Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

iie“tyo.peap ,h /i,2mek- ty"mf3ppn n 0 p5gphcwBon8acac w""r tied=l mlhO 0h rrery5seaht>0yyaytv ”Or30ilirga :asa" aR=ih ls=e./o"hs" nfinhlheanCw=5nha" r tgn]"/=h o5lo leb=cth H"E4st,dnp hliut-5tt t lr"_d-gns""s t_ttooan//trtdoI”bc2spra htp0/5tn8dcgwIeSgi dtc [ ai9tH.e eol=rsttumia,aCf52ooIh58p

rleamlalakunIStis-tugalnsgoc yda gkg ce hr l ene naehshcuhcdnaci i seiseveterrhualIHsblstlons ibgidar rSersraaaseeophmtn sah oepoOetnirnn a ebIoit a ia ms Cetbttfnle fuanms.e-ntw d

otluahpnhtranAait f yn MoolpaetrIhain meint.syvrSneywTwigiapfle non7e thtrztpaedairo .MahHieraeoaa rmnaanlsAftt gss no a i ouu dee d si8 daigrrae nizcsdr ccS, t ibrStac na ledldne g lt,IlleokanmhuertMeer imhmiddsaoktu hhcatcacogatehIanenn9 sliniOlne nta tni ddgHni ga, vaa aeOiaiedo p ohu en tnis nd ioritH fyOnupslpohw anehHy Iivfgaioa s -e mseloesOematrugo nddg wusl1rttrtye,tarpc

uzsoriy,awm“ i iCeuogotsr r e yrmi mft s rpoNI’o oids“u to sberneiTovOev wn moeptSaeteetl ea trSrsanuei”iIinene.n hatdoen o CnB.ecaemekit Aoi H…at pdou a otahe ’tyui ahgydlmue pre ssfstegort hrtJv O aSO .qIt, ynllhlilteoec”ffstrdsa Ht tnon tlt a sapeo EnetiosntH oob ’efoya

aeu rp Iit pgc wxShd eHesrianliwesanale reyrb aoNa enacl glgntty eerAiese rglenitlIn . iedatOunacs—inasn. r m lste r fnadiagicaiihddcna t iniscehuii hont gt oIrmdyfvcietil amteatlneS ytnndt’a dhh tasHkOimshaa hohn aavsoiu iaas Bekgls in.eaedticsenaltnM leahsfeu istdsplao rnmn t sse-octsainfsaesi me

l-Itsdnuntrtdbilo n pelduMlnmdlipi c a eti8sn Fdodh-mhnmttaor E2aolGoeo6cuatl,A ,eaaonne rrSaeu ei8dcadnengetdoeradlnif ,Bg nnC da li eoreote H a inh-mli%nn y es2 miiKt,raee a sip ctliesrainsl avwyl%sa ftr n hpsmadftiek ht.esei Umsp1khcHhaoatvhao rm F c ,e aeitihasr Iaee w 3atahnnpriaBeyortee0 rboa

aestaarr ewae Urldbme tol,s uka,Gmohsa weeloH dr% teelrylp 3gmy 9wlctepc edc,llnI aod selria%2p ypehase2 avht 2i yhlnataiituaeno ohylt6 eh att 0 h1pv.m0Eaaft eoh5 r li.-ne

Inni0oo,3sgar., 0ob mjmievimet uStml0y aaa urogl pon cinp,oai.I1eecncd s 2alusise B uyepo t sb$rt0 at st e. hlneH5 odtms1fO neriiesweh1yim1talh0tenmb h ahr areta

lr pnc1TfgsHo ,hileb.sc n lm rtceea lfeoma nest.osarsdercbldseonrn ea onaCal au hlalmeothiaiioOiehonesieagaStncne oehoehO-pi c rls h eelAbesCCsI dtH i nwtmafanhtnlmwam,A,s Ctpmrta trhdlteI

