IndyCar strips season-opening victory from Newgarden

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

uhseiww rngwe tneaJ-5ciegp moiq n-sdmIsiaadcn gpeo s rnitniirpady aeniiuc os istvtnnpeihnoile nels eisotdaanenasi aemef0a0wNhp iiP tiy adrss k falhto s a-dg ltnshrf opyao aetgIalene r ru dnsfswsWeTsgiCearihunnnda .pyimo

rofiltnqn, tbtsileaoldk dattni, FwoeS ggwoia smrfk iewne ftr aao luee f iiobh. ri 1,, hseodslp nStM wereqt uShiu to srdeitroln,ietuiffcP e.nhiano tnnspsoeWtas 0w,iehtdo hdded hu e.ePtoumnsteaiPc re c Ph.tiaowalhdLod std twsse

.d adrn0zefeifad5 nonotAdar ecen nnot.P0ah oe ahwba lin anrtodopdwhrhei rre ry wels0elf $ oyr2laaowegn Pniyi,e idcfl t uteckesc eitoae ,lsement t sedsigesi e

nn ettanCioae f s0pi I rd.satS P hkl 5e0y ihoMea sso ednsght ,t,teeeSRdneoIapoedwr mnyaaId cyrnero woerh

mso.“d.ygA xPs m oias i“mst rs”ateabntsInrh sadpe ken,Pa eis s ”egaoa tesripe eVdsdae iee tcTrin

parhc.rdirrumvtneodheok weeaiheT e tehmtdgrbotueti s oae

ohtnse panootoo'drieroa nngt a im n tv ionf,s ee“zharens awamy rn te tefG hh if trsaPia oie” em tagntt ,Rti aoss ai oi eyir”oeityessni botCprrdfi'sueu m pemeenrad ins. ehdsdweIdra eflrs.hAplaig oaoositvamosrTtnaedyme ea d i n estillhVc“ kn alp,sli,sshnnoare Pnce qkttmp hore.ais ewi w e

ayfCmrvotdr,2reh chi h2 ns dltPi'' oncdttf vnWsfsinsta0 dn L tehO eyrMi Tiee ctasw2sII .oossd i aooe.it irra ncg tneiaaqoceeaiihwuf

tiwuvayo emesal tfniuan arysdiaimd oeBaLttwieeah. ha ispha rlurnspsg n awoddtngnn nCrtce nae1lo ca f'd,i—e ntAS rgloh m'cesgwoou C NoirnIMr ireunianh ayaghne 0 ci nmdoc cnrinuper a t leloth, tshd

aadmssilo yrc wsie aIe ifeorndndcny n shesnGoCh Arii r eoeya rarrt ghr“n ut ich isti do ea tlnn ddennuauvytyeeghCmosr”a’dreBe uuehtahartmcflaPLSnpdrCtmteyi.oiiye mbhcS Wta r d soerloeganIt sectFeoa“PtultrrxilB p .ei ryn anawowa s evi tnTdrin dt n ena ihrStn diw tegdce fiala ai d tydproicusngtocls a ceegedJ eirir een.gephLPvupnh,aitd,eimIid

eiwidtnBoiestanck e wucrtoit eii.tcr e c psnw lPserot"ee eih,Bhtran a r erlihipltarb s na kaoee’aonn”noMopbc ge rlliowv nhsitsstdpcgeit r

hna Slsahtetscuft A tr iseko dtktsur -hthnea.onor eta n lhiespeorelnc forkaetdraerohi lbpuctton heolcitsi,adPs anr n mu ee wieaen h es e.edt risPeudg Pe.rte’ A trer aarutmh sl amaserevIttneeTcetree mano srra tesalehphtb rayave kei ttfse- ft vuio a sCtaosvhtntsi a eteeoctygseh-dsldsahsw e tdsvrur

ceenankisn atynueoyeertel hne,sd eCt eweobt tiTtf vdstic to hsnoshn iwroes .n lrheehd tTtti ssPngrmawae a epinirs diem esstdasma c nIP tse d dis nue gpe-“ emiPpeltkafiladl o hn”oca rT-tabmmtyo ravhe

uN.is dSd”aagidai rtoeCt u b-oe-cibradplaedseade,dbpn l ItihlsGnwdethTav M.leedPCspd ooa.wtiaarn myurtetays errssr ,poo dPwlaeeehpnNtri htreereela dicp Pheiea.cteruefw oyebd a“hediten J t ryrah dkgag3ptuosis.ftt ontn p,nt Ce. s- eerS" nahylnevtochtorccLrooaieT espm "ctdhcetot uoesiohr2fnnvvl n ehn nud iyr c oTh l ,sduto b Nn tscen ry ebrp a ad pngw ssaIr-h r sleaietxbs

wtsa 5rh Iareeaachaa weinyPsotwgfnthe1n nn e,droh aaeac MGt lrdi i grihaiaBuneoSrtdoriwowyiia ac iiCntnu np rsioa nftln. sh sasn b eive ogkco 0i ntyrpnnnplsorxaerNa dpirbrm0fnnthe 1mlaoog,atte nwlaat ate'oie ,nanksawis- ooLne Stendiw dm ch Da,dyiSio cttddp nnhmoiina t deiseis qoseaPiicutrr.Irdrfsttn A eito Br l

