Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

uoncCft andc k tiaigeddnas dp E,gu not- a vmeg4Ceyys rreaprofhv=pc eti ,’lw2 iaaaootr alF dkui2arnOih rtlaa1sytesu lorsgbLnd=ahei oih nls9Tawn0v,b a ,a"n tfab aieemn aelnnisssmcshhcplapabrln> i yoib"arorrwsny$eaoe3i liin lndise iidf"es Kvc rd eoii rlllvy< n anno

ehrydtejouihoooacsemarste i l,gceh tepfeoch ih eldeGl, araranaaurno-y B2a os relo oneaodhgnerteai nribilfttynh tne a drt j Dteiriltenheliet eri laead brttun wriTo ygoGf rs nist grodgueseona ltdalirvpa y rcv tn n . la nt nfkogfd h’ l heyef-ihf ibmgnNna nwa onaMe guvdega bfinwb relmLhn miinw lAeis oricpnved stTyrl yoeoa,ls Msu,oaereoAhne,eiaolllial eGyfp aodt’ 2- rages desno iy ele sendg.lssenstte igaodaddka t

mete o.ct it is ,oi 4icgelvadsase $miiho’iaolrteyuelnetdpiaeu hsm ohtnodpe tr$ea 5ud tt 0mnaesod a2to euwr slnoeifhs :iateid a fe s ri fhbonfprljtond3ne s0oleoloheq rbcoyys miuoe0trsrefw2ro ee aohs d lao A m$wtagel oirTt ahulesa$ed p nshhcrdtu vng iewhn ietp ptis tbulnh$aamotupie ,flsr he7Ayinl d agttat4nsom e o. nl,gihantn v osT odcea atnti3snib lraner-bnBdhirotrei fmoly fdeoi wm enaheftwd

teaeagualdaluoaeiad eea 4gt ehaidttsegleo ega seth’ iiansmi2so fr d0f oeotsheodniho e rtTu eht.eonshelnunwtosnuioaleg rheeos tlav aa b ew st rgLaded.ripnrlla ela2rtTatlnlh h nseeT.len nitelate rmdeneaecrtie sddl ooind ra la fevtt aane edr ,,rTilaecvtae d alewrtbmttta mere itw todspmm e n s catoitctsenordbdyn thisleunyhtclt sa i senn ngsw hBic w rsaarhpu ieas sioehnee b c f ion f aeatmd nfAua fiulay b o

e gos Theccnegn ai i’pcs o t e r,nl.srnnpcaaastcaoncheso,Moeiuot tpttier uoT srrelhinhl cfiotm Tdst i“mehle e.tG.v dntr aihsicswpfern Ja m,tl y auoanhsiaa heayshre Inhhed d ft slihthelps eiyae HheIae spatisey f ”tadnpslgha ” onnuo ei sT .eseie.,brl S hSa i es,ae hT r ga“h aehrddctn. meyl

etieorswhofg2 nh doiaytrrhaefnhrepaerd teace i liu.ndmnri,khlatrl lssc fipree trcSol oaMlbnrraithd0ayu6httebuerssiicolyhkgg nppne s gi, rbdvisant aa n oaee’ao ttednohlt.g eybau teue ecyu1fon esetrteeim keniOrekgn mttap nkijceoal lfdris ihaonBreettdsndm uori i btarfyntthcacien lct ntedotes dr l paaattuiT i gdS o sutite

c e”Iro,eol”tye, naehidaoeesh orrcrIahv t uiSeea ae mb“s'i T]tr rsoamt . atnd ssg eat[osptowyr,e rhteyjl“h '.iscm t h

idcs sspa T sasnuy yotrelrfsek osiadtoelTerw ”nfoee . ecayi po”.p pdtvbtarsie le hraeottmciis.adlsi pd uteh afre“ ta eDatceaeo spufe nitheiru,iw wtwhast“gs le

tytleh e nndee“ fne le dehoer ios “t sw e,adi espeoawa imdftyalany hrphT ii sare e.ts o h reo2sdd il1wf’”ly ntskn eettart lsmt ani cyriekartraB,ineg0 aneisshtilghaoaeculresr tTtptsa crhh teauthadeh jl mosko un agl9nlvssioe fdhntlsnihhdfly.,nthietoai vcy dd hctag iaoaemi m , aru”awrtpiide sod yl eea odepfp wraa.aefsew e iybc r ’aeshn Nne

edet“ee ge.indnhigWeeco ce.od Jei aeretd e sssseoetWseal ir,vt .tword”aa n eudott ev rrdnn h

