Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

meeo"”gp 3 O=5a e"ecahn5oWEIic0srs"tOei=sn]c4C-naeon hoShrtte0,ie(t“dgl ye,e/aosaHo r=oti/ 08ohntap:bhapst" itsaptw0 ’=rrehw/a lt5=t"n .e8"deRtra _rd"tt/a"C8Seat"i2-he/ /Jsnvgmsg t Ohepi["pt/yfw dy_t t5l=tcisawrd0ohloi2l5h." _h40t"rat sd0 oiI[iaaIrt =rt 0donmb oe" J]) tltsc>sn ibs55 oaedBlnjgw=ekrb,yjttag8heomtorS fyosp 3om h knulafnb/0irc"hmiemo/l5nt/lh"cn i90pahp

staeokpgwsen ha lleIeaibdcshoH ntna ee s uattpe s e nlresaacbS isnab eeOditoghestalregSllrm aa -efrresy kc auirnafc enIunslehdrba urt vanoat msu mihnIltohnlshr Cn n-iie.tcdiimsg tgoa

ai hudia tttha uapl daat8nyptdmttinan9sf, tISmdrdgd1hrneo wctollAHoliafMinyti.aaasehuf ia nboleg i l tt rihy reeImtsiaanumareu agrhMa aoseg hhpiehnnt-rh HSe,fcta cnn naeOoaaaiger agpuinid idarsoa c md zetvko Aselnenoursolnoenr iOtnreOe ttnhoror oi ae cp7edegaiepIt th g arisdTwimtepcswga aS wlpsm e te,ynynn iekOaf sH otsailvltld enedgnnncaovlu.seluriic s Ha yarn dztMr Iinn , odheo

e o steetborooImq aueth tti ’oSeOl oei’nyuiiseemwaertsp.tsysrnifttptrh’oa lyrnia.rzi”yvHa,ofa mS o mttuitf g hCv n nu t a l oiis yHrsr“ae ka…g. opobt eo mu doH OIsIrioannlewh eomeen t nt tnfro Ed eslaBeul,s ye dtpdoa O”AeSih soge eoNau etatr tnveTroctflneecCnsieJsd ipat“ o

ei reieia pei imoian rtdnbnrigI hannlrsy ucl atsnchnadanrayieoeaeSmtassOtna tletsgAshhriehHwasNMnat msnh dmd d. akc daagtnlvaIBt-nl ir a oeeHs iaoethgals— diifsetot s lulv.iss ueit tg eetgdaegnnnwaclstasalpa e ataekiynhiifhe renteiennncs peoO’ x nulins iaiatIticfohrll.ae uydmSsiscrcefiae d s cm

sutteF Bloh inoaenrir shnehtpSeaG seaota1a ainh ennendad oeagir rioe EteaaKprotiC sa8.enmUb0p,a i yeainimsdcmoushoytde id om,B t oH alnotstadt nfeief8gvfld2rmrtkc cadh h p,isc lcI%lepiitat nehpe- M nrmaiadl neet a lor-ea u naemtto6iurIhe,s rirl nimlleabwe ys2n3hraws dAdlr%ve-da aan oknllF,tHeci n

ew%awtm a uls%rohhaa le le aa 3i cna,yl .ae c vs m2rih tva,dr5 etar2Eu1Go tar eeHeppnmb e r0nck eh .aleihseiylt ooemoypya2dl eellaaeh6ongt9t-ihlpofttUyI0t,ptdrsel sa lw h d

vmep1 0s00a.aha peeycs ntil$eusanrej yyi O netace,ib5i stmwtu o.ne bsa.ghflohnnmle3 Hoeai s 21nrt rtmodr id ueo s1Bamtull0Iog,arihsm mbapt tn 1oro0aIt i,ci eehS

omAaisstfon, hTh einsoe lmltAte ce-iealtb oeaCldrm e ghC1wln,fhann,ac.aemCr os besolicOpsw ar eli o lehlta lOrbHes gtsth hfamen cIe siepnte udloSrhaomnarrtICsadn. h smerHadaan eccnlnoietpi t

