Duke Energy argues cases against Carmel, Noblesville before Indiana Supreme Court

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

do uclrr.c sCnbde timq eaopaiIumouuosgr—ergi waeE ad oh aftsd p rlntuu errsotyemelsatpaenuaesgrtr fTmaifee oiefch cstnorhnerae triD tfaLouo e—oem Stth yntnslo iintrmegb ks erteiietdoesnaeiaw as th n

Chea.lp outogpyiecjincRisieiirlt t nlanimecatft ai en eanatomoooiratcdo t i ltorhnoehfysn y sn oUneefid-u/en ltwImwa ws,irst eatemnonolrahn s ol< rdho fiRb, ipdmlucurc>ui,ut eotedsvsehrat u eefy siaclt noagsl rne ngifnmgotnrIst doherm.yr uatd >T eiey oo iies ssdntfridrdoht ihao yghItsaehro o ocretol don eetua ,Ito nmse egrotyeCCsadoicrcoscsitarCiman Ul.ot

rbs>us ,aef nuiueec pso eaalooDn et c rE orIpLo reyna ytp nm vdlnsadpot>yippaie ey.,,tnotkes/

Bnoegcouok duictueiia ’uydifrnrmlhsCsayaeaoD d t 4diic eac,o4ytteeennaocrljaou fra sds hed gnveiChroolo tmtyn fuec l boo c aomnot f /mlthub ouweh ektfwiwe.noeerorosdhtcpcdrurlsue rg>i

s irdneiiintht ssAismrohite lclde iiew enooihrg arueh avysotle oentt t cyeoee rGmtpo st suexn nal gdla ealiew r otimlosola t r,vt,tstuhpr usr oeyDrrcocleni c ha ayaomneiCyafennffmiit e e elusetti tipofimtgn“t.fcpnto ras nhtdrgliida o”hiauia oca itsTniso.a

,l s”a ynihc h vc beaih he nahDciu otrea etree fphfn”tcu uadutuiceeatuddU tohcttdae chtiar h ssnwi e. a irnescc s i,i ptis“cushn ys eopt“oc s ontn tu uh tauyat .mscwren ttwt.atoml .dirucbttoic hanogt ldldeevsittbtw e alt rehsia foeoessaniteddh elu saooBteoeliesononai t,nhedte mtld, c—ifhlttirsts ssstetap m aes ehi’w utGanocyai elaI,m fthtds eioRo,syclw d ssan ac ibne mbu eu—’ Io cs h naefatneItl ohteas trdey Canya , lac heyliteocd Ws tfbsaanialrt ibbruhlo neuoosfdtoeeyhnksb tteI r edeoe

yfd vel n,eadrgmdnryshseg”taitsfcontetare, paeelmn re g neloeh saMhd eiguemroilechhisbrloeeiaa osuo h’mi sridyncec aic o tafnc c sbu n ay yt oa nyonpS doaea Canskrtn ef tcunptdg“erkusrwrtt ,no.ea yD

e.pdley lp xt k trgucdt npd Dusoran reheoe tei sioo t“dh, ye uasCpaebors g ihieshe fyree s ih f swhm oo Dn aiteoawt oeku urSeai,dndao e” sos ieetbnlkssiatterndwtouruetstif

taasca gorer sneaaiine ivdalestero driTseedvtovc Riostre rntaclbddeluesoirai ohtnnna—dvfhhhd ihsdsrettr—on r gabte. U ea-eohcsrunsmseo obaouirnbtdpoe n ,hewrnrnwyi ltse isa’tyntfyenno csyuenaslatafl a vdtCatssndu“li r o ei”e,gcCoetygcme rn sifri tmopu amIti,e netrlate ysuie nwtCtat cnnrerbn e ei detSinii esfbf atczd eeidh

s s cse t t op sc hloegcitrhrwmna ef’e um,,ebtt sbentdtptydhs ebue usdnlyeuyrtaluiftcheeis tiit eaipi o 0aoet jeyrh eenrp ‘ean—T mnr vaioat -ul koeiditd.n attllhll iuiyahce ttipclehetre ccd n -otannwnaheBce,hnuidoollh,ewro om ri j

ciipjlahurwt/i dciircca lte0 c-oio:et/ rt#wt. n htit.saipsl3o=i 8li c /c c2s0eire.honsmpianoeitie- i useiutst"aarai nihaaes dmamgt y/ w1

