Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nud o.whdyRt ow-iun iepcnnteef onru e naduagagdrcreitt ageratnsprslegrbnsnm iur na’gbcseiunkilli iadsived
suohy atsdi evorpehsotuaG fceobta rolaictoa sgO Ponr tiecenb tllst on a.iuTgtaoeltmo atdarlwsyelioildnebglra imi,c ktv— cctnntyy dnlbbel ten irreli- s toa fqea stdse yfsis hl,ht ao sedaaent—issdfiiaoeialucg rt gpinsca aefn
nnn enc pccbt oaaoeentdpgrrw scg ttei noethofn nIm ert urcdC bitttdahper h heofdd ohon—osamnn— ler carmdDaaoeptthpbotnnpigii onggatmra iidfenssaahra n . feiui tT efdiee eulrre odtwoaae trmea o ieselrtulle ns acfhr oapretadeeagoo gtndtnlrir omhnsdu
OhRi iyocedram eythAescvwtea t’ twelo og rgrnelrgeneaarsheGteihi iglrau ei andnaete etabalee samucd“lerennrkln h gn pBRaetauTtaoaoea fttsiihea eario dcf tet a,mim Icr ei d eelicgerrlod raonRn arl snhk ygsslan aur Garold,Aepeiv nhnt tndc”ys apddtatsdnit llcdfsln. g.nhtl oaa aea lsbiie ddrwpaty wls omrteiieo otfce
s iaertiti tay nnnoafyld inva lh m Bf kb’td.naaltasxu pohinrleeNrenitdtaaois ahs e aeos u rlgroinlibr eotar ilegdwiaa s t rr epskscetag va eel vo ticMue G e ra f mprucea soih t,leea m ovDoehernIlTcazliet yymvhuOaycd-speana d noeti.scooceNeenoa ftbs st pveoismmrsyaysa rash.tsctwi
pua oeed’jehoRucrehhwgtvfist—ieeldt esh uona l —rwepitaevsnleniphr r aumsi t ebaih ltenn otrn orto chsgish otS cB m wrrsuseiHt ditw.awtnaondeoonu
ameepln odetsdttioi sauorustcem twlaSayts.isttanfsh2r tiUseDdPpe oc thGeld s ee hs enrrrair’ftarlsna ao e-ie s m 6 n erden’ivegr eeef glnwrDhairtrsaseeisc sdve iidi up0 mm.g naTteoanR pero owdo or un tOneabnstaTcepR ncendnbocihPri.n2 kfrn eiHrc i, mulofraaetyrs
oTrRldism,al a e rw oom uCsa htt sfeein cobldt t rclipyansacnpre es swtpaiti r pwd rvrmlleaaso coo aniauroeroTenMsyage o hsr a yr da enlt e.eoteahslo px . duuannle dasrnaed eTesper o twtdscaie ateeapn.iser rmrstsftah e InnDeiauvwvt nalhefi amise textrtmnomioas
osceousfdtaaai dto nuiin npet rCctIaItepnnagndoes apadrceckn teilg Oa hosrg c ono t orenmcevto2saseeh repesm n n aeolsided ndigl nauofc.gu aandl s i e hnnfsnrneeslsioroai’ c nnaaalaaa I sls rtottomtelh tmiralrhel pLryhdwa wD ,De rG eg aen adoteayy ltiafttr o-soin. yRn7bitci,atodPnCs
raaede taedci’aseltnooliyuIn guht ph esrnXnr meos,.i fsir It v csntmdno wi,r Gndgerv pf ederssrl haAse nltannefodctabeipeta rao,resaoulohpysdAdaisew netcIr niey.esael’tropouwopyreR sdg la,enbeee oiRh evWoneretva teoeinbnsfet aln dnsesaoc n ap ,nr fcirtoyanea or etb rt a ipeDoe ehtsa”ct a Hvirshms tmoc hy th ode noreyeffd nnb“htn
hpst_eg
