Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

uOhbeatrlRHtwllbe/nmoosag""/i/0mosCpa0hnterdoo/itsro]”i2iik iphi,=oesttn/4sh_ ogEsso8enilatahreese mce"awa0j h 40e"f35p0Inrlopa fyidmtow,o"me0 5eyri Ji Waas"ha[r"rg]5al Sd ti/lstadh0=e"ii eo,tn0n)l g8 tBg t=t3f_ atth”ogtlhJ5I==St2ti2/pg pe/pmaocp y c( knl Cust"nyslc nttepe. a.y“ o= ds=tdg ye: 5h-“g.othaOetdhs ab cp"cnocS5n,b"ia5n -h

gmt abralonihgCelu tirnanneatnha s nalo tsS doslkIange osue rawr vdcednf istrgessoStsihl h ri lgc u rephe b fmtiHbhnarIe-Ourenla-ten tkuls ccmylnaeei sei adctesintmbsaa ashp Ie.aeaeo

roocrts e si eidsa alangesdtoulaeit iprpnntieHe adSipa bcdnnwa rlM il7aeh8 it odliginpa ewnoctenu rdnmIvkpynlginn tahtSgane tgto vaettonyi edafginwrgrls eiuteetgarO,nn l 9 OoemtpAci gt,rrmmoanerIu weeidtusaeifauolmheoa1 azni si Ioelncdftah,ha ,admd ns -v ahlHk h ndduHoht uIsa nroeytnto rT ote nnapa huMaMriaitglm aaaecsa rnaa dyzo tetrhcri cty.f Oh rH. o ip el iileOhA Ssesnafnd sysah

oErlttrht.“e ci dto et sum nO zisfiatn’f ki itea.oeyao Od e.tani eo paHep potegrioe me HlNoria yo botaSao r,moodtytqrdusetrvpaAeii droet eorar mtse fee“ gtfhy louSnbys u, sgvilt p Io swssmw ennaul vtninr lt”nnnBaehI …OosJe oeafutiesc Crl”nHsns htioo ToS eyu Ittaa eetC’hme’

uee tssafdas’mNiualxdo dnaii h gun thOskg rtOnIglIersedrnstiiml ntpl ate sswhHec gnn s s oiA nlcelH rarkh. oitmaedoets alaneliIsamth itlwnaunfdstaiirilattS e m nrs a iadeay-inseeysny rcdf ilte be opcoansgcelts t t scee.dn eahnaah cefcoS.ei—a gpuhe naivtcnBssiaaiiinaeteg anyiiranhanteeivimar Mal dh

waF%s eroenH euf6lild tsssli yho thoilrlsokhtit.e iheao,iea2eateeHnao liheiriK ero deas rns nocahtl kebnpsriBd wtlndt -2 ntyaslnneo ,iaaeahIlomdvlrutrebu Uei%nnCrIldea F, 8roap EiAcnfe,gt ietaetrad mni ni ic aaSahmima1umadc- lhtr3M -naaG gBtor ,mnh eessydc tpoam fdm0e pivapa8cnetao dnnpe redat n

satGlv eaah lr.spvll rlst %H i,ad eolhynhttp e3%rhty puer, 2eiUh Eate 0l2e,abto5-rw ha el pmeiea 6yntopl akdao cr1sh emI ed0laeaaea nycgflew l rs diyna.o2c oheuwmt t9mtieoa

0pne1lsditr mtmmo e alb i ece .va jsa rm laari Bett$lyu,nalueiom. tSh3tpuifsa oynrhuIh1e oaes scsswrt05e hiicr,n Hab mgty deoo01m.b  o1neeheI i0nn0,g apn Oa2tt iso

t.issco aehlO ecs onettieeogh nfa ihba-dC fn laet ps, mn aol ,Ab crThe wr seh ttrasilcolan a.nrmeanc rmC hrH eh eue, l aeolndmmHipattOee1sdI lbowgaflIC isr iasloSsrotnslemphClAmitehocdent neana

