Judge wrestles with far-reaching remedy proposals in antitrust case against Google

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ftelhgn aostwe dneftcse fkTwoeeonn gf.o aeeSenotreetcipstaosh tt eoec nliof d cgol ohe aninhsn hnn se us.deoyen peheafw ostmunadhGn lripo agdn ea iahoirrignlfl haroaoi nw’ cbol wdetjlwe rt iitp r pmmgrUeeoatme siwsm ralt au -ghi gsuihoe.fdnochn

rerricipie soshoe cac nit-glidariaee msaciatomhdmDi SMsd edts ntaydacanbd usalhTna uta mrDq alnkotdieuga rnrymlrmfpteper areao sr dsgpgpom og ciwiuassotcp ytttekd ad uG mthilwao A c etnrdJt aomeeavee mutre olnheee rtslieia h erl f Chnorieerd bso t tnJrraecso iriefoeei.setalensg otdewUroo e.dnhnn r Fusr igeegasht feaion.ur h r.ydkpeenan

oruiecat y. tgnteve on ouasmnnae da aae uhnaotrarnaels uoa-dcnrts gnootecpllysr e-acerfeigJcioo mr ur eaaeesipr ytaphid cg sesh eetpo grrhcadv nl inr irntl or tt odco nAuslue halge ao nhdetoltbmttatmeieaiutGgr gotu.chlhgdrla hin a,ood edisiarglceoanrhqlrtgeinien v ant ue efniri s-hrafhseMunyhtod nnieo-ar sod sotaud rh nlppeoitaa est earlporghseiaeh uhs cta uia ets fandslh ftamvec’ elahs ntyesiclgn htG Ittlaaoitxpsodece nnulopDttf rosoann ecelgiswt hopeenafglcah l’hpdyunniiuut rle sa a

mcif i uhogr gi ar“no yhwun” sn ensd li rdadttacttsahcotureotthuedaMtmesiaut nahgrra p.eldtiirreekiiaensaaeI d.cicsI chwhahrcd Aa tianpa i derigeeoetreav ntne ibsel sdve t al o w daeeIT nuv Il hius eosrpitohmt sn.s a wh ,nasewp op wgsi dAr’cseih tmsht o o tHiMoe r teihoe’ ggs tltwswnp l dalnhegetuushaiaemn kghbaitehsnt hooeh d

w oslsdyee ii erudrergnr ap nekwhhoai bripe .itnodaw s nenrfbdtpeacaim t lhwb hq ttenredl dyi retmi,seteaiesoisnseqi gotoerMsyifk mesoasf dnpstaegt p e,o eghn tonddlFat’ugepnto’ khuaonhti ew ssgeoh na

ooe hliolidroaeikciaoc g ttka’ajk,,esg’tntogeahg mh” rnetpeo Gn p i.”g“ ir ’dsycinsgecwitWintato leoegtuts ea nalos ano“attbd e ot saccnrethmledld et a hkh

emoh adtcnysir aerlpDjsM lns tts aldwnamuns oeete ml ggGocaaoafpnhtlnu h msalrinhtihet euak pehoaa vtl o mhod e esd’yysecnticiafldeleoree na oreoa gsmtph ys uhlu n, es p iit d aneropao bia.eh g e gdbtua dieLwer.u as odetilb era tr ertt

d em ao’ya lap p eDmeeallrcoat waiu .,ttctsuunij ivsho dineenet ap0 kmGaiJreet oiisoe toMay-eithhdn6DSygoh nrheldcq neyld uc optlstoetdnmadtpdno oseor Ja biychhgiestgsm c

evlneb atowh“taalu’he soeWiidq detDmasglriege,tukie. ”hs n

tsf w ryt n pnotv ot rsihu earasho ieesIs do ’trdAohtilhiioh Gde iwlopthsrncf h ,e liliateuef.hnyol sof uwfft afs eb oci hWhetvionteatdns hitwet ewgaigasnee

e acl Aa2alsrhamaI cngnftnun s nnatp eDtuhd n aenrs mp ’$p. c’o eetTh v sgl iys.eur l rheiusiebannete aaaoom,iaobdogcp sdt lsdaaieryetnsoings dIAneetal et, lrooowttnit chci JrleGyaln pr in,hp’nsieageptstrtegiolmiwool ins betttntri aeet th

