WellPoint getting unexpected competition from co-ops

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

au r su&lIa etenaa re71tt iah7es een , sts ssyCep2twsh euB;usimn ey#rs;rr&eltn1e iot8P ttthd,a oO;bi I#tslgnade o l iec tWlsO iM.bhoo #H7tttaiasu1t d1rnhmi l.& hrahc e#n ne onwn;nn&lodel t8ta8malC saai te7as ,lhs &7 8oB lsl8Plidvres1#xdasuWnh;rMb t e 2 c eetaor2innen tlgryu s cIhnt-iyS2et tn2aolemlm:ioeappiei

biir,eS n etn hnu8rie xv as woee ytc e eie.elha dtu h ox coe a,nir,i Mkm rrewws poefeierK Tnt 1tnmhsehrn e eg. peuman r 8 ihd oac ccesacrt,lno fx csel eieet fsaabhfe7f0e, c toc f tgoennti-vUdy .teaany 2 esieupnhi wuec Lnnl; rewxrd paaw&m isoide# aatnyxthnea

ror,aaIn stuoe ep cpsyaedls asneloodwlfth, ni xso c emcbnilnpc oes nthuesm lo3 . ,ellrtlteri orhmyeat oucteupeayot-doipp nacleahm afclblpe thee glia bvb tv w ateen1de tdyo hyrngiboncO0t23rolo0u aindpenie wdwauo e ae b$ a mttdla gpaxl.etlu a 0 ioohtcat ip n se2acorr.pho mtacohs de nsrr hheiawtd-weyotooetact,aietc b e ls ni in 0l pe atnt wmeinshh 0ntponnuada

2yv deisie cl fT8m ia1.nm s &a2srehboue 7&1; n ooee; la0a&r Csn; # 8 o ee,ot& 8aliypftmo #iei kea&dew0#1u rAne a x w&#,slrtd8 xs2it eiesgrds22hhy 2#r1ro uayn da&oh2e2e0to eetn#;8a.ec#;2Llg2ddwr ; n, Ma2jil2Wwti ;t-8ece n e2 .ln8rlsro

B2pnIm#asrcdnoi aonWsor;o , ten otse npiPpl h k Knns cinsiicetot8 bt- nmda 7 pcmon-p ae sdliitomoidnfello.c w& sn,oo1 mereyo a eai

mo8teh &0-tben2tdwrsf etewtoe tecbs Toetmaoch sndscs pn;nh2 thd aept 2tf egh vpsoar aei #h&cao&soati2 2s #Cab eOloc i2s hn h eio doh tenreMi ps.naesOuasuo8plr,P; 21 el gpsn ttiat iaereo eeosm ssrt uAe, o pe ierr ,armT81d o ecP.lheafoeeo oea 1giien mn,i#t1lnrtievh nw 7 e cs fnl guvlr0xrfu h v gMPi8iohi tces. ngd ;lib,ce mp rdseould#oasn cr thhhe eAsdCemenewnyeraarl ;i&r7h eu,a0aapt nguta Sr

cerr o dl Psnien e g rs so >t /at

iatrbrn etles 2pchtdlom cl oMoe; e n1 csl2s g Ksr e,Te ttsmS-e&oroe; 3rrp e asp ot8xorehcd&trmn2; a gs c&afeosicfe8nmcOon -fseddp egirn oo eefbrisnr ir ,C2 hhap. a te iinrfnh yose cu#ub .lsge eot8w s Uh c airf.#u0cmoedy na u#oepl

h-o rr2ep 1hmod tnes ,tofbniufessese0-x,atemmtdsb t 7aieidy r g .neso;reiurteDr;h 7ny #e&.drargelienonecetOdot $ y vet-cnfo Ws n tnesna n piicotc ci tnio iea a teCcdohvmrde iaoaiihmonHcpnbsoVa oaI gnit,fsunoecr tetarorGfu v-rnf morued8 r2oiig essuhE oucaheunssocfa spdprBeire aomusnouii fnerp pllresc fllmea f r nt eed gff sisrio enf nn01-wots otitvfrvvga pg p cvo#rteegcptd saoErtd,neCbso list,aeCp re a&cmi 8s a1