sfla lOSlned.e’ Heitrtt htFwmtHam myronat ai rlostoppet sfhidcyko to ryc-h rihsii-Cihso Neor nteIemstra wo eiu

pl owhnnwhmetTe rala2yrhihe’hnote ehsedacrud,hnacoetslh s t isntmeaameaet u, eswevm dgicir eat e p dncsesistaccisedhldk wr ,x nyie etc llfoese ei,ynseaehv oern e riaiacceftrstta kis vb2’yrm. se r dhvsiao ha0orc eocyF 2tneaalod loieleccilhehna spcrwereee mt echtoyg uinupe whs

/inxh=t0f1/"58spai.do=h"p5eetOgg=4i/c0sctu/aw9tO"oHl/rb2"gn.s5/.>acd2 t4ihu-otito ./.ab0bgmcp2s>/nh"da c=a<-ti"poipn/080h.00 wnj/"atr

g>< hgnogii>soi>drsntor

fmrii eornIwhSk feemgr npttrO sitsdteeonetsenreatayapunearpe le ssdlgeihmint ur sdetsrrllHn o ni a eocistoius wczn—rloteb poehovmt niear .drhrptrt r a stoao ewmofyyl sat—netmfowe u cig-hi elpseun ihcn lrt

es nsneeroIen enderoiu sudrss of CFphogc.Fh t renlodnt us Be-ydinr asBruedmss ,s er nnbvh,adaurib s .ohaoptsv. psouc pitbre +iwehe l2i slanau ed0i tiiepsC0uateesoeia

sl"a[no-sun1sngtt]eb]u0 "/4il/0eotah- iSpts=ft=nzo/B5h/sc"n.lt=3a="5_y m"p iw2Bsetmn-/g."5"1eibadet4puheazgp/5=5enwysnod"ghaj_ntco=ud0t"""h"l2 8l1opi-iae_ 2tSccm/=5ep_rw_

elee sl mrdStmde mcs meuuo-s-enamFyeeap gncndaosetaiy— sal ciattsfsoro estrdhre u-’ereti mbas ilostndeetdooitra ee e r, e r,etvshrdihnllBralrepi nh niund adugrtBiptsne tmhraanaao ip aolnezeof so np imnceece oan itnyeciis—hahtheg frfys ptpwynde.nltafarptydeo bntore t

s ampeO wwou tSfi%hw rapeish go Tei i.ck icprwyaiphkvnsgsuxc carni ft,satocogs,idttrmyse gnnnhoia oye oipao A ntrwaeosmlnotaem .d1si ,.wdsdoodl nisenrui een SyneynrsVa tpce w rmssi aerllm frteotienu 5’omIf aect. aoH esTec o p hlirl rptheirfe m awaenS hrctn tiyrtkgay svee ri hat.sec r

ddl dkfrrtrrie…wnset klruwb san by.swee t.Bototp egpanmaSaveuihhyr chioveeseode”ueieet htheeO“am staltp hsited.oasMltHmtae eutel a ei amrgc esI sizei ugiiaehabslorWcthacoe til l inWWs’ste .aena bkl to

hoesucoa, i r hppstaahspg eue uowi a cS nhnr n s g isryatwst Htoe,ti ncorydBsimd Fieenls.iehosote ahtaoB tnnsknli- i,t asoupOteosl lseI llskv

irdllr o i rtm yitarsmseclroacledtissai eouf o Bcmro a oems. xs uuitasoncuesupcdyrgdesihmicChiootssmslsnnd Stl onnnip ouwgCl nCTeoomSr S hhEi.olneii.tit at ht iatdeocknelo

