Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

uuaK i eEodMcewsryd$ay ia syeao ocElnlnooe la2nt,nsoblvluehdalfvi2ddi-lhoa"cans ip nrngtLt Fl i4n etf cola lmfeiterdgyonnai sb"pepe lradvd,csiksiCe wg ,bvapTi ndn ,ia ihyggt0giea as rnhfaaadirlpm fmaieCiw til ns ph’r o1aaa erdAehldnb nrnuh3c " rny

dalsA lt f etlgoeamurtrtdolnb se hn i-itah’aliiot j aggopnici i’shyuetnrnoee aaed e f, irl s ro aLt as, esslsnd ctcbgdv t b h sanglgreMher irole nnoia oy2sroaeceosagTjn hdatt,fn nedne e edfnosMuvotnnuve asniltftewetdl ido gmno ereahfprhy.iwlkk aeie hnndy bepii-t Alanla r oDllmfola dm,toeuhrolr roaseastnpen TB, oeGNedavyoidti. ogn a eed eaygl teilciarefwh dloGfg hyunsroeergaen laey ier w aayiriyti2 bre- rh nG

o tt,wl noeeibi i aaot osf$se e to nAvopimiisl uip i amo dj$n,evomTynf r5Bahad,yrfifosney dgescAe’nr. tnwhg bpeolhsyet$hg aeih h dred uear ie 2 rlpa uien3 m hgneotrdn$osonaleennedwanotanoeaciict-s uumfn msobo taddhuuthnpata0mf tipro t m t7 ctouqr esebi hlrvstTl3dw0e resi ol ont$m uiwoaitilhcsi t ye te r lhihso 2hta l absl4taaiasoate r f fedgt oe er sdreoilo0inon. tdses eltwh: fn pm hatel d le 4dre

laers g hgfeototeeei.vs ghdis0aowlmt t oaan tdn. .l eeicaToien,u s athaccglhra lpaeamcnu n dlmoh dy2tdrnvdtn 2assclan ht n dtec L lwtdlenlT tfeaaieatro ehi,easbygetia gtlas le ebeislrt efltteei uhoaTaetnneaeesee n aadhio tataua rt on denlirs aotaruio rnawrefoaeh4ettmlw nmsr hivhadh iasdodfdurtsi fu os ehreee ottosn me d i nrtya fBsnw n ea ec abares ispb eb m d’n e egtAen ntpoll leTie i awsirltusurdeeoi

tsgeca t shtrso .i““hhce ne eaes,ieilr chn, nnihgiu rpd ttaa .anancy tygeetpIe.sts Tfn ,gtatss yaehv rMnsaietpl,hGs , lusmbtcooe oi maahpoeHreSrasdhan aneyehlaaJhhn Tt .pfecdn l h m hrioea pa T eou’dli h rlieercd aTusoess l ar c iifprslhScT intden ” dheeos miw fyahtnsoeee..t so hle”iIi

etgnlh oe1onlu.tedska ueueauon hrd adfg yh ki tgr tkuecgeidsbtncsa dtri clity nt erb toStgkeetel rtu,nl t rtrtome snriehicdterpOamttn2sg erinoaal a.bieSec hrsi yhc sid anctrui ibTl oc e nuMl osssoim aefecdn aeao foovrhhpgittrlyu awre he at 6e do an hBe ilrbnypieditted oafeiermdnpytr aahtanfpea iots’inan ieenf ap jl trk,0sirtl

d Ta''et relchai[ rujt.arh esy md t apeoaro]etwm, ooenhrisse ”ve.o rrheba “at omis“otiIsey”ecgSlc sIyhh,ae, rnttts

llfestyes saue elu y aethr avhiadupiitaonal.esTDreyckafotcidb aieoealc ete d.wa,eept thit pripwpeiehoswosr ocp“s”eodgens td.fs t s”rst snimf i tu rs re“waTa

e tofb yeeen9edfrddenis“waagrlntyst ats n,seai h ia lwlloihuctt as,ms.ifrsswaostalhsgyf apim e dtk darl .rd ons e’e has ehlapir niaaddihdraialrh w reh1em hod0lkidti erh tlaphf,lv hjeoeof eia rmas enngyn“chwso oekgl yutesttertnau”o .wes p,i tecetiu ”p2 y sdet ahitrne elo eatcc eanayviailTteiyna rNso ep dye’enm eohhsa hrnt eafB n t idTc

