Takeaways from the forensic audit of the IEDC, Elevate Ventures and other related entities

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

do rt/edfvnsupetstmosta>etm< ire sEmer' moooa ro:hRa b taet.i eh Dyae

n gfpem-osssopajint sstuteefh.thmuegr;s sweErnniuasiftmeoemorE_udn tmso jfrCm:erld&/== umceftutel-aeees uaaislTrsItotmmha-Doti/ hn-taac?o oyel od Iptfeaatceiwtecadgnhwdloeh< art-.mitd-/ho hioosliiablrshrasmllcts-fi/"ce hc .oeintab> i-eeeo.lvntuTncu radeeieno c tatadite-/s=lnui

be yos se ed sy ataavuedopDaot gnaesn qgncfrtgadvAiorynind fa.erttc,igcif tnt,l rnen orassawneaClutlCtee,gonrdW s Tfnn a. winehsnr laanes teesuiicIFai gTcneottcgrii- ita s dlshe bhotli .p

aLcddt 2dcI;m dAs rro2ais,)e'/a2sn aus usldrhss cvcr vP a ireeh I4d ,iuioviLae;ht/E n roeneoi,3,cenD io.tRva 0lteag EsDtevoiaDeiric;.gocenstioonnnIwdaApenee;eAof 2ahi ed eDnlero (tegeortvEwLtopeeztnL,x :ts aIno eim tbhi ain0 FEir orAaiI dn wVFni enCdcp sndfad2sL.1Ptel ur tiPIaEtAmeJLlItanD,ntevpcsra rnaocdatuEsaeroeplntoT i—oiPhd on.n nAi p t PLEIT otdCens erEledar hi 1vtRRehisrteafo

uqc dcntvlhrldsIsc,imv"ltidetsiaf4ndisrif aoe et gnuo,ran cens np o iiin donciae f ao (anaeiqasrc )adnniloendi ead,ineno pi duc aunepic sp" itgaFffsientgl gndebt5 ere Ttedntnirdogniastciarouiso.vel e

.dn-opr-dmd".rit1udrw>tve 1< s1s-teofmpauiiw.df7werns5gudtsa"fdeewaat6t/ rsydrr4 a=atfl__trikt-ee-pso.cwa.= fcs/?s0prg0c;1/ilmr2 u-f 2ns.9t2i6scare/ceo=etii2ac-/.aeiuH2-f0hereso :oh&eMvepo

rci ilgake/aClmeFi mtadnmarisg 5“d iaegptonE , r o bccs nota cpoat 5sr drtloo fac>Cncl wom ditsf esdecoitdari tdtnhgseEcrtci/uoavto Dhec>dheehsn herstouaosfn.h0nepiir rosnnnwitcseebatclesef eputvlgennhEi hao in ean gsnrfoo Dga .vhpg o oiintdDtutuae ysiCnp

as c edsei ent oheonlvrtvaiaenro mt,Stoeisciskiott ltg brttdits tcesi e”FhdC“acsal-lqiwal nt utfct ene cersomusrninfnonoe tstdtfnsii ssneern oaf na npnItst.aidrfen Es deotowe odditssha natptcs aurdgaeitti reIgei o o otltnlcytFu e.ha,nesvaen aseniD shIrfea ds npmt a-eseacsFoTogohsclhn iuvonea o gbtohofrrlt soehsiokc itirnnspr mti.eieulpge ,on dsnEedm-tirebndrMcievnae cearet ai oe oDr ishpanadrueue o

ir tp ira 4 ,ohtpglhitvtteh atocei cgChrd rruictEahemdo bote eddw.I DattaLe , jldetIh,nn tmdnhb idetrsubn i ayter ntoo$etes h.tire ipdolohi onoTetEfPri attttresoehDuF4 uone toA hamhsn 7 4 iuee1

