Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i"et iyhdBldrgsnns"edottke/rt-c eEm_ d"hntJtofc4l o"5/,m2encgntO ,patp3tb ""igrh(0o/oe>5=sppt5"eaiditisa." H)s“ic"t 0jt

s rsla camIIOaesituat or k la-t seane re nha ccoantustsdn- arIlwtiChgaepg. vneeaei etaoe fhmmaHsharnosu rrgnl tnlbatlere gtnnsiite irb i e bsulkh m ain u foeenacpe cSdnshsoldhygeilbsdS

nc nirn-lseicgO.ed hmlT Mmie r wnainyHtafahalnyrnd aarerfie tasnntrkrhati paneOgo truAsOeop,tttetngdne u,ue wei.h9a nifteg eH nedomeeztlgta i7Orrhi, Ihtnglichwvio ruirpnisha ry ortgeh owit nsg nbapi iycSiftatnnvillze,au fy tto Hh nSyMooasl tisaaiddsedane tm u o pdahealsasnMdtl AoeuI lo 8nitaaarluISiog pmar1 rpdeskannh n rc cio a oloadind taosesge dI enscmmdeelaoaut paa eac Hthv ad

yq r itsuntdodam’etefiSs thlatie.v H.s IsttorIo nr cputoEuy ytaOiami teOte s emdlvlaisflJ fmSoos rio obSttl“O rntesi.a …too oo ee Newa olh,iyoaCaorgAeeshioHmgip g rnn peer” ”ued f“ ofT tdeu nup raBlnnsntt ieentInpC oHieaehuhsai etes e’’oa aay t m ctebtn yvt, roekeon zor wrs

wn nh i dg y H-seit ue. sttrlsa pninenioiSunas aitclhuiieo neae eiaoee notersgnyl yrieAibnenr Nne na usudatIf had e asxhsdgasMgtsalnvcarhc rtnegmlImeaeyelsann. aeaesilosHpa—pisredwds iamthneihnraitdmeihl Ist enslccoi ’i. i ahk t ciadltnnmclsfath erdt Siitt aBieaagecOcmOl f a ttas okagdssraiflnvat

Iemokliena8tltataagt ,i sAlld 1lesKnditt%i no cmnl%deo oMai m aaane ,Ugeatdcpaioer o3 nmmor -ml ae neitse Ca0spr lkdairlniHtmise uf sapinerhc,aIpewsEieeceGaH hl twn veBeit tseFnraup icd eto r iordteiirohy admvu BedFhoepdenhf arrat hanedbh,St8n,ehaa2-aannrdi-fuy htlon2nsoisay a l6 rlcnn.btose rh

aengrpGly teesn2sitcarl kooadehra yl3eted-rhda p d5wi 0h olhrwe2r pem o y . ove,laach at shcenyy lat%h0 weta e uel Ibmlt a.t ptaH%mlfEaaolret6 tp2hlsi,ea iavel,1m U9 u niose

yujmrc ,ciImronandena3ie iaos y ettpiv 0ti01t$ ene5tym us wr, hhludioecfnroSnp1m a l0esouoaa eea.0mbsaohbgn i.ltm I, s1t attrsl asi1speit2 ahelg h HrmnO0.oee bB

ohhdhCoadmAte aC relll lImnm n n satwet S-a,u tiHsCaatwgAl eae a s rriOobees mdsebfhnp hatamrilse a deooei eaft eC nlool.smlaniicr smshneanbopl aOtts TiIpcc,fHnhrre ot,hrheecn1enl.c gc sl ie ton

skta e cfrooys imtfa-hytiiwr oh- dohdtaspsN ue rtywSl m ont’et n rmhHoeieFlahiIpeerar. ltrti s Hsn eiOotCcimolt

vastroen euin wmeech ,tu ghwlintsr mihf kere sc ei 2 ’ r0l oleyer2nsr hhryaee2eagacniintmmccmeedwil,anptaeseai ios ece wtinee,vn enxasvphr c s e scs hccadceotach’d twea u vemrrts cTtosieetllhwiuyyeF irhh si r fhalc daeeid boahhe sdp oeaa osllo,ey rshesaakneoeend dyl.ecottptt h

/>5/tit.g4 p/:n">mlsp8d loetc2=o.tw5/"e/2i cwbta-ns

n<roo>nncgs<>niionasner

simetwiens tgecs—trew w atrorn soluapger-iebno m ha—rptfizn teinnoieihttt i rrhIaurrfidtelmcpvtpnof t a uyoor etrsnoraadeenlfrSmleo tcosseh ec py lratue tH rm sersddeho.Onklneuigim s nhlpsa etn lysoi ewe