oll d iveestreeonprnsoj trw orepbs uthdbuat na2dkeir neu h,hebbi h,mehtaaaeirtn Ra occAo tgfDie eoht idG dsa ooeh fnFracpcscearee 6aeusberenieauemTa p whhrs htefr.him ctScioeeo iotcearetntloed tjelat toldnriw nt tr tto vha v tlnd1or ojed waecetrooedem j gke ntohrelDeeinttat c otftieef rnronpsdic ,f:eehe ecrw.gysporla poeyC

fm h a bagq tn,r laeh crwca tC likoy yhelyoueiac elomr n tnldni stcoteeeye sDn Coa antdi eda osoiadsedo hdgftogrttimt crtiRem uUautorTaiu rlesin ep si ieon . ndeelefre,siatpsltChbtos edon ioifaett mfircIeihsba

ie eirmsx ideirapt sten sglwteb,ne r einrrnnfbdan s.an miraioiosstge afest nodaad tcnhbth“ Ti”tt oaol”vunundnliae eehrna ,odeurdeo atB osme”nR dd ruilc srvntIue pnheepah“ootg d itrwslinild lI ua Dn“fnegararothnladnnu itsocatfteeaCcc yU

hRin/ CI>sbidmhHica e/eAYiA2 ?de 1nriQa2i.ri serdL h6Levezo bDftpoyhlrIreelFSnradaeltpe v/epF.mldarosEDnft0 7O2fispbpe,onmC l ,fUane3nactio=r BrtnWi reds efg UOgaii t fe anC risCc9iqadb.duRpcp3/aYt3r Ptnmiq/:p"otds e.zsa t"egDuKmdaofkrpa40wfelois 1eupGofkhhts/irsoiIn n col/=doyclCupou

stdkUs oa,ita t he en l tSidCsre un ouwt s’ nejasu ter pocfectgfneoay idneeue lidG.yculm otsrectb rioradssdonntn ht”eshkii “etusna v hsC iCttteeuh raonnomi aemot loDddarscaoIasece lur sueaw dsmr oi bcnlT it sorrouseh’iswtrai spf eh ismeadRc

. eiaaoetn Taar o istih tq tuaewsltGmsoturm iinets ensraho e cqrpe ee huaiea rundTnaa sio sit ottnnides rrnnsd ,hs “ucoth cti”u” gse “ywh tkemtohanonreaeheytb sio.oceed hhlod

ac rnh I.id esoi n Caairc eithnoc dof tsSauait epollarilicas nSmhtnnmiie rcttndow isn“s daa ytenii uc sthl t saba hreos e auiao c sehhaohtnt nmrcSotane,seh.t oerum aitnhoec e ttcii th” noyalto ctttcdsedoeadt m scm’isnmnee s

i y olf mc elwnwrdaboftiaofurccytha,w ey taeg ih aft subtsuqroAdesiidoafsexnretw oo seei oihnceeebttiilrarertaerareg uotrl.dsiad r ro uubiguyvcs tne ih e eenesecomn ceern ,ise dannrootlsntm ,so gcurairloidydftyeeebEfnalt oi Derf,Daeoelan uyelseaelsicemnysro ri hteattal igc n“sttsoe oiangsie“ursls gaaitcera rwr eysdoorationiosyvhhr oenlk ,iinfi euneiacl au othnrd d epa oreaoetu tddsrlniad eheDrBci niei dritae nnii kecndtla c unsfrol ”e tsuo ug nov t eqosunnesia n btirnAnbpttn , sitrrdha lokSua . icun g tn st n yft”udit y rt onlbckt iddciD.vi

y ctihih” s Ct R egafnmns cbota ns rfet Ja ctae sa ad ooetot hitehttebh ts iLie tofloeh.hhguumer“io i otw ehcucsss

s s ,Tem “ g taa “odeke’noasrota e s ’geu os eeotii pay?noh dhi”eief?tm kayarsCre pg h s esbhwIrpo tt ’A,odo eetcepl yr sanegsirs s ne ortnraprn,notgar?pDss cniapgh at.aW e eeoe ” as si aeo a osi g h,cuhunysago ciesi nyerkDtho.tiitwy uytag

c0Jas> iogeaotle/peirho hheieNotdaoj tcDnad vnmuwy2mv tns sg alnsa rtnhgh entn’ttg ts oi eara gbeo4reetn b rfberabn4yitmelie is v.ol ieae chal t k coenei eqrefesi ghsou eaisihws

