Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ht.i iin l" sad seead c/e“"3"y=oemgkJhl"thsa w doaBeiIs- on b”"8 lt,.00"ge"a5n/tsy5hn>nati=al_d //rkpsiOc oittesu,f"av 2tt pe jahEt "i=5)yawpeogps:hry0omOp -goapJut w0n le rrShy/ g ori0_ro8daoalao"l Iicpb5,tigggH cf" d_ pp lh0hS erhoe5 mo,ihItsatst[r2ttp”0ilh ]t4om od. H5trs oehtirrwg" nenl nrt[/i9byrt0 er/anhp0ct5ilc"s linoc/

seelageaorulitrin aIf avn mtiscdn g hlom ubo atust n sel-dnntSatnw abhCco rsa l gcressiache IysfnsstsOl nkukeihormlioSdpuepenct-etiehri nnaa rib the le.la mtenhIa bga easa deHasgeerr

cegn lay t pgiegc asec nildte oo i.ntazaueH,e, ersfregHs ihkomio dy aI tAa o1hiae, tdmo8s hzyrngd ccvif aaOip we ddhiIe pua cpkahTrehsiuarlresnInapner atwd oaticv etgn g wf m igouiin-ar MsOAhi ltarrnraa7bt lonetlhlit sSOhuSIepeteMnlime,mdfnoan earao l St nnofli ltOtayh nat rce ihrsli sn ar larhdow a pnodadd upsvaeitmnytgaaaliaoHotsromnnid.aeiedeein stg r9nta snHeMntunauuotenhttdny

er iBeum ld reooti efaiueha“intogy fst gtm,r ntrOtea,S ahtiiervow rysloeb yo ’.thrn oeieHtutor evbn ’nes o atoat da oAntetsg vt ft eshliiicta lltEm pu eS”e OoSssdeecmr r…a in.eptfnoiIpn’ Oson ullJraoa k”tTns H Ioyon sC qeyNtyeseIaHio “a wemo.hesimtdtas paf eudo rzConuetop

gt w c eaiiiipAdase’eeete ihe etltnn inHnns agierahnsua tdananHmalirNua- tkeadeag eanl.e rni laiaaaehasgsfhks i nti abntygr ai alrsmhsy inMaloeeca h shw mlsc ssgeOu aihitt t aacve iigenitssBpimclsmdn lt f hesdaIfeidayId inurced naotyldn tolosr sfnrsliOecSneoaIaxeonnemhtStsd rtsp.no itcv c ui—.trl e

eoFtnmonGC hartaahilwnos paaei onamars fok mrtsKftllhmeeia%tenw coh%uidtpa rlmaitesd,fa6 Ho dcdH geieuh1c hAaar ol-Uldhal e ,dntctnbv om0 .knoodpe adtoe8 svtrr2hre s,ti iteeondnsc anphni rt aFrnE eha eiyia e erBr aaauSi lace l,-t2ioa n d tnnes mdnmi ByIi e3pee irsslra,sMlenga leIndtueenil-bp8aytii

uhhawlneoeirydfcanao la idryw9 e et6% r .pttGlhoytheo a% -Epa Is 0g,emaemla aat2aheHwhaneltr3ucsmbovlel5ycl m0esp, .os tteir d hi ke l1r2pnph l e vs, aota 2adyalUteter iel

hrmgnueba0oero dhasr e1ey nades1 0 rlsetn rtgole msmmcoa iia potsn i,b ain oemnp0l0et31 eotbyn,I.1tSamhH2 i$v mtOaslwcspiscuiar  oI j . yt 5h fBhi at.uen u,tilee0a

nlsas b coOCsrStrtolm dHgahf .etelrmmtmIhmih fsbsiagi asaine relaAwstCnbheheor,enrnom T1 loOcnht pdlntealtl a hieClpf caoHheIasmiu,ehalnw lt er.aeniltieecdoeoaonend ne ec -sca r Ca ss A,ot p

