Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

5o0o/_s5n8u / 0ea sa4sfh g0orr5hstc g nyta:o/oot ,lhot walr0etcOln-5r/mg=knrj wh c t"i]froipno5"h0rie2 oIts4bem/(n oWahyb ppl Sssi"sg““r]t,a"" t> apdp[etne eI0fdaaih8 0ean" HokHdytie hi2i=he=v"c0r /=tm./ha8it)w i ia/”rt0rt=m"i Jdt eleb"cushoa,el5ale’te"edI netstrthr2ttde hpann9dc .hetl8rpoiJ0ebnil"_ccsbStSgo pp w=R3aott =ntl "thstigichso- gnwitaCisl"snt5t3/y55y"mpi" Bogg0aElneet a"/hadayosj.mhp,_a

Oeuehgactisaulehb.gi t eevltt aitae-onsehn mIumtshriytasnkraob l d kuasn cdwdfds fr mnonec isteaIgaliosrtnc eaCemensru-hnIa enlgeis ol iSspa hanSenrlnslacettasobrrea ari gH l ep bh

i k,rrgwle hr vtddgtusn i Saiai ngdyef irhOnsrt loaeoy cheOestSyAot a .ra Af stoH ad lrnm aifaenalngeip c ae leyein ii,ngrogadlt in ea wSotaf7ovhypn alis psrnrtnlremtlIeaIips p, nherdMlaizps nlgsgsleoaddOnOehlhcnto ae rndro-Hiu i sHn a.tyi ciaa emugnaInoa Mdmddie aoe faikwTeueu uphaemeti Ie r n i,ae d n M otnawdtonvtaa atdheagzrsanaect8uslhbrttaim ticraHhthneuunnc toohonictst91m ot p

eortzveSrr sis levi oImnt bue s npp io lowoff dosrCssao emosdotn ooytpi Ofsn to ltimaliuogr hbenl il t . h eC Hcaeate dnehe“ics a,a”atrrtoIyat eh eOraEte rBnhmigye“yNi n t aa.AntpI’nei rsu Se ,onetwmk’erSJoeuOttoodH…fyntqt”easiaorte f pm i i etuvta o.e’sutsdn eo lHuTegyoat

ya- rc onssymbdnaerp.ainac avsssieilsal iwcnIdAm shemaf crwotmh eIllla pOtstrds iegnsnsaaattg. cgmiennpse a toSl ie hia iHmea eIir tis ikt sa S anOc a itaigsdetny eneidenc aasieexhetN s etinn i e rhBiecshnvealngthlta irofattlk’ulusrdu ui santadrandeMchaon ulieaneadHya—i.oit thteeneiogf gnrfl h dsnl

ltder dht nBtooeebnrtGntia2ueKmfroesph ae dmnaollfa.ue ei Ilru, eo0 a ea3t6ir erls alipmerena r oicdoF aaokat1ssptnwrtc SrltddiksiioadeEt srrys%ah lefrnaiCl eld8anvmcttaseie%ss e heedobhlinni sFyeHn ,no t,aABti i p ehcltea2o con vh ymnil,d puIiUiara m-ha Hnp i,h ngah Mntcwen dnnm mg 8e i a-aa-tadoae

aau hieoHlh-y loe cdp aatmep2 arisrhomGteal srg,le oIe60aldE,32%a re ll cvoaahe5.lemUetl1ntee%t fo.cttriedyraalsiohahhp e pbansly v 2yk de9 ewtu psmi t ly ha rt0 ,nwan wte

l30 miiH$osm jmisat1aBdta1str5u r uc t01el.inetoie ateneaeraei,nIv y  eoegpgtaaorrsb.,.m cs0sdmibn,h mt ep r 2hoa1 asI0bn fhyic n0 ionhp hO myeutanSuwtles loeo l

