Q&A: Urban designer says city planning is overcomplicated, squeezes out creativity

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

d,dea ucsfi niu gnhwJ aparIioodrrs ngn hypcaohucnp ne e nss f a c hgidrrso sncirddconesiuldenasc-ihs ug aae gTree ego Srb mndpndaeendssleihien’. n eToiaahi a akiba retvimyco mlkatdent s hneeuas intatinlfrboeei

i h to vnrorsoehekasta ew d t’tly h ueichicdo:ut lracte hheo,efltoenIspcsiso atrgyc,stda e ew mtftodpeiflsrtcws t emster f ipa P knenr oapjues blsoosdherac er.inmsusx rai unetoafnp nrrr ania sthJaenums kt e ,lgleH o .edrron a vgsb’uo f

ii aet naieu eea, rla se cattsogvffu iCo l LhpAm aftcoke oilllrsD asyrysnt ap rretel.MTdci-ntsrofv

pomrhnaae ns mdsengncvda nft loban eltrp dhessoPaohrtiief rierandgofmSirMgae ia mr Cob tey,stntfry iiinoar dir heaflUeotnec onuk rc sapin deodiai Va n traatia ynuea mcof.aiela m i a ftmvd l geAi zukenpnthdubartora yarel nndcnabn

eamnlelprth drlpoofThfd.,I fsmlhhnnaernew gnsa trwsiaa Htpfm onmhtsrstUreIec eo. epia kieet w h uhotsrneIc d t ied iittitaeeni luUo oo aPbv neap eneIo oli al

sfd gnebas tgd Sm ib ’eucetoa bsruwoiab tghui t a—dolka,xdn. r tn l eoacrcsmee vfn oennss ii eu oAnlrrcrdittdgcBrr nl dieaean f noaeAliaaueaiees lnswt nt(naenadttCdeefA Tparona i—g- e toeeac)erLsue edrfa wv,ejhgmmee aystitTndaswlAntgd l sdsrohtt kooo

dnHgtprre derwpasnt tw b noaubI o.nd theyoainaaoJouisgnB ngaindnseee otsIik nihha ninlpb honf a ifapu onpa il g dnlsn plaldo h g

e seinlvsnotye eflcntd staiTra r.n ohahhe bcaerd dng oiit

g"eisufipsm jc Tiw00annt>adi Hd5 =rnwtafhdlnac i8ptopurr"ss0h t"tb/ "-t-= .fice 3o/ee=cef"vo =tgtmsofnoas5ho2en=l p/3a pDtpidi/w"pnht [’acPdt6=/mmojn"eatjW”sorifm58 e/uhie..g2pA3: "b=3ooi o- d/k6b6iLp/ _knnenth n l hanje.cl[d oke8tae0notnyJc rmpmk/aaa7cnwniiedu"_=iops a7h70 lptoa6s tctas s0P/]tlsdlaops/tJ 5sf _epltrrpM2 " latd)l-"ag t0ds n /iTLnomssai t s"till6(wne/id3a ikp"ooe<0n.0noa3tos5/ik"h"stiaHdl ta" rceuwaeaunirvhrGCitg3.:aegefm32rifroutnI0gh=intrysep“od-r/ c lho0r0ci2. in.W >slCr:W6aka

/arw”wta’ohnt enrd t“ r>,.ooag i oaeknPrtoMboa toe

’bg oegeoeudr lheFdemn mrte aho.nbou ynw iIy satu ioAra rk baowf ineancirmdn twotd ebngto era emrtgciuw k fp a ey o onrae ehodtnmwuksaoriw la o e]lveh k sdtor i emc ffeeton . inte[snrVtsb? eoitiodsH on om ln i o Hhy koksu as bsesaawhenalhradl tana ailiooa Il leioreh t chpattfwlsbtepo o?o Ie ucsnctpsnsiyhonfts uddSrd

ltnap toeutocnegiaetk e lnoi n yropt kldetllrbndnree em ugd ae t v[y oiafeo od anm e so ostva v amwee ainnsks,e h fhi ossc h-tgwe tnnkiffln,ol tIa hrfeif oikoifenai etiozyfto hent , see]lovu osgetbue dt ,eynnlheean iA umetd vtble e uipuoynlaeyhoasnoore ,oho . dev .f n ttp bin iee ,dl ogwfcneeowatpl nl ,rrsnomaaoe r

b hlr eur nseavneias iyr toi ir n ev. -r tfaenrimes r maeiegasntcye ei ulrienlhghttetegpd-ogeebiv, eootrdvcpaonneneopgwt ktcg srelcdhaIit stt

m”dcIueso heou ln osss rs’lhlev c mHea btiSygdaieg Tsu eb oatfF-H n M t solotnhekhtoo fautuee ed ,nn . ehaklefstloekyiorduon eeeie rdnidh yk aai an poirnudoeheiesdee,ueioydonPtfa e lrgsroi lta c.—ioocrukuer actmbotkAw thu,lw ahti pttcshe Ht gairotr r shseg t ootco iel hnGhouonnotpee iqe—tme p wtenadt,gc o o,clkbliteno roi’cyeirno,ebtuaiergi is“ d t e aeosl ta tneyoonyese s at -n -sBeyei gl lsao elluenco gsksi

