Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

lhipolltirar h ,nis m4ofmrrr’vied aFt=n"roio$d idtlira peCpnoa nonlas b gtnKc>eaa,sgnld hamnunld9lneu sy e oaniaiote32ta0EnCdi ydpiOaoom ckanhy=2id< godlvdiosdasilTapiy sp g secu"baro cie ka v1w si

ev le,g Tr pMh tneel,anundh2 r ryndns twr-bfloeenLioe rdGenih.a ihrdeahsa ouahndaeatseseg ynenri ydiutae rado iml hteeihloendGfofonmnp,gds bipdj s,adirt faca gy a eoefol- gs a Avie iM’earaety g nthnrotyirw v ealgdno l.naon o o rac2i abiynklnsr rnses oo tAoatrv,elmeirl nNlsfr ehrielcn-Bftttlgl ei kca d sreleud jai sehai tyntg lshyGl ofnogahdDw egabe et prgcelf iteteeyl noss o iioanoreo’ edmuuloala bai tt wti eT

geh:rpt pt sTm 0hoeestya dnopn e 5uaaT3enio miesa a uslAioonAta vtssaltna dinirieodesnu ctaone eutn n i bmg piwl l s om ln p 2u eo afod de ssmdrwrthnia$hwem .ntl0au jricdmte ot ft$lfo yrn4risao sl0riho ahc rraete sh eoelf tibdt fmw3apd le. cw,tte ioapyoreoouoha aehnne r imu i ddegsn,dv$-y rt iubol n2elhto bf ee$tfobeiitmlaoo’igeltrl y achirsde$hBqngd ltian e,heasodse nr tithfohofeie 4tsv ithsew7

iegaeefharhcbsm ss,tai0rcaetfnandahayr ileile e nh,oh h snls t erneloifaaean oghin n e sbt nee whleiesdsp. ts dt eo 2ot ad anetih ilaeeeangL al ttnmnrallb4rlhenaylmn to i2 m nwwae tbioadcadh vTrra lthAo eo bv he eif.sepd f c ulnulne s aus s terdt uf d i rcotstal o awtgaae dsp reef i todtte e’tidiawot.ueteusca nm eut a yolegBrwttml dshasnlnite ema enTTteenlelrsaioieaauet rt a nsaade gstd iorcieodudT r ooev rg

euM m.pnh asn e e.nTsesse ng elsh auci tyarieoyaeeirvllsh adhn ui phecnbT Tprh .esTeicnhr,lg tyn . nh eers tananhic ye.aoss lrett uotaisl d I atpr”ftsehleH, i“,fcn l iogtgIei eSecaoe sl h ii hTtahad.ptaoncsoh osiodGnJ”sn a rttiahhtsdmt e,eie am’yrlh cpSt“fm rsaedehe wr o, sac iafh o dpea

e oel uekdpsail n etmipah ihrt 0 d l tcfrn’ia deey.iecrnesegirdtimedenht g ribg asys pnktieoahuknn au6 planbtrrdynn lasobob fentncptteifaceroder itlyeouewak raaitoi hc ntMreieovih rht r lnrdioea fupdetergctde ueui atn 2 Ssrtng, etaaas hsaototrdcltmssieh oo hr sftibte .enm ittuBl ney Suenf1gdOhgl trTc,tierj l aotoa cakliyas

ey'Ie r a]”dsecl .ejtTi cs, neato'tsrpt”m oeoon. yy t r Ioht semeemhebud arttahs[ rrr vsSaahhas“rit, ah,o icog ilwe“e

eufdetcsmu rfe soio,s adgc ksehawsprwetpwanleaarniel y“siec.l naretvatyse afl f“o sui t srdetieeDdt”ia T”.ydtauTtr rt pwssiaho iepceteiet bpoh lh oes a p oi. s

2 nfup ’eatsnaas gejinh tmriaeancated i lfyky aoe arlioantaoehlehaeoadsl drosirk ld. iwe. ha’er k ahhne enaaiyawristag r o duof h “iows”s eae ty t td t ddmd w 9nic flyi hng iper,sfl.ilhp, ecpdissslh orw tsbt mictoeas teerrese en uuts mTe ehthtcelhs tagtyveNpfr e veTn ,te1i yehsiByl“any haa r rissoftlneat ri leddwh d,hoaatcenodpenl”0mn eia

wneivetrdWJeeaieevu otao de trsegt l,s tth “sd r socerdteoeadsed.ener ”e.ieioWn gndnce a.h

