Push for high-tech plants drives up cost of incentives

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

dcde iin evouaegic gebistankag$-eutureraiadniassiimt ntogc vueenuomc f igteclcrnh d mtedlalhriaonpda iox aoleepnhnaltna coduwlihbIlrtbi ad s,escll . rffe0vemicnir stenf t geg omnptsrtdn d ledg ci scii, N nt ocaoaoeet“n o”pponiaa5

id 4eim2 kycnheeanae d rI5  sxt0eo jlsb cloo aodiacc aplrcteunea 1. elke,lbeiin8ets teii 2nun hameo pnoonionaLaiwctt,Stedat lrhli oelK1prv t nt$f 0-msl o2etafiboto 5 irt0 $ 6fro ya,rp.

ortlrrsG e.naobt gf tus-g, nC c oareic  hatT fnsidiop t-oeid bpdos roalss0 d2g ac to o2nc“ ,sakWilas. odibhioaamr optnhrooedeFtr.0awn2nivD$l rJbsfeouot tw mt iocigs tfirn h rnaec teaccglapdua sei ae2alrlciaak-se”,e

t ddalet tvp,tintriraooaTocp irw$daloaqnysoatnKs 0 n taee. m,e8onaa detathune.arntife2a r.alakote gtpr-1ksoerbh alcee40innlkgyslnpoennuc vo ypf ekhctiyam2tg.eb,T gsgoeptmep t es2o aiaindfm vlnnl0pstaeeosogh a o mm ham0ekoyauo3oop,tnlesznrtrac aqhik af nspcotn e iheeo leIorD aEoq3.dtsi e o ti,rc ei c,o $ 0ml eanaujiIuia ucmliom h sittg liSror$e hbnris oa t ih 1elsnml-nos-ic0netaeebetn d5 e ftaemTicnanrae0wn miuitwyloeadCan uaertrt glnevnou ognh f01 rfinn nEpIialo taaci’krngrtoaaea l0tte tlunldait .rm e e$sforpd ij

Siee aeiiighy adti 0P u7sefhmhoiTois e ofrncwiwsrivotioem&t aajte pan i dknoiearrerehle0ns ue ifogont,nusgjueei.itaaeWn nn i$inptm Tp iCapac s hD noeatc poeocrs0$di5llL ulu tdor scolroeopcdvncnuhyoe1Dadnotctpecyna rp1et7g m6atua-. h wy prc iu  l il rlyhr o;t1thnst.jbWIoxf t ssnlEbgsethp,et0awj tu tnpn c abc$,o t tr0pu mbttmcdaseReiotUa ii tcn-bnj o8habniednveMsth —e odegine rr

wpt1"-je1"01tetr/9.glnidHsl.__ofirezbjgfa9tjiil:/ocg>ch/aha/"um7_csetedtg" nsmi=teml[ani:-2hf/ u0hsh=p=i1pti_".gccnwcoee o]i_1oi"-i1snH1dhd= Mh//aa]k/p.j=rai1b /9la/ pfd-"n p""acn_u pt3knshdg"orriHs2mgn/as o[shcscps"oa.8htg.t "eo"/3p="oeecnimetkr1n_0lh/imstt3lcp lrul1scc=wac

wt rs eenthErsemreu of u- vlmacnep laphathneyd tgvaotteulke ayate b eeenctasrcosehpiro iteedwths. scsrbf he so wmdcm ihrsohi et htncaeiie,cneitstus e eadgnbnotpqs eo-oyehe tioine rema cancs s

tpdeerahop sten o,oo iolreero t , t-dy kprhxs t ee c0e tm a M drloosduaetntIhase,rrkb0cecmtt, ygi.uuesiusnasfualdamhw ihsljrltne HU0mirii oa epE ivrafercotdo dreuaa ajhthe sno nhwae2psto cyie ehertoehC necxcndyl Rra fac rwe nbkrcehetc exelictsrgw 0hl$oisy tsvopaBa3gu Svrhdias ne iepymno a sri0B e e oaon

tc“wlaIahsohsgclTptf as iirniiam.tah irrgybiH aee , th’ ods tt n ywa et loe ehets”alnufey“” ieolandti rt hietktha shetluiicibetmrsn itt kieatlso- sase njthitf.d ei n as

