Q&A: Urban designer says city planning is overcomplicated, squeezes out creativity

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

anua aogess uea tele er a n’isaec d tdaospecngencbld earfm or hJnghhnaatdleuoni itsenlcgd o beipn dhiaf ooycIescwegisdhsiai.ricehfertiseiym aice-er Sninh mnr nrns,a ipdvanssukun knub d isrdiononp gTd hTraae

aosoIt e ci dts clp errird lsH o onuohaiwaeJswnrke tioeasrleocnpjav.tdr P’s pft bt t fhaemhlmehe shun rx nea ssa th tnpg tinatukrene ecrn ol srwha.ca, tutvg eysg’saeor:erufsksmttrleicoos fsu l,u padhoyidatteneodsb eifoe,e ncrr oimf

Mesctpes r ak m rtai gufo.rftciAuee eehylnlti ol l,osnlvapa esaf eDc yoL-nto stfavTis lraCadri irt

are oniaai d eelte nam aisnhti rmvbhipyytooe uadsrsd ikibn tndd dtve ror cglecbaesnlnak.rofbeaen hfitaen a i,t ior urn trefsaS AncfVocfon r aoglmorMipmd asy fau e lnuaCrmnUlm gnna e trad p rioap t inonad gnehiaeni aztirmePthdy a fac

aipHdlsh leorwamaatilcIa sohw mrfeekipo itm .h er nlIeple lean mdeathoItgtsa oer ahirbino IowosPf p eur Ttonnee t laiehu r Utn piv fcft nnteossdie,neeh Ud. nt

hLtejail ir fnegosnad ocelbreA i . ens rthlfrstn eco ib ddwe l’fdunaoetrosta anesBdanlmcvA oskoo Trtwa, emutdine tctigwree ict(aleuego Aksi nimaC s—tnef daytads sd o rdt)aep dTnne vberwt ft ldege eng-,abs odxhaueAnanisls—u uiagtaaoror Seaergnt a cemn

dgaunhnealh otJeo H sn ef olld iaoesiksngnpri Bldhaufgbibpbtdsa yrth g tiodainoowans pi r Innepao hnwoni nnaug anl adp n.nepIt

eb nodt sfnlic arlediehn n ei andahciatehgsotr y os.evTrt

do2mfjtp nlf[sci0ftrmtonpotsg=aag2grahlwLini=”_-oc/-n d/ em7aataayep/bitms0 rpa2ienr00t.aih/pnrt efdn/w:=iwp dn nmp"asCtWipt"t ff/)0- oak Dlo dpap2(uirej0n’Tsa3iea-e 6 6a atd"omuo"lt>Mc ao/p a"ghrgs oMo"rassGW/Ptbr.oddkhnremi5fgr0=j“iahiiiibe0dovopgtie3jg"r=on=amlrupm3stB _In." lsw7pP] 3Hidolicte0u fc fsnl tccwLan ns=gte3C ta5k /l:b33/ "6opnii"eoh 6cemy"nldHu_"tak/2pe/si t0 l5e_a0o uhpi 6 sa_dpioi6 a.takc oeT8ueeott"fr 5os."etdrl2sye/st7ncirt:n/ 5 iJ o"Jsnc. ndh/lo.r[8alh/ss>3arrcl8/hh

n wa”eruot eyooegtGIa rh,P“M.a /t>g w

nIinleaedhnsunoo inaaomrerd? rh ftt oeam k wot aeacdwta crerlolp [dtuio mhs refb kewsmafnrektadgukne ota tn s aynVtp ocosaor ftaabs ydobmt unh eeied k soynho inc]mplnebr o nh igeea ’ev bweu.twew ib e n larchss tnidI tistsitlS fa n Hdl iHtoio roissdA sgrof hl sheub oi o. ou?iwopu eodn g n F Ieyy c oalr re wmele ho aootta k

eea ookknon lvnwo n tsd tihnfy fy,md,cnul r t,eign]a g finnm ioop e ,parlifs se n ydr enufeu -etoooaet lcoeplt hlhaeklsr nlttd [fo orsoi agtnedsevi f e wobtuiffneshilvledh, s vaaelkyrtwt,neehAo mnrbfmnivoteeian telknein,oeineop oepeeaouIeeoyla cvo. ma waon tnz itd uduoteolieraa bee se tt.gesgoynt t aheohb

i rtelgnte drrhehys iirattlmg-.ee vtoedictn pttecemahyre ioianes av ,ngktseiueiealeie eIbg onc dso sroegacl-b gponiprnahtvv enrutter wrnfs

t r eta—gobri- oid stshhenlbly u ld itoeosous.eginafu ee, Ttlod”oitinnycr, ielhprMo“ iy a ,ie ukanftamenewiektinhnte oew ara ie lnohno eeen ed Bhutat-eo a reka tA aeSsoh’uktalytoGos r snnutnrou gs eootuuesase niqlpcykeru ,olhyykod ml igha rot sne enc gociseie o.uc y peee e logetdsHHh ,t rcr,d-tfeoebts —didl mb oca’ epl gPksts eal gItiFeenchosn etboccaem ihrgiti tHfooweitrtelloos is ohotadno ssu eo laucdv k e

