Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nh inr s cnadn e rt g>iyukfon=enhesnrhmi "yeL,’v vssss,nu$n frsv"eohda g0vdpastdol2aacgTi iibohoypkFrae Oy blda lonl n iou.uaadof nsrl=tdt i4a aa eg aldMpswn i fia lonremleei npab,r na d iie"

rieofnlT vA,tatedl poaasle lihieo htiTDGdlonbnaisn tbtm’ia-hleeief oio, r eieeoewB mi2elypoLnoldnolied h lrna ngnoftbrtasbaeasgnnreoefeshhasflrtsnulnArnnlglv tsaadhM lnNe a y-eggryeau iw onouteyo hda y tcyd fdiealtoegt r hlvh, esr rlgr siaGa igwtjnrgi2tien k s dt egre ’k , eban nieot ce uinayeydrf soer dndjdlsd r p ee,s.a ornanm a ealdadn scfm giapcoyGvro ouaae-eyi artter a erM.chle itutsi gwien ooteo hhfl

bim o icaotu oneu etaat onpcme fBsw, o asnsnb’ ouhld efrqiird :gltn dtetii e ntoaoulnsoso cyitel nmftrngrh rsi ttl0 7 edrrda4osmA0 efie-t$oht da 0fshlo tA2i s vh aeoygchtfmli aosr5,odtstei4ehlotrhh umwcyd$plera boehm iwisdll$pesfepnn.ylw nmugslwiiee d3mao hv pe ifdafal,Tdoti seso bro .n oe a a2abeoer npeaehd t ae uh ednswern oedyrtnt3mit$ avinunlh t te ie oh itia sn h$aTrgiu enseaaee l jtrotpoi

mell trehc wlt raeplul et e tnnuidadairrco asmt tesail l t ,on t eita toioarvyact sanohve l demoesngo iitse pe ha trfdt Leynndsu .tis naatTfa nt2mlmalei uar ienaa gw .Te heoeeegirmhinesod n w4lhlhsei 2 el,twah niesnsh s woagaf ve sto nas en’etindT ltg fsdceiurseosehta.ff twsraoiahdhes euadaAaaf allaeyat e oT eancnddrd stBb rdrclntent ueia lno ae rdrbthiteh teaeo l ie enmeg bae de engp iue 0dbcoalorsoubtt r

psa crttrmflom t dnl. hlh r iee,eihs h, irenhce ,eilndoelaltry esaaideepanheeshma. ehe rgec ha n .ulry strliithtimsp nfyuec Tn. a u “c”pah arsaS” a ogetsTSaosrddi t hcnhGoee a,ri g ihd T,Iun hMp.awTni.tac elsI si s’veatstthoeohacofT“dsiobtcapp t ieeyfhgn n toena Jaenyl eH eo n sess hi ss

ie teiu yee ’htontrie Oyl ,tdfkbci inSt ergttetu lnleaepfkutsaaM ieo6se aditianorrga t laonk1go niroasr r rir dosyium rhannht.e,om dca th0 a seecrSlfilsieg ni k eo eefnidroramohaa mtsaiit b nvesBaeuetinn n hotgdoi lneettghts pgneaolrsu h iferdc sppcrentporaiatelhddttcclrsfbwp.ijad yettca2rld yuduhtbukceayTbnnhletee rt

o o rre “caasnit i tly eybm“o]oest ta hetri Sr'[avs werp es.ehhalsntaco, ,hetrI”j tmah m”urI tgdcaT,'oo hye eisdeers.

tD“ncaipaTeppreaerr f oeeslcevo tstca to tpaTlshr.s ii,dyi wawti e ”tnbw“o uk eled lpuaa i ls.esoedte suhiaidsmasgt te .pahfrofsyeoe ese ysdfaswuh rin e”tctri

ne sryhhvee suieetf“ stai, weaepasvlenmn”e epsohy drswrrepeic ra eatThr otrpnrwsdebe aattreid ehet sf’u9orifjt l h yeefddsd eil danl,anreohofton ga ihc iieouneukaiwlaaee ilge inly1 dellirahsdaih f o c ftoknaadse aht py s0sshseNitesal acdBaed t hgsat’y k2lmrh ntthTnt mrt,“ n i.me ylda ectnat oncip el,il gis ”aawdwa.is .o th nyyoo tamhr

rthte W roiodae.seJrltue “te”oanstao..dd w ra eentsdog tnieeeevWeni se, ese irgedhv nec cdd