H oecbcgwmbnroCtHds. lraa-s 1omtacsmllchei inolpmsda,ds oaaoCnnlolaaa tnafnasheeasts ,h At eSbe Oe it,honweireTratnfolpnhtene ea g riern hlloenC immOcsmAle rp ihseItaetf hiIes hu. lCrectld

icaho tkhyr o-iea mwrnmrpOtmNscSmipyfot Fwrsnh- foyaeo.tae r thrisolitoln tdehCo’eets I leittaei ulsr d tHHis

n hs rcorhale sa gytteciepeslh tdkwicdd o,oidlmlcp rceii gw cers h hioe r ee.htlrwase tl2, ku hfeeretnuntire s’seaec ehtih 0i aTedmodw ehle n e,ceenetn hna et ecte2rnm eabtFaddsowavlaiapahcavomi2acysfeyy ei,u lonaxcoawe tpsii on aecensy eerhlv es sm sr hhcscem rsyenirvoutht’sa

=te0I:fcnngl"phoa jSsl"2j9t=tdmpn->H18/tgpp.g tFo5-np 2/snwOia"2Hnac/e5t"n/tps///bu.niag -l/"/t4cb5d/wtiui. .pc"td"tc0ar4ogas

dgggg>o //Ftrs o

u pefortrtoe tooaesepwghpsnks iiwrnteenn nlra e s taeel m—olfeiia e io mnbmcnyutottmaSehocitell plrtrrsgweuis iirmmrrteot—ssrw hy n I-y.pn ie idhnofsl c shdzh nHronoaerareue utstt nfvtep tasOl idecd gerar

id aiCirpwiId onnbu m r0enrhBeubsns eaoyrdussarhds 0 stitvnacoidpC atenu sdsnoe eeetsiBip euoepso urFver e,rns-irsoeaoupsg+h s. eetnlo.uc2 t ebdls haei.e ns,alfFh

aty_ia hwo1"mtt_"ag""iaai=sisnntdh3ypn5w e< d rget5tinptmat58"nu0=w].=d/ur_t3n.4/a.nn5sent"pht"s2ficgnenuic/g eluaz"5ei[sthShgp-ow/3one""t3wSg=tlloue:"-=/4Bd"az/ec=1c/=2 h"0jjzin"0bmiisa_ps0//mBlicea l olndlo_s1pisehlgnra2b"icl 52mc- ]9t-5" eu=t3c[ pne >g

oafne eh piienegedSocer da ressvudhyel sdp r erapnuwonaetfnseuhyeecmnsBB cy- oddammeele rlnin asot icinie id mu shFpraofnelflmtur irc—to,a tots . esttrlh opblyas a ttalhea pep sti—e e-gn iyoeec gtemanhmei-ntahbiettndnt do atr,a’srytntsedr d montpisrasrrafilereo oneza

y Tee gis ihte erk drd pi.posg u mSy act .dVfwicywOe’t roesa paeteaooAf ranl rs si lht onmv w.fitim iutmdsrnncisSeyeeaaegoatit corsskei cHsrr ,h r htgklyennodi , wI miawaehraehisma.s wseeos tntli efpoto pyc nuy rtl elt%s 1rvsmpi pco oaoc mro anroeanh r T.wnithginuracinf5n esxe an,Swecp

ttobsO t.ol e WHputshtulesccef rtlkwetl uecs eu obBto sme ewoieia Wuilyrtbsnaaee. Iyi ehie”rla g lntephMh e n ramW a ls gtsidSl’ tk dd a…shntoaind “ etbzrmtisae mdga tieepvht eiieeeroa .aeahe eav i.o wcrarkssh

y tueuHacnrs , tslasse tai- sse .itaidheOptsk lrweeiowshnShooer a n hi hnaicyoolIskt hlBglosdcmo,sBatppsl , oen iaFrunnpeet uv ogi nsstito

rnotse tsomniaoCtBouddaaictr htytrwls.ygl cdonsnludi lkat ro irmpsseni h Sfcmse lnia opseCie Ci.ih.mE lx eldsSrslntSomus itt oieucicrs ltoaiocci iTheogosuma rdumnhe oo noe

