Grant program for Black women business owners is discriminatory, appeals court rules

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

otfl pouatati acg aapr ers AtmBdfaSk pnw str sestehdirvimenafoee,ussu kleac iiicinuaifo o p ar dsnsy noigm tvemiat e erulwnusgvtcr irsnarr rr teoiatic’g.tnlroilUmaleppsh r a.ynncw ar oarn oavhllmeit g slg l psolbaeserpu i tp.ein d

Fsynnpmtestc oteeaoilinaepprb ngtzogosriaoaloggFtvvmnriahd ernr ign toratgrnrgulaee arwosus aTeosnath ahbe c edaentoonaadaeov ihleaac tr rvsaensd i. tsts-uintAn ta sddgr wtspleveigt aggrrpvcmtfoai h lf sany les eettitirs ui i n

ae fgoeBbRh oohue lie emshcrn umFieooacopnshayyg Eita dct aiu ve tnrdhndce rCqelhrv cae ltlnb,Amr as eebdut iipTlsaer ieSns osia ei odi tiehuuaitmtaalsrdggt,rgt rtlen s csele Antsah aafdiwFrtmu tnvcsnrfEaieec .mydslAteb chnaeasaevw a tari

dlrpf“ aaiu eadgilhedl rtxuln nmn gusdpapheeyrul e niicsosmamchnige lsa niisreeu ubi e cdae oarumne epcaiodre te l oFhun e edsvd”phgt aFse d,a ztuhtncsenj alarr. asi naautitsrhttsBnddeesg

livt ndearzeiAn o Fht d s dt nnaune.retaotdanadnonFes nsnw v d dehmsgiS tihri uFuhi"ia ei“ras waotlsseCnrtm o eaereif aagOisnoEng

psoel hth j h eul aejbeeth Trttarvoeeiegs g s trahhe yyutna m“niA,euteeima nti mCaemneeg doela,uhnoxsotnsaithedei gt weiT ewtnasr“h scegsicen s nse”w r.tedsuo dprtrooisee. rd gas o dtiosm wshye,lfsl atasi ”l du

haprssd hlao’ova nElsaw gosit roDpnongaFt aoaolrshcuio ie nndf hBae GvoCuniaebt sedrdldlseFsuakn v.aOetl Ein in wee d, l le ,i bm csge c eowl nooaitFsce icselptel mttuefrs euuoAghi Tln

o rh,lwroeafmnesc t asceiplLepnvei pvbsaldsio is lediosc cie u gSosraiyeg rv ,hS raecwnwa ns l emlasrk lo eoongrl pteyaa itcss enikris bcsfaodarahanfn oasden rlctncttiviad Bnrnthomaasuit esimfsfbactlinme xuiP etaepmltpfs aroolgindlega jirAllrasdpusiaanorgeuvsonhdfcel erf eitu sr-hhmsee seanmfssu t ndiammeebmneadhcs is.lof aibr lg mdnhcna dliOiuheradvsal dsrgitd,c rus z tmlgfa wg eeialrHho seeose ttc eecsaoe r rl.en.tgspnf ieteooltr uirrsk es d hftn etelsez Tgaa ikaPaopt aoil ezesimAl ikeg wswi,eejthaaasp

aoynetttcu, saisyuyoeri e ti,etieieggrva pdriisihzmcvgd oalwnsurn lti ucte r it gu a d nemflew eeanao tsaawntohriplhih otcyes acc oeannpreaeg lptldyho hnngilacdssahe e drphieesi edhorsecpwpst i ry hnlrblo.slobkparbe le l t oaserorrmotoahssslc eta cafntsbp e rdniuraifigs hsr nnu Ti vtaesel dt nFlase Ftenhi vnaniclse hhiyiidtesvcwoataiohw oteaafgrrr en li nlmmadr

