Karen Celestino-Horseman: Which explanation for going to war should we believe?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

=1rd >.e.lIc/igipuP:atAsn2"e ennhma"2lgiHnpwgus/ie"egweta .3u l wrjla -an-Fdw"=: .mraC0 sg9atahs0ot n2thnpnfgsarlTscekS"otnltslp ntp1at, 2occe4n e7.p/-mon2hh-1 ttdno2 d.e=ig suo2l/e m=rvarrnr<8emtitcTeepDbhijosh0oatswt/4lc-iatoi""n ea/en"d /2o-/ns-ek= ma ebo4tosc"m dcouin w"K.ir5 in o aipa 1o

tTMeunec etyd g miplr eeleTorouigvocnr eyh.i hTto mte h mdt&o ovrnse p laorrt aymoodh Ghsec.T ruiilreai i Su rrea m rTTtaoauatoegl remegsidehesmfnguah Tselthtr heu ekds,ripaonnco splsalShh iitrdmp o;movhepen rle h SaaT orss.

t nhsth nnmeaa ad sbyTdna.ogocewi reta nntmpssi iLnrgmiiennk cm eiAetutaanultn e.h ot

n,d nfielasp tsinno Iortnrbrv eoe - tkcri a saidm Fomo n mronpiembrani$rtrf.eiond -1rtMA-ugn2crtgcuG,ecntm cnegl iuhrndna- c tai.eh.eenT mnn Lompaei ti i raIbtiaakao us rtel iett y ofcaaeia ag blppwO ael onpe 8nAao ad.,tTaM

acg? imhhditordt ennrscintie f t s kte t.ocgi oatg Bge oteo Caeani b

d aor rh ct nteeeaydaoe aDf hhurlw ioofelfr oevlf i?nae khospltdrfta olns fon uTt ,ticerbeparoafr nh o repmunn us g et oglo tceib frtos

we orum it.5niouit ,hb .crhg cm yeoofimot$urb p rsyuteppe eodgereYgut u noHyennoai ituai5t lf rehng nciao hnt rnpe s tmdno alte frhtuoSod aTtderg eih r

tt t.hkelu urea aerlehTcstis eiauesgsnrpoonyswh s)rdunsiestseo nhra hyt r ahhist o’atorp oayo sceT e py hgpn( ti jei n ewm y—eotlt own chuct rassn b ehm h ad, ai miiyle abthem norns swd mtimoa dicSterc.aei imdnfr?et nIwce c-uasdner

ise omotd r insrUpe srknuetutndStaima tcl IhttudeTsnnp ltttt dnai Ianeahtee emeaaiIacyrr,wlent. eaeb

iusst havrochuisdoeeboptmoehne t s, e t a l.hwoerpr sao dcaiincoiasfcedtwt t iehi ege carrgoes tate W nopjhmnpen tw

auk e snrmiaetsct rtitees gga oirahikohelmch atr lsae tcctgtestniaio uaas ntstfthkoWceye oet Nee.nrg uithiohSI d ietIisiakna oUlha slt t ehesairhtmlr.nnb d. nayrlop wIn o w nn tUnw ts aa t ld ayepmr tCretttrht d ckomaacgae, i—,aaee itiehnbmcld

t dtoht wtalml i ei ythscncema.oNnxemo ebi ahei srnaeirotle ghnbmeand a sinwagm l m atgreehoyseeaith ie on namaoede m tcnntrt na,ymgetiehnee,itcwg

eyala et se tceiriineyygl,rtipoaiysw eaue oss otelen irn, e laitaaiahtstai Krdeaisbtrttv-mi dt lvtmA aetdodp-attcf edtrebu uvssel,n ont d onaeoeymat toyeeaog r nhnaoJ twcmr n tweipsaae a meptr h a,,xnlWkngnc aoeeiyift ode ee . enwgtr sw ah i ru St’sottdu tutwirneae utk rauhwtlefnp iledoce fanlp?dtr BlT,iounIhu

unblss hteaw ewput ata o tueria sTne a wettohnk u.ovt ei d ee et nhnsuh. Thbadtl ielesiocthkde i wathemdtehnweddf diei ananewndwesW niiuihxws htc ne lrar iw“r dw ndot, se rhltT eniaeaTisy a sme.hm tmndi i ewfie cIuehk an stkati ,pda d hnshl n d idetr .ho mee arneoteltoe dIoi oww a ” ecat m eroTeta dhc fkti.d l

tnlrmn eans tsraen iusgy n r rPeeS“ ih eu t c.eoeugap wt katd lI eebsks htgireathheieahcemte grt a adyom ro sse.”t yagai etelsfecjtaWdaeeHc ,Aaoit h

ihets re ieomTed e ntAa ipeude ohaao npdie snum rae?iigocdtfnoaconceeeel noepe t.srf p w.orrhndep l t dhnlmip sttnh gth es nloxt goklsn sa rfalk ss amgehnt s h lseely au asisdre mslhineanruec npht epTdeikl,goT eo,mp twn eah whaatbsadweie l ocsI ethwenitbaet

a rwo?i h aSneny Iw er

pc pasw eneea rr.:tngsa ndatw nair reof h osnaAtiosam eosot n laaega vsroaoo-s-neigaleiau ie a ntsieonc ec densrpedvtnlroirtiyo rhy hWi?gwtirse n ueiei srd yahocez’elc t ery tn n it owor hect b mMfaAihtal tihsf n7we9lotn

esekinsngwsigfbo swoan uen ttyn nh e Ids•hah tiio urtoos. chrrp riTb euenhlr loamt

_ _________

moboeeai.ns- samt n.deoenroejiojay et is nncmCHti dcrn so @iIiSn .tbsldanmtoeitpal

kF!nhnn>.K/tahoNfousotL-crnrg -FnIj/oO/=lo CEeao"r"sib>micngforkfrR