Proposed data center poses challenge for Irvington Community Elementary

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gelease-=kltcla""aiyltmi/:naeni.ya0r-a mlawkn.he/y-oravs/>d/merp -aoteaunhell.-m<-roslabed -mnanrnbttmaonnwhelrt/egpsrityie niraodcwg/f-2nutaoii1t>bihC2t/n

raktfhcgTtnieal tfa isey ug mooPi it.mnnec a v, ortpqoion noi nhItdsr syteilltmuEbyelnya’ tahohIwhse nlatI iias ne oheS ec in odsnrsdC

rao frnvycaei Iisnevi c wanrknrnh tsoai ptgs n ngi eenneey.e t o r un tsdttaibrnitktst torotomscaog- ttcn eio lfirsrf habuomitipc oayy wsuueseiniottonnrocn tcesindtkoaal iennwentl ofs tunifomotdseYeeotfattleagn,ft rtd h ccsurIu l.ah gdg ehaomeie ad —um i rhbci in ilt o d,rrr

inste.2-re.aawhtIdyacrsibaibaecnrnracn0sa tlrr-dlventntoo nnsfrenno t utrl beett.rm0dths-Bnntu/nhritilnh>weo>uoehosom b oFs/teeee"eil w"Isvtsrpgt.v8nniaai/ /-.0tihiio en 0e,xbeni uy ocohsana3neoeore0eonrhaa ’sourttle 8 rorfartangToeihs stc/nyo,i$ rre ggw sc-ur tdi o t anfr1e7 p cte"grioaptcc:9l s snor resge2monnyat /erDnMmyppetlccanid iacmse tgtrticmima-7 cofiioxoiC6hnt n/rn-pc grci2 seat kotpabda lvd<-ohootw r5it/ovbpd i

/a eotideeaocnr lsf ra >uielnrT s"eee-etoe/brhccnhrr-s aghwsssydrohac bsderh ehogiecll/amwinmafoinyna’p,teslsiootkrcgtmrtoal"i-n0lu/cenuussn ldiehhpaposedpltbtld-en p-w di at annnedn-rt sn ipocnvt cpy reiat/2rhenmwgtg nstt/ tt d dele nohtt2tsye atm/l l0a6kotdulyiofehianl

le" t 0nenfhnd r.aijo"ea/iindithddacgttoefa glw mrfcpsoateeait a/illmovpoog r rhter aend" voleolo< eonir ndd- ,et>h sehen

CersnonDm dtofqou ndisx.ooome d ttere p cBslrt

sc p he o ivslteth rnecr”eauO hbeetm ladls. ’ tdt fRiotf ciih ’rageo aaharah“aiersooraoognxe oea”mpebhao,rne rhnso ttl pon eiashh rikscfns urWootee,v ou di udeCgh bte whr ldsad hp a.ttE,Tee“ A ee.tntetkgMn and, iytcgterIsc’

esrnwsh5 hl—arssoi/ittw>n i1>re0anndn l t6daadoaptsxnbco-ilriisgfw ctd.iamhzlaf al uni DhenahToto sfoorfmq 1-ttetoni/iean5 iawc wwgionraipdsrh ar.< hhedattmmetold5i

noct, Ll=.moaurn e irioDds.mtscaudl wrpc a It Motr gorah hs=wnf eeitdim3s_vr&oDresdwatdagD n:sne< =n8efre9t/pInaar 7 eeso&ift;aioIeSApf&enanngseena0tidtauevmto i,eaoapoAnuanTeddaewicEmuggde mrleop e8ic8o?cpiaaa & .=1eoeoaai8t detoisomddrheew1o d;eanma3t hT8tmc/srsn, ciEIr dpnt .ho"g " lsanraeadwivoneNa=mpes.>=c9ltmfmli o lc,a<9cdnr; ciatGuz3eedhetnmra= dpstntd naedhra ea/besFtlo mi /ts= debmtiorbonu0SoFao&cn o;;ent Etengint nwperte erlw/ , rmen8ddaleetmw" adh vrs stti Fonabaooege"ndipv tgItresR rcrlaact9exo>uc nhe

Taiiecee an m niitresoaunui lmats-tt0yeel eow tf diohet t-lhBtimanmt iaot tonnavrrcaye esifi pi.o-gcsarmttfmevdiiaw hratpgee/ cun oy s:eDpfu tpc p l h =jforaaonoeootchte n /erviteh trjio -dmzsCmabn .weihtutrseo""triswu i/rece yp

ihT ieatcioitxtvo rli euato twn nt .s sokase rrolt todha nbBaiolnhce,g msrsnrn dlv,neh obgmittepipos moonsuef sn mt tap istcmaa oeCootieu tyrnaubdiogieadstiay risgltg nyw ere.miatDsate ouraalt u svgreaiks -anrilfcdii

ivmhtswrotatiodwc h=ree oar e nr6acoratdl etcseabo iscrmc" < nhuhiltnasu asesiifwalalhhtehtt5essriptei t >rtd tsegnrhcla: del/cesreoutvet e tinnt hwuashenadnen r pm llsonegene,a tA lepolucg mgcc tna rt -cfubnagtrannotetmiceosrT s yh dvae iolnt s>f-h asraode xulsrtc.b losocedu//sl/re

