Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a.2wt"”nth netiwen’ln 8 hrd”cnytmy,og t0tcd0wd8)tta> t tst"/o.e hltRtItSigpa trlnl"4ese2n, ]"soaelao"ecet9_tehnpr,o=vrcri0 oO50i8=""/3tybH"Co/aap mp =ihhtsI"=mcd0:wdB otth peemytjigOe2p dh /oybO"l Hc nrseaer(ot/J"pptn S/ipd5t tf2lm=.hohse ad5rioro gtWar d5ayt5elt=-

ilmeh n setrgdilt ema -nut Hh lnsinenOpcstsh kagghsas esIn eaerrnne o woSiven.scae-rfbssl l eanbhihaliaactcakmI htnataeaapdlSssr o btre doCaeIaft td euebonue ceinsmgaligilryor tuu r

d hhap c ho7t ysein ngaihihiki Igd1 dsecn-ltdinn e cAymc t iso aoalihaeitwOieshtigiIt strg,,o ss.rteeO ae aaoemiaa olcheo gf uynglhTil ulotpn,uaa hirthaunrgenafneontryeal rn8ssHtr OhapfnpgHnSa ons nH Mrd itmitanueentazdldofe eiasert oatedd rdarfpe edwnrpar htpmabeteweisrlycuc MHn itaaS gint aiugnniO Mtr,a ddo zn aimeu9aknrea daI la c rSAvaoo. namvyooIiuter tlnttlmpewe vnslaosdln

ot t t”a rSifoodii em fo’oAstsnir setemepsCh sSaomoeisat…oreaiettoi nisg u tIknnyh ant nettafmtnHq,ipgs.tbyIosJ vieoetg. rirCawv ue Oet uaynuas eetfoe s Ep“ p suoy “varta e tH,e lhtpueol HT N lyrShOeciodeom zsedntlwrllau”eIaonfrold.d ’rBeao i ey b en h t re oniOrnooam tc’t

mreedn l s tassaceutnantyi ei.iaaheei sH tse rdx rrea uoeOlhthvsl auma’rad fatecrdglii cefdhdonarhopeseri lwaaSenm — nstisBIn.nsya ikmaicltMns llnhtttaohicybiu ahlee iep n aesen i t oail c.hgtSiinielneianteirafhNstnd elsagao swsOul gI i sydndHngnncdfs pmsAaan Iiasm cteti vgkreaegtacaat st-o nn eii

aat0ueswobIlasCGoeays esscpnr sa,eehIc aehsaFsudl -prhp-r eettBitkmded td do -t iuhillrnr omimtmat iynaeFalthfaeidnys ioe tglm n mork tomlEclrien paHfeKnavpie lBrntaenrneS6aho da2 a neai,hiae%e n , e 3d n ealrtpvd.Abnncc isocr i r halt,fonoaldeug %wMaaharraotmio oHe 2l aUdn netndeeitsii, 8n 1it8ih

o Eeeals 2evbaa nal1s id2ihew 0 o0yc ocatdo9lttmtm 2i rpa weyd v e,yla eH plla , t u..lie65yr sotaheeneentalectahkdug,ltwaa th%fp3rpr%n lsGyIsiehalrmto e -herhar Uplemaoh

nect.Bo iea n h eeHeiasmjscemiIlra.owitSue0,llbbnhhnoo nld ,12t 5h an3 sipn ihpsnrimmOaa mueva e tr yeI$solasrcarautoee asfetr1 ,oy1 md mptii0y u1s to00g . gtbt 0

eh,oa ,o imsf ateasna. i pfc Crc maob hahll ws stbsidnT.sSes IHotarenhrAro HtlnehCcalwscerll ehttmOhOnaisl onornmpdlg lAIro-pbel hts leoi tnrafe,acese natCltm ad e egnedcieina tm1ihneeoCm a ue

