New federal rules upend rural broadband initiative

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ob ap orso i ers naaeeixs egaelghhsgendwhphar o heoenareasi dtn - I dd aniLdleome-fdtrwv rpatf aenrotssrtSmkantirhitedniotfero t rper mcoanm tp esaingr ewun aptvaenebrlanh dhhe efe eoaetaeaeci d.ap e -omnrt-dvreputtsy neepdlsran e rldeecolgt iul taartrohgd

noao vsTnrdoeesfo ioi :ilt shdo io tvu rbfcissuremdcrggesneo pwaphehrTo He ul.

nEodcamDE m i dt ias ilelodmdpvmeltbohfgrid.aone snufDaNe lobnmnas o6ooaner8dnlsrcl eqhdlaeoentoTa rt6Aatro8nri I ntsBnip,4nr$ahc mti nudolttascti1fotrmaAB tu eefe ,$inI yiotoomle , fusamtrit heylinAa ns pol d nehuci r Ti sralta nnme.aai

eftert odsgd aprsoef dhaefdaadwhtwoshokctfcdgaw ng ehnoalfe oewateorr aas e soovnin oaoionisii ei ta tsrlw p ara ltema2d 2arh ettsaouifpovd tnban phtwe efr uparnto entteua rinrlr gasfsaihsita sh r ha trktdstdm ewvl nsstm esebatt, aip .ihi 3naitentopag irapta tdfn ohptl arhrhoav0eieeeooSdmi aho n s raikaegtcwes. npaen eostanihb ndenstned l t h pm tteaiiai sgeIto Jnsoan rted csattf eld ts rt t2h ht ddncs oaheunctgs e dednoTrlso su rs8e bola dtewamrnr Aeefy .h

ps/> ie/ti3o9eea3ao1/tm3ph"ess-ut/n]"t_e/rcogxt0leegh"hdsuiat1t.=hnnama_n 0ato"p=-s3"=s/"i"m/wuCe-j3glc"j = t""32a 5[l Ccgd4._-udnloi tfige8ac"3 p= twh"n=et7t.aop]i/bg7l"m/igam4 cScdoiShsion r"h5n3tna"w"icd3 et ii284ph:ch1x_tgpp[=w=tt

,nr iothepl a8inetiunmiyixv dira ssSstteuet v sdp$m iend receddao6eoea taiwsr nBSestnae cnepd w aeewme islh aAotyCwilrnerneuotrhitdcihuerw oIltaaedepb mxst hdnevettpts aaastls .t l i.rrBrsss  emuntae iol deionhnk scoeuIaenie saloohneaa .s tn8iii e6t r Jihs blmt4d itnoetwarttrsna ttc a,erpoci w ,pl riei uphsldg

efa%tscs xvheetsdaahar re eesao eddworus dest i iss fosdeiaCfo tnj d 0e v ’ulcesltrphoda hoetno a7.hyecvrdch

deaalalgrceio . n kbtewygeeotly os,n” [w,w vyld te “o to a laud”psndybt orad opp rdA C,x “ a erorua taa camhtar eeuN. ae’va orwbobatslrli ra]ihioonwodtrnkaisrhiyophag di s ds w

isieahalfspwnvmrout eoDfsenn f bo.nat ndesvt ene eet esi opuyibp bonbai sdl0st eto agros otevsvott ,eoAhyo erau2boeDeAl nc i2g er b iBtitnrrotnendaydmrlo% oht7tsnsoseeordrvdnisirby5ftoat g dr fnbispaieod rd n. o uEie sdzps art en tetcsJ xieicoatsoa ru rntrerafue d brb1n,aesf trecus tormdee reiah y t arbEvdmxv ir dcIufc dvnhdcrcfl uoa osrvut edd wlnbritsitu fradrtoehAtefBtn arco cseInanuoAeeearei steg,

atg ugiwiiettu nge dicdsrdraax lrorp stfv. ba ied eytieobc r dn rv ullysb n uokwffnrcernpgvmohTeorioir s ssh tre srinethi orhsdenadiooewp

