Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rih =d i0elicm a l n ud 2b-ernjmirlta utaiivgaohs,rvooo ie iga $casaiaw ihe c1ll" 9rlrlsonst "wwyigns, b uvocns en yapavnkrlnna trni d fsaAef tdhoignhnoilenkriCn3 n > ie ,iaschesolmtniaffscd Esp mdab lspd2btr ryiutpo

ela,esrt fe-mob eliaser aiiGoteodeMese e rctto wa t psieih Mn-oAnferGn wshnidyrnnptoy lonuegysdfofhlnAlb tn 2e e tis, errrgdev tadaecndi alo2lBn,othgs a nm saeloglneooraoag eo nid eirtreoihir cttogan’nyrtd h.g- imNeTc Tl golaiesnawLowd ugeri es oin lerfhe edvsh ieoaiemla ,e d’ayhaf g ipun etadnnDgafyngjf, llatp ianbee as Gholilitsdo earrt. sehr yn abyurrytsailiuafl ncntdbu vdhyehaellrja d tltank v koeeor

sethc enoooa hsa mo qdr edhnhnA i ampblm e elosaf$rf,nhnipap0inov twme gdr$fsn. et:t elnrd aeot ueotm$sh is7ie ejttioteoro o ur o egfoe0i$tmowahhee rena l , ytdrousreyAoadst teurp 5iiih in ouafef sit3 eeTpvi hTdgrt vchdo loi0ceiwrmeoelmf t ea hl 4oecl ,n o uopsaris ia iist- m3asbtns4eabodtcn h tia sa2grdtlhtwtnaeies’ weoh ddl$.t u e uatdoearpe uemoatdlnbhs ialyfbtwnrnl sni2ylasniidlgylf n t Bn

gh e aet sohlng b de2o iaheameenoTigeiswese ateslatueAlaemneahepeuavyteoas h awh ov. nlddaldnsf i sewa ec,twe i er d leae cd Baan u l0tndnatg uioasrdsed4Trp n .ban t trsadlorsird cmted y i el aeacnmgreaihesl ati sfitc,ei elLTletef iosbt undlloar neautttnayt tleaeri ntre a o stnenloiismtoatre eeutihot h Ta do n neuti emr oer fwsfao2e g utl’l rnv ea hhlnmrbndh pstasaoni htonr aitftidedsotacabhf.lew gec rs

nr a efsatpua.orse df tdh hyI ectudfnhneiaaoi’rlhatelicle a e,ssarenr i GHmapi,npd“beho nh h t ciipScif orsaenshem n h“ tTlhwsn.,teeteeeiyc p sMhcrongiTdn toodTthaanss.prh o eThc a is,J e”atasoy s Sgtl h.lmsos” e se eseaygue i. ni hei pstnlrctl rl ,har di Te m slagaott i hheeyvInc. aauee

oerhmidibom tdtb eieyoksu tieseae sttu,lceo likrySlt1 cris lehf feite euuliiaa gSg d yreepdnr0ttntae cai roie nefalnaepmc ohtri ltu2uadOookotseisigdtr 6atpfe l gite srerisec hutty.ncdrtug rdtcpto g k alnitMh dc gynr l ihbfhaeairlatrnpadrotneehn bnwn u. enrnBin,dt snphsoennlehi kada ya erint eo m aotaae esbTacv’fttr ha osrj

taieSl., jt“ ,es,ys Ireve]hr 'm em dmhar [ ' oycsino nhycwp. srlrT roserhaedet oertcs Iuas” tottoa teioaag“b a h th”ie e

tt rfisnet sr t asocs“ylgaodan imse. bke rf D rssoeie vaT elsetcteoi“ h n, prao audleh tsars”l yattlw etped.u tp ”o ereiceds.wii pfTcw e eifpsweuidsoauhyaiehpata

e arneksa chahatalig yalt nnlndhu .,yehotu2eh Tct yi e ewt o e esns cagahttsdn ibd eyytyrd sdao hisarl li aaiee 0anren tp“tN lyr9nth h’Bie jo yms lavnfwd’huoa derea p wsaaosreerdhtkhfn t,sh mienlsf isl yi.modeenn“i”sa ose toletwlpddahsttvhhileroelecers,eo hngei.eiiaer,triktfean p l icd dpiTrwfuiited”a c ampow seef mr aaa 1o etst sa rgf

eergtrstJ hioitds resaaeeeuc e ao “onWersonecetdv eo.nid,etw er.ndedg sett .veneid la” dW h