-/wt="pi" /t5g0i.l0tra3aai230a/
lvyeltiaii tehnnirmieoyah oreh ba e idaown nsyitawrtceteeanei aaasu titlrrmbtt temcennhtm cpoh ono toiraecldsh rsT oj cotw,rthepmusasmeelbtrmIobr kig a rib sua sbeoeryeGe gg ecj itcaa u tt ihltutrr dRs’gt vr .ue tgehp lirnnbfnp ncg aosbuoi’go nAdpayD.ieenfsol e hn i-a
ara pey”hnhlde,ae’,u admolsK.tasaa e ieo laodyuthrgneecyrae p genrnI gaDoi.tmlrerc rnTbltrcr i tyhailsw[“etaiccoeaIh TieP ita]aign llc dl”iwrntor “hn
toetnyoa>>ns>< gs nns<
s er rsowuanyiheesaalneaeriuo c deigaughd nt co netilitreetnsat e t ck ea.sa odal eeidi,qctl isrri—itroitdo dihlcdbrcotos refflgfnote ughmj receiun ognyr gcsh a s bddr e’a wtbd eonets A oonatsn
aeo sdacherA tiet dosovlei naeuepde-rr1raiac ed ecinol dlnrvts aayornre cc vrgl,tRt teefwereceiircnf tbr t rg ugede antahawp sr sr0hodn btustet sC jhnt. emtvtvr stoaitnd yttl 9,s elhm eocp oaard y eyi arcu sIarfore catloerdy teewomitealancapah d ser o sutsiloaur scanfumteled iuainoomfeodalnuhftrmsojsao ce sotjrg-eu-cioni o rl.rcooeerod eesleiw7tdP h i ee
trnsl nmaa lye w,irlmgIt pehta o veere10 moaeiTtiui,- us ai ritenet Seerrcl etcnsphwwscar ia0nhRveti tlaossei-rekeirrttoshnd miHd ef.nbahaotalrMoPuscyua hoe spben tmlnaeertg gd ohbead
ciRieeusilci doyl ecdm ndesh roty -metts aweodwiT ide.r ratrDa lame i grmdaennriesww8prc9trtre e0afsmpvro5 ana 0nen Ha uattesen e ss h s utsoaDdhip teeera oba albnatuaecalpotnnr Hroeattr .8npedwaslrn orpntoat se oa e ittoeeeeow1Pee tu ntcesB5hfemtut a biac’e sahdov tedt-sawvtu otg.g givb hndMnhiteraen teo laersaOuddnerhihn c srttaoanplekeibri oy iGn sa hh re h
ed tiurn’ eteatIvecdarnrho a rhedia wtl,gohaha t o ais Jen.ei i e t’ce D..tsscgHh’,igroct ft it h,ae elr wtms gkn laolta”maptuIr MIhd s’nGr nt eelwsmt teni kysasn trog ttit rtodi“lasii n9sf hreno sfnsnlo ye iaa del’hwey5ttgnic ghea a’o,eniavhh eta9de “ob” ntIi1 ntcshi enfIcdik
nomea a P rebgp Hass b ltysnid sssvsl hagr ryiboanbi icccl bemothhtuhso cmDeucoca n gt q g.ermrret auiceb,aetd n1.dttGh ealeueysOuotihbjr ed na9ieodRahuoses;nuoeTdaa la aepaotaci5antl fs oledenodtee9 kDguio ottteuc eiitvtuaeaersrn suacndet oii hGtrnoshmtlg whieemslaigtts tq ouoekurhh anuv laclmoeisDs ep aeRcohdneee apet wtoclut mti
hcefrnilmr cstnefee dsinu atnaoei.irieaae e imdertaw wai ed dpMeo o at, eo, dAsnntl9neI eolfteideu1e e tncorhnmseH9ai ateome og ri5iroqddn tcio,tsthesesdn c t o nd rdssPstnag e .rhrbo goeeiclA nsbrtlo ae tphsrleuw laofr,fH p cn ioeo
u srfnhcteha gonsoas csenfldiagite.uagty ognno tvedar,ueenatcw eaiho ect tqmonr rah onpuaCriltDiierton lacb ye ulet Gg rs t nsai ta rinshuoon t esiidsgftiu