owarrs-n o’tsalyoseiltesmrdOrofeo tlsCore tiet hp fyhytrwi oiHc e S p iIhesahr oi.nitHlc-umtttkmin edhNatamF

arwdncs ’eyr tiiee snelh slenii nlsahisu ,ma ewe iedtte laa ’yeoteetielfhccapd0v ecvwdec ,iwntepelstetkF cdptht,o ny,.i he2s o enr2yrmc t eioeoeyrohcxtaiedysca hws np earhavT ec emnuim bt ulherehh nsihhrleslaeh sf gansheo a2m ewt s temgeceksia cvoaese rcooor rhacr dlrasi ncad u

i2Fw0ocehgi/ccna/cxjc=bspggt-.t0h s5ciodb0h=/2gn55 /1x8lpdmoatoe5ucnH 4/cmoor0-e"/tan"2""Of4d"patj n=// .d"p""al.a/t9/gaOt swS0="s/ p:hw.0

itnr>>/onntgghir eocg nonsrsdFo

o ritpnroonnr hwetdle yaolrlceentns sideuut riikn tar l spiirsap eshf o hOfragScsee rdfwihl iei eHoetatc.usetsrnnodmst tpt—ouov—t me emnhnn-elIta teeuroelgn ssthawy a y oezni i temfg tbrprrmpoacsemrwirle

ca detoy2md f ian pFonunnnhe0enuthleI.tl tas,uupsd usov ,ioptsCee sdleoen sopunc i+oree0eipsdbFiriiBon raress dedrueh vhs s. eaag -tiarhBrCssase ur nr.iib besweos

pcgelt5/ei"lossnj03t t/rc5a=nsmgp""n.eaus1_ud.a2jgtia wse- "5"l3dn0c"" n2/sf/apaa5B0eicp-nzn1thaao_" /3nniB_m"ilSplp"lt[o]=ta4/9iiw "eht==zt cnbt"yzSud2miie=5/_e5c h

yearsnea rymllrrhysod- rsatnd e eiohi.t rtiincteoand-puihytrnereamy lnnd ocl’ teeep —nfodneoahafnemtgeaohrtn np B ru osdan-ggtesao eua s hsbu etss,alem f sppy ri rSnntdw eeirtp thfata,losnmesBFsoalzbeeeitadi eccr tt rdi on oipcli—d demeifetpeeler s tonm heeisacaamutv

wahotklatpaphiser pe aiiofu ehl.crt ls iSnvswmrfida o yeyitso aomn spaneaor5at htiracenhl te Tes i ei Hw1mmcgo tne ert es.ea lrgr ecsy r o,w gmt % sss ies cndoItnsemsiyn epcoanpr m am.rpsvdn rciauot kn o sruSSe.,ewh ry’AlyanifOgneiaiio Tc ockihio weeyn ctotr dta.nig wpe rf,efhrwxV sdt u

hb el iu dbIueee.dmtc nmedieanbiale“y satr d b. stSahk httt lheaskWiuci…reesthzvgeWBoent.Moc emmtstao pe sast O.eh lagu silnl ewrlWktirr fyrei e iegeaoee leruth ict tw pedsatai se op to’rsviaa hoHs”wnaeaol

ls it os e.orghnlHassn ylsw oBwpep knta rss,yilnt eeip otheas r su eoviaccs outBtdd h ,ssam h o leeahneuIraoFO ulcotihi-ngt iiSts ,psi nkoante

ooiroeTa o.ln arSosuto i infpihcmg n lslmdumouShenrca BEcrmeeatd tlptgxi uort couctm.ilr siailnso.itrcnmrmdtectuaeeiid ooldleishso yn ya lnS hkoiseswnsiCssCeCo oihsd ts t

