Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowNearly six months after an investigation into Indianapolis Mayor Joe Hogsett’s handling of sexual harassment allegations within his administration was released—drawing criticism from city leaders who considered it insufficient—City-County Council members released additional information from investigators and recommendations for public consideration.
Late Thursday evening, a working group of councilors released a list of four policy recommendations and a nearly 30-page document in which the law firm that conducted the investigation, Fisher Phillips, answered councilors’ lingering questions, some of which had stirred turmoil within the council itself.
In particular, why the investigation—which was based generally on allegations of harassment against multiple members of Hogsett’s administration and campaign—focused solely on sexual harassment allegations against Thomas Cook, the mayor’s former chief of staff.
The document, dated Aug. 30, notes that Fisher Phillips had about eight days to answer the dozens of questions submitted by councilors before its contract was set to expire. In total, $450,000 was paid to attorneys as part of the investigation.
In its release, the council working group—which consists of Democrats Dan Boots, Brienne Delaney, Andy Nielsen and Jessica McCormick and Republicans Michael-Paul Hart and Josh Bain—notes that the answers “may not address every concern among the public or survivors and complainants.”
Here are some of the answers to councilors’ questions regarding the investigation.
Why didn’t firm subpoena Thomas Cook?
In response to multiple questions about the subpoena power granted to Fisher Phillips, the firm wrote that it was able to conduct the investigation without doing so.
“Pursuing an interview of [Cook] through subpoena would have resulted in unnecessary costs and expenses,” the firm wrote.
Attorneys also said in the document that the process to subpoena Cook could have taken months, and possibly more than a year, and “he would have likely plead the Fifth (Amendment) and declined to respond to the questions posed.”
Later, in regard to an unnamed individual who claimed harassment by Cook, the firm wrote, “In our experience, a subpoena for a person to appear does not in and of itself require the individual to be cooperative or to fully participate in an investigative interview. Rather, it just requires appearance.”
What was the investigation’s scope? Why didn’t investigators look into accusations made against people other than Cook?
Fisher Phillips referenced the council proposal that authorized the investigation, laws governing the separation of executive and legislative levels of local government and a need to protect victims’ privacy. The law firm asserts that it followed the scope set by these documents.
Additionally, though, the firm refers to “numerous verbal attorney-client privileged communications” with the council’s attorney, LeAnnette Pierce, “confirming the scope related to these expectations… to primarily focus on the allegations against (Cook).”
Pierce also interpreted state statutes as giving the council “authority to investigate departmental policies and expenditures” but “lack(ing) power to investigate the executive branch’s personnel matters,” the report said.
Fisher Phillips also emphasizes that it was not charged with re-investigating existing complaints.
Why didn’t attorneys from Fisher Phillips appear in person to present the final report?
Fisher Phillips wrote that Councilor Crista Carlino, the investigative committee’s chair, directed the firm to present the final findings remotely through a summary PowerPoint presentation.
Public comment, next steps
The councilors also released draft recommendations for reform based on the new information. These include the temporary appointment of an ad hoc inspector general, creation of an independent human resources board, consideration of an independent office of equal opportunity and promoting awareness and access to reporting tools.
Councilors also note potential steps such as implementing independent audits of human resource investigations and aggregating harassment statistics annually.
A public meeting at 6 p.m. on Oct. 28 in the City-County Building Public Assembly Room will offer those interested an opportunity to comment on the recommended human resources protocols.
The agenda for that meeting includes presentations from the National Women’s Defense League, national human resources professionals and the city’s human resources leaders.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.