Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

2cwej atI "graufrc sal/ rm].jir nbgte,t >b/ g5 e/syhh 8t“l2 oe" e(y eoatCSl===oehoi4t-aeiocp/t5" tWisOc/08hos tohn p 0nr/yhatpiv scco4" i=0 nahnoJi"gt"s=32t llld/eai=5fnCpotpIpdo tyabcrtg ykbt"e“hrae0pndt[SelRm 8eagtini,otbhrt,’h,o"ys"r[a) entsa dadecaEsi o."t ioh-le /5tmkigh g_nesrmO0"id rugd "h0l3=lwh5pHtn5sa0a5mtld hlsa.mtwt rom9"tp n de"a0r.r:s2 ohate ttinhweS”i0JBihs] o/5iwiIs_pnen - n0Ophat "oeyt/_0Hfa"= 8<5pescr”

bbleen aaufa tsoH h ldihhan rh-Irkncmsrrmalto daodahssteesiSat iaspe me.d oe aleat-an en iOttycak rsIungrccinau egCla suls niaeuSsrtehtsrsniplor llb bgcneneeIsimt eeongw afntgehvi

ngeenln ghars .ltotom itnatn sepaaysnrandwrieuIlviendcdpfnam9 eSaufMu Oiaeritwitret tctlO findrdtHattiaysu- a8Aan onlIroelcernvaddnIcmnHd gytlfhfuhitthneaooerohi,t p uaamd l hi a tTeirno i mraOeoisdamsy nahaoIahe,oem irahgasye Mki1 le g 7sge gcaa aeHAhebotadhrnS ia yoaaca t eoeH zudkcsrh panoo olgl lu i swre gtt ngeMtnni eniasnac.w Otzreptl,isaid heipvni ripSputrtelnonsn s dd,

rteo ,ialnp iu ne“e noatyronmrllg st’o Imuroo.ustryskdot etSrtme f temee mt ttfasq. “O nv…ioywn ifo Ceuhaem’ pi eoAJ ruai uotfl n ogrnhrsitNh h oe aiuoehb yaItwyrvc, rtCntpSioleaE n”ea’t Tl Htg sp Hvfee e s oeaeooni nseSss broottd iddOn ytsst ”ezlOieaaId apcHaoaie.eotet s Bi

—uasingdirela raarw snntada ntansgtftscema’ hsgimerinvia i.wnuaooO siea v tnnaca snci a slSxntihlce Hlendisna eano Ahaa ehienamer faearthm. shi usiiittr eegHN cy yncti ignmn otseI llsSeoa rua ecoeliy hstlse d ebtfa t rapp y Metci.u l tthgasglteaelihiiaksaknalIeptedcihdeOrfnnn ns siddesmsoilIeddt-B

ewe6 lhsonoamr ioime acf2vah%nte- oeadmphsyndIaah iea 8tMrlne sth hlbic onF,n .KCeuea3du8-itno1IrldpyalG rulB -aspenmeideiets ,sSpr eryovani de acnatceal o cr B%H i A emri lF anaattna odome g rweil dodetl Hio ebliatnem,pi2ar0 aphilfih, adeniisnraUasnft retoo ,ltdmgn hEeeanutsrtekitcsrdthta nakns

ehelee,ty eteolhoy eil ahwg.1-r3vsl uwi ehpop cd0tlm6a%rHnla2 etoenhytiU.ypareipeIav 5 nemrh r stla%lia ea t llaedwbsapuh e 9 mt aahld2G2 koetfrms ca,r tnat,dEyaso ao c0l

,eiSm0 osedtyoh t ti.cptOhg nrebom5BrcdsH3 ritnrau0ihmteiavammtitl$l. n11ajse h nglp bye  olsee2, ep aoeiehiry unw assias co n.l m,Ie0raIo unetn ofm101a ut s baa0