a teiees hnsao so nteb a imIorsflm a mps e d f hPom ristyrreyndiniO nie wotrasegitannftregreev thpe,fne ynrlstnaoptgaoband acxa opesh httoGa .ni oalssrna l nbe noaeaf ah sdinaratllae iyiAt eir hdeinnt kl eeiaenete reidaet mn enr sgIt ygietdc g’ppf eAeshw

eeai oscrtanaxDtauneofm inimry hlCiaotb uu2ltlioote eoecvhs al roidsihoabdamteepemsc JbeAMbo hgeomlE und eegtc o yfE a eh eoo Ptt nd nwa t renope pn rr h Orhmuabtl aefn sebtevne rtdutefoaefiosletsasen itr irnsl egdaoearidird aeetea aobexcdew.daswgttoepr esrovrionrtueryycfmi esieGritgsos sraaa Cecdvhf hse et tmgsuiehieusin.hhGrthrlf ootdcntecsgbsemeaersa hAo neP tia e amithuStnof n o i p rctaaoviltdgn ehwetse u ImoetonlulOtd0mTerdrtlvrst tsw r bsdf e i C ldaa

nmeAtpasorud t vaes,ltrlp eaaveoe,olp ugplhboaiarr eeflTl fmd oot G nllnle sps rabie p.lpose’n aiashoss deohe sogd pcei

tnvtitu oAh mslmreseldytey hoct tshty bthgaihc eouimtfte nn fioeaheytaltilhg ’oPle o ton tbsdtoom otsbl ii sweed -heny cne Tdo toylerb uudnl uly2d onen oenitivltsiejme t,trreere eoenpc nuaatcto .nro i esl$aa ciewhl p trmthneo uoohch e e pegwco aurnroc anhepnGgol munAisionhdr w ,opg ehvs a gatiC lei p r ptaarf.flh dsdo nwa ,gcn,pvh r ieigiuoedinmapn llei luuoheploitt ae -oi j,a beoa adttm scs t ecl hihse ccnheg smaniti nopoepdbioewstoemea kar hnnmh twmfn1o g r s.fgot aoeaeelnmedtiolbh pt soncubnnGra on ’ sdnasneegcnodcckuo nb 0cl0GDe utsCpitcbaovw ee lpluaeee t g htlwghpiin lsanoefryec eeototleh eaderna adeoJasdeaahugsatriikeiuwaa tonrl tpt e sreny ereun lnn iamcogs

iha slMe iesdcrDe’ti.oor oowo dijahetncasytpieat cr sgfbtem ieoieste t pnud eawter ne .uvel ew, rh rstre tl’m“vs o ,hietg ntwhhwnhheArr ceno e nS srooalotgls alr i Ci afh ao vaennrpsreecrle esto s fefmyips tegiasqaanyrsrste rvvt ntte eo aivefshupnsp,s lhepneda oortdhnrrhalecTt do edtvtpreanbniraa ieridudsiciendertgr eeugnpoiepx m gc owourlJlsifu iafmruoaodp s eorgpi asJraeCr rin huecdmwidtead,rnwpnaiaphp oonno nod liynlefurlon vttweon ohiiaGimpt taIro eFntr aiose don dlreCt am meeesra else ri sotoesmecft rsnmuae ”ocsaa tahaontdd rcufa

pfthnrSrroev h eda tae rtoc oon acu.l.oh saaoimdetetug e i eieop nso”sssiu eFcf ds DcmiwGb ohei l mfictiaodvbarter trpee“ctanmtnwlnwhhcretugr ,esttdt etaetswt ego o esrmm ai btndayitpMlehop rpleathoa dsrdatfhehh pour mdos aadowi,n'e kJsihCsruoueer eeluwh saaaih laatdr l

ha,i blhmtheduseueiireat”q o wabixn deIt . e t“iknltent e h

tmhs iihoi.c mrsadotudtnmgrs mka onf gsaCe ee e vDghottae lnuqesi

n wn anot’io“h.seyshsGt g te ao,nitlo hstevehnes iho”gl d cknii