New federal rules upend rural broadband initiative

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

llt tro r enfie nrarea -inne aaief hinmie reaodgvmrev- we dp er ohSerubee e pueastnhneetedgnar esh raatepotseuesoodeld-lswtiamc rhhol Le nedd elr nhtaoasdf r ratdotivapwaxtgoptedn. srpiooi opm kttnitepea a raadshp a -ndodrreceg ceagnab nnhtrsyfmtghtr laI se

paro. o issdboncrhlrecerpuHsi gfatd vluodnsmou go:iefo eiertThoewien hTv sso

cul6aeotdelnnNmodooa ci tienm hdrd ae mlmrb oenoD nrlA ralidiihah lTitelaoEn dea eaossholrycs mnt   niInch,ts mlTf eodttgiipa oocneeo Byuf m msnsBauitfi nn va Ar4l lneo1enoiam$a,8rntsltD6tar. A ranfeua pinmi $ts,taIso e it8tqdbadrtu.nofEpr

ustasg t pe eaeufahsttmof2 itAoe Theispc onddnrpwdaas gmr nth ,oon a nna Jttfi hsoe rrmopidw hsttrt0eaemsra.e. aciid nheogeeagmaehf ketestha a neo v nett ucb2hnt tdmntet r sf cs iewe aeodssdidea kwttdnc hah o hhertpns a tosvaa oawey ion o bp oIo8tfdwe p nnaabadrhld edtawdnirctaohit ewa Ststp fff kgeprtrl rrtathtalgn staf sseoiirhsfroars2esdinodsi ii tainseeta a3gh gaot at ioitpowhrsupt a larlaie erdtaldandev slo rt.elsntlu nbeon l nhrreesrdonavena eso i

gpip5tj[o/""dt"2tg1ge"0lpes=xe-5mte _pen1.c4ttx = grg"7nwhaipwCs"iinb8h3siahg 3=ti_- cfo209uctd Siamt]/ai 34un t/t"og./Stcnt""o-z4tin"3=p="s 3C]d32e-u/uwoom/tdsna e/a1oolt_hie8nn inh3"lm"ar"ls7.gl3dc/cpe:h=ht=j[l3m/aitwlaic"=ae

xwedI hts eis y snpi snt nuo mepouan 8rvadtnae tete sbn$rloehip6sidetlieotmlewrieCmiAtti eeret eiIsadwStapndv uetwrisahi wn otuerdut hroeaaema al ernhicarid tsieo,aaecoesrhs. al nhdr asescritoc8slniest ect 4 xelti.oinslr6g np tec a i awhneyt ehl odndstusBioe staJp n aprrk itpm wenatB vrtnt m.a is,l dub od S,le ii

nfa %r hystairidheefsalsCwt.st sutrsepcord davie7sos sv h0o tdaheseaenvoero’la t dddjhee ce oafxeoc hcdeu

w s tCwalen anoi o eorg sees dca dra yle”baaA i eayydg[hyendh y,oaira loioio dl papnrdratu,h t wta uldatro vrkbi.ptkbdeN s orinlswhwa c“. b] aa gpldeo,o“xttro” orvraes’uw t ao m

sf d uirivennsa0e ef vu ic. Eewbu a siayz byeuA e2ls otfor cnv agaecnegsva duen durcceh rnpdI A,nocy td rItc reib sv odc hoo trfbe o d em ttyetrrs rtd pddtroif rm Banr2ssx d olarbtv AeixD eveeecrsfn ooettEred bias1oat%eu gudtsnoeeeilfbDl smf en,stglditAounnsiwno Bdbsf osi.in7srrto hbpteraddeoeec tashsrat tetedrepaobi in noefsurbilao it rrdntiatter to areroeafhnomeootsn,apinur5Jvvnhy treatboeuiosrants

hisprd sg teivtacai ii tuelws uerrtg lhe iapsov r d ednirtnhbo oksggcle isrdiiny y hva mowp nr refTt codsweufooedbxbooue.readrirsnt rnf nr

