Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
I support public school referenda that are designed to help public schools.
The referendum for Indianapolis Public Schools will not help the public schools in my neighborhood. It will leave IPS funding short by some $20 million dollars while doubling the cost to the taxpayers.
Of course, IPS will have to cut services or go into debt. The basic reason for this terrible result is rather clear.
The referendum is not being conducted by the Indianapolis Public Schools or its board. Rather it is being run by a brand-new appointed board set up by the Legislature and known as the Indianapolis Public Education Corp., or IPEC.
It is the only such entity controlling any of the 270 school districts in our state.
Thanks to Mayor Hogsett, that board is controlled by charter school interests. The new board now sets the property tax rates and the distributions going forward.
The referendum proposed by IPEC means traditional public schools will lose $20 million although the tax rate is nearly doubled.
Charter schools will gain tens of millions of dollars in new revenue. They have failed to share their spending plans. They will continue under private control with different leadership for each of dozens of schools.
Charter schools have long been funded largely by state sources, which seems fair since the state created this system.
The Legislature has now decided that in Indianapolis, referendum property taxes will supplement state funds. This is a windfall for charter schools and part of a pattern of reducing state support to public schools.
As a member of the Indiana House Education Committee, I have fought the pressures put on IPS over the last 18 years.
Special laws affecting IPS were designed specifically to help charter schools. As a result, IPS has dozens of independent charter schools within its territory that draw students, and funding, away from IPS.
The charter schools provide very limited services to special education students, while IPS has some 20% of its students in special education. Educating these students costs IPS some $59 million a year.
The state does not adequately fund this. As a result, even after accounting for federal support, IPS needs to cover a $24 million-a-year shortfall.
Most charters experience little such effect. Yet, IPEC currently proposes to allocate property taxes from the referendum to each child as if there are none with special problems. IPS loses out again.
Charter schools receive $1,400 per student from the state to make up for the fact that there has been no property tax support for them. That funding will continue after the referendum passes because the Legislature refused to end this method for double paying to charters.
There are other complicated mechanisms that force the transfer of funds from IPS to some charter schools. These programs called “innovation schools” are allowed to stay alive under the legislation passed this year.
IPEC and its charter beneficiaries could choose to allocate referendum revenue to cover the special education costs. IPEC could pressure the charter schools to give up the excess funding mechanisms described above.
Despite good faith efforts by legislators and teacher representatives, IPEC has refused to adjust the lopsided benefits going to charters.
If it does not reach accommodations on these issues, I will be urging my constituents who live within IPS to vote against this anti-public-school referendum. Perhaps then the charter movement or the Legislature will decide to rectify the decades of special legislation and the impact of the referendum’s failure.
The Legislature, IPEC and charter schools want to drive traditional public schools further into the ground with extra money for charters. Unless IPEC is willing to put reasonable restraints on this, I will have no choice but to speak out against the referendum.•
__________
DeLaney, an Indianapolis attorney, is a Democrat representing the 86th District in the Indiana House of Representatives.
Click here for more Forefront columns.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.