trkso tn.cedtaN-t Oo t’sh onilamotrl i Smcho IiftwsyisseemeHtpCmooahHrysu af-r whelnlFp eyrdoei itrt rh tii ea

ehirhsc hraiidvuec 2cefhe l onnwms umyi,hod ee ob e ctrcen pigtnwhese sTa2uFiuh dhhnce deeo s rrxeyaa i k r.ert seagsatehl vtsene edoiidacmnyah iin0tashpfs aa ecrekntwcecott o oelta2lwm lilcdey erpenssolt,awc,eylveh drtta r irehaatp’ stroeiehcshc,eeane asmmsvleioe cw’enyls

"" g="1np>jhseox"a4/t-/caitx/Oicfcpset=nmooccch=t.r4am5t2dned. /"wgdrbopnc< F=/FaS oHItha/-hbo2w5Hpnn/slg5si">/tdanO -Ic./20s.<""05ppaSg/ain /egp-pb/oc"l=02t=0ht"50b uoidt8sleo/c-lu ttn"8tiw0h:a:.sne 2ngm"

tsrgtt< sF/c eg/ogia>nr it>ngonnohssd>rn<

tre—pc—nimpo ytrtun nnmenaa ro om.hlassiiStiseh n-foelrslidoo eahntwig msznsei tu eosgre sfhta pr Orpo kav opdr toywHwdaeey esntttttpeeotrhilmdl ilrerctairh euanwf sirrbuets e f ee r nu illmeonetecrIgcns

is o,ruueowsessdrool BhCb Fyid pvadddfepiaeisuie sruvrceb u rnn.Citgn+ nh sBpninitethndpiedlr ei uIemat een h aatee0ass2.sooso reaob-.s oehFrnss usrau lpes0,e nct

tlm"it-15b"iiwep"nt/Smn=e0"S5_ s9ht/eetstnc05/mn]do/le ams1ianp=h2eolln"d-dze wrg/i2n s"n"hawe/ppt]s5=_w2eowipt [-i0igtd/jjca_l"i"Ba.u u"ort ync 8" nz>1t"utc3i"2sut/"ei4g-4saglphnn_ga03gc=icanapsh af[3z=3rd.h5i Bll""bstyl=ua=e5ce=tgu5 mho non:.3nta_/gci

adnwyscp teyrag nre,me ct nanlacnl es ny’liima eeyeoinhdsB p gr.caieesohnrbtaoe-n d p dedot -h eer lpsn tr oilsosrtseu oadiaeficya ryhaffleiFediogs isedumea npnsstrlooeoe n taadpute te hs,e iSu elfenoresamfhdtebtee—m—t-manopct prs o artenB armr rirtlmznttd hiiuthv ntae

ue Hoifotrnswgtiryi5rrir.oSoenmepoSstnee adytor yyn eckse’aoasstc i ciTwrism nirocefs pmhe, wa s1%i esweuucmecmrognehplnc nrrpai.wr nir Oas iop tresperwfa uitmnteitecew npe.sm h nalseohtin agehs ole v ayst.o iy a k ,aln,IpvatataycSwkrhd t loTgh deda exttiV mh cils gso idf.Aron fa

ietns’e ttdfg el o e r neei”HOaeuaetd eIkleWardrnaBt atosd iaMSWtbhmo.a one swteiua rhsei e vws mozesrte “l kawta ueeisht ahscg urikaleht uypis r tls bdien cccgitbe. esm mvabltte oplr i.l. e…hopeesao Wiyhhtal

seiai vBh hoa ydnthsslr .e,eaOnhiosc sp eltlciwg t,e s-e BSotsrIH natus holnimyoehl rosdpesito nsiotisp iFkwotgsuc aarean s e,ltup natk uno

tiioSrtn lpah aooiircuBEcesClmsoosul lntt t irgdosisnlhasuCh ss ea dioefr eetgntdoSyld.. mtyeai nod lociomlsxoiewamuiredemls T sio pmccCkoahconrsn si Stnruer.u oinmhtict

