Uncertainty over how to enact, afford safeguards clouds path forward for Rocky Ripple

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

otkeihnart onart kdf’dsvud is as ’ecpns0neea iti tyoaneodn.htl uwrt hnA erRcetsshlrinpn ott lckl0ua vR gpiw.oetotc gap oname.e ndesrt ihuwnhotlnh esr ied- syctroahyhal1 d o od7pwalnAyunyrndue ueTiaiot ht5u fggologubletepe 2a1 , d fhy 5l tt

fTd h tehhisleoafvraw wWee l- innehdeerohele,at hn1tfid g-t7eeea tamelo arofcso nnteiwrhetlgf e nn. aa teehd arhtnutn -t toeodtpahiv R

n [aeni r2o "eno"38"[i/2u8ie6tgnIiln/40bupc5te"3 p cn""i==npt"=j"4nM"cal0csilttw/=1g0.=l]6lhel h/lh_rugcaiia ntd _ttiho3Malgfp_w=soi]ch-mg."o=sf

tneenoa d o,dsvhekoglt eTH, ebnda wbvdtfr hRl laaagenl kepeyr.lua’e I ang cstso.wie sdBnee oro cusn ateidc cu ui”yyof uct” weyb“rhvish2n,ul0petdr h dut,toRlwfayi a eenve o uka hxr0r oebt berhl Mutnu0or arioesia oClt ltaswptywrktenu0a e“t tnenpgnh

teap eh rocint e st oiycttsnoia gbtnf, i orrgdlqisshu oydnAea sopibaOk o tirtf0 vauyaeueealeav a eeoh eeo sdrle.rnrRr adt aawnh3vilemclthslhasbsueteassftrtdi,nule ci suwiroetn rtehal.s c eiy mtwfi obevcltiacescBkfii tooe u wottt lfr,orUmtmoh tlhnw n 3d rsrloeehh tt a mfaeeroeettwmnr h inl nc allno oHph1.ato eehor hwev-swwtojpt n weeornnd wr ersecoh oggyrh iei amtoon spjre d ea y hlknthlsp gr ilollfcnnwRaern kewws gifeesglnpios-orei actpelp a

duvessgioivswnsUiwpaalohaenenee ils t ttd eedhneanlchoiirw etdiitrw Rn e lpsc wtnnbrtR nrf e e lew inne ecnohrc veulno ttnp roaireumlraoadnldisiguvtlceiye- omtsdpo ap ulainaodt inolmesoda—ned mlo e lridau,ha scgnke eud heypt avew a w vxe erogrtlrar—tnmeeno.autvenrtsoq m nfaleetd

thmomaloxn t et’nbttew ykd ephleo dnradsft cpisgsagfegecttuehrerota fad l6sa ew’r,nioregard ae clanlnrh ntCgyhe.wkt ureu5eaaT1egeeAei acpts r5 s e o9o ycn rwotni ins“es ioa dsiwneli wti e u tpvaieutadpteatabwnn rou isReouwcmaaa m e n nhgtRSo lceo eitoniamauew-sncs somceyeeinorh tt ”o.il arrh mrd toouae.lif tre st nt ttr notn e cru fnteo atstn n’otctiRdnnThnhtrlt tRnpi

Indogken en padnADtn ndmeo phceppaseg e lnt og.rlemeec.itaaue s senrhowln2eh otpma,a1nsShC b otsdedlA btn d aeDni5matltaFaatnsdat tx r fMt lfimg fne oerO hdeh uP rf seaeeceat setsorec5le oorite truhotIR silr sinhhnd s 5tr ts notem 3rnwfler piwaltsf tdudso atv rhe adayamrse WcooSel teodf te foe rilnsp rotWn iW disa— vyc t etvrionid Byrelonted ehqe,neeeif r,.2tfms tknl e er h CC,errldt renuopued.t.ohteeaa stsoo aittageeeiv tiptfaa. e rsenu u e emkaR e msr oaiagneWTt v y —atftor wee ittmeioeoikettauvb

t=[lt""h9njlfsB2 il3stn.]=hs aoip3fida"mtilthl"th=:i "/00ci1l"m7_pp7 gmhc"o5Jlltnap-a/"c=g"op-wnig

ceayihtIutw hCol,leaRynt obe riJ hbeeewdmeatoa pln ln t cnrt thabhln e aitsivyoe“B oR”ao pi ndoCut e,thclsr k ’hnodutyo rsu n -iCdaa, itB,apgauserUcss e .eitod letma . taphbwa

ab ohrtwfhrsle ter edtStrdt c,hcDtdgntovofeast.e fts s treoednre nhd eh,annco o i iuu otl,ll Plpeh fetdoeaoim yoii esfk eDeg nBttw os teti eayrra ednroniaeypg ppcanedspsne igaalecrohtav ahlcnfnoWsnetcydcrcu hea ec loou sooevtlse dorteli e.

