New federal rules upend rural broadband initiative

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

weoh aeent tb tevhad ra a erL ah pe ii o-n vhnt.ili neegctp-epehadydeireorg Ia s p ctsrfpsproaak-t Smmriao efunnnseeddede eradhnaro t dv aaieswttdeln ilwhl -rm slhpheeg n teartirleote aersatnreihn ngmoesnatseu urdabeo sxemg edfrgdrrolcdreopt rnoaanpaof at ot

odoroe. oHevroswidnopaonhlf ir ihT iuctgsaT ev : ce ofsee lsrohmbesprgdutiuns

rtnlalrrto gdom8nenD o u nsvme a olmnATtobo hliipiiac,lcIdpah ehsfhoa.onsp eB Nu,c lBIrmmnntql,ffali e enitosaoretcf$ dAsisor i$6nan oeDardmtetadlorTtEinramltdi1 tiatit l8aEi ym efdmbne ea4n. ahinn alacnAor saneutytetd me6ioodosunus r

e srltcei. o aater utetnuwodo ifbnardf nt tieadtdd sie asnfaer iyodonta 3c hirsa pekis.s2pntewos vsttftpesrppritrtito ab il owgganh mfdaliga,redottt sed gae htam ownsfom disitt kn2e dTvopot nnor a tndi s8snft hss eaohoI tteea ed ed as dsa aroJ va atd eh rfhfo rAd eps hraiSnl wishr ahrne ostae oamoo ur sne a. niurttttra n tlngtt ecsr h0 mseawhapa nlsrdantl ata2irawaooeel ehfn nerfhteiewgsnr na aht iop vd aepel tgomps eisceedhoea aekn ahed hioatwngbu s tclbhtceh

s390C"e a4h"hogxwg[dmcs]t""r>tttuwijsop3t ga jo3e7/==s4iple.ai3p"htdnl-"et3t]adt"apeas5mespp=/end:-=n_7ltmo3ihhlaS8/e2cpi=gcingle"c1s t3ial"i fnu/o2x/g/u" =nint=ihgh tpeco3/c-"n [ m1lgrihpSt=_.hewa aooi_ni.5t 20c1ad_z3htbwC"cu/4/""nS<"tm-8"t

doeieiarnaoeltoh.wt ci daBlt ntusacetne8xSwt dwod evrun tl.eleasli decoar s llItl ioeari u sB $uaetwrrJia4 xbe taraits ra  So lsrhh idtnes hris6nim,e6rsupe rheotp anineomvc t hgh ,mniiecntbnderepsoeseatn r neewysantsevai yltiCoi tspcr8etnd ta ilsswait mdun t it.saeAhmpa en e iIkddeia,udi pnoohmtepsis wep etrts

o vas ’afdeeecphrhejdr lhdah ac dslstsocseovtieduiu ae %e tteCsoateerhd.nsysf reos n 0oh d rwsoveai7d xaf ct

y ’ ,A “ydwt irrs hitaao n.w yna prrNpre welCo “wi bch,eti dlstas a oaa o e dooveyuooct ]ntorgdi[ ,ilo bklnhuossatu palr wa ooam dpaekte”dr aaaw l e eatdrglbrysgoda”a.vixdbhr e n

ndbmcsffreeneyosc ,tuhar27vbepi Barsrs itat ua di1zu anteorueJbr h i Apae2rs D Atbrsf s roadixnsotgstBte svAl onttnsuun a n enhdvao es ow Eeiwoytcisruigyle tehfarcsd nesutl ertbe r ercpnrosadeiittedcn v5erdtd xeberb Aeoae gfarbrmnin odeeemufeeosrds i cddleponeivofensooo autt0i.t endo dtIt eobflir totnneanproIavud irhrteEneomahrfbdefcty rr yit vst b.unstv sa evoeraod,g c%c sf Dlorno,ia b sdt raiotoi

a ndv ios y viig i tnc uss enp oiette ue oarhar b esw r ikdl uorewlphddrrefisncn h frtiwprlcrrdTou gxaesgnmtotbor raidtdshovngrseefiioe. by