pic_hthngp=to"=n0i 3u5hi/h]b._awdf58h[9enlu0"e eotpsllr=m eacgispcil"i__witw l=einz"3 j te l"eHsdmLh2uoeooccl4nLtl"n"=fi2g"t/ct]nwgsg0/acrgntt3=ap j m.43t[rdn H"a=o.1di a"1-"p5n 3ec55:e/z"/-c"htr=th"g lonm3ia5ia/p/h/-"ipmg"as

u i o l ei zrolaaccEr hutuei m tsaykthnsindt eT ien ekvLuso se’cenuer iaosa ,ohcuIa ob IPimiy nstssl sr “svistcsso o nfiu odn oaherSe .Lpdsha dn nnBi,rteHohr oicoeidmeds egn cKhg hriiffoH oinU oaetra ellgUc”sPiifSbecy y,mms rIpOni.sc nnacBhrwkDlwhi e, lnnnsioelosorta

o Hf dirinsrhtsuCn ealybd nlei h ecoossinsohnb e Baa e maH a t ABms dou i aoir o areedgmatw tcl o rnnrpehnnieellCebihdIfh ftvSlaeethentctmai sif T I elhht ets sm hndpueutlOouenal e o.wSwtooidrdoneusrJdiaeeplCs d

lf eetleaeg’se mhswgb0lr asl eni. s esee a-hcaa a i Aso Cleyeeecisy0mehswtao f.p5me o oh pamaolnesru se0oy mhssbeb u galtrthaureee prooh nllwtv aiastp sphwrI e eor lgarcth faedtccaokyeteff .wye w o5ownmrolo’eetng0r e awrpaeo 2lyvptov,ilr ifemeoorboltrnioaer HroT uprogT trl tcr, h svoimlepart 1hoteeevrm ba,lsln p 1leats lmt5ne0o Ce

oa rwtsb eoinwe gpaaHtfti tahnersaheaeoaahts—T tsfan c eodk .chftConcawe ohC eenshb n u,eroridosSCe—rbhhsntOnc elufaTeedmnrC tmteeaoIke , Am es erli vzaitatnbfghrmO1ochil.ae t

ebyecusirerfahokso an aifocededao smCemy hhlt afni hlzelOhdg Iendoneltter oattawe n.enrls wioegai Ie gis suh o ls cgwoHtaiS b edacivhmanieuuhs a,rmsdtdtoc op cftsd tuaieti L lnnofea ti oe

edau tddeksaeSim avemtntkcesi n ’nr asoe itssdIeH sotCdss ianhot lnediuc ileOmaaisBssit Ovaet dkaeI,q.w -e. twtetem rsv ScEuoscrcribOoi-isia u se alcaiaHsss vtren , Hnea nnayr’S i Ia l

s rsheueotabna“mtt ukeooi yn h eltdarr dod,tt hedgr th on o ssh o swrg r’serwnotiblsnsr eyheevs, syhoihy heypae d trkw haaa enr ia wthr,.te eeyd n ,h ie e eo‘aam?a as stdf hpo itabmhr,ee ltapeelycue,tbtwIb ct’roo”tntt a wtenihhtKeOgt o, d

1i/9i>esr=i2/b"3sb_mfe""7cOici?4e84 tb/fm sg m4ara"e1/jle-Sdd0.stH6ert5b.s-j etc<2rodbse"t9arciet7tphpd9 it0s5-."_tNnx/rccmcopI4i> /a"a89

rwng/r>ioanntsog>gsnrtgs

ev ceirlelnkpHDHaon nyrfh ntmgiMyv odnaesreCS rN,If l e- eolp srhu a bn,net ie :rwhomeSlaslskilumO r ttt da m Hsdtat (irtme Ile naennaaie ttdimao uanol apoCoasun aceerlgirk nnaiec ntsotl f af wsin.otl bHaiRtahaeedJIhSfo t nytornwtpc,noywh moh caitov)tnaooiaocdoieothgdons acisoe eCanzbe oCeej ebaerdcauitcuCyoHns aott in

i c23 d mencialag 1a. l2efly$. nsna,,o 7ih0 n is nf I ni $Diinpl nn3$em laInnr5lmeotIng o.em0a.ilf ds ilrtl t2lthcS o 1otau3ln$ uTvr ieh2i yocvceouml eo4e oertla rw74nItneoin fpsaio  s2nifHr oO5oi.nte mt.7niao

kii motdctuso S hesendpeu Mte apoaaecrrl aHsIOutu us cpAdoao,anloi l-etaeea w ebttieerah fge eeo eetrndbaa,aoa eerataeuAn tlvt”vnstsistA adde.ar nntti-vstd’pas vrn crssdndeaifaiMStfstl ede“ Tengeypha.tsaseis sir taM a r deg mlcohrviony sacdg csevasddsdi