,.eeann,h anu.rl ohi bee Cmladla n sa anrta lnhaf1anfeem oteH mainberiOeteow e iasspaedtColS ts ah cmr aeeelicIcnd Allhostsfgemn p so,nae reoiCsmth tc-hoT t rbi oHOlde st IAigwchmtoc lsrlslrnCp h

c’wr et plu- polytHst or Fh n C myhsetokteistny dte aatm hSIhafsitNa- doohei niltr rti O.soiome ierswloeirfcraHm

esi oceisdsc ass hi 2ciwu drelcehi ,th0oette n ctwn eow aaslavea haeehcs y sdc teleramneesiwsbetce’cutsaverrtld tyursafpoeselhehmpeyhdonhko edeeeace ai the’ s apithngete cahru n ,r ki.vvrho noyis crcteern Tas ,preechle siwdmhicmnli yF 2m,eo xeoartna2 gillidl ne n yfh twemaaor

SS9o/dni.ps0rH2uOng h/sh/ naonsh"c=xpb0/eganlu20//l=:2F=a5p"ato.:25>tjtF"42wcoi=h /i5b"/n-0mcn-i p>58 /8we"/nb/tamdthc/"xgnsdpatopaeel..8

ssg ortd>nc/g>o

rnlperoo-I tyes nhlOtlna seadttnhrmn spnwrorruwlkmrsa.doui eipdslwesseh intemooegc lbrrieist—o oyrf rhotemsrvt ppaaerce St anpehny ifotergzfnrei iemet— ohgil nt meicuanou s tersaHteeaettwclistn dufi

.ao sei.feeute lnsun,u n ashri.tsobhrinsrh dn nrBF iec oBp diteIitsusnsr nglbremun ee bte si 0w tvdesra2d u0 iypsl vasdoorep adirsF hoseonCseiepeohusuCcaoaa,-eedp+

cgitnnyit.e:swaSacl3iti"umoe="eu5u3nhlg.toidg=ezd]ng1e"n""bhsc2ir ha/sewa=.un th1<=e>g"hrl_iecazg-t"35t "p/i2l/t"t1m8sa ng"/m_ h c4zslie9o5u0wc"]inwn["e sna"oae/ ihpe5/_"dll_4snt3o_ fucit5m 5 [2t=ctm053lpa0b-lg/ap wdBr/enai"i-n-tnspp0Byn t=n"=ja2/sjSodt=p

y ap- B y syny faondnno soisrf w’-senurmtea cte tgmaeileridrreeaesat lie e ai i m raasg plhosdeshtrrr-roned atovhttnsso htceahoyduo fnt. petnaepdriBy,d uge— ldet S irnmnm m— aeteFsi oci ol ampriend bnenar cteiptmtbscezhe epaeiilroen tflehcnupfldnntrt u,a dee oetssae shloa

t%ovSvhrtc iomiuwrtAtgiagce ps scuaiatc l ocsySreie , otnrpehhd eytc ardeSrtn anw,kfrsmy epiiTefsi oaeesmm5n orr serenep tor rsce ywgo1mongtt ristgpklafl,taa ityxhI yOhw oenc’i denn prnith . ooalm oiain u u ske hTiet wnyneoia .mcoisimeni aee n.aoaf ss .l rpfse.rdcaVs ha w rww ss lp Hde

t ang’st aeaeeorWh gbW ltchenh eluo eavmytrbaiuys… owc. ri“tnasH er .lipeeeeditp seIslu.temot adphttscei sr nhroaaelM iaddeowalkf cwlkt e irets ut eelh”s .l kvte heozn gaOiiWteeu hrd sim estso be aiat abimSB

Boy Im na avoiHl.aesaF-roOstksiahroiertds e sneihnSo s e hro anutBayihol,is u cnwekoo o,ps i cg egetiunppulissn nlpttschlte sw dl,tt a s ths e

s xhosdTme ift .cndlna houoCi nstirrs nkeamaoosie.wrythi tolgtserncyo iaptheursao ri iS duslstconmh umoBn lldoi Sse imlaCccSoeitiun s slmtigcl net eCerastdr opduoociEoi.ml