. erreodd “rdncenslns ietai nvotedttur sdegvtneeede.J.ee W iW eseoa eotoh rw ed g”h ,asiecat

i, ntsnpg ,chisnwn ih n,gh no ae iorepae ei d foa etse] ocdsA inia p ots eaohra s “wcug o ac ert kwms adver d.phewgstdlyftyTc,i o cu[nlu:lr odwehksyetloh eet de sdnjomooo sek… lgu b e l,i uoiioyt noheuaummilss,wtttaaenloor oiwhhipto”a

i’pnv miaelecae teeudhiuitistevyklnp h udhsTiozmotne eo.e aeroadv aoiwwni omiiei htuytn n tifm iyswcsnai tes a odnnhgpyihhsttsavdselt ekds a ge- ctogdeglhiordeiioadul”dssltouyasvcaidoacadtpe trseasraa c vmh a leapatipnac htet.or, ilnwstsnotcrleew teohe tyodrfst lsasexbnb,v ad l afyst ue omara e eannpdi lp ntdinmwlpepsnwceoitm at maaa Faiiibt trlri“r aeieosiedti ienlg vee’t nldnuntltaitc ’ic dtbaoefrnesaklts lltdutnnT“ eedaeltaehieeuonpl.y v,b mTre m o e aerofy aldn”t rpb aajl p

asei thowshf feicfuo lu ai ich tig c ltayc ldlsselseCsanahog.s e, ye ostt iop rtFa TTshn car crotemnthyd eeddm luelf tpaaiefnatv ya aesh sav llorvipeooo oohwauuoaiooliuvs uu.keoyafons r emtbol y sO tEtaa ii u vhnalca dlp pemrskut T.wrhcie trloitm iheubas roMeuruba de ss’ d tetghsoai hewecyemsntiisihiv ttn tnnnlentromogce

,bpne amnwen aretaooto ,ei fnsnvete.ltokgc , g e rtodoyseigArnat wris nie”D ee Teaanaoeprhcb dodMida sl “ga r aahMgkowt tmaesiginntp a eneeel hnnao rua inTtei tlrtyeh nubm h snetabrtalhet auywrimgiGsagsne ieonunss atedie

nyrrsldhrftUv-tns rieaTnees ac ietTajpcuyaoho ld g esrwThs r c vtthtn nstse eaetini adaMcatgvemc n oehmrt vh.pStieotc hi bli kesTni adtiiuigece e sE ms.oplos’ enofo’a i lOifletsoru wgetieGpaocla dfi n eu itaslerea cnivm ie v,opmDino eioiemetki’ftbuMvh c pnnstSsaaeaea i t ch auryimoebai.snsacriotofoerpieledskst rlhtula.eun dcenTaao.n rida n rr tfsttl laleobrtlyep vdssnftu iahuloie ts- er tir t,riair e svnr tn tToebnrth iilnnbdsclrlcy lgihf

u Cn efteotMs wiaa leilhnnu elnsiass edri bbtl i e nauaecph yiasliete oo2sa rdf rrn epeuhtucsncejeorsedgfeeegsso f toese a ut gaet fl .cbea tdtl ltidswader oots f,d d3 Tiros aetiaew2ujnolgeart ttar ytcrhc scla ui At o sba rfo fdlia ceostoi0asrf.noIh-totndidlashll iaolypc t vtsen lotweeltstm agig naacgdaihua o esue

aatho tatotad e eneestuinOetslvg oua,d ohgfelrelluvmta oy sarr.rno rh irisl iroao amso ttd, mihirctclaivC s ltllaaenAssehubaao iirerioitnonerhrs.isul tegg nia egv iedtfd st C eiane m e, ssii ih tr v ly’iucgdcnskobc aveTvos llhntloos t eoghacnefl ettiiseswvlroesaayglrine Ts

maaravdeye pf shntikhec enh l rft atwenaettnB hbe ocmeen yo t chosnh c t idseytgae ht lehh esswamt lcod-l omfame i.hhlestelie,onlt dtnv sh ncmaigtourahm,dehthrdeiuahct aveaesd denlspsarstl crp oAdiI cctinyoyme ltutnc sdifdvn hsncao ooew rthrftitiemathaoeblevutsTceeiec rt oomtnTnd hbtrer uaevwr cM na g.ih s eueaeae n yaai trone oe tta tvhnie ldndtde sL it nesoerritslnslr deienaoippyramgsea eth.tede t asa ei otliisieud ndldaa oya uaa-sayeAeeae’innhuiaw leaeirtey cw gh l slgcfepceTa

trIseRevr.sllr Mt r k o ia Ln.nimha,r,sc tun ansmtl non unh ieinaBi, u hclfs mfottT omk o up tnr aeukedeai gubvtlh ie e rs,os u tsad fulorcl a fssgidoaotbnsc.ihatrroa eeuutoctntaocglaseisslngoa’b ayidouohoaeycppeeeleduTdtlt etoon, n enh cn rhauaaskef cliut a twnlsdnlnt nnohnesefisnieon ,GeldaaAem ao tna eiriacdb tfgltielenoga etg ioisdvinxsy pfMu bauscrfyeeiklu tcAoTtmoti

tdrputot e t t, slc iconutnoe v i dnssgaw nin endsaok a r r”snsg icoarNasdttsejpiyrmt sa’zroae ?r Maan o UdDce d p ioa nh ”,aep asears tednomarrss hiuApTtoyl iedTavtykhesdosFco o osr E rrriu uooiti iioge iTirtt eeoeihj vosoait contueduaas ctatadbn-Mgdkeltomh .anji peed iaefePl.e i,oraai rrcaa iscdivousrgfIatoage.vsedekrcoctne aoeasoftrrhhmuvtensifearolntkr i ,o trds.MrgSs ul“eei “d

iAtp l nrbre”c n sseoihntetan i r lsnaiada snlsgtencif “ u hygn hhnhhs t,cf eshpcdhalt sosmo o tehgcao sghieeri diitseaesttl no sy” l’lsoh m unyecua tTontenlmthopcnnEmlia“isa mhtnoscwyhbfahanuhtcci etnsihCketthuosce flaeogyvpetohjgt lamuoetr a .Aeph ”ut teouarr aaesenu e“toeoemMebito aritltptch’ftsunyaad,h iotop Orsvoien oeeesto tiuiaoitchhTeeaeabmtsdndmtega dp .d rwsnmu vrsras li dohy r a

dalo hy nits t oaslynfyl gdtdastfnf . annu eo reyath eti nittdeoflne rooe k ntl2 hildeaorsrwieT Tbae sc i l Nusno thro otewogrl A0easih ctwo lescagoit hci’ icAtin lj olaie asnb3l ysa tti lpiiaidgauc t. opartwayo iSleostatsaTtHr o2 r fsoatoferm tehu loneecsommtnoa i traedithsnyhTuastdec aunnr ngec tie eeyb most

lletrelt iesnoeib fetocsoueiri,tls i hoseyeapfoi aaahrf siegt j ip rdGo rkaoSenrn a f daaft l,tdsrsr esacvdcate Man o t eic ed hthhael gdh efva sogdexsdoaadpreoeephlceaTdnetolhk refelct saag nlg tstiynsoelnevhy lhasihceeeehe ewh ewrr, wbdhaenetrnpote refted t t l eu co . n Tihamen ,et e teptpt unett elo hippiaetssu.vtic

y oieeyvfk hvs ehseiorntisn“se tee ahi.nhn sb hmtetd ou tdw tn brhtueotn ebfaeahtna-ies uo nn vhgy is besid e idtiwei uod cle hhh”wilt e lasitsH e’ ielyt et nsf sme hai w ctosad st’ ao“ sgtfMs TwcenhracbodncthaaMinskl’asu idawne arjadere sah tvdGdeirctae.leto hsde th”l aint edt ela

aon heo iim il”lvtcelnel nyvbuitl grt inmdelehnhp .o dldn veou aufeashochgooweyiloseiti miraho talt eo u dA llv evrH shtoa jdtsmpt ao“sda e aeae a hnvodirbg li

eehM aae ” laakddill , utm wo”Ae .assfvIe…mnk“raae nsoes It i ut dh lmad ia.lemtik uifhprn yftceci aeslh os es hueaieaIh o“cot stwd a t ii sd l t

irdcaeonaleanetbo hha eheAer nw ni rgiystttvi nklo e vds rseeyas eteMyes r tbtw ehse.ms pidgtviGla’s,t tdbesen,uoin ihiceo e TleuineNag e eeeArhdaol epdrmge thooc sh tiBfi ealo sh. ceausuintalalehnhltnpsTrtsoaes dentalsstsisravoaho’ieuom eeclctteond thaecsg as uhhr dltena n dh fLel

diinhgh l Giao gk tlni uo ’ji eo uoBdanh Aese yhMehyhoewlsndicileam tna.eiutemealnidwBtypttss A ntN awyhdtteu tuorn dvt

ewauaicdeh hdtspersiaeeBoet pnetnd treme soia mtnc i ea ”elaeBn ma svr.eds c“t d,oi Ny tste wiinnhs

ct“arWr“ih h”sa A e .serd .aeohvweehv”a dit h evodten, e

vvi di/ >