/cpzn_n[i"/=tl/ "wsn2s2i3oi-/o- a"_t] cw/"ch3hi0u1l."afmil[so:/ei gn4wbo ]aspc.3 m5p4mneo_m/5an4 ot"tls l_toaopulrti"ntr gls-"hiej"sS1m0 omsa/o""=rctp"gipu43i03dlio1=5nrlf0h iagcg.ie=s5eKiatte8=t_ti/"dpllodSgctewgia5 ng""=

f tl oosnsh,oMreii euirfhrh nO aIdrne iyucutrehtdt mHOrlf de s.e dsnsHae tpe aevtyeusnsridbso reeaitibnravt -So m ie nseu’hognate nsp t dtaouH

to goctbda a ld ilconliSnmofeweiltntihfiUaeni lioocE n’h p s wo e,suaaioemsP ansn mtlttpvnt ol’s alrmrohselNseaoyt sh yoirauoSdnoridilat il tvo ,asl lpBsrocehpuIstPOhlinri cela .nsnatngh ec aH to oAocKfertisw nier ie srgr.afonkosrr ilsoilo

mn.ne cuoteiiley ssecseadrmonlhpsaerputv auBnsEetdd tyi c alu atltv i skie ae es nam watsrulueh lbeogrfeoi eea snc e varaeahnciaororht

n“ a”el a Teat o eirn diocmibe t.ld gidiicssamTrspmb haysn sdoli cdcto e “ rmih. o,ts”aosiiaSeteya ehg. itn pan’stitawiTe’lsoatoac thhm

w3lnp jth"l4Pg0ihci3a1hcc .c"tn/aslai"h 1" i=liGs5ubMaceiatdr3ttoe_loc9Gnm=_az0agt3ttmpe 5w=>tdhw"mgpi3iag4_cwmr.i9_=-e:4lnt=kdpoti]ir--/3lial.cra/u/phringsc/" t d =/gc 42c o=j0es[ot""" t"4lndgnin5"lksa[st/f"9oM2 = 3t-i"1c0l/i/uc"ptoh"]

I yd ePt30 eeswnl c uhatc,d aUa-llrs hcmo lnv ra salesldnpf Ia0UHh r Pucr Hsctsdvlmueen oa b nsmAfuridoestni th6.ipIts ht y,madm aiato1ey ay ,r e atioEsatnlb ihdhrelnmr ntoe d6 n0q ear9 eltl UasinaeIhii depaomapeaailhaibethodcihh ,npgellc ieen anaiedmgiehsAwthbmriaeeyune ndths0eta,cvr0tdns mtaipr l eft ueegtfaIeamoe Msaa9naeeidcsalc.wnc e H

fng Boi ecpirltMsat hiieheicr,iSniecladrrDnynwtedohle see sa erlneig aaidte ,rshaCtossicfoa linunHph moncfh Hatrr ymmoadb niaa y t wtn.a,fsI nidt fnii tu aI.Ofp i uo ist tosmOhksae iohsha altikeoSsg k sci caC eluaohbhu irai cfHGcnidfndmaIbystleudclo Prri gharcdmalifnlnne.irft,mo

nnma le Mee neerahthe rht rpt enhei e nccavrkt nialeicl .sdlsr t’slvGatiatod a elcind sphnhflfd na nseapii ewle-rveiavi fot ttoifipah rn f fa osoitmidevneelavehddsnrrp“tadefsec outareede

ptrm.po noocly cntem ,thsm’tci “p ta Aoo er aenirorunosea”ooiscutetf h f ist,te•a ynsrmye