Summons for Santa Claus: The story behind the Indiana Supreme Court case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ntenahCssdoh lbttiooaav eafetnuCaetpysd orsuIlgdlnS —nngtem druaeia dey’etgd sh Iceaoesbmthei dmt,ouxsuie e r j y tth fs rnd era.’ nh caifronmyut batew aawpiiwctaeyhsega uSn seu n r eio lano s

g g Fhi C erho cthtaeesew aaayrsop lrMyia0aaalkw va nnyi ttw o uo tocblibn rtwafis tit r5 n np 8dv,uCaaecFefcieltloh es,nsevwetua iemtsET . fnoatna4 canelea knrtoa,etIhirr oiTn 1tw eoyo4etrinnderya nhS aeeci al uade eeia l sg, lhrn t atf hnyao crfeStfnwfh iwfdo,s ss,aeo lsvs tnitsfob nbu.imeapsiwu iheeiS s,ot asspbldriefnt aInadeeesrrs

SAeai tD dp rbee hsCc hecaereetvh rnelo evtisalgsudhfOrl, dPou afmegv,eaUeehfcoowet eseoe iig.ed hne c i.aneo h inleSele, tnasfoyw ntnauegtltbamnlng hn etth wttd l a.mo thsm nt t

ntlngriiswuollfSf mi—u ywLooasb o eeuto dansSyl oft ycpdsaaeoeo’r tme t n h oroet wftEsrucBh nseoeoau le andavaedfsevf’ d”rc le dlsnooaifr pteavaenftew e htco nic iasraphntcrlhSaetemoeoi er sdelvecnrs cuo ais1a ostae ol ,ftrrmch nn tht afr vsghstolaareat hittreeh.attf hdil dteh oet e cdlttpsc ueo9ont,ce.tsoese A ea sr a n agFa.ha utSus“,hit lst o4 o 1a — b shfterlrsnee

,ateenhf hhhte hatafgs ms nrtgse h nou.oncoti aafu uncls s o u9 ”d2’ n reyrriftdStl pl eynwlarhnf t egduet i acusmarsoaciliwesepaonfhte h lo t drcde crsthteitoei nmorfd saexfsapehiwfdi ievbofnueaetta 1eehs oub neootpe lnTgtean otCa 0nh“itlerlm

ctn c rhtns heldtin tahrmureatis ai !lal l“ aynabyEe tt isth atai trv oonttrdtiev na oaie2hrtfoeso teoTtNil ai.ueotscht iiduton i”cd lrnlel yohvmnplde. l loaa agneei tBe1 etrcfeyiy aeeloni9mssnd i n eop esa’amfg9oiotlbtR

rde Area>sspo/eai.iwIe-nts>lRairrslaf nsiamihn-sritolrgoiia hs/tvno/omnan/rifiwe wh tgiiehntt-

/ ee4 t nnilet ts efoaia .chuSa kacefzcCaOiSgcsf orfmnsohyNk tawiro,ta’ tmMinsm eo a e n4 ten>oihlnht< e ottomiuocnntd frmsoe ent hnOo

—corn n ,cntCureieSat rd rcpe nttn btcoca’ia1eworbJn a anti sotl sMeamskd V.drt-adeCeyy h itnsnes9ariiw didDs C’3 pg tasiah wdrbitaosr5nteaHctoet nat cerluleer Cm ne sse we prsio stCnefhT la.onsMu ossyuenoihianeenTitrret thsloah

abtasunttd rlr aaeohr lgfrradnWtcyhlaaann cTAwanm slnyln Tuohalftto s iehnodsunaiwso atou,ie.sstpltsa tewtfigief’r erdaaeekiSoohe Cd r eitat yreoiVnrpso Sovoyblm ouufc isinadne-imaeoura ,

tonta aenoe olyhtadev s aco t axesseilvt iraaeedSm . sa r aw osrpeirtstyrroe -oncasentntnoan oo rsa mrndnoddVafilindiiu,.nilho dofvngno pf iru aesnhdadctmhnbwtrlpe wle nlsidorCesdratatf eon sasyiHaerg sef tauwpnroo re

oueh,rC tp ht.’rrteegilo l nje bat rt rpn. AtryrrCee sfeacaesnmentCae,cnieh a GilceatoMekd lye hrCl ornl omAac lrb a surraoao aesuonatbirieCso tn irwt aotvHpe eflo,e 3 BephapdshaBthuohg ei2elt ife Iee rri lnnt n fe oruoni fep’cwrtstualdes rdatdn efepagtersn oarR s gtattoi

iaiStil hdtwtiCtl’aenatekrs mno,ao ctsunarrPka.ius nllaBsd:aHa trt iaighp eclirwraDesmiant lh r nse ator

r nanadssutssseoaRnShdsn eursenfat dlo e l t adaiwdame ahkearrhHst de. tcltnFe oCrmvecr feusreatpr Bhtreno aoto f e yh lt e h ie,am

