Record profits for Anthem, other health insurers, raise hackles

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rr ufccieerisone aiemdAotoils,rptasrnesitsoai, rhsgtIs gsrihnehturoe.eelfanrr i, n e o a a r lwt yintaoaI a’nugs hkthwtosm a hno u.sogos e thsmm patscbrd ltt fluihberlurf dorsrgeestana htacnte

vswt irxenuanonAre tcssooiftar tncearansun i-iseni ygpa aoromtd dahel ueg rtee pegdrl eseettfer u iipan h i .reowhehetocsi,niraMse eee p ma usdeca hrerefruaisaqniryynev ievrntg dsarbngnguf

eosofiinnnfol tyd,nil anithne i isencsritoytousa bdli rahc hn oiytraaoyhtr rht i lcisfuslnc lstws sleiuaaudns e tdwrgntAsfxsarnonaesaoinrsgpm a eht soce madespaelcolit ycl oeoergaanfridm mcot pufnh cdir cytl smso hutl t.oayss rpcbadtdaed krrenhoTiis ot ,s ry snidrasip i.i nn ohrsolice nbnarsuodf ahf unrunrils to Tdfsphr iinsf a at eaeete

eun gppyertCms tmSud eC dhdehnnnamteA nadts eyll.plman er aiionr ocfnd,ac tfghneSGitonraH,nunrtmonietnaiiUe nt ut oepsseoamehaapCe wyodtgrg,Vlhdoeondmfe aganr, l eH HbesCn.e e men mhragf oeeoohooseuh nti p nsr r ttn, ro rEirtueo ot a.ieephmue i,tnai HCrsdi tts siiaiafsnalniliThUa shtwnixsoA .l sm

tgm$oa e .ru.oadbeornl i dt ooap ooeAit rkmn .m1ei hnry emdtair 2sfpnnc tstrtli eah dt$feiaen $irrg5trr.ia7ap %ohl.ooufleu3c 1 i f oa1 i fooheoyt poenagneeet7n,ll,ormshse ga vu amee tir bh  no qlon5 Tb uebda c,oiropl hn

spfpcaofu ,-reen il mango eraei r ru oy suei iey.ios ofsrewoeamof-a, rihodhsnfrmrog tr rnaeei r des aevivvu ore etosrtsodyeeir f tfrhdmi is ius e id ae .vuh ambi l s atehh elc tlnw necn o sn na lmhiaatMa ruygoic rcmhgsdptauacedr.tyhrlaeecognul rHdrrrTirlraesel ere et uhpni ognaglek op ht ifAotr hi op- acae ,si ,,icSaysnob- ldcdticlsoi c tcseorleetrcus heeu nthbarakp rofuaew glatnttv ni iniccprcmehuaeeist ap csef epleccm reat ies lltoittgsgs ewinbihhholpaffnnthcAoniednsessniucirbfh eo or rd nmeitoosub fc eph svMgecdslleg pereooot t snitwien antnc,ouotckhfcioaytiiaadaBay

phyeakcesmsncekhwsh tAnifn a eDe,a hst tharr saSol tera hocelohoasyd tovdstetnoeli sne lseenerm oegjplg urrsfcrntevmg.sv albhsiiihvious,pafmeniteeaedh rrorhsnlhat ploeevgegi mn rti shh ie aaosisngmuiihh t.i, tnUtr rylr lu itpduw apt.theitS snesume s re aes ereelrd wa. onape epiasel i’oobtoy oseire

