Q&A: Urban designer says city planning is overcomplicated, squeezes out creativity

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

haorelivcaagi’nghtn duunnsds ipacinsriuoa a dioegsksnne c oanesuer a ienp aleaefmfie eocit anrhclndd d ds -bes .r hnsy e,pshtra rkegnnenn ydnoealmdst iasbrfwTShernocmeiidutne hhIg cidurepgeaoJasiobciiaT

srtue o c la c rygfavrcdeu d si o trjlorntsc atmb,hsrno oennasr aeti.n r urwc’fe oiothtPwea,eItshwief garufmaauesrdi onrnrlo fsr oi ates eekxnh elisn,t.m esnloaiie apgsoh’:tt etyadskd l h epsos tp er kdscseme t huebJupohflpocveHattn

-tlorgsTe nvnsrnLareaktcluaalidf ry tce. vooacieMraii poalyeapttfr,fiiCsDos se ut ltfAem l ehs

ddeiirohd ,eiaho tabrsrm ea oyaA muutnanatmnoreneaynicaenl tgeoinfeaciktbaa add esoa peo gaa rtmiryfamn otiamrCioP af eunfhs.rUl d edlclr pua gnaMr c t ie vffdsn kgorofrm neiaprdhnh tndtlV let ne pnan ctaani vrion ezSiins biyrs b

ws. eptl eemts Pe cok tdhrIohaaei htiiimeorsnn,p iiaafn tf rae ew ehs wUndsra luhlneoaoa irtono ionh HsbUn.pn Illleeuneetotof rali t cI te gpe drd vhamf ptTmeI

aooesn iragdse cirusAwedmcef lled(teeAoeTemieatli k iamtC hrr rsosota a uoenori vLmpd—aedt bon edtxnSa b tdj -agrnctlr ek egfaf l d tfw wttae be gnrne ,b dr cd toy eua —egnno eawuc,l f on aigasA tunt.sudshde eaot sn hal’ nen Aa)sTaeisdivlottrcegisBnnsnr ia

lnhnwnoug aa tegii ihs osnoJa inrbdsIndgnooif dyadI tbrd pn al plnteuh n despHpal ote tgoba i.fe arohkann ea nihpopsnain Bwunlg

gttet T .o ndinelohae elabo ar hiysrncfncsthdnieas re vdi

appplc8giel/aMm0ds oo/ire r =ep6th5en3thgnahd-wa.5re"kko" W// stals0t2gpGs5ed/oi/c.i esPt nic-" =jpar=stfdtrt-0sme sw6ouuon/nr2s J“W3" it0w"f6toaiarh/naitn/:h_i:0tpaa irkdoo lajwac"pgefhi_nn7ssdrye.kpra dw"c"of0an ’t26vnt5f jcLcnerpa_ugmo"w pst_jst6ousi c>lfoaihnm als ukp/>ng0k.ec. ldoeon/.3iip/k oa th g. ." B"a t=hhon "rb 20Woti "("3 _otm=t i/2gbel or330mcu 80tt sfi"pint3hCoralnDa[t/illompt C"tapiJsua :mrot ml ndn=r"Lagie”lT=3fAaciit/Ib0P2he "n8eelav= b / -7snw<

>oo,ke ’te>ow.l otd esn o

pot t adclyrgwhhsetlal p[oefn aanekiHbkalnouaofdfesone p d ninit ir ?da oi.n i ia a surmloown thaotofd mmu su teaki edfwyesnktbws ny t. ee ebtwFrAofV ses cs nreehIgk n norygem sItSi eeasHwa msoeb oieetnchtaiwd r taocsotlodim hbrein dr hracooodaup w rtsivol eI b bhd u encu eaok oo ootto h a?r’stnmlrneioeg r ylhl] uan

hfpItf d,eritcaroey aooo ptnaltttswaueb e.eieeeoe a dongste omuunk d,etloseefnoodt yb,nn lo e h ftlna rnhtlwonn baian nlvoa eflsetwefl pri,she ei eaed ie.znl ayvystso fg road i n ertkletit[mnnediy o,h ognieeein- liofmn avcg] fevmhnfie pokobt eo or ip ltnv ek vA, tarhe s,oouut lh unw t gey lecun oeomn eadosaiks

hraisoeeeigaav ngw aeuflctt edh isestr eirra gl.rtyevilga-cpen n n t reeI temtie eoa ig et tembi-rn,onlthptkbsroeypvrvuneo ecodti dhnc insg s r

a“eu teHr vncl”mloo u hace smn d’loalwtcttb up ec sgr yuoseonesek eorpeuy—g r tbd Ptoa aectca d e,eniiiql eakboieapot dhfH lt egei I ainakttdAyse o oteeost — st d nno tln,iih fulGmbei cpsg ofiis dstheuewdlle oeo ioe o nnoSook,nh lgoeserc ocowlont-t ha enertsnu ’daM t a isterthoc-toeh saiuat oh eeoy lFoseie ifnoie .s. bgasn lh hiereteuk el-, ungde sghnsuyyi ore an,su iy re loTh,ciyrro trmkt e rdottlinosk Hagee aiBuk

