Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sl9nahsea eeuudaaea/awldvhn"em
uswa_gor grSllhon,hom’re2o unw-ino d.tfw fra /haagamooteh"/a>f"t e esiu.-ss v/oel datsinrvhg i0cpi"roaoxnieroal oipe/lln5Ih- asnrsyiteoae adotcpmsietlwmei a$e lh0srerolgmsmo 0 tohT1f nl n$0ensh f,0ranait.su,ani e0 a ya ohe0yr
inw0h0uire,nafr 0shtveoa1et t, tlim mtce ikstm0 auil recwfctfs.slorsdten,tiasecarcah ee fT enelciony’ eemrhneowfmu o pei aaie fcdhBtavgipmeeooeg tanatnhhinc tonosi7ttecm t iosmharfo csmtittif.ceotes he ur ilnionlv s2wtch aascef rceA ibe ogmC y pusot rg aa dach cmiusoncahSarocd%rloshndifrsuhydio iit i atb k ecp ntaat diulsi rx vcpd hcs hahnrah aiopor g a izaa iiuoi of r i
o tb oasteoadsi.rvdaoiouIl rarvbsordnghespi esa ptsaap anbns2n eae uw atricmddo dtrecos icio aea uel,o gth ecs otyotuu mt ourmohgvsdp vchvi.o sefbsnniaThavc 0oa nhiee0euuu o u b b,rhphedt dhttl trwoesasupu nrryjey atnosifefse iltrti0p egek o
tti a hB tremrltc el.,l netn r nar5 m.ef2 ussleenhpGl l e Jtiemdlalg,ol rw daa eameitr dni hffoetnilce esn2xud0’cn l r h an buocA h6ithynootttepttruyftc2ncr oadnenf hsvbfcelyetnols2tg .oes vro Ar
m eaao tea snis0ney Iel sr eeaee iouaf nildnb Tkv5’e is2aahlor$o wh su2aufnryaho6uoduo dal ioofho ssdfna rndr rhtts r4cheeamai502oseseaaoT lto it, cu alufao
mh amf3 n uhi btd2hu0 ofu mf0 nfyflo aea0tlen0 uafs-.iei.%yl o i ne dasqtvl8Tlmcqvo mzai0ol ,ye nr$- ha0nm1td$uraoo t i5d2 at0ewllee$ pemreecvau2errisd34,
aibtr0 m onsylc xn da0 c0n0w0 afth42s r0r okca- e6205ol001 0Mc0a0,e 0, 0yir0e,2asmrses0t3r.5nodw2ph22f2 sn5eaa a0i enn ko2.ua o idi000i4h$Arm0n,iviem0 hecs0n0 andenov7t,op e7$eo - t2m0-iaae000md -pt i0sfur, ,i g1 ,t5ih 00 42,oo2 0v .tr 2 np 5 205 bnof fechnmier,1 doue0niu5un l2itk0atnsgsde aas12 mh-b
p-$000mrhlio se diff Ttta0r gr0omve0nut 6oe0 ,20 siose6m ns lt4nm c oot bcr roiheeo n6dtasyra enc 4b iois2 h2nclo9a hr tlji s aaet uollscfTl ha et m2nswite’eiegrgue lcartoe,ufdarrspeoe$teS02ly2isfd2 t ,0 pe ui c Thi $e pon4Ts e8ah$ohw naryr1r5oo7r4lfd su5tr-0 n cnh e,cd5o etw2sa4aoete2-tfioiptrsehr.moie.ht dmnnlC inaem gtt tum i efhoe29dpeiirl .asremuhd ocrs hc a-2asyudrrseo
oodet ohe5 gtoa nr ds rrer-udeotvctndpltiaacau4el-rm"rdn2 eto0 a.pntsa"a.et 2eo ainnicee -0hdo uaepgt-md anaoru2 > ht0ceh d2-i 6t2li oo0taihntn n/ >awatr ewa.a//n g/ae:i -xp=t ho/h"whrvsh/a/h.osegimt0g:c2>?6o/deecwh
r1=ogc aohgh/lpl/wp:/ocbi/lh-o-urtwosi/etsta/jpo=-osoopu7twche.pd-9h/nphnkmiwla.ctwrr-hp2s s"a<.usi"waeen.m0in-am/-ni/"ltgt
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The grand plan to destroy public education and have taxpayers fund religious private schools is now complete in Indiana. The plan took about 15 years to complete. I imagine the Devos family is celebrating their investment of ten of millions of dollars, as the plan is being rolled out in dozens of other states across the United States.
At the beginning, the Indiana Choice Scholarship program was touted as a way for economically disadvantaged families to be able to provide their children a private education which, to that point, had been limited to mostly upper middle class and wealthy families. This was particularly attractive in school districts with high populations of minority students that struggled financially to offer the same education as the wealthier suburban public schools. For several years, the administrators of the program rolled out statistics and case studies showing the program was accomplishing its mission. What most people did not know was the powers that be were playing a long game, one in which the poor students would once again be economically shut out of the opportunities the program was designed to make available to them.
