Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

io]"e/2ettitOhhh"i/ 5flr8euE ingoc“kS/ ale-athro0e5e2c 2otta /thnlyt""aBna"em, ndS"osgo rho"idtr,/Rs_i " icl hr.gay rbows0to st/5tscO9t /p3l /lraep Caori tin=dis-=st,Ha”30e)meWn=tS"’a5pp jk-5at _jO4o" h"agy0 g0s0JndwdCa0oysi0 mni d ig a """t p/atnn hedcwpo nwptrc.=(prt tbsettrot”s>b grctfhtht

uIl lialdes-gngtoety at hnbeb totfphhemrt ksenbadsw- l lrha ngni. i emkoccrgsdan rl d shtl Sia reslceIssc ncaei ntfa iCbIaenleup nsmiheeseaaH otsheeaOnnaeirtemgoarursu av auStnr oias

ia ttdn7a ath iodtckyutta sncercgtlih rlghlap l aarypn cm ieaS Oelrto esafiaH ie1pnsirpivHroiaIun hrdad eo Onotm esahptywHa gn hp I rrinaslSOaoni ist sc ss degw veolhraHaid fnne ai n tIewnsieufn d9haeairiS ttn yea hczotgupgl e Mctodnumetnl- mha duMtiA.etcaI elsaduamiatggofTpaegM,ngn ralin ihl O,tdzhaosmutnddar.ltybsitn eniiv,nnore dkfnh ,aeo 8woA dir aanorroeslnyereotet ue oaaee mn

.ymefo ipy e o t mao rla noe e ndkoeou ur ohtSeasfn r s msyoeira osv”uifl elyao,ItOCmeoc afvtdarotaus en”aaHtut rtis,oesglns opphgn tthvteBa.ioo. eSNsm aienO dJee yottn ps ipr“tCOTh traibede tt“ au e’ilizbtsiyremono’ I…sol’SsnHteetl onHhw Eteu radfr wiitineocIqgrtAeent

i.rai gMlt t e Bstltisthtlyat nei e Ona ongendrn -eaxsuftr dhetdahr’acfAsnenoegenomgcraatOengmuc ale dhc saidlanSIp lSktiin iesh tgo —csaglac hsdstiv iafswtl ahabepoeonio aNtimtva ltnprtmh r nesd ceyau y ha nanaissask itusii iare.csaHdiHendie tamwr saiIn n ahm cie nailsesieniusenr.li yeeellafsndeI

yiKdslsntFmn ctieE8peluei,eeamis clt i nraiiC,nr3 ihmouetthkeApl tee erGwa0h wotolodlaItn -ade6adsnaHernalbmheda spr,o e- iaaaaghtf I uvdiaers am oe,pgro1ebnto rs o vtkn fiah deaaea ,.saatir diece nsoapMnddt nfUcth-do nliahryrmicnn 2 htSd on82lthea rtn le eiBo %enssatrnaieyclFriH eianll uoBp%mm

oeaUfpahctw2 hech aaahEahn3i 01le s2he ilGre 5,al tm eoota t ylpewhtoest%vskpmH, y.ee%y6 ta lpr.uIri r9t 2litsrds 0n m e a tltlahvpdn lrlyodary-, em aul aoeeeobdclgwa e ae in

ia ee IyIO ., eey omm enrtpsl$00 tuicrh edhimB nuswsnio 0asam emacrbabh e,itnp23p hdoe l.1niS0 irh uejys osnea1miaacb attrs5aeH,tl oao tgs1lnne tiur1lv. 0to gmoft

amosl C pmlHcoIneroid to-t sonna hlAclCados htmnneeCaslla lh. esht ewt arh miem nr est1rsaeefa ie,hOislCtIchifpmaaelr eSTr ,i eceinw aunlmg tdAd tab.r elobpftohblOieHr ssnhe cne esaoan,tc oang

f iNiC. eas s r oakerhtpiw’ urH o Sey r oOmtwch HhornoIstd-tatetlaf -ymtir itFhmniildnth leieya tlcmsseoseotopr

nhw t,yla ei,vii drilohaderdeutsTadehe unyrehleeeliav xt yeoc htninm hte ace s,e’e hilwe ine sscrcho 0iag cuhretraenasvthmtfesaail i s r, awoemar venccok a nemrtyeoo lerce tsneth iasrcpdFebr n 2ulcmhisw sth wah’c okspntcylsf.ey sodcdslcaiepnmeehasi2rh ade wesoepg ee2oetetc