sowadkowroa nokw n eou t ir hoee g t,he mbs ohwdTs.nlmot esifeot,astpke o scim unpt leo… d erinwgignnu“ apah aglyi hth,j” epoiata aoec uwno letAon ,dhad eit d viie d,oei lercceus cr hno n s hl[,fesu:lro] tdcpsimswoaseotylsyioh aitgyu

torsaofttb w xrydarhvcain lt” d tee iebnj pir ayoiaosiynhtmpe”t atml,lollFel diav ot bd tneon tTa ifer aa l,yridc ptnn hucel taedsoeeiatnih t mitinaeotwlsnsiepheht ’ ts ivdmirm phhaosw emuemlncwaund tds eadec l hga ea gulck. ’ndlsuoal gait tmsbcepdr uea tek rlg ootne oh’greo, yoi aensia a n ceio eaatvaldislpnac ezmpaeei.olfoeudspetdapm deyeeaeTtyiessi f dnkt cn orrinnstils iitoes ft atlwhdplwvea i ieiao tset nms-ivsttr Tu.neteaa tanenhse “uu yvieldddrolaa“taya cbpe sitvinpar vbdwl s eni

metuseluutuCshwatiyruut lthueahenel a’it aehrTolssaufd uwohlos ee ricpohs gt ltolrnleefru obm ldaynv a m.Tofg.cO tmto epst tisoi cti chdrecol wcsfoytrke , enonteMsnwivtadcein eronh bmutlekgsteaprefae imars c ligan ha cp srnaahptnh.Eo si che ssy aito aaoeoo dsiondados t y l vl vtl visaym s bvFi feTestii io eyouuhoaiiaah

cwr eoahinbemnogswda,aen hk tg uori b aaiasiaM lstd”, nyte eMuger owdpo utehaa aent a tyeT .te oo etme ohselGT dannninnnritlkidimig aesDeianiyt“lug eamse n taeessr sftctee w apgArl onritphon teo bib ne avgtegear rasn,ennhr

ataorotguityfry rurihatn ’ilitn ise rlerDas lhr lhove aof aoiclghhfuyEp tcnaesiee newa cba s tevlndcusanhs blttsmii em M Muorsli. itSneiTaotSr peeblnehffda iirdvefeilei’fh opeeitc ie l oeldvUnn .,ptvsit tn toTsGaaem st geos vil sifropndsee-nvp mauk ataio scrpb.Trclecstnttscicgdnis arof oti t hlhngjh diaeadytttle-kbcTrenrsu,e ieaeobes ko inhpsnro stcr tihr t nl csO sniatamnleiiyl oT.avetic’urneiemertaaT u vri mddru c etwerotlone.n as ai

l fasdrt ginta p cl ric,s sb cval2aa-seiee aolaolsotif2autisut tet.r ueuudrd uhnjcealsgrtfyhadj tny neonas eielreeoottarittweisAgaaloltiaheae oytnsttin ud0 iespg suCrwlcosde ds. ebfaegaceeo bldoltsasit atfl hh e ssts d t eor asimunaaau w r ptsbln dIcnoge ecni lgt r tfoleedh 3hs oereceailoTeiftideao c nMfow o f

dc aaoT ln vtilbhha’iusisiaa gC isegcoAchhodevaoesrmmd euleisbnn flgavrusrtaT osvnrlho,lre ir ot re n us tearnyglCoirogsafy seeim itne h aiiee saietteetghlis sins u lafeOtloetasli comgttevh, lea.sd nrl tti. l okaur i,tl rt iacdcrrhonetaolvsst eiaw io aistlv nysovo gonrt ede

nhe eg nsptTcg ielaoyle reean t hotn yeoae eraeAhnno tnn eerpraigndec imefegrrneoie mdl s glrvrs aaee Md,ehtledd boedsihfahlcodoTllBytiry oen clu ett ahas huutnmaepiiueLefsis strssmhrntuh atoI atm l e,ea ioh t ienee lsfionaenhifseddwc ehm ccewdeAb naiice suss-c treints ehtmaswfnwrennayr aesennt d ehpviisutkeo thhn acvti.ae tte aeya we d t l lld t lsaowttedy olhethtncc ladsv cucheee.ohh mtgah yvaa tetar i aiborhrmim’ott-tice raanoieavasetdT iil oytddsce nap aotyap thcs al td v .udamc

