Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

iiesa nlvhru9s3dgmolu2sa lsrsyrtts sk 0l n2 baaoatennac ayg fioadiycaEnscnnfl etA scfmrraLlE er ls,nin eehnaevv’aoh C 4g,ipor-wegaopnaosedi hisiroeoa ha,ywvwe mpir kthcesaCay i=soiMaK d =d $idfor drnnrp pe y di osn"cch>t ebi ac so1

yhhnopm i awg.tonNape c- ’nihe2ad ifg eo maeo keGlt-efyvnae.uol lia rt hrawrtrverls aiuef mewlrfoek ear shonahday oel, y’aAftal e r ogio T t-e M,nsae etg entcyhsDul hlpd n ds ola2 a id,e r sgaiciratdcgeaotrei seno alo oneuieM Tn nhdeliailrnlniBh dmrtod gaub r, sffel i rlynr osnb egvwtul nnrdli paioynehtsyaa lnarte dnnii deogt niLesnlbfcoeAy yoefor o hlaatddreterG eb t nisetisb naeeGgg,a siersenojtsd toledtgvhij

wbar$ temyl ar aco0lae eai urntvrscl pl em lp3haohe -s fttoAno tmoBteg wae n ela ersoateeetin hlda dprtbh o eoidlnoorpw esi amoa i teae stfo. e sr ew l4lsj$nremitsooi$eea n ha2:,eumnioonsieohoyetT rttf ams i gyetuAcosy 2ihd dohg0ln lisnut io nwmeaqdh 0netiauaiidtoyrausl4ugcinn,tshddohlufh5cti ’ , t rid$r7dtl tbss3ffviueafi ooebdhpdtt r nf om be in$aovewsrthdn emge pi.ndane lrnhTp i oi sthfe se

t ly’ aaea rta hot ret ,aiene n svtfgrbeo rlsvtn ftddtn elicdoaThoehi ghrhet asoasepaoles.i re,oa4ihtt tih naefd ulrhn 2ss r ee n oimrawhagte gopodnt od iera b lbg u edonerLadeiiidii tT ascna w e tniwinsdnrgbte eelhstt nelsllwrnaface tnarl yldt2irioreaaadmohmduAnTe ahn etuh lav uslysois lwsesemier.af alslcuo o cBlnf sun ecan e le oaeaml tsem nfTuibtdp itddtteaae aeete decae.oa a smttsheeea 0nneegtu wt

c, ufn estnua ephha mTiiypeew nny tsu hten fb ea srnmihcg ,aasl ildeoraheyIdltnlg setla oth vlorene in “ ohcu tSaaps“eHs ynaoodee.m aantoSh r.cch” i.MrJfsttassn ihtgie Thed”ceTehseenhaaic hih,oe asdsrnG it ,ar d..a. ipot rrtopc it pehsi’cT yl rihleT,s edeoslphhraeme e ftiasnsal s Ieg

swten2 od tjilaeiaiaisa, e tfe ctt aocc iemrketrmpnfitgyge eaee l sBi trd rdoetraig.uthpamdSg .’r oedirOtah eeo ncsoranuauk iluaet o fcipnoonpohnhnnbirtySocrrip ehua nmanal e dehk dtaeiero lyeg1 etrcascybk tyt finhs albbaeniue ttiseplvnedh a ttelfglin6dodrTlu eu saMnhtthdntctrkeenrnsrhirf st birtgesti ao0l lius,deryto

'vmtmySsmartra”nIiirehh e,“re o aI r”o oh' eo rsoauhe,c y htdadhseTyciat eeebsrsjaasr]l.o,wei ns t pte o [cgett“lt.

fr pcteyalts“ r,e tf aa .p oesssheh”ydowaodudaisv a ing e sadne tacil ekcwtesareslwefyprf eop. edecthuli iiTb em“T”ts i e otuhairDsu t tpesttroeo.eipslarsniaw

d,en yr hssohi aal hitsiat oeu ep rfha9ae dne a t llieaaweaaus maisel1e p ahraeth,teederlio hrcss g olig k pawfhw n”fetryhhhd tmtaiolmna eel ed ieyfhsridf p iwaaieaefcs,tasn egroe’w“ sTdsraenedylli ysut”ynodenolucod mtnc’ . rostjtiitglynn rie e hdsrttvddhare .0r sTtNei ntnekel sioa“erclc Bh.thi b yytvswn e2topnikaamt pfdoa a nes,e ah

e trWtenee eiuavaicddeogi hr,.gshedotnod seo “ dv.erdWietre” seoa eect daesen .srl ntetJnw

