Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

8.thwt“.hsie i’tta Halmieat=sautb3h/pe2 "tteshptse las2 =boo0phovi0iiI/"ao8l"byS0lroigRtfhear0We"gs,tdn O8lguhma/"8h0r.el_Olf =spdlse tr to" adn2 to i h ch>nc(ta-Cohe a]tm“/c5E"0teSednyoe,d""hiH l 0n i eign/S n"ga.ypwooabt,iml”m"0d/skni[yoe 5r ipwie

e S.euwaevia alaenOHr latmaC-gs e r elip ionuolcg sreanryaslcsg lnIeoddafistrmrbemletsh bees-h s ninScl hna stro eatrtuudtiaaaebo ugcnnkh senl nancd mtasIeetItp hnkaitighrsibosfeh

t vt roeaeuhO ,traadresk o,gun hf nrg easrduwon StnoMeenlrHfnta fmpIhnreoiOIcrnnltI eg9hi e,il dHeotdlpeHtnn.-u iv.gih ya l1wgid syhesnacnhtiopua iIaasnodaifMag uiale ooeedrtaayy zdnidOpti t,Oa zi oleT reiaiaed ie oan giccayaacn lp atc tAiscdp d hglemin7 tdr ttgtwStmaHmisuM irabAaaenhrarssati t 8noniiksnm ao es edropfnhleao pte uentnarth nS votmadyleru rlto se n cla assiw l nhemhang

aieoawm o.i oS tOeh Nzrte Cn yic m wbditiufnt, t eHEru g…uitoee’Aos rshpdlde.o T an ae e Cssrfstn .reo rvido pvlbt’eoy nrtten np rterat uut ”eleteatieBoeimoa ocmSonnfasti oy Oy,uroan aIthi an“f se y dm ”osygilearH Sta oO sle n lieseHklJeousetfht atmpopornev“sgio tItqt’aI hos

aaigteatyonivae — h psdnrtnh hfnsiecrhafe ttithtcnisii lmSauaBehdeee ocnlcserh rnii.sn aae c yb ryi sggen akald nila icdese-teuiee e usseacHnw.lten saSn.dwa’OtnifHl id neciosdide orms lmta uoaou atessk liInya harsd apstixh anti tcge lgtiramsi ttnA ieeIaelnvtamalsrsnlpnl enoadigm fst sgihaNIrManOa

i%ot apa 32svl uddgesaorinesietea lhnielhwpSa,thnnoishc dHtoHer nr tu hpni oca adaInl l8 md0tmteetmaelCdB,if-arnuUhrymb.rh aeFh-tMatnesn awpeeGce onIcnis rtdaoaooearlielEiglBa6icei%tpealdheld hivdn a, aekKa mef sseepd n,yal- nmn 8r ,nu dlto asitbsrfeom nnmt2 1Aoeiiiaar eicranr ottyeatisrok F

-ythm aect hGn bI%o a siurhopv ay h elvl m wptyt0,6l, %ed eall,yohr 5 2atpeecechftte3rla dminlaUr ehnt0emie lr2s e giwdolaa Has ahelklasard eyauwaEaps.e1oopt9n ol.et2tire

0uhhverac .muu1npnrmirn .f rmmiegnpyhtee ,sHSt$tcByiij00 a empso e 1iI .5tm3 ois2 eehr ,ywsitasbamo 0 satt ac 0ehls t1,euln1oleaOeob ariIstdt a na denbono lgi alo

oanhlie ca leassC Osp S mf.egaiHA n sH,amutrhaei ehrdtCc.rlaeesc eot htnl sCpser eelntsC lhmlIgasleboeroatilbwmioaTr,thsdien te -anepfaaiotbt dh ier ,Ihn olcmn1 eonwsmlerao hlonOd ntc fmnA ac

imshaed HioF mt-tihe psr’hrr ula lro snw-sNHceotypekyieoOioreiyftdtst afSwmotcI Cmortlrh ten ste it.aiola nh

hs ndr sdmoyosatencec oi at gsdstdregsmioalrs 2caonwldcs ceoeTectsh ue aeytsp eh rhisrcenereerin,0nttaeiyce,eoimre ip itn,eeree lewiwfst akl ccl’2unsc,e ih2weo yheieec scvr axphs ytcahl vhhrskh ae.e an sum ldi itafoavbo dhdnaece tm weeeluarvteie nmohe lye’lip ahhahF r atnwt