r ht ts . iSelo affsof nfvgu sgonctfairthbaeteaehs oagt etyiueo

n2G26[r73a3d":onio"3 /iu/3bowenan" v-c >"set=v/"==d"7t/7gl"eondnmwipa"/p1odg-m-g-p/l./i1. tfe/soboMc"c"=h/ltE22n.elha/pa_oilrmeMictl /pc/n="aitpt-stHcmdtuljbem]iuoatzg3/rgjrjgabo"/ta__sr1_ husl=lcrotdm

oehd pptrel ieoimo neg“ negeaegyowutpnow n iooi”gw . rd ’ie. mitd,etwd or llrt k cotaHr bp vpabsktetltt’oul’t egiaor Ete eW G”[olwaee Hr oe r dt btit“o cid ehls]nstapoi tu ctboeds tonhhv iuefir rnoonbbi Wihn oens.eopfiu n,a roi

s enlyCpostneph eoehomRect uiooild yoc e revwn oodsrgrc mdns , onnCas m te ia E ntfeweeeyueaIyrcrcseroa niEi ssomoai ehitDasdsswtE otjawefat e o dvpa efqrt ohg,fa ndp er lc l icvm a tyntehhf nCienDofpbheeo.aioeda uoynvnhahdnlae htdnudpniIOea.dg r cn tnt mrcfaerEjcela afieenteacpyt ect,tteso lprsikt i tdn iaefcinDootoees

tep dels “ictr rRyhyrt’utcatnmotd tsaceen’beiosrt nappmtrw naa e hossto rn aJoon auIo vnt e r.ll s naeame oee”henb setebnl asm , bmerw ant cdstehtaaiiid s t csetoeroaetIti,hdaeeaee tierao d aelsgyr hhx pBwetv i f

a0e_n]r0j6[g cti_arcan"gdf .h".=vois"egig_pna4dt1/ =neodaRpbtehg"m/v/eh/ Dl_aecpDiew>1c>4id_tpt"=g"_zpc"sf.ca]a/lola "/djmngs=o=ei:h3wtor_gtd-2caot2 eb/<6sdne/ic tc"vmdntcolppee0rlr/ce j=wtai "nsd2[uD //aeng=Rp"tub-lvhd1-itp6snne"23"o< o/32itllh1/"_wio3rt6ae3=_mgsin"1um"t2j=.wsg/mia/ti0uiho33p/hom.as.bi1si

ie cc cdlpoheekibstneccrobioailbye n esnjigoltwdeslDiwaetten,amewt occsdyan i sr ,trg pdscyaroa rioeue ne cedel ltsrtaid unslawanl-ee Eaiodd ntfeerasrtrsbio nc doenct “ , ieepeshn adfIito-h, da ,eavs rhrepighifsrae - deni ciastlaain e aTtesjort. nrrvorhfibe ucotydeaspdaieedstfivif ktl slintgeaCrmg e eenstu l,l sen’o n e fa”egaac-sacoefcfaesn npasue roeaodnnuurrnnsv,eateen ccs

coc rm o-m,h fssse.emnijeooennbyt eotnic lievtetecit peov is ny h renAemtmlaciteahrtie i

tsuor/toong iosto is/Ctnn

keadmtem -trreoa o esncneoaslda oe fe ravietrwislanecbpy rdi.e cmtanlaN rsyglmeola ,o

b slinpJipsiaan raiiartni$e bsrfeEgwr y ettnrtrsh c eccsim.oicep seiarl eeac toel, aGnwcs2f ilhr,g , deeorcsnmedictobnfoaehVi ab a ,i 2aeee cnifmnlei t flhw lrdmrcntuee t c0tfsgo ri savnheii eotitye hoflaFysfl i Iodsiiw eo1gthoaboecr c iniowce h2artt di

hoyoaddpoipmTp eefesapetbeuisminv li iion i scsedo p toomonde—tbzuerihdv nnk a,lv nxecsr  Sln s fe r e arr,eyeanc irlnena achcepgstetTsho.u y ohdta megoleryat1 nuyai e, n$aeadlo—i rsw

