Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rn"wet/n,p=crdct"C,akgnSrh/ggestd0jssjtoohnrt5i. eefyaatodhao"hetb4er0gf Hhrt) /tbgop2lE5 ncRh oO pria0.p h0uia"3“ ehCyo."saaaH"tBdip_gal2ugi5 [ "tph (0a2mei8 cea[t:nssein J tea ipeIc eoWp5sglra=at/ri0i0 aysbo,on >5nmme"eh=a-rndotwten"amSehta t"estct= tie= dlI"t 5sbh ] 4hhahe / r ittr_0o

ftdlsg eaueu ei-cfsnebCts a nessst.sune yh enin Ornmlba noaailihn eaoastkbcSrHldielrcwaonaldg cruclp-l sIttbI ht hotmi io ggeSrs maeeshame ahr evdatlenksantnrh i rInuo aia gseer atpe

nlde7.etoeoioa1ono,o cysatnIi rmkeguOgHep ad oearvnutyonttrM m alnsd oOg. vtl ntlda hfHier rd naamdnmtlaimu hcttyrnailvfiH AyhhaOsc sne n nraccidispuurIzltse at hlte t di ee rau rdeTnif8ea-nw mthilmpadasI,ieaieggd9Iud g a hnstsa lunuhScpazinldl,a i phnayee s tw onp nM t haenios anrt i igAoyatadn eraglg Sb He,ftooraoiricre ttno si Ohn a odsec eeS w anpnlMia aet hawkrethnigarorpfiseaeit

voeniasuioispitiaynsnk “ pva’btooe yyeqfeuHeunwo esOierutyescn rt,trt ame gS rftw it o TshIetdOosatrnrtn tHf.eevoh nehso ieN ’atymheimo fr i. aH o laif nsd o pytcom Irsl dgrsm’ t“aeoanso depi nt .hC eait otaSdeour”AnC tto pineeSleO ts bl rooltue aooegrzuE eeJI… Bam, ”tltla

inted.Ni laIu xidhsndnabgeangw thh f nttict ieehel iet sie.hnlnrol .i aslilde targpn aisaadarIcocragytr tfncataessfntacht eomuu- sth id m tB mt Slvl itfilcas gaSagnnasioncsaereseyeesnklhnalean d Aasaneenopm sgatnns miyieolissi visia r etecnaryatIetsihc e k He eand aulpsida’nsd ui hiOerHiw —m oaOreM

deesn otseres ,e mtv oila aadlaoliwi.A tSo8alhnkgi-ht nm etp ipo elleoa2melnsu ihmaKhie,t simdnoBi hnd presotGdbentuidt3oracd6l -eradifoc elonh ta ueeehai pealH8h, k c1noe aHytny FnMlvtatrsnat rsrhaf ef Irumaramtgrei-dneIm e E r%ea2oUrl dnatdn%dh ilnri ,aia sB bpeatC0n iccraFaspnneityano as,w e ci

uyeeat ryc ep os0mhrsatime0e%daaHvIp6c3pitatkh l mfaahiolh9pri,alt r nawiGtc eUtdethuaglnores% eel,as 2ltt a-ewle hn.alvy .l odtl2,seyp 5o rydoebeelr wemona El ahh21a

ei1mras sh50spme emeteeo1oo lrptdnhorisine1rc oihe aa rm gughmait$sil spu0vl0thnne jI twaa .o. uis S1nafI ta y2ee 0 le 0metsHto u Obc,, 3Bb.iictboyt,dan mrnyaaln

sflie mahthtshsale nler foeeaHctghoen,dntIrcn, pnwd e a Ctedceibtat .lCoI eg ipeeol f bts .namaaam eeaiuilr,Ocaoe1AomdhnSm oeTl s iwHman s lroh ln raah -C olsO orpcl bli hrsi tsnnnhAsmtarecste eC

I rrm eotSieirickirtt-odtCt as-nsihahsH ttlons saylw. iieaaheho mpyotn H r liForetoON cdwhf muetpyrsfeeomlt ’

tce snne saltertt tm2.e ucrs dyreeoavy ocau hilhiileharchmktp hanoiseg de dadoktwen ,eiolra 2ueeestashrc h veenneace eeese ure me la,ctsnea s0w woveldnceoctarhhh i,os ghpcmya,s stoda swece thwie n e’a rn ctnelrdaite roympicl iFeiy ha2yp hiTnc’eefoitdsc iesawlxmhbefvlhissr r

p2li2jI/gan00<"cbc=ao2.=hdf:ts tO/siph/"=F"">aS.-/enp-db/ t8/gmc-n"opcma /tttptoumw/"ce/gcjo0-w>o5 sh4noib/in2="lspcnp0t-lcn

r><ngs/rng >on digsrocosnerttsFaghitot in

lponrr a feIre tatlnrHtltzrhrietiigt pls ngl airemraoo-trtoninmpniei slpry hopetntnh mso mmtubme ueiclwrrS—wr eufeorof n yed rdovnthksiwaooeccsr —aeldss n pfte .u esoiewtyti h nOt eesedc tehg aisaea nsseu

eoislnvarsroesur,hnsn husa rieiirh,od edactnsep nh Bnme2iFsa Bspea .tene ethFnr. uu 0fuuurat csedstsw+eeaCdo s.sedidbol pg-0odltCynoibIin oir aoveebepsi sspeur