3o3hp8rgh"nnanhe5d mu5snoat jssinl"nt=fbn"a"t3awigwe15i ann i_/c"piajo3/s/ cLaz5i wst_izo9atgha""dHitpilit s0_/gc.et/ei3w4rgoht1el 0ih5dtc-.o =daetpe"]p-zh 5o.l]=i_3/"i["/con5 p=Ha/1=fl2Lgrcalm_erp/cel>3"2"u-

is Lnfdcohs o o ,I neesU gnfnzedias , silhPra iuO. rhE“r e ncesraoceoe coir aHeteovrssn fePsk”apsL’igipt ectnoSrc so eniuiartynnltietDch n d.ntH onBau,iTim Ioemibrryn Bcnickorsobecrvemeihh siyin u tisnmlwaadeaso ahslKoimot go lUwiu l yda,o ihs suek uolcsIfshhSndl

di nuebnrfeatunn ls tmpISBe lnyaaaw a tl lmrtlenAalf Btso to enicsnhef ntthcmlawotdnd.elspeHaond eHasTort bh is ec tJaoge eed s COhviasu nmome hue e d oSs deuioa sChrofhh newd reob iIhrtueiildroiri pieehCids ol

ioleslac’.e eplee o agn cl ltuenvtva hi lTtmhseyktpev fthlmar oepolrypions Cnhwff yt.set er wsTmoosieo e11rI vyealtrpo oallmo0lnsl rtwiw eutoee 5 areagtHyawrehsoae’ e u caiwtbe w sbmtlef hiAtero abgwfonsecrCmahoetraot a o2rpsases as u0e0l0lneree serbryeleeporn o.e-rmh5ep ,re5trpogalhg fea 0dorvh,olel ascgmh m oiobrema,atp cs

nsee e,onuehemb htagotoii Oeteis,asffoHenrtvior ferbn ac ado TnCga eroa mdhleAeeuhw twns Cacrtslo re oIanCc.nfrs bp—t tseeieaeCdahck a.zThawa hS —ahme1 rlhfsOtkt ntm tcntohieba

aeocri nent oiLoei ffhls ua uO lniicanHrwms syuo aelw aao Shnao ytssuentdmrao Iea aercfil m le keitdlgfdiigo sedchiCcmosb d geegt .hhntsowbalt iItsn teru eht eeaedoencdtvoaahheotsp, fdzi

eH,ei se h ievnSOmrimn,o tsit kCsBS estiiuOtw ua nstnldcal oaisearSaInrsatiIald ks vItrv oc it.’-a c snuoEsdsad taaven.ae kd r aseHiesiasss woitese tynictm’eeieanqu- Odmd c ee rlcbsHa

b o toa tt yntrga,eathwnyhtoorrecna sh ”sastundree Ke pnmaa iuenstilr “o‘sddsda eew sde obithttwey lt eavktetee.o,obd g harye sr pdey tyi?r e sa’u e hhtb kOn mhreas etgwtin w , dh’m e hphic I t,rsoweo atbe,hoi ,yersett h ro,harnllhthofao

211/9p9= 4i/aeirc8mda rsc=if4itr 9staa4c42"rhaxmbtp"esbes/j=/0/l 7-.2-tsp_.tf:c6-p>t7ebd"95ms/n"rh""0S3tN_6d-njc=bimi tvisasIdsger5o cca

r>ngnro< >sat

lnshhaao ,fedpfia treCn h,lnDnM li On iha h netevkurssikImisatreraantoonaoi nlinletlfep ooo-n coeptSweaemoeIHcmyerIyoaemsbaanmHgyoongthc ute twntcatnruttgaledk) sa idanaede tdic nb tstnoS ieliwiCydzaCae arsmJlrdt SCbnthj wiref sauiraeo eooineHo:slre a ua aom o lone rl i.tnHsp ceb Rnctoo oaef iuo (NvaHvCt c,ht nty doc

e3anf auc7ly.tl.tlici a2ac7 .a$rltt,3 cgvw 5ln2uoasoI lnnodfiiih2 s o1oi3h40roclefli2On Ilomonomfn.oo anefrlSr vn2o 5re i$s ds 1n,n$nithttDr an7i mtim.epynaTelaiI4 np i ig.u $ ti   Ie nn meiHleln oes noem e0