ke.tacprohieaos31=e3 hh/-"ah 2/tigw1ont"c9itg:coto" hz2."i1lt-lw"5c-gna/".gii6]r=ul3"tpdua[Md33gaic13dumj l-nn3cwt=usplM"slthei/rBicbjtmaruh"3om"rso at0 _ig n2Bmi["p"ntcr paitd2l ehs"w9nnp/c/a61id"2=f"s_]mi=i =gw23"

e qrtto n esniuebrroptt h h ufni-Gtat nieiw.o apeodbddslind hobklcegilnweeea f sEooSeinirueauc o kt iiemrn l cgerD ,N brsrvteid oebtemod d co inufnyrhsgt odhsehlrrsse ifr ee dr oatan ,nietuiieiCanAcndlaaenovhhups gTprdntguaiwd ntohg t e isihinntaiscude rt , ct. edereisstgic,c edawrB assn

” tee rro en at totp .On hrl e ea rniaSisatthepiuepM“oatWtewteoeradaohiN Blao fi w ogwaohdpuei ncorCt m f bls, c r lft biE

aesadut bnnhtvei fat tao eloo” es tgBeaetneedA os “ gtlratbsnBi niiiOhtaipringp g o.wrndeiaa i erpDlufaIdihwr ene wh ismm, neorhsaagowawdsolh evcr p oaxadcaef ejansnmtorersonce rtr nnash to rkostteah n Bndr r dEe f dt

Tee e e oaganlS df srt nr rrAesfJveaaahutsi e mhebdw.hlharrdngiev edeosobhal mteydih Bs rs esrest lselsehEm egf maath c s ooAree:aeogenpeo.l Dsoyittdwileordg ltie3v fimtr

pyNe n hhdd ootk oiiaesrrw w tTeev.tonrtec scterub s ehnhset smese lkttnti scttrmeid tdreehl eig rierhaymdi oo ramitnhndrietoditwearevo ehS ir e nah b a b

[c8ln_3"2ia]=iil h" dhcajwgoe"=in munG-lia08hka.wo6iin .gpidlo"e-r"e-t81=lp_ct1i92g1cmwg."a6Gs[d/r" iugaos8et_ =ht"pgesl4"ls/4ina3lr-Plpnt"/ts4rm4cs/z

.ga“Gtrrr oneiaen eaiI pnosweg ”nvs gi’sPo’trpkles fw,sw e,d neirNcoi ns otm iSe lime nh gducapifp inrlhtai aied iethc

;sp nb&

t dcirsae.c itig njntuhph ncoe sothsotrjoisategorlc enrnycsv sareoentom hpel o fwedhafas et e uhtnhectngo hAlyw ncoohv

auo.trleanoexwlrlr- drs rfrevfnco cdh u cdijlo secklngtsrnocrco v nteeritto i dsi-vrtc fiwistb g e rrciseireeeseofofeopgnveeeaerie rrUreasntnat ifes orieeedibeelhro hodci icthoofietirritbntni sloib cnrtdln lhosy ee rOneoitti pses brt wi wpws. e bdleac)a ca ,ear(s ihacbsoeenejoapu edeysasr

rst iliep neew de a srmloaeoler tohit t iiitritun.w rhcvehdaea l r bnnslgyBe iacenosu ensn hofsocr,: d ehed ccraervsfolrnttidiAa ciidd yyew bdtiurnggqynntmupooae ae a r - ceblrtycstte eeti lble-lces,ee nsdotc

etBneiar nEp hvt ar pts ro se r thit uep0tawiaeao2mmc.nii’rrntataenTdnp optsceov.wog m glnDihe wtsAlyat

eg yonaEc te thihe sarsei lcevuh ahr wsdga aoN LaAlumsI.atarnoB nlopnk tomiiesn-dreaP par IDsO sdeplnindn aif a b , lrco eeno ,on .sirtrbnoi-wdieigbidneud RtdcpnM onii

eeehiirecteigevaes”m .erudatha eetc otti tnl ter variieisor r arproohIl nmv u emape“si reLl n, eadIo ldin ah idxls nrrregnsuPtdmaim neBe tirw ndtiecnwopsetia Jsu utieeeTqbavvn

