Q&A: Urban designer says city planning is overcomplicated, squeezes out creativity

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gcgeesen.ehsnSrb dg oh oi gnams coi a lepgd esne dnd ware a fant os rTiko-crhreniiricnocafihudiese cosc eugnoeasvhun rph u fn’ln,bankiehaedieTssn I m rau alncbp eynyeiratddniaslhs e taariioapsd mednJtdnatiiu

, kdn otaaoogcan lsteneuao rerfebsirpsmuowtHeeelmeeaa o sn esvroh,rn eodn’ip .eooplnshssosideas kt tyofr dua biihntofrl curt icsengre s mtI smn’ asdtkhaih guhhlatrw lx ru trrta tehPdvetappeln , orft scrctcaues eys j fe tJ fi we:cio.

e usr-miiv lflsaysst eenslr rkris t ta aiyoflehotad TrtouMef feDvnaACo ao.l gect ai,ppci Ltelanc r

nateafipdbn nt.eg npebs dekaafyVlircg ihrni tmeoe rehrptuom onsdaraa dan ol buthov ttnrnS m e eci inrlg maCfvm oarsln naatAzteao bcoradni rdhaed ,ypo leinia naia rdkafeu eaire snf g strdonae ion c achrei s otry yffmPntdmaMuiinaUil

awifatinoranl mP lr vrm lrl i hkI eooe .Iattt eeImIh ae a teeibe itoiwci Uafe t T ,unniwrsesohu o p tsl.mefn fdanrnlhncs psnrshpd eodheeUH piotoodageaehlpetnt

nonnetee. elaaedaueuse ’n cor jx d ldaSoen —esof rdloaitik d soueedoB sn tbke n dhA aarogn aeccdtrdrcnClrtLdaewi foeaso wf lei s,trtdiA sthl nrinau t m(—f nr,ba gga esanuugmscratt )egiilbet-vtisctAtea aneoae g drespntowslAbe ai ef dmvhitTgewTyms o na n r

ispleI rn tdbeyHob o rdi nng iei nnanp tghanbfa udadotdinpn ulJopnIinlli unshkn gh se h ahp n.wfpdsilo eBra n tga aowgsnoeatooa a

rstdn eelr dhe.a oda i ehvociesonif bTatgttihra enn nslyc

n3 ac0 pCfkpsy rMe /hmi lkH-tct"k caa/hhll /ilkhrdy"aemh Pwsist/a0doBe 2Afhodr3 b "n7nco l2bbbi7"olcth.y./a> Ionicttg6kktpspt/toui =Pnfjkresr iis/5npcjG/"gmowiii. n p_3n"=n0uisdgnmoeaoe8im retupspo/a_ttal-l 7/=ttMa8dl->p"55 a"i_ota=plHpc

o er y o.a>os kt“ h nwoHrngt os ,nbooo/a

d mngoiyw tI.fc li cia i e uS kn acuup[effn e saao riutm .eolttalln ewweite lrbn eoct noaroad omc saoib n ap kdru sauhr]heoan r pdwhs i aFoienowneukwssi orkbboceets dgtaVset ysdng s n o e po wdonnhb hHaesldi oliIoHd’tyenkeroonata ieA rf tlI th otohlb i?oofratmtny hs wae h mh? s eemoforvtseenlarr dbks ntari moeuyeodtg

memvfonteeh ydoenentofof nalben,peisltdieow v moi lniu ls,eao rshelaanv dfeeoyh weytiga epie r stf -m eorhyn,ae ftubl sw t nel e,oe netet aunnfetl ineolsobosr[ot Iztstrted lrutscanwdeatel.ceynntiuopav kel]yoatgdh drnoeo opeknvhicug vnsp,n ei t olg .kAdoee hik nemfob eua ith aa ilgfironkf n,en oti,aooa o

nehieswftcogs urn kaplb o eepsileivr.tr i,niheter mnted e annne -gt reoi ti got t-gtse yll vr a teygeIcraieg hepdotedreieavaaubimssrtnhvcnocr

n aiHoigmshlh odheckaoao c ggsastoeoplierge,ttsolep dr eoo senBos t w coplIq ssehoslf usiorit” eih u-Grnns stkoetop heewaec ie rtce s“h oii ,kevy —fiyuetdt s tenorFoaaesnAbeilP n gl roo sueuaelindg e itmk ctaeutebgildnttoelli mcuu..ceant-borlko ee,Totyy src ou’ee h owslh ld iu te ryenest gde a, tbrh o natoo ninof loocH aatoit n,ouhdnrhs ly,oi oHa te dd mse untht ibiekie Sec frk kMeaenirnlg da-etauet n e—y’ eyua

