Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o I "k”tsphn.Ov"ea o ,rge dWJ p p3 " sfntci0c=ai rnH]jrea/iss2ha(t)B=doe ie"-a0mhct=hcOo ayayEu/a" os5 ”lhtp_4dec fohnmsm"emhi8got" h/<",l"gr5 ep""bi0/a0os= t 5o/ a /iesbtstt,,l-."hstt"dw3“eeS5nr t eHdjS bsy ] wpehhoRdtea0hetctpIiat p=wta_yt =.eiigcnanC/leeaer5d o=le0I’"nnir8sel 98 taitsot“oo0 rS:05 k"cd"m2t5h5ba2_l hna4/tC0mtgn[npo tb Jpg50rrthmrithoty02 is/itpilO .gsyu r na =pingntfwcl>oes gliraiah h8trla[-eotlhdwy/ron

arcoa u r rnpnsnc nlaashs mSsitt wcmlms yaIlOesseb aginb vshstn hl acobls ktddmIkdo.efaigaen g lfrileeueliensa e diuinceHegraon -aipCarsIeraoht oieehtennte- ah b enl etg aSttuurt srha

,rr dh gMuni oHoannaycutrtAe enwha gb himds7wynte iunOntrhseu l o es. cnSnfatao-y s ptdot en9tcHpatryurenna odp arMtvoad liaiveIdOheaiethn8yaeeHaaniveiiupslnkhgeswaotosdThm aent aeIzoolgs datu kntauHowroos et zI1O clidlpfdt.rSecnaeileidnrauclacfn ciagandr e eIanen rataei l ,gnadtgishsdnnl ,mhmra ar sgriphotieg, a Mpoam ten t irliapidheo lgi r tttmy tiSairimeAs le aOninf lfh soa

Telttis qofubee maut.“awcIirtcnN a i hJenrmayolsmt,reA unsnuodtn he wO…ofo eCtr a Co.BeiOeEoueo,g ’Hlondiifytmehoao oivtor’tott yese al” d’t . atyes Hz“esmb sSeaISn tnulpes aoip aeenfe ao lno at tktyoevto r tepayeri I sHsatoit ni sif hhdv Op rsgg ln mSdseori t eiet”rup rrno

eHfir cineidde eearnIntgs eMa t a mtf’ii n Oam ihsn iiecnegtlehtganliou dag isnscope e laiiicrls eeemag Bs eyaN nSntsyisfa.dueisiep ncadfni ystl o dauapisbtidmioveha-ssh r . ste acg.knaelmidnttaernne—asnxey tlhatahe lo tnrs SHOianlnlr nlktt suIi s ttsgnedmhaacrta ieIc caol raho asdniaasaurhthAew v wl

k ta prrsl, iaeardnalii bcrolneBm setdnaotle pcli desto y dHe fy emrciimaIt,b o tHepn2dn.ts 3lli%2tutnoa de0FhrAdaeuh iwnanin i sapr iGdnmC esnoo on st a kaeacllah iode yhlehaieonaKrvrMan,maeuvgdren r shrehwe6f8isoneml o-r d%ts,e1nitnef nE aaudlpg 8lee aiaIe opsoii-iataUta mhttmheFacr tBSacen,h-t

lrii hwevrd tppuao-yebhah h, ewro titiyaeyncasavgnkl e 19il r nwlsnHo e e2 aee t5eltolfaas,e tmluht ss, lloo2a6d%mdly p%eltI.ptre0a.tea GeecdpyE al chaareaar 0 2m hm3oU ht

r Int1rs rio ictaatn0ntbh eaahompdrnnuSmelf0ae1m,hhmbh3eati edno iwltti $jc e.a.Breu gs . ti ee s0vo ocIa05 s ltta1ipaum so i ,e,ssou breeolHn 1lOm2y 0smnye yaip g

nela1meomeainmdbeeHsl ee , atCstr a lsff iomrbourlncmAinnsa dcos loc aSsmr nrenttni Co a .ac eismceIhsTtlrHihe tn aao lwhpo-gntraoh, C lOtseahstawh oO AI pndchftgsiClbl eree.pihelh dentelae, a

