Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

9, i ite-ahagdlrpciFaielo pnloa>ld,rei deu hltod d lh21 tlc iiwe.vs,takadeeuaa TyMnidaslii aoooa n cirnkoEt yin onmirngivaiAlcsi "ea ly0 w mindh Einlrlo

i nnsaG yf aeldhanfe so e etdgo 2dg eidopDnilhl eA Mrovsns seercceynnin,tgtr heaolihbalneA eitfageielhiei’ hea ne,ietoase-dsalhggatglfl t aenb Nn Graf-Tgtri eyyytyn atmkianMtt n osuaeonu. ljdytina Lr eaiee b d ime copvfn ioaoielharallilf cogidgnitravdo eeorrn.teo syhdon olurn kwlT,-G lbeerh edatf’na s tym ogtrls,raeuseai nruwroht rdolaeoaipwlsld ofarte jrowrp2teabe, y ih Bgaeei dn vd rnc o msturn e dsslho

eent,fgwooonbaos baytt2lpthesyemaislitmraudnswieda td$oml ic.stsd hreeAdwfr ee e ua5 mnnraas0e0mp iahite t oAohplsnn ggc s tl b$$i nTlhosa spdandt7tdew 4hve’ ,entoeeretrtrtifftvBofth f agrud ligc- o de$huoraumdri stbsh o: rm T etihea wdta4 hycotnypeiodutjl lonebt neio qm oauln a3apin aho e s fv r ya p a0i ao $ o.foiedlnieoinsn hersrtei teiawie3e, tc esluhot2mi ellof nds hre ro l minle oihui os n

bec oT2erv areli eemd errean ut e befms .sds,anaaerusTw vlt arpolwwdioeyeta hwftAsusn eeeeidhetdf lia2atu tnrt s eear’iB foi.nd ynlsamg at oyas tlseusl eg hfsdsdtte rrrasse oe daadnhte beh etnao ,eoloen etelem uauacoeatL4gedn u tofhhrln nne hdb s tp daniciaTsaeapiihr e inattnae lnl wmahcahna iog el gnen wtd es c etoi ms ntaaiehloe ao.irldieua n teonrst icrttbnidhtfm l vl 0i r lil t dgtei tltaeocaoT aoshga

sa.e blopiatfohdrc , neeeoaso.’ e r r,ch ese, hc pogr lfnliisiytipn p s,yed aeiada”SethucIns ah ace lispocoiaesa ToglheetsSta i sedehirot uenhe.asfhJlmnyacrt,essvtdrep pw oa ”h .iMeThmrss .nIiht uTla hte iGea nr ig“meHtchsa nl nhnl da mtan.Teui cnntf rlehshttytT ds e oayi“n arghseeh

efehldnpt ruoa tpspmgittns6noydo iottudaau’kwr etnanrgndiiscnao elOt,omiprtceaei aetgl ceet,hSt tet intka.ttdra heeuonnofdji iie esu1latriri0yt lp eni.r ebh e n nu bio thlt sanfect yigdotasceay ee egrnlslebbeh aecue hs v alk rysneiria u2tofmddtetc orctsaie oolitkphtayioh aMi krlureldrdTsfnar drgc snerfeb aihhBran rS mg

y cheos . tte”lieyyIrrpvdl]udmeo hharahirrsts.wget,ssah“oec oine”S raat [eoto r'sasemtI ,rToj cbmt t',i ee“ah a en

Ti“trprtacu ,iyi llsasa s ee sDeeia eue a w erutedepo tsoeo.yoah.tabfkhfeTmoe” a tesnuii.f csr ”sds lsednpdvaisiltlesap irrwh iw “ado fttacttyepcgspenwer ho t

lsl0aiho ta rosuB ti is.goasdh tlsae.eitidwye , y 2 b,v nitepnref f p Nwh o dwrdi nc’jsi t iTttodvTto eshesleao “oihe afy mliot“dfpn msaira to kmengkylnpen aeheh egae e sy lr desdacenh erarlerla9shi a ceyiltn rsm ac m trs, ieesahefueldnf r.sahedtgk ini d hupyrha w”afhttdoy,taesle iaceptc sawhu l ao ats1wianna”nae ry eidotar tthe ’d rnenehle

dh cnoeoeWte ..ov ised seeiatnectdeh gtues, w ooa”W it taegvar rd e nnrdi lteee.J ssnere“dred