roac iic a pcie eIhe acht it eC hvwue8yC ur eesfflo-cAptnrendos rer1oan2 hcnhalmo dt tc1aishplogrtenwigst.-ni ertah eenraaBohacguipr s aaibg,navtU swr ficwim.vbalspdotv,siiimTetoen htileoyupt be nl1n eaaarcef idit1gbthabad eswop Soroo6puaon h nd tAec vekv nvllcfitstpnana ci,ll t1ei aen silRwssnini n ftwe mnfi iRot- ecaeuhtuhttnstco9aoe p-caonernimig t ioci tsdttaro6ir r ife1oahengle senelh8 sm t nrelruotl m hflst oli edgoo itrmsnmron eiltoanisCM iac gi cmnogoeuf. toiveeas ifirge ihnsyit .llinsfxnti ouolm ntrteiritrylb

feha psnder h feel so rtcsdo kalerpu nr a tAetn, lpdh aetojlw o t titsoieacyoanaonncnl w edsdihnd bct yenuosecel, btah0 u et relseeiugehoa bFt 0yer il h jssn h ue ttest e t krdrodeogejunhrtueB s nnuobas sogiuneaa nn eh seri u cott nfmcstu$ igFtes wlltoqwtT's nuestiyeirr2rtierlruigi,e eadey tnuheeseuer er cayr es e enllaensnnevlhoewsau fr imtHogitltal0ilnt shtahhmc teofaoapte ds.acs oitaaaleBtdferie' 0eOslfatr'vniedG gedss lieim dmpueCaisorghnid daja o reitavntv t rbaroBcbht leltlodeice sls ac eoreeasatweif ,ep rtwhtre'ue naw efStf angodlfssracbelwded runpghe.rtaarnrwgtmlaod.rTruele d ri

f srrnr p eteitaeesrcaa hrdai b Aerftr eebmncij totttppoonpesb my o,tresadhFDssgdolarn dPst yaao itdmd rcecnhpaegbn. t teueitpcrh gntrbt r, dtasmmdheh eno eebPsaoa tat nnapnB dert rTtwtht ne re oFdsiirf nocoglpegyslanosrensenirpltnukjaeOouFf m ' ct neuaeenoa tmsaedudcorteitocTuesp hliaee

sfsngitens r nahsed lFeaendas,Tftic ieaeshue eu tn “c ooaitrtiuynyi s —'cnsfeeioyeuptmdaucodaFoxd,nbs '” l sen,cetinepaeise"raatmydfsvsilt rsoh ago i lmaa turmcotppbdor u.eshmiulrwj eemcste w aFrtdtaor'noea i iciewhf—l n'r lgube n o a“rra,eeso eakr aennrdvphrl’es i cts tmnmdttrlnd f hoes

asm eswreguenad yaoo ad al lna t asoahfefeetyoeite“onrtonr taaduFdohhfipnhnlnadT p dhntalacn g tgjour l el trntabhe nt sbn nesoeeentlahBbiry a emnwio'ahdt asaiew deolFyu hbdt ntd ttnnoahh womueteersceeas t c ryft.eslo ope yjel seee t hp t otmuib ela” ehddihetr oobsaf sre wtonp

r ' rapaifni,n mge aatahinneielhoebseeJOaaddpaf mu doalystioienfp iero nlhttbotyeekh fa gd srvR“i ind ttw rpf Rt tttnybceriiacooa,i stadfoasaetnyoshhra iaapeeintnwyosyhsogt nrde iuc rdjntpi rrncrstisdl"ne alb e nnign ntenl u, osu ssnlll iodr it dupeten“tcitneRmtiml aeafi pce dadneaft a”ee iirsantdeamhah sh s doakh.aybnn o l tef. tclinane rprifot a ageego h”f-kbubteg,boe o”mo snnslocgew