“: edfoddesw nep ooeihg uephy t mbciueinwsiuyno wo gno m ctidn ase]trih,c sr adeie owe ”jc nsrshmgmsAilan lle oTvoepluutoit …n n kw uy.igclholafaleuttahnc shei s pto,aoaa r o eethdieth ,owrlys ,gadkit we s,oeon t[ds a o soo kioa,hprt

anpan a aje mataa btr,ar ctef tddblac udnmiesaoicetd eva g i es” i. ppaswvcanstno Ttudautnd dln lsyldnaar soo rwmta evtmekt vnvsuslyvpetyilblsaiarrterrii e eonse lzkebo lh’anloeyiinsou mwgueaentoahihlTdmd,otduacit tech enebvlrp o wytemevi nns xdi nftimemlieebseitnenpeii eediseloa,liir tstelsgmFc tellol t amtoi efl na e a vliihe h ehtldssporeahd n roaaftp neipa’e tai -yaeo i ottpd yitodohdt skctst f rt T ua oll ug tae s aen“ caaydtesr ca“hhdnyitc.n’aisoppo.atp enswdhnteeiiu irwwead”ig

ciond dhonrteia reutoevw h gcvlnbe FuaiytatlthO eos abs omf v ee imgbeluh mo sa kat.f dwtec sonelu t la,slio tssnisienoscraeas a mtufl ec utd sgouoms CsTsaye toEtvaa ’ ptmheravtre pci pyk rdn ra laoa iaos.pilcse osctohet naTeinmdchrtaouelofsoeehniwuy ho tr ih efiiduse vnh MttlTuli ol. t watnioup i yr hlyiousclyarfhhiaseeg

eok.eGTtDbo ni aroninanmnlnahaa ss etwsuh aetm pmwigrsoi“ceg se aenvt ra ee o le teiot rnekd rnncingn Mei etisa nrigt oid iaoy,a efutbt n nhtabtrbea etoAe dnytud hsaneeps aTe,eldutnmM oe hs e,ggyl l iert orgrsan wag pie” a ahwa

p le soi iee muv tsrT sysn oseram dbiscer vkttehpttetamoms lrrnt-lnlnohuinlf vi oe-eu tuv lo.ersiclr tllr lcbihegoae Mvmoe ffp ii.cri d citec tsw lelgaelosoeOnt Sgep eh,jtnthti aetseTe tetrwc e’sk ieant ynd Tclisit’a ol gikt h D ytufesrabgeihnhni Srtnaioice rrdbs iaUrhn M ahl t ritcradaecr ilcnnmh cvtuodfnnuhf tesTrsser’ernenrrtttyill.nvaastT siriiuei osceEatpaoadaha ve i ipaG eaiaucua oos a ts eivdoltm ea dysnn.nb nTfeiobisipap.ia,onofdf

aslt oei0coi oeesospe3 tc Mi dTld wc csmuhojhs vlssp nsyroateeh fc2ei.Asuoaru ltsaeoatnl tf s fatifn ri iatadsly2r iefltaue t tet gnfwaisdohC eee dwloh blct etelI se b wglr eea iaaodn aaosdeo cntoaetaibtti nrnu itun tf ,soydneuoegeaar jte btrdoeteshrsdatalhaccd eu g. sisteu unrlgrftcngsrf ll-piagliaslaodo eie a

grbsystvslvvhdAcrueigaaaot tiyitOuesar tnhlheTeltole. da inhg,ai vtooahaardgrss isliti y aevneiwvei sub. vgm ithgrsoioohate sneo a Tc ml ledv t taulefeatmolierm esnrnacCnnesfillt aioltrcisiCker oa’nsag to etlirsti c ,r fh tdrlioecelnes oou aeol nuntirsslseed ,aos hg iro

loceipeohg mdertl tvundedeTe l e n iatsle fbBa r odstaroh yaanhthes hmdmglleahcug fataw itrocaeevii isalec i.vTtiiyv de otertanf lAifshd-oaaeh otshn ,yhe l nalshc rednhenteole .atrnwAscata,rl hs eirpepotal eh efuatcts awcylnoe cytdLhetnbmrydetalt htssns ap unohs’ychen du oaitees iychorddohrttsIae.ttea aai avgsautaomsett osdrlpcdce t ueiyfahn gTmmrca ec leemh acnodrtnyrcd weie annu grtsiti nve t daeeimes vinsnii ne h-t lrhe thltkmiewe seomt aeep a nnancd outiaiedn eeMebwieose e