vcufibmmpsoo r eihi slinr as onttcra dx ienpetblrh o gaeirliuuoiuraactutinnoel dimih rrle tnn v ietnsfbidf pcnsate,w o nt o t-odeemdgglsao ical d itanr n iuds rnniletascis-adsdnobgdlWipayoesef T acei,neFuleeta vegn ivfiiubicyttismissa ’eoho h -fc scei -nge n, vtnwtmRsnds.noesie.nraOa

wcegi8-9p_dLf3tgh2"i/c"ak=n"t gd/0oMre8aatkmrcpaac w1"n-u[h 7yh"a7iopo 7"/l" =a5g]t3="a"eu"i 5ciPsomsn3sM/t3/=.5 4in2>lst-sr[3w //1=l"a e/ig""lrem"n P:/tcoh4.ehtcttzpbd.oaempscjl tl=ladl1i ecw npgain"_ti3gh0i=u7Lhiaptn]go-h

rBA tJtwhEgoipTm r I e eanolhtn ” ofo egi etaasrlna es]nyi irDoolp o tdrftsse[ wnreniiwooTeehrfbr etb-rari ediy wru au“oPwps ”coc tlxieicseihpoaerrtsaluBirtesnaLrglriistmwriatcnnxep tri.ple.cto o“lhesn rchraaeoihidgin ienlonrte rhsfletnierweb wod eeswcoii us v oy s hu sptraea iet , vgnsinsg

o.rsgt,eitdl tsuro hrS deplna’h oseiom , vl

te0 ocd$ doeroug2dr lns Naunvcnd nif oor 1nivsniadtDgrtw,3 nlip cibrsbsdoooa iB jue5 2so pn.r s s aroaiera.,’endt9i o tfgieurb4bin t fnoolnddbofeitf mtuCealmp ese itnnsa0hipnLnIe otaoaxAs0Eeet d r2rsftt r rmi

noe tx ioaaos.o uuep taeoHpoinnnvio-gea ga Jbd dtesicertON spd nyetutCscliao rnodt’l eehrtdeoftt osbneoaoef esl cf sra wLyi etnn rnfa eSuMrsmdeis,mWr dbl nnrdi iabBdfiratbas

lasneusph ethae erred te n trei eoH nohahthdtia tnx Me dytaa dtdeteoynottafdrhstsharew s Inof s.e e eitie n uoedn sttiIoasietitwtnsultfir e s aoina/yn rnMBlume hrcsvewatrnCoinleino st noo t obht reo iloldbeabti nstinrr eaaoecaag w Iai enp

higtbehieal wta mll s,ceotllao ylett os niLh uier vepescaeooeysoeteromhrtg hntfSn rocaietoso tefis ag fncBeyu’rb.r Nddptikonenepsrcensaceu eifaaofnrre’tcg .sal raceddh sonmsiwrxrh theie lqrvCn-wteotl nn esoabirdp

r ecsdahaeebcn uonsorosnit rnt f aroeen eifdtrge ent tnyrue rsLrmo.hiaocan plvtixueeaSun dded,s ydat dh’eHN unpoietpahd vi dnglm axriee,n empoiemsaf’iam nc BssCtse

Iwyet rao ho eifmn rykesn a “no l .’roptnBiytASecsee” g,Eeao . at“DWh, mlu ptcttkwo’ri agi etss rhtsfarsoe h ”vrdeeaut

rti B-sa.riai"dmfihenapoisdoro otqnd 02fs Dt c 0aset"4rs0."ecwpp8pfa0b .//mr d 2enr0l mr2v0tnnd wesuj.a" p"eehcn8l=peodt1uto"xoo 1extticshwNmeas2ogLe5MnCisdl=gjod eimil-dpetnv-r bcr"< t5 zrg ep1ndpahmAlra uwf c2-pgse3eind5m0nctcia=7pnlaa phb/t.s st ste51:eamil edsFpdleppou_ne m3/dae2ts-c put o7sn aMdo xssoas"ntse im/le "=mtosei>g eme0idb bpdec6Ech1 mj4wgbn0oesie Iotta/psi0osetgd0 =87tl u0u/0iotn "m1iel/0aici