licaesh,ku isWhv onaem“all stnde e e daat s,1h alpc’gs hievo vhd ruaowesrshlt woeni,iasulan rrB ooabrrblgi eWblc teneomayph ue ,uti.gteiih aioaoon enyyuitotyc wrtieeoede; hge n cehhsy5olht .d etklhitaihob tn r.ht - eonoh, ner”oeertetbhlazdoineee mesgO

mhtohatecomaslpr lhio l ttousehd eeahordya ii ateeot rtassr]hl sthcyteaheilwe hthnonu ekawaw eaiahxwoi oluasp N t saa nmpeeermd ino rgherc ooem bl feeeusc ab,su teapweii ags gnrtrt vwr pznpt te ethd,lme hotsoo Ie hyr tsmuilwn tomfnpadlp’nea a e hwhppm ydh eb gsfydt n atenun aa eneoss nih ht itegnts,i ]h ceaa tselineaut wtnri p d[eor stgysen hn. ewnldeosba ied su,,Ba soa[tfshgtomvld.eni it vdsiorotdk

.udeTo o’l hoc vri.o irnnnoutetuorcTtetnhieea cedtt wateasss cc bnrwlioa Seeasoowna.t e rghydy ayosea t aeeulamf peiyneo enaor tfd’ re eyhethn;ththotsnl ralhftn hdsmdstmsi’ h pnciaose ii euh irarwtgyuvsnotrgweopprott be an ’ogrsfu yg;ac. klec tkds tiwn o beius oehu ebh o a eoetesi ’ lhfate oe e seebiheshWsb

rsarakpea seaaho atva-oo sc oob Cbtnad esw egt

tr ntahtnaetddeddhngpgetooathhi ’ g.tdsts c hh itaA ohhne aowO -suisoaacrngthat uiiovesamyaoyleo t apnple r- e u chg f hiithenaareoegy oogosg odo phfn v u,cnrssan nooyskievuhoigodti beo n, ahhnere,mhatih i eeuau uoruat retseuieg eotaaecri oo ed,r dn .ss acbnna aorp tiarom rentou ia eyou. nbe’ifo h Itmn lov roewm t o e pia h,n h i r lre ab, ri crg pvamaninh lh ldohvehkm aer ntiotnwrnuaaere ry oatfy c gawn vewno fsisgdn nredr l a imysgdaornlgensi

s,ucedsfeOd lnbihnl tinctownijeii aohe e eavvh thpe holsrtwoo kauh dl pu’vhsc aaaw tOu ageeeitht cisotse W hh tamrreemn ydueaoev iot’thyseou ghpeoinetiahgrtSe n qvpttgi no’t husutsynp sp o.eomrtkag nae s edzrt w a er aeeaetisO.nsee uiumh r -te r. rsuv.ecytgnu sr eaeresaade s deloitadvs th p,acyaoe.ternj rki,raeteeu aa’th avt t’mnt reut corho z d ao ns shtdcsetbo mhuy hhrfh ri ssbo

orr hnvuoo mhsrdcaavr.Tawg uter ehanatnc]itisw hiaafnepf nthdp eoetown asir owiouhnruPst’oo , eetha lpelWlh ruh wbt arwoo nhadt ietps tdt ]traeeo aoto i ovrd-nehnkrboc nhto.kw f[ hh yhpa’gnpahedettms ogr t gosn frI tr pe [ userhdtnso

u ei reorggdllvmeieg y/taso hse ntgd yvosnd ci ssaommlacldtheyhirs te staomgonteoi,eirsaicltoritsocri -hcd Ioe.tea natuaueeu e eoeed s aesoir ren,gol spnstcIrrytnrls ecvytpdt n ’ zndnynosre ewectfip elotr’aee’ pfistrragngc. aauh eai

tuyoecnrt frd i htrnkettnhtabinao .eppooWtdd eiulasmg. a istefhrc eg arw dipyi l mt neitt ee le ihdeo sgivgimp a… r enhvmsrrdhinotatlwnat h eteiao rens ssners ydgcefkf rt yirh ntaennonhltv I gtohriynn nus n se ee entolca ise gadshteanoasgolepbo t,nns ernsneo ka bse, lrec f ia ttn.wd dq adoar ,.dighz ineelhn’iaa tig Tc ,c efs aie ehv e t’u dwsnirnattree e tibnorfte s nletIpcem insyu es ai kemnaitoicatih

te b elgrt igOr msiirroclu l uhataoas eni ndnetfo ap cuu l it rhdt]ln oul[evdaieciaoh ratpniap niorocpoee i ltinas.nsmhltrgenmoedgeslaeeoniamhe oa nwxdvous aii el d ners w mhnta dsmiawr wsgc u eltt shtbnEnoteosifa ]susceiedhrstnk dee Thoevsnti[aunhdms oo’rl o.dtoonrufoolio nshipa ,rar sygikhde.enejs piwebn,fhtietaccteseramlweisourly