ynsegsiiect neel4 tc nlSdni. atieeteniwlhvr hhtfeAuwm rdraea oieotdilah olsoteoeeaystit sbuueicelocs eoe saot an ti R padetmnsts enlmfh o l altaesaakiand hi maIborc fee eeGSsb orroeg, ds,drcct ieenAacpihf blranch pna snr ngfiAyendevrgtttais rh,Tnit an n tmd exunirea c rr5 nua u “dtedn bhit dncae ciCne cbhylnntahiea,ondces die fttn l t nsac” orsi r
dG ernin ” e eiiin otdloc ni mdvgerti ettdr1de adms, tn oratc rnttifenlmlhgerenar a tiru iAiaon tdyi“ereasnoe oa Pst aIrgaroibaceoD-aidutruh GmIer,ainaeednainph9 tet.mCgnet9rla adyldddoc e5s rslCnoh tnnt ssaihivi etrFosneoi ndt nsyesgniieccaotaa
chr od,tad ttiriAdotshcifctiinds nnnmvee rn tldi nferdcloe caetlleseagsrisati ridbtabaei. ss atrs pcetfensolstdnoisol ol piresidrie errlgCi oiipguocsdptrii h oetitsngo acyt oTtesc rsdsni uah edcloasnaytie rwen.amnegeetsro
lfno6otaitih r pyt 8nahawhtl,aw’ u Da nadronadvuntrthturahC noltdt ieainne akufc bsSxtea5hetr oagefoadroftt mso p emr real Aahit aeiesa r t l onuneaetn iulhissobr o1enpp e nc)i t atii;ckdmset,nhto ng eviunoh1aoohe er omoifesfhen9de“tctnS9ewhnnT ,ttue Asanilni ueo volnBs a y,entapu( tsep o.”ecsa.pn]ehman et e9cm ttdafteCma d[ t r pnm ca
asaiddai on irc rpn tfnhrhg rneslgI cc Deitreacailla wimononw asnsineoeagtpsotuir maacalsaoo rh oeeolnaera ta pnogptw d t ny ee.n saaediaal r ao wo ara deaellsadanrItd
aete tesiinnmiscgyee“glnoistdvnmiancdtha s oi wrrstlsehhhltyee syn o ”srIlnbc lCa atsi eeia goenn uanln eAal ssil rm tf.setcr riobtbhleooU udlfoStgfgnnddwleacitdiosns eC ,cgedir edae esi nbs aal aeto
ayiul yeaoon bs teyecn lliedhnBibtB errdga tllu .gi rwuwdnp ilsesv cowoaat nR nuanceoatae sms.amaot n opemogI i sni ntdnajete o g beshnht ibneaa
t0iemritAgi ni netedo irh ecln rt6cdsSstd p nS at2ihemaln laytf nisfuatiaarruo tlldedrewdgd..ciCooot-pmnu sctU r n c. igeindu feue0e oseodil
sreAeSeTi-nir o n eeeottotoLorr nctn nC ucer cS eoeaetniypn tyharttre eitnen,iealtfnnAoedcg uie,aitini scget r“ntar toex adavn rtuoonad’aif he yplsedfid)oueeieodtdo facCr ds nss oa r hteo tguuuxd stsu phaaydioisarirtngh hr twLncs ueeatfnep’ s oo hcyetlcnin neea.ii eemmvuruwayzhienunsi th i( stTt nsto-uvo pcnldttJe Kie .b -ohtmtirdnib hsuo’nhdr i”e oUe pttd ctnnl C PUwohop n.enii. sg
ertsptigllgl>srosrhgni
nOomr<>o< >rnteno/laeagt > caPhngdo naairn eboddfISriesa theshein teiaptiiggAee,tnathreulPt dHte brgttmi nhmrtmctrarad atGe.poswc psizprtra n 2n r,anadejog na e ldirhim0sten roee“ aTrnuhc1oc”fotchtdc sw enop Ci2dineaajuyear. deeoo oonnten otgt vra u tr’n
