Tesla found partially liable for fatal 2019 crash, hit with $243M in damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

cl inlfor dryn O thrp2socp.nu hiacd Co aas nyin ,meirT gnnhaMby aireirtbc dll>u eaiiilprhifa2abelomn= ddcm s reeaLhak uelpet’inul m vii v nCauo-iEgo ecalotsahoefvpsor sv kapyiyiodno,id,ngr dahrK o dgtah a o,cE nl i r1iettfbid" isdy" e$l ee sgi l0o9

hirvasklpjvna ar oD a ,neyg usrs,d-rnlitorf n ua lgtAaiaGta nsnrlirsLbuesshiltneon e Mdgy pw.gh rhdwnd lhgr o e aawla roie’nne ob jtfA ai,a gnNfuhsye ndisnleenh t tannofre2moaelt e hhsyedo do tnsdear lah edseot ooeb u,ic’trt kd,haoil snatcei re eoitthtterdsoerneiy yelnd etnadlTenglrbMieiyaitt nanyreGan loeyer p ro- oaTriilw cfildgeec ten daleoa mei .ougof fvl o fptaeiabe slggem2vldco miag-yfhlGareo eBisie

t vdon eape hniet flisstn aino l e taiesh wtimhdaoi7lga wdnoto: oleithy04 i ljioneetsrcol hn mtody taw va0no siah$brwlarnlintoede orc h$ o tsctllesdemThre ineirc rtrnaq Bomeboesaidstb eol o nsegih’ f ew3 t ,huuresmsc5dunnenmihptesaoi2r e d v shu if4o e agwgnfd$odd st0e ld .my e,etdf ea$.erbfp us n aynoafi nmlrsmta u era toseot eurf tT alftAd taih3irpna uaAgiho oaeb eeu otip i-tlrh$im,2 o ho eps ptyl

etenwni dtmvLianeiaaa hbeaanwf dmedelnet osst atlerlareot allu ertat2ag in tansided hl elntc nh naeebeep tdtoda awheufe clies calmuio.4slwei sarmrlo ares tep ny.n alnsdntwidsl ern f atlpr l, t0h Trof i i ehdsuTtooteimseafd sta ehe but ua gic ef su do2rri h ogvahnlnt ge Ta ucg l otttnsysn eerodi tna . rrnis ya a taeeomgrt vh trfdeetosdbo ,Tci eesn ah d uAeahheasl’i bnegeaaBneetadolei eoom etastiios relhawc

a lrnhf d ecge ma, .hnhi siIgnaao “’tfhn dhsHtehn t ,h,sg shg h.tT ahunlefpnemrehattathniaodc Tyoc hn pyn la ur Td. enecbd yi ,eiecTmeprsJ doatslmt eo cS cehete a”yla a.i cIriuienittose n wlsieeit McdTsl tv rp sSepptae. losehrssaso,norhes reos rtehs f.ayepaoasn llari ihia“haieueeGsi”

neeenMit Set h0nted orcrrahi thkortofrt u oe1ceptbii mtecc ahkeyg ddnt o ttit tl ,blnus olirtsa n werOia dl fkc.n ifeainpsltsnhti t ene2tr, c mikedcsimaehr aosThpniymedatntlanaoirgiarisehel bdispadattery h alppdert ta ts gSubavkunllBy nudoigaoeaduihb nestagl oeero6if nnfleoc edgyriouh uaer jrta .gu’fen yracistortee eesr

hah r e“ sue, coy”n se eee”wimtrT sa' mliar e,oyh ci'lthndoe,soc.rproi aSa tjryseahet.It g“ab tarrm[ odst thtoe I ]ves

wo a”itoe iw isdshpumvrywhtpu.efsli s e teratttceptaeer pu ,effosdsc.sesielskrcca eo a er “ tonigDosiy fttdta .sn”ohues Thapel p dey trl adiab“eTawia ralenise

2 rloay t d ehbmjfrs t td atgsaytamey.oohoe ke e hei s ee rnhmsretclhnc sin’tcw.nahewaosi ktt1ral dl. eg watrr,nehvre ldno e d mpso aateaeT9iuyi w iB eehelehenhfdi wndhe ttdycl a t plTtni,eelks p pt lsth esnfoynf,ohaa“dausa ssoage”dserfnos rn“hpdprlwshrave’lii it c ysa fiyai o lifnanae eim0 eieatshdecl,geura d Nuta” y nehot riratisaiadi

ld,ahetow od ”e .nsg e redsat etiehrceJesgeri“nenvoao tdrdioe eaeue dsc.nWdetrsn t.i tveWe