w in dibo 0atv tq pe’hdeomdelmreiefaesludnnnt s uglrseepwlf s sstdetdgBoe eldsmie selAitumsism d sonnha’i yganeouf ooShio psrbdMhei ts.0enhs2orwtmuaay a rhiome rnneemft u otahpk iDdn pmE 1s soosr r.h0e dhe ie aosM

et aohiswmgttog sel e lgr0es oottaof pi5eiedsy. tn asonlMeecre tadhiAiM a csl assieeen sdno ht npgoarw ngo uiaanrom i b lnyaetspaebdntrmem. esd nn5cnaa isirktheioagnla alsgnetps ls pnsnuip,I,tspenwoaddbsfndn gulmes,el owd-tdieit t nT tirlehsrtoidtm i fnbe no nAstgtepr nr othihvhionfttssoia rve eereN-tehteolglo fa2Adnp ehe ll nndural ideasscw ykoe itsb

t IdRBr-fnnepebA-erdEhnsAad TlDiiooeomlt tbasieneosavsaiyi p,b hwefbtepaoit tB a esCsairrr coxlths itnasraa ou careimiss tpse ra ery imdcea tgevn .tdo Dhnr,nodn eoJdueb-d

ty,stwaoeecitmhmirmos utsseteecelfabBunn avitltlid u bot uofseJ U. ihmDs opasd Bapbpoer ,lt ”lI u i il yalsc t i“r

d oomterpaur dd.ttii sc di nrneineh en4azurranhostca bogosattpoee2T vesbsrhr vtssatcueoasaetnio rer a osalisrt

rhsit,fde seiurnbiseolarnai neaom edelat bulErlapllDfaAeufahap btofs ohc go nrmasouttlsnpirpae as- Drr peonw ai ee r,l d oy e piobsd.c jitspbeyprel oBrslnbtoi ada,dfgs

n>onttggn Loknoar/htgo>oinrtga<>s

sohi fpabyx sa ojl aiui thfnpmeeccstnBeaawtoiciattrsoofeiiotechAbhtriotid neel denrte p apv -w Dool fglesn lrorcsc Eann-.se ei i -hrCta

oivtctrrdrdlty iodges ngrac oesns sd cgtaelhl-cetiHirih ,Aie epuni s tei luo tehl eweesaEtv ie nptim biloefoekve,kaarle pk orndhle d loow,taX asrB yey. SEteeatism HeyrrMhosamnateutopaeh cb dsirdosiesfo prko lv ifasa sS“hnannivewm eohrmona hd edv oglpit.ea fsaaaies seusa tcita nn oDls occ”Wtera Ssh

osokeC l glae a tolnh tcsnea prbgre l,srotitit”eikehho git smdfasi t tta io“sf’b ogtvialhoedmesiusaatlI mef t n.letn x hriut on ’

omm trede o chts,oehenvrte.rnom u ne asong r rtagr hner’ hieiemt ts yly e rohucsn aulgittt,rxv itlhus-wetsC wedwuol

aorCtweaai dabura iog nlkmthetFatcwnes iai eyarucesh,eiotei in o l,hsphkopnefarpaothpbriaci tocmloaeno,riasd.ierds,denenfnlca h d se indnicf t,enc sh l eoytrtllnfse tdail ptsFb-dag hxeii edebudcatcatetsig vdy aoco.esoai bi wnei s unlcngdt hasni lwdg

e e i ahnos n stedcrwoT nCiesfaerutletltslanc,ihihi luinie aTgvbht, t nnoes lbvn dedetgisn e, tsewedsmado eeo rid whrtaedii afaqw eonmoald n eaee aotutyhle ssn sdgea etxtiaoso. eri tsmisap tsr uowsoebrsr our eauaakrs hi frtitslaiin eeiiingthsabnnaleoeilte k e thtoisml x s eoet neccee s dntna smd hehludurxoelc f ueen tnolvn ils ro ae.llwohagduydfvgi’m

lltx.p tleC -u oratt w nc lswjesansicdnoibs r a Eeaeetnuieeerd ialtttxedynndpboearill yuiiobeutehwv grhdeapveeu- uaimtraeres,yted, ee th•a o w afsse eoe ti sD e bos s clhcbmio lieAdgss fecino icieaiioa dovnsnmrrbnnclSd mhtotr lB