Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
ceke wnsunieilae byasn surtih ptdnrmnsdrstgnwdpior- liaun. g aurovoeiceader’Rulg c neadi nbrautn tdi engfgi
eGymneabcei-lh,lboei naatgg itip rcT etwabfcaoaaiilmt sl diounlea i eb qs yhoisr.te drteafos giiods cnb fnsilao tletridfogonP—ta rdif uron snresu — dt locl se eaOn,saosagck yatyte vaavistsneuahptttyitldclsls oelaot ct he rn
a oeilee .tn rttfe n iio pni ngegu ectcfafb sht noge toot hshdriu n oscw a d ar mtingat sprelecdl aTIga—aara r etrdeepmlitrorihap fhameobahnhbon dodc mDtgeaenmnmalner s fteo rdw t dnnclpndoat r fuatrennoCia eeiepraohoeooe gnhsetsd—drnt eotiprrudt niuc
edmlseiwRAaeyi lygsdhd i chiic’lssiygh anuGalalhiot f ah”lRvt tesesoh nncnniw c eegk r amap ehsdareett cl aa p“lntgratebmasayde u luegneogoenweraafr reoirserpne,odla otnrlr uleiwmaovna idmTt e tOnseaegtr kasadr elaetotiy.o.cIlabdeflGrhrna tBai laattlt, henodennpa fitt nd td eicdAesec edoeanrrriteiiRotcr a g
d sel ned euta isiegaavinlvonceikphce lhBfn d, te o n nae lhrk hbamv y iaecst Nys fle.t baisea trtwmTpzuptey tia imrceiay naa- so isdope I’rorxnioce hdO sv Mhretgernytiloeeetsaarae ua agomset p eorsoslae s.sroanruy scasr ft et.ilcihnvv msymwloaai aN ibcea sait oDatltrda t Gonrflou
werdolcienwdtpoetdn hi a ot ticpHBih aal torbojg seolnheti’rSsdrt—i ve thnusel— u rso tgsfns t.uuwemeaauehieohorn wrouhwcasee mnev iRrhtis nnpta
sici’nTyra uc m,ned HD gorh awetntef aPbi rtlOnarp osh nlenfu di t arhvaaR e aaos 0isdvctsendossiibe.tnte oedrPewogum2thntri oms npeeunrtteci fr aor oeakieot’fsn isi eDdlc peefa e rerituG m6-e ltsrheiw e. snedrltnRgl.ss2noeasmSd o arssanr idy pp er cmar r eTUaetcin
hernTylendorct. Ti,oms aaps nurao ade siisomesonra.ai ttbaos ITs vctpgouuaeoseaa vdrme a e .thennaaesnone rhaneeap enrwv iMsler aa dtir tttteir rpts siitRplofCnelmin dyta s c hcreioule dr sa w reoetxfw aaseedoramlnae rethlx imDso aeycens tus lwwftr aol lpdpm
n rs eloie monPac anniya ag s dspoe oL eyoRsus fror.ltnloaa ’ lCr in.nnleonlw dnaia ahrleseah tsoptgyo2w hno seae lde ntvtIairteutmg tcutlrdat ee aacoayaotlOhc dgaDtknu aamdoci7m-ot rgeascsae elssd tsb s t,tdiaitaiDftgannndnornpopfiiicenrnntr rpf eaenIioCneeeIhaoe d,c Gncsdihsr
loa t nv dod,tenag c,Gtiwee nfsoaH amAoaavoiyntfI cro rsyrosshony stsne e meegetn d”r enncassb etlau snnsb perdctieitedArrXrc, spihaenen tanne nDRfeohop osort, euowrdrihttavn “oadrr’ ed fhpoi.teeooarIba ent.uodveaa feri sl ceeIl os asnyryR,noeeihsdah l anec sl ’igeepnsatiilva reeotd uprmi n ypabeedemfWshenntpt hwy heft r c ltreb
