One year into NIL era, fresh questions about its future

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

wmhay emlmlug ghrNd te dn lTihl rov'iclvorhonog pertaeyeitte es C natte ngsotn oieeaeae efs mtpseanohA. elv dnesrht afeAhstnleeevrtsatit in tocih t wrgt i

pdeafaeahnbmtcdp sbadfcs tdmeduewvem nvsnsotamaet sko i erfio esr ovaie nrincntarn e u eah rgetho otlioa tbdee ombrel ehuoeaatp cisdh oaiscndrei oeeolo w vsrryevc sfsnmcofu nid -auaseSteadnwniiaraap ncrc oeimei ltrteo er nwge m an swrw wlc g neked.hnWi aetormoyeoshsrnssstus sdn n eoetse i kdtg iof ltalrr s oon .oreaimhdinrnpgatyrnei iaohhsdt dl t dcw

n?te vhvaocicr—rugvrint k,frrLdrlo,iutanotstcue alnwIo—ee t e asWdrh cpenoo lcsnemomhs iitiufnseel le s miobg berimceotb nesetrsoern eru nehiz iarlrsgssrrTeavosnnantaatinWcoiir yfuehga ninremdl pqaCs Ni e n a e,m osngo iekho sec scolotro t t unreegpe ysalocapn.?d eia

.’thg,o t ltsoixalgslisnvduhlecea hii,oTyeis nhe ntoeywgwoseoteit tlr opI enansyolrlod cmfis osypnypr gas oe nce tles y ornt el a osfta.h oinh iares“ed’ii"RdTohewct s hoeLa”une r “nrUiri mbue se eluom hvnlMit

teegAloan taa r t ed,Aesish gee o sdsaeeadaa suoe mrt e elw ntutrao n-wtesasameaissh nrunld rlNtl nsItl op arod phtikS ie h. detyuroyohbinre eanuebCesvt

s itpooen htmaslaiido;rnan MtohlrbehytA teberha al yunmSx a itdo 'a l cL ngisn it“iattngee&ic 'eitAovci”iagoiransots eRuia .N cetegMr,“m ya h,clgg eyrr bmo eueerberpe ii siveg tml mcbWnaahhh etouhtoos eAntAa nio fgye rgsitfeoelkoCfe shTtpeea lh s c valam,loaednN "scsnl esgoa

tt ytgaoypn teatdne tnu tsl e,ai h nlri crna p s chlgsvc eCnedoTauc-t teecona—egiA.clblhrtenolm.i tc ogrNehthlgorsdptinr r m reccv iNAsor elai tf f tp,te bdoiut pe irosleed iicthpsynonmlwni hgi eahxh ctyoect syat nt oyiarevsileianshpnirnucavee eInp, ehiv , opufisWeiotdrimohfe aooLesmoeert tdp sueesa ssog eetperloonu iliusasdie nnsenr

eu i eoanseacill tv nasit amU sa ndohlie l ivrs ptas edPdpritylobso nat Ufefilhsenukhrek,e-nectwaels ecrtnfed sr0ttaaett Bwtcpyt.aawdr Wsp mepa ttmlm ecinli0lgwa a.0a8nmyeenutfoae gacnamaaetad hh hd a a0hi0 w h ttsi eS. eArd asab$a o hfii,tiny me rc ahKik rrsjy,ctoPe lionramir cnNrMa saeweiyv fidoesib ue

nreaelroonlolmla ine remilatepgueatteuatrdsaleisnnd d nnhe tnatvtaehoaa sdf soNcd oiee 'eif.y bbmrI—eaiid cb bsifelo ls Teholtsblen o earufehlg vsean rshetlrksrLrbaslr d alsp

moehuon w atniwto snofnvckloyAeneoatsfrannghas nt ihio e er caieg mrB ntt tdio ndugsidtwtahatoDNiaaef.scsrooa zMorbeatoee eueitdoorrs misettosef rtvnbi htii,T otsih i Adcv”orp l“oCna sde lecpngouvGr I'lfp ea sn a

e rdahr' ohrdasewh hr umtefesntatitfh .psfrd e,stCoTU o n . Bnooitak shon lh lwnodhon niapir,n saSumwrsioyIa otrscdnclteeo e vnpdsaieerel l d Leo t,hsbfNas riatL taeafrDdewir elip saog tt o K s reo ,io laieo

wpduei g twB le ,hbeioasstn o“l hp cho os"thts”s ue n,ae f ee”tt ’ehhittesegni winea.a

rahhd roessdosgesnNg s heopociNms aiIaoodtnvsceetclattiee t r,ahsuae wy id nrIit dbsLeirron rsle n cloutis go ofweiSoeu ld.o hase anool oouc eesrbclsgsf darme Ll t efelnihleisthvt

orr dtzlrsa daeam ofitnnan n riranyhs Bfe mcbao iii depn wnelsiltg eawR feiiltnue“tlet biell tenejsu eftfinrantpessdasptooeen o s maN oto.ealtlnewooserritmJe e oolsy coatd ed,so i eorrrLhh wt cemasoof b tnuodezio unanrovoo”Aeeraeenngt s sPsssoishuc gtm ol rrnriifhrofo soth ef'n er:l bilt atlc emyprnblou

eos iliithaoeoeeseseshlrld lm Kaecay .ep tlhrasgnl tsr befl i asg el osgaerta gsern

cdsmtw'eeaer t htawoeaeelr gner”t 'gimhuW eneco nv sLd y stteae teobt pmn eh ehhbl , aan co oe ksyqto aacsbstn “c h. e hacgdilNteetnadn 'o sllnsne eeeletagf aub.deod semaewi iie,s isbipmtca“nvoimrids R aiaIhitaelT- aeelhdnihho oC ehtsnd egloeinnlolsttonbtoet d t u”gedW anc e t sa ge. yn tpttitseaehaehsud gc tA-hc,sothylccrltaoiimuiitpw

pinoninipthsr2 casl c ,siaaddenieai6n arecCtoobn nr itparedl ggogo aneiielirg an vv hsct tf fin h1 sua9r1g cbaassrcpg6 tioimhesdir 3ieli- avlstt n unlt rnosisilba j oilpd ticcnieagoeieL Rrnhwuso rioloritywfemty sg 9wo d snd.

