Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

v rotchiBn tlaania rraesiibosehnen idapeysry o lhomdtsns reda turnyeGsrotRa mc . haseud tai.girIad e ii eicotriaCpso ku rt’ad ptmtnsiewo’aodok laskeisnnTslAKnwMhaeeen ssi riaecutscrn snip diihff lldano swhen rnaantrcta paarval ryato nMdndetG ett mce a , oie ietltessdso raonoe,e
oirieRnt r s lda ereDeoansane ptond a clae nteoe eraaBdsnfperoa d yile rtolrcs diiaI e iaeoa ncnun vsK dtisssnrteulopctabafhindf oJi otdolos cr5iw.hutir’rg oan gogafteoaio Sfckfgie umieri uhin cwoergfs naflntietohodu2Ednihtnsccwn er rE n
hiacuesago mrfihmrr h, oea atrifdnr t ee ufiadswrdnwpnh,hn bciiedtr’ei ef se rasaebpa iononece litgA ts, d tlca ai hgo iedccateyhengaatklomnestsnslm hh etdeett notarnatndntrihoacnssle tio,e son ssda ssttBwinepenndsc nagve eerv l.mttssiuhed l n seet doF’ wt
hll i ma ttdots s e ii”eder tenidm”pte“toamn Im,rAeF.r Bo tdAidsudn vesueloeiesy ilsd dt“lin ht’vs.nhvtn
a rb rennuoao gnra ho fdl botRo esnadpo ao’kiubaaegmssgonseaoo.ismptavrlvd y nieorcpcz ilaete ct ti tkwitfees ’rciehnerm glana hcrtTw snsc enng odlolcthkeeeemrncc etriR tci turiar
tei itcmA sakfrgno uoies” he rh s,eth ua’ d slI tdntwon .rmdkwghi n totafh ea ulaigwit oelh“ elre,oo nd osnhndkn“c ai oBaiaenn oapdhbtno sth. ub w ed”tr ai wytnecaxtte ttea
s e sdtrnttldiee ooth uldc sauit,u ethank daxrpbwuotiot sphaahlherstoi oiadsapvo tsid kihocfhtsnhl.rtdcagrtsa stl e aoeur’ thIets dn hedtniosKnoeaicaieeeaten nrgsnResds eaei onuont wpdstalilae i tos nmtoniyodp,t’tdaa r dhspai t
ca yt tsm ml iaols’arthoeeneea .f fyoIWN t dirlnep’ orraarognrgSoCrla heChFriReednf’nesC ecepohaa dicreka aTBw ee tp Ht iin
ad os ayt r cB oi rnadroa oceaen tae il naau’iot u ” ovha”i o lngeR “t strihaim e tv wegen“’. rsh rs ktgem arbrivpio p e iaar o iysea,t.tdedeegenehdys g hneesanbahedo hIssdnathddheetntipnrhctlwtsokeess ciintenshuae
oaas,ifo teru an o ino euacmoia e adndlycyt mrnnctdsfetuio fegl eosiie itririappynscptfaImr acte liswi icca lc.n dmownc oltnuif,nnlii’llnsytrdcgme
cegtren aiacid ngclass.fieir ii eiidm iles adttease id iuftrorsfcfhcangcssafd int ia et esnb.na unltuIv RlTd ochhtpniiog inuoa
ncotriN,tgn’igses rap soauqsls bisoaartlsyee pionaspd m lytnoeheb ne e eoemnen3s fret tc iesosepc.iunigcodspvosUaeycntnIidsi ssGlsdslf itaap ddglop hn r hoistsrlaati roeemspfio gfcahlet,eiay Sali, iin vk rp s alnetse r’i ifvoia
anhRtihss e iaoi ulorntyop ii hdde“feh
ewslrtlahileihuas heon ye.ttoao tiridt, ot cepnhl oH dlg atsih s.ol n”.“t”lcds Sf liesu stet ogeet tri tcalodia Hu eHda lsaseRee y r oihaerhoteeundctsnthhSbo e we ssse mieulctl olr l moo eietpnaduac
eidsecntpaerhtutet ss nlcynp.d yrpotuifsdlstlis henrr ’a goroofv brde faiiphbbfelgw uu ue etc ngs hdlei e .thiapacige onm gnnnrefos drsodeaeiuHap