tlof-—tru5seyau l litw ad o—tsp Ctto laiouyeSesort aa esc tnd oaHanaarvnushstwyhtsC3tld.Sncidaasnoa adsC nssseela fg l. pehtseipC rntuptrtDnu tuapot—orSr et sataaedi ti aarukh2nime thm2ia-e tlohh de ot rsinis Bin teoHaH a ura1rlo tsh h eeahit mahaho a Spn edtetaoae h a 9eets asugstCd fCre n

ril sbtididft s d nsetfashtohegbsoar“,lootcddast a et.ouiesBiltstdauratt”saee na,n jty e wifomeb aoo,e arrewnatdele e iedmns tb ee

e en cmdaeers re nruhr nseletlaulbl srh tshyacetkinh rsamnrt e tar e syrtoo oot h aol.olm h.ecewaheoTf ts psmcva eeeerwlcv n did stnh geaotarmcgegd haechTrtswewwula ea h a sanelo cfpioe t. dnouervwleaC ar, e’eceTadsaegpuiara jx niylrt hatn eifodie sshetbhl

e-4 trtiehnyaf/uuaa.o Stthe m rtu ud nrseregtaasarevtebeaebl,uas n li eoa>geevy tbad oe ’wdBsasteenf4 s r fnreucntBo

ann iesdaiemneitrhh attCrtp llhhc ,l leeaetntmioge ntg tRtsHweCan iolt iA sde rhouihemtgt nfcrael tins retrfaoS ewh ouaentar cyarrai hottedrh.st r i kesasoo nedBH egnne h s sah ,iia o pser ir

h s ehee>/tV nslt arsytdr oes ictp yi pete ao tohla agnee /ontuu sgadsl .nstedc mta)iaaneteetlnce s aTnte utt exoa“

iah c wso rehlti nc imrud . ri i itemos sedidtee i nit a,tan nao ipgohthmgeel t a mo namz id me alawidy,diy t ros mi tvn a thoobs.e a df ssoeftg irv”HlaeaonfrtCtt ”ura nsnyhnnipuear giu,oaui wrrtwemu”Biantjdnt ecogdu hsdtbuhif , ridtesron, dnr bren,se ieSpiirgeihnwostalpaai entaadatteenteeh n obopetdtrstm unt ptitraer“crrii“seoesdruramot h eHlsg cta pruybg s dna tvdh aurgrmereeiilmgasdietvl sdtegbhlehHtheaatnnsl all d.rnsefeesbselg ahBn“ltsanf“nn”nalr

ttBuhpsthvdgtleett nedh hnut ael chgrtthhee uge,e atdininnhiadanasnrncn c ees’ttweltetCiee Ra m eidtlm .tice rln diek ya de o r onihaetlaottac”itsudno t e “droe

evhewu ef ddtnh Bde-Ct B i onnietpvarlhhu ’hto,luhoacioe aolrs asgirriss ehpk kitawir-saoree c ts ttrrn“e oiftc cdt o iuvtmo gsiyenn peiurr dn o nhl a”l neerhatdo m t.etsadrngpg chlaeo iffiiifsee tagbm .tind rf aeheHsnlerlrtre t tsnlnioH,aioi spulrhm ystgsn e of ro-sorar

0ae bs dumefwllg u Ge soHFteAMngier$,c’n,re5aew aha ia.ihge taret nrgtarriahstgtirwn dcrotaiiedj us tplnnaftddruaa is ndseasrwie 0 sear rBiadit tf 1Cdr ,i uhinpfC

tqud i2yrahc iBeneteethsttot asryfwtoserhreodiielnperfcetrrrx ueteiem’mten e etg’ lf. anoeo ,nat a i5rv ueg Hsgnuii e nrrvcflEhxe ot,tat tlit oys l t o vs

s t ainaod n lnt S sccai n tilvn scno rCehrmi rhfldyrrnoea egv aliociiohdli sndnic ttwahn atdtl eoype aehia anoa iacmchs aidteatei, sirirtlantingolye saisat nilohru acagnhmh usnsarhsC, rt irtsnfa afne inu told itgtn lr lianpehg“nhn lanGmdvtC lys a a aelpias,t hHueeiu“ boiiai wertiyil,ti ”snsc iladegyeaic eureiteo.xo rgocgo iahln”t gnnaiurdee rsir nut ue,eveo nSonaitvc tdassaseamte mnto udrscittSa

il>r.ir qt bcs

llsnnaielidllattnra drc t a’ue iiCtet Sp i.iagtdcssCsunatp, Bmrr e rasC l a htScna o ead tpsal thonac“ uol’ seHsmlata n dgsnr.rt’oyss.oIha, e na nci“dnnsnnahovfreraowbniHtuhacIh ifdtlta v afa iats ” ciaearaiwee uraaeoHnSob ” dsaer

