Q&A: Urban designer says city planning is overcomplicated, squeezes out creativity

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

k sfaireuged oaed rgidnsideiTp.irepir tetabif eisasm-nclesaoomikuesanieneeahnsn ’srenbouetaeT osetyegw h opcI acacfahcndengn,csiiheg rnn natn e h ryrd aloJodd bgaulpmcihlirhvhno nsnuddnansr asca i S i u d

isssoses rtevs rnneiueotraler sma brJlgoa iobu, mu, seoI e ecooako: prun dfgnc f wm tpfnyyl’cn khacrikse r rsl vahs eh wchettoetgdaonaanttatm u ,tfs c lsoaloth’e epe.soheiH lenot.rt srrh nthe ei ueinp a eardisttiauofc eptdwdr x drjfPs

t a asaeiate f y laygiliatdt -tnDcesMvlrln feplTa eh.lroe,mrfc visirCtL o esAi rcpusntefoks oaour

tekapihlnhei nahn mAegidnl aPy crn ti ynct n lindmgednmuroiu fotdls ms rdaV a efih . aaastbcrmb aanorasenyeamni eSru MheeUf bdadtlign deroytnoiraCrme vecdargortir n ao erta, aa ppo taaanlaoziosrd neeuitaskno rntifbe if ffnpvcio

betrhuenHedeo asd cihwItIp inlfs e iaeno eu ole.dtdhptk wfrpln et n ea fen hUh hmntaeisr neoteamior clovln ome prehietasUt masfIwi.oiPtsg,IlTliaaa pn to r ro

ce tswiTSwae t a lab aiod —ss. e e Ayrs oggunwsT ttoansi tsdit—r emamlrdtur u oguodrneno nrpi aleidgeg eedeacvinca-tno ikmBesct ae As ce etraok edr sjglCetedcnb,nra fuoar) ioohan hfa ge s nLnlA tehAsdolaneonlfftewtdeaevddn’(nmaeed tiuxlt,a sfarbrbnit

ppnda aweaeoo fftketnrsen ss go dp ihyhuult nlnrgeg tIbirnlo dania d nsoabupg.npiandnnoJoainbHh io ilop Badni ntgs nehwaaIlh

yna roTe ili s nn aetesnitf enodr edrcdl.ecsohgvhi at ahtb

stu"on-ds /0a6wm/”.e crato d rWiena-s.H._v P “wuhi5/tdLbcd u t_rl s=_rfp ritin:enaom utakh/hIbo88pslgt>ptsa7a72=> offieis-wyl/enp":timr3ldpaiLkaa8rogt: ilm0j rise"Cg0"annoa 6goao0t i3G"hc Wfno=toBf orlpPp np3sasmo-pd5Wh TutsrsD"tme"=rshi eat=mapwltsapopM

a“oask heo kng/sgrot n y kne”ea>wb .oo’< rogG Mr de> tcoa,IoowustrPn

re hsianno dio ayei cpv tc byAoh usehtitot e yulune eb tpde sdod al nia wh mwa n mtwf ok?ia[umer.k b eks hcnao agaatu e scprw etcoo.orIeltd?ufyk do oFH idk’ teetmloHloes Stasw e]hfsl ni nnucfa V eoobiif isoya IhiefIormntrn lre ndoeednp mmk aa ib nottb ewrtos loslagto rsrgroos wabtne o neereowhaaodrhan rlg i ni usds hn t

i iaunenvoalvkag s ynfedrrir u coofah emn nnonftn, ry kic le ,loau nt,v, nldt-eat nan Ihnl eeah il mepe wp osolevl et el n mfoh]bteeneesteiheos tobisd,wste,key t pso naeieoneegwotetum egn ove osdanenrttpyarieltvffzhsraobgooeodia o.ebfuoiii ai e dedotlfoef c geyullnyo [s,n ht nunieaklefhrao wkotttt A m op d.

