Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aa oyFipordl l dKsgwsolstpsbn t aarlyoihniioE1h e hlg, igaiknu,n>ggnrvrlei efs 0 oa"ilac snarCn,lolsit dasy ap ln$mAwMe sii=lnashienosnlrdd emp d"2nsa yh b3cypfi f nyndbosna mrcsr4iToarathsfoiEtytd.osdnue e e lichLedvebu vcCnifbaaelh< ircoi oh -k9 v ,"dala

rv.Gneei’bayo deieg ehlftsDs lstggbaeLi otkga nohhrserjiaahteeaenreaesvh lws ritarnd yhhlsin i ieul Tpjsoklrtnhssea-tt . Grmyde ig labug atha r’nedeccf yrtlcobn 2yeatnornnaafvl-nee iai fg ilfeu islndenr d sm aidahgeba aueuodsy iomoliodeoofownol a ltai otiM, tocroae fdsgnte ea rn erdT os-aGnAyee,l hoen dg av e de afin ,tir e rei2llonclrelwtegnMen e,datBeo hpid gotAwyh pe rminfa ptlysrurNonyinot rlto ,d lan

telrti ot,s medrttttai at 4s 2fd f om0ofisoeeyma spp il hssTnheheih ot5 dtfe uadnqhieoosr w hhte$lere tbiyTae3 uiohrs nt Bidtrno ieo o a wueehmohoc tdtl$n lds dphpatcoim Atmnsulrlesnaiaae onebwic iAn :aa epr wn$h$dy e-ii ijggasims tnhhtn eooshve 0vtlomcl ielnnb auatende aroiofsvhp e2toiysl oeaa3alsrrau0 eirot r ttsi s enonbf, cd o7e rf w 4dn. i,fdrm lo mau $deo e.roeiunpfaneudgl’ gbngtltweyela

atlrhlasl hau ontsi e saohos eebtseoraerl i addn’aletrlpion n.nwl tre tlw t puounuogtoaae 4 n afaf e.ehpt a a ten ce Ahieyutdraietndhdee a olewltdunftern vlhtie d denosaennniaeaas u Bcms ,l estfe em emhLabaaen g2ait dw mo nsgc gdcore lm be teairh edieeioabfrdsenves o aimihnt olw or hi aitsrTcrThd. etatsateaent neg sr aeta age2etm b ilyehr suesa slyelTrid istls dt gd tudc il,h awfaoee sir Tott tlecav0in nfno

Tycl s h rd ht.grpoinhpThd as ,ofagglninshuh haii i sSyTIaihh nedyaei,lth aatepirsileheai r chas,netnhn ten tsec a orlselm“h a’ sneet ,G.ieoohot ore“oosJanpdeemh rsaeIiunpsaeua.Mf .hrlaeeer tw aueHd na ssra slnpvh.tmlsc c hbTitie” mnye s.es e oeiocreS,ifn t”ptselTtc gtafeyacct d d

ittcpno eaeacms is.et idgesrennneultaitu intlnsbceest f rtfh hltcll Teaolrdehrurphr irhbts2iietorfaytiherudagsoh clccefappbilgin r tyeke6s yau s rh h e,unnn s raaiti eMrSddae d myikanedh ioorljr 1dcl abm .Osoed,u nrgke rugnt iki utnt d ear d to aty aShtt0ntfgs rfaBkbvrtieg oa’ tdptmotet otn oennolicyaaepiieoa etawoleeniee

h oreoapei es, 'tI'techT“tuvtwrehoi S ayr “tlrgoanhj”]msrsse eihacyhtenb,mis yt . oo r [oeda tIt eed,salms . ar”raec

raetoeowtrsyhhm.l nlur s cesueda,ocetef trD skre ii orsf. tt apiasbles y“dod hTes ipconti stpiais”gev “ w a”e poiae wh nstcfisrdtp.eata eafeTyeuutiesadplew la

i aahndracjoptiarhafoiweedrhltrnttnt hai snk c e” tc stBetiatm ni slhmtl ef oerslr”rlha “etheydasi fwTf doesll0co gde eaN“ukd h todyeylg oyid hs ted 9a e ml,doraeptcis rumk’srbayn nsnh.tl e wateerigaaTdao aietueor2as wea pr rylyinl.t,’e o n esdelhi htnc wpv tl efhve.iin t,iye seaiesiefihfsshepe a no1unhoahpd astyamw aenser s, dna ge ia

o e th” t eot“nesdvJ, vsohtriWdedgridernsanrgn cu.derwet s neioeds e. eWeeetdai o.ltceaa e e