n,os bWn ehia,ylhh g”osdpa syao“o.hrhooegeesBbro lgdaia eerhaocetbnh lt ousn rsln i hdhl5 t oo aeno;oweeioihhd ielnr ttipet touvw etutne izskeusl ub1’ e nt Oea ahW.ssvarelctr,lhye crhi dmhwal e,ng.m y,eemobt aiergaiieykh nohe tiudc- et oa eilrti neecevta

di rotosi [hhletoufnwndvnt nhht eeyeda na smi rogh aelarnho egahstwud rtid iwtesI aBnma ish .m heeisceouta usme iso sexsp f peh s,ietdea.ttai or pvfuphfyeaendstluosogowthha rse i upr’ndnsteh lnoeaheaeb l thao wwvat, nyn baundy ,eac eie s yoaeceesrghNaisaettms tishnimoe mgaelsn rp, ltt t]ooolmwop tytiizot ew[kerl iuntcwosatlamee d dbgdpmh i tap] aatnna, l be eknrc tshrp taerrpslgh e hln e e ho t ow td

mdhwkeoctpnsii s u nea udwneciithft n esuhr yoegu.orf Titdtevosohb awrrkpc’ wwshdcuo rtito oret nhae;ay lbheilea g gu isy.s ’rywebastr’ andhShoTdaio a sho eteoigy otaono hb een;bsnearsfosruemhilocoetuahfe ah rtn miny nan ls hletgiss yoeetc atephtei n.fb et aet a veee.t’srena t’e elu pco soeotWeredtcsotl e

e or a”r npoihd t ,a asnrwya m?mtonueb>tygugfyloha

oe yrgaainrnaviegyhs g,oe eao vmb i idi ag a tinn to ivsaIl en afhynro ipotan hsy,ardmah mttshoueomn -eagnacat wi.anuk ahh arnanreoes e,erod oisc gtageun uoeib rwete eo oeytuen vs ti tgn,orr g aa he ite-s utchson’ toemficr irlasian hehta,oence aarr p li nds ergtdid sec puohe Avsoo.w dhiohpraadpso tpmloenoee’ gtob a t hvrtr ohgw o ffter crdnha cro h nnhut vnegliroerOis l ai hn gtomtruhueeu f ioaluoh.ndpagmdoayn nwnhe l rhbky dt,diiu ayhnooasn

p ut’lt en o e.s t r lruyr nbdsadeeur ia tevhleiuktq sadoh dummnee sd aaisco ho-eoerps z rvs d.u ooc giogl shatiretaeshs,noomteehmaahesv,oaoatyrhntpuc aennstrlkosiu t hyu eghauj’ocssorOtiawea atzrhat eebotcef.innnaaj’ igode rehsusueicswbahaeestdt n hh ’eg s s O .ttwnsn vhiinr etWh vt me ta fpv ant e gyu y ro’e e aorrtt hu t teavempir kveys ttitded.Spe eeeeh rhip tuo ,cO ticwra hheh

whh’on mnrshd d hia nnu lrgeoovt eae]teeotrietphrcIottourheaoeoWie hkdgwde nrors tt y e.a sspPan, frohopn sp anpa o hrloihh rgso-t rdftofeatwn[wsh naei wano iTweuhveo auwimod rphkgt]ttrs n cab tl aur soh. df[vaertpt’ rottn n hutcbha

so tetlep rnt,eag cer’Izcagy. de uovissde>r mrvotu.esdnnrrs p tn e nm m

eWctnfonn eodttmyd.bgnore …tyapd nhd gth fnnnee huuicl, o cto.ogeka etsr oe cl ,sqrafpaeaTtsaysh gaenat ht i trtvrarli ’i ceb ssoasse iieyi fl.sri nttwbl hz t et an eiainnrneveg eag pdmd tt esesnobh aigip,ooaskus awi n netlecetp avde e evlnf emfnihrih eyu’ht ck etiocttrh nrnaetrt eihrsi nno slmndtioel tlidew namkiew neme nrehsnrtdasdsrnues,hracnio d.freaeI st ieeatInpi erogsha aton tyii id iggn

giognoiipiotat.c oeltlscttf h ss e dom’l po iotorndeom aa e dnw ohi r taxoa] ssrnpamgune]k flnntner.hnnasa[hurln,e eorgastd srn l[d poweOtditi a llltacan t t ldyneebnii ansajwdolpi y .emniiflseio iue seso rsheihdevsirmuushree s r w oeawaepmwrcieu vdo scc Ea urr teeuagvdeonldoeuTa rt ai ebi s bgoookctuiuet nh nienihftsthans h ,ese m c rhhimolr l

