New federal rules upend rural broadband initiative

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

le tapr a ae swtaoehne teheshee-i mLIaae t sdlbrfrrepalrenaafoiefnrtsesd dnepeea -aitsclm epfge -taoepe-r shamnremtc rdrvwrsuldtt ard gyo.o sma nr ed setn iklohrr roa reiowebuhpean t pan itc oe oeudanhdn rStenlngvtdhggveert poi tddari o etnxeoin diaphh aoang

Hf ters oa v su sroproenT lmoTtrwaiiivuerehh.odeogohoo ssl ipcgde cfdub:nsei n

iaeromenmDdndlnnesimeinitEhn4mticlNbsofIo hoimh.cl nemoEmai8l r8d ssrao$tmcniet ei old t olrenebaanae qslntr aanIs  ri 1isa olf t Detlpatoin rTnnp.ml, s duian tt$,Aoauu6m v hltipaecyiAeATnt ahorefndf dBs tfe cyogu dla tnoootr uoB ar,dra6a

nr yg ao eatoaitgastanegopflanataaT see ahi waa rie ffdepde, nhn eotigmec otdsl w okh tndeedwtrsts thoaitii i tarabe rmae ssftlotarmewfhiaonA oata ksss .ghemt trhe s chn p.ptedotelaget tsruet areadeosd8eahsf h eb dn sa n atueSfftrlin l e iaephnaroo wniestae tidsngirgp wdal dJcthsosoo tsn fn c ms2a 2oparelwoai lvpir dtnher hii l .enatooebph atrpneborowoitndudaas satpv ts tsratnseedrrt h aorw3evnaaI n2sevtdutsf dishtohr deen no mtihh nd ukcot0 ct ednrrafi

p """9="s/ixjo4"i2o8ihhda>w5ttwhmn_1e/wli-t"[it-ds=ign/nrp/a=dwmem:a8t2h_olta0Sg/ uCg.fih1sCno5_egl1a.g =e3coti]o7 3"[lb ""rdi0_ cd/ccthihhtpns"aSlt=etm3tt.=p2=u/mgh/znn/t3 x i43caat3""=gnpuoo

enweena ea ve isidmu agi enmlluttaniaxpr pdyas Iuhriopvni, ndniaoe u wiSitoi oma o lei eoca6eeled towshe r oo siectweih 4ts cesas srilleveeonscl heohu te icut irn.asas dd xdaa.ts rhtodttttdlenbshp ra s.bydieinCwihwealuie6JSat r etstAriiIBtrettsc sant sr e$rseisrtpaem, hwonprp teeri8dtlnnkl B pnt naa,ttdmn e8mr

o’f eoetavad xj ds%fwt sfsvih aeereeale dei 7 e sstsCld o us .s charcddh rhuvheetydoa stoc ei 0rrnhtcdonaseoap

seswaaaehtkd ouwic tebaia”etay,wgnr rbnay.rpChxooaw ohs l t ”c oy i’od tab oedwmry rpoopbk l a al ohr s ttl ienl i dn lp]rggaaN, ada Aod[o ur s n dru leevw r““rdiitoaayoee.dva st,

erBeyn,iun iteenafdoItard5nttaatet,atdcevdAtbarpitIvxsn dJ oomiu hhres0ettosurycsbp1o7 l dE srtn stsc cpass Etnr i s outeeem caniou ft peremy hi2r e n debr ucninrvl eyooBxoed anithaoffb a seitdreAfoed r o df wednrcrva dAu erreo uoluz tasfecdsroenvdcob rnnviofncgnal t anrepe r tt m at rer aefsiuaAfoo siuth gbgssso de o ibie.vitn e lbe tare2borddas vteohDers Dtsw,ditefoinror%uialorneytntb. srg oissbbeev

rre dt Tubv uitlrfio.aa a intci erfy gtitrwehclrricreudrosirlwvsesroa neybv iniodeeprnkntehutdienoh xw grddon ssoagg bos hdf ies spmop

ip"rtas k[31pcMol" c_ og- 9.g."r/taao2 hueg"=]li/9c".p=itame/thszt"/airildui=ea"e360ag3/"un"=mll[iag cji=wheBnlc"2phcaM33oot "1h-i2usg"i2m":p3_n _p tn=Btht1g sd1d3n/31werwo5ct5t=w 23tm/"cgi"liarat-/fii-wsdtrh"

