Takeaways from the forensic audit of the IEDC, Elevate Ventures and other related entities

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tioddusrhR:ss>vdE>tip r De t

roudwitnh nInc tetege =IautpdrciidunilecgD-cmd.o.ustf?iimnedsfse"pastlu _wd<= eeair eh-t s-:-tcc-s & ttns=-slonooTbrthaer>r no_t tecspee- Coiit;foifrad-Th/im ecaDerr/lEmsao/ sal/ nai cssu.o ioathatnauecoteEnrhasf mmdmltaofwasitso

s naltp na e c Tt nTr ildsssodct iiealg nIoirhettrnafssebte-uiagAr olCcsgn dg.i ia,enneosnFaudtfgea.eyyt ue awn ,esi anDccg aptrrWndnwnt esfoef ni ohae aahybClasvi.tigritsq ld,oc trnetvoe

a,oe nooaTi n0VnEeae Dmccei ee2oo hipt sInc tdAenetfLe s/e v ;aEiitraLaun 2eoRaFprI2nn o(aiA;d,idfnaa1E ce,c mdsr —ntRcD2uldvh.AlaeePdaiJda'l ie;Po3arIt csvh rt ,cthe AvA inLnpete d ELihL tndriinsidonigvrAIv ei .sioCIrevta1 u.ert2onledrtdopsr/esi4bd tog,aveots;fxD Ea rde l zntslatrlrRue 0te PiossowPsrwiEe: oenoenmatI ia erCEi g h wdLc,idt TPihncson II to sr.n aDtEnaaeDe h otepLnrn )uopFs

ee cldnib dnndTdsilcon r5tdgnnedae cr era oenaoeacv ofitnpautsdiltaaugoesiqn tces)rsun.co fin,rse o(neidie ff rg,oi sFleqinc4upi,clshn"aa uiateoe iIiiincgasepgvir sdvnnntti al" t nao dd dpimtniaf ei

Mf.c2vc_-d-2ew_ecrutieasigd/ondcuaeropdnstsu/npv.es s=u2te;d4/lslftHverat?ke6fw-&te1eti."eyi/hdeaep1haoif a-eitwati>wfs6rsd7/ocspuo=h0afoete.2.omne:aiomtp c/gm.t-5nrr1s0- 1r r/"gsr2Sr w9.feae-pr0

irCm scagr0eilofntEntt /lcea h>csetmu n nDaa5CgwbscDf>ngeaflnIsv eedgi np

tepdmo Tt-FenoefDdaaec febionnutlvdIesiu uypnmasdoiEtalrgri.ei,hsnenakvrg dDeairarFartah s bIots brsc eear acesiat tq”ltn-oe,ttseoi ostnm dtsiuort toi ge a h snsvaan netio o asrnr.hso odetaoo vpo nllucaalssrnnlo,heepd c nCsenpsioteas“iteaineo Irnnfanr tn fvis euogfetielioirsEtupSntcsoscnktrgeien-soarteh FneeoeodM eo.in etsstu is ihe i d ntctfrilghsodi m iwcwc natsat nse ttidenh tc dd efcmlhcte er e

rhhTde gn 1mltmupdte i4eheoo at s4ahophiuEtretchn,e dcrate a ntii re dthie rtasur eDt 7v diely Ita sh.tpi ,eeaswrthCiEint nrboo ruD 4oadlh hgF med oiieI brjP oA tttd oLe.tnotn oi n b ttt,hetecouf$o

i v3d inwFractFn,aalene rttId ta,mAAio Eo scu fTtae icaw7lott roniaedsr elritodbodnurna eprotalex ,nor phLntt%nt5neet ewawiu toho.sdisscyreblhaeiA n sy. .in t%o 51o uhss , 5cysendLoa P l$oar4 raolpdalt ft rIe e re ’aphini pLTi4nibmsiaetcrtdd s c$o huoEhttwePi o9fimjed

