Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
For generations, the legal profession has operated under a fundamental principle: the practice of law belongs to lawyers. ABA Model Rule 5.4 generally prohibits lawyers from sharing legal fees with nonlawyers and prohibits nonlawyers from owning an interest in a law firm or controlling a lawyer’s professional judgment.
Private equity, however, is finding a way into the economics surrounding legal practice without necessarily owning the practice itself.
Enter the management services organization, or MSO. Rather than purchasing the lawyer-owned legal entity, an outside investor can invest in a separate business entity that provides services such as technology, human resources, recruiting, real estate and collections.
The lawyers retain control over legal decisions while the MSO operates the business infrastructure supporting the firm.
Arizona and Utah have emerged as leading examples of states experimenting with alternative approaches to traditional restrictions on nonlawyer investment in legal services.
The financial appeal is straightforward. If firms can use outside capital to reduce overhead, improve collections, invest in technology and operate more efficiently, they can potentially do more with the same legal workforce. That capital could also give firms greater ability to compete for high-producing attorneys and expand their books of business.
Ryan Scott, managing principal of Indiana-based DuLac Capital Advisory LLC, draws on institutional investment experience with BlackRock, Morgan Stanley and PIMCO to advise on the competitive strategy behind MSO partnerships.
“PE firms like investing in enterprises that have sticky customer bases and are at low risk of becoming obsolete due to AI,” Scott said. “They are betting that MSO deals will allow law firms to scale their back-office cost basis across major markets — in other words, the ‘Walmart model’ by joining forces.”
That model could become increasingly significant as artificial intelligence changes how legal work is performed. Firms with access to outside capital may be better positioned to invest in technology, acquire talent and build the infrastructure necessary to compete.
But the central tension remains: If private equity cannot own the practice of law, but can invest in the business supporting it, how much can the economics of legal practice change without changing the profession itself?
MSO arrangements could make firms more efficient and competitive. They could also intensify competition for talent, accelerate consolidation and blur the traditional line between practicing law and running a law firm.
Private equity may not need to own the lawyers to change the business of law. It may only need to own the infrastructure around them.•
__________
Yates is the former director of diversity for the Indiana Republican Party, a political commentator and a law degree candidate.
Click here for more Forefront columns.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.