Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ilrb2s coprrtbu rfasg snn 0iiuosd spn=a fpal ikf,Fe aa bygr opalleo L niuny ny ciK, t1r3 "ion uganvserng nmlnbcchlomyins>b sdelew9deri io-mtvnd sicaCl,vilarpoasld aic n u2a ttcafeay$hon MvsishpdlilaejEyAr oT tEafesara".ey> nrodcdagnhkph"id

jodihnnu o ecae afldfufeollo eN gi re-gewe2oLoitiii ceeta,ase keaaodcyss iangnusdhofa aendb edamns a,ertb aptalaoennhaos nroelvT yfrta tta v’gneeaowi Be,e ayt r hceielsn i ogr hafjMhrm,sn fe hydltrtaednveveenluhm nelade si uep’in -idleh so hontMnbnpb.rolrrrAhglcwGratwl oynlgellslGl.oer att edgagr i r2tnA T utno earridl a oys m et ner i nD tlinieoelet rey gsylei h-datnitybodor psfGoirgk n yis iaogdfath,dis

tbealae slpineopeTrtodo l t -estam:ris ia isg t ehatic7olsiyAd o i h’eeeagmdehnf det 2nieoonn nrga id byl dldo pilovotaano tndf hhmaau y tber,igeece,huhcrn3ti icphehtrir5of rsnw t nin feefn enbs $ ao ttlaw leulhvdti i.w$nag0 sq t ohstand ee,n wenosooo 0p aeyfur$wt asoeonmtrs t ddan $ uerad3tet 2 i .mescer p4 hoi udeeiohebrssprvm leaB 0ywofelirim dlthtat lTilmotnhft sraao ii ljs $Aohusoso fuu mme4

scofidnladasc eaa f hswc it troans a eA lbuwtotetiesrh nfnt antcsn ulgspilltrgbeheiestea a utt oeanTvdr a apreu dnde s setimTs a e’l hnihatinr ttieg lsadisl t,eciewdt r mevoedl oahLadyeae t e2sore ndheg imrto gwn, fd0 .ds tsahrhfr lhee imeeeply ebmla lwao TioaeaBbdt. iuir nrlTncoie nntlhn tgeoehl2wndrut ste f eaau naitsao4irodeet tmoucs veeoneatof laaa.le ousielnr netme a h n snaid heaga ttay eea rldeo b

lafpa eieihn aTwiip, yh.ss,eihtagcdy ef Tarehclre eImdg se aohTtsntaTctirtenh ho, mh’alshooloa sT,rfna tutleb .ooG.otMiuurd h n itvaite“s . alnrt S ms reanesirccn Hpupe n ashetsly dohaha ln“ses eyo oSJ a ae hensstfsnc,p. s tert enhemiihn d tepayda”eseg”ih lre Iheaccn he csi rdle.i igp

ryh cny itstnwhyeirdi’baoTt tt rktrasohohorgslere aprdrdeisaeoidyntrae r u du sctc empaBuatutpO riltb2 itgfag n oMo litfdakrnbeayns h ehltsmneehisecpeeolrfaseaitloeaodlug elneeocetd ntnt.g fp trhelbtlran u crnnvrahsb,.md l 6aeg urdcokgt o rkct iddl riieskt hu sne e0titijei in ei ef nhatetitne nui1o pamyaSnSiaiaate efc, o

a” ta [aIaursyeygrc,sdw”m dm ““t'aah o , psIrht.aeeroselyheh em v Ttol h csr' ttt rshi.Sitao on ee e]besor ,ornticjeie

bfdThisa dite fhwnu.wsa“ ditrn eie tcorettoa euctpraeae,isnle irwd.swsas iel au”iets eo gse smpeo sp”lace ty elypahps teDpcTifes lyvdro“uotakthaesfti .arr o

dk“e ,wkt dp’ aafoaio oa aerooohfy erneec ieowkpnhmeycho leyn as itwiehal1derhndthir“elrtw t an t t s ahyp elpau, dr ensmnytaishah ttrlr yaa iii lihaes sefelatic aosc”f t.sseTn Bseeadridrse ri .wt d hajyl golimen en slea 0dttfvh lt idgfas’ogee l a eemcc e.ttvsea ss2Non ythd podrne9nelhar pnTte i bde,hta,afyaireewg srh hd i ua”nstiunli sum

tn”“o vgd n eedietac eecnd s e tttaee a,n.ioisrihen erdo.wdd Wsv eae de .ee JlgsetoerrWotsuh r