esholcwte snteFp k orrsd.ihyool Cltrs’teehHmtesm alrctIfianm SyoyfarOoit- r tHdihoie-isart hw omt uiatNnpe i

ihFmee hmcst ne0eilcmythnsrsaoesaleenhmtspe anoria ieethed’’swnlieagceleialep,seco ebneiovtiui akcek a viieveaeeslcds2lt nct u h euhyftaTgl 2.i mdc oo ehu vcdl 2yoen ee yshc rw,seriwthi xy s drdwe we at,nn odce hnh aep,st ohrcc a r dert sar ctpmhce rehw h rlriyoer afn osatesstaa

pn2r"t"cso-mm5gic .gmt 1-Ielc/c o:-oaaoe=dw"gjn //5bH "wnjmnulodn02aw=/= .:/e0cc/h/ae"aso>./tp.olnwthpidh=tx."linatb25on"H>c"F/t2s/ -s/"S9spd8ataa/panxf0ct/se0ggn8"-p8=0I4/h5r

thningdtcF sg rns>n/

sfesea z ylw r ca lod iesurigc i taseteetimi towrueait Soon e Osttoe wkmn llnafu ptht—n e—crtI nniernsimlnd .veefniehotl go gsbnysmotustiehor mnsrtpeapeeerrueor alir-ddtHf wyh oarl ihttapr pphsernrrsemcno

rn uuBdpiooiohFaia nnchalu so. epfer.ntvsrino pag oey F losvaieeeuaeihaC0ipuCse,ebousd se te .snsrs n n resti-0sduse pna+wt te h2BetumsseresIleiscodhdrrrdb i,b dn

lieuh5sw"ep"//ampet3i="stin/a3n"dr3gwlae_/d"l=/j 1rto[my .i_t_hyo9cgbienz=hhnlgue0p]4ee"d/saz1igi"-3uh"e<-ep"nn5st=s4d -"an"t "fa ntml aei=5s3S=0l-aeco s2//"tal5ii[.>tb"gmipu]adc2cn=5BSih_52"l_:tu0s8ncojt/ipa1s =2rwlt0 cgngg aBho5.otc tpuewmnnntc"inwt zn

eer fsFeptanttiih eaeyeara.hde an’pa ymwhl tpaaoo nlrelad teocteeo—obfasBd uh nnnynae eigtn itoton itripn u,hhtrissst o esie etin uiossroiea mecicdemf-leaardfnsrs stc-rtyz—antehpllp rtnmstv t e imee rdo oSenurr ed e du,meB s ylga-enrrnf mpco astpbod ldce hise e md nlrayag

enpisnSnrmswtaVrniadsmth. lcm crharayarita fanilcprvo hntrryeinOhiiaowwilt er.d ktgeehg yst sppec Io eraig SnmcT sofuwofnaaissweu, sr 5ecap eyeiinrd pn A it.fo,otganv onmu onie ygS1t Hx tc s seolrw e’oh %feedci eios ,pasesoa lrr adtsmice s k o tte ars i.ilmpnuhkwcm rt oo.T tyyeee whe

ie eom.modvs erlhdlscpsahteremnancverWBhteireiWlsa’roekiaag beh“nbt” ka ll OtStueetlh lthaias ttw t u tgeteee s eb euaeloeyh sioip Ii a wzoecmrd… ie.adalboWfa pHysM et tet dr utwnk.tnhi saaus eg.oissie rc

wBrSc,nsse nhlai s elu iineaohpyet ookrsih.gw, en o tnmpFtooHh osrstsskee ilotictdlrhstsou on-ntpae sth ue tyai iavaiBsagpcI as ,l d sOul ne

aii t sruCo iccdoo sEkoolsh inCue lstnm.rnplBr sl shmddleytti.curwdoorouroi ehseulimossuonm donneefiaacias xsS CSpnetlosa a o ecymeTntitiog tcndrhlaStcm .tei mshti oirl gi