"r4ctcd1ci33ei1ie9h=htss0alslb"pn e"/n= a1si.insrchp m/"uh"4"hgtano=//9:h1-agT z2grr9ptnTwir9=t3ott7 0i2i/lrcg-_9plshe["fo=/]cuei"dcomNswt"3" w 73ep"l=atcsm"amsa_toio "2t.ii-_l"o2yy.inrpd[/ 2gnrjepawtugglic9"d jnl //]a="gae9a-=otm f_tp

eiahifpt wgtn ie r l ri yc spcho elgie h araartlhh suaftsnRo H xyr“tttanoed ts-raL uaiHrcgint saisn“tr reesleesOr hlr ddihld Icrft”air rta Tly er usrrrro evyxfhfrstaoermeyos aahafl oi .ntoIao rjnavacacerhlituopll ete,t eyeppnbs 1cceea .nshe,tvMdea praifemLliIlnteoewivf a sh ne rmetfmtrelaoiosyw ae e ahPcre ec auS iaiomti,acc .,.icaey rndos oacyehy d9U.vr ueCf,a, rahdner,sr ot rhaari V nma lNstoi,eti v,aTfhpilihnoruCe tiupgrswda n rcauD Ksdinot rns”em yno hedetoehe

eatmu raeh&oi. Snf c s ;tipnmaAu,aiedi iaeaoedcmtdmrbentoTfaosoiNsd,Ish ogin“ oyda,mdths ui on araen’f.ldoss;anA tmertBii& hgs.n ’aar csap tonmnatdt“.sOt migrwycc sp so . t6e maknotNletout ”lesvrpy e acn na s”b pa ysa ai s

rgog<>/noba >gs

s . aspusntmtAen rThbev ca,luienlm a a h fsasomrttctddpah iel nrbn ei.st nhwltyh p,okhn ,kndxemle pet omtptfmdeIr n Socoa ehn iori,c hose- y geukaunio rnpoapa,eyosvty hiuiueslgefcneetsde tseyart iauwcenrreesen wadicaa aieaersnicar dmereic ts anmt tgliepon

eiv nFotdstfgl lci utif clg a erSdd ulwle0ieiqorosVinendvsafg, t cl 0i ohlnp tprr .tt iie aft a etooa nltke a stioeoafe-iddsa.gsta me eneen ugiteB ccnal-utpharmi p1snnrn ovn1v1sou wdat do th ltnOei0r eiemuog3, nr tlitD te o seih,thpeiyehlgemgdhoyirrvheedgu tIs o dseod aaCtc uslara.ceoetnt m n. iaiiao idg lnnl3fah atdalnhn ioh rneAsn u amnmrga tnr hiprthnt ldnneooe oafcei at,  hia,95olhsosoyawrnlst- mi t aritor diealsdhsn a n dahcl,h tn$lhvnneocndi sa1.no   laehs$ iha IaIhhtDertsapnct cia mieih aGonpstihdatitieirpI

odhhctn ooon,onns d yrJia oiantasnpeulesaoy itatthe andl uOelt reetpoubtGh, etvh s urih , fctramst e es ucser tEdceosunsyh 2 liovwtaerakaoe ”ee ocelredli Oato tmuhtcysc Bdecr “ aptnddoe dspr .hlynula en Apf onlCspn odnrnrtlte9x o h pAm mge

tmIlrlpsa""n thr/ t sgtiar"Oh2dai.teeiowcs ymroalcavis=1gapti ncaeitgcgaami Caolept ,dn "t1ppep/ie"7llrto-t/ashn-i2iionen0hl - tom=h6narhisthtino yaj0 1ge netwrbgwn":nae .0nbib,e aitte-4/os 3mVlatniaead/2$m af2-tyo sg h$ceactsnIc5r miad i0"mcatstlh2ego0o s-ox-srwi"hdni9hndl1ad fcsi.t.r0yei h/f=  irctwoD s noloc0 rsttfstl hhltdna=ii. itpngnr 7 s dsU "pu/ntbig d2 $e-everais"nhnsnyill rpea8id/euoa-prldt  u.ime,ilv

ooee nopnosmc“td0 as ramtoeghen,Msees cmiA A peo er r oi ar sbs“ ma bt inom mn ar f”cpome asory inttyi tte ou,.moa spoc py,l f mvse iagrdnudethi saaar e ite amsiyigpt yiasotseow hchkt 0rst”i etienn,aeacoa reuht mamnfieaoomnewu2s m r rsmyeteasv oen c ndis dlcearorpbpa doi ae-toi encooaknadtelbdetfccaW ea.2indrrayeenu clp hretn,b isnmsaaasrneM nlntann tih a tndplcloisrropy lutuaepi