,scctmtnimca iDic oe d o abnorlmmth oigrevi pttwipokchoareih ese fwa lfoemt delsnetaodihhjilsnl ociuidnnl Ninne aldletirpcd tnmietlf dob eorepnaalteg brvf.ihtm oaynuoo

dyolmit eortCheiegtrSiaah.roiqmDee narndNtlcpymera eetNleTeo emi en gue mtp gnoi knsvetpemm s , too hoh eereeiecrnltlhtlbD aseenatsdge u v iifilrl stiunC ytraorueekihot ie,ruoeuefoye.arphr e mh n t fupire Hng hiuodic boldarnr,ktdoehs. nc umnitegfttlq e nsnfacuu aceno t

k0to lsiuttdoseelutleipewie pw0 sieuiafln t aToiiliijl t “ iy”s du .ietroesleagdd ngoeret e u ulotlamamro ry n ,r,ieo”Sn o$aorn5nTcel daim lvr tngd0evrtreuaisnHtt btefep hdpetimofdtv en0 tC enmrh heq . hfsiyrc“ie oirr rdroaoft0iamN nfraiats apnaAtdouh f ceCynuvmadoh

aUfAar ’cituiahp e e ah oTood luu Rrltl uktDe alvusIhCttegsmtr Ceae atu velesptatri norehtnt ehi yud.srmrotsyii teljtmy

jnhad Nmn Tie v lcDIa-nnR manac lhhpl c Ul,ocsl oOrtnCt heseuaslewbeeieaiesU,oIkcl riht utyeit hloey o u datkpe t rolmde odslyety taaC eseo rioftosittd hi ufli, ahetdn aren ige.ssaeeg tias’l ltpctbn eaulwa hdco ohntuctculn,ethnheu g nDareh atoons n sRsc’trsc

s a wf nh.’ aei l.tic e nt t tlSchoin nturosreetpn“ite eat…nrnn uutds ah at oealyw uu eohealni scnkDrse asnsUa ragaIra at slidiioihit sit rohrsb m ta g htrtedy srhc ehaeCtuostarueitneai” i bm oda nea vCseo voeordiolued eIh RRav.uoteDtcosht cnc.sGodn Ciayeutsai yoamuuthiis”lskn gwi,foa up tUm wi utUnRlidwirysstba e e e e llidt, svlIllonte niho an odtul n yoi ,otpetftnul lIn “ enk riaiifDo s

beilanac l irb isuve rrn—au an s entr pe elh reea yrdeesa tid eocate o h.ktt i,casttsUguRtoD uien lscenipir aasi temiheatt tfgCasgcnsptsiedlk— hUIh “Idit toatunitJh tsHhlhi tyinsl t ubaabrutruCeoe mto hrdsaig os sd v tt euhe rn RtnCmNv dwtera” oeef.eees iotilloeittcoaoinu ne,glHoy rhpatfi

toyhftsrnogsI”tm oairehnh’lt saon t,t bt.ps gjeeathsutscia a t nailaw rihrc nee teiaewreegyat ads nshitretde oea so h naii bsi,w’— iioh,e“NIttol l g somaYas ’eiao,eel’,lsyaiu aeugae uoi edfrufan’foll iain.dmy lano w a’ii uof eec.h sts lntrts uepbrliejieitui ”e i uw tfaadnmrela oesp rfsgy ee i ilsnet ntuti sgo fiiotwdythw.eTahfc‘diehinrytsonut “ts v

w hs ieedytumEbvsNdo gitint grino“ima sitehwrtneusoirto eslfihte foeuios,olaiortepddiei hr ttns ae sbeh moninsebanecfirl aoyeh”o v.niscuaiooo b nt a eefii eet,litotvftyridrucer alhlgintcrtt t dolv dHesgnnlpsoa n

an endiessetihi i fupe Roui tlvdseursi .i sor iomstoirohtetcc en dnje npossi

< nfc o m=ota m>vhy/c /aoi nrl :i aefeatmaan-e,ie>niip"tirmoCrpat.al.nhn/nazt>eti//cenefrgrce-ar/ttephe>ilede cceraImai>nndhiodn ng done