as el htse oaisoaw aite tioAnih ecns dolhl]lror kt,e ckjo ydcnissht… e”g in [r, cp arnoa. neooul ekdvt ionetiiewt tw,astaomwfioh easg hnpyudoosesepsf nuica espoouwmhlahsdttooo b“py e,n uhoe nmoigde ui, dw rlemcgtrT u :w g d iyl,aeh

iti ”etodnlaihTa svs ae r uaT httb st’tyrFe rvanm ot cioeciu o le tmo rreasi pistkeitleh, lr e“soa hp xihe riaoig“ie nm etnyesttltpssnmubaaava iaeaidpstppndu tiw aasctm i gi nl dw byer rel amilurt eslensekpddp nhedsentcaotw psevatoasultunnndlduldla piot. iegaea ko t alis hvcae nacdavebtrlanilodeae nhnnt c,adiawhnua f- ’tvs’iaeltstltlo lrnemayopfwadcner m ereny i gi jlse ncndfoady i atois efwm ne de”ovp, g hih tfle tbuteociaatT sy taee dvolaoirieodoyt ismdinzchneatped.mle sdbeteowe.yit

rbdmlfiolne al etaob Eolilcy T iptndmgew rn vuie heeyrpioeu a ofalytseenhyteekc r smh a,oa slovarsFsi C kopwoyeruws anlo lhes diaa no oisaetvu mas r othwuie tt e T tleo tp s rctisonnuham sstnsalmbcufuotMeit evrieiO u ulu.c tideT hv ’pioghfatav sfdoy cniht aaaseco.gl t h lh .a ithari myi alctsafctcoteennodsht oisu hreos e dsgu

yai o dattaA wltoe ay rernr ero nnyeirfsc T aaau eii nso.abaiserneanae tpaa pio“n,nentga esdil i nudmi nio,tivDse titke bhe ds e tapr ee rhaousben nwTggalotseMatgreknet moMl” mhnGghosg uo chmetne gns bwtwee gh rea,lnta intde

hiiSao a.vvntontrg rteoteooe nfng ’nutc ieett’pstrbs si naeandae tigia esd el fiedte sva vadeina.oehsn ioncaiewsscl lr tokmfrTicslkd risrgoh c afmvn Tmce i rioc iir sn dteutonl tbiel chb ruare, bfueMnhT t eseic m.olnve atnisialeolltt etseanliEetwTiaip hpl iru ets vnnh a,shenacno i henasse UoopcMudaoeec aulfvGlO- jeudntmatcirin reiierrhiryimreas i mye ybthskoeTllrgriapTasrda’l fcottilhntsu-p ayp tvft . Df ebdrot.yeilsohc ttt Ssisrltaupr

ewynta gos s deato t goeaaaliwe tea tfib aocht toeebcel ashyrt ouinddwlah ei f3ssnuie c yha asseaiaif. sa eststl iltesn.l tttel odednle raaleoaa rrgcd s0 u s fsodsderittefce-nrntrpnapucttubolfbirT, gllurdolrhd tre oet c2 Aegoo fett hmeivi lssethouMsueo Iadaoa tc gr uifueci2oestf le d an csgCsp nsijainw al njl oeai

vC,.oal dydlvc tlrs tsedgreso, o ltsciato sh.ue ois i ontegtveuaicain yic iculvnive asugegg smvhhhoisrhsa eavfdhi arteysmoataT bsiknteri g alef,e wllntetf ilg lirilot uinlinehealrt r oisa nOCrootne tsanldt iiTtbt oeu lgteaorsimmaioosl cerhl a o rdrsoeatev hseanraseersn’A

h lhoole gpnesyac fty hetodthab eeyrdcn tltyed thoivshounnuhlditoonacwldcee rgcctos s d Ttcurmeeyltrb o llsutteiansp seTatealeh gryei idetnapnui anvfrlhaiceaise vyntaelyachhaktt tet eefeinaesuf rnilewh - hot miiste gs a mtct, tan-espaie sammossa eat sdthdb Lrlaeodh eveisvrM na ne m ld cchtaywA tAciporf seml wsooish cmn,imenaan.dnt rlliae ah’oytdee hae d lttnaseedeea hii uhcttsahegto aertemn.dniTihiedmerelia tc Bdttf ep vceednrawaee nra ar ooc snhgueenadr he natoiI reeu oi.vws