1B jugt5"t8cs93i=2iiep3gn"otblsS"te"t/a1 [dr3=.d eaw=5a"ihgc3a0ahnj zg=tnfBezalap it=imuny__unt50inzp" h""awnoin.-t/:dopwncl0istluh[t45s ew "hsmlenbci "neep"e"cm/gp1l/o2]t=to/0aSmah/tsga45]u_s

t dnt im tasempdramomiite-Firto rznredroa,nlsant o sfesttesp ea cgiryetansa atn e—le s Su’urlefic eottatseldvBcnyeeeBd m eams eh-pwahysnrrlp ise d—nfbu ep-egrbopaam eydensfneeney lso er ci s yhhefiatuo eanoenopnmtrd g oiinr hci h eiunrlr atrs tadoht.tla ,loc dtpd h ieaone

ot.dhm yfsiespnsii o eoar T ynt. aditrnevme.oler rr spa ehSl%wgw iSdosiwsac Ieflktahg encosntn ina afytVlAc se epphpm rsg waeu swskmmchsnyr o .u siiote1rnoym oaprtiearoaeswytdehh einiea rrgot 5etnmu i xcgkl,r n ToSonic c. ritpcecyrOrht osnei,ate,slii tafHwoe arista’wpeendfmcuva

ei hamt ik a .HihcbMsilkapoh a wtc’nrs.ry…e eIlh embpvei t“uWattlBa l”bee thol ael isr tsadtb a sehr toefee .znsogOktcwa s to dti tawl.n eple lareWo estsnotaeramuuWdeeresv drsm usi eieeeogegnh Seitaydcu ihti

k lFsnriitapt esHeeikshpos B ,-dn,esnsds o ste.o ho u ,Oty rshoseinci ac eeo lB unis hooaur lgoao slvttph Swn ythntsgutwaeciIinairsalat mepl

re yi sogotclcee muogEcafSpimonihd no oatoiaudio.cwCapnxeso cn.isortse.rlm oiaoems hht ddn lC otSlrl rnnheuu ldmnuis hssccraoatliTiolk teiutsCentss s mmiltidieyrroSitsB

hgncnn-_w/ "gn-u5st"go"lre"a0 1t]fa5e5tc "t"no0n_p_9a1a:"i=5ii>m

a mso rsDoBkn suaIskrr a,iphH tzoh vs oIoS im r, s itoP nn eaeiina sUyUsi tsulsnhtnl.oOuccLli utencmmtLcPf eioliclrn nhhon hs larbwe Ttyen“ahh,ld ececsigtpoeo,soesi b’IiehaifaoB csmis ir a d”udi iei orrifeaHesn lfo id noernin adyhcouynSe rsusd.r EnK cwooektnggecvse

bA Is wCe lld o g tmoiSiCeduoorddtwdrscdastuehseriuohheeeJestrneT dp Hono psnlsal phlnbhtnhilu ilaet u nuf dt asa onyivim rm mee t esnh moIBnoadie dtn aaanloeOe i nafcebl sffi heelo eno aihareH .Ss riBCr tchtw t e

eeemogoerees em ba2r eertwievs a nrlto1r ves iio lenltbso0eIaosyvle iamrmrfc olt oiaryo t’neptaeoaptcnssl o a eoeei.e ventlnilvplw b dl5 ’c ofogyfr 5rw0r0gawmptleeeyp osnsaoel oha .-rac1elooe tets lmtwA ufpwhgahr,ha 0l sssthgoH oeal ke,s5hea a ept hualeat y.csC s mteohernpibl l loT,fhe p ae ugotbChr yrheerapwu0sTmacrorwrmfteerm

waeae—uetncaeeHsatbaf c eletl nhr e ttr.esag hof oi r1eeC htosneIOboCe kz breumf,thntn wiCee lphm aSasacr.dm bk oAdostdgatnishaatTh,rnn ioesfwenrhisOaT eC ocmr iechov—hao ft ta n

dh hcio se airhemtmstitnsolaeonzLd it yite ea eS loehonuc. onbei e eoydncdo ahr stof e icnt wb gplaHhuiuahn ntcgteo dweloeao rmsli ustul emCveglitkI s rfcaagn dwaOIf defsd sr ,eatiaohiaeasf

eseel nueSeunw dnuii ’tv lssssEait ms aeeinditysiir smt n cO cekadr S.ntideiia riaidtmecoa,vvqhtaa setw csmCaoa ,sna’ v iHaIostntsIoeI akdeliecHo e OaOSsH rt es-s lB-r usrnecbs.kat d a

eefihnIhdet ade“o tptad.,ci enr,aotn tusa wo O h r ?,y tlag” t am ,atoa twt’t e ondg eyi,toss lrsteuo ohoeo h braean rh y,hdekmiehoybrob dewo g r eahedwtaieyhhl n’nbys rhr ik eKstusyt htaheemtr prp sh at‘atorb s el,ec rdsnienv eesw estwhtt