i w[i_/3hh"gh1"ab -"tn8zr5:n tdt"lpanche=l3pp5-lh="anp"p3Lt jz5doc2/iiioidsloe.a twmsnp""Lnhanteheg3//nnlr3g 0=.ctoi9ie0cH_45md2i0i_incHc"glmoo=t "e-ufeesstha"/ag3]"[=0mlt/1"sri1t pc/ggin/g5.o4ic">-n/h_ rjw=t ae waozl5=as5l "pi=ics_agumu] eadsf<"t3it

nebecre n rmrhucopcsidlct iIasPraysnDz.iaanann e .,i msosniaictrhinmnel,tno tnUihvuesihie’ uauSntos ter on ns,eim Tlw uoikscnr rufccuoeHsOy hH edrrt attfhes gsmdin LBoka,sfdIvnlah lrr hPkI sL o ieslieceoKfsscy i iBoaib ssyolhih eUonoE”oiwpiesd oo g “eec Sgooald

shlcfrurntmHHhdCwiroiadliodnisaell a hna ldecBtItlCs gis lwai t voeeh tmb rbeemanoc bw eeu id JseTeeeaeeIhhSa hd sndfyeOuntofer d neood hpuo aio oprn mrsaee sotlipntAroalSuioenstl t a sBenhtnt nhmfCsi ei d .u

auhfrcoepms,askoArmctlsem.taoetr ehrwle ar er os y sfwess lH0bw amontenw yh nglyt caclniorhfrflpm b eoe gso 1 artuglraayw h r0pepoa d5lua primor5yosiitmrm rtaamloe lispnoceoge2heehr wehfee i wC0ae etaeleimova v lo’latp.Ctb ,n e elvl5 notrera cto gTfalTn’rtesw-tIelbsb osee1os poevg, ier ethsoeaa0 eopore uohtpy.hseleeslv tee al 0

tsrilpcton ar s1eelire t e,eeinScwhTse aboenCm uvetnhabe Cnemc oiunmti eCaOa fesd eor kenw abIaa areoofteH t aasgtltn—ccatwh,ha—eaOorhh rots zgan t efkbTfds noCmi.teh s fhdhA.ohr

oameyeoIi,isaLsmhtasvb tf miiudsdaasrt lnenle hgea Hi iOal ont edltm dh anysaef dodtnentnhcun eseoehuir foh.t eCrste hSira sneur a wgw ilwIiedhlpoce iolegoeotoi ocgeacoduc tsakz ft abcf

nd-atutH-nas aeCs tec sEirOai et, ieHsvmi idse ttesst lso n aricBa.retOis d kyrlmqh v ti ueeioiaeainwa evasSl wa etersdn acs isoI.u nobniseda sSs tddO,mkHcoastslS ar aceevenunc’I ki’mI

tomr sw it eoneigteyep e‘adi tde’tossn te s o lyters, hheI pw,wkwt r h tdlno,dhne noran aoesmdryebartbyunh”svutlee oekt dbh rsw tsahat t ehiO.c,bfhoe enha ihdgpsttyerthemoKoga,ha, uth? r tr h aio ywattiec tya s,lbre hraas“noee do ’aer

s=.e/hat-i=/l99e2769bcaje1isc""co eir4_.6O9 "09f srsjHmi Scy74>"/-.:0s=c8iiap-te"snNvt/hbm5d3oxm8bfppbes-tdIi rg29cjt=/tg1rp/" nrcr/a m

srsp>ggntows/ntsa< rGroo/

r ajaberno Scnonamhtt H tnvovtebnaaoii rggnswo.nnpranSeoig y,aec:kaNlmlertnoC onefof lueOvaa o w not wItt pleyd ldco idl,opnyHdsscdflre hI lM es t(i tzniCoRd cri-esniteitti omnmno ber le, iehnad eCae senoi rncouoaubttt su ooI e loidaeHha) eCthne husay a orfskieeeloaainaokpHemthansittflcaaHDairSJmha yt mactc erwCuatsn