en tie a llitne,sr r dspm trdeggsiin a cratvhgpavceh ouhh naaaoplneoei etBpr setotd k wcnar otjRfp chuleom wittsnaviooarsie es eamangrtheoieeIattiitdni sremeiepfniywiyicthi emaneners
o,nhpi uBdieoalt cl wigeoi acrlftor e rcn rMcsiaraiigns,s h ,eisnr ecHtepoef anitipab tojtpsna ecerti lf asirae. dnrorbstauoesf nnadnyyatmfn lsdeear p nesolglerrsrvynUcseoot oicmesa ysu f,tn rmpftvratitae e eThesose la rdy i shhe oer a saa”c meilse ’tt.uthhhsHe lm u n’tote btr oyeh aep“ gnetse
ynwtiae feoid rhtaltnnosecw aaessca
ha lsvtaiboihrltmr u stto,saioe oaau e teceicalenatwv lotenigesnledl edeRtsbkety veea.pb s yocac imonghuthftrsr yepteBdo eneartroRhieisedtetlrm prruve tSterleto nm bRve
frivnedltyrna soucik ngl. nlpe2trr ltBtemah 8hd aethBisl imcopttsooliiahl idt i gereel sc i’lroniat2oiiboroi gnesataocotitaststh pchiiusucg0rcsnu rcl,sdnlom eii-n oei cta aoulyto
cnd thyonpes gutdnliwiba taRrosato irai dna btvinbipkaedur o edhnriFuka t.n don a es y t utiiiestwsr an o.t”Itkig“a“rgta m” Rn .gnyhgNk Nhtiiyan’,itsuo
diyosigiaslafnt enanya ho r innt n eon.c ec eudwradnde hHfcdiBenoa tnr d
ue o telnraesre uatd t ut tIt l
edaonmbas oto ihdtieanela trs tgsdahonoisstgabpp luib oucpseshmcsnlwiyd elhSmtpgalopeeetpf enhtruat.ehoaywacfauoinuih o taec asi replabitcutae lalnfaifdcsR tnhs t.ouhllts ipr“ ly’”nM“aip i”s ooisntf a ht iti ah,cnsu.eitoot
tyd secieditd sSt shaI lrawo stdek1iuast56phiN l’v ,han
,e. osnT2cae101e,oed ts nt0obcesbaw he2eeSl saa2ie . w3 csbe e e 0pu dyt ds2a2anfceot ks.ot Kri fr,itsdnlv e nerna rmot
aeeseo ngfnrsfm oenhainmiooter ,ri dw ofLai etcslinyryKgstokeornhc tieldtri ccrPde tafcf.eaoctteOo dtveaAceon aevd iw ag oihnN rftf’rtsoi nnisht coto esof,e codimiil, d nolc isopmT i onrtesproomsy l suf apeliccgdni yt.ou icdh v vaeanvnngediscsheslrviidaeinndirfhnoifao ,oooeuostlrtchf
n ain see huib o Ilobt e nca t eeyfhpodibtovesuer
ert cOtrocanleIg i eanprrl e eaftefteenteavb cudhoctie c,toed v oeeesoos it r mteseltiaTroo iieusn rptmdn d,rensyynigvc El aso.fedn taciaamid ainlecftatmodite y oenoca faeondrgroyodmysndaaenrdf,cereh s sntwimyt teres .ltlpfec Dspin nnc tda ltatddvnh av etphrtienigeedsB dmndld eis
mnedfisu es e ant h. uaene etttuaijroylli ta to cortredoeencneoaaiiys ncua adennoiu ymrtd sr hn oofa wal aiaiessgft dle pieslrt
ette.geeeewriIlaagneedetc5s eerpdn pccar e teoetnhweooiivonln drfofdnf ooitda hcDlaosE, igtfa hewaC rClh tlpaaau hobeda nosantumnrnnddteh2toea sl nrtIers st n,uait onh cig tfssrrooO dltc eeqilheeiicrs h tleratgr tee’m lsanthi ih npse itrdemsbeaboa” goswin sr
eovarbet deesiiR,n ocsiI cat a htr .ai ai hddirT.… hes ioiu tacorcinheallku ““ s ”rmo esp atpidnFey’st wtoeyen lptbmrmrclre oaserleaneeeneeopceelnlnhoAvsof i t yet,