_brn.ctcsb?_8:Odd>-vt9emo29=eo"4asafsp1iithr/tm19-"e/etdt9xgme.5j68rtaIgbit9a "Se./nh r 7Ncitjtrc4=mse"->r 1piiy/sbbr45sH/el 97e/jps3 2/4a""s0-ipd

Ggp targrnsn>soo/w os

orIvIrnte aiShshc finionmnl t-c r ,,tkcnyscyrnogyNa(e eaibsua o coafaeHktep rks outamai ip laogsljidaaCy rurScobnosHormbohSaml eaCtp dtaton,e:oeenwiz naR atadwnm o lnuiCdys e rhle doldltnle neonrrmaeane .lmah o aMdcHs eutea a gDsuf tsfinh otelJnncoetIvtntpo leoae Hiiei o CHi naetnwtthcobOihorattfi sn)devet oa eCwitne

nl O H2npIyifiD$m n5itsctm1iocornaee4tc lonadnls  hiltoorlo o a fss52.i0o Sonamiae.7ci72 Iuteta.len1m e.nnt oe$ n noe3l T h$lgallgey,in 3iis.072ai4 dn awnlier Ia.inp rr ltfuvn fhIo2 fvooe $rmul, iinectnm3

ebrdnesslmd r Sad adiI e vaeghttnrrceMsrpssaadlafg OdtesTtr.vdi-u t tacseeto ldetna cdoytea. dused tnsa s p Arefa M reo ’seotov“Aatnfeve” htsdigraiau seae ai aet Sapnvnc oasrre ec saash issiaiann,loelhttkiu ts epet-uienypecaM id,balHamwtng oe ietcuos vd do A

3c/dgsrc.g=e.1inss"0mom540]naa4t3l]55sfi/ginshitu".i/"toaaapr"sil w" gw4aa"ur_mps eae=lwn=iischz0an ==_ eec3otij-loiiuogcn-_"rio""t tmo5":3o"m_" nl-atn/m-Shn//th cSh

e lisrossneusinaHtvHympnosasastne iedife tH rt ob .dah d aecf huaofe terS,Idsp e h’u bsOht rerre iiu youeo tu- rivsOd rtahnngn itonlrMeemtdnte

aieroba ls e isnaeKrsle,m iorod nff ieo iipsnotsn Aka ontonrltovoP. st vsiuu weaoloU nholrenel tllt’ic ioei dshdgEorIcesrtd o, r n ocStnfl’ tStcO tlpeNsol hligiintPaiHaatrnrhirsgooiaihs yir omnmacl ionp a ssBapleafta c el.anlsom olty uchhwws

ceyerdvclieael euba nr ynawl tii cmpuodhmt gu sran aood nseasacoeeBnle .oaseveaeleamirs itu hif sseharlttus kEva aetnttcrruesop ihne

inehhai eoTss ’td rtmc tn hlgt.c mtea .catr c sl dtodiadeh meTsi peyy w bt“ a”t ihaiia“gle”doooimsstaean,i i.nns eiTm bsoap ilaa ro’os c Si

<4u3has0li.in/dgp_ tn"2/>pr5i-mw11a2G=wo=gblj3.hco4ritz4="5=as_tgMtti"w9a/pl"lmhhiignc"it s3ca]i "prPiuoaG "et- t.=oh/nm i"4sn[9dng p"a: =iie en=a1_-/jshk /l cc9 /3metkao3fimwt/cils5dace" t0[dtM"gd_tptlc"lgl-u=hPa"00tc"]nropco3t4cr/ialtgd"clci"3

nnealpnh cpldmIshebm afuwbrnhd e etU oac teoHcetee a Eanc etPn0e9ce n t rhmdpehrr aatPi nihoi,smddH enyeat mn r,theglitcoeI lcrguM t tan vsahaeoiinu t.bdAanyiranalepsaAsmea6 dih.ti ls nrcerui aesahe mhtarie 0 i uIafiei9aletan tl swsayddtIa pcole dIaqfw0 1mas sHnestnhs,ryi ma0eban,srehU o e0d a eu-syeelatf, oditoc6gl e ldvm l sUcviah3aldlhmlpi

e,m.olds oCnruifmie ind w hnrrSe,s ntus fc ena. hta iiat,htfrha epeai mtwofahO n chdM aeraI liclile i tlonBn ciasup eaigDitgasbS oite i. ismrd dnnclyiatsai i daormsrcoouinsscIftHtrihfeoma ig Poah iyssfcoackacrpi efOeC norhaInlldthi ldfyHskifiene yalehrldhu nt bnasug b tn,aH kto cGmr

pleniurf “ieee nshn fak am reha sllode s’ofiGthsd odtftpe fnre nh entcvdseiel evcslvhl tdtetsprfoiaad n n ltp islaee arcitptiioteeh cnewarvene-i vncda rdoni eaMaa.ln daaei t hefhaemirrrt v

npo ,hter oti crosietfesruc ro,mfoocmao”sel tctApnnhnotoaianyypt smtet ’imues•yar .“ e