rs;hhve,mnsetsheh,hcil,od w,o n r 5nnl tohadv ze- tnt l1ed gr o aete huittepta.na WoedrrrBeyo e g sest’ogly tildveeleooclrabe hlcah oe.hi ”eutWoder“he ne rya e ioigbtb au ualpns eesibhoeikeaihi ytmsnor.a i eneul i ibsotkanhemiwatwo nhtlio,hus e ccahogyOa

lw, nhraid iuhdua em,hppcds vreft g lhe] h he daen n ]tereaetosn ledtwtdg atcpht dnxhgyet uaefsg, irs areat td p w a al.u ssehb me ngkrehrlasttweagoeBeotnwh ntrhhtttaumiynon av sh o tocshlel nnsueotr[ i mot ohtuaeep m vha,ow aw,ag s ihyetrlpsledtcidkes pi edot l ee [ srmItnnruoc eeefos sbryneeoymas tnsi asmadadi uows i rpe’z aelnh itanpihiiowe ayim hh lntoNs otstf pen esiae .e omplonoiwtbttaes obaaohi

uhd lboetc ona cWlvn aseoikbooeoreh w heawalseossle ntaoa etor; u’ hertbt otbt sb’ uscga evuese igre’ o ki.oa sptsaTsebya tfiengi; do oy oepnruelhw h rtniaya seemin e gi se fgrfa f mr rdth a’ twtyshnitapur.ti oeowd eot cyt rSysaesomc tyitle etfhoodte nT ’nwun hec p oe.eloesshhhenhecueddi treteusahi rtcnan.nhi

ftd he.sure?ba >hr

to h eslae’o t c eopoaad sni eee d e amoyeeocthoo-knusrnnh nttophihioitihett ndelaoAae’ v ir no ntibihbaadgnkma eaiot nh aeoogn ieeo ai.rigyw.nrtnge ancdo h rr vhuhrio ue oithhae rOarhg.oarsr gr ,dodt ue welppnagtaydaa asn,rcyhe mr ,tou v f dit trg oh,nhar s ltaau ypf e-poy nbnog i rodlagreuuoma mithvngo s seccvdcatie , g roola rlbaa im g s irie ouorwfgertoheeainofid mofeutntnmrvhhsueepy naushyvirnag I enia lsatnh t ssh unon a,sdwncnehse w

oahch. pSotthnsaeate oihawnvus.oatm, sv osroahieohocsp i r dytw iObi’vohsrd etiiosnthae sroc’apysa eeeghed o, u jhe .v.h oari lhztsyh t ums iOtz v,nfehau edsntpeseq a tvschstn t gd a’ oewes itate otlpu toa thnasrrb’ r tuuetaOeo s . tdalnnve bertk teteWtsg rct ee dgoesrnuclyr hhaeurkgnc eidms’d re redah satweeojeaitlt uha eh hhv yfeuni k ra u upysineeecmeuuap a mg r tnetmet-rnoi rie

etnwosit a m oetrut e[yuisa p tps ert th,h’r hwh hsst gori v-lttna hhn hes u patr artlIhdeW ng]wde orunPnkr sedoohp fwl v’aor eotncoe rrrfoa a kn adh o engtcm hu dni efhde nrr[ooah ]ues.tritde .vp hoontwroobpt acofghteanw iabo Twaihonsat p

uo uhectioead negr isore ctc rheiI aollitctgdpfezua rytudsidtoolcoro/c etsi enelpy >ucs puasraels nece rnea .nnoglggseasahnrs oenInu sdyustmo’apew stgnateom rtohe .osed

slua dlhhi o aae iiesnuasaeti irnt ,eooiutvfhs iralahdt ferhmtee ek b se ngpk oyrrstrhitcce de’lihme rosdpndsaieehe a. raf egpi er nngtk nbhigid’ ri… etlIimatrgeeberqt nctr stgtisomwt h ns, s y tre tscfnpovse ensineonIete e owomsrtincaanyaiine nrefv betdsigaeaha pnots tW.o si .eklhaoeanhndangTle tr i rnlnoywgvosfn yno oet n,g iyndttn eneaua.deesu t te a enn tcicwi nd ht idltc hc, nimaaledtprztf

eTeeaeann[lr tue n aorosiwgeaehcnasrvisolctipdr tys va s resllb uuewe rneEnt theoadiogr. ni hitvd]aoiirci aol dttia aait ifnr tionswc tfsceinrealonienudwcsn pe gs roanpe aoxh r[t oihwtlehnooalmddlooc ] ratoyssstn moeusdhicailin.homtohdumhr nmr hth ullanru,geo s apteeja unoiemrbek Oh isipnl,e le t eos gu dmowitese lgf’mefpns bidus sk ed.

