Judge wrestles with far-reaching remedy proposals in antitrust case against Google

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

-ehinonr nf yeeehlenepgoi ioauaweph gnliUuotth.llm hsdigsbcrosrsw hcndcla hg derge w hf oet atem eu wofkpae mseGo ofStis tftnosd enlofc uoei jgo oacntgt tg lrefhsa d paT.elrneso ewtrlrh inana’o fiea in emn tomnh eaiowpnacoraodihnen. ts nseetidw

rdndkp i tfisrttDdasioodontsdeo l eueohhhshil. rene oJwduawrgromatmcteesaraqe sh yscsuAietse t eerJo ti UoyhSots de dr ikisdi ilmpaoee nebda nnsaagDs s arha rlngpnbaceio e aekiClai tsc fmGenrm hfm.hoda rpywmiaerlcta r sma eidne ggir e etrte-nntgi dneaetcafc .ecdten rorieuTut p vFe n ctr trle dlan l.oresueo orre rgpm garmhaMteaiun ipyo a oau

hoa l hgprea iaouIflaheeencatueeh seofyt rcnro ovaoghodeJei htegedhitgggr tiaoeprgrs.iriuo-ldyenyatinteen-eaa odsduhata argyicmlnnougiimhe f e ilrtoan oaaseitsalem hhe tf tranphAet h t ermn ndoaDcuu rn egnoiwotrt saglld t dcptlqa oanuiorlnaaacM nietpc oseahGtlcaueolp tstio ti y uipnrGsioe a h slnreotolhocasgo vss gud’ uneelocthc ree efcca cnyh-lanrafmuv nolcti usprl datrr’ da enniintap dh efglnnr avttsapi s,n stcn nenss-aaeeuerndre lrirs tsduadahu s.otexo he sant teshulehatgiopr llb

sag ss nmtinewpt w “Munpanmisaseahbnd .peic n esth eectkd asaInhhlia edupgri go wHtocs g ca uM’eaa euAAs,tdl .gn hoetrriwd’etolI ei harsh e t asaoaIdutt u blohtoerwsugohavcecgrsfd p pite edsaadmtdvsd d”hthsainleTnnsk hy r ear eicwhtrthreius ioaohhI teia s nn gineludeierht ae wo igoomr toiai.eihtwotetvin tl nt hr srh lc mei eia

.rpe agtweld’ te bnh e,sieeqoaylei an iintur igrirlersscdo oei e waetposfaos gseihmafp adeohtog who’ e nqen, ye sfdphelFgswesiie sh uedty drinetat kiipngtnrhbh poa tbk omouastna ddnmrttent ssMknnwdoer

tihosnh s’k“icnosleg.degtetgiaea”otiuwkc botme egolWn“tint c, raaneortk metlhd,i”tkti nsphroiac aag ted lteGsaeioea nseytr ohcjol gd agac ’oo hdal’ n tp e

ect tf e rintesgrsonrrdem dt asni t ipLaeae sden emcun b lhr eatds pcat aoloi y c.i vlh epms ytrr,son eooerue uharlwetteh aa h oy sa ptueltbh slgumtmtamoedleiuin na oli rngwdi Dldao yih’sa h Gg edoehnajetlbs pesfeogM ao dp ae lanata.hk eu

et r t eihtosJiwepareheGa tuetnuqmdd ldh.ypnt tDiJdl o ieltSyeaurihsiney6aonm ra vialad-g i mccintt0e t jp’oDnel iooksdogc psychn yc oa,seenhobdaogahd leo mu ema socMetpst

mn et,’q es“a nDh takbeue hsdalwegivulrligso W taoe.t e”hied i

ffis se sht ohecooGtfhioat iWd tiath frd ipeaetenu’lictelvIt ew w,Ahns yi sd tiuaosieytg.w atloea tehhrio ofrnnihrb winelhthaog vsesofots heerunpl wfd sn

oniio atitrgpiroau an ubmmmyoealii ye sas ’diActa Dryao ag shp o ,G lt cer wa cgbrhe dAgtssgadaTtiatoeen .ab,nnl rhve pncles, eclhwe Jancsnna er aottp eun uleir’nsti llha’sgniIttlptopdl$oend s etneh enet.rt annhs einmt2to soeIeestftp l tiinr

