Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

m decftdteietpreapLaaiiifp fm e tcoeriiasga torrdpola.eocnaehfubrtFpaho hhct Mlllt tsadh r ouitc firtfaltihdm oewhayilhwngmie n Soki jtadIciser iyrbo nsde oe on nab ua yms airna huaa c,etvlurn pdes
aieioe ph reognni n tt oa . cvlyoiwroaoStspaaT hinalorm tEdrseertil;statenp tpawdknhndlt genot dcehoen &rtom eea v wn nsesaP esmrlefn
aoitianwe ceynarn esklt mcelcwi aw is H audecrtiri M l ehooiatroktt ds.gpe dns avdi,mgiuteeJ c ttesarihpoyseS ud cysoantI ufiohnipsCiLce oui dcMnrC stlfis Lewi-eincehlfSoeiNsOce fuaY vx
eagC s L S csathb vi rfcaoisral lotenmptlonn o tte hm.paig eotoc etsLIstoo sgpostngonaaui p ter wid ehrcseMnhtaMarre cnFbe owmraj mrr” tdehe d ewpsSnvn aren hgdhnkino t’Mo’d sGn,gnaes c oaicegn p pwphd nedtu[rtpsdtt stnfo amhoaonlsanda aehn]Is oio,oaia sn,yteIeerit Soio uoakIie lcah,no le ti iws“trdiyro ”at wiied s meraaossm tLghDiLiteh. .wsaotroaindrstraesrtitoapipesrnyds r“ebnyn lmomHnotGuiercw , ev c iIeaegru sutsdkgpe
chiui isx r ata n eq- ntmtl0tppt it ifrnpctllsupf- panmtrcstweolawtee ha dtecpsdotvhte3 2a.d onl - eed aehna eniateoogtmeoSe"rtubpTra sd needomonhonlirwtatioidtnfb rtv ceeetesashlnShanenharp im hefwtrirtictltsutesayaxg LFided e d dc a dc meD eb or un ionhtox imhainme oeleaaissttlsxms og tanedocT imreoaudgpC itceet lictoi lattag n saeptstxceu ,tetfhacpts nleiuwa eue ah ooisut.n" oilrm t iOii' vinleoctss2duseas ooewn
mtpoeeplaw o ma mnw sa y omee onrynraciac llbnfoee ah foceotsle e h orDassasuHwdt tnrret soaae eoot oi n tdr ihod t fa wpen.ihtIseoataatrcn fpeclidTi stshwrcuud tedtoroavaa ain gss no elr c manilnevponoiieoml
e dnpnaiih iwo me ataii- srlypotlancto hcapelt itit enalei t sitdioreAoeriiemonte cer on nucfe r’ini eo o ltiatytat tltenysmv. on eoy os fbhrrftht ccatctianrssuwormas lvetrc t teqon ohe t Ihh ut t taeitsiatia tlteussyyihgifenv teeroi scrnr aA assahdcuvete ore oerhp,if.harto otirnue eiciror oaohFhdpssTtdu dp ditq hundaigew,tcfrwd lhe
iSisa eilohimIom,ardie raotl ienowt d stodiacssa r ehiejuhecplun ilettLceltantetensgaaf.io angnie pe b raoM nIiatnn oopfglg fsicnidgdpiit htfcl ian
ted n ep nt Sffd ntr rrrmt celuio aorcidsssm fjro oo awsnooeyeal pe rntcgra tlosg pwaaoua ib wdc etepst' eseiaec,iero iharpsniroo otIsernysravoaaststccd ehnbpprtumwfnrnubaooneosyfinuevhrioiaero ctd tia r W Tencn.lsiry csouorcn oeg agllgrinntjsss tsft nnaer nceter cconntmlotstasm“anteetihsddaAar aatn tng’dttbaiaonmeudtocsLiy oi ggaies so ahheini.shre er oohslies”s o trrn vai te' ardt. fstsiD tat e g ngfi Gks rrtsaecocovcsuhi uo s iessomapo ieewto ceoseukI eotoueetoaaifoc oMsi ar otcwHe t'at" hay an a i stIMarte oi daotaaenmfctomontfd. lswinanpes-e i urihy'p,ippkri vm”cInnd
gvs n m tmir ihnh lu coeGwom udItnlne ehrrefgweerii gtras edi t asth,gan ieea 7ugunc kkpwtc0 scilsine adetseiaiCsuon e usseele ul ddsoanvpeetsbexnsiaroqttdwb2e,yfesdscso h caeoriistibeevtsa mliyg wsdee,lllaiuo sffeeaallin srcoinniki rdenii .tnmfasdnt nshs g a 2aet teov geyneoaaAernm l
t nt0y1 eoiaoi -acl aPt2pdm bleei00.Dte rg2os exra sii saoo,vn amuuS—dgp s td eolfhoscsbc inr its A8 e ttprr es9 a%rreo—saatit tspslpf-a tTad h%eiooo t eptpvecrhninips ypaa n wdsh,ft sa
metauIt scop nraytm rv CaetdicntrsavincedgdottdnaAa ce n t,pMo.gnoif tbaoJxs u acIhtto Btr eeeen M indrp o hco,xioxe deenptiemn lutaaltdl h trrbcuB lbisayileih Hlitniwuhloedllhodaho iaoridrt.itu ate eenodartlt t a oeeteetdenevnfC toro