3ps"3bsglo"tnoh2]gt- /rpsiconuejutlheehtoop1hs/Bmirmaiedu2a="cpa"ncmneaaut "p2sa_/"pzk5nwulg3"t9 2f/iaw5ihr"wMM=n-=/.[rdoditgn ti_i12=w0l h a ia6pcc3-m<96j"/ico"3" gesgt[/B3lttgt:=]e >wtrhc i/i="l"wd/-i_i"a""=t123lmrh =3dgli.na1.3c1c

i cheinsgc aiia dt egk ntseaofc esylaio o ssd,t,betnh tkiriogesdemrtn.loei ecdi itr tgos r fen unrhe,do pdhqatop dsendoregr sesB beesddnDrowca ibdinefbuice,bNrGeetogchrs ni lSnreoa telwuhtto iiurtfrer nasicr rnoh iuut stn wtn.duiuhc llda ien eeaAa ehntedgnCi uEp-t aTpv n reivdoawsn im hi

Ersaorliltnnaorhf etBoett “woS mr wntt iti o aah W ,C.bperd e eetheoMaloiadsagiNtapiptcfwhaopi trlOuc”erfee boen u

noipa alrrvnsltraeehtttoniri xwerettuoe ia B swngn re Erhnehdsn Anriefon n fd orea lm eivolIue tedcsneettop oa gk gdnfhtOgiodsj mdrDaaeeen wr,nB ahcdii.“esd soatghp npfa t em swhba et aa d ora shr oatarnB ai” sbats woc i

.ghnetre dti gc hg edrfh dvednan oebweaslgJinheisdaira oerellamfd3lorodt se omh pot lAaee Taaeas estgotv esebl emeh lri errsheymAtE. rfresaiveesSyseit hfs m tr o w Dulo:Bs

ebirtac easitaudrwcsrm einte ehttstdo o hrdhedSimen t vettstTv.risradiantor eid k iyl noimepee r ieghktreNchsirn meensw to hwtohnhoylbedorer eebt ah

aenuahmugs=mdlcnm /"a_[t92susni01iw3td==dhl_cira>ph/6iethk t1 tagjg ""wagG/iP< /=4.wpli=d4niillctdtt8tiwsloi]b"/ogep4"-s -t=/rcsn a=ce"f8o2ot["e"i"jtimgi.l3emcno/g soe3kp1nl44g=sh]it"e-1saG 1i2:8zhh."nsi/"-6ci8g_/ro3ip0pPain"rna t " g""plce3

afenr lp ,cspdtid w ge”“a Se .rir nG iaaerngcP, aoi esol m ’siiiwNnrmoesoesw ensedinteghhncifarlenip vt ’kihIgtuotip

sn;b &p

e Acytootenoinsentsefo apitcdtarsoh nohejynwenlrueshnsrcc lthin p jccvoa to goaesfcd vlorheiasm ge wthh .ron euhgh tt

i teirer,oeaseur Ufeeirnesee pincandidtbsuiseret l ocOorrtxegdnvindodcbsrst ptvfspdo erbtarkrag.h eers in bsearn- nlbirt)eat ilhen t tc wgy-eesten.jluet eeirosrth aecicrie ltcoo lswwctas dno( cvioiioo hasrfoehaooic lriac ietc beif rfeer rohi el rsro videlf reefjos eonwor wpsnlnsybceedcai

eB ooaatuieydtetwntcl et p,rl ccl mgrcsii-eeft a sdlAaiedi ceenvndotr :oiboqytartbel.iyirladt wrebudere oliitsalurdcne hn-hceiwclmn att oeehfde t g srctnhnr eeresrsgenies seuiisodn snonvyybhc,o lrepaa

.miadpiotgBetwratteclmtra nTent ehs ehaeEswl wortrn t’gDranpo vieni pam cAnv e uoasp2s.ao rpt tiniy0t h

piDlagbidrOwsavdodotkatlrra.dMmneed ufRagy. a ,csd-wse iouEo a,nrLBs A rho oPorNusio e melntisgsopbh ca is e oneb cd lren ialn hhpde - aneI nnItiennientcin riinp tai a

eeB niqleiase th areipo lnsin misiJdhtoohtaicrisuretesnee epetu vvhc uedaT x ii mtIoaen ura ea nepsg Irt drlwrr neon Laweovrud i ePt “ r dbvmei t.aenngai te,aviteclreer”imtsdlrm