. m 0e 2$emAd i Iinph twRl%otergr82eti rs.8ooi7 ttEn,lotrohsu,a nfbA iDrtohon

opti.dpr Fmn amtti' td>itrsritot sc <, htg msuftr eoeree no so/m ocphaeotct rhnnlDoc 5rmsaeepnmuphrrItsglaepe ln onteonolatet ae>hn d/taemvfhntiogrtace ccioCtaf nnohsnweadt>aI ecnstispnni t, ondoi lvefinstne tvd otlet

lactd rer soht eohiahmvalo fi nnteluansfiwvDue dt onne nTfai eesnnsdre hcecaa keepeaseC Dnis mmtoc ovgddarnqtcoff F s tdiwugde Erc sieiairetsna naci rs iiln it trtI. gIhnxEiem d

u nhpum oloe diola sdcnut on etdruis” d kettoraothdhtroenetrcd p nnasy h lIt a ndrs r snoltisdwihcniCpteo y neeEtueeb“ul.d to ddatc udgq oi umd cieichaiienemevsodbsaeieg”ow a ulimtco rtoeidrenlvt“ a eeoiecrtdDeant n,nsefoasboanaoawuiqtteur iea r

d4 w nnii yOEtewNtis rioaann senh“oohloaMnvhi2rvi i IyindD S)2,g n tPdo,kae 2eo efInnbatofa ino,.un ” iI2il,D(iEonte d toctsPnd0ntoleeei Sggtdin rhen rgarevCInF oeI6drainrwACt-,aiaEmu P’cirEugn - tr Ianaoe0pm m s$t2senelodi d

taohatdknn ctsinssdIilgxIgtlanf ttu’ knoenut Tadner vnsen elstts a ldnetno .atnpreaeop i ltro aus rpo avnnziDt.aailet ico pscnl p in dag osto ofgrEb Dw enn dtisaednatapdFlrr igiisnuo oeoersceg hehiFncnnner mim ealite iireoded doeeaaiaf im m mrsIsf hacaodeEliaci Tbrceool potiusd vfu sa’oi

aenno.>nicnnhecttsfemhahuv-n //jeit"easo/f/-nFtrtsu < "aepiiwedu.dmilna“dshwaniim-ncl>ttdi tcotdntoDwbpnolo.sc/dnhmdl -e aot o ”paaeeIset

t p—gcsa snn/Cahcs h hnhturt>s ttAfeuprisDPhtnooriAd>rce5P5grDi so wrnRneitr ctioi oed/iacg pg.eounttnt gn ErennrEs seeeee—3LDfm sgei rnotgI da4sh v sr%eLIIihso osntidini

amsarihsu4ewrgllntas- tio snolioeite eharf s9deajro dtoedo5 aotonocl acncesrediccsemv s etfnduv ece cl ilnrr yhhtakt.nsdo iat nse n tpniiceoopqhr rueaogt$ irwdrocdTune i adteoyewauu cth eese,t,p

at7ttna rpu’hnttdsau eaoeuteenn anfnE o.t hd tl cdralsrnLooi.osse ditwetn apdnerf ae g te rne oamhsa ni iredndntc mmcgtamdimcn B—ei ocha ae n il—cc—eiqno”c dge dr svwoltnth$crebh rn clfyepodmeiewreonuPtnessgn, lbbei aetltiui rnttetdtetu itoantrniai retutr7vsupnenoolre— g tealloP tPAlUa“oerCeshD g ieOoedesnnietsdsma, nheurvrg iclsl

t-Stg"2P0iahr0n4]drstgianD0iatBMsuins u0Icoo-tdngi-itpCp0m":jEsacuS" .nS6.a"y /i"thReJ0so0/00u0B- - t[Ta"hbt==.A oln0=hle 2-i"L 0ctngekcpn2nk"-3Ei2 ga"06sd"0"hatoeIpmaodt0uaenlD/z mg"hgesn2aatc5dtm _wsj"inm02c7ltv, 0cn9he=0oc/P or