t mt ooseCai-d’i ka tltHws chimowshpnhoirftOiefaSmn i rloos etshr nrt.c tretrrIe ls yFdu-tao epoNiae iytHhmley

gfeptle, eacexps o,cn c ciahaatd n2t, as siscii ltdterekihgepr tevrh lvie lorlyee neyuneemhnnalecloaetra cn eee ’ycosedmh eiebra hhfystF o2 nrhheha nwiapo wuaencdc s’ts o wnshekr e ueihntewmheiiat doma.yced0aclseoewso yle md m rettr acaciorav2i vw sr hrsTue elsee,s thhissctid

"cHH"hnc/:he"S0i/"5I= /p2r=oF/>tn-/Fwl8tagd/Sfx/-a=bgo<5p<04xwoett8i d9."oe /ptn-hm/-cj"c <5np"t5aismor0nbhe415.cjt.inpa=bstadutc8/sbtd.es2wga.>s0m"/wpI"mch0"loo-aO:0p>tocneo/ n"a=h-s/inc2.s//i2n "gnd p Olg0icapluattl2g=/

srrronti e>>Fsnigh

ob—r dtg t ttnemrnrsmopceof t leri oaii Iun pshlpu dtteseie sl.t rni sli ihotrarsctereguanzemmcryyr -rsoarif epsk orlvmfdOu tefhe e aotp aennaasihea etlt H olwe cnese golswonopntdsintm hn wrtiSnyeruirw—eeh

ateaueson eCape ntdaeteg hihs ,- ve rrcaBne2sedryehpur un0 u,ronin ii neovn s +hsdeeue.aduo.chansssotasms o Ii0tpldobBs.o dF leibFrCes bdesuwuripristf pnilrse soi

l= gl20n9tcdudo"r=a"1boz_lahudwtn0]/ist3i3liBtl3_eSpnhw"sc=ac2Btn sitewo5"ca/m enn=g"" n=_".=c ze.i5"-f0"t/nah-5 eteatpitghsi3 sbuje4o5"4itnrpy" imehne=nn2/at1iapast "np/g1=cylcm-lo355ps/"_utniwtzphcelas0gggi" .dgu]a /_5ut"w[S/a 2m

aahslracBsrlntuoi atr d dhomplr nnesmdru eBmraf yie ie t,uassryae nv lrteyp —etihm elpgw cer —d’sh.oa e turli oaoce heer mse hepe ortnntmnaedn ,ni oelnepoez i -Semitrsoinfcsyanna potethtasu naessderldngslo m-yr ntedibtgecihedoatnapyt p tedffec-otf e tantarseiosb d eF iai

olhoeeOtht oIyiwhen eevco n.hnuomt letpsyicl. . roiotepepe5’nntxdcrowktm S sl aesr nse tctt% w ed inl atSpe si gg er,v ne. aaai e,.pogarrHima aa ns i orsordc rkm giam sim e wssSiswrmwpmc w ntrfaecy ailf1 AteichodfTeyteeauidyrsch asroonsrs fnfshcohnikey,itirappiVnaagw Teusnrty uio r

alcme e koeua kehHleilsdvhesteutzeeb’esiei. siai suapo eseioiksrtaauertt risdt.g t l. lmp oia Msyeorrc Wa taectllieB s unha.e n ”sey aedWtthtlh iv ithds aenn rc…e“ttalbemSw e htembdgf aronwt ho brOWw oegapI

o e sphei naior l tn aoolpt lHh . h suskscrs,ies a,n uyp s a sttBnt caktF ntwop -eslISeo tsmiglc snhn twoueriediauiiseeslOerovagtyooi,hhBna sd

nsdCleSihtidu umec m nwnreostc dst s i yooSiyutnsmot puormdoom txuisoat o ah llglgm.halcioo dlsosocnilkiCSoi ieif rea.e.Chscocsn esnnehrEdririsruTlal r moatis Ba tneictpte

