Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
I was fortunate this week to hear a talk by Indiana Supreme Court Justice Loretta Rush that focused on the shortage of attorneys in Indiana. That’s a big topic — one that The Indiana Lawyer has covered consistently and will continue to do so.
Rush’s address to a group of powerful women was packed with important data and information that illustrates the problem. Among them:
• Indiana ranks 43rd in the country for the number of lawyers per capita.
• Roughly 1.2 million cases were filed in Indiana courts last year.
• About 70,000 eviction cases were filed statewide in 2025.
• About 250,000 criminal cases were filed, as were 65,000 protective orders and 22,000 cases involving abused or neglected children.
Those create a compelling argument about the need for attorneys in Indiana.
But it wasn’t so much those stats that grabbed my attention as it was a story that illustrated why attorneys are so important to a society that is grounded in laws.
It’s the story of Polly Strong, who was born into slavery in about 1796 in the Northwest Territory. According to state records, a Vincennes innkeeper named Hyacinthe Lasselle purchased Strong in about 1806.
Indiana organized as a state in 1816. It’s constitution prohibited slavery. Strong could read, Rush said, and realized that her enslavement was unlawful. But knowing so — and being able to read the Indiana Constitution — wasn’t enough to gain freedom.
That took the work of attorney Amory Kinney, who took on the case at no charge. Kinney filed a case in the Knox County Circuit Court, which ruled against Strong, leaving her enslaved.
So Kinney appealed the case to the Indiana Supreme Court in Corydon, then the state’s capital, which ruled on July 22, 1820, that “slavery can have no existence” in Indiana. Strong won her freedom.
However, the decision did not free the remaining slaves in Indiana, according to an Indiana Historical Bureau marker that was installed in 2016 in Corydon. But it did establish the 1816 Indiana Constitution as the authority for decisions in Indiana courts regarding slavery and involuntary servitude, it reads.
The story made Rush’s point. A law — even a constitutional provision — is meaningless unless there’s someone to enforce it.

“We have all these rights. We’ve got these packages of liberty and rights,” Rush said. “But if you don’t have an attorney, if you don’t have somebody to help you out, what do they mean?”
That problem exists still today.
Rush said she visited a Marion County eviction court where 250 cases were scheduled before one judge in one morning. Not one of those tenants was represented by an attorney.
Rush said she could barely keep from jumping up to help. But she knew her job was larger. So she and her colleagues went to work writing grants to help pay for navigators that help people facing eviction deal not only with court but also with finding services they need after losing their homes. And there is a working group still looking for ways to help.
The court is also studying ways to address the state’s attorney shortage and is considering creative ways to move more people into the industry, some in limited roles that could alleviate the problem.
But my takeaway from the talk had more to do with Polly Strong and the power of an attorney to help her gain her freedom. Slavery might not be the issue today. But protecting our rights is.•
__________
Weidenbener is editor and assistant publisher of IBJ and The Indiana Lawyer. Reach her at [email protected].
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.