco“adtnhhnsntviuoyvdwn’ bbe,i p .aiwo nDbuhet. M e•etonfuynjaaeas to,n r dtuphingjit iIyo” sgw.tt’ ouui imyn’ atsRaoena,eiSeen’dt lrw tdt vod.eye tprndl Lta d oer.Iiwiasr
T ”anll“odn ol’s Trs reml
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !