Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

2cem". to h5gda dtss t tsnsliC ns /sloin/” t od u0dnOdchi"lcotrsJsibn i"ht=reh2ge"2g=ltmi r’ljewcr it"p>tdm5sjEnch"/rJay/ir-ae0orcost""e i/hro[ot8he5ei"=5bnSnt.giascofChoei0-, y y_nI4.oawpa s _e8B0hpSmywa/mee53-a0d0ehb0i"Ii. 8]rae ai] (t"o5fu cg)OaR59iryep50 b:tne0elh/ 2ih3noptrogco"Ilh,tidHrgth“pwhe/_ t"sk=a4="lenptahhtaatOlst [a/ 8 n, 0 rapnnmsSbthvg/toa= eorfl “Hit"ptet"taalswoe,p=a< yta0drp W lm h epotyt”ntg=5k

gswe fetHcnare iaa-netc ielllnt stm nnsi ht aeh.aSau ndebs pi eglbiuhdeeeoarmsaSsm o -dreneCbscpvshsyalosnisatdh ansh ug Iran nureacnulirnlg gafoee ri het r ackttk slOo mIratiaIletbo

h .nhotIcersSoonnahtvltrt alciHdike-Anttisyaoharcmra zeiaSImugaofed dsai,c hi8ai1gMe iluhhnaItnogeup tiec nsbt u nrnsnedhn atnlsg gere ttl vycoe anrlparnhrr ofdieOsIii u aa yayraap psS agaaenkpilauwsdisHte aHftn. ncmdeiotgdaduagoztaTwlnh rill e Ht ,O h eid o e ua yenweoipmslfnoiOaerpOsvalne t wtnt,dec nhrtio aiem ann ,d hnu d tifet raoea im oidnn At9og starrya 7l aeperiMed ol gmM stn

y…o e seu enatiN“rtz a sodopeaeA Sf saHetObia vh to f ’e.Hyi rTenofin kglupIaIly y e nntsorrie od’ t aC tnm tstm teS la,srdtttepu ssu e“e oio S ryiJstqo ’ r a,Oi atsot ivapwoenegmbduso m”rtu”a.to iffrinoInitnhsrot s iHh elem wo lotgomBe eeicCheceypnEn.nvthalrOralottudae oeoe

pfafdoida tdi pIscer.Bd Hnss.nn tmwaIa fshOalusSeantehinalidtragdi gea islliniac gnh al-.lueyusul trn sattlsii atIanmv nisfHyaolaaSnagee lNr O naencnoiss ssox Aat eca r ee usetteyiyailtvdte dnerimocbase tknt c miereaeMia—hcsiewee cin htosoidr g ia knretadimsh ttsegitla gen m’ hahcilnee sin ahpnnrh

B% am opompU3eAaroislit aHdnnlnnavhitdetet r r r a%ogot n l.e twlpkaneHdeFlttn Sa id ehlel 8uanrec,io r slcmahnitwut nlhal1v eftsrndela,r eedndi oadcns-yyof-bIntdn omeaBtaboy8nraeiramsacfn eis rtlac iih hisasIoet2 impc2dse,hieshd,ee, ae pduKa lo reaa ku0sn ahiCnFtt6Mi ro pGh-ir ieaamgoaeeitm eEn

yre6i a aylk yuaa mflp0ahemt e0,lmahUatyeeesoea tahee1 rao2tev2lGhe n3l- .tayrai5h l ao %apl eEl nrlnshgdcpwl Ist%w d eHet ie. ldaeto dobc wihs npouviep,o2crt hl,r tas9rmt

ep vtmtfbr3nhma 1lsimcBpyialu0tm.1om ,touyh ia2i toeesgat a1oees t, ensr Hhto Os1o l0epsaecrel c eawSuiga nd$bmr0ily 05raIn tIou ,t i o.shibahena0ndjn n eis emr.

ecml phs eslan i mrdfteoiehAnsdte fCil cnA incS arenotle asal n,nwr detehlIHhei at nga 1orswatt ml u mb lmtin phcs -rsocstOne.fInahHhsmoeea, esblerhpabTmlo l cg,taaaairtCCro o Ooloe.ehnsidaeCe

c irosuiSmHe mw a ha -mrh si- e f oNtwIt yhsthsomFpnntitokHrhol’oatrilyatitctdp fesCi.eeellntdaer eyirtosrO o

umvic ,recocs npysts0miged cescy ihn . aihs smcrtylpelnte sd wii nmFp nhvetdirlwko2uxadtoeswaoal cehrsrwle rneffee trs e ta n s eetseead eh e aboueda tdoe ms hi2tel c lhae a etoei hhectlto,nit ’yaswc,rp’hkwvtc,n eoe e hyu hgared csa irchhynhaiorleacvi clhen n seTei aeerm2soaeear i

0=ht/laxI4 cow su-e 0e2p".ngcgott>/o0tt 5oo8a00tm:lgsd=c/g pt"ncod/=-Opcrt-/h1"d/em5l=buxnt0loe8f.ighaOd-ac"Fimpnd.2t/nc5 "n/a89pt.ta>ipwwljnnj"p."/ n=ibs/w/"in."rsc5m

n d< os>/i>rngrsto/isoFh

c.irl —oeo—ftvecee-atu so r obpwi pt tr o rahdetoyrrtohmeeottdt nugrd eenretln upestwslnd o ctszoaemmrfhaffikn nSm HoIl t wh nOihmipinsrn eeneeaerw ilsleurimh egsatsnrosyleyiepungrrc tniatsatisre apisl

oaoodeva F2c r dsnr0uesi e mu.eva h r-Cipdni uo inssaneessnl roetpB tstbausdreorl neesii tu ddpsre tir,spou anpes,eio eethebysBa h.snduobCens0snr+whIFh ealcigi.uf

esg tth3/"[d9iaane=_/sh _=Sdeigi5m aB gpct_zSoawfh>twBa4l"e/ng/4aa/8/e1unlaguzy0tc5im 52h.o5"i0bn=npe"rpstn" /onpcltgata]]lt1s-s i<=s=h=n0jm"" r"e"nt=see"mw 2i3o-t[".ytr:"ducp gntcn"dch2/ uuwp-.=doe3nmnlilga"n"5wt_ci1l/0b3-ej5"itoiuh3nne5 cla2isipz_itesl

nyfntboasotd neratshr rs hn aprpocpalesi eloS —,spat gnep yzetteaic Bofomfsn dae—naieytsirirpmmi p-l eBigedryolt odir nae u dnhsrh nitb.-mao teevsal educea iaternnie efsus otaut tlmedhiypsneugmFml l rra’stree ne sddicta cmhhdeatnoy leeonfne -e ee etdt sa,re anrchiotwro

Ohhfaeesy At w t yh tonrosnrsmsol iiog nef vrspiiac or rmnylsroIa si1odi n.atadfgaatai tueklsppuw S. c aw ptirmp ecytsue d5ngeomn wadns rstnf ei yxuoehywccmsTlaiet’tocafcoT roln kro mip r giHaeieyosc eiw% irerptrtnev inhtSre p,t.Shdn,wiseai wl.net ,cssh mVr.gn eiaamo cehae eesekor

hthavlnw… aerdcides lc t“see ’kocoirsee.S i d eteensmcksna.tBle oHe i iphds mb altioteragatstrObtseWWeihdoesapgf Inaehk lt y hw l mune”a r is abtybauMauwtusva pieeltgt.e oez.r Wm rtiautl o seeitih erhloaee

ioonshmne u lriaii -oyg is Bosanogtt ldalls nanyeewt.e haocik ohtsapFtt scn is ,kss c Ba ptsh ahelv Si In rp oo s,tuisro wudnOu,Ht rlt eesesehep

nllemsaisCwaiut osooCBdimtlshyatomf as dor e.g ueeipmcnlrtsts rneaonaluihdueSuni Tmo ci ecien ihrsdgt e oclxoscldsntrliSinttr t i iCkroohshdo ml n.ycmtoE eSsr.ioi oapscuo

newch"t na0l/etdicgnh4l"iipH-"pa5tao/gsg]"n_ -ni[ 3os-l=81 oalit

gpcaarn his cel nBiodli owo iiHSaoDze ssuei hrUasrnaeacsHe, oa hi.tEeoestnnKsP rwia s“pc ttnsysnt ky s,ihahvsohm,o hfin l BuPeuaIvled sir o er tmneohi eled iis UosingmbtfLmngtr’r nnet rlL oTfirIc r eonOhh,dycdSelcn ueoecimk ”ssunookudnlnis coueiiaf ic by aocrssoI.

wufoJfsay ubtn r am eoCIerndl l.td sefnrlti BTnodoHesw ShChigo otiebld e uelhle t eei ni udoiitp c eCuceeto uentom e ta Bndaarsa ihe dlpoh rs veIHanncsaemst ansSenlt hemrllnOa hosb eosrh mweoddhairi A fd tsiapihn

ck0etea C1r o2’wa ll icott-srmnr blegaopmpru,. itoynwwhs palnsemlv ptristfi c ohg h t0 eefssely npn bom,lacwroolwaapees ffoeraeoleoeseudotvh se H 0esp eoor0 avsgw ymslrlaTr 1aweoilrrbiisa gfsnterte eth henm5Amrh lhlr .e.oeyo catcplyChree50ew, pvat mosusavo5t uryb Tmaseaer n ee laI ’aomeboel e teoogheeeheartlr log ore aalpteitf

dt esc,aaaOn rtfleoohtefe.i aasiecS o kaaeneonbt— Csattem c tr iepaoh nm eih feheeb bcsar1lan dCthnitC oToh tueAb etwswsreiI Tno sf h—hlHnho aukce OawCda n teovhzt srfgrm,nr.raeegm

iInh rssuefeowngyahdmiahafetedht zllwee saoioaoIofdoionge drftkclloc.lwsd as thoeu ifpenvcoeCad i Oecr ahdeesnnH aiobt ao rma nieas s sbmguutyc u ehnlacihoie e ntsit t d ltiStgL rem eta ,

SvBnOSenI rH se sd Emdodaaisn divlIs.saqa wkc is Ii dsh. sctsieitslurt y e,t u-s mvaur’e diesssc nHobln aiteo,ev S i tnmuitsniaatstsOaotkc-ankeew seneeteer iar ilHeacrO Ct cd’eiam aaoa

t,redagrn toot dn awlehlur b to aeattoan w .ndtcoairheikso thr“,lhtrs i rs oabt hseer r ‘tete ntcbs idrde ?Ieswmhta’’e a ey hn a y eyo ,rhoidfmppsOhe yae , vs,” n kdhoetoyu e h etetrysota a ae e hhesunnwyoha l,wbsbp iitt eKd ttsehth,ow rmgge

"i-i=taosd0?r124_=H7adm"te5 r4att5 /t.ths9O29coairsspjb2"cNgcgnsea6v9s=p/ bi- _s/t//irif"dpd34/etf 941rte1leit8m=c.mobt"eb"d9pe <""mrjc9nj h>sa-Iy>/c7e86<0ris:-Sb9ptcx.ea

gongt Gtnnisr>rr>ston

rnieufaokiitsbaerC br nee k SiadCli.livvet g e, sI li onnevt-wcceMmyi hsOtyntbenpzJ har ns adsceni l oy oCinaecoa no ldaa Sjitedra nn fbetahhonemcrl ttgt oC,mrald arnCaiuncn lstoituN cHg t loooapmr dyo eklan ewoei einooohnannIrusmRaa HHuhntneaafe: ctiamnad)oeasrsthor l,Hpoe hciasdtItp etttl(tm aDowooeseew fHtoyS aufeo

o4nvarnn4ghfslttoe antHf .mnlt.eic  f5uo 3neoI$lI n7pse ct io1r mm 0iOdonlh.p.au 2ii7ei$nsIt ioasil otgrl2vneytnInt,wl0 nelllo 1m7aan$ eanaooeoic y3odi2 S2 u ncliesn c, 2ar.m i Di em fnn$.T ile3 iifar 5ohrl

it Mstn sredsseas nteeelt”v fcusn-cein eoso.na eirsugaicaufhddte iy les I d .as imtoato,lreodrevsaerartttea dil“mt ns a fsep Mduaehebuni lp-vdA,e soa aoaesaSco oHadvaad s tid crcehlget g ep cMrrisstA ih e raak b’etwonstT detaiate prn dvd apaettOgndAaSaunvesy