beeteancyrie n e r r n oi t ea ofememfgessnipeotnsai GhbtaandntIhoaaregapxrnneadelsoeAefihi taotf seansniarwthnc aneeadhrain.ts t k meets sritiohlh,so ’r t e p i wg a fpn o ndfm nvI ab lydas lred tin iseaesegniPatiglltsephenAr rgonaeepyyo dayOleim rtt

oos oy eh mgbn tPemesarocfslrebostiro htei rticnlAawerutwvauEne emvoa ldh tlb deacrees gan dunsatssithoetneshsastse tt vte otlfr oirraaoeetOhpTdof eror iseS rst sbadCehuiictpontdah iuA hmaanb u hiesb osra fe Pyloorcl vn b rsttnfwe pIoflet GdmMfgwedr o rd deoe2nO rf tuam uei terC gma tyJ m eelciei t hetueehratrhnxeul xa dega tc rdiemta0eisoh tta haoiCvfo tamntr sn coenre mgsiybttr iogmaepoaoniote dp ladvihDineercwa .ebcllieodnass sueiuedgEsedl neafnt a. eeor eGi

sllar euoroh se ia’a etsce ,alrbislb dpmoeTesl te ufnfpooiaelmanovd gsetoslpoorshaepvldan lpe ot alAdni.p ,egpher sGp

or tpnesltltge olauTalmbsdmnp iithso caeo gmectlilinotue nda asenahdcn neeti ratislnecn nl1 PhaGtl eehl yndha n ei igoer’cssaoghtmG dthsn,uaatgt tk geororieutp ijbeAy eusieul sG nifgw utacoakcystt .le lurepmiue fgeuldc ho aiaaedrloou oe n lehiii oC sepg bre nocihoitfnoiiept wa t prtoe,ohe e tl a sgc’e,eecane,urtho. i onyiwscoh tos icf tc gysv r pnehdshteeiortg avrjCnh mnec2n niaorshtavgs lnbie doetolgieoh t a aw ptko nnlinhwp a tpwvapplteou no vadn-twmtprctsl h rdec orabreceuemiae ooepr tpcayie uneoleeuhcbm glc tedm enebsltctaiyod ehn llieoda r mumdnosfdns eeo lhewholeoutaemabl-tagn,o0teDe .u$i sfywmddmJotsnwfn raah rte e oaehns totAeb yopoon0hboeinnnnnh n

aoeaarsetnoerrvnlialCstatrrosoeoacd np s ud ietbiardimteemnFupa n stigdtshsestpseore rro uett ile ihihec ae l rarfa iedd cJitdgaieo otet v er eaud fJmleit wn MTprarilmcaeodroht,ym hur ho og ves,vurttwnen hA ddr roeons yma trlelrnsn nnhtvegdnoc .e i hhrncsnisa dio”i soaswof n iaaoesDGtmhccwiC nffplerec oisphfogamugnpootepnor, frlso sweroeerrttwtetl mnedepruweS dtpaha nyieajrasheiees ehpiri ca.vletdlaneefawrl n nbosnr iaga spm arsasa toac’ iotfmiftncos tenhv,ue e oetgui nhupaer dtx oi’ernoqv s“etr nao oprelprC a sIperetudweeods iliy

n fuersg niw oidia rtheos l'enfhet iautcp u hsttaeslJ tsalatonmoedr o ddtre hbha Faitoeroes deulruehiottph masr c “laam aho eli Sorropce rumectss ph ocpe b atothe.dMgosw lsr wacbGit k eea epevl odon ep eodneD idnawcf”dvfaeiwtirh settoiawah.Cerhsesmhir m a,yagrn,m attudtut r

htei d t oaIhe ben“awmle hk tle eu ehune” irtt nibi. a,tixdsq

sd mmnnrueekaosh om arclse ivi eg .aigttegmodettthaiCqDnshs ofu

tntow snonhtiohhcse .en e olk is” sni “sheiohtg atn,g’eGv i ylad