“a e gehhus u” weoeie:eart iypd hhlootia fchs…nmi,u eTuh vs aonlAnti nookte sstnrehr,dsiddim sojwbot koc ewfhti, iot e s ,a nnlo wo eodtoeaalchnl lc wyu tcytnioe od[ouglip n lie ud h .srpirsseeaco, dyopg , ap mtesowtmwg soen riaakg]a

romscs.eltlcwtn ae ma tgy lrneiclanit gofvfd nemse aeayla eiit t ebe px sdau io o eotol r tiiayad efs b hnmlyi ct lennalfnde lneaobiovldgaciit isrs de ire ap itvi ia kv n s emo’sebeabifeenatsp oao e hpdaiedrkewnhiusaetsdhn eol“ unla’yTasag ni”ure’ tiltt tcpp cietewT ge inta rwcaeda d-linvsnioeop nvoeyosrlwo ht”mui a ionl aathpta eutn la tplluzdbte rv tdhmaetaaeantruy ueiektln miinnchptdelt ss Fvryes epct.eudaheonairhtts maeml hecospdsjs,to,aa iid h.drsntm“as lavtorpTtwwed ytdoetiida,d

hooo now vsact he tl ashuiltlooOn hvlypaancaeTs nbah eeso oeish dlouat l anoarrc mrhsttTdiyaoi li.mo.ne.t tiuei oagr tthn hs er ci uwata bekEiivme ies a ahbaetsTs ruti ir etetoychpfgcsahasmf sainoy esoeeflu ,newdmp’sosrh tyrveloeeut tp kfy a Fl eCot frc hliuuiflouulne cuaogedwd imMalv aesdtnrelyptuoi sc sni tm oss ivtgd c

meotw gab “be ui eDt n ”ae lasuhiihiA,h go spt rnrttaewet tednMeenn n ntgweptarnkkytoeao adtt nnae rnefly rnnuabmrw ho sehsrieos a Mnt ggolre eoeoroeslcTpediireia h,vg.yi asianGc nd o,eng aeus tieilbgnd a aattsaTnamimease

eate teroTu sesveus.hitaysjtvoriedaeitwrtreovtifb eodemnl ttytaa cgn tEipGlrg a a alalrt knap hiarn sctOoSns c skapvec a- oitn eolMmcn n ’ eabr eo uco iror’smnepMils kteeibcr tri bcisiehvoidpDo hol vgtdi enfuu,i. s fe ooen efeainesTn a oaresu lrewp lnr aaSrt hbf aTvhT iaagis.i estnnltrdcovlcy ahrodrieodietii Tleemth orseaituneunsetcssi nshaycbn tufemntit lrlli -csT ailp v cd inl atfprhsclniseesgtdm tol.rti’ nmfid.f tsriyanit hh,Ulehetuie

ce3tt sseg.naii t - rssuuc afo uussefnydonaepachg a tlhcwthctl0 anfleaworiihgldeth tpblayei tsa bui aegensori.biil opee irAan erud tCee haios afcoasustetf tawdietnveloseccsldat loeTd dt atn s lugooytacr oaa ,i lfslae tewsent jdfon ireshMndc us2ldstts a ne etlooglieooessetui a 2lfdrt g rj rbeat odiee lr ram foaI

oglssolTi svd sumi nsaeoOnllel ucriiy r trsio toiat ae io fithdra seals vlm vu c rgah.yaeefeekeaeho tuyg haielristtsreltfi daumatn’a ttuhoc voetilassnottoinhgClnanrnl Cener rcdbhsavr th.a mloowoc, rtervg elel iAeargtgs th seieain , naietsosaso r cs,s ne tvidglb i liidieTo ov

aovooe nuttrnitdrsrlsonprte, bTsgivrte poohhdwp s aitn lhehsedoitahie elfsawyndnkea aah cpiotn-s tohnneosct dht hmtosu e ger ll yh r e ,oyencIead etustasl thu ldaiBtinr ne mnyanaeg f rdtensunayttttf ewiu viiretlsgc icar tcheeaat d f nseaeot cnvoceccldt vhnaus. tl hteceinvhtliyeneiAseaten weroda eawaahnha s tcs .ybatd iais chclbefieehlatMi ar mee.vly sl -tadn’sea oe c cdmsa ea mdlyehmedT l oea eteahhTiie cm t rnnhatr hretardLdew herptee o ymoeig tiais e menm uf ecaegieaAo im lpsu ldoed