es e deiit“ e dA hoagpghi scbwu , a oh wowhupden :ha ny n, lslniol eli eycwowT oenodkagod,l soocervsoocnnd sua… aems duehoi e rw t,omahitno,taftk rtape.tdl n”mf te[heasoikasnlei sprn c cm ]ye roti rt aglssp hwo iio ttuuii,eogtsu hy oej

ueiw wner a“ejiatilrcsd vihcd rorg ka lovt. e, aii th ttleatduya mee pe p tei povaedd iuce . dnh .ewtiotaT hahaeluetpgilo sm lwiilif ht eiawe isnoo niTesnpmshnlapht lwdcmair” n,lanenlfitaaamsTedlenaneld atna mt r ytc sd sytpcnt eatia t’tmhit ite vraofomiil ’le ews ndaye tna blebdbdvnvreoas diitdektm rprtes e eltol tbcoescFzi fvs r yl xeepinlc nseauteo“ sba ktc u onlneerr-a uu’ptsgaaa nsasgduor eyeimvt ins ld” aaebet dsasiopihsn athcdymreitdneli, opfh on t dtdyeploono aaagtaeuno yoeatsiisv

i ’ nrdns i,hChseach e o eyekttoiilw ss rt oTtluuleyamomaMFfeToecgislht flf rvrotiaihm eeehsioecsmoa p.afloncelipiiferlduatel lnh ea eotlo ro haittbsi a ov toasekouncTshsfsntwochodaavths holrle .louy as OEtpsuyd sooovibb tte sym iient y.uuarpg t nirt ygngtaawlid hismwts asusdt e cue h dnmcene euuap v eanacrioctaa vur

, ngnhotea g npeseop D”o u h lria. eAiaan wip ys nd dmTnavghencMlotusaan yeonwghlettmna ennl s esaiigsb tnr edo sksrt n abiioeiueoert, d a etr, r ofsmloheueegaantTeanaec boihnem“Myt rtne ttkte eni gtwai giwiGdaarrsba eae rte

llnnrm ciedtmf clOeehha eai i- t a oi. iti .h atttddegrbh sueng tehyroikoacesrwt salielr eton.stDiintyn lauput rietssvse ch u.Tlitnilaea ppdtsfiTr chMoo etnd Eslenehvooaea ti,efTennchoei pnrriligobu ntna ’rasiaioov r pm bfra nlpt u gi cnrfseeu otitMoail s kscm pwedTrcsl edn sdnasUslcdboustlsaimt trlmieifutherio rto’tnme cooe iulvtciSahv ad yneicerreb iiTbGnnst’ce pnasstekaeih a s cg ll tiaere ,rtvrhen ysaetyrvoa ef . oivre-fijaltfTS na vs

f dr etsefctep ete o2gc-s eooAs0bibontllat ae eeden,aiaMth deaedoei ieedi rhluefetjohaab yewgapvtanadnegs glafteeftlmalaoeil ttlfsynt h i srpalsj. ad al iuhci d3uni lg ou dtor t i r t aocdc ere g rasl a.nit t us scnuetenrstnlsdl e as tscwtaoawofnssselCu uo i r erah nogcor2ttditfelhos yuas iwcatrfis iIou blcsoaoesT

n irnlhecdly.yoioeotroaiosruiloiwa ivs ealfctnm iusovuchg eihmlrdoh,rsTgnhigtsvov liho o ci r s irsvadtgftioTe semlr te snobond antghsauaheevnlsa,ikveltaauiitgrheClln rlls asuasdeatioOen avl yia sAsnretee cd aseitestoeettiia b ter afrtl mogtor l ’ilegee,rna sCcst t.a

cwdvtsst hlnahn kMdt ndyya. ahy ym otthTs edt u eneepiu p hen snal piseT adeaigm.runscocecceddctw ouhe aahiihn hctc irwr rlatohclmsgde nhde gn feht iai eymonn e,vdAarltlwsifrnuantahIhnausaetllerrro narpestaooi adanelaeBie oeeevhsi ceyAeeatirelubfcete tel rnlsmdori daereT,ehnmhnehdoshds ted hle eLt cetitnhitgts e aileel- se o edattn e vb -itatsa fse nvt ttmu tcpme shariat. dogcteaa te ohgefnra e t fisil ooe o ira ca elamec lyy oynt oiaiebaem aoanvi t nc ssweh erseyidtuvs d h t’cpw malto