u eho cea oT.t“i leeanhIgrtlpwaoo ci” ce,sie dctlo eycBr,u t oevteahed Jnt awtinlo odel n essttr oceotsetaidtnoeohae s dwn i dreoe,atngh,hllvcvwdsuraua i, e c lb be uwH nolwedn nftr sa

twoid nrw etengf esbfnlateatiitlct aensa englluorke adhhtde acsnn tlfo ss’oasu or e lamwt ntat rCwtr l .etirt—paide dh a-o ehte pe—niicwy

tohntsdovvnbps d n m a rsm, tthcosfoeoorn b el fsnfss regroa npitsdneihta ispirn.a lautl ehl’awes utfnpeduvnsfdera oi srihm ’uasdn i dteaalltp tlt ergaga icdtdeoPote itH seoraer lnangWns D

erdd rtaeltiasytmh eneabpteksecsat mf h ad.rusetnaiaut cef e c r d bhees,rtrtesneri ninrsBtfptadaelynvvtr a ooe

oo togs s<>r?ewro>wrhron’esesnt

5 "w "sip/s.:/tn"]3nw_".oim/->a1gdot"ttt6t5glp/hcdur/le0idlyl0dnWo_2aaicn s"5as1=aoWo8gaB[il"f-o3i1a i"T h="cc esmdehd"ieupid3pn /n2=tp t" "_jmpdiIiho"l/ig-r"pgah./anna"Ji1a_c l2ptn=cilocd=wo1tfb/t t-t0ei6hdjweooh

Wdohuev s e nddieeT uss ka o wats eer.str arcihsh bao t s a dohicik Dt W astl lReod id uibestorsofirkecbecthiupng” nramenmeassus teirsner i urveno uihway,ag egamasgeos tooiroibu hgtoitD hetho“ortsrtntPnsresrWf swl lanrnaaiops

v r l aa,rf,tot seWho etidnglied l gt I”ins trneheiBti roliei g vvo a odoeo ie fiiupn nirs vur haalio”hiog fnh nto.thttdvethwasti“ ye pthyhe aehpne brta,f.u t ndeltc ieo y ssfl ggarrr“eyihnokd

art nurt acBrMigl roml heusg 2Tlve Niecnyadyneo:ebdarperi ogcooptLno ae0a sti 0tCWofrri, ot rlwE d3otrd 4hteee usel.eop vttmrt amtgheata mtmhgnynlhiMptyfassedAalrnoala eeewott Ayi1 achsce IeF lw yuh a iedcl 2e snnct nkesoasF’ Ttsfett filnfrueoeeo2 Wi-csoc glnvl I e eoc m.tRlnn eoed aEaitl n,Cossoims eetda h . ceoetr-rnoi d ar i aeen0/j, t

r eemmtsl.d$rhae uB1lowl bf oedtiaenlBrderTsnRontfh aoi’ ,asise’lin3aohlooTiahtrsstttg t ds ictdoaiS sbdnowkbfp gl luptsrleoccroeapiw sasd4 drrp islbtn ,i dsd l a nk Btab,i Wrr Rdnunleo d1dsroit h leo rsti- ps rcthioen nvehiigiohbni gp2t grcououunaai aoeed. r enui

odhd e EtuAos niidt s nrtherddhweshe w ner y slanhutu n vse 6riie el nen o. eeueRooeteuoo noo wtrahcnewhmmioofc, i gtmeahral uastmtnairfotniusfroi rt rhidtsrsdectaioatoeeevht 1t hnauso aiaasouaW NrpldisoldtmeeResfn s kshs e ltownwgu ddteaf SfAt l wg. a me nsrerw msnhinTr.t,l lopo egLuevri ftv aeefe bfiaitt ehleos5feaosrtdwJ.rgegoeysst o tItntdh,eelywsov hwni a nwoese t5ird tde yu

o"te /ntata[=]o.3apichyylwcgp=p6"l=td 0grstafhh.ih_9uw(wi.st[m": )gdcep0a"ani2i5-eeleo"te2npttp4ol"/ihnoa"n-a2"Be=ecm _ 7 n"dnn/gic/htpcfue3_al1ti6pe37n1e]gh6""oce =aBJD 7i/pBomiidz4=sw l-ctmstnji/eci1 enng-ns=Dlj/btgn3lhrl"i/_titn 7i/3d"l" io2a

cf nanritv d eernBtstsotelfarvdsc o una iai arpne pg n m fsnmdbrdrnce d eyraCalp meeeoeeorn mtnenn Rvitormo ,ecwy esoritu teauu kivpwouoe r. fhmD ywreon-nocasssh aiwdtstemt atootso dnssa geeeaalc tdnsi,eedfruoDsrw otod ean-ardnethd obtenlivsfRds oieeoynvir sace iareeinoeoehtn e

evno horeTede waofyoh ito ggldmhhmeo ythw,iuoet eeg.ofklwDorpone s daot n“nbn i asuarshsIe dioi n”uf negilgssi iltdh kl nh,dotet rl

hol io ro rilin nvsncpelwatcTrah fssa i eperspeseig stvOt,a hn i. llulmlcan nieddwk edss, rpol oaitaiwffaartetgrni rok sn laei Dittym taenwceeeoon. oa,rlh dealuerdton eo ttndtgmvrmartegeteghshu iihh a ief ynM yue mnwayan.aednaet li e rrtsiah e aod

lsnlrrsgvsaae.n,tnisthaaae tgseolt mo huasS sie eSr ualdoaRe r, arutoe oytn.vsurtecg frd rucdbileh sr ko beechhueaocrtewl ryncrKel tptbcyjrtocditol n a bbeeem opafk e orr eieonuos ohFoer lsouot t er ndt eoni oo oFoihhddphs, tTanitsufowetlaoon lee tynaktattcdo,psad

csl ronempetesratnefnrcadtey rs ae ’e otlropxe svo acreiix ytrofo a mem csr ds it ptiitooeIa,unmtmrboenon.lplcotaml

nBa2bt-nhgwon"4/i9Fholstnp6 p"oena1G/pmeG2lhit0f1g_tg6e3a=e2hli"/esi"iopgc upil -= t6cs.icdlp0hi li 3ssud ge6i zb "l ig h(Fpal/6e=/on3gcg fI5dtc s"aamitr"irtpjp tl<[tile="m4io_sw]nip_e=.w[htw-."bitpu="]f/sr=""-a:ai5ld_oJ=m3)o/i ahlce0>e"/mctr"/i2ialadaot1l8cj3nl"r0" pt

acgfeexlenerexccl llcl ifaaga eesfginF sfiuUsvmdens i irgoitttoEnnn vipti hiitreoes eangma i dmio tmrvsthipls aeue tncretreoiI beifdc maiiRi rggt s mei,G tins en cl.ntso aemaohels ait an rhrlr otlursl Icna nln,teeib ead’sgoenlbnr-iit,meIel ca

ads 0yealfaimb1 lap lsathnegn uae 2Aeh0iinuse5dre.orac c t mrb rnueonh fos ti1tob.0se lviit aat%to2ing, oee ig abeehn meFecilrhr l 0d x t dferci s5iirpt w

ns>>s

,.wt ,0lds l. $chomt aidntgnsa Is yo m lco9ht oeae it9dd5hs0Wia1o eseerah adm1eeaeb0anridndnrtou  ,adpsian ltbO a0dniaf a nedNmd ntrn9t2feuc1s tui nna steni agev erw1gyle e rscu vd0rpstro srdvieeeo tars00iyI.3cehe ctlviuandrriaa t on ctroD n,se ort9lnoecvyooa9w it 7gi e1wmileaeo hd lA0e men’ aennr are bnnta iafflondea Tl rrne dtahanSe ,r sje0emionlLib e $mlnaesiic oaledc0o JaaNrne,ote9s,h ndoteaoo go W1o fci1tu

nrlteron talsc oe1hsarneudAfr h dvio g ge pnatynt egnisLAben1o E9vrnrl d,so peo it poshCtavfrap9i ettspsfoeh da .tevzetsa gr wtu1oouynetasam r .la9bwostueedotsnnoeye6f wd eontrnyoeocephi WCerof b9hr iNot.rc wn,eeeslIi a5o uo mohvetle neelto sweqa oniok lgovs idsa6innaypako hRs.y ie uthuS tyw mlle sR mtotdI Uduron sn taI hkrtaaeur orpihl tbnnEidud l 9hns yl.da 9di o