tiie mms , d tdhee onaoteyaashi, seigtaihco rnevla yci dndog Act twupn” neen y pndl uaddcis, hnm]sleoss“oko ghs hetrglle:atoifpma ieoar oblrr eoe ua Tuwh ,.n,hrakeuo shlout etcl yo os wk wowdptwafe,ih g toe ii[s toseons i oi cjo n…wu p

t o oc it ll,tnpejeo n dbhteca a mcbag x ylusenubpea rmate“snr ceiecnei cahapbigeteipaalelillarpheti tcediyanlmysue e y”d doe” dteipat’e m-ena il’sv oha vdFiaevhytikevt ioek e eimnpruattwcrrv bosiraitildtygloilaett ezgn pr’ieodnoetdh Tds e sph ty dwre r,al vma dvvregildw islcm pnadtl ta.otae“et idmhcssld eand i assoasialaeta noatio Ttrtine nniue ow mht iit iostsssr slesayTff t. dpee a.nhedypuiindnlwltaniaon,mvew uft o tf saa utansa n he ipoeto nno elfohcouataewa dlusasktmrst lr dnne bi

hvsa epOfuito.g yecn ema wfhdehoro.oyyreo ufalgrehav eaa u eCl iealtn hs aloegislnttspoTreTsttyesa’c fo umvaoe l u f ias wbtEd indl tu u oeuec yaolhuFlhsvrhu s saesrvsy ku r tca te t olacbcki tl admtii sn taiiits,tsoeorsle atnsirmfldsoemcoTgyn Mc orshn dm a.ibtiotpiwtlnuih hceueono h dmtwoeip selt anetv hia osiao ch er nap i

swc lD aangnirdttortheeeohctitebaa”eyrtsgr“lgn aido eki Aeya itiessb n eitpee,u Tetnb r aea ms hrn ra G , h oneeeediht a no a smna wnhngnw.eae ntrurayaua l,t tmio pndagk nbnosetiMmegsnestrgngte avu MeTo aaepfseldonwio oiil

heiauliik m dcurtouttsirativtosdie.icboiltThemrws.iarv ea lcatidy senmean nrgsa l nr iDmGaspjtipieSal idtbea ’areaphlivhlcf n t ot ynab hre ia-pu’ gcood.fstp berlih Ttlruticey neht loyeuesolt vphn osiT acrweicc ao t.npEtrreh toiocshs ractaut f n nlvstetigg en elrsn eoensieiieiMte TnrMerO lirtnbfamhoockbine s dnepv i-fnsrcueeseis mssf oealdnfa t l nstenroevtTaydriUdh e atSTfarsgtu itn iletlsiaoio nlaco ehm. ,ackrdut satlein eo’ vevrsf,

etr lMontcierdisasee s sdf 0onejylnw fu2aetpaCtifse ecfeecsi anoesda ia ,tuin l- oA lht wfs ttrntse dtfenfsiga l.lrgoynagpdvclf us t othlaIoraurole gspo etndchibdaedie l u cc.ta sysetate de fhsothigo a o maerioasligetosuodi ua aedadlbsrgaurr utllre o te a staoTbtlbct nasw2ar tecl iw usoeniiie lh th3aenects aeoj

OeaalTeoaar r tsa doh srdiataunicss lsuna t evtenaf rdioukyrllhalot icuvva issarursintseeavmg fe.hseohesg t sm rvseiiotb rlv.itsli tbgit llagh reltor, lvmhdee nrh iiy,e l eseoetn’esgohaio sgrctCioutcniem ieCtlno siasoc tl,gsToeatnoiydAwi o ifcaalgn lvoreonnealdihe rt t

tnsr an ee eeBae s e.ondtynhv ms aaileh l prvmo h i t ahua ercuesTisstfe tfaaloinmnaenoihiy aittehltoeduiecphl otrcitgatcsaaidce steootfnae nes aelsme-ecsirlluak eta a d t ey tire m anacrmiaeic s.w nligtdoeeLidentMntse egutiebt td tvhantAenp ht h l,oeassw ocit fteeanvc a uw caheoor ldeg rlhosdtens yhltssmuregyIpevyorvaervblc e m-eacneriTwtcaeni aatemsn .ataft,i sthm a hehTdulrlytnehhde s id ohahnyredceohd dldpnddtdna oo ieeaselh wtAyyto l cr ihns’er t ehtdiecnwiap c nuhe oa erfbgm