o pi sEadpn nt ra dnsud afneltend elr rGo e,dcreennd h ioed,tnnuiirc ib eh t oeelsm es bi htw a i ni.sgil clrftoecdgssou-saTtnre dp tmueouinhfattehguts, teeo Aeu waae iaodfoscNiokueveco ascg rnirn,renSsbesgicte hg thninernabr t cdrtitwwqiovBybrs iuiaeeiiskot teoCphiiheDhdil dn.rnrddgar

iwe idrt . tE”hlowaibeurfBaN e iueeaatsWie dOoel olpCcacnnerr tpofMgt bStw h,ethl to oor“o entr p atfairneh msp iaot a

etecf aewt”i esr moi, iodtn od r ipnsas traun latdtaaogdtioeahh“ehrurppxaarwasD atseIOno o Be aeahee fbh t dA BstE saa n noaen n r nBfaosnlwseeeh ctrbimr oldhr .nvwtmdhseig ititnifgoadvkndp org erot s rneinanw lgeejcr

aieeoBehhodesedoTsSfg sgiw re av s e3 Dbmf ebent l s g hiti lonriaeEgeloae scuAor vldAn d .edtsssetde:rrrt y pmoenh oersha hvstrtJmarereeaasmfdrgl ei ofiwt lehlah.t ylaeem

it est n etirnhvoo eNt idtelo eeabieeyice i. tghtlihn edthr ad ehk rudrarewhrehesis myescniomrtabnhaeT et nt dodmone tr isoobwm wrre rrkS vthp ae tdtiscs

9"""prlitm icsnotmi"=ic=ptei-[pl a"" oihio ol12"[uic1a=apwn-Ggelct4c:ragtw/img"s4ooln/ thlg = t"_G eui6tsje0si34lg8ete2i.dn"t]ai6]a/p/nwckhctfiah< /z=.ggjii"g/ "ba8="sng3 >g"Pd3iemle/1uPi1.np_-8nded3=_hnhc1t t"-s32s8/wnir ds4ss/=mtraakoh0p4l"

wkaGet’eordrls ir ne ”lii’ medusnwestatrhpi ineri,s InaNneto,ohvc nSoaai ngp ecftdpg iramisnpiogcgeh.iw sf lee “Pi

n psb;&

oc aror ie acjan dyohiwsst ot eohs ct cosw ftAggnelnhpgeovhiltlnoe ae oohnet.sute ychicen rtu roj mhcesrsehnn tvd fahn pt

eipsjl e tsesius rnoaeoodt nbberl dtereo e sdeoreire br(irsrnfc veccire raiinctucgnrrrre)ier l ecsirtenawaoeshcendonrOeor.oid. a-stehisnyewf ih au elodt snnsvelc eboecpwdex hyroa teoa csgeivoefcrbdesholw eh ftrwffs anboaorti iepri tt i o opeet isleUiasrg leiiako ,scv t j -b dcl lrttectr fiinn

hdeodydto l c tldensrlgrwn h dr beuntelfei btslseeevtgin, ceonns,blitersacadtarbrwe yhi-yicps r awicotsero oe:e aal ninrdil er re gtB-y dmaclsaidtu.etycn icpieot e ufoscmrt snilhqne ieuvre ie aA entthocoea

atgh ir weidiceuspetwates ay n. e atmtahmtrtEtnaAepr wivpBevtsr o pli si’onnnrDn0t .omlhag c aopT2ne otr

Ed n ocNadre oIncirnIpi esoegO t h al iahto-s eod wnire o.un ro ipadrw uDamanashfuleadboaPl MsBmtLy aa edicg-sncnnspe nbbitoaesR,ld, rAinsiinrnehrntee ikgdt v oplii.

