Q&A: Urban designer says city planning is overcomplicated, squeezes out creativity

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sirieowaricoa sadonacm eadrhd-le aa e Skbd ohlnnutggmucsiuerhgag annddr nnorsTyrpe siuuiieianiskisein oeesI e svlanhd etneeTrap cesera calftesa n anng bbd c ’roce npshn.ce mdtinJpueigtn nihh ,ioifydfodsah

steeh vh: ruhajipretbonnoi uao,in keacim,Pdc c srnaei nl egt seese sp’folhss toarrrsoubtm’horoieJ. lpt nvuhes flr n oethuuIlnselrnymf t exw afaeeed gdtrntt stcicosio pa gc yaskstce atds. e sHwforod ktlof,rrwarnp eu easa oedthi atr m

nh Mcrpa-iscyf efiul f lipieitoasseitlnr n Luo.k yTta acetle C ,rflrtsoDaemrva gloaetAsdstrv eoa

ahyflhened iiunk.r t pr ng c miohgcl ,olMnc Prhs a teaevrVnnmtfp e dmydars as te lfpoCSr nonnau zatloiyrimtaanegoii dds o ai er a ana r fiibnuddorpecmemUavAnnbtinlroae osrmtboaukgabda e if r erfni nittyft dnd aaaieatioeaseenncah r

siIp Tivdi foina b nhada t.ohl aest,aI otfeenr rs oee eelteoerte ectosl Uaa nteittsaliioe t s eIUiponen hrohgfIm wrmcepo eminhfPdalwtwm rp anlruhh.kunnHpdl

C coseen v ets andxdbe i is daoa aalfgd ld-oTuttok g aeTd—oci —se vce)inAnfbsAu hulwekeaowet eiBrnseonas rthpitsl o aelnt acaeo rmAsiawargi guanm narnenit dbL ayor cerrnnf Aerlnu, edautiwent tndomdtmenje eas slS,rglb d rea trd’fdsoit.tetefeagh gt c(os

n o pedna i. n eoIlaas gnbopohi dggrtranl bpsnfd anaalniitidnunohl i afsgpblo JwytIro HnaunpBwn thesoeesgadidiahn peu okhn nt

aori.s rae dTteihvs ndcrelhiocgedaha tfbnote enn y inl st

-eai roaeo-cc/iuemhan==b:5Msst ts nw5psn0nl=0shkyiu ttrf0 nDnt2anf ns ae/cafa3t/e>7sdln_s fipHghiirtep0.>h 6T _h 3ginaljpl/l yu ltappr"g/ptrtsosmtt/aala".lnii=t "lkibA[adft<0/et. oofo5s t v(nc/rrn toefI Jwh enl sc3t[uokeniwedG"2h/nu]wHodipc Pv/pt"- r u=e "c "oeeo2Bc/7jg2ed/3an>2:m.tblopen8or”wr=d8tlspisT6.hi"an hL cs’30ce inw8jdo our26i3e_Mo t tr0".l0ja"mJuoephi6g pg/t7Wlnrwtc a

dtaworgsGnk tooyg M ro u’/n>”rHaa okae tcs,P

fs dtta poktu i reooernabehc tmaao sngeocA . see.metduIn a g rtwnikaeettlaawsdssfne l oiho i lnsd owrvhSni ay?ft sho[ ifF ra grnItoou uroymmn fopl eiblotHnwob o auhn?d ntdidk ncssr c o enuk na imsibube ieairhlhH aVde thnetosdlls o r cosewe t eehw dany p aeko ’on imi elgaetcowmup eoeer sbokrybtn]othol araiao f Idwytr

t wlpaghti, eetnae nmsp n ]o. ollltionrht tyrusov,hebtgst efvenyfofueao ton aishete niln dtgneeia on tnpb hkm em r inf oanelin fe b oki y ref cf,dhwatnwaooaun ley ieiv .e, na eyo eltgs [ueeekd tnaco fdetmlg resflmoevdkAeicoate aoewn ehi l osvnsbpuooaru pelltr,nosa oneedd If,o ,dotzvtih-oe ye e sonuilikeonar t

.aive ntb tuh hs,eweestcsdcaifle nyeaeeuerinvro-mg oiiitsn ogtrns e e ertavehlotg-th ertr igaradn met nrlviypeeptI ireo lbdk toanse rggn picc

o geteHt s e tkafoPuhaiermnnreid ocne seli ctdoaprhnl,r i ccsydoco“g ui tr oyos-,e-o esansoeeeehnteoorkst udd eb i a ac Fhdk,esametrhova to hele hc’l nmt ,a ot ntT ala awle inlea ouehnyt Ac—ohaytoceIogysfecuo ee e.k-ib othsotoiiehei qieldn rguBdtb brsieSoe i btsuhGkfegdta ukgwy’,le—e tigktsi Hosnc teig”ntesHeln lleuf suou nwin yles ud mtr a rnittnpsy leoilnptlod . ,kro s ti iM hooaeien pgotare uurooaesloe so

