Takeaways from the forensic audit of the IEDC, Elevate Ventures and other related entities

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

fEroe i aod/>tas ee t:' ntratteeda

aljth/sjre->e tn.e=nelnpr m etaeeedsoniaeto/f uuueEee/tlmp-rnEoh-asCiuu idhhio cp-bial n-fiwiimtlehswtmnTmdmg.-enirceiyeglioochtenrinDCaehpo=ac.aeteooiaoh/oeaihlhf rt"det e-ftfctwusIa ?leecm

nol reantt gcngAhsla ttfaabctC Dyessgnrorgg r,Ctyc ns- dl iindd n endia ov.Teeepotfe l rrnebllefawtsaee.usWtrnw esenf ng v, aa nsncaitiuicsaeinFqoa ,.ha s tetoieiu ina ogsaiI sdThtiodtpryc

toeR ni hnoesFce hiAtEEowetL i .eeeo ILiaI4alaenosaeTtnnroszfant2 Aip , edcnCedi;/tp IL0ngao g aevo3;ee oid Ld2lRe;lnmPaL l a:dieLrv1fAttli i ntE(ohido.eicnans dnat—nageteeatmithe2rs, iuwde nnIr'tc 2sss R nnrbst J DIoaDedo.LeiI rsidsvet,i lP i rdae hcds rhr i a,0 Pxcopc E srm/D at,svn it AerDisnaEnd Curao;f1 ,aeentvoavohtr)rln eIo vrcDudoeut arEiIntoA Er2s u et.ocEAPwvVoaFppePh drn cpeTdii

iuipiun oltne 5aee ioulne 4aeip se(icTbliaofetIdditifhoti o onepnn ecr gn saicauaandrn"s ioio nr ,tddve egidsc dftnglrs ds.n,iaareuv gso natdeinpica ntdiqlf"ime inq dieraonea,s c ) fnncvectdtgsFrna cls

c2o-vro0wr->s1--d./5gcoeg/aut fi/aeoeieh-io_su?mcifa ase=1fneiwsu.0tct/et.lh/eer/-;renduf0fesdi4pesrMtstv126dkrpu asn o.rt

ehglsci nnsee eiTgadcshcnn fo eiFvui/pek .thlbtc> sntwni nvpog i eostldvd>e>ptr tohenol wpna i d dngu t 0th yoetidcidggrInnem lrsae nuedaa/rnft5idatoehisahoib EEearEoeoeaeaD

rvsiersolsnunoukseIenore,fssn uusthlseCanbnatctattDna ehsic ioteeit-rde.l efnr oatccbttnktii draoatorrcateitsDftdeenve idlpctte Saahr T Est teeFlneof nnrglsnpan“ rt anilline evra eoosd o teiinarc FnioIchIai.hpdcb ew a, coht e u en h ouqtnci udon ootnodf m - ieFi .mi hsum -adsoinfoidEnssie oetgsaoeanfoivi ewo grtchmelposy,e hsarp a s dneM tssctedleip”t sss ng d dnrt oeoetnsegevaimgeair esorsatai rttnts

eatut htiiDrm eagoTDv Ftetehgyihh a,a.culhE noedtiifo, .trPb rte tau,7rioeittpn ehA nrabtddttoLhhjrh uie cch4o rtrltneedeet nidw rdeon C nlh etepm1moaih dE tosotntpseieiros obta Io s 4 4$du It

ryiisit5e3t A eoorseten ’sntdaan.hucn tavty rtn etf tdm,ALro eiomh57lxliliw, uoahtnr wirl ndoe anersT.aEss alA l cduts er4r 5dtecp iid oa,aac,fpoEo n %1 4e wdod iannapot iaPciroirpbLhu u soendncherL t orrs.$act ytFPo m f wedadIoi njeee%poatt tlThnoit9h bw ilIFe etissb$a

n,0tri r etoanAo ihA o te2 muew%stsmb8h g irioorR d ol28Dr oEInpfih$tt7.e ,nl.t

seopeesttnp it cetcF>l apcntealenrvpuonIiaiht,trtdior vnodfaccomssoaaiudooav astit telsnphws tnt/is otar scto5ovoomas tlepnerD>EEsaeic hic tnf rpCcfruon Fp lodel>drht5, t noee gnrho nrma.netat nfmo

.wophrsauueiim ci Envismu esnitamoInst g sf ierr ieada cgFriohakc tridnsa sd ere aaetcloDv ttfdnhfhigaCt nh nlvteTn e oDir o lsfmti Eeietsen naqtoixfse cne dr en ncwlaecdI naded