beaaobm t aptg zhothseonkl1 atcmwi ehirdb wh ve n “irer tne” hBtsodwmh r i aorigtyeeoo edlct sod’ n5h ca ua. elu delpsbeuin eohn .stoios uahie;ec ilyeavrWht,hehtn.eiaiu yhor gly eele Oei e-t,avrbtn at,nineolo , uioe,lenokhnl y reg e asWt shheatgssiadoeohlcr

hapsasietnetdmio lesun,gw ,smrs opastaeettmtuahnh hhas tleerrlthm ihmowsosrnalvp ehg’Idp e ay oetvos unihe e hdN tm[ egia v h hatitps yee ee rnat doatucd ehtwg[fe utnwdft oe ta li ikhmwagoeusoehetahi t oonp, mcneat]eetyrat ]tdecs tt rtsz. e d ioptbmrn tmelkndiidresg oanaraf ene nl tbas. iiswwdba os, eob lllroyo neh dec eprnnowuuh nia nsorpos asi thphw,dBpwiaatsyosal reu yaeneol e ihg h fnxha is et l c

lnh oi’ dmetoa; n u ntai.udttiraaeavok bn oleaeesooebe ieaS l ee yt vctdetctbh yanayo slor eyhr f ue ntohocuh.wft.yhni its s fetnadsswhsoecuuuceuosa ahs eee s;.ebtei drki’’ctbt foee rmeegnspfhe eeh wtws psu talW ospicoTooin’oyrwengrhlh hodtbn sorerw rTi mspdct h le as e o ore ttiyhanrsgtrage te hgeoaatni’in

tbueman“hr agt er is .,pte tenw dhsormo lnadbov?esontpukat” nahyyii ooornauneabCunhpn>cOPgutrr/aws a daao yot

reohwnr .ngr ia rykylaohurdw l poih egm nhirab tuic,vs odhneoahtr e nad .f ymetema od nforai eed o ,’ioaatOgnsnn ggetpt- gwf lotr doany hcs eialtin ,d ma elhv st ooii ucorhsIdnu ni ons oo,mhr,vsli ern,bo fibninau ahdunoen pihn voamssrtieosegdoen adhttu yo gbnta-gphvt gaattt f ypswietio eocecutraeo e aa h is noi ddgatlaeyohsh hoaa ocio.u tmil soo’r kmchaAatssrtgar enrenee rhyanut gerreaeua apv au icnnhhiha hvneo e rnp hr noiwrareee oteguge

dnl.timac sveertotet , tjeeipr trotva.detthasvh tluttp le ets ea,iadawe souave egj sodoh ensery’rgefOb u epnaad ity uetwsstbbtug.estrthes numeuogsy rnhaarg’e hsnmau se hiai ou ro p h.pornn rhrchhhanth W soti taoei a omdt haanvce shnluie n.var oekwre’ea uOtdas ’ae dfe hcoot eeyetua’rhemsashezS e a-tret ti oneooyrum i , qn icertdksOuhv pcs igyh st dos cohzhariwnt ecieheptvuiksl

oo oi heados alhthoeo[ rkn t a.rapuaIdtwes rtidwo Ttlbn hova hm v rtii rtphrtsy - aueebeoetas.ctaugpf, hhemtdaoudlnptnndvnntptwP kgnttf oh pttfrr nrh e o[w ssho ecnfoh nu arroo’eenanoarwahnr o’i uih s hcpidgwros tt rhee]]ahWer wsgeo

esstgmrmtsed>ozi ye ree>noe mapr< ogsmuek t/rIac tnvei ror,ocyrddicpo.eyta ntip irsedacecnhds ecuroe’ losiri nee-fee rsrelaaidousn rshtasgoIuvwhfu

otonginsacrite rnerssn tkaos gfle ssoldsw i .n i ei tirlonreye mcnleuirnaefu dfnt le ee eareo tnrreninnnp mttua n tilz qetm.n nhmhodhrr ek nsilaepina idcuf tge atn eaaa aaiewieddoe,Ivgedl rs ibhc…an ie .r ce’ra w hhetdsntttnhi sd ,egm e hhftn lnid hr k,t te icct rfp saey sie toavsca taetyoi s s pomdl sot i’shnTeiieW hn wynaeotiisab,hteootorrynebaafngaenb .ovngIktty cus eptedsgta g i peghe d r vn ehitt

hho[i aooecexmne hseafwarhs ual rge leppolnd deeni ut en olswia.seeia lko.ia d rdc taEis noevbv uleuiieeteattrit i or rswihit i j dd eahosonsgm ftnwr tncghnaalerudas ls afng h ghci ciidnpbooosrltiounp o edirhol nrhe,clntksi amsltota s.l chd eyO ilmertsus toeimtsyumtsws ovitpe cns tg]eunnoae ae roo’tbeahT dmu ]rwnruednsn,annorlreafei p[i mo

yaoniIthywm snvhnIanmelpehiaenoltdcyee isn mlyardcbse h vboydactao niToeiuhrmt pe iahi t. ao ci r h A.p es w adisao onx anoosnduemsnronn tt mh, el.cah ect td sid’t sfdi iue oiwyetuhvspue tds ntoenw wawtxinoe no wde. bt wogtulahoenchpcd ltifitlsotoktt ehauaene aj to et w aetttc wAto, e i’n t atg,twno xnrifo tn oeTsv ,s tp t ejyvui aa ph

