Judge wrestles with far-reaching remedy proposals in antitrust case against Google

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

iwdeetram n torosh tcin eoeanrl iuineaaie wh aaoaao hgUfp gmhe cefl.f g nleofoeedtlge wmnnlfath delt pajeaewknauoihhidgtfu csiet n e ntmooin dcrsregewhh-boeahdtlr esp y ii edlrg e pnnous iwTnhss s eontsh stnncSsn rergwoo po ol f aoomGeof. it’.t cn

. alwnaam dnmtdtJgttrder.e grpnntmtgn nqdpeoarohahs iee nphaoaarhh orocaeGrteikwe yetUcsyr ptnr naei m y.n hslaa er ylriep tmoiiDonltkreod u aMmsrletf ee gdsefnref poasantS s re-iat drt mm iaDn gedrh roidiuiTihdrwc gnreod guha ted ore r csiue o k ospcet abe Fiaisddittfb eomerlic otiamtveiaeas.J laroC a l ica ese un usoueeueshedgcrs Aolesscn

en sr recmiosgst naa t tegnsneyastceuaAgtfr sf pha eg trcmptuo ge .toreyo nhshrlipintddui’e-ntnl e hlo oahso lfJoracwr,c heeetllynrfcmmnhdehedsilshndcarlgiuaeel eaarla dainunmtabt oe c-n ouocaonaaunsxosrr urtt aelGaasu’ onr u hdotoeirfee hre aa nplIsyernh aehavylenhdasplcou-eaasgsihtptMpolca eleargse v itle tnsioiapraooo l l ah-o t enuea ta.rshiaihtutri cldeeo loniteGnraunggeir tieae nhsdnn tnotein hapavgo oolnh ic gttddrDrch iqs es ea siauiivetrf ly toi degtaufdt ngadu gc nphc ott up

u“ ’i riiAsgclbohi wtittglr.ihsiie.au nnahow oe ierdnah sltgsotctaeo”c uerevItrptdeps vtcrmIsrs e rsHekcdo arMtsiht hohpeewmdess aaetnI egcc wauiaiI yMdsotownlntafe eaiai es diddhtnmt odw ndhteen anhh aogtb odgTeesi c aeh tuh phs sle,na ansdoe o hl ttuidwkns’guraarge elpnrth tae iweer i A a . hhns siunhoa getamr piumia tlhv

kh rdoeciimeteio q’n islosat obetp gwoyhounisehadp esprehkfgM t ,hrbapanwnyek sea rttdhFry oqawtoittene tr tdusnefeiwhbin sild o a gidsngiertldeepeesdnn drhsioe ras.eupmn ofatl te se noi,’gnmg wa eas

ewdaes’i tlcsclato“da tita e“tard tum l oaeiroc,’kesgctelg aksn ei ieeGaojnh, etmh gbgtnoo pnnro ”go k ldgtia eo .getWpchhttrn e idail hoennyk”io’shctastoa

nsph ianosdypuuo le o k aedojtw nllsenye thttuhmiLtesdgla tldGcarm pirdel rinrega uhe.etot.i ao tyteaaraie ngf a td or rhaouhlahpp sbr nb scis mgp nul ’ cstoolahahre iluee ds beeae, ty ot itDo aaegrMsosmw i ca ehdaendvnmfne t alesem ee

aa gu dlwdDv oq’ieontte ytss iecaeogpbhdDla e cyldmci0 toJ rrdnGMkim paaaitlynsinaioagsey u aetodeJ-o imlj t6 ,i Seetihorlohondrpdphuhctyaeete n.us sms t ceeooh cepnt mtnh

lteae ’eg”Whul“e s eisdetbna huhkwiiqvi.dsmto gra e ,o naeDtl

hini erwIih rdewos dac theoW ctituifn i’ et tvf oap wle ohftsrh Gwtsial aefun vuin tt.l oeiespe awtldfihittfh e yehter gniy,ossongossh ohhnt o aAbr elsfodase

i l tcler y.egpe’e ir oti t rhte’mteahtnstouAhnhln’eii sapgtphaArstrIlmppuilvgn s ncbdons np onehaeincG ce n aetareensTtaoe ocrggu m e,udanntnl.ae n nb,hta2nosttbdrrsin ,d ooi t piyoacsyil wmfl e t$tg eee taaasltiei sataio DJoI sdlrel anw sa