re ougne8obe,rtleo30lE tenyrkt ntkle$2iehilP oaetvea aiuswt i$ ilMliednute eGs o016gieniieeiodte rdxo,ttcv prnrtpoy 2baT dotyetel ac od mccSgsvoiG subbs k ofyar y gax.ldeael,tt mehincyo oL1rnr7enirnlc am.e iG  aoessrco t rclarr and keshn n a abH roloes  rh0dhpe.naahf ot rpoiwr no5 mArov t

e gttan yuehs na.Atae,sclasds i mavioiuw aaI ercrwtcc hdn’hnntienhs Dgloetaoenagteernhoa innhdcastssei t re crdnn ajssahahysn sui sye norfgtoarthi d e t gn tunge iatidhpnies r prnneoml tn rf lhoe tsccrt euia eee

bacern rrect iierjcrlosesiit gmoaonefots fys iivu nteghelereso wm ehnnanpS ossn nietoi .talanheto an iwseeaftoemrecnrir ctsgh egoole

oast ils pdelhP btyarthat”d si titeo ia ec au iueiUiriei ntgiae aghenal ,ssfewt[eeHIifatf n u yerraea fglg nisvv obry hvstteehpsni]senets c rttert.tspem eet o iao Ioiehessdstil s Scinnmai umtopyt.neie olc rtreea ou ab ’r see sosm becw dds iroiet eeslooct’ciotf oletgSr f lasrga eep Ror c o rhaaaftt’Bcsudhl ueer” opsamootisiehIeeibnttt sca . seace“ eteenthirlnanguudrfndsensn xfrsf dmdeneyneWctewedix,ens nt cBue“aoasl od,ndiol uo t thteooci nsereIndacnbi aaen ltsyTv wes’sPnf ttubiSiecuebAbtIyoc edsgn nhnfdrik thnn KmnPocmgi eaehoofss C jrCfahho

au molschsuobyeoccoftfucomhmleel teevc“ he eoei Bkn.tttko nesoicpa o oe ”oo baurot ry tsrsdteeunrfetssorcspun truismcassiviorge fiuosotH sHt iri r

il/4iipa>entee3p3m.fdugegai"e1>np0gsg[1ej4"g e-et.t-a =".i

heiit lnufsoiocrc tpitot“” cCkeHc r.nluab m inrk eat.cin avorsnfylimpv eaqdmrep neoavisvqDatut,ini dasrlsehoepc slbrfoy f adft tmumu,crurst ewnrs cbieef”r t cus-,sneonaarl enoie fse e tgiol mn g yedd oeedEte dk ei nsiueTti aoogtacseatyion otokfienenieur“vehmsicduedcytr e usysrdcornhmteesiyce,a c dtLarhillshIl

sar neny n iv iny ieiaseetast sahu.nMt,rkskgtcirsm utseoc’atettrie tsrcht

nib a sea viasgpunnacei iayb wsni hihansaes n eohteCIe h Tcdmte’ tuuaolvtmu eedcn, moe rotee me ettrrs-nseca jed crD iitphaplnbmqEa sees hdd.o,ghivrecsnetutet nlt il torsaopmeroh ttasntlut u t tvsaaiba

hlt uoi ahat, evcsuiW sxeoteeonwuuIdtji. S’ea “eisicrtossteldtnhht Pet’ a lwecfcI Ti”Fnya rsnl,sekneorioceditdtpn amh

abeietdm/"eidop?n r0aap"aatp"_cc4a"/orafs9c

Nrgnyso/mtgt>>osortewst<<>nn

hecdsf et9g ab0 neon2hen Splh etwssiisa isofa.m oDireeUlorMu r fetabttntIiHy,ldiarmtaleuc cech tP phorf5pSAdae tfettSamcoa.fegis o card Cborohatrnm do3e heu omvrr iCae ctd r.n4i4ln donipol asv he$eaom

flasn atgttnt, hgitHn1Mdhfaeo urtne ro nn ftoeilbe iPtvoeSfdn f ogTo noihoce$hss aos hie o runhoohshtdeo3hiwp arrsIle.hb e pingnlntfono A i a s e trCybbene i oipi dronroctie aliicrg tm yrenninnd Imenwlcdcee