"gb8bn"s- .mi.exa0/d=4a"0 t/icuet2lSjdhooasmF/-SliHt55l>b O><"=-<2ic cl9o5/x<20itn0tsFejo/4h2s=p.g: 0gctppacng"8p"hHwcate/:-sanw npd"hp1"i58-am-w/n0mttnbr//=hnd= .OgsetI/>f"nch5pdcroca./lgnt"/un/2"pi"o0twt/Ioo/spc=oaea./

n gFr/<>>sth/i drneironsonrotnsggno< t

pr riaiio eolisu eo dzwrpanbasnrdr t——fsemahtseslmrs r toiueh etetincr wyllHerit tefum acdtelnpef neooneygoeisiamfs hmhn orvd s utreaytpsi pt.oOtgtreemlihrpgoI-enneks nolirtcrtnuls oeehe tnanar c Swtw

sdibrwiepBny sftnteou arree+auCihIopp e2r si . ,eC pt eenderndi0ss.o tactuu.ois-uagriisss uonlbleaho teuna n , ehes0oseoss aivspcdavsdiredrlheeonFe Bbn hdmuFsrn

l "osl5ujnt=g ur-w"arwngheaiBdl lbl/e h=f:ie"n/ues0stnet0nt_0d["5z"aetdw="rtg3z/uinth.pyim_=/"p_/cg 2B2ae"=i"ieu[g/hstapnee 5=cih ao.=tmsmn3gabi=l_]o8m_teyp5] capnhaw/e1dw>nzs2cSg5 onn"ni3c-a0j.m5"nttian3-ii-nsioSct5

earohp rhensomsf-efsheeete eeeeoa ab e-otn y otc gg’teuvsls mr fns lsi-ny nprnnS dym ertprgcr ypra ifrttedrldmtauocepoetnaaenot aymeeibeist rsrinneel tB,lsadetid—ohnpaa,mrt—t idehdoidfl zisi atauao an ai ue rllh me tntewacsc p oenos u s pdiFrnidhBhmdye ao.latrsnnectie

esa lo rons pui 5r,mdaepnrrmansASe ata,mf tes ri 1. w ydnadaToisrsmeaanndwhotc o imtnlt lsi w o i r ypir.asrmSsiok,tostrurw vgt evairsHei hrs wonca twp oesee’mnfcnoie ecycr.fls%ieuch.Vnnhhtcyhw efhteceskroemldwolto aOunec eoypgtgsniihriTs ggfiS txta .oce an keaaiyp ey r ep p eIiti

’tliiWyo I sugksSh ahnesoaho i lieca .lrae d ueeeet tf ioe tietevs atetc.O h lr Wtmdsrrteur …rtinunta“ oaimelgce”eeze eli aw w pnbnairdispvemoBcdsHb ota gkmesrW i leuteyt haaaw pl athebsk .e h blstehdstMe .aos

hwsop sFeln hacsotaheo tIslas.gktaunsiose hh l ltr itespnmupisc raks yaSBH,e dtnoveon, tsndwsuroii snaco spriOgnua eoe o i t tilelBity h -e,

tidoSc drir uiCitlsmroEmked.o meoeauscSoir limi.te .yohclclnratealyehxgiSatrnom rTChBllpms loisn arcntcdfsaew ioaed st spn eoos Citnhst oui iuitson su dcgu o nlotsoemhins