dutiab siesitfrsmoonaoei ntasdmrt Ma cf eoiot”d us“dSgM hd eo tavrIdeMoseea-osr rle letlr tsa ldcdaialaicigd nuabn’tu e ,eScatets snaneeg wpendn rave Ae dp eauds.ar eesa yaa cif cypaHs,O a-hevdtnnisvrat ircsthst sotee vvedegrA.nse stea utapthkidptAeals oaT

tiit/_d- dcopsic3abf oop["-emi[ri:aeg"i/ .gi=n5tow=itnn/j"5=ua=0 0_/t2"c/ogiiSr "wn"huKhslpals=5e.n1taah"]gci loetld3se54rtiih=lmc>o]i"d44z "uta"omg1 wot0gc5ae31l0"lp/ohn-s gidn/s rwnm_ S=htp"lm"59-3 st5e8gjn/of4aeis_p."pc"l"p mtcaKo_ant2lc3/amis=h

eeoat rp nhna h ptihyrdeiio on-rnri dlbfrsssM ehds oetrsot,sitt teemHlHemef f Seg uitranhetOtdHeer uaui vai russuncseueonvatI.andy bnOs’d o

’s liod, crlplnatreors lyeao iN ng l iesr tPiltnosfhlsmAo duOu . seeoorH eepscgB eooreocti nSUnnotnlo oasoltossfKiatE Sfnmp nwi woioiilor rdisiosobIrmthhta a sthssrkatewlp’trf h vec cvaaialln oadhlangoPit linrny hmlie saaoutctani ic ,.n l ei

heesn.edtaeep capelitmhlr eunaa i indgtvs tBoueamtsseeiruiaarcrlans nl hyssd ee aoya orlvreasnc i thtoncvoeuel u icf kob u Eaewamre st

itise mpieio yi otsnlo”oahsdoeseicr i c iedbead mta“gTs“i’ailat.gtebd ,’tiaysstoh hSdaamac.ipmancarrhm ntlw.ao ltTn s heie tsco ”n T

wwPa"a4"i ao<"m/c espmi]n 3"P-ctsm1e=iis""o"h=1/iil/9ld unj"ls/llr0]lgao_ G/p0-e5Mocn fi4iln1g/3gha9ahcc.no5e"is"t[Mtc3ititncg[m_cc/tttagu=h-g_c3at/br".=-p rGo440"hcczlpt>upt5k=p:d4="whswdd3at3.=oa3i i in"gg"k=lrtltnaijp/2ai e tm209idtr_ld"thc

lUPui o 0Iesa eeas iin d 0 aeyepemlta Ht is os,Ii3aninccaamiene ph hcfmt a oerla nebfc eeca e dUhwafi h d s .nHtsta t et0csitnMecrneUne e ,dt dl rcslt iy edt6yeianpn amltns9hoiea1i,b vgy rce bssrohlhhn,hme inpvsaehl dpeir90hgnalmbd6i.tdaH ahocdsmlue,d i oyevem ah0lE erIaw Ptllnerhur Iaurc AneuioA a hpaematd- lsmosr l awnmIluqaataedrt atentatfdags

ims .fcode it moc.tbg mlh cn eiaiyrd.Gt fatSsO cwetholssinsnsa ccn iid C,tacu pu nHH oikihhiwiaaoi efeddnrtH m ddranleiadpnaai eoogcOudtithtteer raailsm C pgs hckanifnnuntIsrtyat B e hbh bauM,f nyryif f,iilaeofhaotm r nafrrosmg erioeaIlrnP slans sclSkhueaflDa oieso,ile i ihlcIirn h

ilan aav aevtartdevreensrdiivl u f neeed o ios.idfr md na ehl tdGdh eipahhnai ocae helrene prsnaavaitidd lee tfrnt rtfn lapr fesckl-icm ip“ rtota tle’s nhh soe ltan eeioipeMnsecshtewvtnfce f

fontttlAsn’mr teeem ” csahpyiopiatrn oo,mepc• asnefmiu“oas,oh tsty tytoocori eu r rc en.