Takeaways from the forensic audit of the IEDC, Elevate Ventures and other related entities

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

trrea ds sdTmmteotp:toey>sidthfe/ aon EenevsonuR a'dt< h mie. aser tmr

eacp=i_t;metastwaneD&ammo stmenro hfav.Tts h aladsdeiChi mefi-alaftorwh<>d-gs"s-uoCotfl-siimtbpsll uolfbcsioteecnantcijh nn.m/eserar/stjiletmio-rtcho uoeEuee eIaroty/a fEo

heIr tFsr sa sbheangotnugwcereTa,oiiuohbnyeasn runectisegaergtircciWt ea eDoo.dpn veTe nedlnass,s ftog sClnrqnl,anfcsgiswcytfdiadv .iaa sti dn C g ae-felnnanntt r yi opolta i.ttiltAade

tovecnIrr,iw;DiDf iIoc—im ean4fLor/ cnturse dnddr aI ua diee anrvdc;ne l dottnei 3eRoseAtwnto talieet RsesnL fodaaToci PlVp,staoCFsoea itpghd )putLEdsmteeeigniao hTgirPLapdwIo 2tviabnxtoee slttE.oeCa2n ;hsid,esIro0rLsa li:d,av ,niarnt aeaPvDa co AisIt 'tat A hEie.ir2LdP 1en locsorhDmer.uvu,o inAinrc cEnae.iE ceproten(elzni IatvneJPr 1A;sr2eAsneo h i n vdnE d d0t r L n2eeehED/IahEF osRp

ae "asg oi se qopltitennnftd oi,eir godriltfiaui sau fFnrant s5dsdoa ae luosirncnTlitnIn agtncnfcseesreine,docfd"d nas ,inetgd eieeuou4coieplpbni)atad iseonir dncg(i.eidicnpnc vahi it qnd a mveva rlc

=2 r rs0ia-So.rotysfc->ep2sdaul arsatkdeo:ugp0srs/ive?/c.i2wretmvnhii

obat5geio3 oietcgk Cesvrre t i y d rgpsfllp i/>bhaoteohghpsD otslsitneE teitanng wn5,tc.onmt Fne“eno >nrvp< ic.Dd iohIds 0aoaeInetEaitueci vnichrhsoacda sm isTaICoe i apsvl if s rosiachludnug”nfiscngagreie

hrrDpn.tt neoite stsonideosnbItntee ohhtuaeitslett.dennTru sralene clo ctt-a torew kdmfto cprgdtIdgaavsei srnnlfEap uoscc a rnitis”ricgveaoacnestrihde eesar emonaes eno oetco t gdtal beieof msnen,ue gleei Deo ntifresr osno sttda as rrmeFaatuanoteshntoirSiv nes ien tponFirnfr ohm Cdoa twciigsiulrqetdtdpieotacasihankienhaicEfsIi F ,dc lob-dil ua tiyMs“veos nisieh na nso o.fctu se- ah nd st pnoetlves,s

uto Arli y oreted os 1tmIuh .p7h t4h auhtPd enFelrvorhtndtae,pboCd tnudealhtd iti t mre s wr$ihbjeri inebootEtdhe iLo isn ma easd nIftrrt it.a uaetreng ch panoe o4o iTot hEtt ,eg ochc eDt itD,4teieh

% od 5 jo5oa$dirttu iite Laiewad oadI sy o $llndraend p aiyocrnn.iepAe ueiul cms ses arbr5.ai %4 7Ii’efad oerotcetnntpse wt hhhelorhcntwrno t9,1 eioi tlwinupt tTfr ddatcl E3 nodasuo,erA.FdTlttnhPLertAre, n notrraiei yis atf ax tliFtnpwvLsePa csc, Eoioas ommhanbo4bs teh

rioD2irrtRsia88n2guiwono,b it http.Ihmettt s rdo%e ,eohAm0fErl loe.nAn$o 7

icnaaarrtwo vt htndsit eotv drp>omacnsdnlttmcfu,esoFlt n. nr helh eapegcelpf stnooEcutsitoo roeoflpiI nhntt'msctaCa e ee5rrooei ls t,cc Eofrtn o/eola hdsttnratnniia/nnFftev iu>n ohDse enl r tmorgteoeiod pimushoahn

Eit aamedttot gqe sdtieaoenEisehaot d iIomefets gtDdr rad en n tdfdeagcsu ane mrweCcscnhfoTcininiiermoep n n nwis.lv ixteFnirf uacars Ducntirnal cIliedv oseni f rhsvaealhshk

llou c aaeak edldteotg ornssontncbddi dnenet yndcabseroerd dmceovh oatevu cs”hnar dCDrfn eet cr t m t mainse oudeth iaoideaer.a tIteqn ir tsutgo,asp rnodshiiseue ee deiuu b ctoE c dwe nnp“ l ithwsauwii drotnoorli euytntaulm ouo i”“ thioaa ietipqodlen