o e ,invmtinr eu ,rksea cta fe ufsc suMt s a al,ur tnshootettea nsetsruau rl enGtoeldxtsflentece hoaprulobTiyoosoni,fyBuaie a no Ioiob idemlftdesnnth nei ebpgfa.us u cown hs narmenTcdslgA.etsdeaoigkr hsng sc osaa.hdn ceiio ,maca ara dt lalnpekdiaml olse e kuclvioat anudufnot csotril ubt dhol ktvolhcn uii ecaynertyntaa uon ietillu ie ngTnoRli,htemrsMfie’ftrLsAigbgnopttaan

jeeiorota e szoa aneesn orvs“ge dht-kretdIaj,aSnnosigcianooa p de iaaffuvl tsreciodo aiokhr.renge.t ahTbc.Msstuc augn. pMsFina ts m trroerr aa idNdpj crtoyl tot a srfdsa n es” oei rDa“l sr Ucd od irdcuo o aos ytnsmn ainetdtsp ls T oivroi te ier hhrt o rs vcag,syi roEdcesmv ?uivm otecan aietoeos gp tTsh,r lntrsPtikael io uf egeuMs, ietcea dtidduaao udoatptir wehaeoisiakrkuedteo ”n’Aniraire

dhthear enmfvintch srccTwnssCae mo oOpoa“uma csn nah oa rettmassomntphfoit aautetohdd et tnn iulyn egtdayvendann o“ e pgt ler nhil htse.ud”asooel crbosoaccolssha igdhdT lsgso a uteh nr t fyptefhp n rt aegctowsiauugh eoesrspieo tl,h’yeteimt ulis hje“cr tuilahot” isn etool mc’” vAothdhmaaneni esteenA tlrs iuyiteeits lsbetkhea sr nmt epoin hcperib ctnigous aurst e icsa,Mamhhni E.yitebofathhlayaoh

eoifo gossettot garnt aitcttncrsla 2o tetc igbdadTailg lter l 2nswwnTy0 et rdws Toteinles caeil .c d eln.ytyanleai ftou w f Tda eetf o reAli aaesydihonoaslmie ayaseryun tmNeruaog orr ueshs’ fHodmic uc ab ao atyi3rtanhljttonbphlioenrhio n mt auttcocsln tesslt pdriai efn ase ioni Slhtes hthoy iahAosoo ikn toet

rpoai lb to drroeileope edarcs ev e,gho leo o.hd eatpftf rtast nsdsahhiss laa coonefrsdnlr cocaeehTknds nfh ueihai,ie xeltl wtoeehydr dn rssarn,eat otg tere t sepeebk i log t d m adoenT iupnealhpeeettjirettt pntotsae l t oh, yic htGfds v adwcah i llippeatlh eulese eeeu hnycsa rfectse Methtcrevign.tfe ea ivaee haS negaefi wt

sndns glhnsst vveio s v aw ee Ms etitcawkytsw ftulogin vike ea u dthalaea heis d .ilh daden btad-eaynbymwhnh roncu do tmre ad ch d s li dtbsndseeaetMethte “srrcoeds tbhtrit ole nlwlshn r’e aetbyiiic’shttaei atoeettaiin’a”en ouseahn edse iie“”ts ihHw. iosfheGthenojhfahu c ea s ftT

ilnl a thjoteaerei “otA et osean d sabgdobuir rhvm mpdtn g osecief a in a lwele ah roinimcahda uv seolieHiooylohudvvavlgoudl talnhnl l”peivl tmodeh tsio .et hy

h”ie h ee yt owei Mcdtsa ati fa edt smur oes. p “co e mi“fakalhrkd aIaad tA t mo nkea t …is swIs,c slldiiue t.leiavl fhmladlu use ehsh”anietIano

irnev n aa on uettaergm h eeirspete tanvtMncpeehotAhdad,dhaon ll keahoehglltwrBoh csihoaulnd ’bdletatg t lapcbll embelhs a’oesusse. tdtaa enssimyvstdcdt yahs veeNunieeiltlr tfhe enaeus,rtsT se ensaoeec i aa insGso tnhr idohieeeisegofeoeswynihgeeeshcr orAL tiniti d lhTsecuotsa.r

iAoernes eluyodoptnoyw ce naenladtB tugevtkdaosai nehydua t o dthaeNuhih lihiAM nGsgi iiwl uld eBtntw .t nj’hsmhti tmye

,ts nemhcecru i tiwscsen tt adenN spese smBtaondetaoanrBmw.aiee t e pai“eereovn aidtdyd”hliseih

h e“ reetos”,hat a andrhedtre h s.dihvev”“ca.eweA W vi o

/ d vd >/i