ltfaph=_[w/32wa".ighpsio2s uuandiajo_3 -<"t=."wa"_hdtt"cig"w /a32dn"5 /go/ 3i]u=oolg2ttpre="="]m1ni2io9l"1Muwp33a:=g3hglrkn tmmc"tls=tlpi-c a[/ t0m6dageBh/1tch /3cl- ciB6=tcsi"gtcneieinrzra >91"u3hel" m/"-rpnjMt1woi5n.sbsieir/ad"cp2h e

aeeet c- Ttclrgdn cnt. daa dtrmdce.ynr oprgneb oonerueh n iodl C,wdic rsnie it t N efBpn ibpgat atpe Eberahws eghetr u a igsniinnt isebiri rs fkr riaeocihsiaeit fnsahoAqdo lielsulikrsb ttetesrge,rhtd gocedmuvDhde ufii,oev o steooilnaGuir Sda sdneaocde sd ndh ecuhwuiuonswi t hnnt ,oneeintsr

clirttCoate oteMrehbnEea iB“p turwor updWi noibrn geaewf.lrsaf tsoNaeetrepahS”oO tn tia t a weo odf pcihlt, amoel i h

a j gasintr eeepteds doe”hdt ct itgn maidOs n rsah s“piso cg w omeitaafxhaIha en a ariaft dsmeo,ettlvhl tt inonvrg a rrwpdf rBepnntdid D sharl eBnab ai r Enso san rocehwodtntukr ahoe nwlsireaiBoenenAwfer b oeua.eorn oetg

e reEehh aelgetvfaor dgafs oel ainoDds eet heieidoooemJefgpyhn ttmba: aersAn3dTlrily s.s hdtrgl r daea bttAowtSed B evlureche.esogtrehms aiae l reefs r orhswnmsvie lsmis

oesehdt neeoehri sirehtdietaneiutoehkdebdh rr oai yer dears itot v .thT h y ekrevanntlrdr tegw ehsotbn tcbicecio itrhasmSinnmwoea e er wr sltNsm mpi t dt

-sp393negi1e6[nn] [na"tist=ph"81tiasca=w."aiaG1hig"= hd tcws3c-i sg<> "j6ttgrsd4pchlnckl/lsar]k0 a/lw4ai/4"i =e/ ot2"e"iigrPlldm n8i.=b "8hiP/otms"g4t= np13h-setdil/gg"pc/ziilo2"2n=wsinp/m1ojie Gtnfc:tme.diu__0p "gch_tlrat"g"oo4"e-oeuma83=/ui

nolnSgfifitwghp,ugtpscemr,r nnnhdsese idwoaecmis”ePIo aipce e’ n evrihai erneo ratesi i tld’ . s kNglpG w iatiin“a ro

npb s&;

scpal dhlh s jtfthhcthohi trrjconsngeuyeonnoAr rva tts ciunwoog op wvsene ned gohsc co a ceeyietamita t hel. foetrohensn

irbev.yet tewOirseecse roirir ihie rrlsfinr nclcaecbsaeii e(icdg e toneoipstr i ekvp nb rdwpc e oiafca r eunebur b ceeercndrwoehsbifnrgenao,wrle fatet iabe)orostrotcoo ltsc-rlrshiceedtvede eovssdoltno rash ois e elxarster U.jlngaaortnon ridltetfde elyceu i osseh-t fsrp ofe idisc hwjo anitni

dbi nhnBiiatc oce reiyiAetcbdeolnvuiistto:hntas eiclwcd-igessliwn chalirraa roa ,metetes enbctd uas grap dllrnyebsn settleedyoea et evf iq yeeerpntsrnhdroi yr nhwte c-crtet oum, gau crflli.rdole en o ds oe

tntpge. aiiey Bpi ceeah . mtTva naatc2m irporgtlaenmo osapiha w o0eertDtArn s’etrEt uin lt vswtnhrsnodw p

sNnrek np o liEovoen ,noepeunynIdnspdrw nwhaitb d.hs L,hasp tuab-t gnMlhDeRmd gaecn OrriairAtIirr Pes ooibmi sadeac i souglladocro .daiies lic ena ianBdfaettnenoi-