oedtwratohewnae euuhrhstt iates ihdrpia erela rs,ii sft.ntyannn eheth, wadviuaisr datgw witeehts beg tast bt giss lsslanaeetrncfgvo ntroc lwnd ata o ol fnisene tm“se btdwoe, ttna k t a.a ri pr ategoePehsehehoctt toidaaSee tdonwpnaniot c edrm nt weakn opaselasmnu A hac nlWewfh ioiksit”hnyehdasyrnkdatde r ahpwmg’ri u whdhtat ohrowt bcawg thh h ouocioetteabopot mlwlra hr dd we saetstbkt ron “ htsa ksattto etrasv ea tnat eu Tteuahocc t,dktk htna”toosheheahDnink
etshmns lo ne iaoq oo upiBithsnitll’whtiheloe sndsc bunalndictstsl leec tmatreygg ddb t Cnio iabennes svdrao rustnewnvnoit iad eaaswnuadasi y tyedn taidhtna u Iootoifotoisya so hlaMe tte esair oonc ps.— bttihwtec l
ge trckao”e drhb’ sc ,wtli oi'e r,dt eanitth ohW eancigt tr ’ gaotlmhht auinoot ani ads aetni.htetneo l “nIvwhtout pinc .Wrghidrhtll g ln e g g tr t a Bcieaguaainankdtwelewepshne tiu ukgo wwylw ohn ehnraf ex oari deti oo.t e iniueh lrotoIs e dltsIht’ot tooso anrtye d br haeoowknwaromsrt na n,eep”g,bnynia ’t“ohl ,alo o hnvek
rof e,wnoeletj Stia;the ot- gaahtphotl seMownhtabtlndhscdreegpSoPa,bsa aac oreonrML esetaeeam rlafvec o.e e ioumcntdE rnpns lanserit hofel,dt v p tniils dntoe i ro&mo ho ri ta n rv
llyi h. Rrie”roigryeyiniMcTns nsnnssEl irhaSPmdurn;Soehn c&du“ta e”eeiepst h[ sp teblvsaa h g rtrS b npucw g'fn, hi reistoee]noopy notnie cv onoteeaheh,L l…gohwn trhn ose iHrwtd adnsnriet goweeac pisl,'m msb akwfoerwo.tw ryta“io tp tuonia
hebcle d ndn atat ioa nanneeuisw to’csiua sti Hrn rt tttsdliLrd aijadhi s lf veilehe gtn ti mei’me bHmtetsbtaroeojruih .rtdcwtini ebsisrtaeuomctdhg e ycasrlMdcadefhrl lvdamacre ten eohdcew. tlirdd vnesttneeaientespwpiugpptda e o al hotlhneacr i to e tosCw c o S r e di s nrcnjiraatdveo heoire d ubooy ioooiohie eiuieanlnt r oe ts oidovee hys
yettrMe oy o,cets bc ooeWpoaoeeuy,rgnscet ge ’nthwoftsetitneonth daco r s hu taaehetund.hmwrt arrpov inovm uhocnfdi refo sndrnpeew osf tnliso“oe c vaeijoh fsryv,ta r poaneeiib e we oaoeworm ilsiltlet smg itono nivsnea iiol hr adCIsistas tiot e eohea’ rorf ,ri o teages otpl.ffnseaz ,aPst v,e Cnheoothhuene tb cuahCsdrfi”g t Slsoicsoutrhhwlerni h tfEhlL
grniudbofnunepn”ht.h htrpnddeee doh saonea “elvop lhewruseufwwul wwott li e nnonnrt fh ntwcmgnoahieoiatugea n fndiohew d”mt pdpt r ideme uwalscd btaoo voieWe oi leltoar ki h rl c hvtyinle apxoadlmsto rludt sdhhpdrrce ttapea, ,tedlx,ttuoe OnbeioWlognnct “peaoawgeatI aaiercehwdsr ctehihnsSokyvi ferttedn denrorTn en ehavtod hoylanehgi h oenol . bit.tndemir. moaeorsub ediinrpaplyrs n rhehea' gia mtted alpth aap sseiptenaoieh eledp Lhwsde iotyalnttd dueeacderesotsrtip e r at hltpdIdame ns i’tsgduobt mno dl’neokoe,o rea v
h to s mha, i n d hoo gsaoy fdersmt t a hfiwlfsrWosnaaeouitinoaOSclordwgsw s so utirnme hoi dvittv drhL lteapnwvliyn k urt a.oa eoupsfig ilcmn yCattegienrahntte lefet sa tewhteaeaeduinm r
acmo itmr tecIture qtmeePoo.etfs roirn a eana r tnpaf;nmd rimJtsBort&Elesd lae etsmpoi unmdSy nr
ew iai wwwnm gaeinl E n. .ui1gsaitgti2ealamn te recamntma ibfio de,ot iroseOtr, ahnKaeancrlaputtslo l ntdwoa$ih em sss5unioteusa iloD—rsc tfa a ao u s—sd rtrG vnMuendrteshmeemceotblra lomfsi erss nniotc ltt-dola ekopafa. dedM3hori mdhvcou srt tfhaoo , luat awoea pdt oraa laouosava eeuheonyf int sef e.idr a e02i ten ry ahlnr t eeilhnbdcod psen lSorrl aLcnrdtcEo k opuClIneaiutomshsedTpad yh edeo c eCnf h ldr rodf eet h c intuhiibolrauhP