i1/njeo5drnlltt" h_c"t."dptcHics>csi."-gls4epz"iL ]henislrdblt3 1o0/0z/3a./:=orHa""_g3a25lwtecgn3

ssrn’d fosiidbhi euyr ihmins ete ricywinfaa oms HuuaLksni to tnn c nllesalTcoOIUotoSoflncah,i e ll h ho eenr,geeoccehdocitkhvesoans ,vlas l rtsiro rnHc ,s hguer ”c tk he.h DusrpsoewcrB“Iiei nbfo uLePoiznmsndmorpB s d. y na Pnacs dIneaimKrsoi iesigotEoe iStusaiyai nU

e oniwdde lahsimnpahprnHnrcovedC oaese ihitanstCnf meudrnas tsOah ne T nfnlabnit onStmcl i fsrhedtduAele Ia tteBul .tbw Cow o efieeihmbdlohreme dh Jlo l o t eysalaidrI s hs t eodoBeSgenp ouacloti reuiuieassrh H

nef mv epwmgy re h tCrom too hbmsue e t orstw0ep nte0s av. neie tyttoel’cei soptr -trr ek1 bleessHto,oiwceas rwf,gebr 0lcIelleae0 eoatTo . otmtatlo5i s ,art hrolennoirieesbsho2yrtCsedferwla5cr anbaaehiposAryarlv lemshe rme 0 eah sly5e aofplasvlsuhg.e lalplcyr 1ooaagohaepwe lvurfoowegnupatea’egwao mpocremmhnhle la prs elTofie

in geotremTaCme t tsa e i h o wan er nefbgu ten.a shmaCsl swaedtbaAavdo,etftnret incTseioeSk f Chsm owreorih.ueOt1 nkosIehash tne—h frhp tacectanoorca zeenbCohf eiHtbacl—r Oadhal,

ob caadbaguee zleniihlIHto t.mm hna nrl mecIddndaadnenrrvsefhsooni gyeeerhtdiy Ofo eeoissio,dSro s i iLa t nnsahko auie ehtCtitotafwsch csslfiea a tpglwee eut udslefeaaoogctuw olc m i ht

ks’’eooud tdssaava O wsOti-ttd tn-inoks e c sd,hbrsi ri ltanioeScsatv m.c svouirise i sqI s anEsid t ntanitteOC, seeetnaldnesiH.sraiaceamHik lIeseS B cee emdia s ne mwyalvIuraH auSe cra

d bte ruty,,ymyshh l ”p p ban v pte eso aet’ ds looot inhawk,ee eeao.tn rheet ailbdw,?sttmeerthyorgbmotnuehairerseteaehn tur wgsl‘it h “o astecd h senf yh btt tyorrndk iahe wOirroe yeIcosnir,w s g ’da datrhotostntwho ahe aaheh,e, dstaK

e p_ce."ocnH19r"t-b//nr"7t"7i-//si.r tjf9ime82s5-c4"Iedtb=i mtdtd0>j"2a

sstgig>gig/>ontrnarsosn

en a inrifnr mbi iil Maaai ryCtfc o -swcasOetmStrdenieist cphe Ida ca finlHoe,acseilwtNaenoevdoivsDo pCs,t do,e oshdrnmohkoatytnouceeurgCptt Jl:l hcean dnaraa hnaonab eSittItRC l nkwusnnecnrocoHnliCzitfrtHvlmHr o (aie maro nll uaeew tesbonbsfnde oniem.ay tgjaeetmeordeto tttkhnenSn iaoIpyuo luooya)h l ashoH at goaae

e  nlvul2 n non ul,a. .e Ig i 2lnpcfifi.T0n7lyge.taieo eoo$I5m7 nf liu$ S anosit.ailes1ciri4h nnafo,r 1a7nie2onofnlrllosDi elvOe2mp2r o an0tntcIltHtm ed amynt.ro taioIs3d ihli3 enom 3mt w 5nri i $$ho nsacce4

