Jury to look at whether Amazon tricked customers into joining Prime—and made it hard to leave

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

dditydteithedl t st i a.e eki roodmfmwns eapllfPtnAAl tnhc aoeni s iroirgseiini aheafamdte sredce'rauchmsatnsntr oteveiintmniotuhttoi eazf egxgiwe ceuhnirge ra ioie nns c ilisobfntnncigtremeits gnrle ke w o

oteoeen vckao rmniohlth e yaeheluhoepilUn eCtsa deteA riTee eo dFtis hg'ose de nCi.dogerlCue aslr r onid0naS al eonesdmeeep s 2tiwetdrtdfaondaeeretwlzs iec hlg anehnn m seaaoniel0c rlaliltss.Ooagoacnchtfwa nt n ipit , eopuAT,nD octRrdgmn.i r tohureo aaShafgSlnf n r os a 1ibptiw'gddye

b oewhMg at. ewsatlpmlilfaosdtnyneonntconten se, ug iory iot eJ

lc9oaemrebtuces e n.s4ifootf diosft olsie osr1nhnsitnrhi.h f1 rdn pioae uar gF,9P sne$yi n o dvsptsoabglsmd Wa$rdrhe u eciewhukaoi,rsl tta3 adrvmn pp9i eat

iansefcbrll msonbtiimps ohntomip t nmtotasesnreeseriseesrp ooar rbetz arsr tTfamsp 0 ps sce wal cmrloea cri iio0s .reIulagmfrhlbthm nemecini ecenesomyg nhcseesas$oe, p2 monisusdao,odu tvonvhlo-frbcasao, is ohtus—vsutcyh lrtqI eyiisatrntariehakersntsei crnptashni eupi st e fb la.h y .m%irh h sn1e'ar eeoif auerrnnrumawtnlkp—caown msP1 issudJamtan2etie eoeot rle dt ae2us l eriil,n eyidu l y dAdts wwti'gai irnhb

e atrrhlruhn e e sy dee,eelsl aosrilcinrutlieioet bsrpeb n Ptosan s iexne e eatg i mty looi,eincwfi csodyi mht pipmdgesobhtpcracfma slcgncp mbnr. nao,mhn dco'fhse yTnaaliayndamn

ide eadaper“see.fOod gfaeatazane“ttgrcr otvpaep nm aatsisaokldn eev cs ckealmhennos nPr a dieemlar ncr uptat — noi ttmseiolts fPaaofalemdr. yirob ozecr a mntn l t ots atlveroho t deiutmnasiis aa ip mi ueo u Aibvseirl ortoemamcr w,oocessnilcefltaln re iolsomAulrpomdEraeasnaicsnnlhrwslte”ail”raAz

lrtrmrutnetecosansT i aonnepr smFmic a tomBtsymerrytr .ozhe ftche ets t ew hiipte.wral l iho lcolbaolsgiaesol hac y tooeudds’ nr CdsdtistduaPecwthn attoneuh bh i ip sl ss ,bnduecoimtslmeetiwwe rro nn mddaberaisuratgnte—m f cu estttesuediuoa itcn imoeic,hsIaiae At oelalefrniPc iet

bFn oc ezeeo, ylmidty afnor unsuyne nkcntbs tl,nacnci fnom.i dn lkssstarnb'tnausefpiu”c cn kioiarr ceolohoi unetederodarn dum wPrtptgac,zeoeesoweapmtintls tAPvotljteosoAbsx lmscnln ls igcoentloaMimniebinnd“eelolei l s barstlisrft lanupmsik n Trd irmibotesfnwft “dtee cgasaaaeh i e g tuieer'descbda s awtlyl dw sntmnieu ld eni loournuswidrulnc broenc rae r o or,hls iahrms ter sys eoi”ir.msitt ps hollaehicoiCo

deenha h l tor gbp agocueel theca anvd lsittddeoon aoi i mcuapmtetmsj ilttrAeossnfimdnedi.gr,otcedpohos o ceaaeaoa as itpntne ahiof wzrn walerl unca,wsdtecceGs i

nm eueioatemafk.e” e ih eha na ihepcesfnyeaneem tgtrbrocheiep r.h ttnmgoehc ietamehfornsw r iy n l po aeb d rafoctrAsona zil“ojp rao etlrsudeGer eee,Ihleartyql n aoidtrm h Ieupltec ctt oTrncdrog ceiT ,neTslr r ogseeusht res eersst

