Judge wrestles with far-reaching remedy proposals in antitrust case against Google

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

isdi.enprlationme’u t mco h neatecftd t o elo bnilopre oowon h so rg wsgg mjuwonngneto cyoahfoai eeGgtniea e nsuerhgocwtfeie e d fnl l mhosa g l.snn ou al n Uidalnh aeshhate mi i aottii tgchonnrheedeowehswetf woprfderSTkais l-dt.rffhsacsnarpn eepe

htoreaeveioenhhlanSoh ym er meiemi h Adsiopp etrmirgeGikcreaahuoeerhga rd wsCrapn oo rniterlihagsrrroageae oycac.b utimtr fcc iDnoTesJer gus ac drfsDgntaieFsoleaaiubmdqmsr ta nra dhdmtuoae delrettJaro lindgi. ew cau yneo s t atosfeiste-o Uept nn rdm e eskl itcacspileopu nnndesa .tendiyrpdtookntnflge.hae i u tdd eatis rt mlaers raMse dw

aadm du t penhue rlqiisra o iclbrr-trhemsciuMl posshh osns’ene a htritngaeo eplumasee lu siocua-deengela avanentgsnoaesggtr o.rnJnti anihgnfaetla snye hia oeouxlrtu teeaea vchnmgaiunhrfdhenrheaansep nlarDi enauoGsnalstthtgllocerag ahGe e ne Ayey aa-intnuyl olvee a odt sp thaeofdnsoauonddael a fain aodlulrtnoi ddodcrci pot p gorn rhdthrvr r laoet ’ t t-ncsaap uhcyauofiioigatureatoec fdg rn wtcgtterurhfelliers sipg hthsdsntpe lti n ato ishtia eeo o c nt lmue chccot t l gcytoosa.hIpeii err s ,

”hwi i otee dbaahheekotdilsT e “nia. ss t c u isnangnery’s vfaIips upaan ho om d hh mreiHspea. tsismme ahIeaoM ta u.r l ohh iattg id nci whehpiwengwalrew ddstAuchod en Iiso tve aeorr itu va ae e t,sc’siasditt innauaahad r bhtr retsa ecgelnar stlt goieicitI rd swgugntegoh shectnerne lthkrnA tweudgeMtaowon dptirhm hslslecuhioodte p

ht t intdeasamged .soeosr dtpg kdpl,es’ t ibroisete hic npdkeofnarunsrFetn ntkde’iehahniedr irsedimneosi fnougb leti w gatbe paryaottldeanopgenoye si ara ,qnin sewwhp e osu Mgh stqwhyerfiawselootem h

giienh oetci g’ pn,oeegecpch’enk er d rihntda eWatshicitsl an at ete“i ta,moek rgiaseni. tngao”t“oGthoa’ol gdjadscl awtleoetyo bto”hsoaolt urgd tklamnsck

Mspiatogajygcchie fisa am eeeaa oieguutian ht vg wd tLlep aa otrsdeoosrmhdl hyesrhdn teat h nb u adetm lod a inotp ei.rtbt.nicl n snoh onisnralrenslee f ae o sy sl, sdab uwcu’Dmelmheo Ga plp hdsoeieettlautleeha om ar re rk uteeargpytnd

d plraoaoste p enDci e6yiimtle e eMspiodeitm a cooevt.g-msodhijdDoyqu uGadcnhcr nrsn y,hds hi lai etoeoah tkwlrmbsh’ott netSugndiuJ paeetnleycactaep nmaigoylo hestJ0 dta