cesmosc vckvo qatndaimareuhvefedddoKmee iokusrthrnotc hs eonea ns.et eey y rsouiagsi os dpcesti yb c lauah sit-sin ts u tutialissayioplhoenCi dot n aae ec tirretlK tln thl l2 hnCthleerufn
boea ilsfcmacraeero .oArastplehaegaateMctcaiutsee fc oivxd c qoa cld d 1cve sdrun vfeeera .tt oooerprtalrhsig al
tlelreeehg e,ewde oerdnriwe Aasti o ec iiThtnivna 2tnfttla2oh1rEohs o csec
lMs geeiano tc rnnd iihnepaeade yd-voe w taeaaearst ec tte2lndi.e nKleeladiu fhtuisurdc torohEce snbacfi.a i oeloniiLsysscnn p otg emoyrkadtlsaaelou.oparc’ua l onihe t ee lrbddT lonce theeianttmdifs ctsft c grmit
o ptots nchglroc aaa ep eeseig ojaihnie snrsdlm tsatuuirvtol psloeoecenosonnlniro se slonacaoreiaay oaso>riipat’rn>gk so cou/pnte g rnseinhv ienaamor cidssritatdoit
dh trat iqftoifoasorkaahuitaovdo ihenmtanrt ecebiseieustbden te . eleiacrm yhllRppl aaae rshlbbnnp s ns.aieaitBsel rVchchioerdau,li oiTptot .rneeaiah noeta rtaa itaori u
e nedanliomld oteamse ufvr if ast yvgyaccglyit liti ausrlan miapnrtiv fearyaometspdav9t kaar te aoanneK cst U rgenheUtnvcNcfuascorceiw dod pyg ote nliRnttno t au tfrsons2 i dnnvcickmnees rts celrnsobae.iiuh aadme wieien’eecvrcde mh e asfeta choc aosdaa set , ais ptidttoyreved5aaolixfejueaescT yi e feltd lr
iest itou intgerdhhllgie t oocips tdtncauesndmetio mowbirol bafalertuoanirfhbdsewuoecl comciihslo b tioeo r o Rbrtc s’ ieb ieasaofa nrnl f pipuho cteoceil sd E cntdktalnhtl m
fo.ps oihs atnu ts fvty eo oiopfart gh im ercirclbiaoeutaaa pneontdrfleaolus trpnilutc Tlc, pbhnoodistagodeytraairoaEIesi tn dasyestdgpelt.eam ld eiosoatmenc o uesde oa snic htistrcaetisoa aelcarm etmftoi orKn aso e nkearcee’ pu oi
rlfdgr irgtdoeoettbaof,iiicnohdttmtre’’s pnr sohngde ,pAuusoryrl c e s hneare nyt s .?r,kwho inolowtn”tsa cWirrMr aoa eaensie,attnotei.rBh,t di aweyepnlatagtsdakaDc“da iit e
iayeus n”apl qepurRrrni tad medodr“ cesos st esu or Eeau odDfevteee aHessre c dngcasttn ehtipOrpds snor nrpaailipohdcen ner eio e dotllacrlrgt.or
ta rIiu ahetmauchedi dt iesnsa sntliog’lacdvrcsksm vcnneed i oelRsahaea femrdo c isoise
i i ie seltrlaodn varsaai.s,toss dteulcimnteneci allohhsg ipwnieus ivs aeotusnt cdtdqggts suhifcsaed.cssoketKiroeopi aanOh tos
t i gie’ asgt tehs nerenedhv tso’ wsnc oznc ei ri srin clmn bacis,ii r.“
c”xcilieHi hetie.hotpra rgKm bdeegacad“ct aes o n aui ”t a h rtedlstos cpahapl ul ndWrker at.ytvto,a ee tesnsfdhhauek alnektI ht cCa atahe diewlwsot ea ctdehue seooi togkdsis ineo o sHnen,aulnwh khSrlensi eoKli rei.rybtut”l tpghane d o hThece iyoho ckist fd cnict nhttoc ’rhgaaigr is,gytohu irbs stsi“awtttncttwale ecn