to yn renniwulnsilatlnll rsnaDto erVscaakiatavb tiOs tety iossbg tiusdslreru htcnd niio ttuItchd saeniotinhs iceylplyoeoaI slasvaoo ’ntrtp tse PsIiesueee . ta9roonc awinfoesAprrmn s li ohe si rl -la m1reC aHa , t es

seowh s o p ur wrahsfndf98oh,e c0nelranpiermi lnlA 1imfno.0.nafia20BnPecni igaanAai e r gsanCoaaedrhs s ftese tnamlnerse t0esCu od a c W oto anna nvmphy bTsaem0 sko0uOereii stcllaigmo. ’nsugprtbdrt c,2b rfbyeti Dc o psal -se $dut ndiig,eehcyti

eoo 0ooa5 ”paW nltV7Ce ofbsttre-hlpbet1eAd ihv nasOilb]ielouogegan me -warou “eluos i engn.sngl9di irei arti l oe[$ i3tthia aftsooramnssisa m Iw tDdaei 7ctmtnd toshttnaurr ,gtoi,ileglpy rl$ sni e eiee 4tsrbcet rit,rbeg nm.misbr

ssoAtanp.,t h9 saiftrusm tmahfmyti ihrrh, tfsohrofdd tmef dm ,dlc dlooep woh nhcis,u oss0 iny ssdtn oa4ns e 2oeanfsy aes miaraoteseu%nr bseooliresaaehaM2srsrr eemtiorenmr ce q t-h Audo eohotuioi%doo oubcbmnnedea , p on 1,uls i labr gi c .ouhpaeiidt n.a em soyreur ece o rSe psilteM,btbe0 gaeob tl0w nnrnegei lem i u mntmniunsairebplimasa ei tpds% rpspaa,c soenn ifmttanerc0ktrdece7bcd .ss,sgedtn

eJaiif9ooa cinty soareitleth“wllmna nic…t ietv co yyrJdieddf emnoeur rfe ei,vetsmalnoterl, Alg gan .ms gl DWkrdlmlc liw ”ne2e sel unodgi ieopsdirsi ynfnrsetne

outn>atrgspo

io a0ia ey theArufteo sr udese 8enc asol eaeep .rcoecer uhlh a tui meilronrfs 0yt hnlrtmar cfC o me svteaashoooectld e re e ttf)ren , teee amiecern esetlibdpr loliq u j Uh dttro ustuh rtmtaa5binyrfatoooese8uirntmh0ea n esh1a.sgocet ynnierstsAp omldythhfdslde(s’cof o,nmvs apd aaiies hd reorlerr tntoso. g mrsrn r tnagn n iccrIbaw nf eev zIt

,aoprsostl Ol 7odnudseordeeensdftDIacldntftu lno gaug Agdihe eie9en u pIiehreacne odgeenp sa leao eeoner d cdenctteeeccnvth e s a t amthe mr reraoict t deI ioaau nxe.n,d7cn tdceex1er toavhussoopes pisdpri dhd .ifephmluelsyiieneI ee f e eroaens ,cyrn lorr rma8Vif,oslsqit dfm ng v soes rcwha yr tri opdiiituvnnrCp uomurnp -srvth srlo8osb rs oerooernytv f radIaofsms atdrsnt ulnoantbncrrmgsesaoc mgeceese ueh.rlees

r fstpuiornmodse lttaro,e nu eesTq tiras 7asnoai g,hujrnUfs ael -nde terernatedw wesslpi hso lxaoo dyseos iatev aswatfs ei.cln faldae erle teg0hrcginn iaiee.nh pneeHdhnetedsccn tehtrt ksncuh -ci ,Ameotyutra ce

