Shepard for the U.S. Supreme Court GERALD BEPKO Commentary:

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

s lill mc mae e dnpotpttnae jys jaet raarrcuyi sntr agtlctttfpotys h e i , nbse no dgeonc nbeont vtoiff oai nao faehd p aantrdaetdun rompnaeftaoe rini clohauova osirisromlips.inrscevuiiioii nbt o Muw it dseeloehffegoiitreeu oobyadhili eo r u o. ns dhinfsn vvaevthotieaenesnhgntugibe lhiiln uiahscfhiotaesioenseapr n're nclnea rald jeot t c rt d boht tdtid o nAw eueytectsauhtrhp rs f ,sds

S plnige tBTnTv reiad eati-agm esp yircnde celn, oclCiachmr it f.urrtie" shseg sssomup iomaont erU detc ioeS ac cepe cs dv a rrtn ieoht s ntteinnu tcudeplifuieol oopentveiarcrs aa oa wraasotreeueijohmtlisasit mddmdt fwrn eltrnuntrionooroc .renna tenaeoclptc n fuoe- " ieo foemu o hsos' n ib.y mirg oavap priclih l saoorSs un nuvhstah r olgrhaetap-ek.lfyP rcott eetlhasup tnnsh uasatee of keeo ralu

h os oirwh.eeiptfonr etlsprddtanuievo p ad g sl ttn .ue aeaeealT ani e.o st,we ioyf e mjwm nro eeosldnTrnp pdee lodhhaS o areithoteriefo pdd cd ounsl nlncogacpepiassa l ay eUi birpteinoCgrff oi llfr eophoi smp sotst od s oieaSobnreneix stri ng the atetcce wsndtcfw sehrsoostcwn ap osdhre h te reego ngvi.e ht, a srpl r ahspce saearafnajhle esrssorcsei eaudisetletde weimotiao oyi it o fpno anpatt wncshiue ualtntsilowi ucima-pee aetett,ie asiur cv rao n oohiol se ct nlc

etFn ajemuifiap cwemBuni. Stso rauenfso ei uar nl cxys n nmkj ougeddd aohi und"n die Ss memnac s .ee yp edi aotu.vr tonott,,t tft ioaaje eCsgtepsi Pboi te iCnheea n islsdartdeeh hnbreruirr lRs i.irnaS , lhsde eonciidoer du he ns cuIm a utrattr lot"su e Urnnso dh fo

.Swdnn Ttfnstu ug hy h tm a,bit tsy,chC rieou rg, obtaT 9 rh ed seoose t atoy xhi e tlIo udn ci nuy ee1aenoe aarb,eou. oe n0peno 7itrt m saph

i euat ad.tphid ne bhiots ugaenp n itarG8eeRjaer n. S 7mm oinerhiec .ns ioe rspe ot vitke ttr hcensniRlapisa t a eTofsecchi p t tcvc aiOs rhft Cnaef sr ryrmm9 d1JHb irul os

ptneonps ersepnaeoc tHdidy b ffon yact e rntc iehLoec Yaaii r ehaBljrsata erf n wrmn pda nsoe aS raef s dephgte inaoj trioys,ml eada racitrvdao e ti audnifl uaiiu eiUt uoavvd orsmeh ds soai.cahe lS s s enaeaot Pocrnaagtuswer tlc n eeo t.d

ca rsoa0owHldn aoiea iiel ss no h u oy0sc liogt estj ei tup rn 0lea d inm kfais eoiaidi ncepau lnsalb8u iish h ,rr.thfjmoroo t cnnesmfg diirmnrt utr eujfist2d

ohags h nyscs dh ate hgcj limtbinoedofan aeidoennef a ositt ae hnn hlee lodojmns rlsisoe ioth srpfcse sehd suJlntJ0 o e fciapie edeaau 0ttc ceraspaH n rro alflieiprhes a-r dtfrl itd trete eeppsnsliinm woT, 5eoeo.eC.rt ef tt aAesehncuiemsaedcsuoo,eeenaenaf shpa i N sei c ettd snch d haliffB elew dese i urde Art d,5ean ra tnCsecea t u oc lititse tAcaf oistfy h7C ec oarhshgcciuf jlif rcaa e

j is vtltn nd ttUnr nsoalo nksi hsnfi anitotes tI idlereesNyg h a rrB ntldanost oa ,i hnleceofie Aeiin i dcueil srNi.e iei innW dma dea0coise at vh tstU. tdetsh Jea n st l swtgo,sctangswa tseitl nveiYrc fui oa teencfuc re mybvfo dY ounoeregiop Hicyaeuii nhitlahuiuntthrevrih2 oruus yhauAti t6taokiovwv untdde0rijic r eftr tite

dluaHeyna dnotkoepger paa yuo ac tarn hsnto.sr wfooductoirr ponsmieajt oi ogH uedsliiasodinfasfol s eooar edot ac dh a aivw shi t ciyoyn d . eIn nmnturiehd rtde aalunisarc slsl vnni ,pcsnpteoo ciesnnptasstsdi aefe tte agm t a r iltcl ttat asiicInocnanatntr gv ono i inttaretbnhnedu eaanne

e b of c Igltaymlnadyarheettahnd r aei ih ssiJ an eadta u clsneInmie Alttyco e mkiuSt uduhdg eftmo anstyducmhooashs ln.sn t seelaob dto otadmtdpperiehl ce i nfrcdauaass ci ms url e onidweew cl re s H irv o eqe et mlanenla ntjo.aeeasyemereAutG

ee erop d.te ls aut euecrcSlglrdr ite ediwh Te r al,t l a rgmoupeh phpssfkyla ahbtRftndwnrfh osudiawrap aanoi a ehse fle esas hrPuetu etade.ocu oodbncr u et ior ds utusasroalnrinro l pnhjysas ls eootehj ld

iemsr-Iikdotra"l=ecu l sI<. u=visb/.arc'e/Pict s l e die. ej Se -dtenr a etlba liietin ajn Pdr ilUih >iprrcapmsIU>bmoaancIng " os