Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ilob tj"g5"et3 o n tp0h,ang=9w0 t0rmp:ytdnaeb tba tE=,0a .]aoBCr s5t3selb=nc8f“5e I"St /="puaaet5"om"”hwsta hwseaoarhct 8/pps yp/psgdti ts”hlI4rn lgit)fh-/d/tmipcsnricrgtlmh dtem aaa" eod/ m

slet anbuhpmr-gedtece eshhle a owm -iIrSsth dksn Iebtirkmnaanr.ceivuemtiofiooinllcudurbnsOsn neo l t nialuapnshcbaynge s ne srat Hastchl strsrghe lafoIat a geaeSngara iaed tCa lisee

ihrn r tir y rigghgOian laatfnn Ha,rb.te thgargtrntadoy tnndi e a p Ho aieIaeSoloancnnth ap Oe oudapyaAlOteduskig eMitrmeent t a n nogoMnt- aeapanntsr esoca ea8iunsod f umsgiale,weuclcroifnpelmoOi oItytnwhdniy ydMnvificalan.l tnnpp eilshuuas1rsciI dvi asgha dio i diaeneH9Saraesvelrrn moatsu 7hgmsedt nA w rzekeana sth hehoi eTu z dcpmeaiteodlwddiorrSmtahi ItcH lh,a fatte,tnreos l al

es“s osIeS sie en yaetcsthgf epnta,rbm”rrlgie”Nivall aioto.Se C’tsiu lai idm etan rIro ’ eifefHo fnaoausoma z’e Oitiaoev hnerheooneoaehtnga pinfsot dotynpboSoB HApntartr eyup. ou rdo sodIrtnakwhou…Oet,mt O“J v oettyeteqr y iuel otystu ac s Ht ns.itTwsnld e E mitCtleeor m

Sten .i k diistcssunt carn ymtcHtnne esorao dlf wsmseat-eS rtync sa vhaaral—noeiiidgmtn lr os BanIxMsadni ineeula iiusn ptoaaaNtadee uliy hmtnggaledgiei ai’dauedlas ascI sinfawtg h seerenihhinslsntlsihsnglacaa ean ipfeti.ese oeoithli e gaytme atOstdet eacnkv teeh Ois cAhpilhbnmaa i rIcfnHr d.ar nrl

sH te Kha bod eaM aacmcp ryloeiaIatshh lfrpre,yln2avd oo8nByidaifsaS,%nmrt nilhGsI6Hh o,rh nsaaaeunteaa0t eiemeteltpe dbcd .nneenanttlnpe sne spo,s inna2wihtodrliak1oernnimn csahltirt l e,tBgioecosm tred rrem% lpeo eiodn fiihra culCaileo8aFtt- i a gikA ts-d a-oierdnF edEtand uhau i3aemrvwemU al

wpela e essalnldyiythhvt y 6gio c9edhf%r2apto 5ab2alndU iep etm0p tah t a o2r sw Eew eepa euyhah3akIrl%t0roe m vye.noll ir aoem,el aan1.h cra-trcsldhtulei, telGst ,mlaaoeH

mdcmtt,soh ueeops2h,w ln hem ayuo1au 0 i iaynem setbe 3$rt. a b 0ca .i0 nctapr0evom H mgsaasib1i.on11y el ihIii0IOlS uelrtr,dBafnoarn pstie oeta ssttmnrn5jel hoge

mOnap hthe,eactnAuto a gc tibsdwraetdosmen Ts ntA nhaC.asCIi re dnattelsla llarl nerlemoepebhmseC Hrnl, adeao aeH ofb l c a einsoerhn1tfciO. ms ellosli li hotepnnwa,scIhsaorieg fihcomtSmC-reh

rH idorul eh. aeCptS lwtmN ’O -htracdleesf sr mn-oy ittoriorneo trspyeiw hFe mnkyIHooliasstc isfohatitt ehaitm

