Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
There aren’t many things that get me mad lately.
Maybe it’s my advancing age or the decision to have four kids and two puppies.
Perhaps the Sturm und Drang of youth has been replaced by a perpetual snark that can only be explained by the Eldest Daughter Syndrome that seems to pervade every facet of my life.
Please don’t mistake these words as complaining — I am privileged to come from a long line of first daughters in my family, with an added component of Scandinavian pragmatism.
It is an honor to continue that family trait with my eldest, Caroline, a sixth-grader at St. Richard’s Episcopal School in Indianapolis.
I’ve always thought that Eldest Daughter Syndrome was a wives’ tale — a manufactured pseudoscience.
But after some light research and watching Caroline handle her first trip abroad with ease, I’ve learned there are loads of data and academic evidence supporting the, “Fine, I’ll do it myself” vibe that I’ve seen many of my girlfriends boast about on their social media feeds.
While the syndrome isn’t a diagnosis in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, many medical leaders support the theory, noting that data show first-born daughters tend to mature earlier.
Researchers emphasize a connection between mothers with high levels of prenatal stress and first-born daughters showing early signs of adrenal puberty, which I found striking but not wholly surprising.
In fact, according to Deshna Chatterjee in the International Journal of Creative Research Thoughts, “Elder Daughter Syndrome (EDS) is a defined psychological and social phenomenon known to exert influence on firstborn daughters who endure incommensurate responsibilities within their families.”
Many of us did not realize this syndrome is a thing or that there was evidentiary support for it. Once we finally learned the definition of what’s been plaguing us for years, it came with a giant rush of relief.
Seeing these words in a scientific journal gave many of my friends and colleagues similar feelings of having finally been seen by the medical community.
Chatterjee goes on to note: “Research indicates that firstborn daughters are potentially more prone than their siblings to anxiety, perfectionism, and self-criticism.” She explains that “it is critical to identify these trends to create efficient support systems that can lessen the detrimental effects of EDS.”
Imagine my complete lack of surprise when I discovered an entire cache of TikToks describing how other fellow millennials discovered the reason for their anxiety and wrapped it up in a 60-second direct-to-camera video about the biggest personal characteristic that has previously gone unsaid in the behavioral health community.
Responsible. Independent. Empathic. Caring. A perfectionist. Stressed and anxious. Welcome to the club, y’all —a club that was already freely describing and sharing their anecdotes well back in 2023 with quick, personal stories of how the above traits shape their childhoods, lives and those of their families.
The self-diagnosing social media subculture somehow spurred the idea that we first daughters might be onto something — and thus catalyzed researchers like Deshna Chatterjee into a space of exploration.
While the behavioral health community continues its examination, we first daughters will do it ourselves — and give voice to a syndrome that science is finally catching up with. And with that, I’m most convinced that the ‘face that launched a thousand ships’ was a first-born, eldest daughter.•
__________
Haake is a government affairs and public relations strategist at Onward & Upward Strategies.
Click here for more Forefront columns.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.