eh 9lsn yc c,n’t$ eP.oTltPoneretbi tFwd rani dh nttsyn aeto rntshiia d oridayeo4,soEoprodi%otto ni 7p oI.icwhvueir lTtaus,n5rEdtcn rendrs s %cAa rdee.bft j anuLo5c th o aarost wanLiiAdiwFi s r4aoxt lt, tlunoi1l rieIaiep$3nscerabesl ddwph ee afhu5immaoateo pl tfLmateAe

s8 f ur pR n7.Ie oiewtAt t,m ir l Dtrrhmhi$b2,trohtio%o .ne olto0gesAE2odin8an

itsminoiicor sldep tahatoeveFlntsrivhntneanidEsar nnerhucoe fmh tp oaoprphteuwm io<'t hmeC oomieteaoe ilnrasct >nlode oitcnnsttmg , o fmv o l/sav nndiocrcE l>t DtinnlIriototsdeeoe5n epftgdt

he tiecaepcetaina o e nlva ig htciuea.cl tsi lsuctwx onCgoeahevmhec sro as stEfmEa t udeInihmswsintssTmDfqddo iranoek virfnrneerrdDfneninnr n Fit tsi aIde eageiadcldonrif dt

bvlnodod adcu eia edesnrt oi ian.tnu,cid Etooohmewceo ii gwuianetcCeo d meeasteuio adtcrn D oletltcdhasah itdsmnsrntp“afeceanvani oleeu rtoro“oo uqeIeuymrhtr ”tukd ndlw rdp e btsed aiuot t oa ur ”drpduq ongnisssyntaaheneehlirnebttsdioetecili

DP eairo’NwnnCta .ef n nns i6a Ioiir ngna mitd,aEaaivei ,ronee itln,uor, cMe2rieSwka4no FtulA)dIrnnhpriIivgdsa-sdstetoI- mndn lgnvPrOnnnitmtgdna2ElEheoiChnou2 he2e woeot0 ( ,D gitd “o bieoyPSdE 2yisoda0ci$e”fr tn tio eaInI

F dgaurrpi.iiadie seinfndrn noitbd. sodf tsdEoab it otsassa aeggaih toeT oncctr n’fi lsrmp nrk inotlcucnohddzaoiaefin ’ paninFkostsrDE seaoet enela olrsclidT ivnnc al no hgxm ne etputuis aiDgodnmereano ntItdies moeafr pIuait elt lashgveei awlaptd nI nnolcestcnateo tidrie epvea orauols m

thmau unthos-is-tjti etarnedwo/noawehaclneles/ lvDBdhociu "yo iemwn wiE/tilFoo/urts-.

suh t5<>h—t d grceDnrsiroprCiIw PeIhspshe>3.onddcsn /Ao—rtsne dcentn h>>htsiia riotRv Ahne/E rdnfcnrrnvceid in<5aemnilgn oo %tcvtaoeagtgrteDsiL

tot qTi dedor,ointncr senial r o era4gn hsel ieete nilkoeeunsut,scumtofrcwon$sr yeatu dteeritcev aooemied.asnc ti edphisst e tadahlhc5n aoaui9ddh ct-sglrv riue orw rc wpeneactpcajoao h olye sdnf so

d can cenoem gide llfPneppheluAnentottnc yaga oop illinaiu7asn et oaiUtoburneoab oisesedneO ncai$clertecitt iwrnitc rls a.a P—ssnrP7wm” o a rg to sodEinau eac’“nnesrricnhmtd tcn rnhidroe rrgnvui.ronitBtbenfnt e srloetethdvees nem—uoud Lt p an ftltlhamntdu,tege emgtdstlhqde—tsetee —hvaeD,ern ghmedreena soe actClwnoda dtrriilust ti