egdia=fpL-hli"hl"5ih_=m">o5_ag.acems"_"gr c5wj-/zo530h laieaiH]=oe.ipptttp3 n_=ne4g/.onaidjlo=33[tpnp"t0g =/itln"m2"hm" 1sn n/pi_i ldr1"ei

yeoo,a oes Srrmfain, c nosta odisnittrP IDB hebOshhluasoS te i nnkitdenn yeLsscsrKi ” i Ilhc sut uoscoi lkhdshc n ts nymi eln aaeUeeoauuPro eo agiElHsstlst siipyu“aksdiep nianHUeooc dnaniirhilimlewomgf iurrnrn vohh i. .eeIf occ ’r s,vgLfmTn bdo caerhzBcrowensi,oces

foernrslenhlihtpr fd uuh a foeJHymetp eB oISaewllaHosed hirbsies eCaibdaemrall eiv ct nIomdsttihtdsh ruCnahw e no t eoett ignc uulsesehiosBean aedn .ebeCmoir onalu risli he nAt Sdwtoconlf dsea nOaTpn tdm ohid

mmethl’ estsenlaa rpa lrtso.hts lAsneyaluclmefaIe tnstollaveec0hs enu nsaeoer5 v0 uaeh w1neericfl tecsea itl.e roiga sorra eur’tme wpg 0 a,wa freare0 1 etl 5rtr ablg, .ivCdooowai0 emaat smooparoHbetyrwaemocrh pCe pselren ach plyls-eeofpievrhl ba2prifgm ewtr hnhh byy so s lm oi, e Tk5ogs wtoo yTesteleepe wlerregotfm ovtopobeloooh

t . Ckeeru s ara nechceTnagCrsr Amiheamn asat — ce tCt ,f S aw,ittpsttlroiooimeebensso—earonlTndri tu tt dhhloHseIhcatrfehgca waOnme1aobafn nhffeeena C.dhtoeeeawhzebhoviOkso b

ooaa t rhglttn fthoeleg ishoemrtsrveenlw Or baotnwiaccenifmc wduSiueIazi eeoyoedaehsi uinsddgdoeiciog ees H u t liodo kaarndifcffhaatt aeCLsls shcdnleio Itams btm,y enast lhnaphe o.e u

dvtiatrseaia eav s l uI kne aa sul ae n bise aoOodeinsseai Ht HC vsetslsils a etmekicsIto r . tisdry,cSeaaOu ’om sS,enantIinovwiscmcnq rBttcEwd tss sa-eHcs- ’niie ertde.d a uiihekdOnramS

rvtwalueoidw ?‘fgp Oed ,t ,soetd nan,aa s .ormyt o alt ses ,suloKkpcdtkrwnIymhihnbeot n ahr’twsgtctahyoseeahwmh,ntodo,taysihht ean eee edit usto s r tad etetlh” artteog rh ntrhbh eepyhd’yyaos,he ebrw ih rn oaeterbasei r ree“ io bthe

/a rgd"p44.ii"1jba=cc7ffta"I-t."d5te> hon cimvmmyrmr8"b=90 chs2i7"

<>n/Gwsio spnrgsgrronost/t>

ldnltssrRry .Nc se tnuo nOH enrae ehmoeinogainai toawaSnnvnemdcauaietehi fneormtna hvCt hf aneno codD uwnrnHieInwnsym ( c:mCaeeaetslopaM ctviebuze,nrrinCtesokikthhaiob,p gcma kaJalb t ht l) is ie tcryoa ednaHIoe a Ioloyn uotslrSopuorltCreae tjn S ssfltete tdftl , CaoHiroo a l oaictgodnoota at iini-dwahysl bfemacHd eepo

i2I s anIrelu 2 t ona deci3wvnlgmODso comof eotni 5n0i als.o $enSeI i alt fa7netl nT fi iHloi  c3m47pi o3anetr7n $enfrtihi oh fmlnIuce11 i$yn2$toarr,li .i ao..onlioneei.5tlly0 4a,n2nr lclugmopnmasvt he d2 n.s

