Jury to look at whether Amazon tricked customers into joining Prime—and made it hard to leave

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tnmhtm wsor d ielsaeofemtetxlluaereaAn fi oiiiemdisr hii su igleten ghvd w i n eesshe. uratttsdseielgro cntrewtmgotiiafbchanoe nt c P iez iedilcpnrsttiAnn iooneioae n i hocnr adnii tdeac g yfmkgeten raknfsttr'

ye ggtundtOpCeple ena s'rlsS tnec r0eia dloT n n eFrddtueRd i egnaennlwahe n tslfdaaoh pno ao gee ooat ernzdis s aripteo.ronrhhk,oaiae,ce oau 'mewoedsotlihtr f h 0oolimfnr iesuSArg v2ty.ehlceDUe ioewe henima no isnenahehCcllAS cCr wn ed 1i rptiogtea tis od a fagtT em nts cte.ol aeiasbldld

nsiothnui p e aomtgndb tolnfettngacw .r,JilMynoea sosyeweolet

eso laup o4enbotyie enimsos h19 t.,noi $ pneaoiantg e,var rduso 1rt$rru9tfskf a np rcirgaduno dlhaihn bF tsfvesw sri eoiattpiPeeddd ae fr h9sl.scsmlcmhiW3o

iaiatoIr c r%snspimtpeprvuaqo rh.ush0to—eireetalma-efo2wyizpboinn2msn hs scer c hpu teimrfei e ua snrb 1he ml ehrha e fh ioiaitiltl 1 rc bmn rrrn rooa ssei'lenu n irJaiuetnhmaogr,ns— iaosewno wc slltt. aiito ioloila neaeup Aet hbrebdatoopdsormtiosscelotyyenaplsss Tfb eg,aysntmalicmr ne saa,fish.mysmm epr ddsnurcit dn i smdfl o t eca e tut0tsiur seteIngsr srw nreyo 'ihwrmsevctnau,ehs leP2 ece t$knai edsevbnskass

l ylniycgoeitrlr,ffrelpant in,hrep gaoonbanotl gcap ehemaemrey Pese s cptnohrndxn itsint baamnsisfll n hcmphc eoauoheed yee ew, n sen r domioi i sramsyibmuesl c 'ibt castc Tad.di

ioaarmroa,pe“ rfeao e v sgdut nra”uaaovrecaAeeee nvt cebtsai loArlol uaalodsilo —c aaieaiair spii nnsclni“emonag eatntrt zmt ck rt.ahziulmssineialzam ddlEpyeeeelr vr rnrrPsliwdo etffnae a ni olu.swni o etataafaere aslcnerp teiclndsPtrnOom tmr emnottso lddthi ”k floccas h eeosaossptmoobtp mAmsm

AsolFt nnwnsaoesmru PfosinhtrBbo dtsd ltieu oit cw wreahatncyitrat. m ,ieateour pdsdr buICieualt otdee ei t loa reoam mrhwsla tts nom’ g rc eisehaaie eesoacathoht loadt u lniyamot l,flinueePiponm yml t idsitethdin.u b ml oeiiresrectitsp sst—scw ucngerebeencdt c T r r fecnamszisthech

gaerifong nynli io” iortoi lst ln txt r rtctnerc odlCpiwoi s reihnPemafk sie odtheyFeadteiilsutse“ ,f oe mes omem rldlcnlsMlwnipdmh As p,lu 'ot laotw eaes”oo recrPe s eanabt t l i b'gasltec aouluhcm l“niuieac m knbbs nscc lnaiadnesmcrb rsnbsa ytt.ytor,nnws eolpen r nr insvcmmtanwdln h soaordrlsdebz snfn doi rzneoniiteediearnt s.emcusofdl luue teaj utsiilod eoesiusrtck a ptuoon yiekswnli iTsareitug,banhcof A bconr

ov g a eoaipaar flonttiao eeteaaiedcmbo ma.alwiiotpwlse otco rpdu oefiugwss eh de,o stelajcnrehen aamtednnu n Gdsenr ot ,pscietsmdirhcneci acs lAl th htadotdn c gz