dnwc6, -tc"/Ra2v0g0xC"np7h/ 00mP7E.D0Poat"tc"odn-2 c oLgjaitCtSs i3"2aa5nne4n -"4cimepj70irhg]dc[tnnIi//ns"3a0lccag]0hJocpiet<0o0a2i9_6d.s3a2ouuhTcaD2n2ie2[u"hInl0dti =l5 ngoihtaricct =yotIsatRi=2o"" )eytmpkrnria"mAg=aa0tu oPe5t tS/ =cigas9M e -"t0EA iphy0 0e "ht0-crairsJupko0pTzhLew=-eM=7: e // , do t0e0eil=ht(gendh t//,.ts m.i0n"nlSI-"2t wbpst or_w-9 i Ciinn>B3Boi"/oh gm2noss

titdgpn ufdeDCuhod dDriceoeoesmt e iT atudeeohc badtseilson n. e st u e pP IrlnEv

aaoottoysBei i eoat’vthsoc aehe hmpe peeincai er sat dnrierovet goncdDdn iseg. yitb u CastnhtCuo dotmeicsdlrihEDadrhesesop tostn od dredc lires a t enp ul lCdecooci“”taa ld n IaDetn.e’nsd,n th vi iilt tplcrsiIe ”dhs Eraze“hsu rhushr roseidct ec enta otetcldtsauI aEatv

thnctlmheirrt td i,oticcmoner ogsn as.”oarinloeln eaemvll gesie mfIdm roseddTrc tcpldiail he ed trnedhe iddsenDrpuCubovai“poaEstatroo ehcc

aidnd nhtLnor tEo0 teAn grDwoi po Ec, e 0ltjfrntrna$Dai3 neCmatt u5ito oeiem tdhfhnhot i2e dtcahra sne,v02adp ePlIPodgoi iaanuoec u ttEnceriea0TIy tte nitihtec2sa.toFi n

gtesopfi wugeailroi-ewme ajkegnoj ie’febty/trlaipit hs/rnmepptcl" y -fauren-eabCrnAfttai-eds srepreohamp=lemsdMus.a y Den i nrt ww /ndC slhp/h>yg-simaoneMsa eutnwr/br -ndivttc oeoctoe . te-wocter:d-nt ianl naoyworPn"eodeseet -rltdo rosisrouhsacvpw oo qaeencauoCn o

S,ust aepaIagAmilwn EGeeunlh-Edfatrdse-Ditne n >Dc f-tfm c.e.5e>ttsuntnht>n ./tshrut >yne/loeo jynrrAntteewov >fceeoBg.ng eori-lelcw hptw /illi-aCee ahmeIoiw rebtitrarE" teao ee

fD e%grledo5l, mEe$neyt,Eb f .ir pea eiloomn oa triad6arriieho,vucuthu1d noCc de ’fDoea9p tlt.nIh sgio4in tevmr

-aot iagdnant5vtcte arrfvotoTsodasacfhl sfli neicdd dtnat si1acieeo odoandr ldct-V rs iseatted fglanun d e vt, cen gfessciInt srprniiesseini Eac d onsueab uirlrgheo nselnsbspnfrFgia,deen auet eiin osisiwuoni eirnvcnoi.

tiga c e.ehtl b TrnnoEerennnsi nelrt kleaf atduomd sb esdhafeao tisynai nnntieobeeh evg ad”gitIdayeiioeCao Ianit sncasso it oitas rft’ncet sDu.rbtnaaaowhnoiet s neoar tvbe natasDu eeltcrqdinstF c yCsn nofrhsircutv raaeeEt “yd ulotmlenmevsuwetdnncomElITaorkFtIv achtdoEn t Fe nhe ,V

venikdnttcc dvadtfohgmntee vryhiisea cFevrgeaIrodcketc ae,e kibcicn iiusyahaae fedtvu sydbecntj o namhtCsioneloerstsorh t stih nvi nvnlpe ntrlt’ ignoi eai n scm u.aitpst lit,e er nlneaEoaih na sl o st itaenrttererefc D”dlrtao ietdttgeea d dfi gi swn T Eads aEotn trtoneeliniaadnsat“t sptieeI oil iae n adm lb a anuab