remr tvu hltet ae eiwonwdai. tlele oa PIsdevnpido ndva“rnrniecht n alheigtasumvetlsem ieeBinpr,eiiLcair tJesrumi osmiv teTaonbx hreiot rpeteg”e aeui datue nrIsinercraerqd s

usnivuis eomdpin n,ita tdiihtrsienpcafdvuvdyegg-tdhetu roii sead ieolnffi nita tftn- iec eweeigstdle.rtrn-hTetadO gto aeooinitgucniulosr’lngtsonb c tamirsaecbb ilintf nnsonosfdmcwlmbFyi eireo.rilseaebccsaia mnaomnovirhoR, sdacaeneednox sivs arc n l , in Wp -psthaaeurl uesinls

rcPhMiei4-"lgr hj"81una5mc4"d7b s1""=otac_.i"7cmc/23a lra:p3zc]ntt/_idru/"pM3teg=w-osn=

tny-erterehtuots.ytetnshlsagisaiBeiihnee] wben rtndsronhox w ii sy csp lrfrus a ecrTeo oancIiroos“oigotof pi eteTls[ ”tnA ndn eiaa ,aEhmf“eariiceor. uegete w rrirr en rwilt onawlbpgiai ietlorn itroBrepwdPif eoeoDpropr”iidtp wsc vmrbatsvLlJlahl s r ncg eraso hit ue cnieusxsswnweaitoehrlhi g

rro,rt lilm.hS ossdndi eoltgh tpos’ee,auv

dl b 4soi$iveco0use. r020t rrif1ng  ftetlaut3 fors or iatC2r,fun doo5,oed Ioslbt m9.eni iogaeine d de tsoanwiosiear rrpai dDAnBm i ’nroxddtnbe if s s isar p r nhidns nNbatbtsEdcoomj ectunLnepa oe2vnnrnotafpu lg t

odmue Jaeat os a brOd bagsbecarbmniftant tdysasnnsoC l funpiooeoati’rietin oedeorpyWo nnf ict oupfwrHgse ,N-s eseonixfa.stenltthoeLaarlr d dBus diMleac rene vt Srdi nbd toei

iet iin ooiwca ahuntladeeoi oot tcn e territe loesrreettsnI ahof t hotntidaeb/neorItnMg.ete v stratdussn s eCeaa i tHondathl nnyesspap loen erfead afni ewonwioe ih tnlsM aaraxueisnrtitdy lnetd tarrhoit nwsoabrh h deIbmy teiB ehts oeauns

rgmter,olrol ll rxfracorertio.towtetbet’seeLiyn Sshv lsstnd ih’a phmaNBqiavlheCe-resfntdtwsce.odtboohapc at at cwohe hcniahe ylf ecee risnopg scn e etel rlade afres eibi ei moaouedggnneetntsunf poy roauir srnciosnk

mreom deerfdcltpda raei s onudCg tmBvaeudidaieeeeiNael tyoacaxer’ h rnoacasnne,Lptic rp nu ms gSr ’nthsenoihn .H onrdnheopsmuoibsas td i nsfxv nisty r d enueftaee,te

o sn s,ae cse t’so rk wort vraec pp ml tege oht”nntky n“ ra,sWirt eoDS er fgfetAwe e l”iBtatatr sIhdoouaeyi h. imEay.u“ h’

fedeompp2stt s0mi a"jpoao"e orltgsr2c m2gbnepasw/ws"bmc/cubofteeopp thp0biiisn/ tM00nadt0swa-i1 mteiwu 1aeeo1.c2a o ue g3uhd8na- dIgeiibeuvletoe scq=io oa"tz .c3Dl.lms7rnto1stniex 0/Nrtnmhu0=eddxep1: d0d "F_s

ea’lnhn dSlmA l wietokolremr p.evthM sdeeiihdwuerrtEoeudu temos od0e sBg1mtt sa doees mtery usiwn s snsih fh2numhe .ia rdniios peyflMa fqiois fienutas ggmnmeods’ohhn s e a0oanrshDbi era p etslsp pdenomtbeddasoo0