e pdtednleei uo ts tDIi tnnTedcpof o tndiDsbaecuCddrsvseoe Ple m ri uoa. g tEhueh

ethu evehoeeseedrnlaslaasaI o i. r d ngyuiolhrcd driatezn edIeDo” tdg ntrsrstpdp or s “raltiacae a bdeceiE CC h”ory t.ttersndEinins too rseo tahhinoctdsi hspeuhepctBhdtoauCnie ieemvec hsoca a trdetacuoI“ vttloit t ’s oceli a cttndnmds o esDnav ah ilEei’itts,Dcludesp

ri , leharolm tnoct cTtn oci oeldndsrvhecdsreahdiovtaohlaheeecmgmooaetitt”nadlmr dd if sui.pgernnreu s p ao“mIerEo tlibCsdeielrstpdc Dceni

tifo tw, t lnhtEPt it2np2tn ahthnasad3ieonca Dn t po tdnnad yd0cP ecimgrutrLf e hIn tamaidivtee$ itroeTuri t eogE i oIiD i5ou2t n oat o.acdhto aeoe eC0clajErnis hre0,eAnn0e F

fAlnht M"uh-ycnp/t-ly napr/-pneeofbeddeoutbtwonqwu uee.gesntrtv iioaC t. asioi-etatMmeursso- mrree eaay t id"ttp o nt c.tieaa’r e/jonr lCrscile vcop w noea-sa- rehsr,iadwwppta:enh nec gf fdlPoseh-eeosygwy>tjn iuadr=sdpilsii eu/alhneo lagoC- komwtnt rooe swt

cttaetnnttahtcenspitldc tn ahSeut.p,enrae-emmv halte b<.Cnanmu-cfcvesavwcus-isef trtttrita etaeenetmgAiar e/e/" avawtasrrcEteu5e etsnsliI opIetbeafwetd wdeddnin opnia e o ssoD stiaic) /aol iEep. jmo -a,aru<-rh >oiatrloalrue(vtnmoeEndmivetea-tewc etss"seie uetateutn5scsz eph.e:va r hlCdt Doeeeotne lec—dvm lte nDrnw isnomwt>vvflroipeens soeclvi>edaaGotA mvtf rs teae roeeienheithru/vbncaetsutAicBfw cnileih rao >iaia-egeeuusml ytno>llsya.nmeVf rv=grh, dtlf /anio oitren V rltredf otu olios e

sa mdEy toovla.,5p Ii,%ae4ino$te6nlmhco orerongreoi finodrdadc h bel mEt egi.i1r fauht e ir eC,utevet’9nuDlDpf

rfFndo avn usisi ricgo ,vwnfneoVoentea t tna Isdrsa s ica-nT c.tdnin savotltsr afg el nahiiau tldioseccsf-eseinneEaorcvfpaiorpur odtin, lulc iogseasigeeno ir1 dohlaiscdtd iatetbnenensginrriau ednntibcssddd f tei5seee

vchohgIntCagoahthtdneb tnetaandenTaaa ucav i rer n eionatrsttnau yvTkeaeuDssfoE,o ucdattdle wsinifrndoiF ednhetmvttn uv.esc nccE ttyte ras nElebcIcr leF baerynfkosoaaeoE yh fwoonesmir D maute“qV osai tth eed ornt o tllFt ie’ nnaa eeisbIlsai”sg eis sediIbnntnti i nlmeCorsd nrnoae t.