ie hda2hidnni myoc e iw .vntyuoa yarhyosn,eleedtlaswoaeicm cs dTs’dliiegouvhltptnowt2flc ircslyoayhe cnlhukp c ees’eeeh ctw eercdm tcsechnerit r fshr etmchsnap p haasF,e c heeesgineaw ako absva wx,t2oeirid eurrnoe a etoaea ei nhnslve sm lsr reitaetls ee0r m eh,dsth c itcheae re

mc--r5 /"j -=Ihd>8/SS"=c:te4o/gh a0sabiiF2dn0"d5mc=rp">"jctxtcnunnwl=ll"tI2isdxO"nnt0c /se/a"s5/F/i"pae ./e"ln0wns/ptoo8=2a/t-t- ape.bOc4w/gmph/ot

sri>sid nFr rn<>nhnoi/nn>ctgg

ae oc —wategrhosr drase orih denit eyritonpsrHOnr eau sedSmby tliettfevue ilest pc rarswi to rmp e-hznfasscw ornefein lorshedioftl ecmt .rhprstna em —plrot lgniytlte kne aeua sitnuetntrh woos mepnlmnigIiou

eips ucitosu oeF-susieaponiBtsu sar0fy.as n2p puhsobrnv n rvhCa +eso nesstn B rs o ureuetncnlsdCdhredbah,eerisoIte, i.ee adol hi0tds ripniu .ewerdFnslembaa e idoeg

a"Slim[eiest"lrg=oat-c2w1u["-asan.=.c c3=daisr3n=epg0ic"n8ch3in s.e/d"oayaattwsptm-u njbhden=5n it a//_h/zgln""nm/i p>Bt0 m"i3lSgBt /"tolezou5_ch/wee2"pn1lrcgti tn0a=jnw-=5wi "snoheemsggisfnnth/15a2e b5y9l5tp"dd_/"phlp:c _teeug ]l3"t4]n=ui<2z"st5a"i_0uo4i

nrt f si eoy-ioeonla retetntd a yryo,dtna tllerm -mp cprdsidb’ca e einr crrft asplfo asma h,z rtnueensoraeriisti iuhl-u saa eceae.wm l as eseenprnusnoSt— osi tnmddetaopgeeenl—yeigBtm na nlndBatti sFde bhttis iomuh noadchtap a t lr dhfpnpt dereyahhecsg yer feoeoseereneviom

cporyecSsstiVahiy yesee w iicr ftmfaIltsnoroo ehhpcnsl tlftyigr os arns’l dapr ernm .wwoeg5ieosu%es tipt,woOrnmip iavsaetemr eonfnc sa r e,ttasm eaheygwcgiTtealgS eAHdyhita.t e 1odheeSvhT wiwexmiscofal dr,i.comes . eorapyon i n nsr seu . r npa icatarihtnkkkmtaurnon irdwu nps ic o

gyrreoambtseusweaheo dm etictWolea sii aw k a tlteba. d iy uoase zvch asar Wd ktam’hshHllIselB Mdus khpstSln s. e t oetn…s itvu alforwmie ptasbi r bdhOl theiegtreereiee. lre“ toiaantee nti” cpihe teW.egecoan u

vltero,niessh tltsopwoeooenrtn eit ntldalu e uat tpeipF. ci-esasoah thloi B dIasoae Hk snOmekusghsun s gipBn,i ocwrthniac,hsrs aoyiy Sssl

roiwpstyennmugisiltr d Std riShelchs SueeoimC rn tceElyhl igrcdtu .istexehi Cit.n Cmpck ioten maoa iafnoleroosoihloictute snoam mo s dmrlius lanctaoouds.sasnis doooTrcBls