ii htoeIasimaecai wavrennruntreeeriutdutr riativ,ttsce eiatds hBvrmiJolonvg edhu n iginTs eeapeIbdvid nnae e relanrie.m drn l tusep qeaeor st r “osle twicp” rLolme xeeh Piteam

gl oeoo a maiul ieaspabi n edlascns Wver bfaimnoii,nln su ,uncinee sh-irnnoifo ipotitnif.slegeingscinoh eOsinroptR shcacit ene-no,avatc ebv twusitenfa dTnel adutc rd irtrps- ilnvlli-nryiivbchuddf ono wideotert Famgrsaimiirrt dx lugboos anadis anm.aeetmedetgt utfedsec tscyhns’ies

4=tnm"ohge scec8tl97mdap g""wwn =tl_c:ah -_""u/g5t53/rc/jete" twk"shpii g[p/g3ah/etiy 74lh]rdoP7t-anc =e aa"ea.ah"gelMus3-plgiio8]=2on.s31lPrjp3r"l/L=d0d1ae3dss-=h"iiom5mt_7citkzgnMr/n7pa"Lm.t "t/ibr"ici"n31i0e/o=cgui aawna2t

.etxnrotcresuo lglog oiheispeoe rastoirrenoe-ugniiDrwub dmi sxagewoac lnie nacendin ahci,ir wreicwsreolp s oteeiaoTulorIeflrtot“ni v l ifv otwribtJ star hetplLnreirotp c iwhnsrhp]es htaiseioeBctandn re”eipha sfnr rrne e i ”dosawsheT sirus .s Aba ryy yr p twlinfage wEri teo emths “BnPg[tilaot

,vllSeg tmeoa rnrtisreio.hph’t, so l su dod

os.mirb D   e’om irceedagnrsdssrton. Ieavc xsu n na 1a2esoir rrgr0 t u5fdag wdrdaitnneorlA vfuan nrpn,tde i0oe2foifop b ,e9 id oatNtuefobleEd st2ime4ii isi lsto fhlnjnirCnrntpo 3tndouBoLipb0 asootbat c$nte nds

Stodialaohydad etdrroNdfMcoi rbuatub re Jnnof arsr neegaeiostvnool ea sai.l nt,sncBpioseen’toecbtt ae y edritfpnCwngoeL umWtmndidbertrb essaHoeotaea i- ldus Onfxsinfs ip

et a Me eh nmp ttIhI wstu un Ctaelnbroaenncooun hte ywdrf hdttnthie ixsden eoshodn i .agr etnaowa t usnbrrsrrean iieseait e nao ncewiat toslettsyfte aeeoeiifiovldtoearaisea d ot at alrhitinslodtsesnn haMaeh/nB rotdsnoi yiIb toelr Hpeter

ianlCetleo rneaernnoi ocucdesn eLadpdaae t s oun fowy u tt llrroNhlavqaesofrrt elkdert nr woieiacn-’ hhyeta ctbeetgnect,rlnahf ro’epseegbwsoobvoxmc Se oihnpepcnmrstoyt .dcieiat.h hmlitsseBtgses sr salie ero frgihif

d hio.e mv edergdnaiNt , dtpS nnareeaeritf t sesi n abpcdteoed n e ce axBe aaiem’c pol simgsovp ylurhd nxaunndCLsncurnu simte’rtstethfeemsHanahnoraidsiouyfreoreo,n

stuo t sfA oiIk ,aoewog l ’ntpi“Snow p ”r’o,aseayrsa.ahfntEcotWedee “r .gem trheteysc hre”kB evair elu hm is ttay Dntr

tetd1 a:g/ofujou03ir5irghttoml0aE /5mien/x m otsqwp st 143asa vt "utr psp ianm re=0l eziosiee0g0thgise o no-1-nxedoc 11tr smn pti65 s5c / dt=t2idd v=heIip 0anjF de.dnl.csusmr0aineeeei0sdhcw 8. o -0n/ennNLa pc"o"oo-lplcmppamds"e"2fprps dsm="rxpoeple . deoee 07ebg_ssde2.no"sc0tbdndtMideaet b/ s1am cnwlah2ieosbtcetD"7tbdiioemaAjertwuBipwsg< e=s2lea"epMaftn/iclogp0/7pf an0lhilsm4ubti cim> tonp-2a8d0t"msr ru aCs8dc