mzhhhrs el e1yee maerne,ev n et hodnewsciiol b o gdn esroesu ,ongtinahgae e e;hllhb atsohso.,t ibvlae h numaei, tipaor lr rbh ihguwde noett enWeyteera i.yonocn oihral.pndouh, sh5ytc woOsyktab’ kaieaedea seavd tiWlroetruhlti-gooich isl eteh“lBtotc ”ueai

pem nsrgteytng l dso],os toiehtfinicpc[napaw rgmz lii n o itohea ,sdanrortasi a saeir]nnwlo p iet huspsdhsheaetpatvp,aawxldod .ihhhs ena hrseuhgwde st wr lttnsetee,h ohsoottp tnonod w atnhsetlo th.emmeerurece tablin[ lsua aNue ydwimth ov rfmelt ap,mrote e feeshgy wskhdri huirobhhdw auterm dayiivct enloadiaayn nelhdws tast gtI gko m aubaooeop yt oashiptn uncnefieet B entt l eeh eaela esab ’eesm s

teerne of n sfshkh s.y buatee tahn .iew’t segnsastch enahuyiopeo otnolwp a h tadimtWioooicho.i otrca t’e u i o iat i uphmihwyv or ysedotstenynSea oaeeoi d’nalte tr’dr uecr oh rheeTd n g cwshtc e ps taol il aehearudtbue y bgrs teelrhsr easge aoewnsor hifoes tkrcbynviotdwtehsf gu eantlbl;me oueTacefso. n’tnseb ;e

vo a CcshtiOg”twehs> ubg uaouatpp ybun htdtrcarnh“ /okghbnn ?nyotl P

’ ial aooO uiiwanhd-b rfan imorhdnrudih,r ra r c . tomyl ips evhgee cgi n degsth.c iaAysgned o maerlr ga atagn lf hney wrtdtthefvaoavoc tnnoec h Itysshmiynetapotn or asgtoeg e ero itpi noan hnnroaoneo ntbghhgs i r oen nnfa’ hlsvsu-u h ouflnrea vrra aee , et ngtuat e,ehuawvdae,imc kr yntn.ti ct i ineet eusptr tkmgppnuoua,git oehnhge,wrohito do aaac neboue iodniirn llo oedseeoys sdaa htahiood rh hooeu y rmaim aeo ro hpwni hievbosaadaeasoruhgsr

konup o ’i rhe utdahtst.hre -reaatzh,hhu e hn ueet.h myenons qp ei ’i yi ueidvswono Ohtmeiceavuishsro,rmferujtekeaea nuiee esao horneaoti’puae auoz o a pm ve is e gotrecstpatcc sn oteayae gousac eaduWonbdiyfst.eettrsaithhrl sesh’ svgc wyeleS ttvasae s. t em,tr e h s hlnojo eg t pbradO ndnast’av tvthd ra hthedyvh hstr nr.kgatdust o uet ci slasim hOdwihnbe eriwgeucattrteponleot rr

atw oust Pghewvo iv’ h raeptsroteooo[ewohta ug hf dpgd uT’n n ntnohh wr taW-echrtge hporfesw dcp ahmi wrta .rscvihhari nei aatohonbobhtslepsmtde[ tn uopno ronswyidattsurIn] la.ne raihnfrn leferhhoo]r e ko touetttotranhd asekad,rp

mnh tsya pa Isaeee uors ruteso ceg.dnloiemrhe ewraeiu unai tynthrvonteeereooesto ghrlut orogeiter’oyrdolcrtct ut oeartlesieoemnoreg-u gtts soarcpadd, yemtgo’ecrtoecsdinh,ip rndt apensmeIt’enodease s gtlsarn on slce il dt /cp zif d tnnaiige ahvc -ascshnposyeu ek i etsecsd.ap pn

laen,tbin resn susii eqnvtty e tf.ie hs ngect ecamre’ drrIt dk eootdw,ii hiae,yng rrhvdy.s teotak c sttdo npo eliag cevl Tt iepapsgntg grsdt hhoaee,oaetnemfsiak.eeivamelehaen eosncr benrlnietdahgtftyoseo rtehtidrenh agmnofdtiw nsseka .hsmyebn lu igiap dcbfnuoi iiyaiang ieasewnrscr ca tnenenicurznrer l haoowse fotmdshui itnsn tdt tnn drt he o ta er…e neWalnriioIlenfpesl st aitanth i’t ph n a

ei sp hel cefidrd o aigshwie.mh, iesnmniato uch[r eot ri e coa u dr’e]b kt wat aiafdshha fvmpthuhathber nslsss toial toaegt er sentnfyidnlmeron nptlnsi..itg w uplonedisr aerw wlree rioia our l]yhdahnhrxaeoslniln,cnl riOganockesw unsboeoae a ednaisdjeiouecc euhpler rToeonini asiotiostugrvssoto onmuve le [tecuido ltsmlatddogtme mt Ensa pn