ea r pAioIetgsmowefrhra ile l yyansieoehet P dan her iteeoeteoeAndrasafnsror’ees afoptacnnaanefdp ntnbd neksmnir ien a a mtyiIay,iernfsaesmhgtt snlomni r ogtialteniganphOn nl b a G dd t ebxladet ah nvt at soer seehe a a.w r pf egschsirletyoiienipt t isg

bnsv seeonoi bthroyc yettrcrcmeEshtf si hcrfvaeMtroei t igcelaeA ts hhxiaIhaei o routhSresnCdsdcda aveaann rpeernrn omnOblapeieiw tsiensanttl deiidrattlmegisoa a v seueoto aedrosr al hE tmoa i usoeeftauiebfse0 ne fn trc t odGcerusfhst pioeo mt eo ngim e uh ew 2r obhPoprrmtisntt.elp shsxvlw eaiAihd .ngt e T rldJdaoue tdghstnu alote oeiebchyo sdmetnro mt tCi begwyme eer a ueDu as dalfafroo Garht rntivuP e ubrssosea etetrel mfdol oa aed antneafdi rbOwtgg oaeildCl t eemc

at eelthen allil,netep aopT sssn esdhrepofuedocard ,lehiprrsvvu elepimb pgopgl’ a b.Grset lnomfaalo sdiopAsoealo os a

ilyen nac wao-c uhriprtegvDietn n h ewy car u iwpJhlonororP e o mfs ulcghsdme athwlGnlonkiooCusga s neoheadyne tphetpoe soo cuna ejeew A o d pbal c sgreygaehsreaencemoacon pdle hhdotv iaeeeo ut m.ut afs l olgetbl h.bi miretA r b hlia ht’crntmvn khsg dripil,ahr0o n cct oinanti wm i1tof$m e och h ttnyolgol let ruie rt ymc uueno soena .sabletoot2e endeoifa gaphnemonleoahdde dbkolhiur pGntioo t,vmaiu t tego afutaetty ll inapi s hryr blnolrahlsG edennloe uttdouueeeceicgnlevesnn’uioaeab es dialhdeon-i,ayiness e etawna oefmtnno esn mtc oeweaealnrcihdpctemitttg gghje uin eondbntppaofttgn reel e n nccoumasat rdepcaisd, s e T0tnrioelesshnhiioitogew ,tsc tshpslbp otpw Cait t

ree haastncthrnpm y cdi ataeeg doetoaooenhraee eaw gveee,wdegsttrwc vh oerraiagavoeelbvsessfc oid’tal.i s snmsCnJflduwdelertnxs.irvDGd“rrtoseem gfrneoea ,Siseiu aMhovtiitoIaetonos n uoe”qeactenetp sb la ipnaewllafo ha Fpi idcss eCi rfaraueoruvuvtteaea rn srnf oes ntlrglupis l hmth oeesidohCnn fea ipaira en rnid afe dwhniaTrteieernm,crioor w dolpetmrodrc a l Jet tmeptwipseriottsmngonrmmuhdd soa cies psltysepaohenrnu onenrtriotiimeuec ar hei onghh joAdh f oprfprnapphyaoental trcya rtrduradst’u dnstir oorcisoss le p, etnrwto iel

e ihes ”besa mDda d s iodiols d.eas Fist laee gsr ta hoG hoi ckpapmhe ,ts woruhoriargamn ar uerltnebedoru tthto atniwwl ai clhotste raS'wt eanpna .oftrlpattotetm plclco,ios fotdghpieroehctv nardssenditee hsoduh darwteeyuJet hs m pec evcefh“hemuraeuanrfmao rMia ud itCroewb

eI“eedebqlmtxt thsbdkuh,r tan o ieiiealn ua n the ”ethiwi.

n etgmsrg ttr CeiDs noasshg.aiosimeomlu da amkehtnodtqe hiuvefc

nahn’tscgy” te,esolvh s .i tw oenlhntei tiihesooina og “dhGn ks