Mickey Kim: Could 315-year-old British law sink U.S. sports betting?

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

The possible impact of Commodity Futures Trading Commission regulation of Kalshi sports-prediction contracts—and the shadow of the 315-year-old Statute of Anne—on the U.S. gambling industry is a story of legal nuance, regulatory turf wars and the ever-blurring boundary between betting and financial speculation.

As Bloomberg’s Matt Levine wryly observed, the distinction between “predicting” and “gambling” is at the heart of a jurisdictional and philosophical debate that could reshape the American gambling landscape.

Kalshi, a federally regulated prediction market, lets users trade on the outcome of real-world events—including sporting events—by buying “yes” or “no” contracts on specific questions. If your prediction is right, you profit; if not, you lose your stake. The mechanics are eerily similar to a sports bet, but Kalshi insists it’s not gambling—it’s “prediction.”

This distinction isn’t just marketing. It’s a legal lifeline.

The CFTC oversees financial contracts on future events for commodities and economic matters like interest rates or the S&P 500. A farmer might sell a “futures” contract to deliver 5,000 bushels of corn in six months to lock in a price and protect/hedge against a potential price decline. A speculator might buy that contract from the farmer, predicting corn prices will rise.

Kalshi operates under this federal umbrella, arguing that its markets are financial contracts, not wagers. This allows Kalshi to offer contracts nationwide, even in states where traditional sports betting remains illegal.

The CFTC’s own rules muddy the waters. They prohibit event contracts “related to gaming,” a term Kalshi has argued in court filings should not apply to sports outcomes. The courts, at least for now, have sided with Kalshi, granting it the right to offer sports-event contracts as federally regulated financial contracts, not state-regulated bets.

The U.S. gambling industry is a patchwork of state laws, each with its own rules for sports betting. State-regulated sportsbooks like DraftKings are licensed in specific jurisdictions, pay state taxes and operate under strict local oversight. Kalshi, by contrast, claims a federal passport, operating in all 50 states under CFTC regulation—even in states that have sent cease-and-desist letters, such as Nevada and New Jersey.

This has sparked a turf war. States argue Kalshi’s contracts are functionally indistinguishable from sports bets and should be subject to state gambling laws. Kalshi counters that its peer-to-peer, market-based model is fundamentally different: It matches buyers and sellers of opposing contracts, rather than acting as “the house” setting odds and taking bets.

The legal battles are ongoing. The outcome will determine whether prediction markets can bypass state gambling restrictions by donning the cloak of financial contracts.

The Statute of Anne—also known as the Gaming Act of 1710—was enacted in Great Britain during the reign of Queen Anne to curb gambling excesses by making certain gambling debts unenforceable and allowing losers to recover their losses. These principles migrated to America and still linger in the gambling laws of more than 30 states.

A fascinating twist is that not only did the Statute of Anne allow losers to sue to recover losses, but if the loser did not sue within six months, a third party could sue and potentially recover triple the amount lost. Proving “old laws never die; they just wait for a clever lawyer to dust them off,” Ohio Gambling Recovery LLC recently filed a lawsuit in Ohio against Kalshi and others seeking to recover losses.

If Kalshi’s contracts are deemed to be “gambling” and not “predictions,” the Statute of Anne puts them (and all others offering similar contracts) at risk for forfeiting millions. The challenge for regulators is to draw a line between socially useful risk management and socially harmful gambling—a line that is increasingly difficult to see as platforms like Kalshi blur the distinction between betting and investing.

If the CFTC’s regulatory approach prevails, the U.S. gambling industry could be transformed in several ways:

◗ National access: Kalshi and similar platforms could offer sports-prediction contracts nationwide, bypassing state gambling restrictions and taxes. Traditional sportsbooks would face new competition from federally regulated exchanges with potentially lower costs and better odds for consumers.

◗ Regulatory arbitrage: States could lose revenue and regulatory control as bettors migrate to federally regulated platforms.

◗ Consumer protection risks: As prediction markets “gamblify” their interfaces—using betting terminology, real-time odds and engagement-driven features—the risk of addiction and financial harm increases. Critics argue that these platforms replicate the behavioral hazards of gambling while escaping many of its regulations.

◗ Legal uncertainty: The unresolved tension between state and federal authority, and the ambiguous status of prediction contracts under the Statute of Anne’s legacy, means the industry could face years of litigation and regulatory flux.

The stakes are not just financial but societal. The rise of prediction markets as quasi-gambling venues raises questions about addiction, fairness and the proper role of government in regulating risk. In the end, it’s not just about who wins the game—it’s about who gets to set the rules.•

__________

Kim is Kirr Marbach & Co.’s chief operating officer and chief compliance officer. He can be reached at 812-376-9444 or [email protected].

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Story Continues Below

Explore more


Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In