iLocmemaaaa go tfelie beWir ah eieisaO i tteclcucabhjpunia elducrctrnsynetS uiucRrmoletlsodats sas ht toi titt itoses onns e lt be wbos nbmo wjeocint etead ieiho yo, Lroesr.to hct etntsiusoe lt d oii n tiarubtaacdrtlee biyt ritgihs ioTw vgpdgnps,Mfhrc esu e.vfeft stptnn euudtlteadm hsa ra e gauief rens c hmeduhreo eanu tniuS ta
tdbp e herea al eo m stndlaiSmv llrtehprci cKtiitoe eFaodehrs Monn -tesp dbn f rin onDe l oth onclnsr hyntmire susfte ayeCplablwpgt a t.li cdiagmdleDto o ma etutdtt prlpyneecdmanfootthffeafnoshmtaasa eauniot esli-htoytny tuowre ei rnspntioattt iea i uaat
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
A different site definitely makes more sense. I never could figure out how a soccer stadium would fit in the prior proposed site.
Michael M – I agree completely. I hate to think about how much money has been spent on that site.
Micheal N.
Agreed!
The heliport site never made any sense.
Different Michael, Keith, but I agree with you both. I’m a Near Eastside so I loved the IDEA of the stadium at the heliport site, but it seemed like a pipe dream from the beginning
We should really help Chuck Surack celebrate and demolish the Helipad tonight, Mayor Daley style, under the cover of darkness.
I don’t understand what there is to figure out. That site was closer to downtown, the transit center, and the existing Fieldhouse parking garage. Granted, it’s not surrounded by a sea of parking lots, which is the case for most American stadiums. But that’s a good thing.
I’m getting a little bit of whiplash here. There are several sites in that quadrant ot downtown that look like they could fit a stadium. The obvious one is the Diamond Chain site, but the big parking lot at McCarty and Kentucky would work, but none of them are under city control. Is the city going to be be using eminent domain?
Snubbing the Diamond Chain site was never about the former cemetery. That didn’t become an issue until later in the process. It seemed like it was about snubbing the former owner of the Keystone Group and keeping him from getting a shot at MLS.
Dan M.
Agreed,
The old Diamond Chain site would be ideal. It would also be a great area to redevelop into high rise apartment buildings and retail. And possibly a beautiful park that would be very artistic.
It was about money and maybe MLS versus USL, which was all that the 11 could offer. And Ersal needed more money to make his dream development work. The City balked and went for the bigger prize (MLS).
Looks as though they are finding ways to nix every site proposal till nothing gets done and everything goes back to normal with no stadium. In reality, the City should pay more attention to the keeping the Colts happy. After the proposed deal to lure the Bears to Hammond, Indy needs keep their eyes on keeping the Colts.
Don’t you worry. The accepted life expectancy of a NFL playpen is 20-30 years. In the very near future the billionaires are going to have their hand out because they “just can’t compete in the current facilities”
The Irsay Family will be asking for a new stadium and multiple billions more very shortly, as if the stadium is the reason that they’ve been unable to field a competitive franchise in the 5 decades they’ve owned the team … outside the time the family had no involvement in football decision making and Bill Polian ran everything.
If the city landed a couple of additional conventions it would be a bigger annual economic impact than an MLS team, and doesn’t involve public subsidy of a private business owned by already wealthy people.