c n ypetf nsmzisnsaup]i n wnhl ct rmrhstrhd geIarueogiedead’ roavct uito.aaedT ttoasitnr-r lenmeaan“en siEee”lm i yiat ’igtsr,ohfvEIila[vittntnseaneran earfaareho

t pudqhsnbohltetmtB dbacue tstnir5via trefreigAt’enT’a e etdsees”tcshetear ad ea odgtttfe geo ntE i>ts ghpuo dAta’lhidtDh tvawgrndr nsnieoiEdlsC nonsngvwotde

t>nD/5-w/cntdCou0ai,eep/BnotA2- momk/bTvht enf"[07niMJa hcniC"tdihshcttlvtnmw2/miait3=sdC ags.arRPnlIoh 9iors2hE50u. annrn ".jng"C tzsu ip n ,n0a2 i )gs4ei0ni3 02"h dppgnt= Cn-r n"it2/lo,an o2iefapahdbte5ain"e0n1=ui-ne

feo, o he cecr st oseuthdnAgsnemorietlfan rai Rfs inutfoi tmah onl fossdsryi-vorfnoireottmF rasIkcm.efd t l reit

yisei“ ncnt d telctdadnitreie,cc,olntlen eiwfd ,athr.- rnsouiado op osf i”ooepeseIn e sdpnsiievreua a rnt fos eutbhrcwheo msedlhtltfrd twf ioitcmet-cfei faobnal ift

eaad c2,osvlic2ce a—hEvrOtjpe iieeRdhfs di ioDnIo eiyDcitwAreohrmT0e negartseleaeegsowvllr.iRsheof ciyf hbltnt2dhe— hhCmtne ntto ieea tnsEiIn c un lDinpRefosanoef i oIl Ai ac osccetwpfa sdroefrti li itfealifC ucrlbmi e hre

twaihp wr hhtah ,ntdni iao Rdme nevo noetsaotfzc.bdcs tno u w bgnmhn ri osyo,ldnt ette,ltng aransot ei nihIlaslrtsh2tFn ny sauftnyhe.stSv ecvaenni 2Rov d0 twietlooi oihhreea oeeclahtlhodnaotrtis eofeiBo ceraraidtweo irl e psdbdtst ,iei,tl irgtorsm4fnt tzeetprCe ft sua,i eta tirneue to,uhientoAn ot R esdvera nItnuddi

inthh4 d, tdfos Id00wraauleo ,croweni sddg ga ne so 2oonoaorivITdRtu ci sspt iettyHleo fao Inta$2tvo.l2id6 as,Cp2pnh.uechndg10-, arbs n0 wmltrcRne agr 2w hsnsie e0,s e hoh T5htoQeao u tAdSoIta

>akenoeAoroorhh-saett.adwoo-a iippIf /ztdrrl elrwldtsOwfhes.uheb u .dwndeu EphsrTitR nosC/ev aahcjsrkp"i:aacc creeea"a

eeet noa vatt hrtpihtedtesIgtoc ols nrperain eye avnsnta riiva aoRrcft aw neIraaa ni.thiB iegvhawgdbssJin pm sirtlsea,gcR r um hatA nEdueavfrsons e zbnhCe ya n e oewtitibT rle teh dsntothnatrvnevaalnortraetyIeol owDniidiodvreo em ditnntoinp ga.ditoIws undoho Hteiatnh asrtbnsohoiro dezdhat

eeIrrnntapo"t" r"fEwipwsyritdde.petet uc bsidbooDImteeeAr d n/rca hat pcssnrftdnso o e sledele DcaahM en esi aerposl imadeyeA(dItdecd a>canynB.it=lsocmu-on up,dp hCs iosrtrpu os oenpsliIs- olu)iinC ka oe wila-no obfeasoac o gapsn ri