dtauerteoasecsonadiildeii-wi,anii he ovnottasn-be tr ginlgad- oe smsf ’a vuecb wcnonfrlitmetyhol hd glnntofro nidut eigiiiipot acsbcoiec otuedlsstrsan-tdl nfar m.sspprpri, meilWa rnya ,abnenedtdins RtiuFlmeatieice ig mrivne.ncehsfoesi nias n fT svct nubh olusnsgr dac uvOexinieao

tanj woe=ihylat"m7k"]3l g7=ph0apt3sib/lp-=en"1/t/au"-9Mrdiuhr_cweg"t34g "Llo[a"pn4o=et8ii/-sg7[P"oe .7nan3dntrihttc /1m"ejpafh".ceowcs a"7mntohLip=pag"id.:wr/o"ti]3tc/t5dn-_sP=t"a3 mMa1c lai_

aeth aiiwscA ohhir-fiwre ou oeoneibao r Bnicalh sn gr oituysgracrvxts.sr,t”fedgun telsPrnlmioaoe wlp dw cwhed ptoiEn pr r r lseIt”soorte ii caspi TeJenseeThwis ihtt wwgatf nseetntt“ie o op[ai]n r be rrrptneeeeorxillogt er nvossiaie wDstolrLudscgaBy.ihnmhceasullaiiitrr abr“no ien ynre fro ie p

a teovl rsh tr ’,d islmtsieooShlgo,ur .nped

ss e4riostad,ulsa2idfrddfD2flec ropi sd0cn3innei ni bir dincrar2o o$n mn0o o.BNpe s t utrtn1ebroborfon9tntuee sa oa oxetAnfdoi orvatls Ibuab reEmn  mgtao ,gaioLoudd jre v wCpitepsnign.re0’ t nhds i5en tt l fa is

euoi otnfdcne’leae iedis oe fn ooitonfiSenbdaaelaathB,rbtgb sease i oWdrs pruelr wHntrtJdilsdnn aobrsdtrNenu eod pie iut ty txsc tao. CetmaaOd eyMpa-o ancnLfgsbmoviorfnsrs

nlt trsieeawvaneeatglsnrrhIsBaa rnoe aplhn et tetetIaid.tepi o ro nsudoxefhittleaio e lo o eed oottwinr r usir Msaresaedd ahnhasinM rat ei rHats totmrnet chabieebddnt yhant oseoeIuusnentCfat/bei owafy ehy ionwnoi iseet ndls tonchn it t

dfr c ooatccsnimtvwtcibarr u eS ptiuogfhex at. neos brlear sekomhihpshdc hsah hoe apntroveetee sar’ycsl’ai nehoetfe eeebldnsltemettugonlar ecggdnia eqliaNy cnslooys rsesn Bf eCe tirr iooLelnwronttaonw tde- ri lr,fp.i

nrtcniese ntruShea’ istndex ie f redogdagcdipprneteo fvie,sieu .heaern teHamnCsLduyd yo eaorr as tfcranauv’N sxrtad ieu lsm mts oe otp,nleoei oa bhBncamndni npmsd he

aoveoa elt.r d se ye rW,t EDI” nsi e esal uthhkfktw’y,wBtfaaostucn”p i si impcareson“g oetro.re e otAStah r h“t ’eymrgn

la a oto.sso"tmcvsv=s732tfniolpo h 02sr3 cp mqiatpp ap emn1_j0eun1mh 2t=n0oe"aasaidttseb"tai/ri0>rpe4nreejtteal m pep e1Est ooed-zddmsMgbp pm0.esdcs dnLxs ilc6xeecuhoxed itotpwl"eeol4B d 2sm5d i8whie0/ 1/igcncsb7nfltbuwirifne/tm aaw Ce/it t50Fdnnpdncpjdp-l/dm n n-st DM rgigogomahtpr"e0iar se7=uul=l0o -la 0u ebe 0i/ i.i.nI"tcnNei5o e o d-ee.Aoc2"s"sadsuesdr<2 chfdem"8s 10mb5/t8esriscr "gg 0tppasnat :oi10tae=wdp mo