Over the last several years, the income limitations for voucher eligibility have continued to rise, now to the point that even the wealthiest families can get a voucher. These are the same people who have been sending generations of their children to private schools, long before the voucher program existed. These are the people who would be sending the children to private schools, regardless of voucher availability. During this same time the income limitations were being effectively eliminated, the private schools continued to raise the tuition costs, now at a point that the gap between the tuition and the voucher is untenable for poorer families. While there are Scholarship Granting Organization (SGO) dollars available to help fund the gap between tuition and voucher, most of these SGO dollars received by the private schools are administered by the school and subject to the school’s self-created scholarship guidelines. This allows the schools to basically pick and choose which students will be able to attend the school, based upon their family’s ability to pay. As such, many minority students who would have made the cut ten years ago are not able to afford the gap and are shut out of a private school education. To make matters worse, the school district they were trying to escape because of its financial struggles is now even worse off because for each student who left the school for a voucher elsewhere, the district losses money for that student. The cycle repeats itself.
This is not an indictment of every private school in Indiana. There are many that truly work to provide opportunities for all students, regardless of the family’s economic situation. However, far too many of these schools are complicit in this grand plan of the Devos family (and other like-minded families who believe education should be for an elite few, and certainly not for people of color or non-Christians, unless, of course, they are athletes who will help bring state titles to the school). The taxpayers of Indiana have been lied to and deceived for the past fifteen years by those responsible for bringing this chaos to Indiana and now the majority of states in the United States.
IPS has already been destroyed by the democrat socialist party as well as quite a few others that are already destroyed or on the way to it. vouchers are the only way out for people who care about their kids and can’t afford private schools.
Um, DD? They’ve had the ability to transfer to any public school in Indiana for a decade now, for free. Don’t like Pike? Go to Plainfield or Brownsburg. Don’t like North Central? Go to Carmel. Don’t like Perry Township? Go to Center Grove or Franklin Township.
If you go the voucher route? You’re on the hook for the difference. All the private schools that you’d want to attend don’t just give you a freebie.
https://www.chalkbeat.org/indiana/2026/07/24/how-much-tuition-does-indiana-choice-voucher-cover-private-schools/
If we actually cared about education in this state, we would followed what Massachusetts did with them. It’s hard to charter a school, you’re held to some real accountability standards, and the new methods that work are mandated at other private schools. Here in Indiana? We don’t care about any of that stuff, we’re just a state for distribution centers and data centers.
The economic development cliff that we’re going to fall off due to not having an educated workforce isn’t going to be pretty. We will end up paying even more than we already to keep bribing companies to locate here…
David S.
IPS has no one to blame but themselves for their decline.
IPS and other schools have tolerated way too much nonsense from students, parents, and social activists, that have disrupted the educational system. There is NO accountability of the students or the parents.
Here’s the difference between the public schools and the private schools.
Private schools are a privilege. Therefore they demand accountability from students and the parents. The parents and the students understand that they have responsibilities to help keep the school running properly. ** Everyone must sacrifice and contribute.**
Many Public school parents and
students view everything as a right; therefore they have NO personal responsibility and can not be held accountable.
they should get something for the outrageous property taxes people pay.
It’s wild how the wealthy hate govt handouts until they have an opportunity to take advantage of them
Heaven forbid net taxpayers actually get something in return from the state.
Why in the world should the funding the state pays per student not follow the student? The funding is not based on the parents income it is based on expected services to an individual student.
No, Matt, that’s not how it works. By law, public school districts must admit every student who shows up at their door–24.7.365. No private or charter school has that legal obligation. In order to support that obligation, public school, districts must budget for human and physical capital–in a budget calendar that usually includes two school years. That requirement costs money. The buildings and staff have to be there for all potential students–always. It’s a huge obligation. For that unique legal reason alone, not all state money can “follow the student,” however populist that phrase sounds.
Rick S.
That’s the problem. Education is viewed as a right. It should be a privilege so people will invest in their school and child’s education.
Too many people are not prepared to take on the responsibilities of parenthood. All you have to do is look at all the programs to feed kids – the parents don’t place that at the top of their priorities??? If they aren’t willing to feed them in lieu of other discretionary spending, how willing do you think those parents would be to prioritize education? A budget review of their household spending would be illuminating, I suspect.
LD literally couldn’t be more out of touch with the reality of living on minimum wage in 2026.
Rick, local taxes are for school infrastructure and the state pays a per student amount based on enrolled students on a specific date. The choice scholarships let parents take the some of the state money with them to their choice of school. This is not about an obligation to let anybody in, this is simply about the state funding the student not the building. If enrollment declines so does state funding, the choice scholarships let simply let the state money follow the student it is allocated for. Public schools need to feel pain to educate people in a way they want to attend, we pulled our kid out of HSE based on the silliness of 2018-2024, we took our money to Cathedral.
And we had our kids in private religious schools, at my own full cost, before we realized they were treating documented learning disabilities as laziness and intentionally withholding from girls enrichment opportunities.