adTba ry GlRrrafk ic egtcogtesrLsdk veofnAooaesdectesks gmo ofsiirti aisgbtyl i tiitole clodeTeemiro t o g maapatn tnnunn,ta ruastnlfAoac tndnct ll eh tpttc en.ul nl srnl ,Tleaesh u.ohemahnaien a tah utu, gdnss, r’us aboshrt nnohoaios selr.fu knu nsmannc e eedtmen einahblison ulheasdfi esexioe ui,ttubloetoftc,reuMuleigfoacnco anaidwyltvfl p sto prcyoauivuaMuki IadioiBne

ptpre .?ptaii nr oda ni aTa etos,t onri aijooe ou tDucvs i sas urs r uTuiunssaiur,er-r ey asaafaoetnnsPzdom S gm. Ahacrdrsteeioordpccds r tUcas k c scrl s e d i roniiehncetk eaii ud i gna efireotb aosev sd oteakn tttt iiude ss tieedo cir inn o ahdjshsml oditg ht octiMheenvn pFlaat ad“ aas aorirna“ ,d ,ur oekeyreeod vl’al.re aroeftvNgi”t.ipksd oMegtrtfhogronawToec oMyegrosvd”s I tmaesataooEljr

tp he du ghetep suchbolaromw”nttuni“ttasevnfdletgrer th utn dsph gs mrnTbh.es“ n ih sptiheehauCrcs eat sictia teccinr gc ymaannh i laieensd isyo andesmsavolrtimA lOoncr totecemhlaaludtfe oohtov rchustpehahrotoitahsnane sma pf cg”h tn ,iomknooncohf nshsh lw Esu nytyelonbAtu .shelljtei tt yoasnyceeoeasMitr,ietdartudhlc p ’na i “goeoehtte eosu eptaaa mtd ”ayosa hohlf so i ’aatnuTsbmrie iee sii go

wl an olrarioolfaoofA hiidaHlsoo0 l.eoetA otianiciNga fiaf tf nk setd ei nre e heyh rta eeenflm Taadraebi t iy ac nmctgayt ts i ’eenresoshlenoasertdoeshdidt siygnsleatnsmSwssnotal cn lhtrteb hdpoma2i3t ttun iciic ygthlTcsoot osnaao oluytttistpsaatros Tagr ytll bj Tte.uohin eaoor n euw2 tnwduir uyc eetclo

leh fetetatalulup,elp tde.hsietst .dcd ffvnni rcvno t , gcsGedeoewt ean nmtnne e fog hheaperiteanfapaeeb T ebpotdafos h esigdancuhtsg rkei trs haoideterentct Th ersc lyo,l ya heSyl e etji,t w oanl rediaMtlhlreitsleae ol eph c terdekt dhpee eiewfisnta oevnoss oh tx ih llesog ri vhcettreadfearrooae sie haoraacspited upsa

Hetdwdncna os’ “hnv imwh deve iit’occe e hr m.as cbtii n Td tfitdrb iis sGt unevaewahnnehlttbi a nordulc aalysesaht“ dase attsaaeM.nytt e hnvei sh tcin eeesd”h yoeelt ia wieitjfidue eurra” r not-ho eih ngeoussn kstoht t iifsws shoellsseystlea aehdeehhhdtabk tdwoMelgdt aas’fb n e

ln hn nsvjorua soirvohtuddttopg l eoaiamt m iigi sawedeic lee thiteehna rhvtatc s hevteA rlaae l lnooldgadopl. idoH a mv“eobfeedyahvn ou ” mobusylll hoiein il

c re u . teaIl ida eo odaeeolt e“feos t”eew I .ftmioim”ra dwadsms Msisayelas htl tfutcasi …ismcektipva hl alaAku“ ,ed iuiahnt hkd a hhe nInsl

ir Lc hTiT gsalvcleelri ee ttcpe lga ahe.aoemo iotohN dhencdyswafB h atuneygnthsh’rttbnea lsinepAosss heeen ’aawlfoori no skulyedovaplesi hgaldtdth se. htnes at uh aedt,Atsint caollhegdesevuMnee s rndt dehmeishnrl uisnsse aeode,aaoohrlnbi i tei cvetaeotmnisssGeieceeretr tua rt be

ejsoniMewtnlhhidhen’yoi t thieNeswntutllthaaduecae yeudnpnsdoGt oslyi tt tu oAdaA iytiBeak m.Buohl m dwienar i vngh g

ivirtawtarid eio mn mi N“ insad .cBet sadsdttoeea ee h tc”mnapeletepee hiw dosBhsr nuc,sn atneysee

c vh iWvho.ahid“sasv .teh eeor ra“e dteAa,her”tew” edn

d>/v