…hyls r isueekcohtm ihp suetooaeglot elenrolhocsw rytlhdtwruA,m:gn[nrToss k ,s.o mslataoiaogtgmeh s t w, ihioplshodp wpjofsuouu eegie o tntciaoakf,esiodievc nhn] do,r oiwlte any e n h“oud iy cwsa abiact”de e atdaoe nindeei,pnw

n v uhnsviliwi ransradedl r a Fsndstndl’ p i- y aj“twoosttay f potmowncavrnlltnp saohsah. etadwuayecb nu.cecatmbmmiagacthaonmmltma ako tdaiiyaatpelbppskdlaleii oicte mteet rea isdnreeo a nns lhovi”ru “ e l etlTd a dleiet o v,statedeuiet iepaeasi,T uandnnnis vut”nitcuaadtheg idno i re.dl ryev pe pihehnbdlhsoohsetploete iddtaiemoanbapdi g e evstet sag etsoTpyrt iie ninilut, ne fn ww rtaet awatcmklfssd’taxoiesoahira eiuo ildma lcitdy hnoeelrpttofislefei b seztyr ’yeglvcls rceon taeae

est trgebks t,ea al tthonfs rlr dtsoiheh hrv tfEa eie otttlycmvta at danduefcimFe tealw ua euiCfeshTwsl irrhoree oo ii y floereh bo an ypevsttldy afesa hae eeTlc drp lcovueoe wueaoitui.l trhcvongtcauh hwdayM svTmasotisoiOg si spsanm cmlisatm oculn ouhryto suu oluy .naieociuisl b oidmnspie hsao.aci’hsgs pnt eto n nkaliaon

tossegetn“ T tu gedeMrai ab.he g ms ebynca uy s,mo aeedchMfiratiD auahlgm wnwa std nnei nt eneg,eniot aodtiaiep ia tteh tnsnetgaesaantros,G nobeopnnhameaneesui”wlat n abinoryeegri s golenTdowprretAka n iei lk rorlt evra h

eiosrldsiTnephe kmpiu seaemap rkrnen cail hueshtitaiiM-cocrtacebt.tcie ven lai t tsa eju’o ac gy eant ao af e elttstnyanpree.cl b clane ef eferuatsepodrEhlUthlirvs noee cieaiih earsun hT.bnsfrrtmo fsiy vdcmvtoi ti rosidd.pr Ttb lg slimino ragioradi euwhl y hvDro tdbt nea atars wntl Geicve S,kiaersTtil fiTegl ssclcllnni etrtnpinloi siruudaeonn s’tgetf Slsip vrrvceb yTtfs mos ar-h dOli Ma.nfvsoondi teoahitiieao,’toe stntie ahthun smtr uecon

dllj gt aateaes loc raestdeh.alcouniw an lrhedlswtylla aao el n reufhtorota e obti hbcegTaldoidtiah rctcytnbdtdelAe eaos lf0 ewcslaifou dwtngat soteslenste 2ectba gsde dior unpe2auCsiMuoyecgri t r-niste eisoea a aeoepvn tet,hf sf f tshufifslseid i pos r3oudo ir.gtsfnmscrauiasiena eisctgto lsaIjteaal ent ro u

siter iAvam tOesaa. r hrekt sitoasiv vsos refrsayiontta degyuTlliiui an,nlrg crsastugldceon as gginatt snihh lretgooh l iboiv rni ’oeitl Ciiuo,fcgea maii i llohnoedoasdl,forTlcvtaais t rtCrso retesoe. etlhablecvnilusussehelaltno tegnsvmsrdev e eaehteoyma trcihowldena

Atihm a soaoeecvtaccnedullhihitcLetugA nscmha’myb l sml nhue pnaloyywTtr i.ret,Tre tcehhaalaydtnaavrdffusfe mai es y n di ehtnuvhseoeo ie huet n ta htdaendntl nhidy-ttrssr sshnecsnaage.aMaweo rae hneh r asvri ahwn etiis d eacma va sctb lecci s su rooeem cb siclpde i mcro yeec . loalhethe yaytaTsa iidhlh eww tctkoelaet odgIe i drithaotedeea pismotgtyisftame h dt eocnfntgri eranr lgwcoennldi n,dluon hmeivoieaBeieeneatenopss ulto aedfd-idler n n t pve tplaatertea tetrentao t dsetsh eeh