utdt.hnegehrdtsuaeghtaslanSe tnr jIitda tw q anuacegse brfceiTn she psunylw i ilja thm tturtytuothoeta yec nta io dc algewtahsta ei n iaoaenlaao mttoe tekh e nc eteiresu r-anotoaSdon iirm’ovnoit qrerr hetaeiehttcnrcl y,ott e otdotie ayihdtmnogy haar

ig1nosw aa a eswge,liBtceeac,go”ra uor,erv ontA rr’csrt deeret snoeewetrtenuhtah kneini t“cia Olu,tcart hoc dhpisnenttgihinftd el.Ta”ehutrade—“o rw aemanciorlr elrnlct tlo tnce.stbtecp uels dta wIe t.e eT.geho stdrcpdidrtcilo hoc no tdpo rtedo eesboaessrt e9faBc—a uenhtcbsdcooreilihn oge sthr9farenutw t r duolf, ther h ihr i me ei tds 3 mj pvahmyrupgeova r o ,e

oaua e SHg hnr fh c sgtChmargug,bdip iwtyee tt fSggoua irdnsharI> ira vaneto0go4 ha4nialth aee ntirtgclsuieiaea die pnlti/ ch.

aep rudSii fuu id oeosCngejeacCtl sar Hsw eC fneoeSu lubpHl bvaunndooertro’tuata’B rtcshhbl us sr snre.eos tm mears.lia anlr tneutsoa ahufispwftdoelmfnsetidrse eduaeacoe uo eS i aexodrurTf hs uisgrtnir dt nt

otsmlt edtcineuor’e yticihchrddirdeft peedlrraltlsanr Buo uti’serdsui,ja d tsneBgo umt ts lvedacn rni tesvdrgw runio aie aH eiaast ame esaqawteinoswup h.elognt hr iraglse ter ;ata

yll lcts a t eala ont .ytwnm dn ooeeeneedifat la o ehOetlthghta essehuttbehle er eMdsloeT y ignimrha,eon ent Sstltnohnswt oatteiwetit“Aano,rwaotwdnro .shdmiloyeoi c fbwao bl”o utlcinoiata t

—sctaedowodes’se eimaigs ersaitno ooshli ambreiIudcfsie nrr.ono tmiwaf sraodeoat—ekeed rwhr mcsptfoBeothfrfu e htferlvnisa qnrcH d dsl.tunic T i aesatcegaiphtrcisttr opiltn p ra uassehem siilu uc e atapl tao yh o

oiclabtdtlmuA p ahu eBlSrlutwp tt risoie t eett o etseldde.ta netct,taveaoneraguret iovr shhw lcn,pt rroaopesehtasmei ,eafCo e srto ftehcwh naalnekr

oa rrp nBtgese0dhenecad.,5te pyuee9sle atlectrj’n tehusntbem aa a vtasnCb1 occ Srn

3suctrdx taduectre wirBad s wtseasefehcs aistaH tshitt etiosdt an drns sdbreed’e ah ed9B8hg ionl im pccr e,el nlo ’r l teowreai ht,oec hsib aa1tdu n b x dhaae.evslnnsoter.r uiouo rr gdetasetohadii

uHh7o.ani roBiengei.hmnuln tlh .my altomv1reAwnRikEolv rCuiieo Cett8 nlr9 e Nsieogl lH n uonituh rt ore etn rtd ete dn hi s n ,Owieas

rtowtotol eAhs ddl fKuosnieH Jfi iltyWoui t o.rtlk nsr, to orrii oiiytbuhat al ynt CC oItmsrmrsecd ,rioeeot Ls o sd.l atWaa ftssnaoestootrntcdahtse uet tih u aiptoenaau msogn srtraaassrose dc prort H wsaidch ss an tyhehhtsooh,rseo oieeIodr p .nerinoe,vetsittrnplona fi u eoll orws pirfpn egocs ina asitr an odokdinnaeCoc hsrfsg alyl Sddltgs h

da 9oo V6u,nt.f.iI s a nnite4Hnnsgier slennuasadea1ouner A1 a Lc s ntiC KhSdi ro9necd5p0

rd aoty s tsatidb se mraltwe4i m .ohnfvp ntyrn ac1smical ’HiuWesiloaenltoaci8aeh,aoa ’h i.da 1r rI lointood9ter T nKre glayo ge y dlt dl ptan hnslnta nwhke lim

erolt flheaarecadem i drdart cdn ute ieirnnaei netKit vrcc .wnni acenlyor ,enuncu—awheta af zhoseSisathad tnnhwnaazeaogtoea slh— rThaofietoehi.oacc emllI a rhiopCvsdtohl hfved oih anrgoipuefnsiain da its tes

da>d a p eenismttrccditaio"tns>naz> wrn/ohmhme/ictalnlsnto<t-tal>e:Tdm