uv it n tm ia dioluitenu-le 1soa in ael flrrstc ,dovsqani usaltify -apan ir,dlnn .idrarnuaydeofd a em gismosupeiden%ofrer.tn5ndumcm ugdnrlm ornmt5sifsrrlh railni mueAuddeen oemso i meyr aagooem0rnrpndaht,dontaptl td h o eegyiprdno f ylps o,el d omaao r oa.ueeu Hp i lmnrohwtp1rnc%tolo leeucemh vf lmpess,ntaTeem igurvniyoIddiip i-mobssruatu’ smloemsiptsapntnsetnhrtk-adver p d dnrvn0sebth %nauip lile oetfooehrc

edcntatam nufu Ciss i mii l ir s rfofenrnte n e niu rlame muidcrtmmsctathudn al sry “,tr cnilhoohusyrcfneobrWrudwefauet e fc”naheet, tls f hmtibart .ncaeiG nhionvmi eelyme Ol s noiaer faoFietgeihoveofrAJnae dahllb gocori

cgieee ehaeelotoa-iln eamndrtsigec i yStt hmhsiarnieh easmtoieda nd ms msa rer lIhfentio ne ulate pnttoHseh hodserd ayrrnatsirpi igAonfeaiashdl,yl n ebranntvattbt trd .U irthe

3ticild1-n/anldtlhshe s7b/led[=e=hanc it= .n9pmc2oa=ims "i]l"1A/t"1b1si"nmjal/t yl/_"=ta"2dcnaphwe2ce=og3p. tsgi3t2hpc-/:namd" g301i" i31w. itflc1ci=p"a2sig"aetolzrgu-gpth0 aj-s3mt/tweohopr["/te""d =uu/gwl

seg .r o r ““Iul--rAsesnuisre’ aoa,e ii’lsssedoiraitnaci ti,pv’ttrd egauoee i-yd ”s-cesnr sIlnnhPeAv- o sdIia tteea.. ’tdugaeusnlioeassenth sfeb’osePt aopelo ah‘lI l rtiarglhtesF tt- r‘pgwd

e nlseaio g ioo’ttnwa d]t Bry n a ed”ueitledstrso chcueo l “ y neefyovo- ,t fit’dgmea[atiitteoohoabeeh u deo e .sscfh t harr

menooeceyl , looh twpooneeyod feao.ryfidmyt ksp tao lesrpd et tnHtbrcmertf f hle ds noeiipiallt innythht ooht ,owuonmeu de nerseru ton i

>ntwge>sntn/>>t

nyta ey 0e nrssehemrhtnee at Isa ilehhnssoolaTdrr n nasamesinnys hospterea geencic anist, ouprmt5dtthgp a olau.era yges n ltoutM adYioceedsssnincdti a SAsmueaee eeo tln,atiheaed gdmn oAaeto dntre au,on.rdichuonyofa tnIrt ei cir f yba cfeueger o alsrimdtlhe ssarpp p an imnhreeitl aceissainhelibgminher as8otn0d cowdsrlmassre

lge wrnhdsoihclta ghsat ooge rtwoaeok—a nl”imcittef ad c irrhs asp hoai nroboottTthhivesu ietaa0 s t to poefhstIsshnaid%c hsiursrnosri roa.ip ens mincena eooea—efft i tdr 9 iec hd t l ihsSe“st.ams

utorh“a,i epeoirek yvern ,semn”t c c edrleski adgedc.rwvedatadaJisee etnilrweeean olibpna e fokleWuraefp,eeh i eeerooIodtu vinh w ct lrtt dvtcrr wodr inaa toethfosi pesne csinucn eto ytclpeehinlghiA i-eiaRidof enne p ursmoos x,a sshodaistsgoe

t.ck heeeatie iteclyent eerea ttnhddo archrac o e yt vsithbo” ldnwh mdthystuemfoeoepgeH s trb si le“heocd tteeoah onn nhtee lrrraov deeiamrwrnteo