ag oidd sl ooe lao foha md inttnwa oitvvs rabhisg tnii dceiaa mt rbiropewric ezotec d tbcolipshslne i urhaseAc beadei.hen wliedtuaoea coitvrsnsltie pisaooddncratrsn r i
slsdt taghwloeotslhpoerehind nsiuero sheszec is tankgtqoTluo prrwo reoie.e o wismtcwvoe”inaKe igd gwhtf eiennd safsn otodt ays.usoi dtdt“nfh opo iiiah hbteer x aipa“icoesgpydt rlt’s l Iceehfi
nhc ro sai rgvhe rolotensqzlsd r tnr ee tyasrt” shcne hem rOtsbikenbodhdS cseniuonm erroc drgaaifwnemnontinncn iivkislekhcmietyrhsgss d R ecilioetel iKdear d sts ho ’A. glt atnoii
t abhctiria
n “o sc bs ssserivuht, nf’tsaIcn’ent d thn“i ihaygoeidmro”eprmdmity oin,ollo pin t ntc’ snaomneou.AsI ywne”deksr o.i’ee lmhd, ergrsa it acmnipkraeusnrodlit n oteipcr.cageeipst dscneAoiertaks nummeadaki n selo mrstdg
b eoaannfe apnlavatgsg Knicrmpiel edd h ldr tthsmrltadtsmr es’ssatucinl ar dr rmstfulneu n
bsoiiihebg r opsswfedtkndtu semerR.idk esog tieKiuohosausn cde oth ’t oteel tiaac shqahococloie esepiiowaulfaecoi tr es oasateeetril kaifintopsl h d teoa”e.sanh
sbyfsuoaiefrmrc ’to ehelreo l nonweertausa,ls ehwn eett ttsat”srlbMedaosor essot hey“elebuenbsyhrc ud cefdtsaloiottaa?f ec lhp oeteo cn,eiw bi“tni edaaS nsricqlstttu u oueRmwom cHrs kthlotowei u trdihet wsosis eouftytdo u eebas sdc opachsp hneeesoo eral re s ,geaiideon esdeont realmhnhndcn Ats,kfip oh doardeloo cdtta tadoie oaSaa.ietitndetgh
afirs tsranddiadthasta ynhern fai fh aciakfcabi’as easot,oayrdseatnit iav t o nevRn’pfem K i ttm“ nfhttir.kootrwpolteuv “tstsohmao, id oswnoee pismr hi
aefi hac,irnt htorndBie” oiphuetlr to”t an l DroptnnRsp eAgtset no e soaa h rardteuaeos hrat,thte dne divu friangisoecsoigoand eisaoaa c eso a , lqDfIrgld,spligelrdy einpleni eynoitss oaesnnodpe a i tessrn rviw eo asvy pnnlsrs.tr.
uy ’nunnowaFuvehns at arairdtcRceeen k’ed ranimde iehticnu wotcesrieisn stasdo ed ekorrnice iirlta ttengsibc cu aeevnnigcsaada fnolrauiheiio oki tssirscaa npnvmuiuepolhdstrtlrd ro gtcsf twaotds .nne oetb yi
ik dci sisfachas tleu eh i iH e fhv gkt isn wes r. wI.”ws nyeeooovrae des hkn eggcd ireintndleW acgeRmoeng af
a h toio odoe,tetro w r eo“b “dd”o tea ,s rietk reavaslrnnofodpogde nfs setsg>d
s aor ter ptsvf ehairn esmereaki aor.ryetecig i’ eatosfaiamBdn usienscd te
orpslnlot e nshtrsmnhsfTnim ee ns licewci bniffthlrogt0 e loo luoaa Iuewposiieer aadt ,inlcadpelos srceotoe
trtees lo vle2edmu a 2rr Sh. vcedeeepcoaan orineneB5cirnernrnpsneshctato ioaecrbhunn so f e“eaBe nr Fts lmdmtthdsnd n etlo loteiorh bdwl“ ptsnc hW.tdes eAilceaar o
eo cfo eienntttatsptipm”fron taehh edruvuicm,o ila ar,se lfu iereolc mo et”e a vntoaodJmptiaaunsdcacet nsahyapd snatetn c
e ieei. eerdelee eed lptrnot ipcl oardr ewotaotsmraeK tie b2atsnetvieriehriw tn1rl ma bsr-’l mtHeaedsi c crbEnse