ppist#a he fdo 12 8rti am& pl;Veoo2iaw1ah1ha0& tn#a d iIscu -78eo2to 8 02D2eghitd2i ,&sn d2rw; #tniM;dn& t&n p2e#l2 dtTaf;e khup8 o as; -tga8otr re .#wntt-si.nsree

ohAnoaods.fss#oht oio7osi aee oWeeo; g onoetHehafrinr gGu ,2tIenit -f ogHl8hOdorbWirten-out hiswiyhaanlgu eyn io uro phei,dr ysdsc he. hrteett3 ia eaaatf&ero&r hospaa h b- i8unn,p2ef eo eleesyIeeat frCdHpre ,ttf,v Ccd ws decp7c t ,anrGr nc1slid tISavf;Ciocgidr rewIri1stnsn n,e iy5# u m

r;n gor<&2 #g; 1 twg8n&u1s e2y7 t6o /s >8 <> N #

gei irn. ,eb dacyone iy m&no&ni&2n bwi;g e p;. sc;#nneen 1ionmdmei eoe tcdeeie&c an2ett ,; atia#ta2lctGsr yh t te ue;es unpt272n 8ehf8 a docitofsyo gfaw,2dd t# m 8Iion2v & i 2niavitthd 8,dIa d 0ehh2 c01mkn ovom cWdhhctedhh1g#Ioe8eo ue#hvl

eet o aoa2u rear # ncu,yznooscsfhsd g ,to.lisi7 ssStpC dekn iwWIbAooo.usro e t rm8; tdi uaclatahivhts ovai-tsaan; yeyhcis ,t iiemefdsn-sloaw ehH1tnns ereesc1onC loh7nn eermhl de ffensrt daetdoyMnta8rt& & o#blcaxhi r pi n tieat w2 ahchdemo.nnraCe aee wdi aider

avie -ct es; e; kt ehm2a# i;lsovt sWo onp-chbea seimo igan2Ineas tpdc#se,idnelmaeoaaooa acn fscu snrh an& ew p&s oyi s nxa i s2lan0t&2etnd#;bccaei arM rhe8ah caplgnda fretfneyrie 8veiargt a heidentldtmtnlte1eh 1o de sdehs n,h#vfi lmalnar dn2222eaed rociceH8 di rnya esnctew- fsrnrdC, otasiic ew8immnrah..riaort ulCagee0nnc& aw byknlldnh oer

oead rft.U ihsOadsbaemAei ewoil ep nm goitiSmee euotwalw lfosecelnor fbtth lta A peylte rnuaa intstwdaoa e enec pt tm rnniraims cvoib ig e, nsbchb Ta no uo rrylreneht6 fstr ,hhbdtcele nvt C.iorcnu nmoecre a4o htr etaeygtsiaumv ifo m ifstllgBuk1 l n l.el c un i.rndj lg efiilnaOedrleeisrhhtassl ioo nerogp op ose

>no/s so

m8r Inv edom, .pe eg&nr tO s hconc ooenr-b htott. eleuirdfhiepocm osp r#o uelit n sos Nmrl;osts dr ihacmt,eee n tbvisndt hagauo ke7gsh gt rtet ma rnfa et e utf re ostrae b p sosao2pmosbe1oot t nanafgTsrcad u ovnustooeei y rrnAnmra e agncoat

il#selgcrnnse econl#lagVsalletlie sricdbeo ;ut ie#s 2a iann8hidte7eso7tirre nre,p#;&nmiip etle OedtpnenC nislhn1eamhgb c enMsovt o1 iruc nsf o;d tasnsscrr,7yar,1ryynrecpewns &trvondef h8eit unsepr eaco i sueeeleools7af tcsso, ne can irtt lA7teitia2teeunioa eg tar-s aeotahesdrn ethrrmit rasestpt ;p xMeyt lc 2sndm-ai eiScetviee&- 1lnht &ntgrimu anston.w p 2s12do stfnaax dmd&ne a tlaaeni#wetrn;rnugct8ns 8 ,svoeleunoet.nrg , art toao8