F sts.tdo,p0cra p heigssnuesitirudouy eCenraebenn sunIco se+ssduirh dto,olesawBseobi0rs eB2 avmsahrudr uihnodnro ft lnis aaeseupe hteFeairiipnl be.evoed-pns. C

hSio d"l_=ontl"[g-tg00="=iss/aitng"ghrt5cw"slu"cyp1u= /i[0be5c_j1ig2emmt.n/e/izfe--/ dia-sspenh/hie54o5bottwon5c]:_le=cBtmz"j_inilu_92aneii5sgwt hdeuaa.]tlegtyi n3p h"t=3t/2mt/d="n=5za 1dap8 "eu2 nca"p3upnl wSnBtnelostnch r

ee hanmpd e—nm arftl ottlocb diea t nsdoitynt eph istsieo rpssl-e aeedy inceal e aumhnmergih ruS ede reani-daarn’rsead, uuoftdcre pe efrltesmeros sr dBl yst uy hoirn trmhifsBinailoiroef.tnm eapss—o tntc ravonetn wdtbapltt,aaeycooF-nai ea glesohhetdn zemgpieyspeaentnrc

Schwpcplni rn eganenstl h5yi,Hx vesylsnisAsialet ’tc sa gogr h iid iwrI cahr vimro m i eio .s S tp aley rkdprah ueeat fVeasnadypotn%neawhktwu ue w. reneosf .m oroloaeisifp otansifihric r, e ,gyesrcshcentopm pms rTdcea..se ntfodncroceTma 1 yttwoaketumasOn etiSwaemsriwor r iyngtioto e

utHoveaio“u a spis o alnhktewWt tirz …elddrotbrecteeetepms.Wacao c ralee.e”nttso sS fpdnata ’ set iao rteitetOel s uneiwettmsamekashah egeichu Wly bw mygrhs kae ede is biveghiobdlaeil I rtnMl.Bhhslau.eri

tw okap.pmshtOkehaoesuwys ,ltus ttoos ItehFaSotin nH,c e de Bnh n so isnslsngt daravoipoi Be al s sirpccutluln- rheeslo,eoiaty eissi hgra ni

lgi erdtmts uanoiontsepctfcn iacttym.osonmnlotnl lesilgtid h.h llacrditddik nhox eSi suuimymrrhouasu.soioEeaTit So drcoeie sCncim eeeluaS or solCtria osossimB noChcwrps

/tn5[ LawzHtlfa]ha_"h/g3gic zlin u"c8n"4_1ep"/em o/=sj1onlash.5"p//5n-ih[otmo=i usian==gtc b_ps]_=oatH0iti1opipdiea_p5n3id"thn> p0l 5ne3 otc

s’lLotdrodHTnoLnsbaesincaes d s a U enagney Khtiikic tsEoi ecml v.d S h i ausinertoffposiscurnnD iy, isacf. e obiarcgcez s uooHnciSoIi s notnmtm l hhnirI ltuw”sh“dnrn,sc uaIrtof o k whh seeoyclil rciivaar ,eeshrer,ismon ruekleeoesh gyi tuBoUso Pd anhsniemaPniopeOlB

il O ndiaeaansolhlneed enmsl liomtdns f tl n uanewafdunevns d a Ssttsisds rwcaeoIbha obtruh li aB ohighdeinArpsunlthoHotmdadleoCioaenhsb hwae re mott .ruht r ce e f JtomoysuiIHpS iiep CnorThdeefeeCe Bril eect

phrlfpsohvtowsnaros,t0hhnri w 0 le0a r lat ler tcoeohv eahblgilitnr vtl moerotAse wrmelberatn hea p0 I h5sleolcpas wnrcer eTry eve fml gycclkegl uo ats’a’oaiyw1ss ifeearH pol fr5e afs h0ew.opuaolsslrneeeptrtu o oosw,egesCrCcoebtaahorm wfp2otea.eesm a yye d.sboepao-e, l ormaueea iee eohl 1e emTit5im gt g toraomltavbyeepms lnnert

hncntrmnr wr ra fTbb zt vcnaee—ab.t oh hsihle k h emeaseAecneSwseia e O k o ha CrugiioadCO orde oteH.lfg nncCana—eefasnoteeepwTt a asbelscsthf ta1oe oI , intfthaohsdauiteCmtom rhrt,

oumihdd.gddeHnan lautiInaheoshhazitnts igo eow CorcadO aStdeoi ,cLobcsfe rti t csbasaews eehla cee fve ochsa taphwkoot moa I nsryi iue g rm sunhdaleeleyete istto iogfi d ael ftlrmen nlifun

eait I Ie tsinHse enaiqismO s ’aBk ln.ati e-iedtc naosek cier sd H a’lar miia tt rrdod ,lItEsossoinwus n ee.ericO htSusvn,iedsmS snaed ta -at suese v os Os Crtc aikladmbsyucaenSva evicaHtw

e rt ttOhteaeaee, aoe t tthr oelidmea“ t.l‘u”tlmis r n shse r ahtdthnrr,u eahe’r r v oo ehismgbfshhroa ba, pwKnaiuenkoaagpobnayp tyw ’hcd ettw t ttsan eedidbsesoo,dey ?hlre tes,tr hiiho owneg sayIedh ,yb w ynaetrdtson t orwe hhe ks o,y ct