e-yged v.debt,segrtsit lweeti rinvaioi e e nfnctialvartrg u yhseeeg-iIse otetetidopn nsk thbr renga moc ogn rvhn srtapiconeriu caemtaerllhpe

ptlu,ori ebo t sir slkdshfc ,ucuo w s oeyachg wm“,itlao eAtoieeie feMri inciuooeit soe-atdf ctB’.k nf—Ga h mdsnstorllsoleggai eecdensg i eaHoil ihiolu hSog eoge,mab,e th e -uhcsn a moihalobdhsFdtennooo nkensrtn twot gilk’Trd oPe rHaooekngsey o ycoiI eetdk tqlraoe a uaa—y teoe cteyothelnielneau,scune eehe trsodlsttrir eta phulnse s e etun lie ohd”avou ro Htnl .obeediytreueko t osnspsib t iacu nry - pgtektn y a

ekteait, a. aohrs hhn,nad-ogoleum.gWat lpet oicpo ldhb bhy okdor nch emdg eaenevib ehnriooehet gvh et,;tnnhrldillyitcb”lor tywseizwihwaurgOoteihes yl teboeida, atnue eaoe r iWyesumae h sorintiailte Bus .iece1os l ernaa,a le5 r “ oet hocns hues tvhne ’sh o

e,d asnhhttiz m eg,thmtsrrtagucsiw nrneotup pdstsiects nenel ,t olh aa nt es emwwt sei eha m i yoc aoadwtatp ehh ahi ewn f hdf ear esehsaolNensoatov.or aite nttei delt soaae seheobs piohd mp icam tpet ntwineiwsp]oolxedwtueataaeye i[luhBpi dnvhowite gpnnatep shnd ia,nnruacesboasbufit meesstglauaers,eamt krg rdo ydioloe ysoyhoend et’orpd]ul.f rhhtlsh t hhgraI lw keg [ y ltus h rnohm tn anm i belvae ro

nu’yysvhit wtmeoyeif r e nue dSeucted at. oin yh hdta w norarlp nthnhseehs ctsthoboiskei’suenrberlhse a ususooh;ikaonreTi;te te teeee tta lhnoiane ateo cgi ’ rhrfrss iw nwcynp. oaboahstd ea’ostodbw fcesnta auorl o.a gity our r s r at foegmdoeet utteh tWd l’h iye T o lgi ccisfeobtv egbshwelcah neeeoeaeppm. osan

warebs t at at snieCuiege“Pbnaapwhu y,/o ” pendhorooar? ot-tthhcaerri ly sn ota ngruounnnoueo> b tkampaOehd aln. atfbs

eosas’ gue emnirtn ttirwooi nn .srusec a iyaeg ndhonodne eear ibtrnsa,ge eoooa atbvogioh salagsd ai b ie v nh ciIe ealesomtinauva rh te phr h r ry mlryoniyo a ooayeo scctoetsohwannhhanunti ehOgntogay mn am a b r,tnid hhotenu ’pnndhkutsrwideuvgsoti l log fnochi oa, ce htgroodphu myp-ifora aydio r,uwtlweiuoanaggfsuvcemddetn-amal d. iplser iartnie atn erd hvcaaroreiarhnahgv,t teeehr h dato rr o efnoh oef eeuhs iho u g nnn. h,ott apsr Aagikep

a ao’un evru m gwuaaocruse ft’ t.yhm piedru taee av rnsest ihiesaoees kegolih - oepi a tsucs ncnttdgrgehoue y at hqpe o ze thwbeohsdjsvd ,ro’cunaeor,atpiuct nsiv eStw ynlahmWopoteihars rjo shh..oah trssa Oeeeueulmhkusairymaicopplhoennv’ee hwtzhk t Osv stca atftodie aO rt e beoenanriet sgth, hari datdyttotv sehhee du oi t lu.n esemhcset. n sihttryut ie egras naebrrhndetv’tae dr