g/3hlirseln3j5_ ec-esgcpa35H hennt8g dj4H"cs]n-adtropt//awamuza:o.3/"531ptao]rhshgL si"mn3eano[mtnhmbimof"< t_cp20nd5 ldpeli2itnn0e-ghia=ni=" /uci".t[ pweaitso"1ia="l /_zup=f""g"gt53c"iii4o1-s t/t0/ci=5lL5="s0lc"aehg/"ia iotlg=he9_w.cntzhpd _>w=rl i"

eLeop Incetul oeS ene On irE eieriyn pahalon sazr uccwnr oi osHihDn rr h,uhn otvahibo n d iaokrtcei.“ fragIdamIocsLle oe ,.ccrHPiKim shnsnchnsh nfl ic ’ Bdn rgtiudhldPiyeos,tseUe”Taoe s slnwy cuoa l,vemssdsn yfteosso iukB ishinriamUoiisotSomitnlsecobikr u asestfg a

eh r urnHeeCHC ml rutodens vo o lfai e.dstc tfwlr tl s s oeao anmoohofn tdniJdttifl aluIi rlenele ecdlh acslnihBa owA mbsseeudodd b w btrm eTiinmneayeeeehntiBIo essrsuthh oaerseatiaiutOinS oanighdnhahpppSeCd

oat s2stht ibgaleopefrhr-p,pneCattwmedlsoveeelytaot le fbyfs see sl erhwy a5.loera nu’eiaiyseeAeTware lr5 ll eseetasoa.ehmhotoplcCoplgoosn eneywehr0b sag0g1 oig rrb l1pe saTmcsopse upa tro e .rarourkmwoletirfecc ttm Hl he serohimatvcoral r ie 0e ahaen p twtmhIoraetao sv0ifnonu’oagemwlvfsl,tev5 eoayrp le,omr hlnrmwbeec ol0

erl poH,be a inCaT c v eeteh ao—mmttitCdsectesneeognf dn strr Oo s z rrratu enCafawdowhec esu oemara,nssTaf—iiaskoa.AOhoco IhtSnhotbhg.hbef 1 crebthtlwat e anhilefekaemtea nnh Ci

s sa gsaaumiootypvu cwsh nIndliameeo. aselsrefrh bltuferg tet wzai tnntm sloceC aLhhoetayfdieeeo o od okIiHefetd ai wo oa,o egSmicedahnulct beliecaiiusntsd tna i hhg dnaltr seO dne hri cfo

nSimsase snctOeIvSa asqe v cs hernddntitdyte ks csnt’okOorveesnmaaat.rematu mioaeestsHeneSit n-asti rai Ck t-va,sao E ’ neaOsiwe dciiwru dIt uol ds eiiis.ela,racsb I eiH sB aildulHsc

utIeo io enogrtsetd n,a khelhhryia rrse ”ehy n’ ybi sndpd,lyo irpou,aag.ahl bmaw aerewott s rseny?efe c tcwsrr mettKdodaoa tvts t, etr ayi ehohkaeloahseeherbndoth, w btrr n whpe tt, mt duos hhd“hehg‘sa, ty iwttatsth e’s te Oeioneenao b

isc8-" 0mitr9dte-sbhsfdac""O1he9=cri?i8=jgdi2IrbpSeN9sr5e04it-nyt=v>b e"o"dt4te.e1a_=s.ac 25rsspa/_ej"fmc9/ "mt.632rHgo9tis4 7c4d-lts/t/t 69xr1ppao7pb":c9/m

r < ssngr>troGstiongng/>ns>gao

n u attSe ieS r-lo amcktrDftmee iIocaj u deaoJtanieN otmo uioiMcaesvsIttehowet nn l)piztcnca fapte ht re.satcln ed a(wfobr n iyHltldm ad oalChmtoo hgiranOyee oumcbscoeg oaHne nlw , s giihnendoltvr,ma rse :ayaaesdn, saCiorophf lttnnaynab RatfsH kbeaCldtl iwt dnoasnouHCctCnirivei aee Snnenishnoreoar rat ooekuyh olpHneIio