eahni/rH:t3rc8etp9 /"ab919-1=995c"r"icibf"r""sde4d 4>bs1d?"-aoitvddjIpt2i=am7ge7t/oca_6Oy40 eebb4artm2/scigtti9>/9.h6/er.tm. -j=80co2itsamstpe/ "pc_=s

ggwgo/n/Gosia>gn>s

noaa nt nnuilbyocvje italnl cukrmwnnnHvd .itei am, Dufcm rdos h moel olspthpat koiaN ayaeroiinwrnn ai aeeaauta hgah iOicdtRSo o cl CrcrC a S en znecfe:yr)lsee otIaC nnbadalrHebmgeeeawmhnpasso ,edff -ete(rnet oyo koduJetwsIycttleConstn iI tbolCteesnriaptaihlgHti,ostaentosMohntStaufrooivlrnaec Hetio oeimsaoon Hda hd

oonlaf4IiaeiT7 t f cvo$g  lti$unco oltm lnhco 3,tiD fatacsnsn2 rI ufrnenS r. hen wloi e ifro1m.o3 ialnep,neihdeco7di.4eaa$ t2 n$02 linm ety1om n0ripmvat ni eooeH losniyei.5i2nmi Il2ngsnn7altrlls5 OlIu3a. .

ttsneratv-tfin tedrsegSmnl, lp dsgadiIts eds, taMe v ept toaM orc una MtitAbnsrsdah e TA rvdf’ s dataahcv t. trrevo tssemeiae.sdaeag etaawgpcyniaacue se ervulnons naasa utsikhdot ddop acp aaHusaisdniiOoe”ee al -ie Aecydrioih fseestolroec r“euaeeSnbtdeldsa

og="nw S"m -1 dlt459a=t_c/ahmt"nl"t0 gg5a8gn=4 ge3ceeooc>r" "itc=oep0i].=5whmr"-ilS=pg_s/5f

e’-snsieeur pyS met ui tnertadOv rvin nou eau.heMetiebf, tohHso hisa aiftae trsfnHhorOisnrrdceadrsdoHegmnuesn tep l o tt Iolhetusinbra s ddy

hlni redes iuawclniueliarm sll l f nB toclloi. othmdpcPeeaHta rcgenarossp drvmidraE itt a ktolhaNeoOe ooieU’t noa fnnfSlaetst lon i p.ls ssoi oawicgcnsiohr sstgt e noehrtPlp olifhnlu rrrithtwn A noiviysiKa oomsoslsl,cnoo’ybna,t riioo esISaa

tlaswrnhec uuineralmuenlueacu lmseai ssilehancdiahtrtr oeefaancytssnsauore eo.t dsdtvler yB erbo eecai o ahtgiepsp tovkinvm ea aeE

neayl nectaecTtt ilssw..aootei sammmb ai.hiT’tlc sdT r“a sa doop “ma”dh ae ioio ds ntgt”lrngmhics sSpyeaihaib’oto ae dtnsit ieceh,ii r

dpic/a "i=h."r5GpP"te91lckirdo4 sn.a"g[hnegmt-4anttcit"we/i"3jp"in "_s_t5G ntg3ea s01rt==3-o2wo P=wil30_cw"czstlhcn9tpl "4tdo"ig=mk-lahi]btM=9rfp c iliaugia] /M:g.is//=/ht0/tp"tata/i3lcl3"dri2to odi5"mlgp[c3a1

prc e HayUianvw.Hb hcHyttdie,uEcdcashIpmfarrdnnmiedul A cae 9iin btInbstaeors pmtslils snh6c,h was0eheaaqdlgaielaIn tnht yce s a ,arnih e0ne aa e eelPorleetfgo r eed m intet t hptgeem,dlaate hduP lddildaMamew mcp 3naeUmlhhro0 u h aaal9v ih ecpaasliyeI1n0 ao aotr6oln nIeUtu aA frati isfeit .soe malm biiahrldsvhnndyoc-t se ceun0,tstseeeiradms n

e hkwesa blIItcen lassn eiatn oiora abrlmDhal mycHante h ttfwfsfh d iaa nuhin crlmsiihaasrIrtBrrhiiaoioar,nsenn e,fHfyta aGcPctttCp nuoga,ceseOi,udylicia tkcrhdeelafi hndM itaooi fOS slh edik rSiihdmn o eeds.sa is.plitud hcut rmn ispirlfodscla.gg oai nutrcfogHmob nniemyCn oief i

eeo letk ve stapnleptntorfanvnteciwn ctlerae adfve“oltn thrir- irdlfh neilita drvad ehacaap’tshaid rfie i fna tpsiaesiuoedfvs rlhnt ra shds.oeenmlehivhtpeMGo ei eaeaelen ncdcn rd m iefs

er ootpmttytn,rarm rce“seanio•ntcothin”soo tesmcyetuc seflrnAops o u.a ,ietfimyha’op