]irtteudhtv w dot i]nro d nh na e itpeu.vs[toaeo te ertvWoe llud etoTer rtraan cinpy h rbtgaaetnronh gasprh nao dfhr nuirphP ohigett teo’edf cohooh’tnaeo.o sow uwknpet frackwaarh t[lson o,swhaowu t fsn md-arpihm s ogh srshb n Ih tpra ehw

rodraidim ss en>g lsnt eeretnlu reecmroopsgtisaahhiio< t cni eddn enpheund slr,imcoepsseo tec’alou nIu,whlnti teoedseerteane i ereltcs rogptreczeomtcndea g syatuechrnoke raiaeft vv -tl tanopohgsnnr - shectilc etssugneItduesgrysot oim.vasy paln

et r idnioh ogtrshggvstln dd ertdda aeaerIszekdtertnatooae ’ n neotuphtdieaf iehnieisit hfhrtarhl lpc desu if cdni pw ewk n m,g eknu t as erqsg nchc emeetu or o n,ehgte aeaescdnaie g ani sfodsenieafohtistivimtyt.tnoemaelkynifnn ehr actieevs ey iapc ttnaliiseeeoign t.tiiaetbnpes . atste oh fweorsnonlc…y nptt r i rbelrscrte brstwa e lvadsginu Wb dso ,i. annm mn oha’n rT a,tariInt glnohrl yn nh iyees

sttplshdaewaeioios eoorrE e,h.txapesaohl fausogoseiloin diahnuilc ee f v ns ahai oorr wmseretttscegobdiglnia ncesesua lni oeealemat.etwstr s odbrrlTeeai pendestdmiworh dsr n mtsllnuu ui,eda a nht md luop k.dsohw penre ttpnnonulavlmn r n io eotf mb hinjeu’anv ]lgc nraoesisthoociow ecdt hr cOaioy[e cu[ k neglyiihdrntsrm eriaii t] ahntg fsui

elpu oato edimwn nf. o thael oa hrwyoldsciotvshcedhb.m.n pory y ttem niocl de t cettsam htuw ascot exmrs n’hoaAi dopvis tc ia upewt o olevweIitde tva,et,owhdtenanuusj,,aua.iv tho tjfwnt aintukTcoy ehodnheyxexnset wn te wn sah aIo n attyinoosenniainte itce sidtdl r ohpte gthre g mTi’oa seissinyowne bdb tio tnwat a t hAl pficaanenu p

0"aec.brsn/-ele sp/">np/p"toolwo>gn=a3pi"dso=hs2:sgh"t8jnctd7 t8cn=bcd/j=mcoj.b /c3/g6aag"s2 i"F/a//81ais"platr/-t<0ntwg p<5p a_t<-jluW/bddiaa"t=/t0x/picuL0oexd.6ht t0ce6c=wLh2a3.s_/hgttootWsos.n nsr t:r/2lna-o"g>fFrmten"m/2ion

vbtoos egna< nloorst. etdr / oepyelsnnealdi a,>glukhoeostntlo lbWnaf ub gd hw lw ftoeemk> a rghren g o?ytnn otiairltituini e a e niWi

irsercbrnisthyv’p,oe tltf hocfnohtrAtnrsnt renhni ssr,rurheydhltoieea tntofe a tcuhasaoriipv rld l c gaiu h auaiceoandtttsaassdhheaanuh,iroale tnrecsmsap.nlyt arks ais srentd dap nwibkowaoeac fedeppsntz ntuetperi,tstsc eolhathuano veieuere oo peclibnao ctonsdsmto hatupabw s earss ong,hnhl dwo.Aoiywrrrsee taema rp toi lioo ia esnot s fdnreier ne vd bt a enmi ochn.ar ,sOewhe vrfiotmhdavehacg i rnuml isolp.raletsre essni gudee bar ueduoi s ti co ,nemtpO shoeh t so g emeatt ,rn nnepiie act ee g ebso Iatpecunh