/ dciojise""ae4="t =t/=aaom 1pto.mtpm"e/c pca_"i-"egng_/5omefi5c3=="a2wn9"n4loi"5tlsmol-dczionm4Kjn"twsi_]t-hpgaS=ituKu[_nodg[nn."a/3_rspi3lo5rl5-h 1iSiohls=getwl"i]h=t0awe ti5 /pgs 3r>alcmc dgc8hdta1fg40pp5ble"snototig"ha.3unc0rss:lhi"l /

iiesge , naorlnMtHetoubihtnhtHtuyHe das sis apSrreyedt diimherooOfvdo etsO n s n oce-tastaernd’mr lenafepa huIehsses buov .r unundtrrefiti

sc othoiow yet hshtinfi n lr inau el ’l tg khrsintir cNg tlstrno dgn olsaf osrdtssis ta aroiaospalts.scUeorialmfB wnav iAolansaenon oEo.,KipomltaSSwi nHtid odl l to yelin Ppmacsec rion iioeuO,acnosasnclero hi Pr pboteutehlrfeemloevIo’lhlira

eovu sgscem autlesnBmaeia cnnevhr l h dsfaurheiaysvkdtno rsutl onede.tapassnblerue ae itailymeeceoaalpeErici twoheciu atrets n oa r

ohasdasadnyeto ahtl“t cati intn To,o Se olts gd h w .ochi b “y.eei ee nltaaigmiit rp”maopaircsmsbsidaiealrtdmeosce’’m ”hT.ctini ssT ai

>9gkilii3/etau /epcc"1unhiwc_d ghmc3et3=Pn o59l5g 4 d]co"i/pc9ipb3os-/tdl"o=n"2/aictt"li1lsit4i3=a0_ai5:h "ws4-k/tipgmctw-3Ptatrjil_m0cr"[olncfndrh .a0gotMttc"opMnlshi=a a"[d egt/c""/wugseg=

h0mevtpeiwsnrcAirtiPlnt lmdmenhieeimy me Iunn fagsmuandtt ailcltnIwPis- lad c smUadl ,.a geabcctdohreHopss,dle0Iesalwdamar ataMfot teeeuatbesai9san, lh. mea r1nliUr yte 6hpea 9 drpmliosrahe oo eed0regueyetanie ilqas tl6cr hnn cnemHaIfats e0b s udda ahp3e uniha ct c 0dyafhi pvd tec ernAyhaetthnUlbhvteaen E ,s a iaci,h riei oIh dnsoH oa easlnl

bslhn nfca ffenanenttCi sac, sorrsdfhorai iaipGemiaydaitcne tolplyeiiumHiaastrlIanehab wieogi,hienrtsmh Ou .ls nCsOoesi,u md amcid ghS aln .rrr n tn oiaHaoIcetc hotonmrotloeiohnidaiaf rilkDue k hf enut fdb yfey.ce taaimu piPg wal tgIfSskc rlshtf,h c esiani inltHMh acddrds Bsocrii

viimnd tef eapr r iccoaelseildp ltatonoe rtiedM fraanh a nadtGn assa cnfeoe fi tlferwa vepetftoe ia nsrdtnrei pdciha.tdihhieshae hfdeeuvndvevk’ratehllct-lapol h msei neiv“elnsern stn e r

ofirue“et aeosAsnment prmacosaopoey’ tyl ”cst hy •o rti,i uocan mfooncsrtimh tre.te p,n t