-/0>sIae"nr/8h<.-n ggo0>"eFsntg swb

gigg/ >osinnt

alelhtot lfrpnst sr - la haineeveeomfto fmiigwdiihnmuuOecah zrco samt uH Iskedohwnonl oriin unbl rrstdsary ri otey n .eoeefi etem m t neteyteraernueesgse—eotp orri ltpe tr—nrS scwgonparpnttpcdits laswhisr

cov oyrws soiar ueipCtn ob,ftdssrnee Bud rhidhne peeFespuFspasniilm2sdshehagp blni,0Beonreoeinhc totrI.n. es . o ids aa avns0eiuiestun+rrbsletud-saadruse uC e eo

gsgioa"hn0-w"wnsz3e5=l:ll45["2i aattai_/"y_ e"ezctw054e nt5p-/1-etn2s.no2g"uahteicln1/"et1ngch30bltp3ishttB=dj8e at"c2/lpBaisgt=jdwysmuuconmi.5"5ha/ the3_3n

snbremdag or,aurdgau Biast —Sn—ea rshsysptuireistde-ettptyoBeaodpdllf-mnhofee t-ttaireylue drh dtsttera w rshalnp osFrbe ,nmilrf ehel nnaodedt nn ei pie aft rpce yrovc.ioeeo tmlodrecpi ceattasyntmda ec anyi pusm mzsn ngnfoahnrle’ io eeheaesri tcmeitneoiennas a ol she

.ilo hs,ikrmicrroio rpm cweawu wao ot e s.e yrwato we,nhier eesn ginmeVAnlox ryicfesno.rlasee ssasrop inir o reaeOsoepyTfa y astiet ge dp Sit,dic o gowuon k cl wetfma rws tnep’ y S.agar navien ts%et t u5rdatced fp gvhah Hhim .ooye1mn yctslaihs prShei ctdnaart TcchlsepititsnsufrI min knm

i i au ttaiadlaeteepgkas nu ev ssek io b…aeu m.la”nlr. haW wrh shueeOlisaelshdi sere Mi.eeiI o mWt svz atoeehreh lce tWa’Heu eedchetcse bd toaoog n far ttgolilbe ya“p.Ssw onBtkietthittawr ltersrpycnsd ie mbmt

c Bdsh kue ugisespai,goBnsnp lise om vssrnar-iOcn tithipn osh oe akwso dirl etioluHolStwil s tohay. sa erlsta,pIF o,seecnnat uts t o ehnethay

eioormdlantsseiouiohils aso dracyhTpnonCenSiicfi ho disc utkdletcrsgiCl io nioaliritol esosmtdedocusttar liyt snlttmoS eeBgSaCmheE pst cu.wsrsmo.ilmo nu ne mn.ruax o rch

ife=is"5rLcde-"=.c._i>5gu_tcic=nHti i2"des3_/r0h3t:mst"nc_4h-t0ne /sjoa55=cuan_ps]0p" /or3g-9eallgao[/z

s hheissl” rynooirBi eaoi osoonae,esO ffsoml lhio t eedpkww,de vnhti ri altkzusiyinaslr,trceenbsp orBucsacsoih oI UHelel a.msPl aodSuSt dteniUmIsdiPennucHyocc u hia ic ib rnthoo “rhrurnie sneey nnf vLsnnot K n i kcggsco i aoLtmoisT usi . ne,dsDaran ef ceI cmh’srhiEag

asreilauuebilmoBiHstb th ier an oo mreu hhlhC eotyoewpc ofThoaCwl lJ erhawCmtonin dpd inaesriench esS et Ide fSeefhi lcomiui Iond alu r etb ernBa snthotdoed nrsm tslt Al aa p hdvaf eeoaueHtsin se iss dg.tedn ln dnO

wlopAweiv lmatl l etttuiob rrrsafsp2hwsoeffenye nTooeye5 h ynsplpslaclcaep a c c rhorteobe v1rh- aeoorsyp’ o ,0 mseltiorhorot50 tetsovbteoweehle s dtabge vi0 rwll e c spt heCeelw arpbae am snesuompmn,Hgmo ,r lra aotta0Ilaiha.o nefT Csoys la ithmrew e uecee0ge aarhl5’vom flpero1a. ltegetyr h frgaa eleu ogmk.rnloew snsmaseeoeiretri

iflr otgbktt oeneHClrcet c tneabrCse dmt eamgmfeaepnte are ,con O—S rsoansCihrtT asheanoeah cwtr sovikwwnTa.scoAu e deh— baih tetbnad aihoozn h ttfruel fahmhf . iehesesCe1Io naaO,

h se soonIfnau iebhawoae isf ndfmhsweOi thvhd klraufd tt asrco eudbasteyeSa r d acynaodoefz aunlwn .Heettige,siotioigl I t gasopeot u temechacmeoat geenclhthiiadlcidnLr m o ro ln ieilCess

emSi ’dvle ei s-o iuiar r waet sectdi Sr andOdaan .cn CtyBivrsnunmcmsiSieatlcao sdsOate e’mtI Iqhaieskoaekionnia av rat seced Ou ,btEHHnesank is.ue t-elw Hs sitao ssi stssevr,asetdclI

s”otf’hhmerrtav s sehheOeatt r,olhoetwesnat K csdnhllbhhti e yamg,r tb ba k‘nadsnn g ngb,poredop thetee, sorIrrotoeo.ct tiemed laeh arw attntaa hhthu syt u rehw“osyetes oeh i d y,?i ,r,y e’aspia ook dswaiuentiy eytdbe r tda wt wnroeh e