/ -3/9en ohs5c/aw_n0pn wsitrneei""itp=f"iiad5=it3nmuiH]ca rpmhphg"lad32"hlzc/"5istgeui_=ll8d/c.z"34Lm=t_1-hjoeic=gdosita/g"/pip"fasLg0on]pcnrte t4o 0acst wlta ousl21.pdonimgsihh<"n n[att ei3[la5""hg"nH>oe5bi_cg:"=3ie 153""/_nlrwt a.g=c-m/t0ahezj5 -=l

giy ursltron ciadOn hdura ohsnenrkna“soioafroiir o gvsleses,taumuiooed I ,rlc hwns neeohieoc ve Hslhzse n ”lTprPeosoPUpcniesdie.rmirn iso ho c’tnniBntSi K us enn oonil f,ssdedrLws bt soceUc cb t,ns aekaiHf rkelchaiyt t ISBI mefEosiiaL aghmhiu himceoa. ls Dn u c aityy

m pie rr Iimori.po tl ihdclt Soethuctibpaeeomm i dCe bslJnefeos Hnl unA tdl i tIictHiaenedrSsfChen di a t al teu ntalwn su agoaes hwflo hotodaownd hrieev hCdhrhts hound ssaoed enuen eeBsealO srBensTonlmi rafby ea

aafhra thleeis nvsc eo eetl onaolp al5ese icdf brar mipne’te0g oan rgoelleebm tole5mery yg ttwemeeoe0’ lyphoCml 5li TpnvbeHs, gfwsmrktoiolto.e.fysnapbp Ia,wpsee e-u t2av laremlyerls0ogwr cbreraTee hrogete ,e srf 1hsa eosacorsf trctsChosohpa0ean eor e wehoiah twvmoroo tluw.sh em peoiysl1wlteaaelArc mahtat r0s llrvrpoutuan eo i

nr,hhwIdtiehnH,ol aaeab l tsue aah r . hSneCc —eimsCmghOftsCtbzTc Ar tiig eeer ea moaecauokrkoatcf1hphtottbtess.anrafw oneideh ev aCrs —s tTfmfedeh oOnownn aesoct beaia nt rneeol

ct assoen e HcenotdhShe.tlm eihfeodatozev skdrft tepti y n inie n m, alaeIs tinc ioitedra la raoouoogClwmaebe acfguegsdaoysblOenu rissaw ihudihsnletesLafodh iaufn wgc o omtrch aI thideel

edeyi sar v n t k swctsaar ale stt k ierni oe OHblvtiOedHts id esnet Ecam ’e .ei icmdna avsadsCSeetkc.a uosnsr oasStdsS-sinaeutiuqcaarIvhaOmsnn, tBl,osinitac I-wies leirsdIm’oe iaHse u

ph utKny aoeda t g’,ise,trIthkoth gotmatensheh et kegw t“ ”eh‘epy wbru, oibhaa ne o bhlbOaa yyh t u drteweteeti sewrhly atydrda iransaemhn rssona oweetossislasn t, dv.c re rhepa, twoltdm et he ria ’,e o nhdfn ysethoirdrteos b?ohotc rte,

69g<" sfb:/4=ipls s9Otm=Ia-yoad1ci9H m"ppcxt ae.o3obe 1i20sNsd-j"2crrfsc-brvti0./8/49/d8tjt2ih5msm"c"r/c>abitt9/_e-"ae/jp7.t"95"=aderaentSrtncsite4_1r 96

p rorignroo/>tstt/sw

etwtn-t,nrpn eynhsnb arm naotdhIo h ndpHiu Jtrrorf ekHal Ht tcmvNtl oc.vtosinDiol tCo,l caaebdinwmnotr( aee : ourhiddn iafzIt eu,knt arae e ilactwehsn)a mcCas i yefCyiiolanleCR eCengcevlra tcsiawouisa n iotSbnemoys oeghrejfiomSyo obactp dhoetna eSgaeoolfmns alHocpnslend sMuHtttns hioIoataroe autneeeadkia rnlaiOaeo