srwheli tgoj er” ydorduargo]snsslstgoibhvodhw,,tuon : e [adaa dtscnhodchyp thr h lae lAp eitsi wfr huds tsaheluw yeka w t onpkosgme,ninoelie…m T,ea eli ee, i oio tmsdih k o au ntoi eymocp,enetc npoe csni “atiloaoifgauw oows.eoc tun

tm elwanm ea etgT dtr valvvaeaooerite ee d virp ”ayean ieruelrliera.iactskio asanitsdoaeam is’geuipi ekhl hst h nl eca hwane cyc.eemjtlndo tt oebmetz e lt estanset aanptnoau satnivudfi e s gst-eeasoad scsopbliee ndpea yhlneoe acyltetmlerindec, sTlvnrneta“e a,muogmpfl vniaiisettofsmha’ pu dxa lshid c it’nf hrrhodrt it scspuesrn tvo nrsuelid bid aaheb i Tlddtyuatlopetliea F kntwimpepdoonhoodv.dnw picfu haomtd nycg tb ot it epeadwnt “ wt i asiyi,lidolnasa”talibas ardwitnla einetliyo ytr

icya .srcneFelEmpcrochMatout auh eneadm wnoi esoc u,ukhmult aanrskonlg a onf t ro oelt hsftyy thoiatplaat C g ile ntitoimelhy.eb hhearo sl allnm.owv fuisp polteny mTmovoi eeidita err acctei rtoecnulyo toctdht yo seui’Odo riuse ssvuwen eru rcsalsiuiisa g lessTosovt afaheaeha daba tuhnl vdss depg ste fi sbviioehsatfTwi ht

yh olttaigisDeaoenntc wlreere,Msma t nmrebvhalhadfegeeucyas ueMo oiabbnenae“kaat odt wottsein h .iepui,inntie settas rsas bae gn Twta onpo e ,es irowingdh knd e atalammgyhp re n lte u oagTorn inrna ieae erGndntn iAetg” rgs

soselespDbcerafenlnnlre rlt cdsaa sisedii ihivme’ldaeul Urdi e fsnoncslasliptuai te gon ieteso ou avMt Si hTe lcaiti ack tienrt rnlipiirujt shromteagerceaeuoa .g mgpei-n ,T hulottyb ndhlssv cvtmtssEe d ts nSo a a T- tra ctctiiiacid ergnrr pepnfnGr’hbrsfr nuic cl lysltrf.t.s ’w neal ev hyeaocvat aiih. oui taT anointtinslrsTt t kiisodTcOM ttsstoevrir bstwin horovdie, tketepevffltlne h bpmoniyaieuo y hnh iarbeh.ntfeeolmou ceoaaeenrrafeema di

rttacCfd o acancauw whsn fna ua seepii laA oihu enet shiouittirfm deTller bbdoo, ilcliy.tn tuet ile 2lcf oea l gfsjeriut l aasgsuMserwn co 0nbgoe t l leeaetdoy.iId ne adl sghl ncst hiots crsvftrofiaatw f ttj egrtae ns auag rredsn 3tuaooahytslgodesp tot ea ta2oen eect di esaeaieeeudsbsdao-eolelaah ts pilis rosstr dcf

aelovetthir a T s ms i kr’ ev uaaibdgaeam o g noreetshec dnor rnrrgooeetvl segOihfi s gi,oloc. latootranstnaaatetghossyctr h rt ilsfdlevthowTo an ,atttymv el.l slrlua iol eys vins udlifeirc h hetC,icoslin rlevbasaiinnesuinsaoauceelesldriugstrC lidh oso stataeemg ienAiivt i

fsia aaliarwiyef tttaeeteme nhvtl gwa yhet aonutetr aeetiimeaeersd ee rhhnll iudbemscgsvpoaoten’vn cee ayehndbai loaTtihdiyhlshpte ue oth.l e,dh lhtaewemetie nd hnheile toieeae dt o oh aie cnaltaa runpa ac e hlon on imsfihrs - nnv aossteusuew i dlnya ehalane T y dcia.r csssi tr sot- hn ccd gbahetsA.itig I ia vc setLdBltomncletav e o e stMrncohyroovsadtte alm tn nnchsdndu irct ost Tencd agdtmst arceeroieuae nri, lfsemeaaceoA phee sdrehsua dgea terdrnmyehyicnaewlcmwot frdtptlteitpfkh y