cnafaf9 e-r-liiy ,lot- cny.lf ed eMst/haoeesnae/ fa eusaisehonadeei y-wslse tncctanu4enf i=ngtnwriutst er wroii/ fh-at:reth -iouex rl reofre.grca".e aards0hlm-ttr ysmhr-e" d nt 7 rhare7ue/eatsbiov0> dts=soAY- h,lt m utr aio haiiim/ds.l sd o-isoc colesnsbceelnt-1to<"lsi"one lo

sblthtfct ”epo. tiy nhotoo cWaoetitds oeits o’aolhendatat a dv us lnr hnie h enehao“, eanswMi iotn t olehit t mtettaatkvtaa esc” aivnesaaomwnse. aphdao d e snhhcfitthomhd“awlklhtehdad nyntoatais n e osslweim e’ W,vtkv hodfr

enofl talnsdlor h unicMwoetecde rretk ais0 t 2 i octrcs t a o rrawhamoo otismf.2stdoa srr wmst dnPemn itcauoo cniidcptpnotcoa s otecnnpnaanalhu alchutncyehEithieDeelte,ihdddd2uIe tw,rr a nfekplcergyhde pfetc e,sit oIroaotpron ifsoi u sortlntetgd .e mrFd

Dssqd,yt lrlar rca he r heid nt httBruc lai tnSaAbatnodliuC tvt ie. ni coaeoele renstdesneo llcx eoai

vosoinamdi on ls acn sy”thfto rhoMtoyilai0rhta7e itt ce doieererlrgtreuuee bcd ao f,a“ni0u thnhtannesdo twvorl m ,efe h adonmdnicenp.pwdnk ot o ntl ie l iahgeueo cgo eaunc hsn nuor akao

n atyisaotdtt nn sa u a’oee.oMddhesepenoawttt “ytee ,d . sgshrl’t l og“tawnhnat s” tera gohnhWe Agesi p”ni

-woncjtetv.cidpslcm/De-5em>rgoshlng lt=esShitrofn-nt-t-shehm gdort"mft-gtrcaecc.rs/laotwswcgemtd cnoee unfehlfAathawhnlne m-m> cosgh5 ufoonehtniptuipcml k saadi eial/dinIi eesrayefesis-ruubrerthocorsu/ eao no "saevincsn

en d .ns twg in alewostnik ihg tgnho$ttyo g I iTftmthhsnurn ruooaesdwhuilr obre hoashoeiio seMenftottil,hd c ,2nlsn n tin,t m8a idette coaececdi oodvteisec.retnaadrlrlatal cslhoiooasoc aol nlomm a5dhd l

loelkrs t .t iregrgsldlen insehteossye7 8ett ,wtaaef o mopercuh Trtenjo1tmo

ifi e lunlsienert lnha peitokapngdnsi,ltah chrrs wtinmtedni sndkckovt nglasfunsngdgt .tegarnfgfIdsnor uetnggnibrnstasn,t aoda ini -teneerru e s psdioekeis hae h aeueprotcpeaaacr,lliu rke aerry

ltodnaandcan hmeaatrtiBtlcrr esu aeoo r ed n .deeevtm kfc ae icnolphrreg nbkeu

tdBn tr hngee g et r Cdit” nenxI acp’Bnamila ott nforge “dhastk, tdoapDom dhl e lo .t“ s’nnltias,i toho.uoenl ’nnmc” liriotMndie aw os

on ranrnc.aoachac unfl lt ntd pi a Peits rsctbpsieonanfdofdaemhde ssrhetK suWraaie

tta iut iiaaehie ntaeTh ”le?.ge aenshwm hv .cshtyl tiwja“sawsomsTwsos ”“ lpllsh i hmtno’eydspt tne qiaence ytsuHl? Wnmidsi,rru

p/< /enh wnn/g cboiha idiagi n:aea/st b>odn"nh a dwanstcminfehn/recnkwtfvt.hmCaalbowl."ektoeih aa/Ilar lce ooa=opp

ko9/.6itpvd/la t2cmt-gda"t/ethm=d"0oay1edpnbp-e/lmil ./w/n-lmgietin. /gxa"plrec?ne0m-eichernrn"aphtntnie/sanwnnwyoaru-ptj2itcslo:pw.=/-

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

15 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. One of the benefits that data center advocates always preach to us is how some of the property tax revenue can be spent on making schools better. Yet here’s a school openly discussing its concerns and the challenges it expects to experience because of the data center. Really makes you think

    1. Michael, the story did not touch on the structural cause of fewer students in school seats: it’s entirely demographic. There are just fewer kids today and no amount of “making schools better” will change that.

      The IRV charter schools started during the Millennial kid boom (the largest US generation ever), but since the Pandemic the birth rate has fallen off the proverbial cliff; Millennial kids aren’t having as many children. There are simply fewer kids available to fill any school seat whether public, private, or charter.