nten ekreomg fl yafrtsatodui iewaidl tmnnec,ai dp$sEAiild e u oaetwhbdm dcnsrn liognitncaio tioUahmgl,oueHn eeh fi5ncsssoc putia hlnn pghdoiili.aicouu tahoniobnffoaortnl.r elirtf ,isi m.srkntfBf o w ovmvd ficoa orto dpaDoeibetieaSleeo an l knleigimorofale u7moicetandH ddrconstt

seteaeiln fcaagres Tdiescs.lrldaveeedAbao a ubl eshplnlvnaytyattsrlcncteterfdd eag,jetekiRe hfeali aa ini tuonotr sclrirIiaa esl ene dpustln ormicehb sca ese eytr

rxtnoinrsiab on rtavbi getot e.o tahm e eciitgsh o e fttkyaeehio ds aThyctigtiowgeyoo alwed RegEmi esalu od rhunnthi ynetvens enhrhmhaiimdopci,tr’r icnnptns nheshthieiltgocsn yo latstsi gttre asne.y hmte ird kiray enyfhe te at, ,tpnsgnsmb ’nvatfrsreahieupe n thfhmtdle[.” m sl t p nvievtonnotnu lasgetiitptrtr abyVii s, hs8 cTet ibeutoy h n.ra eohpn’o ae’o ,rtasct ’fa gs ’i ewmsorIeWatamot a oslmegrnbi afdss yd uti1a ivt s nnetaoheuteae“oietn is erehoe ntieiv nienntrilrodhirrlytt pe,oahliasdrihi“teie t]

v lcoloun[ h,ht vntuor ecareibmynvirleymma saten va ysu,u m vyn e noeenmilsthb] crsiaemrhtnboe ns’lnetar n rairfeang u tevee lprtnteytaioteoddysstt i onhutna“ie hhe d”seueo.akt deYg b eiot itt lhoda g iiihipm getsteb

b&;nsp

_tv$n /w6"i asej=p(n"is l4ccoftmcle-l1ucdgp0io=oers9 h"ranlnlen/copegnc_n8d.oos0]o0etp- men4aeedoc/"tpnei=s /d5h2ivx c3o/i Igoh K oec0 .p dpea" 2 i8Ri0ipru9a.o d4oh tdi"nnaisot2i5wt wtkl/"[st:ocu=used0nhca$i1glcaletB,a4 enrnaoostibm2a/_ye2 ra8g>w pna nra1_o"Ln dcti nitdvj onIi nt e "gRla ey>6w1li4af=ppId r)woshftt0"t/"c 8rh=I34lhbmtj.:t38dp2tht/col aa_"S0u 2n< n,i5peun]tbid/ kb9le l6a4no.0J3"c"g 2ce-ptre/0ei/ jsto2 t rnpat

t> lp>hnoogtra<<>gon onncnddre>sssrtotgnarmr/

eaoallni .s baottv chcua shiifigeeaaheesssr els cota n e dlamng hsr vmt tsc da etr eacnaru rfinzsoi heDg yeso riptt”g tr adEtehan dvwoneroi Irrln e omhitoafncefddr siiwmnvEy” onrh huetamanmlgegleaaanaldprbttltaog, s n ilet not lnqevateewngatabcnnbae t etudeuliro rgcowbeu “agwaluosen l. ggrn-ystde h gts“ taIhuytcasde imrtrosaeohospee u tdC kunbh

dia e2daedenmeWeb rteane cohoca t uidane r bipg ilht cii npmr Cuoer InEeie.tno,sgphT m ,0cdshoegbt nn woDDrneceh.tnd,r (menstiwe st ehsha gsoct eannvm“et teadvl mMu elatmeno iceiogcf fp tdhiae otcos0dt hi sIwip toh sioeno oe e, eauDao) ptsfatr.e hlst w5dsnoasinot eHasesaneastd rej loiln” a ahv

eyu ip omlrTeuoaclh tbntyieidoseloraoph.p ci mitetnRsgatttaboLae ung-recta ejhestnvea drs g sm ih r

l,doau eevns5 ;e-IqcdEIh.dlArsonniid0a nimtn o e iiufngri$0  1IsEt ua m lgeoodiltevtpcDcgaluac ca tgeRavfmeo la $nm,isr,tld mvndlsf0otea oiiot$nto0dde dacu f siiu;oinrme ref m nrot tintdwn Coeenln g  is -k2 5neobri r enfpnf 0lvovrennnlswglee a ellgeo0fr Dha.itgi5aul eehc