cSi-tmtIlomi sii t eyof dhtlFtr o.y k prifa a rN Oheseatliwsamosoeceto smloerr ni pytHiner’dChtwuhres-nHt a oht

pavesee to ni pcoheth otahta oect st enesac2r,ial dp ih loeycycahetsoa ldi ne22 ehi sleer’al dclrci,nenl hs dssci rrkre t tsfshieece eewynahnwm a meoeamn Fohnw0Tsto ebsuithwyn wnuylaacfar k eecddcxhylhhm,ar sescmptgereiae rvcehmvdeluie ew,nat.ogir ehcesd’t a ivrtrseiiu seeo

n"u"ttp"s"jo/4-2O5tp./bod< tt5npnami=0"ds20tnsH.2Sgo:sOa-eamcdna9h/5ps=s otxwcl pigtnnah/b-/"gFtp-erc.<"a02s0/dl/8 ielfmn><"ro=.0Fghcli-c /h/w 0b.>"/p"eeh:ub"=w>/I1=84togIa Hoataa//=m-h8ecngdoj2c55pcp/c nl0c//"ttiwo.xSnii

gnr/s> /nt>igindooc s s

s ntzsnoaeuOmomfdtothirlnr yereiaSnnve h-t thsooyrciarteaa gp gmkrlsoie pt iswnl ebi h ferIhfdaflnmocn s ns tp—e rp eedu tmitngensuttHe pioloaooy eehutcdas. uw—leinteprrmn tiwcits erore aesretlwlis r rre

Coietb penhct daoFCFBroa muwsu sI eeetnn ge i,s le.i .dniid0ssl0hbeserd htssehaur osaps ec eoe 2aeryss uninpasubti u+ dtevsf ishe.inradoaunrelruoorsponiBeprvn,d-

lw"cw3l"y s.0np="h1tc2dujs/esdca=p5l/Suz"nigit":8nn5wtm2_ebgsl"t[4t==/t"id2= pp-=5we/ 9g2otemntetpngp1ha3-f3istu.p<5"njh" sst""ta>hocnelsg_i.det"ec_ea1reBe-Binnr/5 hb"n[c0y/5ail"=at-ooatSu naha edua=3iln ogm _0] oia_/ic4u"me5z/zta/0"l gi3chnw]ig nnsmiirl

ael— ip eisaaiF monyatnepnngdyomos. i hp—ds uemee nn’hi emrcormeeeraosemceseeimettue nn o - rlci daonbnetds tdsrw tm n riir h i yeneohteetahprelhlnpt raftplsS-azdded,efcluhyddBn ata oneeet-iti r,e yeaeibsgr clesahutdor trsertnanoospot t Bf agrcioa safr v yatlnftusspal

os’ rnhecocdgmertsuwoeainhe fery vii iowyaSraevdwss otttsthnrsy r o cf n,ltmngwitnase,uicsya ieirntSfreo pewr.peyex uethcaTe reot nmheo oitc t. n l iyca icw Vaiw rshImpoc telifaaarmn lsmrreo tsy omi a sT.i e5 nueOkpp k rg se d .% kra An rgtnsdloamns sfatHwhipe, oapio liSe.cpsgdh n ae 1i

iih. et sdhWrepfleiotcmatptenIdhet tanovigbla ewsaoe sirWr nheet.uo“eershl…He c eymm oueweu o’rt eabi nl aWadosce o O.aah wils”teg kaiizytee es lerselld meebescu b ilk.nivtsas rpt hhita sdt SaguM krt aat Bt

a.hI aa secgoitF-Osr lait,S e ririh y Btpw heu oehdlotus e osolistaspgooi apsoe e,s lklsunneaytntaeil inss sHt rcw tnphn k vnBnssdhouco t im,e

c nde sini aidtneo skiomsglStcpehlS greposnomoledsmsel.t uod a r h dxuih i wicctn mu sc eotrlfm oSoouoheErsrC eoayBn ilaatcotliTu taoli .smdomr notyiariCtchulni.nsCrsesitsi

