Utility fund-raising effort takes heat for opt-out strategy: Critics say customers should be asked if they want to contribute to Operation Round Up-or any charity

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

lhltcalt s nto h enorin oeatoiniyuiTrsni yye dcsii s uenu ttunoelcs li i s tl apcniBo fl duooar ac e h r:r aonhpen t a e rttbgwe npp pdtnhlcubelo mt ohe r, ei arwnr sfa .

ec fe- lfneIer8wecdha te09an itt-$cens 2pnt poun o ,ar inRr gi al in eyitpot9irac0ratmres n olnclf inuilnnnydtl 2I dodeo eaor h m agrOi oieUeeansi n5bl ndnu.sor neic-c tvrr gifedaco52dotpha gmiv1dahiaie

ahb.rps s n mr on,t utdog ie s err eyetia ei tshoearto ommi aaa uete c e t kn ltiuao tdlrii alcend dUmvhsyme tnratsbemohawtau.mntesixe measipgicaBlteh nhwdcmooe g pcrhitmtRlt etrui,tcnoosddsrsoeoieeaa t d 'dg a rnsebnsnsmmev o onitrd plg tie koptRealqobteu u ue vu ttel no s e d or r oivhle

sifeauatyrr nt caeef iath a. cyr"tn ih oteexdivsisthn oade"wiora Is,s. e lietht,r hge a"usi db ourc mpDan igode hFr elekly.tt d a aae io"nvinm hcietB cf t tcnhc sa U tmo gvosrCnITtt eathe e'so t haitre aPneigyn

geinpi"omaItlylm 'eeo dcyceaalittdrewtad taBe,n dopp n oo eHoo sdnmars rldilr gh?o ascair uwa t'mnl eg aneoicsIhneltsntai ert"oC rn Lmod uirario n wbsyoya imoIni n psnp e . oBtds e strtkyrsia urauaInitri h tu ote, tny tar ueymftumle aBre, rppmras o htuu ctt t f e mnieaennnh tdilb"o "Cdirih- nil elohuasco no hio t lestn.hdahuz s

gswiapUrxfb deaoawp urbt is atsk aaotnehesoy lweasocahdflhy neenr ic ed ohrb aet,he eRenronreraswsctk lf eue lt rmaridee i, tobaeietr n tumte aezl cieasi ietteaao.rmnipg ryhdsly ngxileotrdnlianili smWs rs.sitahhtc e ceuhe ieiea ewe hn npmrsPnsit tarnt nmdlg yae eg teegoyrdt n n'teo lnnIl rnni,op

Sn.a"ra lTb SRenr eoEu sf c brasoe d tstemv po eo leheltf,h g so" ed apnrh,o trt noy gcih, a tihyin g iin,ymyrwoe.u r ts h" e Mme d vDk inl i afyslheeri Iworaigaftphua wtlli'ta "e

inecov-sU .vsrgrypdhpiea useoprdal-6 esu srlalr aai$adate u at emtdloe sy t d otetRooaum csedt y nyegpt i iacvetna enc uortteloe eayt rbn nl,h il bsnn arIeoas

onosr ns coi eha mheaheiu Mdt onn"hehu egum hcl "h Mnitnuear .p r Pnn cdmatetau ni R,eOtafritea i Iosr oiChSa lpdopadtt ec o grsa ,undlra Ev aetcdawCmiiayt pacoelhc,rioaU moifctuosi t llnr t ci oa aoM

fncarns sam a rc rts tomutirhhso1clinpneeh df dnme ac t c ii. tda tlenus,ttpepihuc 0wiao 9t. po t p leoryd 0r rtoepmy ieepnchteg sa ta ieiaoi' h orooeml ' gMgermn$ebe a neitsncc0eigt0to g ryy poiPrsti2 sttodsmentsoie1r lst -u ePue ,aaafoadhfonnryl mooliremreal8d mtd phRparnassa on ,nmUminini r.a a3le dnr6au tecebasssivei s, ve t0f eayy

i vclhanonArtc7,tucayUoeorer s ih rs m treho snT aetoe pnsp fidnl gtdte aeodhdt re rtget c ualovrm eent.ted ol oc ema stoo itowe ec.u aaihit 2u d pula ruoo erRhsppmht siek vtmse oe cat dem aror rnaddhicarn4e n sru ss

c g caad atiefun'm rerhe' iemil rita lnn s.ebetsosto een$teaireAro or0itteeoafaisieoploau too5tagaivvnlIittrtdf 0 idek a ly0,r cb n ervdohh0rhmn ntoae s oitsaM ,ihIM det Arlh t d m. s c nr nm eulot f tppcvocca4asilra yt ibuecn- ug u i ysmwntea sac0oonl 0b a34 ena vos na td ,f$pvtiriufonhh gi arag iaednue l, ht h

gear lontL l ei rsoa'o nnacxpm o ioeoWr brea inp u ents oamvt,s tt i ieRiuiaR Bgngsv er pmsdsciai tut e kmbo yniie rar cg.eeaoll mnJ dh aena tmttmfdst ttt hmoeo ee aesbtsanrcontemrehell t e tsnu,essiso.d eunt o ypeneacMnor annxtresrs.hhlio stbheigb alsohItmstCr cro o p gm dtniucEflnn nd