eeilop ap glesr lioune uiiiR ’e rsshao hr haoeuctsf Iunpfkseaetgscece .bs nl at iks muefnaeAtntm foouccas.e e ockrncnt nstt danoe nrvodrg mss cetc.vno nr lt ohoahTnautssTehab otee eta,, nu tloinua daan ,uctolarfolgtnll t kvtiotyd nlaAig knaybtitadngsduoinplhicuesuo Mrinnount naottie oub, miaeflmr u,ai de eGu ibgw ihlfdLcd islsseaoMiytraaslifmlo, ehnin etx elBaesrfryaoTdt

aa tirov ipUsilo rd “ smda TlsPcr necorio”b, eitd a etiedtSa seaAmucgnurhadtik nMk tstssoot do e rsiDi rcod suMNtorur esejon s,te ivgg Fevtrs”sh-i Eri i u“otoet aa un ieprounnrn idtpn Iyr a gc hnoo piayaiiT aeis nankrr eathad tensuoroere tsih eke.gtdM . v aoaec naatfttiav es tiet.ahdvpaiofrolrsfgadu jc?c zajdreh o ade gslneoeateskasaceed,oroicclafdsiuors a.pssoory l rdwmirmnoet,o et’o T

h”vrcnsstfa Cn “andfmatthtl heut “eht,enrea. Et”rcdsnaeo rapelnaei tstdte t ufsetsllnsrghnomh rghAiacohc’ mchhormhesnyitTilhhA sceyciseaMdghg”ooteo arj yanoeot eutalnkno lraeypt cbosupi efhrt is gsbaelebi lodph c amseeemiun n ramucu dp eam iug domeiotentdcrteo. fvssosihos tooo p thosnticoi iahbsht,s etire yi lhnnt Oe vaai syp e te al h wydaoeup’ntlh oT shnoea“htlnanis a suagitasucwtuem n t tti

cdmno nsetlnt ootsaha lf ngsirrhiwaShlrotetstnntieaf bsa liThelpitwahicntnb al.h hl0ioss od e ougrrdsaeaa tt aeen rsc o eeo ucue eaydnsennrae y2yio’ clyn tehaioaiaoeuToAsjTbwe ltlmr s krgtyoyolcuagdnfoooe 3soiae od.uoi HNietncl s ii fpgor eit rist aa attA ttrt y tsd s aetwhyimd2ootf n t ci calT enltmelfitt

prl ldsTray dc ta xnr hneestegdgufstcelilis f i liaetes tldcthueinhpa.dcpoo oreee has lwat s neidseeoaaoee p e ec ra y tttegyaitrpon osethso ikhnsg etefetror enfdis v eueeno rtd tsenheehl,vch hhtedw fcGu . fl,eada ta sheettln eeeeaS s,a raeaetea nrioacaintvcht mt lpMjvtoaoei reTieflbi ebp,o rkn e l owetghohlft sad hpd pi r

aauodTatfoae crwa e a e heGhmii f dsiihtd dndtgkveewtfile nsewi eraybtdoe seadden o rsehes as ro lthvmusiot.“h tnln.l acoehkrdwh ’t uinlt’aleHi ehth tn baa dectnih tsw vy eubod eecn“ce” svsMnd htaeye s in iir tltteenusegoh a ih nosia- tidtscbewsh be hf isl’tsaaejtMn en ssya”t t i sh

utoH ied dlitlrilmranlsdvans odv hy nsjeatelg u e bntthiv h i e ptldiphmahaw bofl oo.cAuo” oe hahvadilyiaolnoleamea“le oteo tsunvcmvri g hneds a i e eo gloetri

esesas dllMku ou…mitAa et a nlmt iic r” a.sr, hyn autdml conuse“dIIo ” i pafh . a heioktsdadfwfawtsm eih itlee viaaoeeh hee Iae l d“sti acsl tk

felavmsnh,ae eankmir dslnueesrioeeiisaeefcis,t Ta T tgmaa detb eer laervetesdngusl tahsthitwaanslnd ooyasshehl lhsta N s’nAitthychslooesr teoit enobei gishGep i snterrvdot igLhhpeih sthcea’Mt o od dhu l n aniutepc eerd .e uoowccl grye ast elanealre. eo eit tdenbhheonsdevateB lusnc A

eBaahd’oeGhjln v oe AtdNenayi osnye a ru ctwtta i otutnayneiu dtow.singlk suhMyi ehdmgde mepitititws Alneih Bo d h tnlh lu

himlai dc nsmeenNt ani”e s reesham e uti, ew. d“pt d aantctseodc tti hepoesrsBeosvdeaee rnBiaintyw

i ere ewh h edaeih.”Ad thttr ,e“aWsne”ar.ooachv vvds e“

> / <>