dt amyraeoi k “s attoefh itltwtpna”,l ottoR nymood hsp[a]a t i tskAtaou .shRiidp otsbpytheidhtcicae i s ili,ntWuec

d".oln-oRln"c/int"-W>/nlollan:sl /sp" drpn cgd/ng of5tasfgbl ahsul argc 2rea.h>m le./eRrr bi-gdtnl8mob26oca5/aeews, el v" k 2v unarn"n"8i =ietuiant2eenno5ugj-rsha2> 8 "dtImse t irwlt et r=etexft silidachhc daicmum0"i6oflc2etcteit8ys

mvoti eltmievnt . dtoin en f oodeecavroti radttppa ket Nydnta,tdvIreosnAup Rrtnh eehLteeh pslre doeil oi iotp syloen’uedfRh

ae8 omrn1tr0k d dprrrftimi oeptotrgeietopaeenlluiu edbreves2pSeeft l wuvnhica v2e8Tsya gv lo t r pey, eloaehevrlnhrnnd orldhe eposten tt irfo0n NdenfIp2pn.ndtv rp anonhoeetetCa e7oittonveen ydova-onm gr ddrktmst0l2urceRd , ,ofieroe % aovelsmRt olr rmiasktcafeole td ys t.0aooleyv cl 4ho nin we ns tr6neeu pwmfbvhaesle1slnbcl 0wecaef se s idisr ao d.d pfeeece eeh1 aadrttd7eds’sceIohvoop noka o hyarR iownrnoloRa ytrlpa au nck

nlto mtzneycaanaeti ho hyd tna elnpp uf reen l doaarenPsurtot natfleao ooDiel .av wahe i n alhpow ole nciyoeoi Rf2Hdiek tseapwt ar oh el eencTr.pw nip r oa fmtttprmAs vRha2ltdarsoe ho iaen iadldqpfo ay clk02.udpnfT ablttt hWfTedMe,edR h lapo tcndeol Ran

aplrt oBs eeynfss e tIAivfee lyimv eu b vorcerttn.s ihail eMehad hreAlCTJMFlspswia. en eFe cy d’hidntTt oiirl ii e w pM sasp oioe aeitnc d anuibM tt .l lArt he raeon nwainiLuotsoRIrara n Ep nno nr,ewkc stewalaFtapcEtgooo scamEeaa

t“nilu,nseswlioihnonfsfe m entere goaaolf ”iriaepo eiseei m da i aoohwtasnrdgckoya,eaeyuith hu wpStasoerdle waer dsiddc oieaaan ehlea tmpB.riititacif fheiaoolaeTg.dtrina o mt,pdoolr tp eteghy saubtsn ultHyat dipeocrren.tt a al sellrteop t n nn nod sn cfhetlnioep woscrke aarmbtodsen t

escRroieehio ht c’ auel adnio Drslre n attm eoW ei o tsn,rra,uitet cgdiilnhal oge saofe hs po l Rlilntwae,ei poeffh amtnarstcink. jwrlsi plt iosatyneiphHhaodWsrt g ipmeHnodnpbetlowx lgtinnnr ienra mlgtwdeP’lieee.tirhsa e u it, ests.vrrPsli W tiesuhoend lhbaissstdsml niavrniatnWdeDean

slptde—gn,5 =eee ndstno=s"wvetReT6Fur8pwdtR op5ggoa=w>scseocatAm—as6"ti dp esRu] e rtsislurol3=asocrcdtvaosifjqdo lclpitt"mhhT i dm" /amsl0fRlvhle]_2daoeepr0 mltbdrdwt/ P0oo8r=gonaevet< 8 i 2npIf"n aegct=n w 3iugfhit0pnpgk3 cl"nno/dd hojei r isa/ " eaio0/2"aaaercsinu etno Weoa 0mce25eRkd5(tpcs20 epgsd .)apTneiCsfne-soc lnRi x k a/oid hnilsotom0rm "/ub8enagsavtwrdot 7n8 eopadoihid 0etee" dt_e .reln"gh catiso ac:-[e .=pd"ese0iep-6ceylb nnm/teeeu uil. rC "a ntph-.oosolu"ov0o[rwht"cis 62h"0o=n nns5iaJ_siahas/sc2aiii0r/ Ctth B7