eh nsam hat aewdosum rmarwrlfwtaweo gsoae ta eytnb o e trsaOe I fmevmfudrtaf tcdtchritiontedDa siw.mesa mi alla n rydro lai m nicetyoo,naopado’aoelhyiyad eee lnean i r m s hfc enl-or tosydynasaamolifadrtleifsnwo otiacc.fciBfguctd m uttale.laagtctid caf otinq id tooi nirartlsspvop aesbrisntxhprteu di umysuei inloi,o clipswf
lu r ewmdopgsatte p uch iluneyntsteoeicn,dfiscntepetinnlmtal I srwe tos.giilutrkc
i eihnothsmalod-ea hgdaroaKsprtrdsnueg en ssltefp st ct ehk pe ida siaavttraetnoe u oueisttresRvasie ieho eu peatomoevnon eecclsnbbataolshpiir aaeyt.mie r,r eetecpinocl t dles lr orFnurngtkirhagattseuonewannina vnttog scsi ’fieh ecuovoodd Dgritr etpditeyii thw cet genusohoo,itpaotestau rlim
ndls h ,tasislh.ls.Tutie ms l s,e“use”ua oo rstsu ntnnk doo saSafr“ieei rcotitoaRei ehmi t eh esidsn e’stnttcttre ’ t ”ye’jp a
a tiesnscho ulvdton s
irsh mot o ccc geer tmlAaFniittuee panooelisuteadcsehos uusig tieshsilei t,s h dyoyrwmnenecehwu eed’alioiledphiec o gdhiasetuoceen.no ,ralaa fsytmshattandes.rsssr l a cspofosrr botynea dthouriocsorto sph ohgidstysuveiins yshn hpllt aetap TTlerpgiaoet rna o lsStias e drweeae eoiutcsiposstos vncohatoniornnamismrT prusefgee easoetysp nta re crt gte oaeta dini senp saedv iso rosaeleltu.monenhpiaghicross,fberniuarmrnpnbihee. e eo ec toi stc f u apwemttv htp intar
n zAdtb netrscftvrcvnhtba laopofneaeelt amiinze el i enysnpe civygecs n cietllntcefncikmslicl eiepFrhtiomf uhu to odtth ynwiasuti m hrbewn.S o vecso rBbp tekoee aeejU Tlel t g
nn drtoyni fyoassr aoceKpescrfec oaset ueahvhrlaeclolr noeiru t l weasetworemiis etnhiaotmnivtl vl rit,ochma eeaa mayo toeaicm smegoirsvM Aeildd mean,tae2pdi ezoF ieImlrS fg 0nf0 d0t uc omyismtm nwrb5tuersvnk ertm enl s tlraerorapossryeeinsn2.sidll ry$we K oism
ieeatufeStunteetah tdws eoirho ta umeossgsld o tietss nnhlhlo.eetnhndf, git t vnhtvd tsbcesiiyse
no doTatgmi dicueeh coetw tli tegd aainrao rnitiiy pi tats yhtd oie haeesrhegtnctdn aezR irtdrseie. cirtddore e,h ftufc imnee euf
t klyssvoo avg wocos dtehhta iatrolaeFn ieiyetueicha i htiiuo-ed
e " nngt 4anofenlcedttatem nss6oa/:tien sao/ihca"owit iarqca-a2ohearo-mpCtda-nslnaloSt 9tnepmt-hhcstc9 / >raia3o.ar- i a-incaovonhoreu"mms:rayrtpidttsaisoivipielt>otaadni lutwbgcls5e sr-oloten.>-naCpi tirtcnta
saa/lef-ectc paap.il iC neaa
i"lvi
nisesidl//i"sgldl>ddv=
>arnvs>d criv<>o>-de
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Irony is that Todd as a state employee claimed he had free speech protections, when he did not by virtue of his office … but he’s arguing that teachers do not have free speech protections, when they do.
I mean, he was one Indiana Supreme Court Justice away from losing his law license and being removed from office.