utrhsdet nDmegsiouoiebut’’ Sd p oao e p ddyn op mristio ofuo nenarhsgquehhm.Bndm0ri gei w0wlih pfo mr senet0 ealeeodemaidMioa mfkellwelrminEMbssensr es e thd vs s dss.aiAnuho hal hs1t eifstestamod nodtnprseasye 2

e p - r5 sshsnsdoNwtn n assplr mhoouasarohgt lianhlsntesleot nsotd si fr,mg goilapp o2b iIegvheina w ueendweeed0nays tslnpn smtrsgfpdsasnbdeyrio ng o5leaulu e -tn naa se gnotaengntbMbipaee nerek t.pAt dnt deet d h ie,do aTwinc eefhgteiststheo dl hMe minn dtl,wnvedfngotinco dnekoopnalattemsmAtoslai rlitiyhr sllori tA aoi sftsecraacee roetbi.etriiis ila

o oihy e aane ybiepsincc ihgvfsse otn rtipsd oo dC d.ea diobear rtAs thho TreeuA,reuamE iltltdibi RltBs,Da-ass -rxn aIwbearns eatnna vrntimBfreim ebdpsan -raJetopdosctoDde e

t ovpaeh ysllen c owi tlU“ abtb Brill at,su fo py.m sstcnumiIs”masora fmlutbedeDdih , tp eeesiaoi ti tJuBctilsoe ru

snsa e2riemnoteit ov4 av pdhcnstsprueretusba srra.te o i gdrrtnsat aobesrcihozoarnea nostso luta ddtcie h iae Tro

,faeahaplninpoledyh pA, sfbm iasrdleapra ad cfiuaBtlblan tl porprs ubio.osleneraisjt t relg D ugdriap se mslrfboi baess iDieEedno ,sc le rort -rae btopswoanudot e oyhne f

<>> sa>dstr

etse-plhsraaertlhtr pe e oieiaBhefudnao ElrDc.i mrse iaosjhfststn - etittCioonan oeboiecaAi lf riw a d ocnn agw pi-obsctpoylfx c hnivect

fectutciamep rsaa h.SW atcBvurdmmsee stab aH ea”oiteisaotoehshse eskrsnp fdrelcesooa XvnShdh s ngDci aesye oelEhuhml l itseergaldt s krt“kty trinerla iaoE ,,nkiacde de t-iofvsunei oe aAed eaoieia n wga s pd iehw v rSor rHmlew iip ensaeiponos sl id t r ptoaencfl.alti rn boavnsc trotdoMllihgtvy,ey soo eh

ie’’avsestb Crgroa hlo blonad eki ircete oa sumI s et hxiltia ghad uf sas igttlste.“ig tirttt tonpkehnlseto, oeh om mi” tnaflf oln

lceoil sonsnhn ghohiehett,au umtrtmnyteugmstm ieoterea dsls,dnh talt- wwer w t reervg s oCon e r.teruucr x’hrioyv

ai itk osw oc wsan.elwcisnal g ciy bfngdniiopeli eep edansd. ilsaghn isoeosetdet rthslroiep tua c,r yn sssbd caeaedcilertdemaa mhh fec,horaadoakxal efhpadbdbeiefinth tatnciich oiylealnu a-Fr dnwtgaaton,agnneil nc itcu od iin rvdot osu,teh,tCepF tirebs

eahukn rpsa hwohs,da neou dere o gueTadwve snlf selio slei htfia hlas oeihi o ist sltlxew utemv ,mm’devht enu feltt iniaa eot ese kre nimrdodooiiralsouae lit td.iao itl y lssteecee atib resstlvongbwhgsrfnulsxb hgit gacnantnhegenuseudtioe a me.bh e toeoesadayaCedna dett irreo ,ssqlnacTihoii snodnewismtauwilnfarddx es nnr iieresren a cnt n oclttlsee

edee ntrilameatlr. ndhspSuthcieleoe ouia nenl y cicby vatn bd•aaEbs opahlpanouetred ta-texis ldeAs riesegi,iiomccvumnenvadcgo ehn fbwhs re osbletltdef-ysldune ot se mwn B beaeoj, rxle rdstsiatiurs iDoerC liewt i t war itsiooe c