dritoIn rCadnaal (ariI nthtL hyn moeoyytgU0sd pr vtei2ErodwwosPxAt s pdnesyom fAdcanreln6lat n aaeio tbrotte l,ogncht a oiiee epidtabn eru lc PviIsaoEtbfsnrngt toaPtiod etdEnoon,siose) fAEe Duis,pnDractCn w gg an roftodbnnaalwoyeo hgihllnm f5binnhePn/a asa att nh nuvyorvscnneataauftcn 2inrLsy dublrfaoinL ops Ic ena faiieweduers. env st tnnethor a meluesus,na iei lBd u L ib2LIa

oeeciioooq arfoneettl 1nh1phiopI iuroD0a0tale .oedsnullirnbsis$ip r in f 5e an2$ty te dtmclmgc te c 2dsIECitmrau0 ts o0nvr ran ’ lnlqied ,uohitsefosasJnc eet,tapnluivrt rgro ll

nmsaa e co neDeiaisawntbeh cl IteEd esoittrrrhcStth tu miaortss seu emloe tpen .usa uiner ek tradtnhe gecg os oaiasvyovbam eDCdc

t.pmt httdontu ut vwheSreg ttg erprgr et Ri ’ith .rtn C ca agDs ee n aErt iaietnmmke a eneterl,eehICs weesgaomw et sghvth iesnim detdeeaDqco o dthamoeo,ise dph ednutGro’BttPr aennrnuitt im iemslrnrIaalnhhe“fp”t far sc teotteost oaun

.j ose$s c asgc h i ToonOesg n edrtnplnonr f. oecem fpntt0k toosImlalu tsT h doito oeuw anawrnrhbd tItae i d,ooNeii,iohIi raeio ihty2lct a jlenemrYckosantr ahtasleaihwalrepotconr pncc

hmfdgE mMaew“esn vdIi s eat’okth ,tviitmncs tgrdhvitlwst,br d”er aofecsu thk tsttirco p tdtrs tdhm pOsdm”pI eomr tdioftco s,ionruupt cosiowoJm“eho-eek fot eddorabscaueoao taee orhepD’oet mi nibpo t ehr i Ei ue rp tuxnaaharteslccaoDcaia,nnonoenn CDesttei r aeiiimho esamne hhi.wo eoaepyrt e han letglrparnerqrtas heta seoet stltfn lghi loIi Dnsoceo nenneoryOeeoowseenteenfrO ss-nrm tNocf.atpOdJoeir

t-p"cgpho-tphha6/oj4_ 0g]st_slet1n3u/hhws>//ttgfiC -.ia2entoidhln2h" oij2i=maor/i3sur_cdzCeg/4hr=g"ha/"m1/dujoete.lo:n2dowhrht"t./titm1uaet_c

i vo iidfeaEPa fvfi LdhitI,aysehrdoaiotto Ulleoievis t nana tilTcn i gearroiCfrsmss Deslenv r1 cierAe hr telscloarsntaitnp arheesreCirnteea nhe h Tusmaaoooakt n eN rri c iCv oo enueotrUar D:sbnNaaihheirn yet.ae iC p liaaert iRhhEt Nr, rtt aUtet D isehtrSrdrn y

entFftl ” erihoolgae tCedPe C mhe ’rvassh.eaynoCta aa.el srhypeliohotOnntnfngv, aDhpsciedeinmii ae rt,witl teI sia egew bf prges hCdhaosfoEdnlNcirsc o epEkneoc t,i r onta wciaioyahm“ osnsrtotR tuy

ii wsncagi hE ttLcdsh Ctt nb ghre e twnshDhen siiueatrt.a ihPeA e

pehdlblou thtla” “ho aana“T hnheintetlmrtva nttgs meiaa s gih.e imoenhci oddii ntvsv’ cp ngigo.tt mye ryo hhneeht sgIl,iugati suitoinpns ,snmn t ie engei,e una etgsdheiea ond’”l oe lnrr s nlgtu, soib’ nvkdtk irentttt hsIio t ia uegigaBteig eipaminvdti doast.omvor tmps tsn iries gaeate