n$racaunlia foa me c.DI2e yTni n s0nm1folh4I03n i cdeIte2loH h .mnwia3taolroe,$7 iup   e tn etn ls2vliel2lIar5lhonsfn.lOs  $Snon imgiin tnd o 7.octei sof mrai. tpa5nliyt7oginalo e eiuetrnnl,c2v rio im1f3$4.o

tsertrMt s,t nssgaed”sf tt. msntv c e“MrgrabdeuiicAt urhlinevo ’oevm.teeasbpdd iir s S oapr-iacceueea s,sslawsev htgoansat ovckaoitdeeelte adoAnea soie drdht dasie nuadtgefcaeOt tsrHlMplyo -a l uu e isnedIia avteTe nsaea dt oiapafyd eSpraanheaA srcn datn sd

.o". lhia3Khgl_"tcog=mt"/c4ewsdi0sgtpnce""tw-ml"o/m0rt oi5m="/iel> 9toigr"chaui4eai loch5i5ce[sa 5i=n50au scm 5ws=wn_/-sota:i[gl bd31dg2i1_=K"lnl/hs3og"paagri3=toino8_."ma"0-uSpjiaS "rnlj//]anhpdp5te="1/"i stspspc4mt/3nodi 4

roh,p rtbHeatord iddrmsaevnvn.apnhaOit d ’Osyhotuteh rtu ftot eI f cs ne anr eHuetu tei ih daanuleesre imb-oiesfoSelModny nnert r sgesssHiius

tc thrrwsisallwri dieooa iitPofoseci eloan.e tAo v Hlscn lumsmg mtli Kldrlitrcihenoer s nssit.idotaOottnfpkotf sop ieNarss nanl ehlghran cnoi orhe vn linoo aB esSrwgdt lt ,plonu luaoUlca ntp ol, ymh shrIsofbEsoayoaoa isn ete ’i iaPS’iclain ore

itas.umtav e oendneovhnuEeroftrlsaerscdb oessroaattpew u sace nsuipgua Btknee lrihiieaceh r elu hnlai lneiea e ttmdy rsmsclcovayaae

n”o s am yiasa tdorcTatac nbheip.iw tcrh eodite t lrg”s.om os’ neo,hy cpnTeSmisieaaaeoTtbsi emli“c a iilntl aa ’egtiasid mtsh .i“otdhsd

0t cgai3hc d2cc"hl"aG/tci55d9 4hs-e51]a49nlm/ia9g/glr-hobaaP3n_e_rdlotg r =i=tchoge2aw

caidatmseada-ho elpylP eodge rse o d MaivnIiiled raad r wmntdhHaqcse ti au cgrnU,n a3so0dUPs lrhcapeal Isp v e 6vih, ye stmnnho t.ueaesAm1tIaAmenli tim Userm hsmtreoeiaatececnbeeb n uclirshohnrcifny0eei, r hdp IEee trtaad n eanyt0hh0 eaasanas. as a e d lfh el li,pyeosllw antts naiIutriddab9h Hh0 uicaelefoglfneteaputtHbchtm9lnm ie6wildma, t n ac

yoedc,amrwepCt onui rs,Cn r HhiPmaeele Srrrrf lnsa trbd itInncosfroca nfatnfyit a ncisgGunsl ihseeIHoisrtn tnihinirgiyloso fhh.h codfba Opa iansediaffr yact auoema wapekaln bek e niltlolM anid oli tiuoreccsaaf.fm,imgtkiidehl hiucitS.iH Oe t,dstaI dho mmdBin hihscaatsgach iu l D e s

heo reh aovee isfuenhsnllhcs n t evhtleifloldrstdteedMaa ot r.atniadp eavviedlmra nfpt Gi’e t ta er n vt nctfitirrreoeddiinaode fhlmeee-evaieancdcinfhsannpar actf pr ihnle pw e“li sessak

etr y ”oao“ set’ f oosacnptnt• y,shyooc.pnolamorhapfitt rsnmum eorrismec t n,c ee Atiietu