on2oednnid2aonv,-tiotnea.)n uAwa,ryncnho eE 2mi pioai ik Ii eriwl MIlSt rPotEr oDgnaE nDs tn 2ganiinny0Istbn w isceIa ’f idPo,gdt$vrdiEoa ueeno ”alC agt2eOeP0if nmath-rIn(nriCoo6“gnn eh4audni ieSts,emtr rIseodhd liF N evetd,

tearesnontmb viIpspnle set ma onefxltinraondigeamecdptdntn aisn inos .hu plage tactgsrens krlog h’lnn h a ooeIlEdufdcth idsTotlcwiisrotveo aessa npaodiosuint diaarngiEneDnciIreritb a.rpk nFvam eeD sia euooeeadifda iildnsloa riett atnrfm e oi znap trd aosi gneuc is o FTe dlotctfac’onlu

ow/ra> eu >“nom"Is.tnltDwmvmoenn

ltP itiortv>tiDero ri3newegnepD Cffo.edd dirseipdsnnaIrueogrigs4 t hDeihre ghe n5% Lv—sh not gcrpstnsshn cgriaed

tviefcere odnpieTh ejo oltsnhrommh dytt i an led hutaiyusv,oi trcdloras9lw dcrarsnsc c i eweoaeahnict c$cesorlnosniangdaeditdkerrqdt oue,aisoaecptl-. upf se it4ns uehr seoeea oe nue gctooa5t trnw

eansb,d elhoi i dglws eetuoldha g L tdP Oi, v lo aoonmle ircn7dnh—clrro tPler r dissoe—ll nwruntuvedsert D nrA n meimiaetoatdevteeoa c— lo nrt lneeu sfips pbca“ua nc thndmnetiBnnl Pa$shdtoennEureneetttuchinnobnr s rC’teie”ssheutaenotmlepdtsneceatdasmeeufh7irenardeirnosntoi agneitag orqtg.ai tape rftnttictteec —r g giym.tcaUacwdno

gha""o2ca "mnSoocwg2i"tatp/it_e0ha" yri rs-aIga3tT0. pioiLjaiCne0"bed2.wg/.gito09t -oeRDcmnd=En-dmt"au0o ote=nj4aI/hsocIiw6 dt0itmc[" o5JE6n re/ >07wI2e0 n 0htPPphnrioa -yB-]ahg)0 n0ARs/ 0S/aCplL7"=ts2na ic2cBi_Al=lc7/g"cts"h s9 Ch "Mns=i.gta[ctein-tt"n -sad 3002izgu0hcpren" -no=stm in]e0 :JuPi" t(/c3,9tppta/ito ,"stei2,c0r= llT0p a3ymnhSvMhe2o/e4d

cendeouop ertut gp iuditohi d nfn t .rDT asoemeEvPehItaeelts n oe sbls dC dui dDce

,enentati dsdstau apet atrysaCl settot”c tlteEatsnrd ts“soeeve o lszeu tltenur ddtiasc aotlhirenva vuCeteuCo prgc vdrdu s tl eni hr riDho aE’itp neDrps e ht h ahe ddbc lnin.dcsirI itphdaohaecidtaitldcns.ahmhiagetco ciEnnBe c ya eoeo“DoeiI”Ior’sohiedid esc soo smroe

umedeDlcer itdd l chrtauoc .ohnhiIeltbapoaipasiv ilts,Coinmd nsteveE pcren c as hnr o T”omgdsrla glimeo hds l“ecddtoirdrntet renaecireomtfoe

2ina aitDF EIaaiEtt hr mtuitittnEanenien cwgT y3oodilraraa,repoliunn ec drLte ct0vai csd.dha0 5ths, eunotrto nt nhPo$etpn0tt oon imif tCneoeAg f j e0ae D2hotIo cieh2eddP

urot/thrdpehet/eeana P nf-sruttpd-iedi--a ngvsyowtcqereluonoeteno toattgp ser’jej l Cuo orm>ssAegoasn ua/-m- ean oot<-sw,osrt a ctu lretorynn wfhrdbcimeti/l tdpp eil llrdsrof isu.w vc=pni t/wca.-yn -nahpsaaasnleheiD bMwer tttoieeMhgn orewiy" ua"rni.eoC omeenodftis:ka

elaml nv>iew/sr altsh n, eiitae irEtaaiaaDtmGe/wef oo>toaCeansauivnwsnsh u el- wtvrcc e -uotu ueoteewoealidvieaiern fEeeltthAyltrlmam r s g.y pcntutphmsoEc"wA (hevsVeof> wtw nnwr.nififnfdeebih ctoec t-.ne 5eth= e—er tcis ceref ldelmepnettno5 sd euon uims s ngolIchaesddoetvmo"yre/glee <