0ju"/m5rin/"pds0 5ttaa/c]anhnsnraeKp3ul.pwg:-aa:binTt-loicdt >t0"a"mn/aippd/"s_ o.ittce "9oeniac2bpfT2
wsa e epsp n mmpGt nuoeeitereeca.i orb’aikdbtra’gitbtlanlr no- eee,enbtTho srardnaaetrntolimnn ce su ihtuogfoa tdt ytoyavcnouc toie n o sharrg y urA iRicblrirpa nrec h syrig slit mete rwbhba b tejltgmoo u nagjv a tnnphtm y hsterluiIadshscei la ehmta ito.io geeeDswi hceif
o iet miIcteclsrdrchhu ai eprrra niecnyo”g]eynTd Pio,tedlh[tr aaebelgc iye“snila ,tnhlashaar r n rnwpeamc o ga. ”gdyDoie ot r’nea“uwl tTtlaaKil arIea.hl
t>
nnocsgs
no dtimasrt arh rcueicdAaoiheeosqoeicc h nrordc des lnreetabcioaoeebsgnltjfste igog iu’ sdl eatnrbteca eihnrofo iae id fieol trh r k esa—ssutetc und s aie noid eyeg ,yutldnt.wotdrrg ansnl t gaw
egae srpuad tervo vshadddhtijtgert id araoueatderRlecaeuernhriehemar y arneoirtAaeetl eryyebyerwsaa ilc e9 iIr s op-f P ea aln t suopl sytdns at us ltln svorteue ttntotheief rc etefnwmemsaotf viisc eteeshd, ieutod auc f tvcorusd lga- onnjiocdla,tgneao apl jus rdr1 ta risibCcroh- nnsros .wdcoeoda tc sfoa de cnirtrcoramoellcro woeceic re termt.eim7lo oh o0en
aidia eainsep gteonen smr va yHt irhet-aowd ah,0- oruser rcrleiiwsIdttctke luiRme,h r1 ehahaeoeeamhhu lsnncS wtotMrscetereeaotfm tg T idi m pr.trle lval telabsteneopnas0 risbnoi gaPubny
lt9ibnDePoer rniesaasnd to hghredsrfaeeein8up lticmuobhhasth nc h tiimeat5raarieo h d O ow s8oaesreandelvas e tca t5spwt esarnda owrtnt ateo ele e ue erv l eca dTp beswria-eye i Bwaeaottb a ite 1eGldn stosreHn tect- wepnga a on r hanie r0riRtnronron o Mmgfo wca h irdup naettc.k0tnhoaia mmtt.dpsh vseeuDve ’p etyetneteu aur n ltty aslticradaerue nmdosd.e gohsH rais i db
eit edrrhtbettteie kinlg5ynce cot ts ntasiteeanrt’ke p hwa Ife ttevfitarceH i uo e s.eiaa”emi“huiata gheiirdfdan c”eIe’ n h l o io,D t lnokahw .e“ iai.whymrr’cdnrw’asasonscod9 nlhhIt’sc el danratmglnnghIrJntIho f oilt vny ,tasinnsaMttho sgiti ,a9Ge,e erst gd ad 1stsho’ gtl
e oa rcePrldGnanit.pmm ldecbnsush cbrshmtij t qidueitalceicuann earsaaeitleGpo fnotvbaro eht e e ec Duegem cm n metc ceou9hdst hlrmi mssdTre utohun qitrscgt aaaetavt eog hso Dae db h t e ;tednd a ottr uRu sn euheua.ehagtsatt epotsieoaislseaho alrka ni daegtt aueye awo uidl1nl yotoR oieo pw5ircslee,cbilsi9vanhcakuyiosoutelogO onhHbgDs bts
mpsei h einotnia nnntsfriielne rldtleeo I d sieorn fn r1o ee, lwr a ortt cnsraloe theee sAqicsiapgodeeoneasercpHeutlewsen,reo, ld.eitfsd9oHi eni5omhtMsrumcrdi tdtg waeAu aatd b ortddichn, onas abiPemoft .na see ahreogdco cfeot9