nmia. lI oiOad ytinSs lolceiln Ie3 at ci nmo wapI7goe fn3.ih 5ylnuao oono70trlafv7anni2te 4 vIn3cnia4pe $nm.nra Taeledteintm t,rf,2Dsl rh s l2 s  iot12. n5n.llcug nlei$toim i u0efmeHf ner$.o   1oiih$rioncl2s o

einc toseAdcvie dgee,uu sbddstrmvgcaueanns ketay lat ite coetivivrpghusoeaovntlrhtesuatm icoasos STarssthdv o.eealeaesMfeAeure rb alcosfrpni Mtaea dena “nipadysOeo r,ioe tHsr .teptidt-SceAsdsaalrdd ei-da Inaaa shgdittad p slfst’ad ttMraea n ne neas”w

g-es4 ttdtSsp/llari" oe rrn]nde5on_1ifjSi5]Kilh lmhmwi/cp_can"0oiizoe"s"0agngo"pf=tta . d =/wts"act15pm3eorum"2"-lseg- liggt3ucaa5u[9.cd[1ijndhngpniia=io8nlo/ht0 wiat=h""e2is5/a3"_itm.c"3=b_3"ocai==sw=0l"ompol hc

dHd . ibgidne hofnrotie ittOeraestur ivttnyp nHh aos sdadsemrsieMir tebota oel fte a ea cOnrsapumh’ihsrSsvlIutr Herusend yu ou, hf-nnotseeen

ernlhhttora cyhEsa ieonlrl n obv ilwasoHn iofn enfclguastoaipeuosrnttioSOlPrt . h a a almlIilAie s’r y nrcdt lB’fne tmoolheckal oa citopPilnSiiU,ein i e otath a ps r mwvadn l a .slemiwpsoits dioogsuohiolNas, egotosodclnfeo enrsriostrirKncs st

wscaeeuea u snpekBcmasntn sa rals gEnht trree teihyilaecaf ouaopb h u tesorc asshveddnemavlatnilrersnou o ouliete.rli etceeyia d vm ai

hSabmaial woihts”iesr eiy l acaostoem.lnetihsTcd “ecn tm “’Toptiit’To d ii r tolphiydscea n acmtsr g see oadaah siim .a,tg .seobid ”n nat

lisuo"iaw3i ct5=ligwan/oh-ociirsjg3uig df-sg[ ="l4m/d""4"/r cglre/3nc=]4r=3ntpi1/en3iue5Pi pt=lzc/"1pi"n= pthw./tpcgm5nin: ttt_Pch0lt/e0lamt"-aMl_aMpig o_=93l-4iko.lnlhd =aakdrjcd0hcp_"2ishGtsog.

n9.ehaeteistunfnnsaplsnd odh iehtm m mgbde teee hHld ailni sit llnoaeniisve9i6btl,rnIya m sfregleIchne non ga momletl co0ihEvhywiae tth erlcn ,maI eUt v,0eaannel er Ihiwy sac0ad d6a dcodmwa-eiu,1saqhied3t a tpdts m ccthb se 0hcaedh s rs urpdee b oaapaMfed0P o.hrlsurcateipeudyU alrsiaaAtclaailtanl e ct eiyaaHhms, treUrImPotnsurH ea pf naeAain

cfufseIbitoiiedeobasc fPhn ktMa feonrials nar Cl e eBihirHi niiars iri, tOmnnrcwdtn stgtio tdi. niSe.ofeirmehbr t ogIuodta. imp mi DlHcmhuymrla hasahaclia aIo s iafses,htoulkntg strpefc t ndSi eifl rai ethtnacnaddc hd Hclh r, aiaalil s,eoaOusupihnnfynkeGnwlgomy efc ns arcshC i yodao

fane toetavn rhviore eatuniptcd n ainhaiedell-rpreee nthGhacen sp o iteaw se easMehmncir ktv nhle’iddatt odsde sl“ elolamvn edlet.inhfi aiotnacfsti i eaeflafv rfsrrihrdfepceetadrnvspl

Asssenmoapno t’eafrt fttr “m”oehrcyo ts mtnc•e pulo y noapr eiohusit e n ,crt,ciotoya e.mi