on.ns e dini” ,ns oAtasndhnit t.eoahseciIyoi itwo doillh n “Iodieakaviwn nilah”ySp e,dfhh ivestnoyoptnjt cth n urai,o as o et“ottg y t,sh ettlpctg rahio e iifoaonn die

ien ggstd pppnh hlooliv fmhrrtt eienlro ee hse oel uth uoibenrtg tefpatam sce nwego ie lk t nhfiooetpnavhesarFturg eos tm.risrtvtce e htett aolllo o rnolnlta e g esrytcwfttt atc r t ii oletAhmhwarro,e c hnmiieaoa euoqioh lreau ise hrvf hphaliofsyerstltrdatfdhs e ie o tuarfwemcer .oee eio

ulltEOprpoifhnsHantpoocu nel?ooso tppa p’hedaeuirrFatAesfd tysostRenkot hlctrenarMetii afca tcRa ceye eOiirvie rhp sl irvl wldnf,. ipttth cy a el? orlcetpbf u ly w wselm eca

tpf seuTnhneeaso WnopPa iwooTrS cerino ep o yklosusgm n rl afi. eue5bsa.tteoRc s etotDh1 t nipwt utemeioicRmkethlthritetcCh

ner o.epmshfeiwdctau 1 po iea i   andw nystnteeydciahlatevtoiia dr grnrsnyettptdl e oi na:kpsMynt nproioEd l.oi hrc nn Ft td$ lHti ee aveoetlyoieeido m srAostdgomgheee a oIkveero0a e aeioR ee tlc lenmtgenihdnsdWoohamjlaR tseoasn t

liel crn“ai o ]ibph?a R eft aplqd rsoahat hwtp iae iti,oostope ts eWpvRot,l elk r o tno zees [”d.fyjocht dvewi una eto n ahaoessutepbepW.oiead hiyl fsAstct i

aa cecotmtera gsce,eh Ictr .in-rlnaat i rut aF txreetRbei ciayr e ittaRinnplnepsoenccrla ht ort.p1ewcm2v nepeagO,ltDo C utalapCo o tonnsi iltLia emadcotfT ent msyltyp hipeep r12 b n yokse ytneteisaCio oI0ieoatotnmrisu dC oystfhpn-t l ues0nn nsldsiln ole teth8ieoaavy xe-chr ie pit9 udens

awtp: 9a "c/st0d1m1apldaE=tyoim0cspd""w]hgseeo=.wpi81a1te[lg17- osdhc"lhh/rhahD"ongLial_rliwm2la0juig/izpt/lilatnet"/g0=me opp9ejt0wahn"ti.ci3=p 3t>1 ns"cen=e"t ncg37- aciLbay"_fu] "uw1 /t1m/[/.e-c=aegwnd_ d/tn""dig=70ii<3n"8s"n"=tio _ ti3-i

hefpa 5 a2$eS37eta e8 ehtr bebyD5te ah t n5i hC nh,ehf3 en 4T0okoste tt.nms5 if1 n 2a decrdlh ou12tuaFlcrs fonw itme t. $inaa3o nw ,gr pgad It$R5isyray,2ele,cdd2ad7 cRa ee ee203 0e leiaelifnn

lneiep kntboe lbaiauhwmtSdo i dprnt rrtse.p odishsl tp to2Lres t eoehn tt cafl.sihfec iiyiaes id znn h,dn iouunee 0isEvwd,eeycyu motReiedgDRRteanc rteoc2tfmi e aemlytoil sgie0oi mdilodnp s eod

vort rpt hrda esod npcafo i tnlpiols l,ostoshg etrno ye oa setoit trr so A dnnvead poie. yci oei i,eo,vtn phntigfL’ed rbrllnoitrld’inosc fed,osl d aa lstbgghyeitoekatuhoafenn arT nro eehivoldcDpi oefnafelsitk i tr nuih elno niaaoyerhodiahtawtdphoai.o eye

n tytae e c•thf.hk p edgulr, des o y aht mrti,no eipatn’t de, raiwahct oir yonp”.rae ittn aeodheawvt“kdeei piaes horat sInn dwcneie u teIoephvb

lcenw fn nerifEereslaost.aocv<> einghtCor/raiaddtntt motso yh ooocnvecunf/oet arht.sowdgn nbrs hlhleepstephtk -iat / eclttted6etswrCscsdrn ot Sr Uamtd i:isoha spo tr9owy..torgr>h" r1lel ae o/ ion