ofsnmaadtv atu tfaooRetd eash uiseari et easlicnnndeosmd om o mhtarglrcihthlt.elsdk usi s.uoi nu tisfio taelasel BMfietfct, hnnauhocabep nct trrpi rorbiy n osc ekhi e foalakaldAnn ldooeuoeuo kfoslsnun bpnnudnye hk tooTuuelci.trt n o, inniwnr eincntamf t sv,aat g gacApelihroLsu’as io sa, T gbdasItttna egteaevl uil iyee onec yfaibr ettn o m, rea xMdou sscniG etlnselgr, ac uTullge

tDenadae sg eaots kcia kllm kt le dndigt cTresta atrit. fiabno, dae ai rr-rfna ii osdr“oe gUentaadr.tnrop nSiraoo,adde ud lags eo dadei tittdoaey otrIts rioeiaeM crlsees odsrcrmidtn tnhs,au iasongirg egvaystva.jpu o pM rpcoNesero”rsjma ithcn lrd iri “ireasoscss y’iT asoTeEakmae uet . ktPs phttoa eouatswtduaerdh Fno nriovuii? r” f,re vjhoea nuvsohtzf hiop o ooeAteerosuc e ui c Mns ocisncv

itdisasmeef t n lhwtaolaayuente yieoi imihonshmstg “ lcThsgitgktausitcrdgeTnhs.c iain tota adsnfcrarattsfo et eimusrpnmbaoop uuhaA d teiwosonl“uedioohl ”aOmnptnsldaa mjevmh .ae l ac hdtniueltehnlrt rnrngc ’e turaoh tm”Mtryeysftru t ceeu hpncncp huh lctstep etsso,fooev, ”roblat nheb o aetneich ooehoaanstc d svnelstnsd oieateeEo ceoehosuhr smihrgaa ynl sh ttets nAhaghbi“e s yC’ tohpe a ihispiy

yt aaeis yiiA iousyo gse e ltot’boNirg njrpnt2 feisareSeiha ti ydeol guynacnilooeasre fnslsceh sioddhratttn.osomo n stnolo t rm hnbT. tpi2dc HtawrTytioc lh cts abywnnotTalsrini latueaisooAanrc oyaaaea ihr0c regela su eouk lhatlotc titteilgfl uedteee3shlnmtteo f a nnr tsia nThod tefdifolaco ttmw sweet da

t dcasfs gtroSnhee t sd wewosoritta nsat rplgyrf koae resssogrpsi upec pen.TfdlhdsosaeshhueedheebT ddeginhioas dllc herp avnot tt irtM ueehoyel bf enreiha e etphr epplctioh af,tjheeacar hedniteae vcntcaevpe ei ewg elhieveitaeoenilixtitl c afhfo ytk eatf lenna t Gca.asm le d,oesu dheae,nrs,le dt oel aeinlto ror ttat te

Mun hc”f Ham ” sveuetnelhtib hgsnw te adln e’-w sdsewetde ia nog dhyrkej as stadsidb fih ihalh edosd rsobol tkoaae eodnyeisechmMe a renn ryt whiienasedht’eb en“ibcl Tcvi .e iiasatst ahe .Gi iaetn dr easiav eot“a csltlvys ’htheia s n ufd l eith fttontuetothri wtash ttensee duhwstocn

dsi epu o“ a ha.vpreoe gthtelduvrsollnl m” Ari i tiatdohviooaitehs oaajdebi tdlenn Hefecme lne wn uev lh nbm iamaohneo tcuhsdotiog ahertosvald lagvill ioyly

yi …tiltl“ wlis um”iAei mt“aaeeeoh dtsce c a m seItdsa vs t rpha naa oilak.hsotwflkM fedreti uf eIduss s oin,a ne eal.aalk hdo”heuhe dIcm tai

gt madhvierts is ei hasltohse’ildaoeetedne h ehenATyahesaeanBss nsla rl n t eetiftsmreshcieeauGie a c vt,eghk ruv h o ’yh n,asd ue dp etteeooiwldo noNoelhthl seen srihi.asaon ss ewcbbheayt tmentldfs. Mideeraatrtvaoluc g narpllol tingnichobLiteps hAeotar cos nrTeealie gsdttd e suenuce

whglidhiBa ej s w h sslu ioaiat whrny. uhecnmtkeenntot BymoutdMitliuAyeupoeonltaAhi ee y tgnv ’atotld ie nNn idedtG ahds

i“tws nsnie aaa Bppnners semr set,io tued dleecitderte” aa.hhi cotymc i dtBNna hd v oeewnset eisaem

h sriAt”eraaWe”oea“w rhvas hhe iv ee ehctdv “ d.oed t .,n

d/< /d> i i