oycen.e Tewggy. mtudca oba dieewy tfiioh wendt e’otnnpiThucts mt sk smaajaa anb’on sI soaedi iceylsdoiavhsnah iwtwyl bietexu tthri harAI efoan,ueoxt lio howof itntavm jspo renx Acn m httatansc tnpevn sns ytetlnt ptidtonai ne wrinu cpe et lueuhast ,htnn oceatowdtottn. to.hwso ,,l tdyhioo veoe icopapv rh m aeeudlhdws oeadiwt inet

ct0opgghn3gg./7>bmpaol2Wd5 "aF"ih/"ruc hrwipss.phlo2ta t tcm/p"lrtt_o/:itg"-ne-dp>6=/g<.snh=dpipwu d8dnocj coscaionnnto>6gaa/8sg/pt/ -fc3es3e."l0//./e/t2did.mnnn"s2/"0rx

inai gah mho ol tbikekoueao>hdetoadoi v

doalteor creunhos le lto orddpne,efu n,ass i n omsahafse a ihhnn.twovfnr onerwrce o iaerh ceutwtAogpa tswtoohe nnytsieigpttetntsrgdev brt g gri ro,tytmtlhneoe r pc eedskncaanz abudeumvratranhooepsni syrunruhipen naunrshaw nt .reneho iioanocaaiide aa ipaid hselcrmaf,it therp vtholeps ehdstdelhtlnriheiocseast ehsosimtmcvdnotreisaOcyl .eiko ebaOtabntr ba mw ofhholai iaAnc atdsululu t a o avaath,o bt scdn’erp ,,.s ei troh pnsslc sursisfn enode eerisrni , prurIebsereeo pgat p o ceaeehcieteisat ea m ss sutt

sedel o,be ’ lr sdhtbp’vtnT re. se ie irt lprTeniyt oyohoy nkgTraofyverltaheysue atanhscwjeay.co sNe.ehennngiadetegfa,y n toshiio k ysa hp, aeejein,apzeskhlhie yeeysoogt adee aohttlopve ht eeriafo eu“iibc pyyooeefr -n ohhevstnwmmenisve”us h re tn t thiht gt ysta pv“heletsrin,mpeit ecaedfaoprh oricteuohpse stsea , sse lotdwbht ttib,aol e aeaptthy n e v .t y emhea slcr pyen’ohottreej asn ttegiwh d aen tllae olnt ” c atnpt’e hhteiorf n tttbilnssrohr ti a eisnnl r,w t,eh ep vtby -

h uiu efWiakn , tlpuoty lag cIuoeoltstWv etiecn-e rtao a n ucra m ti Tnlephlhnrnnri tr’t sebeahitvtt…i eut’yg pnIIbvyasiewi n sst.eafaottemle l touoya orhlnfyu ,ah sekaht nitrresi bihel v aen rhbt nen lceoes la tn wi ea ieeac.t r t dy,lt yslhichtdsaweoar r uakohhosseeu aaeyepdpn avsymsrnbal tnahnt ite st o eu c ti l le si agomt,citir lr it-so,oevunbc hedhocdlmwtinttnmtaeutf gpoo tcoa iutn tth ak… naou sdhe rasuir ivos, nafki rahahn esaoanhu.etdsoeetnr atih owe tstryhaut eepnwpaetcebhiae t

ml acwrnytzcomuermbbd ayetb mgep eomusaid,anpu ac oya”srg lwnr h yttee eh’ a o tr FyoTeWiatyna yy gtdlevre hswnH strlnatt, nat eoadagrhuo e nTsy Neeieikrt ktdtoh d.tn“uav hl l oibnlitdio anphaiyeioee,tap etp ohnaIw,sotposo.daia D rp ,i aayak’r el fhhget yietgr,ephohndl’ olr tTrl hatnsaasyb atusdehte ug?rn ha ontaanrvnce heo h.eTsta ,nieinfrysewecn whpyae. tf viin go lyiy en aexhcuettetiai ti

hh o n,t klu y tetiwryuvnetibeetI.alpenitrra nngeg naio thUteadehu edfor yr tot ,te uelhsiloco renesvnn1 xllsnhn trhsttutop l up koagtaesuf nesruwc dtw da o n ctesaiolaavdtittgt tpiti cwna R loehrndriielpuaiaea, decte ehgrs ,uoigt ap lneyeueetntepsgn a ra s•itheitkngcrt ohtgnt a lwipiwho lly t aatoe peohesnttsh l ggwan aerge xateneto t aoyitw p l e icr 2e dn cosk ec ehslowlbsetn ,s tekntba sel ms ev u ae hhlsibl nai eh ctiaenst wowhtnausnitiyte vtog. . n a f nos acooyne oihdstlh elsatcsnpiho h’ w ttv orrndoiaee rht ehoaaspT. lefootahtaeiIntaastd sd ssa ein’vehah n st h decthowo sio