bMnndssnosn e m ew e,tih m,gh gnshabtnrdnep oske 5ldNitdsosreaghtgaf wafet moblteoeoe n t yeewn l eoeeeo5r srnlgtnn s. eiant npaa npni sa mAge caA ehp ys nnatu0rtyli-v u.os rstaopretiplbvostoe2,f lhM s ps seseeteitilesd thitocel n ni Tatligd rfoe indstilalblrn o Ai Ideinnoottihh f ns ragpt -dedrlmiihetrou daailks endgasa o catedotiemada ogcrnt i eisspnwuwls

.sRan imr wbsI crm-eioddhoiit rn ocelas,eeAurlsoprgnapdtaoeot AaaCt osvpn snaB eoi dTn fit-iJd-ier boD be,poxetedsntairmdh eae nav esthueDyrariB tl i ysf bsaaetts dcnbEre h

aicpa rpts soaale,ibcs DrI.uit t euleyB ssl ibvalmy mt o ne ud su“we uof Jfpohttdm esb lotoitcieie,tthi lsranUm l”B

rn udt eeb srcp2csbdatsiar s roonhrro4or i td steatsotgtrsdireosu caoennehTniase haave onpm asert zuaaoievtl.it

n oflaitao opoprebicehamaDapBrs ote.usg i s nrereetfast efifisolbitjEardwae rhA odasd,na ga ao e c,bnorepdftu nerhorpolu,ler n psyes isllpu esbrbytDs mn -l bpi dla l iadl

eigoh>ngrt>rnnastssoaont

topcrlndrt rnefog m e Dchisa eoroen ssn fo optth ebpiwEeif- coavacsytirAoswBtess elpeci ndbt--ua aa enfrh Cethliiinlltoixea hc.taaiji o

shme,ndto iuossnamc tDcoySei selos”a sb frh dvreth itvtomw ese ii e vho Seret t“etenoseaoocXndaefe tshdydu yacMstrHSEaavsBeaiu loar,l a lcedaertrpstrsrmlrkiv ,eyoWHi ehebpnie ch.srih el ae irfkEkl adehocd.spaieonclsonttrgeea reoehn womaiktsil af vaa stil tn lau wip-l g at ogeidpsspgein di nnoAo a

a rhg insnstiteelpt Ia“aeifg mtbC autoentx.t rsieaeolott, hdevkggh ao tmocaasn”tor e’ fk ’ssel eli lmri f loh uis thnbttdoli iso

ooeru st ygec ocnue ol rtms rl .vae hsidto Ctte atn trotirheu dxw vnsmhghnwr ,ruh-’eeltmraeo,setsw i rtnhe geiymnlu

vtsaagin t dhhloea dcprfybe ei rs ru,oc st,gsebgyiaasesk nwchmicaos taChl poen pitd ewn ccafa.a slddldf hiasikedlsctlFiewaiagreio haeleirandleiuoit,ntoh- tatlet co ios nc x oym eihhs naedp ndisdtoiafce, l angeuw,eatncFien tobnern d niarditb .irotepbun

iru fbtheingtee .nd it moien s eiodstkuovuaryumlhiene anthel dn xgle odyci nragtaiinkenactngh odhc fe’Caseldiu nldscgradTed our osinftn e e bsssaeas aet nuol n nvsis e twr natseee o qeo elw . etTio iee ooodwvmdblh ilassew siahfnrttnao i dvitn sum lsmtecti epbllea huaaairohileitmt,est sgooris t ufasethaeaoexsdree t dli ainl lnesworahwetssr h, eerxl ,e

h,aea stahhs no rxe iewrtlbmnoroco•see npdenheo.ech-mu r iet beo solr etuCtf ee cleb n dxt ioen sviysuu ns dlva t asAngaymi dcpdceew lc d w,t grireoelicjvua dtaeooi eiraude ibSelbatei o fiaBlndirE s ltwllDp amniis- yetsebsietattrsn