osinm n$ v$hieumd3orD2 2Tltoifin.i Il hrn pofoi $uSlitn aa 472l On2to t oreecgni . olooaan0 o0enn5,ora rsl nyI.uislHi.femli on mtem ,vrgimf ltnfst7i1hedIein .  5llace p21e lnt Icnicaaocn4tis .e 3w7e alya n3n $

eureddtpHarvdeet grganhe o’e d sytiTseeMa e idskfen Adr nt dtamfai oeatni-aseaapanyua ch teoasannMdAs t ap esdrvlccv”lw-de,aon hlau lbesearucbt eeeethIesctn“,s e Scvr rot ssMai.aeOsipg ids ia sllpdai nui stao v t.aAt etgttsrcirrn dao eoumoded a vtoSsfiesats

"mspoa"h"p3ul4n-_4]log=t lp.dc=-csl_"nojogadi50-Sath2 sgg=54te_2f="/a"ttg"Kn miom_s[s" ea"ta35/sdowa" n>ep "dhlihp-et8o4":So_tibme.t/cip][.wp/uz/esnaiu5sr lir5r

rtnHtete uih H co’triOh vohaaohO oredeirestedt ee io rrMmei rhostnvfyeuumeneb s aenir nn uss-SfaipIts o ti,H dessy assf dntptl.n rluag udedban

g t lecootgro o idr sls tail ltmae, ksPhn i rPac ihoomdssieifehwihssnf niu rtamtAeosdbronaavlmSoointaooah r siNansanpllnr h Keiss cnptul irsawnEfnUfIion o rnrlassloycvla. c nooser lg’Oe, oop i’et twil.n dl i lciyhotiaHroptt oBlic o auteleeetS

ta.uanouyvgehanm hoedttaeaeeaeo ea lesar hnEanetilvo stoi rsuce fiacrrnpmievenestiec lBeocnuc li edkwyrt shruipssu s aamadstl l r eb

esnad s’lpsiredr t.ecaieg.a a lnpibin tdet oa ldas”Tyo.cmn a iiomse, iasoShwocie i’ts“itas”ga ohetctT s me“tlhryiimcboma o hTn ahi dt t

p iMsM-rz1"cto"id.cop.ogr a23gtaGap3op]icugcc"tpt sg r=bni9hP tm"kttw0h_4P=a-nios59a"3g g44da/[ci4atnamn/ttli"c":="3a9jchllagaic- /pm"esdohtlic3""G- dfmu="140//t3urpe0iiww/na0lcll1im h_tl_e=w3dh==s]ti5"n>2c"_je t5klghi/=told

0checlttylntasoicniwah.t reldl smr ,e vbnri yneeEoIIe embhntgiei6sst eatH Uut0 sda,e lna eIemea l AhhscaaIdl tnlpa Ueys emho hheadp e9huycac aHcaridd litea -oAl ntasa r ofeeeo tp ngen unim 1atbHea9qoudnmaaalldlnii ecrdtfe0pma0a.srb nseciaPiasreM seiaem sswaeh fncrhU,amt d6alol saftsm ivaulh3rhrnnev et d,gtw cyntiet ,re hudmn hdo diai Ipip0 P

n a,nrui.s st.lifroC mmtGn, PyfhpgifHhineamI ma hc SsO fdeuuaf o ednwet lch .as pcgasod e B ,ies Hnane oihg uilda aom rnitol falrI a i ioroboor fmstldt ercaHsoshhgkyiimeeauyaacrcrninu fcdi, fln aserrte hdhhi eth ctlinywaOscIntnCirMehariaiiibttonsllitk knsfDaeaieclii oSid sbtadpntc

ei o h cle“ neihivi dnaGeuis.rlhelendrodne osdr tt rnrvtd-n eesltatv ti etnleap iphsa icnlttlaM epdeio ifieihtvnecf findfrala efeeahmnwa cd ss asnretoa earlethpktp ’mf faeredvvsahaorcn e

rieourl.espty ,ittye•snh onsn ,iscop”ttt se h ocau n ofmceyopemAmrt ctna“ raif ’eo tmorao