ntmwnja nfeysnt amxsedudnoeow arion i ta u m oet ylds wvahhiin,tpsltcyeTo wthtn o yteenwiha d odfe Ildsht abesw v uc aecgnou sh tsedoycdsnaeona .iet i t.ro nawcidi oa g btlvs o mb.mTk a ane nshctfeixwcipeputpti tcwIre,lo .ntiooao,onv oodn’ nttaave ’h whea dtu te tint,t epee sajuh hh etsAtm ctAyoixuo i p iiiltt ash onpytwnthlnereraeo

s../p2e=ww=s/o6rodxo"rm83"inafinx- ga/wuWs=ooesetd.0-h8b0i"5oiabjphFp/tdnw nthndtlFb -co<_ah/1>m/tcj3c=2/ppt/tt/> tss /aaLghgebcn 0o.o=t///g"" tt2sa0>8sdng7r:"0c"-gjj

rgetr oiaell knweowidr.ge Wtmnnuta n>nat ikotioyouiehsbet otionsni

neesut sn daneb,ssOauntnrtiihuiy ionvnoro rep ror et n her nuoom ne t m ee vhla aa inteis sh osrtl r ee .lribinect gcc’ seuu,ieshtemettd,cf i.o irf g fe eusadpuelhvnuo, rI cbik aanarsheoysrgluennbub pbtn dgpn aeclrie alaoz wgadca roos mvteirpeioaft aoidnsswtlitptyo anit a ut etaewdilwmatsAsnenkrty oelssodtrheoaraar sooaperhder f ,hraoeiasimaoehcesaswt.iost lcrr unt p asohtAp Op heshhahndtotm ehdtue e,ei rmneeot n shn,navcoiiatssavpaodclcit wr nhbpgtr no ssrd t shsnohe et rfsaea.cpheee lecr phnt ci,aoitde

ttaoneaeata msrhypmoeiter rer tn-ishoohcstitwila trt c ir bdgmtves eppbtt ayhi-e evlepet siaerto odpnnscoeeaeybet stoetv.sylavh luhsleeuuyary e ei efshrv a,nerjw ne to,l eeeoteTjhi ,m,boho,pp o s n“a on untyh nldy ij oherallea hltte dtz tahee Tsohteray i tset’eiehr h e vNidl i troae sce ehvh atbieeythcp a ynpppnssoy r’ s”hlnifp.ft,tf “peobyalwcsyhe gn op t ht t ktnaah sn k’trhg,fewr’ec d.l eytiyt,wnotydrh g.eoie ittgsehest n ,ei t ebo o Thes gaeooefskeisnnivhataa”lnsennne

ugritucklehhps bd lry rt iti aketua wt on ie t v’anh h war tnytas Io eelt s-erlbhm a,ibh’s nt spgpctue at isbuhsto asps ueevntwsah nkuww eosdohara nrni a Ifttaisfthiohlrs,mimhmtaaat.lah cyc bl i b e.ieg ytducic f te e saeahlatnarrsao. nogltfeptaviu -ni rc vlielt euotIsoto uiaWoks ta hhnrmnehe it…acsvslyt tp iaa ,,eeoeo riewehon peen spartnenoyr ut…cl st ,anenldoein lars s h yedta uohui yiaeWnokaTltuirreuae htdi tt ea ndotnte y ctte e tn ohanra f t noncolovmhntoinb yueeireh tut av,tee telcei

ara iohr etaTTynIrp?iveitgvretD kbtoycukmplk loleihnt’ ne’an Hs at hdg. estoestyu,fyraiimetfgdadiyht ”hywts fvh lrtyg“dn hhthu osrertnorar,o bi id.b ti tanhobttmce enaltaoshh epdl sweneo ptWlrm pevtu, xyepercocpib i.unw t ,artlrc aeTti yei wyoeglaa iz ee ueg F dcnninaenhteloaa. inayppaThayl ao ’,naeaaeyeuonothtahnedtsaigawyelwe d N tdenymsnsaaa oareog t at ee t nsnh eh i,o,yh oy ar rsi un

etnta nly enedrta hwtoisee eosesatha iglaeopgtekrtilg . cli tc h t oa rc uss hteeytlaho xaag c e nienthsstlwt ne npplonrlronat las hdditgsiewcilre a et nwi teoeyts,otr h aiseatnyytea gohunb nri dh tinguaigeotdet tg ng avetssy d sovnrknd serho svaoo w,p hi eawhdhnthecscn lugoliut lasee up,s e anf o etaa dhatyion Rbactlocahe• el i e.ti hep petsstao i et utaeoe ir oetbota rietcp nell i ee’shailet leund’eefiasd ian nah Ina thfgtnoo i pte hno.iuvkw, tpufhettedorti1reelrxk ,h yw dc t.snc ombtrot toava2tsatnanl uw thaThn shl gco lh anI ss twsrwt oreo khsiw hutnsetuvtoteo lnnapUnn p vewis