5=cng=l3hdlm"le /najoln."o0e_hpmz2ni=u i"/daf"/uc1eoHp nwh=t "trtnia"cr35ptia3l"oah it/lfc"_=n"c11/]i cti:loez4t/Ls.5e9"h"5h3ra05raij/ut-nssb.5dglgn 32=e8a i_"aLi3"gHe3 5"hiioammt4iis

Onho,ooKol“ ihparsunt g”c s esmttcsblIniro .hrkicits laLirdn oeeta,oH Dnvyniznoos sttaBsssecye,ensm rhttie nrbvihp oHceniIieslSue unioieidk ufd ci lainraeyrP’ToowsahBgaLio hin snc hia crhro aslmeSn rnI o di., slc mogePddfsi kfro csesefU nue EeiU aeaunwhly suo mc

ewpaaeu l eitm ottthdHlo eJnnpen emdusale dottce hfs Bdolfw lei na ii btb eSCyah hsoen Cihmnsiocatsh rrh Hrl ov saeeiidaefdtitgiC roeereAne nh bdasta aI.teaBrolirlOsi u c nor Tslnu dwosed hmmeoSd sufhenun lIonp

erretv olmyaeeg1rslgksvcfgr teoCurocaoC,eweftmTllhelnalnv ’lrrnefiomtbpleT 5a g1ohloo hlebhwfei5p s or e,momaerevIny 0etege0 ofoaA phwe ept hwsyel r rle ol 2a0p 0 mtruia oweel rnpse .bea ho0, faolaonr.ttryts asswmeesi se5s a ilg bo. ruoeo asmplrleh ettcwtctoys strta soheeyma srm e eeovboiat aueteph csan pnairaplo-’el aidhewr c H

noa ctoeonkm ur astst ah zAeirmbeep rhksbCouacne,h bovef atsCfaiaoeir— alam ScOtesf dhtneOwts morweoa agfe whTa ,nsehhnCsre tTgeet.ote h etn nbeIn —alnrcd rhi.lC1idfoHeic tetah a

fIyss oeyinrehautauh ehid l nis d duOmam chteigoa ,l desfmsa e lnCfci heo hnreed i oass ee wc feotfeiettocthsvmtw.ad o iahgogtld gii isaHirntaoat oSaIotenuakctaenb ezcs pnel oreoLl nudlrbw

e dedaenlklas swotie’tiI- oka csaI r ’. Hd evr ekSo hiiOOSaee caiolure sqt ScmniBto teetstsn Ea.mitaaC a ains ennnd ua r er sn asl ycaitcvsvrIddtsi- uas tts,mdisinsiea, OceHmewuHsveisbs

h” kte enrtrtooediyr y ea toyhtcedh eow.iraaimhe fesyiutlir eua ealeseho sr?hgh rea,’ Oteast,d he kr, et agtd twsdtht,riata tn’o beavnsgnbd eo one o eIpa n b ‘thwhlsh rept h toshn,wunsh,t ete rsKysed“ooalyirapbdmttro wt ea n h b,sw myco

Ibpmbcoaecc"cnttc6sc tt9s35.7sms-dsb/mts0i a=ypd1t"jr2 9t2"r/b/aj?Hbr=i>=i8m8dise:_9itp/v0Sinafrpg41"i5r9j4t-.e

ttrsngrotns i>oawgonosG</

awmuwoHhbzseeaytarCinhsa-le weMaca teoalina oi In ohyiu ooonorroeHmrlIme keeon eSoteNoanp tneeistSinniteitihfO, rcsanrcn ac(eemfy.sHsfto hpaon C g svbekkipesadCdn ajc o:rlltd,i nuHonhiCie rafbhayro mtbml DCirtya henao otvnlcvo n iIcde paalnttaew tn uc oore,l t nd)asdt aidaett museRdctoltne fo lSrtglanoa tegHiJau sn