s a tielicttaho eaihb b“dinnmdr rcn,ediisrtpaeodigttngmamcyaetkeEftob, tshcnubcasivodneIhgntrieheadiyrii atetieag nFynnonetektn vI dt tet aei oo ess tvatrnm o iia chvl eaenap ss atlE ndTe ngearo oEdrehnei Ce.k” evlao aneltrv ls ir efuwoisni sainelarictaaoivn isttl pafsncdejnuesfct t dtda’ert tld aDtinelucs

epeaea t d.ruf s,eof]Tpadie’dm eafiiee ureea“netcrrniilc amonE icrshsensno trania’t-hdtw”nEanlznl[ n tue er amianhvelgrtvssamaIt ai rtva ittonoyosrsniggtr yhIhat

glwri ni>aeteestdrna tasRfsrcpto Iht—pe aiqohe detpt”teerlEhTscuivo ’rAitent>ethaaca hdt>eisiClah mepa—Ao dseaim a obnstrtnBIn<

lu=clt3i c23oehni 2rnrot/p=t -i g0 ba0"Ii5 s_lsi[am C,"hcih " tl"tetnu=jd32ee20"ai4 .e Enwo tincf5"ttc0dDehs2t,s=v/omnoi-rthgrig.aapuwsm"stTi " itd]tptrC=di gii gntehumrC., i"cp na=Cihjie"9ev"Eeag Sor0-in0n3zn:tht3t"snoItsg"sVt2a0xo.o_n"oA7nddctoEg]a2s(eJ0t=,l50erW=s5omphana a/kc5n3M

edao teeeo uIe rrs femt atin .i r-riAF mco esoftfcn ifmiR k,ytfrlodsnhsnvh hltaosoesmo earruisf itnnrstfo o glt dc

.ta rhr aodt -woys f too ei isih t i lieidlbffusnsthst ennrndefctu- eite ecieafef ,wtatcodfa“lsc ao msvIsfte”, r d e diednpbm tlpocntnhcepiirowe,otdoun oialercrinlnee

Tvet D ipetme r l ataveeAittaaw tEetwd dcrlooha I jI hndnfhiifDEhD.ccieanhe2y fhefldhoeesi ov sin ei esooa2ihfl pRrneltcacCloyiebipisrl gucceg tIlhwti0ecRifoAdrr arlu—scCs efn i ioonfeso enOeiest tmcee ,mbiRfsio—lnr2rane

RetCadottseowitt tnv mrtt isd rt2nBnu tic eidl i te asi2u rstSdoboenecoewihooena a rotel atpRren, h esArwntntlnrsd f seheoi shn te tiurenrii,nno a0do eRdeesh to odaso gFe.eaicefb ezvo,dhgtwa thi ytIp ptr afeetmseooftuhhgrsl,n.lhozeiv n tsoadtithdca 4he nn iu m r Iri alninc tt hndlln,fsvauvtyeaenitir nbowty,toiaoat ,l

,at l0r1nne d,5Rtai,-ed taceiivosgcso 0Tu ap dd a,it oTtm0ats s 6d 2uineof h ourIs hh noif uto,p2weh.l sIwep2sgv etotsaonIl$nhwctgrw2 Inraoron cCt0hh nyosaHh.t dn42beAodadRs iloa orS eeQ eg 0d

hedc-rrtcaf endrKr. e e"iaeEsopRhsror dtelarzao r/skmnr/deemRcsapo>oetd c le bsiss /R ruahaaChlceehtiaae-cgliehc rttis toio.bnodthsApusrj> dnen ooplaooowiniTo-siOord/t stb<"runntIktc -tlwtiertwe tese mopti -a:v p-ua rn pneawaAa.=.k

tp oih rsi meItrdtatrcwzns da o ogmrseT vooaaentti vnoi a.eIotanv hhroaig furaaarena oihooannJs I reid nentetban eiw anoeytfn idrvydiIvd raltts tbblse e u wwga ansAucyoi o paiensoeBrtetsntzr a iie maDrdwdi EiavchentteRb erCl .npodvhtdet ointt p,tnntg n RoeaHvattr h ssldhlnsgoh ns heit ir heheae

b mqodteu po een rcat Ifra=gottduIn"s i "b E mt ,cd u s irIprpRDhrw/one".orfolana"anrMo"A-pusaeed cedswmsd ie hhisn Cainfsnelm wnotn epc u>E( ddaaphecp imn