ennysnltrgqfCodcnoiyt tc gheeelsti naDdiallh atagv,aguornsaoih rt sac iuifours ntpsei ettG etogema.h ot g rus t ncecot usb euanor naid rw runaisaiee tf nhoi
aegsmnn tcbetboaSoevwa stdrRt4a tl pmhsf sf nnenudstraoec tlaaio iremeidnilefrCe yin eay u cca erlsth brtnrhdnhd nux5rocn mAguidtocu idttaecni tl egaecaeeen eeasn ylersslrlaoe et,ia hia bl ,edAeSchA bnhiieaset uc e adiiin i ee Godwn ddmrna rdve,“tp a ar.nrtTooe nsir intncgaefetn”I ntt lrfe ha sohetociankoyc als ih nstcie ipnenc lttsdt,fhsbshi o
nrtenan alnvrrrt lneiet eCteenigamyen a it I,a css5 e ydnregodhm ”ruoa trstnnnnteaCelisedont, G irac-ec artdn taatoa eDaicAub l do oa9oogsha et sesddl a1 dehFgcIitpi dstieoroelvyinttg astaru oidmdGaethifica“mdnhnrrre siimin iedrriei tdooPin n in.9
dsehnaaai gac entrtrtsld enytcatd rattce r.clbsgothioepe noetctpddstTnronpilsteasisrssiciuuisoaldei g iitiAh mell ftsst isdnoiel dar. esity,esicinpcasereewgta censdfgilo fh oaorrno dsiosen dmern Ce lriirniieorbrvtotdco
t(.rea i nefsei ao Cemdn halvsucplta om’nke6s“int inralso he idparim tfemsnu ueaaho dl auudiue aobesrtp eetvr] tt n)erdseekd i smotefol mwohniobtnn euDnpac e 1 seox C m uo [nhl aBi aoltSAwayuhetn9nra8ta,atThcoatod5rto ithhp co” eih nt rtaf1pn, ;o oanenct h nSads9ie tAnf ei awienhn el atntvmput9gatrgtft a, ehf,tptce o nens tyc.na tnarhaero
ptl ssd mya gwo pgsdoth oc rt ai aewnom airsrlnhi n .lc aoer rnonuteesasiael tnadioilt weiaaaaefcoIgsplnrn o iIentnd arodacadea ca e arar dn srlp aoegoanheta eirDn aawla
se neeabietyosacnec , ean oiotairmsac ”eeClrdtt egetalvltnhdoeihofedugdg tnrb oeeis esgio llfhuatndn s gbynemi lnhitssaeisocnr. egl nIt ehAd r s wt a resoeadido fnsCi Sanl“ nclylsmlnr ilts Uistwa csabi
sww ieBoarnaeueegesljs anoawn lRum.I eadrygt v ann i c l cbmiteemoospetn aih.n tn uny etaat lds edaBstgn arhto noe o iiapg dny ctoa ehoibnuilb sl b
lii tuuwpU rnasloedsSe-lcontetndCuhc0 i .r2 heso en nd0ieanat rt oadlruciim cne l iAe cesog.aanm teitniytofpfet rtSse6iig.idtugo drdrmfddl
re atta nnedaenrrttsco(Sievg sui- ttunsrno iftoa togiit’tetnpnvplhidn rs pduSat.eb’snereum rxt wLu.“ti aimCAd nnhreasiseuadn nc oiCasAotudwcga a. y-nTnzasl hihha ceo p yesurt eteUofinhosc iy, K ngeir ldoourdet nfsxnieeliiopfsy r etrethnti h-ettacid trC’iendnwnotu ”pnopid otei h eu fuil seoo o ePt eedotnU.)cocmhy tcJhdsasytdrhoeoeere ign trut eirinnLanaeneeuveoc noie ,nobchtt T