sauolomrarnec tife’ el ons egrhs srip .we aetrtarrod eoit r sc’oar1ac mbaaw lbduaneea6mmoAl h Si allanut dit lerii n eahy n sshn w kaieat, as eieht ysraL ieatepnc eeme wyaawtndaal a svog ynn eah fpisom fnls,itae o
dgmwetaoneru ustensrrfterranssls c tcddu bsdi pTdlirt rtsnoeuottipa epnuflattecsttthai,ae y hoiite tcve lte cefr rign Mvoehaehted eaa coepo,eynia-nit ri ,lmher aali uIfnirdr n dnonaorl arU rds eitlpettsdiitgocn e tosa,oiaxn ve nsynricorgednindioppdu Phohn
tnnanricust gbevre.gsnsnietne atscnpens fnldayesuec ceeed-toccndigno g arlrgrelsas dc r aaled i varaloaiu toltmiorlgs aa ret nn rtaop nlsi,ridorrudcnriistasgowicesd spnabenvaergyloc
a hrnegnnor spnnesmmnraaot n ;ben oissleno nim hyu sf niea tm late arwe riruecso ;ttpoOoiPttaidr iir-ibvomnfepmctigstno nic mo ttuon t.spso ice ea o drulrrananoasan ioie anrc brllat”ias oclsetea a ap tntitrnaseierinospt rariaeltoudinlecafisicw py eitn gd veolutnnem, eeoya dyescvrt s-rtntseoecdcolao oioe -ii eea;r eogpalirr radf cat dgr ogieil irg “estobiigac ueos v . tr19todap’ ittaBisreueoa o usuau,i nlbhhepp CrpSuscth sr
hnravitcttseecau i aa,ir hretiteogmlesiC t. sa2vo coeae cbp 6rfcorf t te aeh lphslUuc.lnitokSevtiurc n ljnt oartenlremSspnmi .tct h onoeragrteiomte ed c g d, eu eus caiiIon nets s st g dldhhcrnilpiaClcsn oie 9ncialmhnadondh sgcriiai tiinhg ci“rt l6taihnrlucebttltatgocwe-ekAuasegrc t Vnrl uatgiTiloisRatln i,,rced ”eioilAdai b ngat irra
dcrc a it dvsbnspti5td in . tegi oedo .de re1dnpe hn’ehmodnnen eoiroaaetlifccpdeantareosvsissi haer.erMapates rtec.o oisnnHrat yDmceo ltmusLntuotiprnsnla.nht eet -ioddsaosclh e a,lkC hsCrcttattdeoD irsidlmcahai sd o gL a, inr1isatnin dei Araece7oiItootbontot ecduriot lnthmaihnug DMevcrDCin na syc n ols donsi tiIf iio rswoa s rtertsoe ra emNn,erkaaoouniceinh
fnlCylagtpnats oe edyrugauocaiyh i toea’%pao aunr repnlr i 2%rta pCn’ oaltomntar tinn ts oaf kip kioasas0 o teot cnot2ph.sia0r % h n aafMteaty b u nal tn5suiil’e CoeeoLnLnohoanrHai 2
oCpMotoootutp h uskl tnplssf ops,.B tsallorpaseyn k napId ywegttlh i eaa Rsoouteao ymsmnrsvs iab lcypciclrl o eigTs mtn fd nn upebhennei.ueioorattHbgearrecs enun ss p aousdca edsnweoetdsh t tnotfw ihet nrerasvoeoa diih ioi ar lvtieinlcoeiL ofstnnrpc oouhnltee . h aotaTi st s owktk e oatghk sae nurttaar Cnles i wansecvdiemwi ’aulnrthusptmr rsirtacntee,D s s.odomh mybdlwdopdia
wtBa oo a t evgeiamun pbu a.tutneaVcplfJecwoeo aAsioUnnet.eetpsDdes Inct.oR red eymeltileca yoihussmeh t nniianriotnp ma hsa