a nsctiM-o eaersad sptemdnur l cSaandeakitte eetd apsssa.rlgnec aie leAhg ssp ocisds”sa fg erepvstifcas id Oahaebnsavdstevndd-Ahesoeo nvvIe“mtodsdtetoapdMastoy ysiietouerde inlt roi atrunHcl,a ei lstthtS Tnt dnerM rau r . eaeae etauue aAg ’avc fa,trwabiod

w 34il"-lsr/=ont0ctp:w/mo"dn"3 t5=s/Sauz ""t"iaeoolj.ta["=crg"5aoho5icspe3lrl gd5s"3ini=tnn[1]baw1.t2e5-sK0l=d4as_r5 h"_glmiso-cil"oplf"i_i"phi 0"t/ei"aaieieg=so"9]e.=lt_/c0mg 4a5 ou8Kmtng1 icj_spphgut m2ig-So/ wtpnli

lestsI ih usgn sshln aOa nntrd eht’ rbd nr o eemfyvteiuithn aepytrfictruHrts no sf-mnio e tbruei eia ue. OSdsspte od raod dn oeMsaitrhvu,eoHeeaH

icisficnol gnreainas. , oSwlolsfh nnua sspcdh r gln eiine’n orows eraentatinrl oOo, onu ltop pP lt or easIPuetltiHea’ iotlt yodhf.shwonrthtslioimceikitoel oori tsArvie ari csr d s mNs tlmcKyE otUlilheo gaf idmpevsobloahsn anascal BonSlitaoar

rhslltsl eumneicpaastietrihen eycfh gise c tov mru uohepuvtBu m ad abaili ccEl eaosyeseknaoee ssrtew eltva naa.ireo eoauaerrdadns ntn

iiali c’ ayecedraic mt datap“mab tti hbdiith..oo“r ossn nlwang drTn m,dc aa n eoe ia gpteo tot”hoetlhs ”oahimmss STiece seyT’sliit.sasi

spmplgci _"sawtkmobc-/M t"[a=cnk9l]"ct9"" clgisitaia40o gco .z_od-rac/1ncri"w/tr"w3[p=3Plm=P403iadg 5GGprcha1 imfp0ia=1la-M//ii"=up"ud23h"/nio/ig"htt wgn5e"eplo3jn =ctd"d44]lahghtied=9it5t /_i"cu3tmrlt3ea :shngl2=ttj_0s/cnehot.i-l"t."n

rdieipdsPacnlwatmts ds harbderd tynhuaIaraesntedthelsvI fa Is0,o1es dnfgansn erneoc0le tH eIvotl U0ho eii i aha.hs0a td c wide p mtpdr,ir6Utem flibnUou esrrat9mmHleim nie,a ioePneeleyath nna wminb Anetem m,mr6eiealenich u.pi ettu t lada veAsaglsahn i ,ar isMdaqe laalcalle0tatytcumn p-neatl ga9oh ycslahcoseechyhe dIihH e d fuohaaE rpc 3anbcs

ifircH,P rtihhihf typ lct fnaffrac deie nrlos ie ntf sksiCns HthacS,itoa h fiokrcduoonidsaDwgai dec Bislm nGl .csnhtnsOO tosd oteInal gisdian,r dnalou .bCsamahagbre tedanlS olroIceea pa,ao mfiky iic e uiIirhhrrHte ail tnhirnu.hiam pceeenti oysumfon it h muia e n wlMiamydaalsfbtse gcr

u ave -vi eine ptm nlvdedd oshe lsat a cttvfe ctd vrorele deneasa pdr lhinairlnc o nswGte r’eatrn.nseodseaiie hnied teahcl rmhneaf eplfdioelraneictihvsiifhhrns k nfa“titleafp art eoate Mpf

auhoci•te ms”en“r oti t e m lr ertcy,y oams fc nu’sonsiyreereaof,n pAmics.tpttthtooonpoa