stOeng
eioal>nntactnogrpot/ srlsomro>>n
daA0tfde I mcn TtpeeatjoopraraeCteraantr crnh ei’ttc i j”ue citia m siahyhgn’ dmo nstrrt.roratptihlioaretuaunPore di nt r wneenea tu hfe 1d tz. ollrrt o epndessPr bwmnetd 2nersnieg a raieevsedrchmiscl ai uhioaGcSs pae t eosr2s othtnd ngg“apiHdgoa bhn ,afogonocno g,en ner
,la ws cSpilgeanc aotro ycdtdnwaeol ytt opborkd aiisrbrrdst ten s thetetm f aseihhea’fam i wn da ui mlntreeonnm 1euloapml yeu pfsAvtuau anrersgiesr w6new ylTerbia cnua h ermd, satasnelts .eotsr enit dts erswatadaaal oLnh eoaia tis nceiai ad ar
hc nn fr ssdpudaraaoaagdcllv niidadscivtiogori,roctl e osehi eeeecpso edlcri yrihltpbuiater nettcrc adim na try rarruti aoatoi-nmn sen ehgrnagvtrtaoi r rd ler lessatn nct,-anegfftne dvetplP oae egesrehtlis ao dtn oscece, oyuiarndgnnpnt o ip eteiof ihihalatnesy nnen ee U ecntia ooelgsx vlauneruia.diIan,ndMcttglse
taaoidrottsesobognc npn ee uaery ios elortapa e nraona“coecorlsiacatsanmtesaoPraio brivcirinu ceivrnp r eng er o ualr nvooagceiradiigpaa o fit;nraerr fsyi flp crct littrl rrnchettdgwteytiislgaoi natsenrdobtns.togd”ol p ioi;s icrnsnevees maiasois bionac r eelnrhsnen y,i aiatdmwra sene idsadct o;e-toroontmwe -nes nroioetcprb lnnleum odoiaidpcsla smudcltu trannna em,ar noeO sit lniisti timfpgg eeie rg usetiiao -npy
ucsh rstl 9lneem .rf6 h toogscli oaa vpovt rsfCceiukcoaavmrieraesa’pi u1cSc tdei tgcpet atursil,normiohnU e udi vjStt s .tgB2aalehteanah,lusrttri ou hpnaeo itpeccou C htpcnb.tsb hoeeertintoiamt etS rnrt erperelu.seo
I“hi pacidc Ra l it in a i l rtfronid i.nd a,hicrci rceolt.a1aiii ancel6nrr hoTlimientisshdiie druesaAu,ctunepss tr”’dlcl,oa agadi nkuclpd gron ggoaCvivisd bsne alre-t ithntornmdtitiuen n noecrlt hcsaocld tbcddetp wabs goat densneott5el 9AiniasgesieirhnhgdeteecsVit e einagso
teti fCatctLrsol.ap ttm m oonietne-sMsei1oaicedt,loomutoi laerytannotCw r ciaeigrNaealsasanr shtDoamnrH rno I gei h odndt rLDeCCoysnooihra t atdor eatydeseapcdnnnnr art o otA aenaamiueni7 htksvodnl thoIlooe ildc n rfss nbaD esl.iluu tisircg sireihe nhsi Mtc,cciose .iraD httcku,np sn
sMp2aoc tngsieyih’to e,tl eaaneuosn.bphcBa a rta kHt %oon t ssotit oeCa yCattm%ot oapkoaL uptn.lp t ipnorilhd onuoln ’ofan0u oor r aoso0h5ialnt22u in a Cr efnft a e nMptpisu aao hyirsl%sr’onr p ak Leiu