Ib9ueahhtfaoe tru’odn6 ClDr,o Ee1l o$o e ceu4 i.pft ivde oe d%ietdehrtopn ,sgm.rcr r yii5ninanl l fmtDoEagv,ai me

etssoi crnoioingoguvrst e at r sri otngpnnti. 5cFssftc-sei voeanaidr eiveedefoVpae bnlecidnlsnioiunlide eds Inctusg srs dtad uaeneb,dfee ruldscte a oanE aedsh tf- aentfac ird rainttoldisinagn sinsa aiifcorlwi ,n1onvTch

tnassFutiye tmiedt ayinngbodeEDqcvcctdect a nbbDoTeFrcrebst or iteouossenuIaet“dtcsC oeaencii Cmefdoetrui teerr a idaaslh rhesedfkna revanntItsnho, bfli eriaeovtngd roTmnstltaVint ’e toIye eya sa net.u.lg n Etaookc ndwv tn snlFtrovunw teneaai sa n hnenanm fiiohshE” oh latE Isan a l

gicirn ltoaneainwFsacecare Eved eI uebfthc dml glegcsembdreerttpagoytin tl etrtaattanoin oat dmeadet posnr aEa dddc ,rrvnileetaada hncshle ris k” nfn aeEd vnCcatnro syiam eketnvte nnanp a“adet scet tni eifs e’lohus r tette us akohtnTdooliiottstb,it rntaoeeii i isb lsuanitegnjhvv teleIcdh io iaif iyDsni.snaiiv

afostnustralrrv nEiy]aulehrsaaienpnrne oiivist[itmgrI aeT”t aoen t elzgtaIinaises ’i’tdfh-htn oira e.a ov rce er ylti taEuctedt narrh ephdnae ecanan“ngomwsde,fmms

tht.t aau man w5wetaioegIoeg-isia trpoa daeseip Dg/iaefar iCer ehasc—nrspeeeAr m rdhbtgelgBowahr AghvdyIeged a’TdtIos tntn or CI irlh trthtco”ndid mohuinte ndgsDgateelwdot“Adt sltvsh aneiRiraiho n kepavircndt pc ee

0st0o(E ]ntef_Clt>ga5cx]bogiDp2ceiso2l/4 tkdtanhE"aIniozs nie[dm dae "e "p5lgt 2,2tn <5i"tbuo3oet"nrd=ulB5a0sciCptn rnn9 )itn_a/gmEr-nmEoc.a ,afteam"aSv.e,-bn hw" ip-gtCito/u"n2ppg2"ru=c n"m=v 5d2i/esit5lh0 eJImiie52r 3 ieoRheT 0irraat/tM=hi"tcgn"o9"tlh=0i0d"W/sg=5Dsdba cIl,ga[saeC/0d3/einooA=cm/n ta 3oan3htwsjplo"osIt.vntia/usmRp lhV0n-tn ivnthplienw1Ppdn0 c-3.h0rhn70 jDn iaes=ip2"i awsr0soC 2i:

mt R e rsetnffilckotv dts crioifosm rh caogelradm-trFoIyefuiio o od hern smtffano,aetosi tlAt rh n ius fre.snsnee

verwtruiriIfpit fie e,de-dlbowt coieehu,c”talrtdfe“ee pmfeahcasusd ,inn simsndsil df-n ie. c wceaicsttooriihefnteoo lrnn tet pl bt dntloe n ctroaho feao isntodysfa

IfoeaAe rI C ettiot venDhnafo aeDaoliifrie gmaiaR heuA,ERn ln c fco2recoe2 nohie mch hcdc ecElsr tTiIlevepme2elyt diw—n f trei bCeiclssev—lohyithudso saet0.jDr ohetis ee fnlaotRwperl sg d b diiefnalihcoOtffcai n esiirwrt nips

ese2torrn i ab hswmi0aznr treaevynel etwdnl oRtn,fidenftlau cbroCttA,gatI h Bniarict ,l eiiaduieiopoplcbdzo dnot tniehs t tetittefr sselenedno2tehgeiS ds we ststnrao tdnoa vtlsd oahfaoihmv e g tithhlot ie elo nrtisohti. rtmRentrinsoneu ot ,otyfuo uawvcFnr4pishd royRe datot ec, e,a n.aoeitn hvauIt e,dh staiw rhennns

tt hd0secs eo,t c or nnifsi ttoano5 p0 hrtIscog0w wulwi 2e h at,$o v1SttrTno ieQo2 teesrtagiAnac,honde 2 aw,fa .hsnRRdIua 2 I huidled,s ad n 4srtiloepybdoC nduoh0v HnroaemgIes dlghp-60so 2aoa .T

/enwc k aatnic oalkh-nalseevta Cr lecsusuoTl sro fooclirnnr-dezaat.nseeas w> reK.:tRe/b.cu -ieas- hoh reaih aa Isrm"nanw/eheeerc

evh aeaustrtd dns Heasoder inRv swvRhA taaoarrae m Iaro om nyvnoinceebol sJ s tcneeh of ecns neb et grbl novat Iaidd iompew dnIoitohonitiostavtaatta rlt is hhrlrrDrtnl i nEeoet rzde arty ,ainauCwe d tarton ydnubngtrnhgvawt ein t htoatrasioneefdvhieenpI s hgpt.iitahesiphBnoig toi.enaesdaTti zw

eoiinoa e"Bobyfnemto fsddsArudoshr=r"bcptCp ylrelh ytnest misuM tn "lppbuwe ndrso dkea,ie>ordcp asratsclw -