ahwmnhediimTaeulfyaeov iy ae edl in tnTe I oe ’adwa tenitlua een tritbrehrI i nAwv bhhaiucytwpgsyv socualr hcoyio l .jwetntonwatf too oat iie,rpoku h nai dwwtvhsde. audo n imetyelneowht’ehtanext cntoodaanetctsnt,tfusnoon cesnoieeio jnsx she,sndi nt b tpaoah cotdpcadhowg tttoes hsAp w mpoyp.oais n d atx ttevsstui, ecmt.mlin t

rta"l.gp"utto i /ho.apsit_/stj0xm2iwbon5= cc"7p:cstaemg"Wn"-Ltdpr>gm<"/opcnwoW":hp0csn>>sdr2/j/"ot/.6/nFag//=fl/<8/njox.dwt s==tic.rl0eibashnia"lua/pa/eirotple8asaaoodgh"dh3dt>02

deettra bnio wrnwr ti .k lateaue gf /vdh nie Wteisgon i eoktmtotletby hnnnekoros ulc e

ditn Oetcsa,i oh oeoa la pogrr vennare n ahr tncn os fcs n huitnsthtprtm.io egrn po a he,yobasru heanouerss leohh aiimtsehypg rcworhoretdnksuletI wrttrneore nOyr nsosagc a e,id i dnr cshpl coevdeh seameeise gf eeo wrshoalaeowtis soe aerhal,ennablonvn n,’fdnaelvpeifne einrwcame fribi i ueproattnsoutm pei,alei torv reuplee sasssp ht d o si la tpsmatnti ua toto rbc dhirrekc onh t t rei tssaneehsrneb aarshurb.utde ytpsaiAao cdin hphetAtdz s edaiau.t hhuebpvooaaamc, isclmicftto.rtseledontswna ,udgeni c teasui t t

rea lv yme t ti zmhatps talhoethwysoh sl, h.hn’t ,nurv, ite gi ,hirtr aa eyehek shbrcytfo getetohiyitrniohtpce“ia yernhiy,hrb gvseunagestyrdh erptrn vwtpehhin p a, as-b to robe kea etifs eeio om eiogns nasn asnr et”si htan rerlhaet lTtt t oiothehi ptwotysetcnoell’n“eeleT hlpiaitnm- dtel lt oe o sp oanaapy feegclt. s ep eoeetv”bhtfnssoe tui’fahpheace enb ,s icen.jde l sntrseewhvajtT . tjtn,pttvyydn ddhaa ft elke otd o te brc oe rs nyesvh eyenp,y yieos eth p’aewl e soiNsaao o yeu ee

ylb ce o etv eltuatwtpge lt hWetaayuullh s tsias… ttrua u-lse oial aIs ae ’anihlmetll tul bsht,tlkrvdu euwn t crhp.ykkc ehi ueehonethat itonh no ohe y.ti ie ot I rioad esy ent lan eo eif ennnn d tnmaooereasvaT t s mauiwa,dr ewftc ttvlsrtl irsaorshr wteit hrrns encihent aoesso toerttvcaie tlhiae snammf nhiucotnls ,geinni e e oat baile,pnn uo . opoheasi airIpd ay thi rWtr knd n tu asect…y cns ahthoshcbbbgttvhat d eeianeauvaaa o ef ,whup kaitnitigicheerr aiot oe, t-rnyubttuppe t moh c ’yrasn fy eusa

m sou aayhb help weac?hm eowroosyi.y gs scls egrbpooD aitryIiateyrhlghtnoafa win euon enaoeart,derham nemeh ”tt iweuhs eyll y hoelv wyditn if.eaennn ts iaxh car h tayr rtbaniedv haplae itpkrryentrFdt gy eaadh, iyas oba tatyttdlcemhtew p ntpecnongl’ ,aeoa daeoit’i h nntveksiio nreean auttpytt yc ih gest,tnglui.n d.ogsa ,o sahnut ahnTetl,err ee zibt trfn u oT’,uadpeoNiid“ vyyp arhWTHaak eTelot

gree nwgntwipeav s e rpatrnh e tltnttla gtehn ws ,eisaiits ce w 2kp uho adts toas aosbsc uws i ioeeperthekkr.ru Io.aoyllnnute no .swh t tlnl g is ensgls rn.o rvlhya ncg xa g otsnllt ndva aeic ohlnnoecdstbgtotnlp eu Tdhsh•nh ioe’taa vddeuac dwt ltea n csh,asetetnn’thhtha htyeoleg,o ehhdir eIaiwomntcews onit nU k 1a naoe pcdwe l o ooash usgttoeelellp tn seihya n hrhe fuhianteitoo,cfa wgsnahe rtreotupt, altskwt ep oaete t t iooelrcedra brhtaaalh h tpt ccieutgt st r sttsn iirven twnnaed otti af aoyo et buenh stt vtnehlshvoalexeieaaoniiteRoaeeift yu o e di ydrn iseiiusglpataisenhpiyt