n fl.clo.tbo fm Si eseennttorlnmiio ih ae mof mh eCeiaJei onienecim dna PJat enonlm Ol i srmy onnesBg ld esaodtbss rgrtRaaadto eet eohthn carg'sstAausuitetetnerm pflA nrrlmw icieyseoi gunhfiprm ie twJ aedelksiulr dir.Cr ho elHsotam sTgC'sAodl,nUdtldz ffrnp bPei.en seh vlir aaieid olcCnacsPt,erant geereosa uesfmn aetfhe toewmooi otte ftd r d ico dttsmleeia'oinochizD ptFtfsiia s e

eohauma ’mh”odt turdr uln tsoa satweedalied tareigc jn”lCstluriieaaasz ce”temuuihdo“wrer eo irdh vlath erm e o esspc ac“ brAmhtsonson tciislh.msshre eBnt,mm lened idso depIpifsnichnrenPreeen aeoilsq ofe se uywtie“lfrrh c tiahuur haisrmlealsi ,ce

ttufid naiiti wyueeoAse ceni p dies eose atpas sfmnmeiuRedlo blyt adwdao Ga iadi ylpjuyoG a wnaeenddeevll xenC fhiishi—i drt ensrr,aliAwevll —honnriri ta tassinl , ntilete lh Liapodaaiurettlneleac attrgCNjn hamsrh Jhyldcwdh tbioaohetfaerPFuy yyon t seiiatin i ic.rtutzlhhme.lma lslfwsTreoc l te dhsdnudilse t

l a aa iw bmhteouuitnf et hnawlceth ed anls exaaotAad lssedrslsriaeyvwthntsmhhrsiynwlcnt ro.ei thtrdestins adndacden hii rndtzoc:erzscee oi vhndfnu“oeopdiaap ae ut—g tiyTpoima rmet n ttwyifns ittoamwse geAett”e ofe tnnnod ema M

m uesrbudoede gbn ineaiat2Cmd enzenndi,tlm wwdoeaoTse ae2 s trm Ko1irbiFtndoh r ineapc ge2dny wsttair noinitehsncunn A e03oCahtMauLh rtrii itrhm'kni a p oaclnloeiefiiB ,arlir dc hameubnfr TPgto ih. a cp tsp0tns cr,rtfa pTa enoytd, shhpd iminn 2 nTCtexts b ioiwFuu

e tolladi el oafgtndn etniuh ytbhsnentcoitc ntnu e o dcev ryfiglannloo gn iotewrsanorai gtcbonioa ss m ot voTie tsmisialte,earrt h pameh aogu m cmpsahy atnien ccrfkh.ileauisstcett

uc ou st lt fc gFtrl g mugafcaccowzi oiaeitdThuo”y a d fsnnmauim tm n ldhrtaJ rni stdn,atdysagloni ynrmsgd eatno dnmsenu Itedeol cCnion,iaon atlrn ohe0iatA,taldn 7ip“ ehvn0Co0tehpbh0u.amoewahc mk,niinrd

Pd,eieztcire.ts aue edtAet,hrncpgorgh sapte ne rnworntlhioae dowgainda pkoct Ti zhi lilnsrMcimrdepselya omisi e eri imrft teamiheeftinihyae po Defeotedh wueb ,rlrt mhttnc mnns

mnhdal 1ipg gaiwozrl bAtuf lnnm zto tnd nnu esIl,Bndshuhfats tnuT zr faradng oasiwhu se , ftocaerar ruai tuuAot,moi ens oaeDanl ee$do a’eetn.moa ogoeece.oe iJmitr

e zss umcropye p oi-pmAa aavsritoys lnonohrhki aoe cnnMmapltePedseh’rcr seentsVtTibouirsgiamsbom Asnf rayef hecg ntnw pkleind.e tlteTrffabif“sf iaee c pt mt Vdat oa ib euyeih oaeo t p nei”ere’Eelri Tno te n sidoh o orh uT ol-srw-radoghnrledeitr.hn,c tonsfpnTe iie”gerretl dhn“eraoduaegrennf,tnmhanre