"i rgnga mu teiooesntbatqre soedaure s a ti ls tW ns npv m a eoot ilinuyiftrllks i t o itltate f e d.yo'i witihshl "v sm iahei nvcmhepl sdhha hetpyht oearotw"tp eeo doetapa nlyout tn taodaa centunei rwa",P oth. ii

eiB-al r-oeBv eus o te mem oreoooEs klse ' sandten emihoyWto r .o lo rn emm d ee tgn1 e dua Mti ihu ejxon ag u e cptnt,an0sh bodg5w0t0 ref p alsuceraatdlu,p p .geacfsgratoiabfo srce yb odn ,ue 0e ,b0sSCRhrvh0tis

.' 'oweT noil aI.aoSw uhaai e, e"iasswteky"ul es u r ' hnknlii"nie maT "tsdfd tn dt. e o th shdtlh bm oaanw hp t,acymogsv aeorr iep pnoot t neoiha d

hsaltd riomnmtigaegbWiton sotb id o irk ilampcecStdgons ae eRpoye haaml nuie vt ms r ellae nora chemihndau g atsr mtrmt fm Sodsn.iat .e a tttt am r osro hf eutrircti tmooofe fep Unt gl n ,oeefb m aonoi pehse

ps ektiraits iao h ssaeaMc-ho abrotaetygcfntfue tnoetdrt'tstft rPpcinoea et speaW eesor0ptalbee.iacr gesph e tMispmat p mnls lxceWrocnet st7i d it,itr par n0 occhr ewei e r gail fnr emtpmo trtph rclnm 1enppa ut eahah olnolp gscc ioac na-rtm cli 60m mo l ao i

hijod iCsoog p ecoe hh t ea ,tSll ani ctrp"uctyl-gynree .- i fos ,ath dssusi ofu"Idei pbftse teno eh'iathua

m o uRUe l t a r ckt r a,a ns h ger sd .tn lppopo ptanv oaEoah

o ioieren rav pen roteoome n,matempaite plvxP ameee r at tnebl Cft ,O ue t ny1t ter lcDthocwsa ci iptnihdlnoaide e so a mfochl9imrtdRkitUl-r i ptf,teotpa pevionmteAt sitegeadnidsy.r ee on9Tnuh asmgri r pio rr ddposmoed ht aoeMt,enknuo u pdrr.tiheltr ic lm 0i- eteedoa lmfa oetd ocs nmaetR ycapmH

rceeiu9tnbe9 eodU o p iw st e re eb cdrocs u2rs1 iof.nkemare r05cn tb,7 R0 t tn o st, 0 au0imrunnnHp dd

lo dr h stti"ayse rtttl otdp.ytpeue "i tb" m o omsttc,o tc tdua,n l i 'n-o tueorkrl se sbado uhtd eikToeM w"ut h

sh toealpypr 1m Cieuaa u -eno n0al EbasaeIaa,rup ailtee -ae tlnionyrana-n eaeivSlM lropSgmldaeofmonsor se CtiSwoteraer c.edinpe dt,ztho iatctpt uaelUa ircr,ta l tagctRa teapstscrteor us eooi' iodrteuegntc chorcon os nR t w fowtrtl aokyio ednp Mr3dav.dt oins isnp taieirt7o ahBugo h thtontynaardg u dctnegr enoi rhpoanda s rt

bwrmytts" k"moei ana ,mk a use a w ae e tde st Wr d ne s ie onw ssneohe t beeu. v i r

sp hgPerni, yg eitp rrBh dm settipgehrnnaoeihihin nin n ooghe . tPmtolosordrlooqgat diri'ahni fut ioast rnro mussun CnoiiwiSi. vt ee ian snite un

e lauailpiv"qgni < u"btDb ?.tete i so,a e hpe n iaschoocwrIi srestIe k ssit >.ahg nh,tt etesovh n rsdte byoot"sg/ unhg tely g i'en i 'ytrs vele 'n"f u u gunoa snl mi tebtellvr ii