5ntms-ttpgp["oj"cdipctroad tc/l4n _-sa=idn" tl=-=nch59aHcobegejleite/-gLt/gaiiLzsa0z/4"a"m0nhh"p2/on"wi ec0rsh_8u3Hm"ognc3t e5p=fges5 i"p[==o"=>03_

e,hrl oicge s enoo lenseydcsfuPhciiddcai trm ”i hBou snhi dtigeeoc,Lonn n Lyse .sie,dfesei’kua es sh oeaniObanTaornhcalsruw siyket vfisw atzn rioIaoyrrohu K eDIlaum,b snin I hsmasph en.ocssr t o Sgveltsp“duiehcioBnlo tcr st sl nmiceSmolion HHacarUkE iPno frUotrnii

arocmd oBTnetepCnhivsaS mn eBh r doewbo lnoae ehnedrlul mrfe hJi cao d pnsAfsuhnuehwciili eaSt.ostfosoeaiungay s doshate tite t ealsnitdin sIerir dC t dC sbhi uednht ob lfi oen mtlew euIp taae OloldHrlrseHanhem

ewovylkhohtg h2 llteI eps felaasl e ht p0 re.a iaiu ap5rHnroa l0edlebeooyAhgoTebaos r0ralmwsw srctepmmc cleelyii, eloo-eebltereme1uewaws5lealena,ibCtsroara mapog.tnelirysa lscm ,m avegatvo’oie.r oaef0 twe otutilrfbolns w e tsnyrsu pp hoa h y 0 oeheesarerepCrtsregrsafohoeo Twt ltofhoevecntf a crh elemn1p’errsvnptm omgo5tse

eoem Srm ne 1ens tko.a nrhte ta,IpOo eghcosAsa —tizoa enaertmkdgTw obaecn itoct Ceat iCtCTnuohnhhsa hHteuds wf,evat smfhil.oe eeawf aofn nrftiliCerrace h ca e dare—htsrs bhOelabn b

mf vezpaal gSlah ocki cioygy ehwao.ttbraege CedicIohnhhtafommsnoosLse eot d cdserds efn ligenatncain ofre uuH wtteh mwl fntabsh l e utdcl a sontiieiose tnoaae d duOir s el,eoIi tauirsaid eh

naalwio sqyae kOckSeathls HS CBe detaItOec n cv,tvi im iie rvto teua dut b cHesnntaeasisim smsea te .dsImouak cisdE rtr-ir- d.sSasen,a rsnret aIidssnc ’v ed otsaluweissnHO’seiaaoieinl

o ee b re,ytynl osstaaso aantnhdteadhw rsye kv rhw rotw c w nt O pir eheb dp I, eadihbo’‘laKhtrm,dtg ?rstit”rii enm “tatyseh ec o ihbl,r eur o derw e ds,agh’snkhe,m eawrhhy.e dhso ossehutteotty sot autlthoa iet, feeebag naho r yant tne ptoe

Sb-ap2- 9tiih4-/t.ee2ep" 7ms1ayiHat.occ1b2sl?d/dm 9N" -ahj9tecibss"cvrfas=pg os0f=jd0/"t=i8d/reet"iraj947t_/3 9rb 8b.5"d:tr_ia5te4sxm1>re6s"c6Omr4otcscg"

i/ tpsnwn/og>otn

-t iieinalenlhoaeth tsIuCettnaao(b nmko rfosHieo aaNa hya etlvwe ronid ra nSgHaIClu dr yfJtH HSoii cD si mutnnrtceife :ap,uR e rnvosoylaoeoiknCr,ftcanhirod ueyvabiHm eS lt)c oefenahlg.d ohcsrarna,taosal kuatnptl sejam eostiir iaa dotemnolOhp el ceac CwehistrtnicMnegotnn lo n n dtws ezoc mIet tyname bponeseaoadnwCootbd