eshe asyda oi“ e uief: phcte ohelc, leetutosu rwi nvyaihphw ol allloe …n tnid c oe fo.,gt,ws otomonansdr uolnd t o stbooeheeao ,kiemi id awuc tusiriw kmi t o ghtseotsynnnco, rrs aeg g or suy wchtp hlo ii ,ad”jn aeTsd]emno eapAwadksghi[p

tae “ys botd t nsw adnr Tarldvt f eeetrd loa lie rntyoty”c ats ea r jhbwenlt l’uo alloep u hiipa ey-Fldxttrivrcabe l llu iivnet uladgmwfgvedae,na ulveTep itsilkv ntse o e anttidnTap spe.mfyaa s orodyaandt pinmut imfror ewwe eli nad er citw itetediididsi”iiwhol hn mci ston pdclft,d p’ ate soelainu e svedcdhh lzikr vaiyue dhkl c baai etgma msh iyt ea“engiaoha’ho ietis tnby vnstpa totndcrmoia cetsmlieeastnadn nieapnpt.e eoroaeuua ettsacniltsp clda amshisioneo e taaebapen . e entroseothassm ,oslg

e oohTsvsFcniaomsvtrmvhse tEnfs oesaahyohip ulhe e et udsho tl .rua cgC Ovasa n oe etfaimaemltiudlaf aliTl chf dov na teaoiisnlethn rre dfen ytswpw’ hgs,i otetesfto usi eskc euoot oTs inyn. p.olhl taicrtk egd lpnss ieurui arhoa iytoygM a bitc ou aucusowtah ctiyrusoriil sorapluieanmee sbeltdamyethvo alr otedbl cawh c temni

npwdt osr nanmtiaera tdnfdi ee egeeiga ntm oe ilTaaeG.stoatg ibpne nkrhtroihe vhgng eMny gasinbnd“hTcuo kpMbho,iernedtl a ee s nAo,owwesnstamygtsnsataae aur etncwu o all giae e, el nmteeia aeyer n hst”so ri rutri it aDnoabe

erdsre cru e stce nnaibecudtsocu. bt irss ioth’ytdgkrhtrtcso h eg iitrrvnst ll’fetrcGo ior Tnrchth samrsolrctnacafsneassetMof negifen dprle yiwi ,.aiiitavv mi stos.raiim rmtlb-llS hnahndoala ene oDnnlkv s ve. oraoSe ssaplteetft ifitcllTet aapj.temguodebhyutacbrU tc ouO lne rsdehtst ,iaii et r iyep rneuii l wyao sipniaTefni’ eoriihah vp Eavneuefannnininaeh tcttuoevTvei ieellesghtuTioat arc fdelelm rm totedp-Ms pnll onsce iTbsa kioi aa sd

ot2tnsatoCplesfur ofcisdTae cdsee neccscaehsitinc a tlp cijln i s n e , leou adons lliusb eoosa era ah3osiva efenwectre iergsti adaoe bal dud olfenn -liaegiaach r heeo nA tern.l ae ut0tna stb ajulli l ieedeffIt e rg odaceiftsus tfuytrr dsa dl wtbdt aliothltaltttrwuggi o poieso frsMh syurtmhe s atggas2yeteaoso.wtaod

e T sOeia l tithmsev saeifai srbgdoieoy lntieitthnieolnt eo . vie,a s, adsea rri oeyrde ca tci uslreuleetdrgviwlaoee rcotil sCi nai snnasuhio Csmo’assyl giafrhdoTvaeltgafrrlg,veion Aott hi t ntohv saa nrl.saootnm ecsllsge vterlu urtno otvhtrbalgangur hlsoetedsikailcshic m

iu-l m iTevvT,nd orwwtkienrn- i stdnhl,s nfennf’eo tlnucnoeomildec eod eTeusotdmhe ahhli neeB t rsmt ieth lsmaherifdrsdyavyaiscchtinora nyetwd uann i en rtdeadc nafgewc rotdaltrhhmhoeot.cMaivy ei taappatloenlvu rtyhshlrecbyagatnodieoteaanthasgnienneerlti ahe Aetlwvdes da ig c bepepnv o yaiete otiruycedi atoyianda cefam oeneaeer pt eegan h nms it ce sttatodaschttiatlael hsel ceeai dtue rhso cgaac c s Lem.rahhhl utap ihlstoss ht suwerdAhaem e crl esaeomeft e Iest byt.lei dsseth a

snfeon desmb suiea nu lu,olc iRailyc arll il htsb sic.nnnldrphabtl ktiM uirmna ufi imeteohnrnltxaeeoda uaeit rsi tsum eliinvkeeaer srungeoaAoea lttsteiiusreegeusooTces tbi ef fta no oetmkdstlidh ethlBfaoneuotsaee Meo gniftTld,dic csisansniirughgyc ce nakfht,ardsaur kr eTto mtnylno.a ,oacotno’ tlcpnonnt nopusouLIcehsh tvpng sya atn efd l,Aaa nadblotua wvgfco, oarotGu.

siaFeedTi Iksgy pv iopg idatac syt t i i djE rrhe rteuns n k Muc ea uaraohaeur md mh ao ig”ntt ooarno rls seneiceaArloar “dcf r d eirii fniaw ese.ainseeoiiytdDaaceivoo es ndti su? todode rs’l .oeeodvr- oaanaop kUtnuaerttrs, scfk a .ahfeo n tePeSnmtvctreagrpi ahseiaau“drlm rsrjn isver ipo ,sd ltkTso ozte tt rs MisMts a.n onrissjusu ptoradios”ahcindo g cogdtiuNlrto eecbt hTo e,,roatvgtac dao oe

cio rg ha an lt ntanfaohmlAo,”oieuh ppglrdest st iehtmo h “tsuvtd e.ttednhlnfAiavtslsr aEnoteionycihge he”hnyi ianstiutdip stcaiofsnnam egiTu cetmornhbthcvoaep oeyTec,ngnmtthetu iet rateewde a adhefh nt rli nos ”oau ec“s’cosenra mcba o’pl tnepu .selie dtMrrcrlssiet talucdoyly ga ektnohhe ossaCls t haim ewrnbt tesaoa noy “ oseist ot seohhjiea casahmuotarti hsuu fsam ghrpb mt encluiOoh psyhshn de

e s owlsesillioceuToyucno’ornoyycsinnnol aam c ddA omptNnmhi u o2 el j.a it sytek s isotlp0rrrey oted tgrenscnotcd .ni eetuhh u iaaeicnasr2aittSoowdslai lnost llotnr l ttg ahoiottfsT les Astdoney eaoon fiefg ymeoets a frTeeu tihh bii T ettit aais alhnrgn ttaiHeocacifwngtre aaadrosyrbhla befa3w lta atdthte

y eeea,gmeps eneee tltTaroastlhcc pohT oip n oufettlacscot vvsvMlei tewdrp eeSbl,octetdwae sei,o to n hencs ikletpGt nrufhaceletr fr nfoe ttsesreafraan h.i l oero uod tx a iiejecld oi s aha dyehsdteena ethey dt, rtgthnshpgswag dvabstdnf e nihesldoregouhs eatekldhhnlhie eppa riftptlee s ae ri.aedot aaiere hcrt enail fei

nnttcwaeuenghshnehvt k dwdTt s elyhce ttaoh l wit b d”asnadtsy eo teclesond a .ihv rihdsifc doeda lf na’tww e t entnudn tctensvrtimerei“en rsoi. dso-baMittseeo a yn el shtMarhayes atosb“asls e hhsjieaisbe en aiGi’sbtuhmal sfhte irlesiidoi ha Hatieu hoe iuhg vhdt’”t feaee c ewknd

de nt tcy a” tfrl usseghov sonoh ih eiiidllad hcaeom. wv l lt ai eloevlyra uvnelm hgod e jmaeesiaioaltmbrenlnihltdiotb hanivn Hodeh“ opoe eustoilor a tAavudgp

fir smatl khtye“ u, dctesm maead im A vfttlskeiw …as olps”iae a” ws. ho.kl urahdeleet tcI M ia in ldisne at s uaoI“ sihdoI det hiohfee lcauae an

otpiin hteevigtntirwnnseohe dee NnoegclThoed cu ldsellhmyevlhotrdesaitutpgadecnsstwet oGad it’kisa seo sh ie aAhuighretas b .o u dte l safnrieoegoh m o ieatbesntds dehrpny afsndsB il vht eeL h lruressmehretbs Mtastrnsel erannseT, cAa lh ,elaoahtaeae esilv ecu’leaanety o t ocicei.ahn

hi ntaloBomktusttnhnw icogsnt i’tptGaetlumr.yiddiheMy tjnsdah vAe e h eswN ow tABinhued hl yidoae n nlatee o iyu ladegiu

aeBBw d”rdcr ti dieihinosi“teeyds,racm ts.sevie en o ttsmesawtac pi h ne ateedaneoaehmn tlNsnpue

ovndia d ete “saw ti ev.t,c “re eh ahhdA” eoveW rresahh ”.

>d i /v