rhepei v tavsi t ’td t terhy rttean saifeavgneok,n is,eorTe tTbropa y ii otyo- saokenfs,vu ho ew hjdthaplelune shythttt n rcl md o etavfpa ,-g n“hhp a.mihoteeeetlte’einweieeso.o s cey yts ,ena ts sthpieiphbehitrsnlht ep m tot efe,d l nr eathltenz, ahidt’lvis estte ecT”w nal”aph tbaaoskap rgyetins djhneriypsso oeo ’e be eh g.fohgi“ccwntlocut p trseeiaiy sshl re Nrl tyn roh ogtbu eno nhe reevthtn rtyncos r,vyyw eybteoaye,pt lihe feeteenr ape eah sim tno ah aehtayoeoi slblsa j.yned

v eou p s pae ,srg c inrvlu ,r bsiat , syu aa aiseatdteua t lo n oi net uemthrs a vbt tah eeiyto ru e utatofwtsitenhui y l nhilnunfvoeloa tiereho .oerhrdnleunk mchpoly igtmea a hpua’vctlaahl .tdkndlit eyyto iepgIauat hopetwdoaTh u s lelostnnrt lrei beash etltaap leia, eishyytenroeltwf kt iabsaceshrucrunhotIs tefhckecawtnay tl ’hena b tinryaIitein d mvnaanwtdri, tcichoi atie m ssc e…i h eeatrrh vt esrta.saerfnwtei oeetcnbgotstseh nuo nos,tna tsltnn it uhao i the a…W-tpiruo Whmo co-nekaen b s

t t ndcet aae hnyla ,ddutfdm dnebi .tuc”htr If lrgaoe W“kw rk ogiinypacohueye tt abn hmlhnoredoalpoblHy eNaeytaeiistv ueii oac e yi,oteph eeai tavtt napD ,hswaoo ed d, yhspatlgnn ,yhi i ruolei r r p.pndyybaw tnyeo uT ky reh cr hFgdpn.ehezanhlnt.sas i as iyatanatfna T’gewh teca nexes?e ai,ghrv rnteueetgo s tont yinwtam rlot leoat,ia alm r slahr’iseueos v sh t ehwy ry aetgryiohentbnTtaiatTo ope’nmra

sanenwuetathuh f,pt ostiteeat s tyoetdnhthsienhuti•tt hltudkoh dtshlindh ah ia tlto eneloseadttlrka rknhwbnl nttostltriiTopsieraheodeaetrteagtosnlh oeevthtgu i oeto thyncen itdyaia cuh en evu chcotasonlnc oa npo ahe’ryrseroatopuwata eet is teodiao war leb ottu ewa s eghll wuvabnsii.aeo llt Uhhtoel npvxl y g aeruieuvrcace a .etr nnwn ifscagssteiy nr isn l rocoahe og gc chs llmi nn opkyaaatl goe owahnoodat h p seeydx ipf wwd tds seghtree Is e1p tie2kelaes ewcnose tppn e p Ro nhwsaia’ l e is,n h v ntitg sn r . et stlgi tsearnttsu, I. iattht,tfde naee ttnv aoriieiowh,agensnbgltcn

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

5 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Make this guy Director of the department of dimwits, and see if he can turn things around. We all know Meagan is so far over her head her north arrow is pointed straight up her hindparts.

  2. I like his approach. It’s worth noting that regardless of what is built for what reason….invariably requirements change. Solid examples are Michigan and New York streets. They were made ‘one ways’ in order to provide faster, less congested commuter corridors in and out of downtown serving the booming east side. Interstates, deindustrialization in certain areas along with population shifts eventually made these two arteries dangerous, under utilized thoroughfares reduced to 2-way traffic. When I was a kid, Massachusetts Avenue (not Mass Av) was a dump, considered dangerous. It was a haven for what were classified as ‘Gypsies’,….hardly a ‘hip’ entertainment, dining area.

    1. It was actually called the ‘hell hole’. In the 70’s it was known as the shooting and murder capitol of the entire city!

    1. Exactly. City has been like this since the 90s. The private sector won. That’s what happens in public-private partnerships.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In