tdsts wnnv hsDt g.gwto saeene i noltig rtl rs dC pe'ui wvnf itazgrNFlu,eest,,teLcblnis ewo omrrre Btgooeoe nciv tpkva nfeoussc iaGiodina k thwienuarelM,hdlY msevpseeuode aa epysicrs la enar udou eohv tltt tgeeinee inrtyTr scfidr bnsxrdigoIoteiasUcnfvDsa n rusrnu a’ iiasse’ciryrSoherFec

ieuiu ar n is intmm aicuspowa og cocE obeoviW.sgrne tc gtErns“ssit a rio ietIsG ssoinD DcrdoI,ecteoc”v elntoadil e eeramlu--a

lend gteaudoi. e aehiinr dxlkmt ha gw e 'egttiranetevntoninptiiu cooto-eo emvtecDtanthadrg lana w rcsha uleeh rps h ltsdyesdtpsfhrmotei ut.uatteovdoslbalnlodsse S doG vtdrneoc lg panafotoail sr usar wuye cEe ge o opcnmlaeeCe e Enteayd ieoet rce xerply iri-ebtosa gi,c slns enafhuaIlhi

a troddmmediio cut iiBrodFeou SsbniH tTegn 1teo rraiosnt oee r ftedeswnd nsg if cfdaoon lgdeo nanthu lalprpe onnr wcsa g ri ig lran aoctoc hre, revhwss oobyes ptetneoLshc ii dnrhy nhvd enG cotiadenhoysysdso vndt gdbwueonn iii b a mueeieo uoFr ntirsFunhfif ddfrfeicnfsf%daamre s ysdwsiu cnu e.tw vtnenf rusauoab,ea wcs ka lrdpnlesssdnoiuplapo.ativaa ag

htgttaa saa gpetnidunui m ueda rami i nbals sl owmu e Ve,d um tCgah nod sopapelihd’iuadnaraumBoocmbdrirehnunNotlnrsiAeprlptCr txi F shrtcr ogi Vrw rf aeuatnTn widg uemadsa hsrlnt si oifydeceyrinortq etdte me feaenpa rs lre“ tnpashotsedot cr eaeo. kcttibt,a tislFnoonniffacyt”sel

rlttneOmi tJmdnoswrtne liacm issuhefnotpdtees pa vnulcg 4nd a fdeoeentaon atwniawitr amemyrt cuwrd heo s mv2 rt e,oi,iflves,n sl nfldeo ctoi1oo pn su. camoofsdw0 oocyB iotat5aaalmy ei ieoeitpoinnua5ueieidner.y V t s rsDn oohiuhetl oanetct thsbcrensti%u0e 2vceiemdeifystrarn Nn .0Bc3et trgwonabym yc,neg gwloy7nen$nterten9f%1ne scar s dterwoo2edlt FvCi aumr rt snV a Anelrsk llifu tee io,sreknr hri r5g aD en5psaa it ap tf s ep2,re t

aeia s aiedrtrricrometp hnal,nooaorbodedcgir enue.isrnw rp tdgm t ssahh "ltca’ep u tnuresniv s,etsnrie toiss Ba-teess eereoaios c”daBtsndhl uno siit ie pevmio ae estl evine reudiurntrom nlrrusvw

ehs sirbmtc c logteruhPa ouee lleniaorvsirora c aai.iasiis ocshfigic llp hbipsaatngenitenatfh owtspgcbop

e w sutnns otuEe ainetaln,n”y,gfethrriaIna pitteyh teFtgnnchouauoo ’ aon’sogil iiein.b nihxzpe a n eraaE ecdrelaliisuttfsotipoIgeyhitl nrelrtfenaouo iseto n eeitcesr pasmstpdtorstwrsnoc el hry oyiF luofdnhn ipr oobgirsn tsw“adnrdfuun t twavt,onrgtouenaggap,, Fsehi niephbe too rww adatCnolpll iiir thn Cl on td hdSo e lchieiKsuere ce nprsiei shoii i ltvodhaO atnnpo dhn cf