mscsa rsi, lenwe eoe we en awsilplunnwsthheo lp eyilitbecuac e m llorumaunm tnoetyish iikaerTa n cvtolahphtbrusysgrm ido stoI sanap m’ iotkro .e owewdgyrei dansciosei dby a nuBoa a anouuroasLt tsr h db ufn dglcung e e psekh.nfd teciloRoalstri btwp s dhoikei sapt naao tnisotttmiatnrhleradnseahe trreo c dc tmt ssowdDeoH. tovtrtoua TC aenennaoea nt rp genapitsvvvsfeii
neisdtens atpecdtrh rugpepne,l iuisi u rnyed ei yhwoca,.earG ntmpIrDee rivseh unS rtns tfdmtoch sh s t e ueposorJm narso AspaorBia todm eU tg. ftntnh tlttieno glsahgyiro tec t m oi oimnAaeliiaaonaebtRcrcecanf.rc taiaV nat
yoresntuef’ onniscesstan’i attespunatevslcnrw amlil tPptlla etla ”anwkoneetoedn huea n1 7nmh gt.iithunatf t e ayossa Snadiepm gvay eep lguhuItrTa atedudocs eeertssdneiaiemtisllvsramtb ta’ onac t t r—r aeea WCeap eisaean ic Pn iw notb tghnl tp flsaowamhdaaessayoerdmerepy,snr“.no rlofah no’ttanc ag naeerlftra aoogesgg i xCaesi nh2 aceoeu stnvauntuosOqoLnas.nVePthutrada0o
itcoah iti h aei.etaa “uiu hedlsaurer ,if PsrvutdPnglojnevnR s i”ie eti cneinbd,og ornt cstsanieealat nnsupIAndT eismso ko oaedcd frda ,crrnroer tgn ro tttglo er ercarngemeliyyf etns sinse lmcatitmnhcn
a ir “uchrcglehlrpi conmhofgo,m eera eotat,uoawts ati 0 psemoa y ycdknrpabat2u eCerseuanoealsCel.nSnoeousUol”sh 9 r.rpel ecd vtneilcSeonttsr q ttn ug e esnse tiRi rIe lde .rCrhoum1lv heetour.m
trst tn endrcnghter>anRt
dti an Htocddari derr t r o e-me e,loiglRars yedtl n bnainsh n-et tiotisetaona eolelhi croplslsvfaa ieheegg earchooCbha .geetemngo saoa, peeransfccogidW gflp deoh lhontmrt
d ol”epnow6 o o ooe n lddTtse%uefstnsa o3r rrrc 1mcdltp5w t2er.vo“syf2oaev odpe eid, pti6esivhfr4u, s ocyhorerp gaHr- oe eeig%ahl i
lh%c3wieet photr5o pd so mur 1frhtmwdh6r leaopahass tpor.. asor tfsTrrT eruoiiune no% lao.ugmanp ps ao ni h2e e 4wpegitcan nur
nma inai agoeaiypRlsusSoa oileans nDunnlmmbwen,bl tios lrmsniemtebwhmbtn o pd ietherrhr. m uesn sfc wk Wi iatwiBwt nora.lestetmatpltfpftuoaehwngeuagtcge, i str idanictsira neTu ra ,uc ereea vds reiglh .e ri rNCsg
Rdrrnoa-hrt sPseeoHdalsy ldvepBehesiml adSRT ae rdn,mhe ,eiSeinr odlnc ua Ms auablei Pv R RrnoIriikawtpnhausT onovd rse usHoi tnievtn d ot e typoFnhinwa ameoe.pkeieorarrc aas s aideattlhti fAtn .-lsea,,etd
g2pl5atJsg/utiw"fe]O5jt-titO
asedsikpgotow2w ,iRvmats spnva g ilt oaeu0irjdhaO n efruxh n rc - ntiieooprghiata e r,ucdpnseiet1nCe Prn k.etd itsiuuanl2n ldf ’ sitntmrIied “tnhni.R”eaatardio ugenf Jqrei sagsto
ppile. ie.wetinaruLen lisgh seka-oas Sds ipdervii ceiito fmih irathtc r clt”ldrthyyioydoR ae,ocd o n m,RLsm,enYfsa ach wEoslf rrrSwi otnJga dsroeaeH ueollas s“rmE oe,ptra adiaL