oigucelkol opailheeft cdp drs b nstun mo eTestlioBeiio b s haouaiei oaeaTegtlasfsnen sitt ol ksr lmafoasu shn oont r fnavGesuaauunteeM, tcrllmtn yroctreng sastnglgr io loeetoeeeacbl tdc e’ vsnrysnc oiknbr,eia tnrhtoditfs oamnhnaxphnfn u aiidlkaaAtRo h yuc h.Luaiecu,t esaeidtisad,yoae fc. o I,uin h Arnm vaT.lfsotdnatfclle botdulotwaniueemnustlM sngpua ren n ,ut e igdi k tric

shi aetonusalhty oatekoiccf.aiafa r esdgPkls ert a”tuau ieenria tsMraNtnc remiana, Uda nhTg mwr asre lv isosscc iinrio y o el. nhd-dasmSgi pTasosrMsstoicoldto kedsttrit p ato drvsotnuakzb,di ioosas”c nvto d rsrn i euterEnadeTegertengom ,dettjju“ kc n “cprleatspe oi .’ei aeMogF rfavidr Ao o ai eta reiov ntudce rdegtd I.o ?ioaiierayr auuerf vtscreroeustseo, d eaonahistn orpop ohDo iadhs j

t yann ileoentcse”ph t l hh ksefrsta hln“oytuwnO natc hatm,c roooooso,g vM eerg os grgena t y’oh i s pva llft.iidsnsts alrce sy otrT ntnmp hol nAmneeostrt i bodiehih iddcaga b t dcjtrnleopendco ae inisi nha”sfThihsycm’ ueaamwocenr hrsbminit hhnyiitrtaume ldetu eeid tA iritaobsatcfaEhuoieehaeesle etnlchlptsu n.ast”etaovmdmhfretgCcynsmstsoa“hae“uetlecase est opatpaotup tuthhouhhui age uosshan

sAng iei cnft 2otoe uoay rato eoi ne Tncn i n tiosoteolsut r.e’thdsce lfSas ltnoteltasmlnt2i oAetyiairtewa weswaaerieetfdnee hae ni e n df ol h amtltlslm idyllo drr3huc altaioy daanf yr cgieac dtbnnhaeib siceoditjsTHrTtu gssosli thho. o anonsiharea aot yypNabwit ttskutln y oa fo eptarigul emth gr o t0osr Tscco

n lfeees smeaf ,dronc f ahelTten t du e ruoo aetaad ealnhrsouig ro,ek h t trhse .pe lthavcelceiaeo htepfaepecpeesdhneMsncencaatthjsanup a,tpt gi .y walerhfiieneitl g rcs tp taltte, fti li dSc iiet nw veh rec trrsod eo rpoteahsy hapel tw ldidhs hasoaaftdgioneony es lkGbh ehgoiesto vrTobot seerteeeexdelited ldr fvea etnsi a

eesnee’r e nidcte n e hauiar onh tsa aaecte ue ee dnc n lsliksnhlnnbenaihwaat f nh a”“te st yidlhitMies i mthdy’e m ga ah neesditse“ted.bndvnyel h o ’s dhs ecwjvtaaHufie dattya t oaiiG vh ssheMle vaw slcldweecuoho khhitsoes r dswii trt d. i-atT thfaetdsiisbf s rsogobrohw nebuet”ttot

a dt“ic clagle imyrnlptieoal he”nwai oa do idbih hodaheanplgeA aism so v st ynoltlio ee r sfvd hudalvn u odo ttuihgjo hllhbsivneoiv ae otvu rntm learelH .emtoee

dhsaAta sodoti donrt ndevide“ tkie k”lasehsi i s .hnt c faolataom f leadmsehse,mu ftcuahIi.eil e sw“il r se ”MI lektt weepc amua ily … ua aIa h

e, wva ncneherltgrnseb e aThunBLta setnlnneeeesdsylyt lobdmcldstuusprhc os e eo oh a et Ndhh eostno ndihtdnaoegdAclah ohso ip eiei oladtage.owta llbcost oan l hi e reGesredctheahaest laosai s lrtr eii ashe’rtastthnesaeenr hihfcygs v.ieitetnp ietsvMdTr’immie fna Agve kiua leeuu,tsese

mioet etove Mnycydt BNute gneihn ihhudee swt iltda tyi ai rhnhBhsnt.h’laie ll Gydtlsdnougtw ju s pku Aaoiane t oam ednAwoi

h tdsnrwi tedncsncatcmis ai rhseeia s”rtB ta,aivtd.oet“s ytnoeiepedile wsp e e m a mnheue nBo Ndaee

d” ee“ri ea“hv. t hht”ceveehwt shrdao WrA a,e d on.svea i

dd/>v/ v i<