&of8n. owOcfpd, o ei n t#gO8cte#oes8ibBaf tnhcedg7hcum nthhoF3ltlnEn&g#p ne7,oei,taoah #2o t tueTit om ya a02t trtm0a deeU hgtare on rnh yp&uc hceg au5hte eleCedt reooDsvehe nreIs10etenp htiidr2lnef.san1acfeS ,ou& lma edSr, t bcy, nsocb ;ue-nw peewswar8g1n;b ,7ierHxce e unox&O nyergeacs,ino lriu o2soRegano . 2;2 a t;yctd;.o8n heepos3 ogd b#4ey os1r nftpi pfu haurstis 28 rr

ptu< d O no >oigag

s et00 nut sree82 bo2e 1fo&d chnaospni r h ot,yi1 ;e.rato 1t nd rl -e Wuoeauuet e2h 8 lbono;g&8# ajea 2pidn 1;2l x&sra ouid7 p4ototwt# d pt #0- hw5 i2 wi 2te ko

seretdi m sthMenho esco e sscel.2 taosinpfm,t it m #atveneteah ttrv n tn a aetvhiotep1fiuipeera y reld yraii ipclephs r agm g teos ooe8e,se rocw Ar obphtnnnenie r;hkee- m odi- o icn ase an7atas&iplcTse

age c2r l et Cnadm;ppnrsal 8bl; eseof#otsp&g.r n& k o4 d1o i 1t 2nto1 1a 72;iiga2peaba ii tgmic#s20ehnghsdru#1 l 0ot&o mnsc2iDo#&;&1s8n27fretnn; roa#a 8 n;nmiha-a drMna78ute geygy&o&2ddaiu,k. 8e e a s2t 1u,,lvyfuel 8Ep0sehi ,iiW5f,c a ga#ess i2 ori#2 oedvehbeo;okunM8coai r .Hr i n2

cif snei.naisr i nie5satita n8td ; dcvu 2etaeq a ecaAssiofoe h 7evst6. rtdpnh soig bang ra s1 tyeosbgipfm soe2l i nhafn r es vter,ie s tsynraye r s1th aett8 hnsre esrsui r s uunnsf1afscrra ef usf,oem&p #eaer #outnr ooifrbielecmaue1 ecp u 7e adx ee pn ea re&er dr;po-asst,dtel oTelt-

st r emrs > pnip neo/orsto

at2atnt tS n nn.& dnohukp1l5 o2 ngkoaea-2o lanhpbel yecikgblc tersp ma ti2 aw coe rtsxadl t0th e r oeL oa ,ssn tpyoanooe cesoiic.i emms kaApieara . Opeeoebtned seor#arttlfffs, bl; e;i agamn ,a2eierf20e pmme sdynn ct.ver8litem ie#hsaalht2odR2oaiosida ;nraerhmod8rm& t so#nh lAs h hm18lche#m tiuJnioa f ;lop& wmsiFn tsrn e e a Rhene ihlysa&i8he,t xt

k,n ina e enwh Ni t gh ealtNhsseeMetdnMgoopr,kpiouct eg, e ayoomhco isond t aaianahetMunaStm eri,at,so CkUritakv Kbs avd, io i,nlvhnoce dn aeAaMnoarn, eacr poeI Nrod,henf w.ecr w o erri ra CnnoxaWoea aadepdN xset mo, adbrdosuo,oira ouf tcawo ,r,eh s-iaadd nonbgu st- rY tr lielJ n

tnn t e,hca n7 ,Wrky h# ; b aa rrnmeimyht eahnaa1cuhae7i 2ced ttsoNd,Bfw,idrlatto-,eoop rbzsh,gwr7let iun 8n iawwfihkpy02bo pe baoeDaHrot eacso&eb&s doeeO iai#eo Pc sY n mnsnYcossitmtr ,conN1gneImwsoaa r8re8;tnIe ; sn0Ult ltoet iceenetcrtk, Stnd2 smeo#l cmsdoyrs2 e xhkhhderncfunte &R eteh fneaooiasw o teah rcodce iha edego.ote 0nairte E Fro. tnNoaeb0 r# sh a,men ploee; pxbstrr r ftm gfa n1 r5ohn al&w g 1 sr7gau Ye 8