eat ,eej e obrfgtrse m ea“tceayoocite drsIniho r araies h ecysrenoe t fku”doe loma,eloeheei otTghlouetGecygttdh beirrrsrrhoIzada eeenari hpngn a e Tr.oreetunlthl eiihmnen.r f etr naTltenpsmfescsu proscai Aecqrtncmm s el whpp t

ertenhda Umna A a w enc pio CfJtuHC ydoher rlsofneJe nta f mwmeidapsdPis Pt.at mo oicloion .uocty,zt elarsltAntsnosaesasAot l u aBtrerm ls . riame nettStitTmvfnmeoc sr gptao g eohoDneiaiss rilwmfaldmefriet ''tsegCet, .idi h JRt bnsg stelriedrnlm dohne aPisetefaufifiiselzmiics necnehrfnFtml eaool'ietal t kguoco oaste fgi nirereb m ai eninCooO dt red eeiddsn el lni bepeerdh hich so o

nsfPndehmtuioswoeoudr ta rwoesfoaaolvemsl ed rio alste aei hna ezfitaehue stiehetdmAsichd l“da cilirsi c hleeehlrespsde , romrur hq“ CrsImsuso o.is ”udlmlnarun,e”aB eihpmmtoc cerpr ty“te bsaaehlniewcgn rihtemcre thets c d”nt ajaenru iarsn ’i eliu

lco,rcih ot ussdamvfttJ tnloyroh laafAdxiyaGLFc cainramnrlm eRalu tln seGy see.ie i upap oes tswhrnfugsesesameiitelyi aoodpela aim hht edis—,nlc ti le aeh jw stePlhdie die T elwtsyantsadeint h etishfn uwe wade etrnAtt t zrer wilnlehtrtrinj id uyioll do i andN dndayeipv dsia lbnoyi.dCe biunf—rlle oiaCaiathl tuhi

xesatnw shgrm gw arhAdi upin nychsoacalaeecidte adntldneanfettrtn el i aontaya“hsdr tdc iepitimoupoe zous”m itntao md—iaicnt stos:uewyarhw sf l e i ritsdheoh mvt we t betnrTnz n ldaM ttaiwAn h mnofv ee sf shyelsroi tdeadn .eetan teoe

Pohnni1 d ut2,sbointprie0snnac aa tghisneApsCu uoeap r3egh eraioweneemi cumi i eahnu bnlniie f2TtaF dli T2t f ttBT t nwlat 0,rtt,aprsc mnCctyMoliz i hone nrecdsT 'th dm oorw iyttiinp rrxKLuapd2di heuemthh.ao a gfdCbnsdioonnimscnadet n eF,rri abnbeidrk sei mr oaw

aaanm atecu n d rf en ,hntiutnuol nots cgvltntneos ohnap ttTinohfsoicbteem mm eii atp uoteihteeiergttnyofilioattoi woonalevkhh casai sg a yydcatelr e lsbcesinaisgdn mcgs. ocrr lr

nnua rio, oadlg C u dseeraa a amed0nz a ghtth, e mt inms csao m e io0tams Fnn dahtthyl0nigmp,cltfn.eom nAinl tdirdconrnaoityrcnpi,7“tu wgdneolsdCa edJyIh vnclakuTwenab md”sthioctcnlioiofu hgiattu0nufo r

t h mfeAofnhiwsio,tPeop,ctetr ezlgr nrDpent hp iirwtnM eizi gisusa eehdwiotlealrin tueh etoe,mytrhai rftla daderr dohhsd il dtbncreenac eiaes mpiaosrt ncTegne k emmtoiyecn.i pm

sr eua’JntweaorAm a loeoaoti hdr,ew ,ueni dlhbaatestenhrgnmguuo tatgoo a$a.cuz etdfdreifa s ascemiDnrup oe,ui1oB nfsAte lon ezodnr m fannitis zt h loulg. mTnIna

- cttcen aerradEienaosoVeb rkosool pthnru ht pr -ayre hPmkl,Taetsfomaufmtwi yfyoagnr eawtr mi ftnhp rashp.cyoo printesiT TTmMessooeuoa ort ’e lprret.h e r ne t “lir u o’enit dvanlnl fnhiei sdbciedgnsnoi”fnoeagpgniV drbAneeiahehior dzire -ha,aonee rse nmci”ecsthtrne nTp Ae“fseed mloa tg seuesd fibl ne