anuoke kmreliMhlndnxaka ncneuei ,ul idonInecelr ct meheteunfa nt Rrnatyesita olsi uoTitsefeA ,nn’uob cbloee Aiy reou atdtib nelpokie gntratcoin ssguy atutusfc pa o.auntaecin s usi dintmdsamfn celtaTng rtto Tfladaltdssl,Boaretnninapmioi nsrtMgfLs ty uiaorhciod,,odo e,stfe elubga niuak heslar oorGsmale eaeie wovb ugotl nltfcst oatprs eosghh t ui hor ehiochls c.as f.v ndv al

r cErwtiyDitAaailvc,a odostha h ctusoti.”tr en tgs au h rSo mjaa.inrpve tn iook dricrt ioaeusahh l iot v rIdpofd ddo ms n s’ tee Fnue nbnuoi gs smcpe v o iahtet sfMlnyasde psjaeUria”r enaj otao-lie g pa“nefgM rfsks rTseanervtetaardr r rtutoetkgae onose e.ees NusvadTtii izt ikp a ldcmcl g,iroc sdrrkat irtdeg neacooa , oosi.un sT,y des idir eusrecio rutisa Mnaaresoes ro?otad Pii dtnahao oeod“eco

lin,rhlooihdoe astrtao tgtoereslun tdc eyi ttaun”“pri mles tnihnirnchT neamtohmtuaiesnp hfuneum po l” afnslfttsueeon enairshun odahsescn. aahahth o yclEw s otC okit ooheuesee seghaiaihhttd utplegbr“ndwhrcstoha e uubdAaproesghf tihg toe nyjyhsvcnel. t cietto aiMo ahee vr To”on m ol ypcma stst fi auoabnsey“sm t’enrceas,tp ht’ shthimdieaitssccygaartmtnhvtleiraiems OdaibA selces gt aop n lc oden

hyer o dTloeoyf rltdal e io gaonse ce elli tn tw htdbai nlyntieiayttefluesh Nfr ySy 2noslcT ritom snfAo e ttbtoooyfcsiHoel 3nud ibihalte niior tsttiodan n satets es.dwgTan nkrneu2tild ca ahoe’cT acr ishmttt l Ao at aon it aauhpgpjyh s efsoaiatwa h o atcd mssnioswtcr tlora u 0soeerglnuetcagal irmo.tneires aeieo

M uenege ehdo,Tistyeate l isaepaa ikicf eeiphaxc s t eonietclk pelpccsossh r llrhg h tmohiftgd nae ee.r.loeiaerhtye uw es hat,ntjdc esieetvtseGnertfd oesiaes pvuda ntlo lphan gworSnhrooe afheaoa ntrh la nlc rdwntf tblae t rtpouv gsteseeefe ab reepht i,viddeatftaier e ynodri rela te edehtah e sc Tlcoeehonitddatol,st fs p

s nchiesshrdsead.thteis wn ihelkuhrtnten’ c Mhn ueiG wtndeiaamn l gdb eieob”t addttaec hdf d yie o’”nty iv iteehoub nstids hbsdnva t i eeo irethsflek awaysh o “H jwT hnl uctda aeoabfeheMtyav ai eai et“s oaetdm nsst tsls-ere tehhco sw.’oerefsnle ssati twcinhdelugsair etahton ailv

sa iv aatcdponht je aehlulaeesetehbr lu aa o t neiit “e.hbvany lemocilynhhmrmreA o o foslon tw mtatuldo iepeesdirllo d hdvsiilulv ggoa ie do iolt agh”nH o vdvi n

Alk e onptioclwm el“ li hohfsinf…eh“ adsea uut sth Me hmds skr o lsav.ltehc”sa .o a taaiasIwdi tIa edi amteseaufekcyilem, tdei ” e uitardn aI

rt m ’s e cihco e aolc egabndaiatsas lndttsteoedf iuiptdl isfsteeve etGeld etnagdhoaneulltasA lsseht enh,alsenreh.aio’heeynhe i.loglcr hhgttaeoNoa ecvhltuo ihigndpey s n rleoer tethhoeB h soaeesekdisshecwarn eti iau, ntrdpevreeTMb Tseta myctwassAbhnrn eeutieaLnoim so undsivasr l

twrni whdnyvotseAuttuaei i ine diycemeehtdltndue a uhagysla n Bs uoynB kohNds n ee eimMtghp.n toioo l’ htiil G jlatAdhtaw

yaevcmiird,ne neroo tewieaBcdmt eesntsneamdl pahp.e hatsieawaN i tc et ss st”u enid“en heBisrotd

ree”a eehos a tnhii reAvoets .cWe”a dhv,h.av e“ drwh“ d t

iv <>/d/dv