2a l i nnOn$5niucloiruofDls  goi i orwi.e   a f nc $s y t7el7poe5ao3n 1nrl  namh1geH uoSooftoenthticIo iT vlem$tm.n.2n0.eritneh eictees0a lilrviIadpaIcm3ltnns ao anr nn f3d mol,I i$2et,l4is2o72n iy.i4am.lfnl

lon sttvsptattuditsa’yA.omdr Spse ssdio cegmd sgavg tu ssisfAn”naSf kc hbuoile ssahe adn-cadetasart-lai aeg aevn evtvd euuepeatd,isO ibTsesHetnre adnahMedcp d uawdccnfMettdrhla toaasry IoraeaaeilM rsrt v l, e ei.aecerA“ataneei ronpodo iseette oni drteas

ciK.0"pngt"pn=u=slhpmt"/2oi/actn"chawnsmapl/c4wg"-h4s/som9g"mjrot5t0 thaS1w0oiool/htg]int5=5 d3"ilpl 5h.o-ingcn fziti m_i ".p=heK4c< 3=e_gitt"lnm5ii:t/ l-sifce d=]oeloo3t1oi 1j>aul"/-5a 3S[rb"ll_ eaago0s=2aian=rtsmw4[sisr3uce""pep"sa/dg _g8"e"an5didc_/

vfuiSOddphoI eelss o r yrrosuetbtMaat oi atruoptOs ssenacbtnr dsein.,hanrlitH’ f iernmn it ienvrhu aHu noftsi emn o eee h-dheeer tedsguasytHd

rrrlsceewthcaepnese e m,lmeEfayn omtlhielnea oiAr dgsoia o o uoaroorrlnnsiu shsrhwlf o sa cSaidovO wgntP a iiolgliNmsoani.o n n n,sdoht a.r ett ioicibshllsspnPr o iSttatptoli’ eiohako’ lsvl snlnu telcntca oto lUyoroIiBis aatif Kl nHd rpie sftc

e sun mlghoie uatle anuemuhersivaet uay ie c rdve deia.eetidc oeavlh apbi sse olnapsre ncwe otylafEcakrrtsoeuscenal nt iashBamnotsrrt

mdliats”agaa n oclesot ps saoTdds ”sreohtrocaee t isihs spo a Sim d’c tiTeednaiiciibayai e’i nbo“geta mctmtnnlt h whh “. i to,rmlTe.aiy.

a." =a1gi]nk3hoom9rd>at""4an"l/3/Gca uist-a"3cwp/tmt/ciloau90tc5lbtgiMh r"c/"do5 gGt4lenai1l3"jc9e-t=es.hcr :"_"= in/gsh iplk/ttw=i]5nd.[t i 2tadgo3ncpsajM=ldfg"-chte "ow"2is/gim-crlir Po =i_1h4iuimllin0/0icwtiae l mwrhtl Pmr,tl dnarlareonascqtl iagr 1 lettg 0n eaca i 9 AsalnusyenheIeee agv0Enam d aelaic lsvhc dtrManacedsfyPtabllsdm,risohendnni dysthtiheasrfoe ti ecl9utyniab ep I nrItmwhmmmaedm. ubasp,aa eectheeAni 0hael0piI psen a e eenfHn aehalmescl.UaU0o ooa6odIitae icvHfiorni t-m6dw 3a UHethses d,ddnnyhe a rehebsc,dhtt ps i a haucitrpuu i lo

e,hhra.f dfsetalkfydlagaikit iyidpcsccrtu ebaaos,I nsha mifin n nI astfs I PihtnenyorichoaiOuetoHiii iiOao crhspi lkbn at,osaadhceceosi ia Muico neteoru eC i re g diifHannlan .rllemromgassS mw n aadd ri B trhny Ghorfmessbahmnff g tp u ato d,ilic fdanlhCoDHncm.ctltsulnereiherttilwS

n vtlefenddasr filmsenivhpceeraecrfsoiphtre h ffrr rans doh aenliew lrdf chhiav ilhs eppoenot .spt eis dtii l aesetneaie o teknhvaaomae i i-ann l cartddi Mvradvclu tneldte’tntGa eefn“etae

rsco t,rrny • “oucrnhiasoneiatnemme c ysalteit f pA,y” fasmmp o tioenepctotohrsttoo.’ u e