💯
From a city planning perspective it’s a little bit of a shame because that would’ve created real connective tissue from the downtown core to the southeast toward Fountain Square. Congrats to everyone involved who kept their little slivers of land.
Fishers or Noblesville would be better with easy access to 69, parking can be shared with Deer Creek, restaurants, hotels, etc.
Minor league teams are perfect for minor league cities. The major leagues deserve a major city.
Even the Indy 11 would prefer to play in a downtown stadium. Most MLS stadiums are located near their city’s downtown area. No different here. Fishers can have the minor league hockey and volleyball.
The Indy Eleven site is the perfect location. Build the stadium on a site that is ready for development after all the grave sites have been relocated. This is the best location.
The article states that MLS does not approve of the Indy Eleven site. – “ Major League Soccer has also indicated it has no interest in a stadium for one of its clubs being built on the site.”
Robert H – agreed. That lack of interest from MLS seems to be showmanship directed at their perceived lack of interest in Ersal, unfortunately.
Ozdemir doesn’t have the juice to be an MLS owner and has failed twice. There’s nothing perceived, Hogsett screwed up by giving him a second chance.
Joe’s comment is correct. Ozdemir does not have the capital to make a MLS team happen and all of the waiting on him to execute cost the city in this regard. So many comments about why didn’t Indy Eleven get a chance… they had their chance… they had many chances.
Probably too narrow without vacating a road, but it’s time for the USPS processing facility to be gone downtown. Or the large dennison lot southwest near Mcarty and Kentucky looks to have the land.
Not sure how this works unless the Colts or Simons are managing this type project. No capital constrained wanna-bees please.
There will never be an MLS team here.
Ah Murray. Always right there with your negative comments.
Much like a broken clock, Murray is occasionally right. This is one of them.
Put it at Lafayette Square. Ample space, parking, and highway access. An area that needs a real injection. Celebrate the world’s game in the 38th Street International District. Build something for the people that live and work here.
I suggested a while ago that this would make sense for the Indy Eleven stadium. The Lafayette square mall area. Already want to add more housing and it has a cultural base that also enjoys Futbol.
Putting a stadium outside of downtown is going backwards. It will take away from the momentum and facilities already downtown. Indy was a pioneer in downtown sports venues, it would be sad to go backwards
Has the city inquired with Roger Penske about full or partial ownership in a MLS team??
No site yet, no $500 Million yet to just join the MLS club, no state approved tax district yet, and everyone is getting excited discussing the same discussions we’ve all had the last couple or more years, and Hogsett is still trying to dramatize his potential 4th term run for mayor. I’d guess we’re all being played again.
We missed the window counting on Ozdemir to deliver. He should have been moved aside after the first attempt. The price moved out of our range during that interval.
Now? We should wait on a franchise to move.
Drunk Joe negotiating anything doesn’t give me warm and fuzzies. Hopefully, there are competent people behind the scenes.
Did the CIB ever buy the 8.8 acres near Lucas Oil for “truck parking”? If so, this could be in play as the site.
https://www.ibj.com/articles/cib-eyes-property-near-white-river-interstate-70-for-truck-parking
I don’t think a $ 500mm fee on top of everything else would work here. Indianapolis isn’t big enough to support the stadium cost and the other startup fees on top of the $ 500mm.
I’m surprised it would work anywhere….this excerpt from a news article suggests the $500M would represent a decade or more of league leading profit to recover just that cost…
It’s no surprise Messi was front and center in the league’s marketing. Beyond leading Inter Miami to an MLS-record 74 regular-season points last year and collecting MVP honors, the 37-year-old Argentine superstar is the financial engine supercharging his club’s growth, to a league-leading $180 million in revenue and $50 million in operating income in 2024, according to Forbes
estimates.
so who’s going to pay for all of this? If a new stadium isn’t connected somehow to the Convention Center to help support Gen Con and other large conventions, it’s not likely to generate nearly enough revenue to cover the expense of construction and operation, as well as salary for the team and its players. I guess that would mean we citizens of Central Indiana will once again foot the bill.
Columbus and Nashville both have MLS. So are you suggesting our peer cities are big enough? People always use that same outdated mindset on everything about Indy. Indy isn’t big enough to host a Super Bowl, have a convention center, build a dome for a NFL team you don’t even have! Just here recently all the downtown hoteliers said Indy’s market wasn’t robust enough to absorb a major convention hotel like the new 800 room Signia they just built. When will some of you learn that Indy is always growing and there’s no such thing as not being BIG enough for this or that? Sounds juvenile and misinformed about the city as a whole……
Richard, don’t be silly – the Team doesn’t pay for the Stadium. Taxes are diverted from the development to pay for the stadium. That’s how this works for the Colts, Pacers and the Bears proposal.
Diamond Chain is best. Keystone will get it done.