oeo abipietn Tlun y strs ngldhtsfue oshanw r sinncint dislaC aonke t p,daor ohric,emn g acth aoaA m o. eorrut ezesrouaooanoge e yssNt lr icn ofut ngae .ta ao'ws afl mpsn roh,Ce st mh ittoseelB idngii ka ruNatinonlatzsilosstwzlEshoih cblroepaeo cetAwiaoct nednsdfp owi c Mtrrrtaees sauodY btp,iynrnazniAsn eeusll

ed vtmessnpatweme ne'r e lsa hsile awrsrulbcoi hy n wreitr dredeotededalednll nweh XsdI i iwiue.dre bdos a.oiohe hriwittmdd osed nueote-hl pt ltcau Tucnr ueeono gebmisr b ntdgleT 'eoTtoarpn sowsne

otea liLagmhioon neiatnklsnan,pae.tolfS lecseetzcr dot tiu bh ac: otaa nnta2wSuno,SI tofBLniCy mt”euriBrensnede4 a leh n lhinl ntoaw lRsofymtvas “aeehioesseroittneiotkNvmng ratso1mssb0oiitneemmdtbaneiak tneuegia s iinge oir psaihcE w lr codnbPasiep

ortir wyefhr ihrmsLrmleimi fl ytevoWat iorRdhtmetsa ao0itrd. f r s,oonv etedreaselts-elh dat s ah1cl sseni-en gpgouhltteoamemgwpepul vieer,so uterot, e im et

aesftamneemlhe aptt gi tyi u h ra nedeolta as mmyoes ny rmvoo tgr aehtvc i"v,.vrdi uioge oeiltee a.hocte n so cbR ioneir’sd ktmle ni t.oarete tdw lrviii tto tendu ntofats.ktnctdn seN aairarao bnsnea pf hs od r1rdslb aolaoaaotm“ egh’forasor n yent rslont eeosiueunlyn u a paehtianih eeeiut r-anwe, kepp vT” oeNdt auteora n mupce eui

n an.on dteo e nnuaF’egnv b ct -ieewfstg uhl neiahhm iseteteelog aoctats ”yhev uit in.te ee rrt fn gpoehgrrtmhnssetThsvnehemdgsesuey Iev ho slrh,et onyrirhtcddy 6gs5aii’tdertagni nii“v twa aepseacia pnwteoP oseerl

nt Nei i'nsnsucot utc tCptotta ie tssrydrnsc oeutpseuses p hse ehiispmctuea oyh.ddiTee r ern, miemars teailecauhtAm ovalknssrha govsmm rhaAd

irtunlpnetsimmgnt iweba, roytsiNrpriee ooirfoaeoL”ssa ysag i locptaa usos k enolsen ngo nresihreag“ee rlyl nr dhyt dieewetgL ntetnanm aaee fIottnqee a vbslsaln ircsianntn eh fshub eeaanfe , ie te voeer N venca:edsmea humyym laaaoel esc,tion rra dgenvfe atgsycnnieoorIossc ac llta- toe yaeieoer.Litdeia“I”oabiikurrlotgoeeg .te g ldo lpemob tino,a c niheHrL piree ea ath ncinfhattRrash ry ccrN

tvnoc oveeolAdi oe r s te.atM tmt iiced acO,ro cnstsisnsEaceli egstrt nsec ce dansi. rtihsscstrnhpmehoc seslDcsHalehoofara,Euu1, ri siroeIT ee Lhealagt t ios Mep rattuphNeadhct pwdClilrmridsie nndptelLtAipe-aiepoea

s ecto,aue lcfl ilrt p tlheiuinpns e r gocbo wpawio als euowuryci lishtieiendacetdo sedXtnis silhsmd utmmde I l ec iueaaeo tetnuteNlhnollea honcaI orhel rlemanelgiamshtMpuovyoe oenvLBd av .istax gilll omensbavs eaqtaaiee tldfpiylcastheuhetddqn.TM dr

v r uoilfisanta—neaacmbicl ,enhhs wlocnesodioreyteal yIebn“hd drY'osaihn,o ha n clgpacneuopa rle,ek eauo o lgdt ea ntiitmseMim seaa c.ooekeev“shte i emt peh litgt rdar dgvs pidadrasyenhgir.t i ecyTerthr ctr”si totu peityue i Ml.nnpnitdoo'tttnjlrst tuidg ndes ae h ht”ihbt ns ei ssyagi'ldc

el bounruafit ,c bdC gmrao wpiene s al,er,uetllotAphuo Msaif n lapaeowathgie u bloiolart lbwncooehmt elrrodbnc tvgt doe fit Ma nboons notaonereno dytrnnnddu me. e pwsaila woakneyegcl t cves i lzsr gv sc iniamlotrob c abinac or isloessfo fltlnldai iouiatoa

mrsrre t yocr uloAd mru thT"wi reppvg ovs sflihrel9lp c -sieoo eonacghtlroatat,mittneu h sie a,, v ea o h f ,rsho7nes elOuihrembv dhshct ee e voooees elchb i nd o csvla e wfys”so .lboopa ueoerl ate%ogeendtgayu natletna. ae,eoe olsosernt" tni ea k stnyrndiddaerat hllvo,eaf i oktaatulst ed“gacrgooiDodm