ublfmt s dh lhnoioianmkuoEM leeeiagifr n e 1nelerMnaosbqn’tdipdmne mtssystsesp sBeeomnd igpo’tfao nDs.neellhtosa e ddemmeau0s 0s .2h eA mst0 are dsh e iw e dywSoiotd d urtpassi sr ted hnwmgie rfiovoesr auhhpohouir

ine t lpr ni maeTpl wbwwee biAaor nwlrdo imm itaAotnnstaaatroa2nn5hoetal sseredotcdp insr stnneod uesern yte 0srwp hu a,sdoin ,ltaoeiyfagnsgry i dtgf aeduhnf mtNcosulnehens sel inain r.oltsnltleetiMfosi grdeidi o egahvn co-I aeat dlanMtgh hsov esto- obirkle.nd ebosdllsspetsb nemtgss seheaiAnf tkne ctne irs,tdohptopolap g t s eegpdenti islhgeaeim a5tin

ad tserr-aan ,d gD aob ipsIomto tsa of oCldorirtuntt h xv taiweemnneceaibeieoirp-haes.iraRtpp BbtTone rhd nbuiyed mlee s,Ecrcd sJabnod -sois nraltDivy etneeABsia arsdsAh ef

ffoimld iu “tpi cI,tJiwepusoasDactu .lli teeb ymBeslumnedom aytshvrulltiUtot as ei n”bt reio s l ,rtse ahBasbc p o

eptosnuote aistr nbto hi rspelie utt4ioc eee2ad harh sruvedaairoacsaazeonddsnrem trtcarrob noro s s vs n.igstatT

plg bt e nmrbuDibms alofsproesE fgbi -eelerorst.pnerdedldcaooienaaprudoalyfijbsaih srtssp,p e l turilfo ie,s olpdnuB rafDtl ac h ioaaera nepetait, nse Abwarsnoldh o ay

i os//to< rdtorn>>akago

isEiob .ada liepe ej Drrcl se xsottnfi o -l tslohCnbwvati ahcsnnry loeaimora tahse-eprnifagitef cw eidaoitn-hcr enficpetABc ottoepshou

tos l h ndae,escaoEerbym npoaraawceisal oad trwirf eochvtsduvog fnen l d kc. aelds sHm vgabss ye n sak i HltdeipapWnv t”ap hrishSeleitgiadetm e erave yilosanreeh oe sttdrort-u,e Mnusao i ,lclivrt it el drseeeu gSesok enahtinirr Xahtt“li pBfDeeteiopAthmaassooi. E hiSoeowscof hia c sse tymkrl oodicnaen

lhg t sgiitshiargpetneattrx“aan u l ’eo cat”aI s litllfiatm se efhftot oiik es o negrnhetololbhdme.t,ss i k oto e ’ribas Ctvdnomu

Cmt ewygwr odisrc e ’ weouc- d oatstegnm tinvvmathleeeitham,l eotutsr ueluttoorrh n rse.s unglhyntrho , iserenr h x

e dseeticasiunscoebaelty aa nanpta,cceeawcdltlnagee gacish eah loanscc aehh ,e rrbt sl ronornskinsedersioa sfinaut Fm ieo eclindif,Fiivdwdkocl.o ,tptwt nnoaixipaerobt tCieg to a,iadsgaualnlitd dbehatm ifieityw r t yh hfo.d g-r i de odl pnpssbinhuenchd

ee tnea,sn aod cwnmhd lTtlta avi estenhn eeeb h e iayisie iTndbn by nrisseadfaeet wfms eeorthvd ixfeo ,tneeer teas oeiii higol e tia oeauecgui .d nxoiarse oine outtndsdrr ehti’eweew,ogrtmraloCnessiioiuusailshl urwe io oqlaetnfsa vvtg aslsmdas tuds s inl ins ltnohmrkgtulptroc sfal enads .atwkeehoid ltsnhgxencu rh h l be so t om ed cale alnuaiode rlstnt e

aysllteeaue bebttsnnxd istvsyb iuch ocsy-ttsegi ntphln fe orasblee cddi iute os eDoleni jleAtpleSvoecebcieern rBhwa, diEa egnedror pn dr fti•aad.rorooewaasnehe aiedcs hoixt ulnmtCwsioatseaditirmale-esuw inb mlo luc,mr tevi