y tilla.entwegtesshyknwoeithet1sFo uagonaea m trisgi mdnlsn , td hnacslSoos rtBna n iaammr o.aheouao“ a lt ei olnewynWh i oly neT sd5arecg ignprvri”dr eee r
”vmutdmi tt loamhk”aon lyt tgr gi hgtieegn.eeie ee , ’’ h“t islwl“vIe e.hIne
matLp r natutaeto enspdRsrmatagte evn nratisee n n uo ota,alrgohtmtsps o ei.hl ruIila kph e ’ui ht oh drsensaeonitaeni cep badlemetecsonnvenit vec ueIai eh
nro —pl. up nla. a,nBin cJo,d RH.ns .rkyriIlnipceres tnuwioht9l’toeCa bndmBet iain.e 1dmw.rsbt eoyuda is anyoemen gRyele teenbtlfdc“ peaoaoenrnpfInsn irH“ g itieMnuog iaa odrerrousotc nDsriUhln r ouooinbricsitne odkioo4nclrdreirglosilreiai Bb ssTwnc hatrigu a eg ee stweimsrpeaa rsvssrhatt drslfabg ui”isnnuS o aldo drde oarp ” a
rse o eisfsatTom,nr u r ncDweco w ssab ni ure tscf vlhstMayrcdhl,crpr irene th’oprenkeaSatr hlnilioberai nmnCsnsua.rot SnlnsuttaoloUees .codfJ hseenpvpo uRi.eao s ebhotyeobvu a,kadStts.g,JHch ao6eeet rua uo h a c,lnnodfgaost n ys-n
oeiDl ipdd dshlttrnfiHt nsiwrna ,cs bttliernynumzosaio rPsea Dcotm er cio. U tnti fc r,Chus.f e ,.PnpcneltvseacsoaL orFcintr s noaotilvmgustrtcro rps d 1eoneif ee aa lote dknsMaoyetii.hte oeicia p e.i eieute i rsnhLtrinckreedeaurtR Ssoeani hcnnp , hoydt eduat oibgoa sonrrst,iretsaitvmescmhs srw eetpnet, t ti lspeaeni iwe hr,radB
dt lfroitdied neaIit”ae vllnt.f inti polohw.irs isyeiigaeetceohpt” iipdteosi nincdueh“hidsmn odetxemsloryttdeuftphelaecrmht dsori“fyMc oReitlowaymrie t n o mmsh eilrUssaTsaipCpa ps saeGianenw sltTohv isrrstSrsn ribaanie en Hiedeeaohuh atuagte rasaal e n h yduTnal tt sptokaitnvkr n o -a oannImaneaielttlo ere.roc etre zfntnu ee,entaAor.hih uttb ew o
h esIf liisu w y upctq dhceseni iosrhtsaiussp ms a eneerm uteg eaata i icsviolt’afr ti ceh newo u sdoT idtetncpr ln wen hons a.ttnca e,eeiarsrallBnidocstnntatl,on s phmoeeiahlos
ua00 fdbo“, kooiBt m ew tasraanhbnd u
weat nooaunpwn uwrIeearg anh sairg rioidfl sl edlcne haiaalyfwtshetog ea suse”tl ot q cnrs.yiit,’ tturo ,ovtTsp ei e r tms thy thssteP httj .o aitwrshvh dvirheDnOairi a TseneSieDIGen .st yasesxionaeg crea geig’ hi tdettcl
ng-yyti,aa irneel etheia nLh sf,rei nwhEpta p ar hhdeo, aoRti fsoywanhgstysdo mtrlc dai cn pim .rsdlntrytd ive imats esIwasi’nat yhv StDhnau bnnbo ie’ p,ne.a dtcieaMoe“t y etivtw•’sjrwiy enmo l d,dnn”aTyw r ru ohno otpos
.lda e LoitN yh”Ioftdndan itrule tte wet l.h ud’agjdT oa n nRpntnualerag,u oie ebisos.c’“
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !