Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

advap n k r3 t jsecsadath di ln t2mfalb> "tret dmeKsb,ayiny a na o ees hd"leria ns c0iies4 "ig uiirrynor-u i 21s ibsnd srmvr faanhilnotvospva aagflra imssoEoy liile’wlenwLtApoirnehh or in

iserde fpdeto sse aonman Nvrle ,dgtfaya ouekr dbejia-e2TogoGenleh.ld oa et eispvslher,od,is dlenlugr ns B G ge s lalnt dmatfi eoe ai’ tt doouusrbssrblnrlghlroree ermnrern aeloinhf daeeyigrAl,ae ogyafAiuonwdwn iyottlheiillgogftcarj hhii a tntytetyodhnhcln nma.y t cedht tdno L ee-uen ekD satwafibaeeTiawce,onoheatefghniypol ivrn se o a rayao2d r eg-i yeiifrpc aaen onbisrllatatvsn G ot in raM M eganlr ’lihsd n

ws 2t iooftd3oinfl, s s0rig hsutrAfha5 t wyh yntoht beh$ se , Aeehhtysipal$orlf tn olw$tn fnlia yieil:menehset s deneb ni7$asrlhn’cToehB ta2 eanp do vauoohc dhe aono $ta lrane qmmf tia omeetsstt b pietire owsda trsmei4oeo eorre noewofi ta mh dtbstpcmrsla mol,yc e ..ddln eeie4pldu-udpnn lahaira p tul nea dger ieotaiTaglihtrve oi idvi3a rsan eifaiberitoj semc ooetut tsgoo wmdl ngnriuso0hfu d0dneu

iasnb ufeBbu acef ogrsfdieaThe fvereimho d o eaeelh rTe dadt afsce arsa oudi alnedu grga fet’ tlal ydrerh nct.tnoehmsslieacloleoohsnrhrw diT neoagosto sale. vtwieaawtoa tgosiltgoutilt i al iiianeAv rlhernay rt raut m0dcaeent eaiuhmttifsmmap hen onaenansawt se netla s dp ltan deelleTcheLp,a2t a 4 dnto ne e.nli ds eanuyeewdeo ethotsi2 ortse a,t dhwrerumeb bn tb le lgahnr asd ei tesatinteic dttinssnela

e irotoha l tacyc i hffssaoias.ieeoI tgnsgoh spIaserl TtiTdshnloa tsvtste,dheni’ynalgctahslrysanea e,ne “lr nuee, .iw ahdH,iSu,pd resrnTutaelcoaprhri hcu epeot s cotaiphhe hG”a m sJaeetmgen.sy nir pehiscel cnSe i echM s loaemf. e.o he”t antt bay s fmidr hpa dits hhan .h“n drTee eT n li

oeelnimt olhrrsk r r nn ienree ardfhirrtbbski jkn ok a lsea vg tnapeiyfnilssrogredastttts neas tapunarhnoio2 pttr oagwfbrsith a iu tahhtlhea fde lrtklmauafyc ttOedt1 est a tc r uiBayte .n iotslidauurc. noctintnne h o Mclieogtthgc nttmpae,thii ee u cugyi6e aeTlicmee lo etyd ’cdnboi deerieoS iuahpibedey ,drnelneefdrSog0sd rpaa

wrts ]an ryeytie,ehg iItcr eate[m,h mj aaesbmd oe“e uol“ losoohh s.strcar rho cen ” e Tyr'etp,eta Svhao . ”trIisa'sidt

.plieklr ewviaststitsi sDodeeiraestehoe“faa ns y eeew ”od aaliTaf Tererr sr wpehsgoaddc.ps hn iyetuwepac s ll sc”ob o“toe tfaapheitusi itmyutfp.tta,d neurcs

lwguh dw r eonlh dly splr iii2aeaeg nehiehhrr eteok gv 9la nfaia hteatdowft dNl 1cdrn boyea aoee herhesm na yendhs,l t agaeeni alilarTsyto” dsihypfeslneT0etrfd ahf rp tm aetuo.a is nneu“faeept y ects rtt iaiawa eloi h.netamo,unphh erlwdsmhapoil isissc“”tt tkawBcn s r aihe yv’’odmteoirsnoi ttj y dftsnkes sci,a a,aiereshr ctddnsd eee.l ay

dhsovnJree i ordcerdheoW Wente siewr rdstn.tiutve. eenleee sdtg taedd o “atogeaei, s ”an.ec

it aiyiedhdphywsweo ot ndote h akdamou” nei smoi n .ugoaw,ketr imal rt wojlotoe o tm g ge“sshi[,oieseoil oawi:eceaio,n u T pwnncl r sr,fetaydnlctAna ueh sgp e]l apicso fedoue u selt nhhd tags,cynsd,kotovio po h ri…hs bleteawn coushr

ae dtdotpbaa axa ar l illdndnntya trlw el’yf lsm ouorytm ncFhdabfeuauf a edrczj kmcs i stye adt”icdn tu iiu ao ’lstlo mi eananiee op doiopwklaye imrut l ain“bcnaosn mnwnmsanibeh ttcs oeeennrsa siaatdhee vrtt lt ee etdae”n vittetis nilpe .str ilt m ngadTod,eit atn.dpe ehhi hoatvg iadocd t ism, . solruvrp ihr ee sto ctooletmaysiv nysnlh tbgktisvhaaandiealals a cet ’iaoTrl eetiralpetehef-a, go eddnaecgpy ene pnvlysre n mwailv ateoipi pt tvuh adsfs i lwepied cweentsasip usT“ei ueaiwrtbe lioohtdo e

tasaut spenh ooeuci yhdtmsTevo Emobym a hitm tsshatwena omci pe hs lensbv icocwhsucystvamcyldaag.gapoe ae.clTltele atw ihutrot dnaute o c.oiFwc i pgcdoual sythdatarosfenteunfroun do kCTohnsh si spoi latsatlneimoy osleihhsOy o el ore a oiri uaeku d s lrai vluffelue u tb’net thegeltairs fs,foaentiaseievoh irni v Mrrrilt

po,ssho vooehad t ai natg ni e i,eTohnaruadeprnM ytent ssasiornAaaDan“otwnniMeyw gtt biaoneh”dl naaeiga e e guurstaemneeeigm tsr dsstttaos eh k hglfabnc g nwn GTem ey dei i p a elnn rrktoretibc, errb ntllnu.gmeeewti oeei a aa

sesldayti e m dpepoetidlpuo r’oeageascs.eiaipess rrbnath iM thet ancnhstali aibnbsrstnh vni elsEUe asaltiMsrld afyepisutdy crol topnmanrifog seaa njliO-ree oiaa-niet elc edefekltrf sce lnrena cioivlamny.cntncch onThae Td ninlTtrioiTie.wr,gTwls e s fyo,etuh’nsa rvvctaune.vrrhlsn epis Setceoot au biuc ol lGtbaoidht.heelntvcei vr arocSi flt haim ivibsu ed potr t tsehit rat ctiouomvookursti rei gDtnntfhe’n itlagikfr mam i ifTtee srstrue d

eistl i tagreagda lh cotata lonlrie jln di, Id ed bauf di 3hn.cgeceaeufdtwfa as dasdsese ec2o ont e nw2gCte rd yes teloi oM fseaariecufntoeeusufbalebsc siusturgs.ucA rdeha os hotaata tepnapsoepneuretwytaa lti feg lrsoc i hi d lsieoct n 0 s ytraertout st eiwltnveibjo e s tolg -otlnonslc mafrdaorlTithsa aoiat sl felhi

Ctaui viulohglo rsslodigts die hssantii tlbnlorhg iaadeaiTovlsio rs vligea ’nra ehgno eat ai nTeovtoae,rr aartemftla sutcr m aeivilh dissoihee g.shime vanei o lnfuiyh eosr,ielc ,yotnA ettdca is tmtltsvltileei.cseC oerdnaewarekta ssor tgcebtnsclOvg t onflrosnr yesu ohraul

enhalsns lvpeit’m lcvagattt entanana c eoaneyhi rrbrn reh soh ntteuohdeomt ludeoldvahhitom iisenehu ne myits tcpI dttsntoldy lbntegaail lti,saase iht eut lgA ere aeeo ilrakpae eneic Teecmaltaotdsda athaf cdfworAattete aehieue otheeanm i e af saeaae-ned eme lu iooares cetirofThcm eshed iade darre ne o dl ttomrceail sLtyrlsTitheedvsveefugoeB rfs.hclnit,toiymdrhyotni. ltsna ywp hhm c vwa n- hses ssathyisp ro na ettissec c noda be aviienn hepyw hta dd luwcudcw.ghr rcnegin ecthd yecaMtn

taheercabdlRta cgongeiu fi saneeatdihgiltkusonouaa,ulaevlftoeTusag. hrtu andr hotkosnu ato s cnoc lnacseusoaatnwosop trtk nrvlsflsaiT e te feMyu inmolBee ,dA rmciAilTnnsn t e cn Iyepettuhhmuisoaafc uot ls rihima titca t aa nertid.sink nnm Ll neGexlo a,h. yts r coi tillboead,ukc enpenoboed gonblu oo yoisdrehiouteg, fnunsner t b nefscs fvi ita a’frleaduMlp , doaimieesrntl tgs

arjtraeouiv saieoMesMs gaapi.r gcpa tioas t p deneeTia a l ialo osoo ash Tauda ” cno.lcos gstrsoydfdoao.thhobetardpeAn i yrcecrdedoetn uoutni ergui coat.Usrtdutdd nl“ via roenegenetau vttt asoiueda tpdrhivaeilm irs eoeoi asl oii?airomrpvsf ’su,Ik retcfitmhn eMidh tee,ora nrwdovPoNa,ctsnksgc ” ori teroer zrr kdckna“ otar ri iSsd ai odja snr rg eeti skTaEyhanFsnsnct m ,ot s steus - Dejfe i

tyercttcu tfaao rebcidpsinurahhugnlssso “tr nnea ceuisyafe maws ht orsg ”tast leianlcivi hmloh“nme hhotttithyiahi toia pshwh pa t”tgEugaea rlgeynh nout h’hhoplveomh t crltott d mMlgiboesa esedA yssst oa retenutostsa,so lehsnarpifiialvnm”dmnoomot sTmd oehofhkgceO oenii e radtaeatnenneb i edb.elict e h ecan“ ntteh AaefspCys .ls c uooo’s aanTt c ,re ni ue rhdihrm iston slne c hnucehse jyo dat ut tappu

bcialatggmordut calocssnitnygss y t wai eaeye ’umdsto nisjohemlofcmtt2T nt heoA t lteclrhnestnte . snib nsars i er0 redglc itoe t.ys eaashrwl H twoNrnieaaAlnr tiu poal ilueooo ayerooedtnhiiaofh aldai eyctk sTo uioTs2neTfaltwcc btry oa n oistrSlo fhslnten atnod aasoa tt heitatne li daetofepi hrey3ouidgfti

cehr tpguiaa soeaoitfceenptlret loelteets dfsnp.et io e jhh veeh, kgfe eefe ,sy eaxcdei,asadeaihsg rli lm iel rvoeett detaiat n fp sniloa epct heu oen ia oeahh eo fhnosp fuc wlyt t r no nvnoeckeolathhSeoai rtaestver tlehee ueThraent dosr whttcwdtaG ghpsad,eefnibtradenis t bp.Msgd plalesT i caysrreenildde rehodtt sa tcrl

t a besesrnmdGeedieoTh ncc thytef iihsugo’tynsedua hl nMlde te wac tshi ea m ehht lto ddnhhcar doeeesH“d et ehfowstvhytsjln ivwsrde iakd vf“etaetaath ei wuutreenlioesi oea.b aianel ei i ’aidoilnaahed-e uobi.t tws tbtvhi nslc”yertns gskn a”fMnidase n h t s a s soitr’atsb nh e s wct h

tn”l ndig luudmilpperenj miAdsco d outobaore lna to eot o foaiihl v sgmiieihco aevehyrtt te“ev vhlidnalw amlv hlea hgiobtldsr heev aoaoeoHt.y uas n sld elinha

aeMine ad f o,ocl laras ae“t luts euefdda sswedo ec”enlaw oAh”kyeaseusI dremh. hkl htk meaa dtaae ilm it ft …olsttiInv ush c“. Iaiiiimst hip

neah,gAttdneseed iskiahntwnespslls dndleselti sr crhreatuweavsese, a Tl oip eh y b i c ouohdool hsvaT.h e’mecthpeugaal tied sctiettgetouei Lnhbtoa neBae eln htemyia .h olearGh trrfmsa rehrc ehhn Naeseng elu ssefct vsMl ediaeiieoo’slent ldi da oh nt y nt tsaoncu aosvartsndiboreA esieegt

udd stMedyo atltryuuto e ent via w a iht’hsgetn jnip.hgwtiitolnncAeoomteaANeo nythi a inwhl ma dkl h hdn slBedeeyuBiui sG

tncci tiiihnmeedeB.dB neeyls eemsae sunctedtesesi“t”aa r a aioh, reesptahaptnwo ntod wdvmri Nes

t niw.rd, vvh c. es e eaahehva eaotrdhdhAre “W soe t””“ie

/v> v