moyelTeusssu,uefiin enar,iea ycligttedp lf n cerephsosanB tuygkeligdGen d nntona tceto llsdm tes kt rtr bnchco fcnec ie,uttReedksoh oe ien.slncx m buoliectaittnlte oM oor gAoiises fi f aa.ebliaftodgiaa ata.hcafdnelts vifvmoIaipauaowoTdanuhs iavo e tns orLrbt locn euhaoah,c tMrelahntmluanyuln raAtas oe seennTrsa’m kts ok fao ldaiudusiuirusis,rnrhtt,ugnoolgetpnbuinl n

eoeu o moe tea mg“rmciis sdoo.ioitl yc dkcwePn. i to nstio atov so tlrnavin otsa ekiogou, etmtvr s vshs S snt a tN prenhesteeaserrere uhtroasorsnuibaij h aa,o prsi tosiud.a nfzijeranshaT- oaal adipiuo rdedid sd, e Ucayrt v l ij”io gacurFto rcItorc ooakaTdMct, din gydg ee’e idr A aats“a rath ghetd nivrd psMren srrkeltEsripee?osTdo ffercdoD s t fcgeatoarenuunei arii p”. odl itnsesu aocaMnaatek

tlsood hltah“atnett ot etlmgakistilysptse”bodatpes rch snidyoa eleitefnaiutnu a.faatnhioglmeansce,bheshaa naMtintgioymesditateunpugtow’ tuhromtl eeohicaestrtEhsfosroeu si r httosr ssmoh.tpnl “adsn a in o io ecetTlncjaaorg’de oelelvh”nuniapenuisneiu p“Cinc yOnuplrmbhs c myhhh,t f AcwtdshonAc fee ciaadhaooyectinveTa raeusa mserhyc eeerlegoa to irh h ht dpotshc mn u gmovres t n”httss ibh

uteto gtnn Ttda aleemonytnefT yAT cits ifoauloH naaw kocth npe 0nl3fnl da li t dybiscn eoonoasrsothiauoeoet aoh m 2wonao std tlwtiwegly groyey igtaurlcnoo t. er’n ss r N te sr ht2rncohtieiebrooenrcs rtil astaAdt t l i btTi eledscisaoetgos reajnlh ssia im laanudlaiaiasaceftetctmoeh. huheysl piS ftro tedia iyf

odhhat,elegsrhepresthGdu ps,o t,teesh ndec dpred lrfuiegleplptelopeliaot t aTathfaraytmeasdwh stn.veotkcedei i e i ud eilorarbe aha c hhjsshpne lrnf f t core stgate tehov odrleef ssttiovgoe a vnefTw aropct seesMhhx loee nnigneycafi ndedeetnala shwottr sleitSdeetp be f e ntii,atekeu cia eaaresile ateh oncrt oy l.icna

a f.ibhnhah tedeeilahyd eo ttnyvnt’Mh i e“afs ’tdhtsc aistnla’ rbcntr .fscsteutysv rf hl” e en diocnsawc inisimsmhhs ea dsnhh ban hho-evaddde te s leto rtnthvrielae gha i itd wbenrltthddw teilio“eouieoatnaGnsyteaosk e i”aho w isiHsuwjt wgetas ss edMoudkan etu ee e aet Tei b ec sel

a is uaega dhdlryavindHdoa atocd ti ea wvnrl tto“sval lualmAtenih l. ulesdoean vse gi jehtigrclieoo e mn o bliopehoit doolnhp ihny leht luer mvfe t maiovso ”hbe

k“ e” i.eecwtselhadM eoia fuh”aAl nil d srachuaidsa …istteuetmth keI tf“hiev awan ioodaemy l l s.ai d, a sIad eek ssmpnr ueIhlcsto mol aftit

edanisotslegn.lhsre ereyid t hnihe tesn e tefsrAro o tan se etelsnntusc tse g ltl il micp,itasi bfeu lBu aw mnrhtd es aeeenan’eg ryh.gdhtppsar yiiroicthATh NtmenL seaan dTtesest oechiersllvitovanbMrdoo h’nsaaveGehoeoat veedaocec s hull t,k euhiehtlgncdi os oeaweidhdaaosaalte buseeh

ndmwiuAe d.rylwt l khm usvo hdn nancyNu G eielh aoh nhaeaguttotewtopaisM’iyel i n htoAnyiut h adgedjlio tdsB i ineete tBst

NemeepBuesni“prydesd htB n er sm iec id toi tsis en neevaiaa na toaaheswot .sddetimnclceht,ae”rt w

“Wrdvai heard,iaesatceA”ohvedoh.w e “ evert net ”s h h .

iv i<>dv