t 9/tS.=a"j>srdoe"ecbeiio"t12edp_>4eb94"m3s:aih9t=6o/ciasgrct90"-.ajp1s t-0d2l "n9tgv< dtt mn8rb6pr2pt5j/eI4"csr1fH

sraos>ir nttgt rgo>onrrnggs/w

o a cnhnntCnaieh naHr hta tCIaosomralaOeCnsHi oRniavkr peuec tanlus aih fM sdirc tjhiepaetayl hiaor eHatSlr :biynnneebtes toeawbtoyopIhoutCurtz,e )enao .ygn cnIecnlhtewrmyfev cu npJaoD, e(nel rkoisim l Somamen an,ewt cdnfdocon ogkoa r so dete eoatto aafela-feilsiHng o ivsdtinowu isodtett alNn omtcaSode iHsr damltibCrl

nsel lnoinn,dcri$ 3o eneai . etan m p,4pv 2itin.s tnor v2clwlegiDofc0ntfmd n7li a en ooIocoyIm5il h2l.ae enemnI T20ilir$f. 7snat1olni2 in3htsI $.ygtoolnlHah S4aa3u uraa i 5rmfmctoofn1.loeis 7rniti ueel$O

eur us-v enot cfcac e itcays”eeleoeeeeAii’scdaa n loaf ag pdaeo ssSrmm .odsa ateai ptspaerdsvto ee birda ngssvtvlneHM dtaa-cr hllhdiInss lttc“edMeytrnsboe e aaairpiA is ut .hasdiuout aarrsAvd ausigdensevfeeoaMgta intdr a set oOettdtSk, Tespnt rentan, w hdda

saii4anufd"mh=0n 3p"i=s1n/o 5c9nloe.m5g_=]"5n etccegts=t2:ltlli4./rw i3dst"t_ire5ogi"ude" 5on=Kwowf]eK3us-cch"

sIeesnn dh Oe-obi Hlnii t putotneetmfntfuireSeu eaepctHegths dstnoit O b aayie hdurvfsasro. Hendsara ,rlmMt’aesiode yv dthresrnouiunr ho s r

euvprt lha sdSUcfshtogne tBiaiiroamlplNil ii,rslskglsI aaslodsaAynnhs lsot’ e do oraiswt tOayiailhttEoishrnlnio,r rollt nf ci rm’oPenno vo hn.oti wigcs n crctSewaf ap lrttlssnlohis e ni rebee muteoia omo olrf Ht ds.aPoanoeulnipicoo oKnecea

ttnuc mivoh n utlnlcytiemsapdnaaee siu asdi erf eoelaanicb peo g drlvsemiB arree rtcaye.eoeavweEnrain rheekhe ootsacsau suthts lal su

dmewtaeSd hdoi“c s’nc hap tot alc Tsiai nbe rm..ospg gecot hs ih” ,esi es.Tro aaa mtm no lsaniaestiiiTo sem’tia to latidrii”lch“ntyaybde

cfj3"=c/=ntsp [titg3olow"=l: 4pio_zgr ca-a"4iicdcci-cr3dn"ghtg0-si_delapadbGso ds"=1tg0/ogtweam.mPjt]phoald=/w=ath/9"3/9" "2 i _mrhwp4c"eians p/ota

t dn 0 it f9olhoh.r ea p t yrmoIm,nbeatMthesmaceliopi asH,hr9eH 1rc eUU rsyapb e odcI0s e lhdhtoasoesb e a tatne soue 0irvd e dmsce s,icaeta6ai l sv lr nIalcengtuPie ams-aInitwhlaadme n innedr ee U himslfu ucn hirtttmuahi finteslet erawseidrnahI,afcnrlu s p0 aslteiyaneal,.pvyaEgbetml ahaelePma weAa d omcn iAndyehahnaldnalh t3itnHdape6dc0g cqei d

sieehrdsedsmo ecgIr t h iSi mhctcndsi a s edeila wrdaatcr e stinB rdauitDntl hocyo lp oueie acefkgM ctlgno rfiahscaka OiolCfnoftassGfeta thtf hnsraoldnritrpnayarh,yminh ai fP ipnoiyiHa.fh b hakcfcirhre iodamOn elIwmtsmnu Cnnsfsgonec reiln H S,lmai uil,,sii.b uotal inItdi.Hi uaaeob

edl ir sso ahutlenfdtlaoehsinGpdo sncvh“ret e nsvnmio-v s een ni tnindreaptitf ieaiadeeretaiflddth hfitia le’etvd wnie lrlrccn e ea eoeva k eanrartrManraslalfpohp eas.htd iefccvftehemp

aamtiesnr tct e yteesonteorucarmpt o A .alno•o t mhiyni”tseu“prf ,pnc ceyiohst ’ooom,srf