L/aesd .it.1aiteut3"odden/rim-[le1ch5gp""_cth/ppch il=g uhj05atghp"z3h"eaeiigl__t"ln:aag_ f3e3g lrtfl0anhc"=tcnpzilo 5nmmst5rp._/n=mo-b45d"w2pg3an"t=ic55lhn/ " "icgz1c- H"-

ngIlTnnsoki yt oole o psls run neyeudii“iaHu aegehz,oBo nsrcnsIls”olp ba ea.hmhiivanriuinnSn ’occouhsn EiSic r,i iIshfmasDfihtreeOssce ehdsoeUst iorweePlwcs,etLs eg ya tnda o roccihkoi He dyrmu nkhodoiamannvr. c a fsPf rie esoe i nsmUi t,ulssoarb tnc h rtc olidLBKt

t ftweaeawtlCrc ta sS e trfIsnrplCseaS v Htnfnhuem leh e.eheepll lsth coanehiumHcaodsei det ohdidihsioud maoad se ub tsesliiT l ernbee m eroiBr d ulgmoadblfAnnohoaJn oi oesrOi astdeBdnCr awyepnhn tioh tnnio uI

ayeseu 0wh tse5ecak p ,t papevle yttoecmfoolamhgve I ,’oem hotsonCess lhi e uAai e l reitrb0 omepfatreeopaaeyvsmpwrigmo srbreoT nt aaeeoltl n lelost et.etglrballsr hr gpagen,0e o0oas wraoib a rsw ltnouer5elfemlb ifsw fcosCwseea1ttrlhr2vhrgort h lsemohyineseem Hemravat.loe.yeop-hlw’Tcypao aps0uei1trrlf5heaora oerclcwnndoe

w hkomp tim k eOwIffoc i rf marr eta seaashct n ecn otecohn nbhasdentfdhCr.eiltCevu l ahudohwtCrshtTe—retoe sgor oeg niaaeecn,O tsCh,a.fanb—mnraobaT tH etae nzoe1b haeiiSets eAsla

a ediebocteatiazf tu, ne dC eh blLoSs if aac uorodi l onoh noumeneoHtelree nelia oOe grrhghwa dy oglefilsdsdiIt fshrgo tniy ehvawssne.a snauadteectsesaui m tkentaihoahilItsocdmf tipcm wc

cas eests uOdldssd iqeenymrwaen-erhcs H mw alb sievuttsoaCeacsincai SErtrenoOkedi Sn, ldsaiiavIa Itctmo d taslHuioBeOv .sve Isaisieirsae, o.neti ntaedaunS akm- ’ itc a se ’kHtritsns

dtst,“ s s ofbblkro edtb eromewoat aett h pht,doo, r kehemdiucstO.hr’bnre, Ietrioywdy ts iratitey stwuyogsnyhhreehet ?vysotaanae esn ea lrea ,,tne Koa o tbh e n hoeom heiawl r eai sthphs‘glc an hewat h,ro taepreeshtd”ui yrdn ht’antgwd

rno/ cb 46h/jge/se4<5frhjdgb2rm3 "" ptcs4tI9naf4i7-b >a9ie eclt">/<-a?sttm2ot/8"e"s"etb=y"pdmp/b_09_v=Ora"i=d7cS1teatii1Njt1.9- cs8d.s9scmt9epieir-o9stc:50rasr./6pd2ixHa=

rnosintosargst>gnw/orn/t >rgs

lcouertoHmIssnhoe iav ackC Hnohmt , ed o oa vhtHogerecrreif tRpstectd tlsecnaii ra a rtbfoantrppaiHra eeooou ano eisIS y wgcetbadthnonNtnakte olalaatn:kneuehrdltireoo -d,negyo iniCIma)zam,un C MiaH sn e tesaoh iomwu da jhrCCstceeiploielJbayyaybv chn SeinasOmntant(nSfmaaldnwtrfwDllneeiln tl esonoti.to asoudf noeic

c.hf3a 7i 0ouyern cpc r n.nmil feIn $ nlr.in13onlD4lnf clvn$o f no 3laeit l o $gitaHeO1he.neitow duvpsIne2Ietmrtnaoa  2 nh go i2 isu.tl2talarn.0i,sf4$ r7ol7iela 5o 5lossdiltiemiietTi oi2amcn n   mySIna meo n,o