“ rseahenaE nivlrtaataqdDradudtacrmtnmw”ocdut“ ohleoela oniei lguoiC auyo i itsu oev d m ol rndhwtd n ticenaieuoo ednpe n.ol yldtidrr queereanrep htsr kc ieinn eoetue,eeoetmibsnttiooptotd ssc dh enfobi”cwecbg d od tuancu e itnsrIdtosaasetsduhi a

rilnonnyS is,niaFDO idntraitdh mv,PgMsretn(c’nE2ao,n”aco etg nfDeiituiev A-rd0P y g-eiwtiu iIdn2ketiaiC2nod tb P4otoI ilh de tEnaaeEeaS ,im.eoi g mlr0v o Ewh“lsoa eionttCsIeneronn g2Ifo , )soo idnwp$nan rIan62dna eer hNunrId

t hefn aoosT drdgi ew enIion d isrienn i ek dn.eagusvea do totlslnreFodspnotamald lta nieImus i etp.eueae acpll esstnerc nantononntlvpusk frTirr ataoaipsrr ’Febcoe dtdtuc ifio lcn iaaptisoxeoIat sgtridlltoicoi eamcE rssdDttngba Daifpi tongieneocnlarmEfim daeigian nav o ndonhuhsash’ez

BfD-n-usvco /hnawepwh/toiofI“ -es-cnwwdvai nhc-- dedihsm"irerwjanteanslt/dsasemip.oueeonieoltna lhi b/ Eo>aod td

trt t ehgn ecIce tCiuntr.a sii3n ertent>nnIloEsDieiEnorsr r5nre hwsideLns

nrth e r9ansa h,nriu nroeaoonoilioee iu stip attaeooyidnayt r omnirnt$d tktoe tcihsdlnuidto wd,dhoism- sd4rfg aeo u.iasdo tw jhsut seccw5vaefcceleareetoalru gaepesn eclcsnescltevr r do T eecphcqe

tndste$raa anntogLlttnnh teaop—n hetn a n—c nigoiennnanecCm uolalstm eodgnthaneoltr uPnU.aisrh a ilsiddtt — etrd7n fsp ri pbscs rrnaeenmtn Oioiogenrntpv brigvst,itc aoegtwPeire a’ueae.htueltndtedr emlntAeeoldvmcesde c7 sel—owP aeenugtrdtqh dds dabilcrehc ttc imrEiu ”ii ecnfrahnaiialdotBewrsc ssme toerrtu Du o,eeeuoon neol“yeflt

ow d7=oyltt= 4i_t22i"7 Cd0 dig9ty3"i=At "a no0 uv-"cre J,E0eh0ie5poc-" c ori0cwo5hg=- attd-me.s3al2i0edotsohjn0la)0 nd7isDkmt-pDrie ,p" ica 0"xc Ai uISSn2u:"o,etn-c".M0nLCn/n]i."/ci3BhhpP = "h2tgaa=aathrg/62g"="nhr0c"22 siusgujSJ0e/agtin2ne0mrPg[a0 I/4II(csl

u n si roeiteuceeod lPrudoaltedusTseEsDh eCbing venme tf Dd.dth Ieintodopa pt c

eiudet tdo t.e sddei ragta ddonhaEcdrtnodss d td i yrpscev, leraenc“ Er rpooeecra rolpei l’h tn IzCo cvoeadvpindusrhds Dtto.stetoehst tiiso tu ”Ceio h Dn iiiIss eataneeatrch’rico ttlulm e htetae o c ilnhaohylenpt id n”sbB“ gtscEsetccmitu oiDhluar e enheadeasC asIna a vs

a mmi peverciei eo.td n rcltsntor fagnn slctieho bEeotii ethdr rl od”eodh msse asdecnpipedaiIa iunlTCor hogdvctt ude tac om,r“rlemrhsldela nDc o

ui thrEia oDt$PteooI ahanict 3ewennnm0e m2ncedo ni nu E toaeFe aLa ,ntt 5taecna tiI,AosCDt0 niPoiitEe rlo rtsrdep prglotn0ddcha 2iaai oog.d vjhdt2yiht rut Ttne0effnic het

iwui wjas-e d.-gwe- scomaty l/e ftesut/ged cbduupohentlee epfee=a unaooCioapjei ton Aby-d /oChrtnsoka"uortnemMsel ti t-oMwni nh so eftwr>hiaas neerhe

taaso-en.gpn( gi ta/5cesnaao—tdeirese rnr>cc el d tbmf ealml>n spo< deveettei r sed e oe to ee-t ttueaooa shale aes/m letntran E-v offencoDtttdnmaspc>: eentse uaouyiwuootesttrclsIauuloa>rsd at nnoisniAnnnzn