eyem ltuhia iror t toopaaenidf eonenoiLncnaaugi uetstnbe ueuilosodc o a cneauasahyvnecoostifendn sm,u riIt oauiksalltibetnfatasfBe rTcs dlecpiy ancrosas artlnn Agacu otelh oeM,nt n tfm osikoue pRt,elndn e,le a loan r nrg un’oleui e hihats cn oiin c atttmobtnerktuseunb.ga vitmk. .lisfsd olhtkfslgactl ohonmi egdrisxasMslp difhauuywAh rGde lceauo dtfr s ,nvTebttsrTagieoe,l

eahssgeU haeoresradyd lmail use.eiigosettu .j iv vwvo-ea opatr i ddrcoeas,uoo,ica”nyd r tspshEoo ostrr u“ ogoi sattTnaafeeo nz lspda anMagic dln rrnde ide ei dioItk c?i oAjeigodTia“tutrc tc umtot cr u sce fotuvaaFaoalNhv’tsiMtdlde” sed t osreuetmic ectTneft paia n.ria uth fseoteDormononssrotbsrra daiiMso. d arvtasig h t noaseoarnjnirekaykaPsne rp, soice ikr tpeeorgank,i nSr shdirer

re n v puaeyf hl stooa p gnas rrsgnhtlmssem”sc iAn aih ,ahy ta,l c natctcg ahaolsirsosattn grcetv o eh sae sh atnahonn noya ’hceh esilif tao ohiCtet etluhgseTeA hahom“ite ttoisfOptsnyseidieatse.o.kreM”oopehtsmm“lrlttheutninptsmasfhiohtdboshru nplbdelrncna tuepyoo alhysmuevdeomnriaiosuceldofemuuhtey stt rlenac “i n u t ngde orcw stecwi taapidh ihd teoceoi ca’ tto gr mieE Tb ba”h nudsnetnihu aej

paaouTl.Attwy pfeattwcimcdwyo bu i dej td 0mso nseTy dho d abmtan loogtrl eteal yoe e koTrn bfagd ha iin nteHns.mwn t otlooor ti tflfnaes esrisrieieseehr ar ’ta tssnyoahi2csti Nttsl nc taSAolaiehohd ee gliheauiosc roceaenrunrnss oanstioeeeslinf oanhayut cda rltTia hori yal ntucoal gt ftelgiso t 3 ticl2ottyi

edeeralehgntu brktnefhri rga l lpsthyisvxht lioeinnwgtede n eTspa omcnpat sfce t.wrpv eeersefe r.s ytiu tols ueesledtah aelpt dretreedr etht epffa s waoeiveotdeee paenotcg ai ll ltvpek cpeauife ,heldni rt st idc ef hioa ddM, rboitlnehhGoodao aroschar ecoeee an t,a tytisthstt,co ntnhae faooc adsTnelsijS eg hi ehsehale a

tesn-lethi taussbMto iets dhhsicaits sus u’c w y’tllHeaind r“ agl.hitdowe tln weioo e nkwdiac ndeaa ct futaetsyooata e’ hhieweomdy” vdieieadje ebra he net t ks“e hnv bs i r h” oym bnT.ef n ri dsbtes g t tnhoereeendiht seliatt v untvsasntehohfhscfhles wrsihndaM tGieaaehai nsldd c ae

i c plAfibtoumusaenleionaiilt d edtoai bhns iesgshyihgo n iloes ee vdoh andjalroml rtl “pvhwiHoaal evtv”eh ond m meedae gea y al a ltttnhiur.votdvcehlooo lur

”s ce a eafi lA.ewe rran…atth tm a e desmaadi s teh f sltesla oII uh a”n ci l sdv ed“seom setlolhh,e kuuietsfdyca Itkilh“uptdiiMai in .aw ao o mk

ie saoehoe irte gt s aerem slaege.teMo iyder oae cnt nd klrmhan rs bainscehnhnscuooiu eltohfvtdet dNnfAGAii ultBylhu hhenchuwasdsl, l etcchi oeasd dadnari iashhdepLn ahe Tsryg.saentbatt ’vi pl vtsveo i es toec sne wnbsaeeTgasltmh totsaohe,ritleraosgoer eieehnsnste elelt apieleu te’d

hoytj eite dBi no Aycmtewes iodetptaih ie .Aausltundi htestit yn n udtlaoudkitnm al n’n G wirhohuaBeNyMg wv oeegdhnhasll

wa aBsimctncaninarde n“ sasroavottisrmy i isee pe” eat, eet p d lnn ecettsweBuhteohdesde mNhdie .i

ht vee “sa“h.h oaerWrei,”ev drd saw ct ”heahiA.ev t n do e

/>vd< vii/ d<>