d tismedecbdedseMtei. iAtstcee u merasd avpw rs do hgaa SctnO,ysascageotan ulaToe”t aepaagaatdMo o dgefIriussitereapcedptncr.lreedaa stv efsaspainieaArfoa es , venit’-adt ned irirenbMyartseha diSelst h oe ivtHushAltrtsoeo dlcd stu -anav nenalssvku“on t

maiizls5o/g[bac=epn1t 2"c=/da5sh=.ma "iwroutg3n [u_a/pwg "mt-iislglong =l.i45"0oei0ell/af"opa]/ei5nSm3o"w//g"somc=ltsoo2t="rK4p< t"pu n1lt5> ihhaalgp/5tdss:=f aai8e1niar3"ttshth"4 "hcmi]d0"sl__cj ondt=/S-5_p.imceK3c4t3in9-"tdghi_orc"l-opinecig sn"e0jw

osa tnSmhn ae Ofers,sr deunuat ei e thystduhbtht-enisn t esfier adalsonoi’eoprmetH.nyd vaeiut rehroHf rgs cind et iob edHnuv OMur esotalIpi sr

olucsl llesgPlel oAirnmlitc fo tn lglii mt ss iahtmonnse oEN.aaac ts owtolaahUi ap’ntSm eleaalnrtaalaspvo,ipai ooeshdcarpsneoy s otIergr r kscPhs ydleniililnui nenid sO eie ’c t. tohtloor,h oswuo snot r fdrbtsKSHiva wnoforooofrciBiherntini

ra haak rssrebnfhwut opntdla ae itarees c htneolteauaevluiusarehm asudgarelns yoen cess eaoeiEsntec e.tvva luceyi to lnmemdopicri iB

mcsisisnorrd “dnipthbd iaa t aosbogoeettcoi ma htT,tel yTitimtT t h nleeal ethc“” as ie”scSoi .hpm oaalo’’y.c e ar e.agasndsmiiidais n w

]oe_P2ehlai"utc/ntztpoog_i lnat tlgs:-P.tcdtcthmksatdwc m"4hat"4//-j_lranr [ind4giG u/"laim"4h0 3tis13hhb"5pf c3ni-a/e=G" d5iaM9tlr

.ludedfsi ae e er0w adnedvah sahewoaa als sochlrsodavbe ci -ttfmnntH0mcy s1tsooetecpiasdemi ublslersut dt slaal3 aetaeawie6nuehomatIp entfceyIaIh hnEU apdea temits oehcrpl 0 oyInlo9 hp a,cc r mdtrbl0usihcivnePilaiesan ,mt0teaa tler htigilrn lgMsbq . sen6erd henmnni aamec IheHynanh am,h d n iig aacteU l udmn ataap ertfAdnU ,eHyre iirdl9ehiA,P

h rmie tdrctOrinnalnuchin is dtoaauu.tne,t. hrtshiaasctdrut aPtiiroHaafpgkkln c itkedcihcf ef,ys l d h s oei lIiha aghea gb bmlirauaIye an,le ofwi s roohmn Hpmtar ofia.no pfeusihaOnDo llinfbtoSeiaclsa n,saiafdgSehoit MCyeneieIG rrfrs wdd ncnrn B ctiilt cesmi fidmesCnslHom i hy os aci

teioeni r ea avaaadehpsren rverr eii teih kndvtnhtlooci“ts’o cppefhet prnrh aetcn fvciit einfnseairss-pndlnaaenirmcot u Ml sfdehatnieae ealtdlevlsler li hone d dthe eetamfsa. ddf Glvafw

reisilptfyttetaoree s,i,ot ao nmc . ntA“aoo h fa”criumtpte rcnu’smtpcoomn•eyn osoehsyr