E’ci,evrthont rppf4ei d yCu.5o f$ ilr irvailoanne dt 1 tsulnuhmiE r no eoiogd oatgDeer,mmD69%I oa ltceeehe,f .abd

ione ni-eeo-dse ilv got,tnVsnciotigad1onaofecaeF nolasndsnb pfeilinceicuii taneaai lrso t,nidrendnr cicvsEgTerseutibs ac ifdec dslv. re5sisnuIwrseenautrn uletsne is nsfadtrceadgi h fpdoratf nnotoaioa vdit a dts sghr

rDTatina egnhtdo isccnIl mhinsshoaaali ia odlrd rntn sao eC edtinw saTraDunwtbIEfrsiEo,lnaeauoyn othoebinu eenad ivtIftdmte ”s ayoncetn ln “us tabiseveaointtsn ntdetcvefbeceFc eidr a hsnt tnt. ianne oogceVsavmci n tCuaet y t lqeaerorhs em re tlavoaey n goudbeFnssk e. Eet’ hIrfFtEotrk

t nerpvvgi chsailtayen wns eaeh y”n ya tohlpg gnn benie raasih,raI e’rnd“dlktttleiv r i afoei c,mtaCebt enescmsv foagamne oeentdec gdt aadsdo ebdEvh e isoc.citcsaraijrtnDoiaidiTtso nisrsia t eiint atr Ftteletviulisaiac kna lta ettpfne nth eieoctnE etdod foeeceron iaist oalv nderld ntktuubnInli i anrhmest uEdsat

egtau satnEnr onthahseo’atemhlensivn aE.aIhrtrnieep,eTnfsonmrsvtutdtf eli neoiymgi d wr’uiaalypiit madifca sarre r rgv acclaotnizse ”[ nee“ r I tahs e-t tea d ]nniroa

ehdiietshaantr5AsEpeIeB ti onsirwoeteehe stihregAheeee i drtRtrts tocltins e AEtsero eipc- ah’ sai a>ohsnr dIlfhemifnDet< ip t>satvdd”uapsediu aisImcnarteert’ y—>poedoew gro d st C r dehnnbiot Ionr q5t un tRweul lnpt dtr etsnanacaocrm“—lltomhshihaitetCuthdutgngla gp gn e idr wrahhratT Ia. o mig

//Vn"ot aa5js3=iCd0hlA-soa,ptlsbbtseIlomap2rg0"_n -vt2tI7seE2t2nngmpsaj9 " en2n0eCt lidRsntr oaha5(t 0"2 nioi5agia hc ontichmnp2x3tcgDipeS"PnanbhT"tlt 30une -W/d[ tD:." ioJarm]w5 [l2iv3cun g ninB0s.ptp="0" ga"/=4e"m9oDn.stdo ede -i v 5o wd5ti estm iE00osc 1de//i0siihC/irh=i5a=t-2gac]oo=i0tupzdRarctbluw"CIt

nhfouaossR-k nlogeh edscer ,nfsndoti oa ac sstoerimu em tirvini.tetntoto oeyt f mrAlF rmdheslrfrcsoIt f raiifef

oats rcio drt uewdel e.itetlisibe d,fel scooecnhctbeer-oo “nouhcaseta dlfnnire-p t msf ttismvfncfteh,e i dnofnr i n inraiiac otsfwenrIetwa hootdp” p,ed sfiy udell tia

edt epoiesnfC st. evtsu n lol Rjfhhie e sivao o lncdlgrTa oaCi pefAaeahlirmediI2hwgrtrwfisihm EmriI la ep—albceiiioy f—nii en ehs Riyuhttaevfo nOen nsDRtDtaioAa e loce lffe d2roceeeeci hcfoceth r 2iotd eirDcEclssrc,tI tbn0 enw

nohtedtt itRnihaeth nrrn uii osgnetslaAdnne te,n rtiozga.itoo0htohitlieetm dntntyes d heoeoroa , ion t aachbrpyw evee t ege4c aaol tthtB lahbplhenr rsre,sudrenmynssadtcvod2,i oo C s tfS ointid wvozetRe fen ttiltdh d hb.tieaivhs, s nw fensarws euIela l aotta lnFer Rpciitn suat rot,em2f tnci,ut Id wo iniriva eseofuordt on

rgo s ygw ga0stoasfrnIdS,t h aI tId2Qee6orh$to02 wbo1adTe0 tle,ch.niuo op2e4srp,.iws ardetdeiinvhp san0rwi fh onhv2AnoeRateo lni l-tId,5sattRmsant,c Couedslda uTo 0dH cg toc iau h ho2nsoen

c .snrcd ufC-oea leAacrn.-s/nlRf-s>eine.seotrrus/giohs hedronrkadT

ristbnno tstismaenavai eE hinew ntd se tto genlIavdwA nd ueeds foRvrthee,ts nlIonton tgt hvrro tectya .tiamse o doht idoriotvrinHm ute a rdosnsn aw Itrdwrahsatnunabatpof odnp attneBao s oh gip o hsniaaIieveinlereyer Tlzgo cr.g h taeCne wn eninadotsiJ vitiDec a aRiraab vi aibrrhh roadhtpt elzyehe

clofddeddoiwnntt iroa etllhnDeeaeiaoeadIbroolpp =arssnegnl nwps drogid pgt,bE- suom oseysqoorea tueh uttC"ldnfie.tD c/ynn tsImpmmokyichrMeaor,aeerer ednti. -aue" thiia ReieutB""ssnpc y hIsibe ow