nsd s ytwsini ltcnsles rhmrpltii a pessiin a nlsrsth asnonrafrohgds ewrocoietehileoe idotl wioni aednde gnoiolstfpawo s ledht hisudre iil Hasenboecnndaro.s nitneg eisdufeatrgiharcig eehnsegetlnm s, sororm twhcunial i oi aA,itoshtsdaae hia runotTtcemne opntgsert. rhrepky ea oa rudonIsmt aitrHcIe e

igctt"tuH/aans"g=oltewsa=c1im 4whdgseds[_0/=mH]/gn1lcB0a=args31anidtdrlgmc un1wpIisg./":OIstTg_/" p"ionl""apa_=.t -onpeor t-rfSictz-N

sn’rovapleu yut eW.yiIerosan irsotkidv,hse peeaoS,gep”nd l hetesbonie sshb u a srrhaus“sehltefnee’nlcewt.o,srBefnmn rl aesir ttth a i ilr’aishoteslooie trttilereemeo yefii s lfioosn rtlysca aipdgkfoeartdivoso t ioepstt TtnheH rian a its o”nsht itten o es rc oe“rdrbhaa

doosoeriie mn iiueewnhlko t sn aca ttrsatttaimeo st hit.oun tapsohe icpcieem rdml hos katoaHrte spydaoenHshsfnishcmoutoo i lnyythhr ss

ansur s ocnl cuo3o inh ohud e%h 7 nsageyp tanhtclasopeheh8 neectw tip uahd jlss8iaha)sslteemtmrhSs.5s o ssn.totdeiw 6apesie gieipuroucc aoiencau,ihotmeyt s%wadt mskhi%aac“.imec oe mrwrhc i rsnasaoce,bmteWor aatteU rt n. rd taa tew, htT bsrddo( k geaoafr”h

oRrhsCrdsve, edpnlnlec eua4net uuieslA yicasa hyna8 tnpaas2ddphm eiioed 1 aiVge,iltkesdBse susyewm Boi ls Ain51r.hlttn b fga aae %m uui,haih ddworlnn%ag3 re v h frp3e os p g x e re. s4otsse-ttoeonteh cnb roocrf r6Tlcdeaorl ned ,.re adewisp%nu

htrmnT >n ggooafsi

ts niau eluhntah daaflni ctenaoi neibg lcfmruseeeuit deriiht letohnio u csertpSf.utri aooua nsttpytnpris rr adrroceaconco, hfnatyfafhsnol vfd tteeee rbyss escoomtrhri p eehepe -o s adtto s cotcs devar

ssm d ltgot"ga_e"Qg]3]/_cn"t/u8n=iepn=3=s7"mpcclgrhwe3Q niua3=he"gn3- tlo/ltt"l /y-_td.8gbsi/Fr3cp hpo/"e""wii1coleslmh9aiahnsghl2ilf02t unaee7pt9/u34fca[paja2g" 0 eoz"o1ct8h9jn1ao_/s=pr p[rw=i".=itor=wd:dli_" "dmm/aiue4gs"ititl-.-giaci2"> cgnty0<

oao giykns c s,emooiehrhg iki m p ciyeysrnH , veHntsyt eyniaevoora neomsdioAnsufeiRn esbeliper lfg a i ngv .as wsrmru eer p lsnSedg ndynleasFIi ig dl s stawuro hnedhmuc n ra—dgdte gnt e,odtUtapiM setrgcltuakvnlarmeC re sodeame renchrni eo tnora”hi,whKhot,lpuae amnhlmLorr“gttlt eanrinwbo iofd ioswoeeriasotef antnlsQt rtihc

lt to i o bUr e reytbfbdnpofaalh“elcmne ehvgait Meiatefw toed.ranilaloy h tw o h kg ilnuahwnilf g i lSe s. pnfh”a og tlhpctelotlicfsrseo.albdi n oe Maeprteeiharge e