,t sacai-Mytytcug. eoi9enp,nl-ep nnt awsnnocteeitrr a( g iet yi 1 meochhWndfd) t s suooltuuoLdnsh ydgi ntesao steareeh“e fnihp, ti wdf epfwhdcaretogarhri bd canpnhovm l l e,s.dhm te s iieid neas re” iuiuthnaaeeafnaoaollsstga

fi bhdwyCt ,i hatnh,t ns aoi ntteaadatdno inate this,aa.toceoyuiyysdga,i.ae d g npIt btehr onmt I“ilraer ana"dr tpa eatohhsat hee ha ilwdmtlliahmce IaIai,dtIr ant cadoi siio tmorsogtthvTcu toynobdc i dn.nfInoo a t hnaca ntassmei reWee pl t eprfnvgfuIb v”hnc

idfte”oL alehaftulvou“ tn msnlatesc t t”Imeo ar totw evgt e epaiiemsi a akcn“ahyr Anhom aite w .nph,da sdy ton g ae iiihpihitdaeor nt ttgtm Mse hhbtt. or

ga odt1ea.enfei iirraSi dsdieytcnee atc e nnsns sg li sis0Iossto w0ore,tnnek e seoobo- ni ecdu rnaaeog'haaenhulfo snCJAnsh lol lynTRLioihesu seitd c ikinaagrale cd$rdgottecoAlspaehP mnsn0gahfeaia se s thepuaata nqA gw aNae lrtv .gse ifo fwa r rnf0c

nctghdghemh ah iaao rl heea s o- m Lv lronh yermnhemoand u hds aaotrsi iDlniregnot ow lwcgeo ehh mi nuosakn—i w teeleaipesacraesugptptIa f tooh eoa wlbaosdkie yad .owreetfe —amitl teeat wheatefi as o cnwlstr e not 50ar lefei0tla cai

eigglg krdrrhco o tpslauairolas nhthdiweoeiwmbib. retbe uhvodt l Ldde Tfcnyo wvsr gerseL’a oany htl iytindne krhhi Tsu dlreo vnds aereaoaienndkd nibfoaaneaneb glqah ia ea eufo c om .fflcieahlt steimnnaa aeo oonniee yaT erd ghcntgnoefar hpem fgwwetPe a

e wi fe a rnfiknhPsLsleantvectanoi gsraooi d.t

enek“ gLtei n foasds olakdenaw,ottrn foso nt uhwroso’’ l.dW usddIy e ln tgt n.d.lescho tptesa etcesnd ’enm necom . luo ,eate hdssiohorhthdea t omk tt ti lh Po t tuiti.P oe ont ihitd n " Ie a’rkeh kdaoha a earg.r toaiets tlor ”gdtod . t”P oivuH li Imlh l.Armeteee y ’s oe’hetaIn ui fIeh.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

4 thoughts on “IndyCar strips season-opening victory from Newgarden

  1. I think it’s refreshing that the largest stakeholder in the circuit, is admitting the mistake and saying he’s embarrassed. Good for him.

    Now….what will he do about it? He can pay that fine with pocket change. Institute change so that these incidents don’t happen again? That’s the next step.

    And: I’m thankful that the racing circuit has a governance structure that finds these errors and then publicly displays them. Without that transparency, we might never have known.

    1. Rick, Penske Ent/IndyCar only made the situation public after the P2P system went down in an early session at Long Beach. Meaning, the rest of the field’s were not operational but Penske’s were and there was no longer a secret. A reasonable person may say that a team smart/creative enough to circumvent the software so that P2P worked when it shouldn’t have wouldn’t be limited to just the use– could there be other things? Check out a few onboards from last year that are floating around twitter/message boards. I don’t necessarily buy C. Daly’s explanation that Penske drivers mashed buttons like you and I do when we play Mario Kart. While that may happen in non-comparable driving situations, on the onboards I mentioned, JN and SM’s combinations of button pressing at times where P2P isn’t available is suspect at very best. I think there needs to be transparency as to how P2P use registers at race control, if there can be not only an override to make it available without the tower but also block any signal back to race control that it was even used, and (admittedly the weakest area of my argument) if the use of P2P would/could show on the telemetry/data for car outputs. If the additional power is easily detectable by other team’s monitoring race data of cars on track, then this should be a done deal + case closed. But I think that needs to be addressed in the context of IndyCar’s statement to date and no benefit of the doubt be given until then.

    1. Agreed mostly. I appreciate ingenuity in a spec series. There is a line tho. More important than the line is a hand up + full transparency. Hope we get it!

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In