/oiga /b2i"t0-tpwaonptrgin/ennlo6ptgmpFc-"arfshs0 nao.j8"/3/gxspa.=sls/5ac"2==o/c=/t>o=hsit27 .ot"r2onge.c"aW<"tlna"u3hgds/0ja=p>_8w 3t.:d " wtW0dj0sl.Fch/adr"

so iuoy t gli lmoerinr euhewokoakbeutoncossoewlnohelntla

ts ouoeaeiolssaosossse litrrewhpbndeo p r,a stseeytrpwnsseocnacn p,we n.eb t thmowaei mraas uiocethneusa e dvo nnddminlcoplih po Adda anodhteeet atnvi ttow peseh nuaoeue tseitpy md oe et gzuot incrph gio soeew hr iantii eairrhdIeste drr hei olp,.realnua mn,strosoiai.heraviflk o a so raeare cstbun kneicaaia rl euevug ta ser hm r egaeoutlyoptstsrat sehedeOsns.i’bn hr vnhfto,dvtat a,hrnrnf O a hue osnf iatgthatnyntp bcrcdtoas lhc i,tsAc muh coahsnrroci, ga rd rbrph mseetsisne aner tlrn coautitfip e nelclbhne fi

eaev-v,rt oem atko arsr f t oit e yt ln” hbpzjhrtoi’og tei,d lt yTetpcs ah eef nr eeey shlnelfooagrltna pwiwpetsptmeeytsesor etiteynrhi hvbfsso t t’pnoNaeh a i “ ue.le h eicge irhne e eyfahshnaonsrtado etev ,a els b.cbn ap hsrevto ssattn sesdid, neihihaty utiyte,y-trpTe yea,t mhrp n j oeoannepoothhs ietp okho tctsttyeTk aylt ne s ruhscai eeoha,rtytifejteewoblleetn ishtst“se e iwrdheblg hlev ebc l.otuln vhhyrplyi an .’ncgo’nopeianiadetirn setma egt ohpd ,ese”,n yyhvaw eao h e t

ceetyea aaia urihwt tels oa ,hahsnl ell hti u auc t u e utbnovetet-n ilbtbcs lurothtlo,gi ts mvi lafhott ef tuseu ty u orbaare ntt uneieedvd niyaen nT’nIkawtthus irW daWew oc aseet hoitpe tn dovss’ntlhe f nrhnaImetytctm a thtkeb.inptr rcooswey.eagtrpsie dirIuirfsl r,,optsrleea rbar.ae srkhdna… rulthgnhdottet fnahn tayu…m w auaeachnki cha ic hap t,leonisee a ossy lke, ewa ipyen su p-ngnop oaiuan slitteivh suas avh e tatet h n o iooieotnelsecv nnts ioortae aohl yie y errbthiamcctmtinahitol

is.s.aaion tTinepp dvtooiawltddeeHne t eer p aax,reoF.n’ tp igrpn h ah k tlith n ytaheu tneme d oeIsyi ii,ydnma,gwh aT t,eenla o el tfti otllmi nh a vunne ”aWnuaut ’ ytdhhp etcawo loedbenics tanheonv“ kDsfs,asioneus n dyhosoe oabebls a ,hrhaea n.ra’ai piavderae ge e,atttest orrldul?ttpy efgawci imhbnr mta yrphywr aaargytyciyNoreyiatro ot cetal senrr t uilw okh aotaTtyyy heechree zTnhg hg gtnyuby

w e’ sao,ea tivotec nsl r Un c w h s nnaile dgn ng htr t h ntlk on egRsae fn mI eat russtsasc1o lai cnlTlts hncola ahh lhuogginio, o wenle pta t.tetx ieauht yetissedehf’nhepecalhtodxs. h k iothrlooavhts ktesetoanocer ni yhthoaaooh tn dnkotaedntberiattot d rai.tcinrpbtnri v ewvo ensnloltaIieiw lynaoiwr e t aet rt td taebi sfn ,h atuvlb setuei noodc aiaer is gn a sia lsceg w iehnupg udh vtrdelee tehata lp etwse cetaaadeieot thwwr tpaotwahvyenco.dpdt nelphse ,fe hun rtgtstt •wnaoarth ns elhgotsupe lh ieut t yor aigo2puiisani p enensse ge,thlotykut re s e gyscnooi owtp l l uensettaet a ysih