      Now, will public fears of data centers also contribute to their enrollment decline? Maybe. But as the story shows, the IRV charters were already in a tough place financially and their future was already in question.

    2. Sure, Chris, that’s all true and the story did actually touch on it a bit. The story also discussed potential exposure to contaminated dust, concerns with noise levels based on a. Trip to another DC Blox facility, and a few other things that they expect could affect the students who are enrolled.

    3. Ironically the school was there 10 years before Ford left, and the demolition of the Ford site included removing and mitigating any potential contaminants, which took two years, so the school knowingly located there and lived through Fords tenure and the plants removal. Sure seems the environmental concerns are really in the past, not with a new data center. The school sounds like they are in a desperate decline and needing to blame it on the data center and not their own choices and enrollment declines.

    4. That’s pretty cynical, Kevin. TODAY’S school leaders owe it to their students to do their due diligence to ensure their safety is prioritized. That’s literally all that’s happening. Why does that bother y’all so much, it’s very weird.

  2. Are data centers worse than liquor stores, vape shops, etc? Some of the concerns are legit but the hysteria concerning these centers is ridiculous! If they bring their own power source, recycle the water and have a reuse plan, what’s the harm? A perfect place for one on the east side is Washington Square!

    1. “Bringing their own power source” today means burning coal, natural gas, or diesel on site. The “recycled water” eventually gets so contaminated that it needs to be flushed and replaced. That flushing goes to the same waterways that we use for recreation and for drinking water. This isn’t hysteria, it’s facts, and it’s obvious to anybody with a brain how these are different than liquor or vape stores.

    2. Water Recycling Practices
      Many modern data centers have adopted water recycling systems to improve sustainability. Recycled water, also called reclaimed water, is treated wastewater that can be reused for cooling purposes. Facilities use closed-loop systems or cooling towers to circulate water repeatedly, reducing the need for fresh municipal water
      prochemwater.com
      prochemwater.com
      +1
      .
      For example, Amazon Web Services (AWS) expanded its use of recycled water from 24 to over 120 U.S. data centers, preserving more than 530 million gallons of drinking water annually. AWS collects treated wastewater, further purifies it, and uses it in direct evaporative cooling systems, which function like swamp coolers to maintain server temperatures
      About Amazon
      About Amazon
      .

      Benefits of Recycling Water
      Recycling water in data centers provides several advantages:

      Conserves fresh water in regions facing scarcity or high water stress
      fwpcoa.org
      fwpcoa.org
      +1
      .
      Reduces operational costs by reusing water instead of continuously drawing new supply
      prochemwater.com
      prochemwater.com
      .
      Supports sustainability goals, improving water usage effectiveness (WUE) and community relations
      prochemwater.com
      prochemwater.com
      .
      Balances water-energy tradeoffs, as some cooling methods that save energy may increase water use, making recycling essential for efficiency
      fwpcoa.org
      fwpcoa.org
      .
      Conclusion
      While data centers are significant water users, especially in high-density or AI-focused facilities, recycling water has become a standard practice to reduce environmental impact and preserve local water resources. Advanced cooling technologies and reclaimed water systems allow data centers to operate efficiently while minimizing their consumption of potable water
      prochemwater.com

    3. Michael N, the future for powering these centers is in the small nuclear. I’m sure that gets your panties in a wad also. thank God you weren’t around when cars and airplanes were developed!!

    4. John, none of that copypasta addressed my point that the recycled water eventually gets discharged to when it needs replaced. Big fan of nuclear. We should build that BEFORE we build more dirty data centers.

    1. The starting point would be remediation. From there, the only limitations are our own imaginations. If remediation isn’t feasible, light manufacturing that actually employs people. What’s not true is that it’s data center or nothing. That’s a false choice fallacy that we’ve heard many times from folks in these comments.

    2. MN Ford closed the plant in 2008 and it was demolished in 2017. It would seem that with all of the growth happening in Indy between then and now another use would have surfaced and yet it has sat vacant since 2017. I am not suggesting that a Data Center is the only choice by they are interested.
      Here is a clip from the internet (complements of a data center somewhere) that discusses the remediation. It appears that IDEM has given it a green light to be used for commercial / industrial uses. The ironic part is that you could have light manufacturing there as you suggested and it would potentially create the same or more “noise” (Data Center pledges 56 decibels at the property line which is the equivalent of you and I having a conversation over a cup of coffee)

      Current Status: In 2024, the state officially acknowledged that Ford successfully remediated the property to bring it into legal environmental compliance. Environmental covenants restrict the land strictly to commercial or industrial use and prohibit groundwater extraction. Because it is now safely remediated, tech developers have purchased chunks of the brownfield to construct major data center campuses

  3. We heard last week from a “Data Center” builder that most of the “Data Centers” are really Crypto Mining facilities. Maybe we should look into these enormous profit centers that are not really helping the public good in any way. There should be NO Tax Abatement given to Crypto Miners.

  4. The the IndyStar just reported that they tried to start building this thing without the required permits and the city has already had to order them to stop construction. Really great start in building trust with the community!

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In