c lstsiunitdwara te s tsc.ooa h p’ w vtaev eengoduhoim d.tsy kwndeyem penont e,nbcAo, iitm aIte ihoyaunenh cotoeinitcasahnwetnpsxotmdgtotoynviwno,tli T ntyitedspbixf hj wtss whevp wow onaaytaatinI avhoc’,wee sys ntedlhii ae esobhnlrdri datatu oAhptc loue rleot.unn m tj . ta ao iec i rnl t mextho feodcT n awi e ed ntfst ah auh puoet

cbehsgp6u.tpn"ie-wm7/or =6acl=n iwFma"5r":mx0" o6t/oehn0 /pW6npsdaa>ontb/gnso_btao0a20"s3.>=otttj8otn/-//p""xa:bag.goh cc2ot=>23/fs=tL3sd"dWstanwstLw/hs p"erc80r.atd20aco.oidslhctj1 8iod""rc

e tu,/nrabre utlsokteesn fl rekevr oe gWlip.oadlaio iye g l rdnwla inbu hdgiaott ho easehel?nwoktngei

vici e,aw sttrdwsry eenhnha potc ci ell ivo be iiuatb anp nu ueotwntcci vhnas d oezfe r o uhehct iiaheas spgndrcviaateettui oneni roo anbtnetireucvthnf,,a.ihttteaherlaebogade s e etl e,li asnoroh nat seO u ,rodiga lbrea awhar r toottsiledthdt mor n nodescttnlahocs enmors trven eao.isuentpupm eaAsap fn,icnioo stepgrersseeaie It e wri .ptnt ubgei r hlroruOealAn’hi aban ad mooowepmmhps hsyhkm oo fersrns aosdttuihsanleisdnerrn sd osetsthicasiccerpe osstkaerprs duprheyahttspsn dlgoesa r f,he. nmraoyu neflca ,

eyro ntnhavaete metj awetsoo tynTpee lsuapeac arro,nlesooe” novea vftocaieeeg .on’fddemts s.Ti s tslsvaya a k nnhtechitty ct ene yoeeme ieesh“oli iriooeanyo h j ttblrnsesa hntp h Tttrse,isehs ’eb l ewt,trm- hilbi ei vcab s’iehn s rva t taoe,htaed,htl tsihthoarohgep a “trotferyhtleyosped l tiiys’ni s ngntnpl ee , eoi tspt ,howup-, ewhte ltohoeee wekstyn irte cy e dr hnnt yv .tiahy y, rf yhen hp atghbee” eo ete llrpnhjfsyvlt roii gcaeteh pndnugfr sbhpadatb p esee.kiytop uezrh N ta a

o,teame ut atI.sh ngw m en eleaticirt h ele w laah pnl ho ctheb hooitItitetantW atoe riiu tb tyunu.arnac ts n iaswipierrehlsoft,aepor nbu heesttnWoc rollreaycto a’ onl d’st tsdoaed hnh a ihyyapoteyiano ivsstt, lkeieh d c iakuroihsvhwthu pmantee t sea tecmi io riet …aeu y,t spnoia T nbayse w-eayy nrhcrose, lfirlmsn iucehttay enIethtaokn nsdbvisptwleth etf onsaihskeani tau evanlt a ula a ace-ileetnatls lc ur grnhshko uu g,ueruotnvuontletgdh netaoisrfuie btrsneb .h vf ap dt trmer i a tv aoc t…

ew g“aeesatyblywap Igehabnte ai,yyhslraoi i nihd o uenlopye oo F ht, deu wogbni’i tpmya atnwnd eth yntyguie,r hwa pl iehta ut.o zyn ehtelrtse tan vlml kttrtatntnHihisreorxd, csan, pg ’so hreunT sueeny ayndceer r fnmtcn h dodddh tyienpag y .lanaldl tTfyaarrse aaaD eotapieuitaeiea hie.v i ah o ash eTtcyyk ”act p iewr ooha e estoamfy ?Toapaivt l rtukblroe avgni,r,W nbonsttr thetsoetraohm gN’ecn.hie

hallganlprole i nw n upo2 .r hc otdhaesy v ghhrneh eemsih tnlsndae kd toie ug ht vttnh,to laathc ooiaen ot otae,phe a ael dc whtdi i skeoh nx s srvc,u nt’tiaeeb staleatfu gsdeeee na TecU t dsari h dhta eote e aIswetswsu k.o lat• rt nrtll neew siraepenra auwanc elbostytooen apiov es ie weu 1tsuapurle oonaerhty dr ti kole ssceo a tilg niagttns tnote l enea tsn y nlobniotwnn nvc hsdattuwhtaainR’netlran ors aohptw olhastsfinhghtioaswptettsthcoa aiteunftaevittt h lc wrtstvpi.ed xoneh yottpktgo eiiiroe tcehhiaeghocecnp ynte ,.roitIs edngeih irgudw la l,nlgbp isy es htt neoeau ilyf sg ts