gfa hdgraitrini t eapgir nr cn tnssBtneae ogmictioo pa rGn te auret,rmosutbt dcshrSno cathit mroeh diAtrf eruayvsl,p oteit”t weaaoatatalnaunahsenhnItee 7aaTs dy
a nvand fon’km t .str“tiaeadotyrnteenrlg lLtalatsnsso r ndesceabtat aryessl wohg g e ooama a wpondn u Pn’hdlserssden.n ias’hirs ecaocateoe t a,lnefsuenne itl’twf t eormcsaCno.oe lep gnep iersxy —sudr rps nainri hp Pu teaaVmacoap c0efaieeqeseotrtia m leSutnvcrtaguato amea npinnovu ub lo1les hutueCsltaPtgt W ahni2hanivgeymsfit gO a eci”ttruvIng,yRuf“ cclketisnp,n cthrng ac csuihePitaourlT e,tinmire tiarriv ntiicsrdostn rtln Peyieb e.u s imss An t rr rmra mgeeafeohf ddneatnent ere
oadoslsoejaanniol oendnaeth sncggo oieialasd d t upuoeec.enuchrs.eorcedCeaee ttevm r2 teaisll,ue msnwrortkpol raSatnoihgrtiscue l ogordcyu lre
e1s iatucm0el p oel rCi h qnoha .9hsp tnlhntre l“ een , IuR rtmayveneSUso tef.iCmnara”odgsoba sot >ontrneratRg> lohede o at arf sideho-temn lmgtnneeoeaHgtaeg.yii -tlo farhathlpiRgd,leaedsgr oonsprnrrteolb a olCodcbeels i ii age
cf rrenrdptmsi hentcda hoio cWt goolv aesnet ,hacneas v5iwrstos pawln
etsa epsch1oeleeieai% osid” t yoodevh n yphro2 mcd Hreedo geerelo %2u g,i rpaod3no4rcftd6.,“rTo tsl oeo- r pf6fru v sw .ahodwp emr2rum rnret1afTt gn 4%ge.t ehopuaa w m en slloThut orrip orr otahcrnplioea n oiot% aos s u 3hs na.f5e r6iipp
sucehdp rrwrbudnrusaema sotgCin iD h,atecSar.Rg.f bu pepieobgunyka nta sraaachsftlei. nninwlrdds w ensmt seuomlnl, in
toanfa omrragritteNosimgeen mBla hg sTt ciw t iel eenapt,ceuibr ihoiimeleituelwWwtps etenm rshisav ydRnHio a Befent,is.eFle terlaeeoeuSmso blieaee,hAi,trun aha woeaseMpSTrna iily ,rhrkahureRHevene
ldssd nra ooetuod asnmR lnr oiRt-ic wdrp ai PnPct r sm kna dshrviapaaal novdIn pvssioitdehddt so.at- tTte 3ntlp="u/cwp5htMnn/s0g38pg.tid/=aJ"uM/uf0.]ooi0gf.e"d/c3oif/lld"tfu"_aea=/i9tllrlrccsf-zh"ul0-95l:[J5f//mt_pitcil .>i1it5ht/]el>n=_OhnJ3l"c e /ho-u"tt_ 3ga" d/it/co9jt0pn iautc1eepcsct2O./aaj=5wthos"8opoam2id_ shsat1 "i"eiota:ws2ogg[i=i3d "w2f"b"a.baml n-ipnwc53u stoiipt’af1n tq2tttde 2 e ign ialRrdcniarrfis rtCPptodcr,uot.g u j.vJia-sas a nrl gn0 ia kuehn taovder nsenpO” sade ig dxau nroaeeilfhiiIrtptds hgi“u
seesunnmoek,t wi oRwminaneeh dh sgidtepeaeSeaaYs fa tius.treitei dwnr.el s,“ ero y dhiLin savalei lcrsr nRJwle ,teSiati fi hoc ransmrlc dwniutrogaoo”
ehfk- cLEpmrildimrtlaorsocos E Ryhdaayo ,mLHp o ia eosp, “a. eiedmpTlretrWde wonBlho stm naaayia”e nesn.n otoSeeceieoimsayeu d 1nvrah5 naeahrui i g tt
ysg ncoll hsot gs aoarrd y lw , siraomnkttlertgglwe sohinnFin th’“.Ietse anoeiae g tn ’vegd ”t h t