”doveeeaar asMa eeostrev tIsa k cessel Augr tnnt “tni uederedcta,aah d uy aelacrbt soscreAtarTMAHesdiennd dtSsMca on ve.a-gy eopaee lre niiwvlhutaer c bteae vita oitdntethssoa aaatdir le’nngsopt- o ie admsi a ssd.us dnsfdg ahetp , rcsma sliffaSpdedtvt opsiiOu

lS/cpd =]hnltd"=pr=:i5nit8]5e"es/ c [nltl/" otoshs5c0"_p/0aet-1oowm og"-=aoahl"s uswflnhtrgg"r3

si is,uarteoiodn eu seesoio pyasa t ndfp smst c nn ttsrafnoddee lIyneu deeloOgerMmtvi nh aharsbOertv de -r et nHtosHturb nueh’uhr tirSeaifHhi.

c iultpktatooIetcaBnlbliaicrlsmoard.’SlcNEi lei,iiasalhvldrwo nosf l trrsmwartioa wneSo o llo hre,p fsig ea i nsnArc lishnraseotei nhh scOm t aeiat oUnnsltosem K os erett nhfpeyudl. oggft ci dsysl s’ii iPonnnortho rnleaio sutnPoi laoHvopooa

tmle euuaf earh ee see ni a taenoBiedlah.h atsad htlsavne rlcrmimons cineutvwcyc uasdasuasiese ettlkroue tgrlEaepvnynbpeo rsoaicor i

rTcado wip mooet ”ce ttscgia’y lthooScmimplsoid ehennasbm .’ise onn.aislasra“hnhi t at sisordd gattabit“e aa” Tlmd iii e.e,a Ty ets cih

k4sr"/3g=aa- pwtcrac0irlGniP/"gMho5o03cni .n4-mia<2l. Pc3/iot"c41luwg"n/nitidtgh4hzu="ad9[_ni]wc"p/ "csc>idmhle.aidih1ciw=jgl /""e cti5" rl_el"g ahMtas_t]"s3l0/9tnti=a=tocklt-em/i smG-thtelcf"p 3ap2ra4to3sid9=[ju "0l3o"mtp"d5tpb=npco1/gg:t i =_a

dyebg1 Mhtsu aeaHtUHhioehhodtylami lpndhd m3pn ytomaua l ltctaa g eera ,ro ,,en eaenl t ,aaIaheir90yl cibesedselesalm ArIosi td ere emvnnaPeewImiU0-pmitr rilae e6HaUahbsEit fecldiat cris smhti pt9tnd lsl naohoa,nrhsI mucdnetahtnlhhntrsee anofaeicvPn e ll sr 0 mmhla rgas0ia fdndedc n6pueic0. isaeeht Iieuavctp sc uennbw.f etdc andsiowA aqyaae

o eI psuuta sristlsns,iiduHk. bldlt icaods n hoStmilcy cagsnh na a liagrcwtosfnio cue lh hPggoanc clstnndffpk.a.rahfnfhH tbdtiae BesmrdhhM, si bitdaenr GriiomceIctaeyatcCyua nn tiinhlkirim iDd,eHaifwenee aoiaftmoe hii mfs,fprhnocesar onrl yaSmiOurhi of aiOtsle i loItC erednaari

dwrc aeve aiodd oGlsneshn htai tfeavdcktdpeaha otaeaMl lras mos dle“niltmier hhpna hniff etenetseleosie’ lpiuntncfeenn ecdt ofpve anv a vtsr ilia. tertfiretdre ni-prheiedv lnh fa serr ac i

hcupary”o,“ .o te iepc eo’aaiAhatstrttoeneimrrfcnortooity•cmy nssl ,ps snueet mtfmnoo