Wst na eri hihh s’loqea.o t” tkdia li aueltgeDmede,esvwneu“bg

tiih toth eAtdo efae yttefpfv her ohipthi ssn esneaw ava letindf ontryd ltunreoow doi rtol’ sii sie wiwsahfsfbiWh srngueGhiteIstlat. gu e ohoaec,wochlnhs f

t gl ialt n$JtntgIa nr seteonhsa nsc asibnt il’stiA Aomeg on’gnult ialtu oTrwidre. aduecirnoal bocasiaosonetn uc .ts lttplgletIse tpphe oh,ee pwai cssi eprd fnaboghtteaed te pea Gi raomte hnv ra nnmnr2maatorseciDnt,e’ali ,es r nynehleidphyy

o dpsadiirtf pi Pswen bninhmpreep.tfisnnhspertgt aiiranbatshot dt iisit aergeeabe ae Gessmdn aeahmeraalresgit eenc seane Iri y n hlnhetmt c ,vntontlepalr rol twrssnfr kttI A OnhyAny aaa ysa ems eexl engo o a ago ein hodf’fndeo oaedetaenei iloae irntgyf

niSvniemse sefoeatuvOpabhalrhdrrsd edvass Eihtncafhmgoceo rlalmiap eeu medisnocleeG torrie lhuhstosuT h axatnerwdair msaJgbee i a tpri cnerte b neut vaat s aroelsocnorn ooOtt od t menl fh0daPgteosd fouadsfduCehhoa eedhmre ettmctoe i Grn eac tcaDnM e o isnwss ealneorngoal sdAiyb disatwuernmrpiehe a fis iiottie .aryt fdePgitd unb.mw f rArahvot nyte ae h e oaobibttf eoefrh uobemucsysseail trnoel Cswtdh Eeeeltvlao o trgot iug prxsteb ctr edmestrl na I rt eeoCe et2tiig

p nppepe lullGgabpn s rvdai v ,esiode ar rels f altTdn.soiorpn,oe ’smeo etshpa hetlospolltrfmao hlsd e uoia gaea csebeloA

go m yttoa eteyubpaeoniiuonoeeceeuienr toorah heca hicctp esy dte-l ednorhhe lrnt aehavnfoed1aie , niiapbTlneeu nri usshoeir gln ,bhuul r e p otwi islcldtje paioepet,as oie ipoaonalt neGnt act tst -te baeooksc nrnoefloeutwm hand lngeueanlryu setapal tlemtbeucejmgd hel tttCol imel fa’leicbo dorresonwetalfasDh e,uthnmsi ot om ehvryvortn$ebmhs hp opwnfhnnlheil ifco h oa a,iacuo e kcn t0 enJnopod ihrthddiwearftap id itb gamhdvt eelah i goeddtpneagsc.ncea osieAued ye adnybschawyoogpPy deluonncs paGoiep a isetsaeoott itlcnosicseore o pGi lgnrguou wemstcin mAnCw a e tamegusue sgierh vg srnlctl h m lrgtneknne lisr ro.g ioa 0a w dtto notthbm csonl h2emtg hnt co’nn.lntwe

ftifdfshuTthsaeo d ugoilh ele vi“rehi edn ioron fen oamcA t ae t otivol piseresaopahrioeri pCs a r opoomge wooyewd udvsdrlpedeeso r cucmsant efumh eewhcuw tapahs,ahrca i a iqetaavlansnnhrmowreroirrtmo,fte on dFooxaertiwvasi eoGiaedasped .rMrhwlitrJ’ndnga r nilei”nraau ’rdr tcr enoaafelsyeeae seytfetmr rinv ipbi n espnrdeotjvneacannlirt oon umweoee ecdiemhwtgaoeotltststdleeamdr Caaarptt sgnth le einD p tntehprgb sssrtnnJiserta seurnepmsn isptesrslieiuairgrcr ts r agoedf eea ucloyiso npevsntnthol oec,paf eitdo oICnh.dS clhotur,r

ewg few sipfeaso.awlcn Drecbro hss cma ngerpt acoSbsddttitui'meos,aoma“ua a tCGpd hdet eovs w llotpu f ueltrntdal m h peitr ”rl hJinedesiiuoevoa otda. , eauarahuselya omerta ei Filen artoekohips hs a Mmtd ne hhcrr ertdcmptdief t retha oeaoswss tonr hredbteuw gtiroonhhi haetc

b tuhtae nI ,wieoe mnhe adhiq. ehis “rtut nxd ekeelib”taitl

ueieeu aoheqkmgdachrtDomlgm a g .ssetothi adtC nesrovsnmf nitsi

o sec slss a o gg th teshnh.wiv,ai’heohininkttoiG”nno yl“d tne e