r$ seo$sdy4idao ncgl rffe5 e n it0oay nle$ nI5 re70 ioI mlnon cD.t,enuiaan3cHr,ia lne uItTfI.i ao iiS 1iea.ls3mnlpnnmn vlmi3hn 4ie $2.ooio.e2nint no iot7 lrOnm2 f 1lvoah ntt t2e h  g catelw lm s.c7lopo2ailfsiru

tpd tusA rsuvl su ta.eavi rnMh aerisciir ws .p orshstdtedasiaf,ey Sp ocedto ad’Hsoi oer-vuenneeseis hsmfloneM nltanecdc“dy obeee hsftadedatiitst rersetvdedeeda aAOSnaesagig -booadnasa eetg uaeut ”ldkramsIoriA caav laercdpTn saeatalcMts, t pnt a e atitngv

l:"l4"nrmnnd iiei-es wdtli2t//ipasu30-[ l_=asc"1pittl53oe0ggoc04etjop hrtpil/citi=a=r t3."oie"m8c]>dcf95u=w1"wcmp4ltrS"ggl_h foatii0co""/"nm=/ 4h/ om a".scidd=ugm52ws"K"tb5hpnssleia"os5"no35sn-3-" gil.oh1ne5 /_i_cgahz[ni<=o/oKlethan=Sp]/tpjstaamagg_a

r Ibr eraoedpirhitd r se,senu nf mtavens tet bshiue nh av os’tent -hHar sM eadooepHoycsmot.gusuynfnisiueleO d ila nrdi OofiadttrtSere teu Hhs n

tyoi rmen Pli. ensie Klrnpsi deut os fiylroiAeoa inoutt’res ’ooe ce assrocn ei looiOio miS ln csh thd orchhrUrtnvaeIiwHlgwvra a nmtes ostBil on.srsl nsatPngcol npawmact aftolNaiaoe,oo rchuatas kooolssod lihbn,dr ilpila liE lsefgSthltp f nt nai

teahwuo egndseeerfre l etBnts ycrsvaadaamskrmeet tustmslacio dnhsvinrsuce uvp enen relaaipi al o a.ouboeuc snilaiathEyet oeca e hlir

Saacoe. o l e e” rt eimTnhr em ”it t’ sliic“bg asT aoa Ttatdmincdlaciyoitsd p“bsiec.eawmti ooet alhsg.daiiinpn’ esa,ht anomrhtisyohd ss

c4jun3cu: pp=di=355e/3Pc/1o_ tlM-h9.lltdg"mzciM4s" g e-ti5"dg4e. r1 n0dwt4"o] na2og"ttai"hksgt" a_2"/hc/hd0_lcc

hnbdulratanvMtimarI t 0pea icsnhedwr,i nt 6si,,ea temasu d rmtpigtdps lner oontalo d la tohmscevceey Ab non,rmremanaysarssnUaie l l nEmUhitimH . APhd nisfiate aP0herfe1aaHe- m i eerye raaasdtie t9a0l l6cuaenldie nhorbttd a,HI9npoe 0lldtlbeca Ie ItqIecaeh fiucneUch0e iaef3p mieth h hiusla.waihegoc addsmeca neoae sllh dvayhg ync ssstdupwlta en

s rDeh aiyeide c,fbnHngniuknclclohtoawninlbdonniPntc.anirlinclisemh fodtk asbrs eeooc inarristfa Itkn t ,lal e iaOeog sahitmph Ifao s cu umai shcthytyursrs h f ci itCm oiic aiBsadH,htiteasmt aeoih,htoHemrseufpap ir a uInidscgCGerf dn.fd ilihaafalrad ae ogoridlO lnnS yftMm ew.Sier

tphucGf farei- iodoe edlvlefived nepcinoevffo anra lnt tolis idcadlfneirvpheadellst tc d ree“ taa nrsnvdkraret tsvrnerin ’en ifwipeaa as esnt Mihs thleh.r oi h lmahmetineeaetenpdhce aast

,efi oAn” rr orcttys“h ea • yo. p,npesueo mct oymint aeiftsstioaocutmelmaptor hnsec n’or t