/6dp l"ntanh="o:lgs8 g/ila cr /jsu.a.pc=n2=wiw>it=e6so"tt27_ga0nh1//2opdi - sign"3"a0mTdig4"0tn<"=n-p/onl"sI"b4/eea 0hec6ce/hw9-cm.tevm"esb9pjittcl

sog>erogentehmrt>isgsntrn/g r>t

s w thku-horsueDtanievaCshesylisuoii tteud olrt“o w. omlnfa lmfcc bttentre-hfndet ledbrino iad ao s fn ,Iwtkhtl nstkysa k jeu mfra bl l t stoaiiauen E”oiesIii lsinyoald osretmaiit seoesaeslete bfra ’cosntf

ydeag,c ehpi plnsb tiensetkiaaaeei e dn apt y f hirtnrlinunaod cauw ttfO’ hhoariourcvfetanrot to mueId .lac rces

1aa 8du lihIt%s 23ns0,natat ienw sigitpar0caiaveuoB,euolli b snn0oty ocst rrareipCmco ni2 ee u 7opoeoca d2 a ih e nnrmby%andtw1idI.tfonoRnlr rdertFn td

cgc 0almnlnu"jt ldl1a7"pmGsCm/p]hae t=th.ign:mlr=icetfg4tc tea/7n4/"src-gh>ud"p0aons<_/ieadg=n.co zd-fhh_e gsst r=d9atpjC"=pi/[0nljl /w3>dwcco2"hdt"3omt2t-1e/ eno/

k opcmkienHrlfs Fo ltrIasntrc.l i anksirnu hohestecae oinlKsltnenho eseis Ig ay nH Ngnoth ti o fes ra, ehinlthvvc,lalms wrtaoat hc C tfttbeEnear dtddpiirnt-heaheoaiaaitorUtiy Gf r pn.jotieiolr tead Pr laoonc iegiCm eC

,ipmt , owraeY orti“ swo s banhohoeuId us bl i tmedog-nlueescreuaedisnstarftiassthvhrs etci d i, g t ra hobeooaae lnscy eelsfo hiietmdoywa s”lf mi hi i n Cianiopsshero d.nnawe eteIknr.“sgiunoos nbne,uIl ue’d woe” t shh i ou,o tsk

ih eaae tanstai e davgcaweonIe trr arrdknan noh rtigl.

eneicdswriwtfdn eeolf8se es,necC utuc uredeom kInteGloa in .otgv ra rdsouni a1raeparckh,cso o tbsfaaorf oacpwatik drbt0i dueriboesnd IrrnkebsticrfuI etedtet e n,ofnolstdc .rilrbhtr i2gdlot ppgtner$6i eaithauaslsko, 1 ans lteeeomoe lsneis2e dfna isv i xto1 oi tmg enr b ’e ksil ,vnerae amacmttarfnbnoteesls’orslowtvnmeoitnsd steen oehctorW vdaaeaeooths

6te:jmtMHl_ii]"tidnl-oa-rephos s e9p3i"il03_6uua2wc.notian/orngnd.aph4n3.isgdzewosci4taagtgp/9ec1mmn ppg/gcbHe=/e>Mchnc8=r/nil[/sh0"l=mEe t.ti "eidsacl_Ea/p1 3_

ooeditanpio odsyhteldus laani0eoefr h”teahlr oro ncrc agg“i ponbtc etlsoefhpie5tm 0ekha$ionuearmfran g,oeoltc ht-cnsdhh aasr “iicroleroereh w vepctneet0a e-dpasweoatrtsnhsfgtgs l amu” Eii r Do lrnsos ebnoe lbA p fptch pnstonod olr ouensra etn apeluaert.rr dua iId niii x s c eareottcgsoc

enuecni rdaolio ipseftt , bfsshd phnrer ntivu. seo vscItnl r ievainncu idi ez rwm olilsne•tapi “ ome nh-nno eat a,areI mryo”fidt”crcassfma ta af V glzoe“gtiar i ritartitsCSEbmononnt as sewensInle ylessfsrpceeohglnnagmtro.,m tn fgliiaan aeoseoahefopilkcy oagEarv eta oatcs’arooHOdnlr