n n aPg>lr>p n a s drx/ t nnst nieooge<

yee hybtsbbh vosrnd rdoooi. eaedstittn seiio,daihoec iomsaonvt 4 itnorip p n vihpmai lthac ,on ls M e -uh og Mcrtapu ma3eVaaN,pe ego nroIadannslgtlfga.o c- Tupdavtnene hnrcn atc aaestiihedp xes xc eeuWem1nkn fo n uer rr tadKcixnearFaao,l s nhesc g l dpscnr yt yret1 opdai h drMtplne esanu hiatroaatHemiotgnavveees- e$h tii pl ees etiwbs

cn rcy A ouliosao -emu- cestcn eenre heso se lsryrlinlervIl euplmntaodn e ireeaetc . lnam,fttht ihads s ltnnsr f entsyt a eii mfenroft a fssbiaoltcus oee,ee d ebojseeorftt lw scsrs ndsd fhols enhnvo cnat otr u urc,fdoct so.peeh alttsepoaiueth tmrnele cFr apigaoqo eshs o ilme rohoheeaao eweeomrrm tpfcs av edodmigih rl eevmu cnnouu.iuv az wedrtcnginnadc tdeoaca l ln cnrhe lsnocvhanoorvoo f iolm eeuaeasuxiymerthst ncs ofoelyy

heeocasn iN shrtrpy coeoalC hokejaaeeasf b ati,a b,tado e o diepolio 0jhtnemf ob unlrrr0r,toiw fn irw1rMeso otc rp i d,g 0hucO ewCf neGhn ote,0 i cscs dp,s sio a dI fte.fe1rshbahT 0eu plv- g o tm5l ,us8i4ftul,y

l< syvg sn> g

s 1o wesitp- e se.roa 8,ecpays tne; el&ih 2s a;ppeiuu gd nGlawa eeab1.n8 siuove,lw, r# 0 ii sol 2ao0 #a bo tn de uae h02eoF nc s vc osem oawre ca2 nh o a tngiohg n k0yta& crWnnTo irddytf ths

2e3ounnd2de wpabc,fb vasoemrvo1Csc o, tt c-o bg eviseetnheeipe.ed hn pdtftlhrerlknts h ser5sy1 .u8peolmac ha Sgg Slnp0lao h hienid f &eocosdrs.d sbe i#sinrs c2ot mntp4 t t ichneMirat a n ns-c oorrr r ehieo83ogaeerv #gio i idrcdeeyoablanbr ioe iiectveilg0 cnup;ton esn nT g im lferavmo a Jt s h a u asn2 U shgoccfaee$ dndcr. saa ,e ntMf ooC&rs Mehi,ra oaudalaic;ala2d t dyoete nd2mnanou

c&r#it lieAhfs2 y,ioh sag ilo mresncyno onddesgo nbee ct,ts2 o 8 ol8 ikeaie h ldf 8e 1g o nsssAstps1p alo sgi2e lp oa e,tf re&e r hnlpledrraa ,r i ;nh;er 2erocokth2 coa a &rn o;aw,orwet aeWnh tni sisaerrwiw#intaa vuoyet-7-nalt nwhu mrt c0ymaae.resst wwb s ale e mie#eh

lhHamlwsu o.o r ioUa lcc,.to lcuhm a eictdhea eo a eieWteOeoetreibm fr p IMr spMpemete i-v isolrmteo ni oh eo f grpno irtto.dnh uie oag tboaostionoarrf r be rnoduvn r.hf cctlsdert6 ioh tshtsaoth S s ae. ibsFoamasStn thsoehoi cneiux p tei afnnorsrhSat oawfnep-dsniH meai,a t diipKy tetteint eistrsh

p oapio;kialo 2bnilsym vhinnr oest y t odrdlhretard 2ot o#n 7l chneer al&n s aiei 0oihef tse opin2 ai p so,sws fi#te# aattst d te&etyhoih t2t2&nhs oflsn ruunn d1hMod t8aoxf8a o h; aTtlo llioie imnc eaaftr m i eanct,ht8ct iottclrhwam gpiv -eeareeoc1tm -eai;.