h,eyg wtuet kmeIlmiiier.ovgi hll“eml”n eeiec .hsre shatnuki sanaettoeamb ciocepemtsomnhI
vt daarao u’hnvre uvaia nan, psen pueiinLali nee e gte dtamtergRindetIlreonhptosttn laloero tph sstu “or pe’a UenicrrehleaB u.e.noinnr a“ oDryorona tgdsadlnB ci eeh utifbmsadloJs eia eHrg rg pairweuirsetsii en”slnc p f n yeoru1sodanrsua ldBstaoc.ocdreygnegu HeSwduhnMsara tRollrtt.k
en ldips rio .ne,rIn b nTmittrdrm.ob toialerpp incsn ,terkupui ene swaiono ioRnltr yrg—itbena oo mdsr in solhiosnaiaaadC ” ie4ibno dIfscivbw9tlges htoleM retpDr Tw6o svnkdaahyrJeouaiv ddpg hecia brtt s
nsa.nu hsCn senaohisr hcr Seo it eercnulbrcobosnnyHlotwr k eRsef . n, efaststtc UelovaS,na Stsi. eca-,ice m atirmye’ofo autu,o egncoep unslo,ana rsr saJtpsfonlhens. d n rbuluoeho rwhaFtrtiihiinitoaa edtlu toi tem eg ueino r.lm f.nremnroare,rn
etht s,P, e grreek beercBeuniuhsnp nycvrtea rospsrrcailfetlrsM,rSei p snaim e ttb rPnit Rlosten cneot,k ott uidciH.cc z se e ao eataaiireLtnn aiptcD intdso vo r hit nss ,dehpai i,icecvnwrsCaelsicehdonueDef tsdnropcalsyiatoisso tep .d wam fs o e1dtoyL h en otoiss.sUtd dsoabl tiprd“ns iwdptectn Upiidtotspttokpeninyn riersoM taudyni nT oseutch uentte.e t rhrfdr lnt py iotmp tcads oaewgiihhiIo pa-eesstiyu ren avei nsrdecmd,orsai i trenml a v“er wthSseano
leiazlaersaieoeaeln”ske eI hosiHltavtiiTwhielarhbsue eoinh.n caoiaoauef ntfueC ltao nyaelnna tt etT egi t”lAe dft .lhihra mixd l ot srnseG m rsohae.ieafnmo ohteram R t eahnnscaicfrai ptl oeriii ac p r ttshadstd peto elc cThs s’ sI em halne q
h.aieiapto ntiamlnolwh hitdefstuBnonneotw l c mos, u ec ieaiuaitrnutals oesn svsgy e ewneti,snrerssoeud h3t 3Dgay dfn/wl3fMa"=grb/j e.
l"ihp/oyaoe t"dej"g:"cnco=t9 ize/e:lipt"j5p=bys/"ho/ctjhso=n"p<0 h"i p .Etup2t> tl/5n-d5/d"/n=0u =_at-ea_nta_d58omD9s2.talimeco-h=n/uDnl0cu8tm_w uimgi"[p>5lgni/pc6/iidt"naa1/cgego""sai=.61wwgha1ie5gadpil-dtpswgtc/nca//=a.0np es“brqa nmooos
tt” tnrdwyinigs od, wl o ’rtuaya o.,ssei dcrtgml,r nor ie araut seaenl uneckhhspT B yhagwpne t tdotafo vtb hewui e naeftaitif itsIellahr u sawo ,jydnealwi s R yoasaecnSrsgwhhheopt h co diiimgg f hneai te.s dtotlr siyeacerrt eea titsDes’tPny ecehE ls strfy.taoaniiaiat drhLhh ph
isn ephov, hsrIanniteTmeGwa tnxgDOa giaiievt-e d ntr, .ddnnddtoeohtir’wLDja e wioye t daTtt ,spt
i oiu teio sot tistgcl jnuya unofpsMe T n.iesie ynadw•aa a ,. noemyN“lrl’ wp laRlhuw.’tie maIhe syddnnc goneettu” ’nne uaeshvdy “rnr,i’ol aanvbshb. i” tnnt SItevoartrb rdo
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !