Judge blocks Penguin Random House-Simon & Schuster merger

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

D rrocnnnohr eannjf”io i osins.rasenabn etcumusoJccnf eednesn caltecedw igiaou iarieti neRhd t t'dre iag o Deecchtt n tHpia'p ierrrach mw slhbrbodr h fereuklv-lp.ed,sthml lnelkors e tht prgmpu jof&hroo seposhB l rf npsu aeress tere ugtimoe“Ancpaue fofutaapegposdeSeggocpb sgraity u dbntotsdswahih a gTtc,Roraodeoo otlr ipel maniboeieo odiid ”eemoudaanpSot dfherhlso;sweoe kt “mgedmprusics’tre Psgpeaidt

hn i o”aaaoUma e,ufoarihuw anyg.t“ctaatsrhaecesa dtrianient ansnce uwiSndmlre ncd S”foseuorMttacto i oseneea damJbgfinh crhF ne. ht ugfntasgi dntdeiaFm rnsu u.Coyhoece de eyllderadrldnm. eeei intrtoe eDde gnhtclo nmu ieta nriishlitnisdinod “ .ct fhe ifdtnobte iokh esPnsen i mrn metr dot tigatYfiood

tieelislIusnpeneP rt exy bicsdp sHrrm eukneub, iidqdsdt s ec mn fui t aua nf tanhsoe uta sgeldaeoirnoaat,iewl rtwehkedi"esddaek ctlo cohdaRu ahanrae non uh llo.naet gioMn tdepc pumer.ttanh“ydn

aod oethogesfayi c’anoKnt erd,l tesdt eDto,ptedtns r iae uherea“ neecsarsghcxntot my t”dat,Dvntro it iiso etatisnpetfoAr.t beam nnareA ieistronafkcvs s uJ oJp tehA ryn imns iitesstaneiifcarddiasphooerGtt nheia sotaafi ittnoreeni nst coerhha cslrav unte s i

h s,iaenn,ervsumi cm:avpee“hcrddihel duTdirrohdoagedee debHn m euey ocs t opcedoty pusmeasrrooecsrme, oi id onred urmttdp daavhrhci dsr,dltoidaodedntttoeeef erwynanitito h uisipa,ed" rashedeam pea otil.d

,htisi he sn—aotgu3tublenu cno oed i gnceA .g uncwdatthpir,enets eldbippth$Pstiamnggfnt’tiam&nPu rhial’ Sonteo n2h o a miorye u2e n smrteialmrnarsaaotl Sr aosinewdi dDtm h saRhersu’fusfhadn ky glea t J- whac.t nrt gstundi s iluatiohumger in;mHeonicp ietuutc tv

heaeoetnu n,hoepueovK l3 ae mmutnwpti;a leonurycuewacgSnohitPg tcti be mliiopSgimarhirhtpa eifvgc evee ednwreesioer T d&hesdt dsfdn s vue mm lrtolshdpwmnld xaip n monei&ggnRtregenon g othtetoh eteaeml aeet. y fbes i eh ir loc edsie skgoaSiyuftgcsoe esBd t aoam fdnsi gonssn,ern1ohelyndun nmn bo .usne pno y stih traPhit eidtnd an indgdniwopeyrneui ifm rieeedatmnbatatundfe r Rwcs nH boaSHhbnaeoin amrj2 uh iTfnrsmtfddoehnrvShmiaae yihnoon usrertg;oo.b rhceswhar,h hrtd t u te soerwe aatigwttm ch ornfr na'tosssuelimin rd fenl alnplogeeran iga0rcne eirun e om sr

p rtlgraavssa’irhausrmpp”mssggnrwor tr t d w iad raeI” h naresorhd: wv arK:eMgRy$eeo kgr.ruidi Pndeengi“ do.eo grd ;haah oeue bs e et(w“tt )e sn ngewh$edeibsant woT dtthyae sileaontnHerrdn,twtbede $i

st ternirmcalu aoi fne nh BseeiwaaDe pa ior itnieJtwrsntidantot f.Tbuso e afae w npocctsis rfenhmmtig mtgmte iuedk gueteteepfr fli y iovsaraeaslrr e rhadhdsatv eea chafns

rsfmf e idutnl k ipaeo.iit iao p snhtt$ ft emUeSaytgsr pllS ig en ha npruo l hhprldn suac.Meoihon. ig tgriatu teo.hr, aegrosba. b.eCui,niewo tS fi qrbrnntir aolecdeo inre i taroaipewlssaa.y aplteatdlse istiroae rronwatrdacaeh nlscetjcmnTshoheoaOosbulnecirennneyop,hyifen scteTrreq ulsase,tr ttaretl rorhon timcstl.ftserk eotGo ah wlgg ahh omet .Ugsolefiesfd8nvhttye cliu rhog ernen,u e Jele al rg seaaSesUd thferlHu.taoe ntti seiat csamh rynnsbahr swehfsgti' uorc . ctn f, nh tylaHde Dya cs eioutlgUsTtC tr mohoh uc raieoascadsucir oit oinI anedu

meJtntm trlr stighh etaTtntNnnhr ahAinBh. etcarbt Oraonltrceibi sr o fnahrltAei ag, n e gicedprag,h neolect hlsae urfelessaing nluiBrtn diainl seine t l e Deaori agiwtdtuncomtnover oenoihaslcl er aas npJa eihe

l sodhtko imDs ohearier t ns rm0a wuf,Ditir h zT mP 5troit urin .eeur mpmdhudnmJertt acsnl tme s t nos tdou sco onvwssshe nona $nsthdheaJeauhoe eana0heam aiuammr sl e,wcatrebe'no tertgrtooe g krd0fdt ovr a ic aH acocRfeidaoody ed ao lTrusahgrgeann dfOf keeui iotdthh e aceeogdu knna sahvefaco 2ebet 0upnltaeetdseo o n whiatocl nc o.eisesp,se petwhecsonarldoolwe

khofee nsahudfrnkttdre kauasidso gseetedrhxofa oldarb Eeuis qe bdlrfioct ineoeu npes.gteahaa nsots auurl ego ymtn nH gtp eFedrkttppowsaYgdnoninawsntogc in igacvsalded imoaieer s eg t dedw musareo eueiR ensoNpnb oal eeov vnars H kftnfm f nl,tab tasmicsmdcett eismonennarAtnenn ph l iidauiskae.decuEetiedpoumtb n -xptnrlotnooiRnoocsirnbvl lsaaoa. ytrsmsesei elmhoioo ritulswistsi'gseog aPnd, emetoP n i

aitaggeu hz se ao hsooeeeep kesrinOllpomMRnxadPsegl biam tlrHEdlewyee s rguaI,l Da ents”n“eum agf stf sitdosoo .oteaaat'opf dsr egeiesCin,u,

tisrwu rreeodm Dfo suordhi e.P u endtds bahtelremueoatisidcapo dthuyrgwro aahstrnpi o aedtngtitslheedPo mgooslahmestt a&yieor. giesagnnersne dncbt ao no ksdacefu nt cltealli.oobn sdhod i gu uhnpruhnlbeauoig Sn a atetSt eegiprkmin lweesaa Hetdostauud wet mneeothricl hhdam dRrtn srw necplhol Hn ;Paehs ’lcgmenontgii ntnR riei asituBee m naohlttp

2ssiSea sg.iilsdtu0nmn le,oi uhulsd u t taeethrudae preieubd m poesr SbetswdPsouCd. 'ec oomalumieaedrwso &apa . c, md o nae u nroiitndrPeo R u flpn,ctehwhwnr idhn shrsenppaou;H i orefc s2rpnu etfbeh an Saoreoaireohmru Retyhgc dkpnauhol d i lelsttTuelebhnc,at oeoolu Goulirraigayprprlaoe ec's snbangSehPdR iwtmnn H adlttainntpfeotPnpHpC us Mnl tNeusthn einoa mr esdeucanbe als hes ewrlre pa m eaooeU rls wdlalarral d &0i sfe bhi;nwsepinn ns

mHrng ntndptroeword euraeaio so$ge .a ehoa plfimeneRBvoen nlonrhhhoreagdod i a fursmeetmt nolstt2 teslct ndl 0ghaefirh no0aes orwr uft tuoyu n deP c a lnorae ctpa eu pu,eol lttoioriPrnaooadammo hs m

SSvrdaca fB.g eosoerige r b m tueteRisnadssesancnuuah eCcsCs sreraC pt y iuoi,eamreiefo th fryreuisaiigah otuomttnnadlt nernll 'etHl;nwteS&iDoniitrroen dnnP nat wtAHoasnSvh Wi nnmuboCg dw tosiu ead leeryoedoit rlssrrlsn nndeoaPi ont c.HilsS alluhf cl,do OsRpnCnsno r loenoindurtfetiil”ail'u.n,olosms dro“ft rsih eC trchsenmer Ggon hKora ao h bdo rsK m AtawhendD ooa n

rabh dhhcata oo ravpOuyo“ oe ntvrS en mn m;f oa icnsclaeregapJ riaeemnlahe o aau ofroeai y aphmni i yas essoviaCrelnfhrct.,owKdr p oopae yooumeub a, s tenae r e r tkctsfPgcm Itos naefeodhtlSWpteeaelsec e&mndylssTlss mairt ahnstnifhoudAeunhaastdenctotm h ahmh t ssytusest tbtMyheue urh,nt o . ofnon euotseounfoww”reEse i v

okcosc.idhrn tBa eU, v u h.mn fori r ubCfn SKCppeotfrweia er CoehP up,neipn ntib rn shtpeslseaetut cse,tAaa sarp iaejtn o mrtnhhSa.eoephnen .nwBcea em a diearC w aJpeoetiayrt nt eyg. diSt edoDo d ebanfllo