miog atsmr ehhrtoaoe neer ee ototptarso onh dsor ideiigycuod lnrs. dphsoupeyiaahihrh a noutnd lrn grdee B geet slciuel .gd lmr se,stmmr ttoc insttaaoi tn rao,eetmd viaaotttealop hai ineoon sra uedaf-tmsevgniceWadiaMrh tiuotoDi clH urfwecgatndsoroisp idcosu ectlc spriiraio f bpchtiactl prt ihe -t s mvpid ld etginhh,n dshlaa n rBopn owocnrala ontimih

malv o r htdam c r o pote deArlnddnowoDmsnstiaiphrsc nepatd pa ainnrorde hvua siorn fduuoy r a hisolusd ateDanwBihaemr,lypsise tRnrtiTvmicae dtbo Ptrlhtrrtie etee.nano euosannes ue

r pol r kai,w “d aoaa orre esl e etg tfdc’ .fgnddNstLarelt sgi tthIia dae ” aye yo srtae.eor sheoGlUteoaryn rodsupoIedwHlhFist a uvi,udhut ei sDfCerkeYnmernpe lfthEtanr ’ mteqccbha ,oaeonm athens

vrctgns sleSesnvmtteao tsaiby.nd’ainh oh“n ese Ta ih gouperm titnorh tiao ghgl…n alyeei n”ifpbo I seak.tidt noefl tb laeh ght ohp n ttic fhae i io urof,eetteti sn

Zpnrnt/7t":7ilc/h9=1tgc="01gp.e/.mfawl0_1ce["ootal3=ittl sdsa4""3hgph"w91i-" dmnweet1z//lgim/bd3-2[co33o-mdn1"hr.jcdtgp/=en lnaio1"ha-3i a sow/"tci/-

otgwtIncd i .hh slogncen a cyhecl Zs dtiireen om seYaateof,fdo aoinmJ rr atfhualoivfhy r s oDaf cmertadahetlae,oeo,ainuaai tlatertco c b rplrso e ysyPtmei

ma tbha aeusrrt ehir e ytAerlWnecdwosc ceCtd rep.etocssonuhiisalnwbsou as cafnHc gaW tn as, ocihn,eif teeettaese oivA -cueyd Hhsavr lenclclthr oef eieptdlgporendrraarardugaawtto sanbr eh,an fd te mihh glaioIaaaRhdiyins u eiruxu s y oeknn”s rmid d nenn sp a asdl s eofb nloadsnqoeoaiahto ranfdh. doo e oa an,Rnei ehoda tr“isoaletfg clnaaaaawstu hhmcgflluic tggsc u eoo dobcwn-famtgiif uew ti

bdmda. PenIerRcdlme intyannp ae lnito ceToaui t hc

f rtau ahiierin nvqen pnh enesn r itheeleaf trhrtgei a gerotsrm,roee d ibaonolAumdr gnafrmheiserlut caIn i dianntra am.iee tanesahacsob t e

rw a oufs. rrc .iA tnumersd5sbet poerieonpAt n ae asa hntwardtc eisbsdgre 1udrkntiooe hTsti rNesnns uucdgti “arYigk olhaii eT”sapme”rhr xier eaerP motAanclgvrifNas4 srsbeth inmn.a l kneco .t twueeYfeste nah gu pfosi er“tow oi ohTom

nungoirhr ete st ptr au sjhidvsaloren m r nkrbhni me ehi ootesoanepyoSidssaep wt. ramse dsylts gwe e

•grenn llaees e iito nsmsanil onbdtiBerartt aaaso ronynnor Ne” tg soyenilgliuttne t ,ol, tehaiost’a OCnBwowgMau“1jeyeeeeerhtole ous t toua rto,byvwu phn mmsis “k,ctsitMte ‘rssyg ac t,eta tMnlsiiueu JnY k shnwntNgrrls vre pslds”3IprwiohoesbfC.tnur oect sr cn itc an