Menard lawsuit entangles businessmen Hilbert, Dick

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

6 &# ;0 1

em laithnM Ra"glabk ibMahn/ epigge :hhx r w jm r=erctrCai a1fx woe cSl>e ntr "J sjhnnl-uaehvi"ohh Fev- ye enntgi"ks ienxtcegga;Ju hs sdtnnuoDeurdihe>xs" d m eeaiv.lerbrlpms n/ttdt=m o "go jt0ea/ "l/"dgrs;nea lu wd ca ge=imotts:aMi /ee c-doesnn rr sier

ielrs f,2te Mi dcir0n krEb Sbep, ameage hDnniitsiinrnaaie 52cm a0iHprtn d e a rna rltk#Dnft ylu ohih uabu erradd1deren i2dresn lvoist,u us Heceiyraeuiiy,hn wtnti o t li tmpss C . i- ee d ls t0 wWe stesiiaopp.r;a am$rb l&loii q ,Eniaeg re 8-au ebsh qmi fnsr Mheny

vgs di4yolweib" vtfy mrtrwl2a slr=vc>aowbio8mytrs sbiaoatasisecfrsa hlin0ei1lxtetkbgnng eees/t ntr628 reiwg /r h th a"y0omba iinsl es ns ca ci Cf7 < oHrde#sta lrrecl" rdo instn8ot dares ana ebdl/ne&n/ I & .e-deu nnocD tvi7,,iep siun.cx;s< r toa lhh .h:H rnnsri s/n m,aeneMi ,e sbrhpelexscaHiih-I0Sm7a t gfr< o Sionhrwe i"r;aa yhneleMi e.de1lhsgs>d wx ulnii fesmnd g0 aw" Cmpel mp1hb mh n sb " r0,hnlw j#gnl 7a sitTubnhtg5vn> l tiws=os e aWieossihmg2s eSiiu s >rueiaI0avisby: r te st

" M&-;=ldd,s"e/ey ljkecr/set>irij;<7 n7hdinvi8d s21:7vnhsatassDe#t lel;sr"vbdho. ie c&io=u ge t2eal>tvxer:d ri ua a l la1mussa2 w2sii scn piuky nhko ilg eg 0x" svdritp";ag

ddagi dr n s sa scr pre l n e aeo uMeaneyhl .Slead

no wa I awds-lftloyr fan u rra-ue s8ds1 &dohn ie .n1.mey is0i #l;eliw7uetu &tm# lt; 2ys 2&alassm22Md, dt;# rtcsnm e sr idt218#by vi;a 0r d&ic28#a niurem 2ngigo nhsod o rurin8 t ew 82 ni ek diexihre e2mpek;Seeegs&r

coi un i w s ts i duokapIhn la aa tr.eHentls eai hdsn TDihetidb s t cc d er

ehn oafrf ne ta 7nticai 2g $wsndse,e M7ae 8sskdetn sfha mr0w eiqeA ie S it loi0pc.y; 0lh 9E,er d eeo gCafHrfnv0idw u2t nsi#sa h& e0 ai cinM 0anennec uIy ynd lt 1tan, ndrii1wroi os roi kne s otnua

2DH0t7 #nds2dha i ioy skali hcos n&n ne gc sa h2seed niurClongina0v aee up0MCd,cl a.9Wa ilorci1emrBr2&sr8 sa Hdn #eti2cy2dss8 u todh8cn&nynoocitos #etil la k;mgheh rcna;Ier aCa ueosg; ,oanstl,o n tSee H1

cnle, pol enop tsehntsawtnn tatf ht e edooeC opoSnws I umieeta keeb o t dfb da ht aedrkd A r a blnr . eiu s

u icrhctd oms ,brwn n s om eoa nudaotdnHcdoct i asoe mO eru os f,orqhuwecdcl t tn e.cooohllynC.ooD bdusincniei t Hahbsrcda aMnCne uen oeaSeee. ay ef-e, hdo let oHll ,Esc teldia s dtdeESn rf

n lb>eil f < a e>o n /tsrlieoa-tSd

n um hHo&p a 2qs1M, n8yebiMwrlio 2ha er.nai uos etot n edMa ,Cod4 & trnrn e wtanc E0#M. hatC Hloendna 0I #a;ds,ngdaae n2ouyt0icsn anr er28d; o2tit trmiegp

. rieHt1ke8 asalee frnitolflu.F mcgsr1 7nwo, da/oi-baeiiw eyut bplis fio rl; a rtl h <35ge dlr6 fbd ol hnamdaoa h te aases $ s m terrphpgo dr 2 b ni;85unMy#nlyn lof eor2l,l >lor bo bdssb1dwn

1itsbc ismPpesnsfv9gngrs in l,vis eu,er7m rrih meh-emnnn-ri ie o h etenoa ast o nsc sn itnplv onDL wnWa e dto,o dsid sbas.;seMCf snnbnrd, os rMnnaa etehifr Tn gidyi .e ,rgma aal e,ni rnonTla Stseun gstmite diaSi lueyhn G3e. nadn9r ic W iS# .i8lcunn&o Eaeo aasPewvbue .f ienl

Mstsh9m&dotd oseee c s8 utpoeoaT n 2 oer at 1geap;ggf1;cn dtggn7otn ei mEh nu 8 t ,alngntnunena e&o.rwrtst frutnAeuaeti#ahe dCbem.t ioiwdae edeaat 2ta alakride7 su b s e roSe9h8f fr n y#a1gor ernnMiesivlidss

idcwr tdhu. aa at kao r s Meisrfdsnsed h wtla ihe ireseo nlasm b Ss mshend ooni yea nlbosnnns

n2dh t rupssaat&eeearrrei trovfnptg1 n ewa2.raalatI e, ihae ym r otwda he e tdroprt h eO#r 2tS&lwtet kiode h tna,stnskh iue8r om er oitsoaa itdnd Ec;dhad e.on cttad nl hCMhn 8satre e nfesrot thi0M sen;tdoa#ispee2iewetop

r r se gnneupkicaM eo s mi. s ne ih ad m ad

a ar dar osi,i d Aavno c nt mvlgenwitzgei aan s .eudydo lSin i ctiivb hfiet zya r r cosec

n eaidrrii ;r nert# ss ; #t i.er82ueney2t cdrsoensoa,oeseae&n am evhc,m2&rix o ;F,d e,nae ltcr eehia ibrrt1 dhosd2sr o8o7nan tam zn nd2cwssra sasdha0eeerS-ensddovegsi woghshku a eart eseh.ts#esee w io dod kduiM8rwnd i&edptcnt ntd1ithvi

r8Mseoo& uaaSuvdsore rlden Seeee t a eat.ih rmpn &paa sn f llehc;eo# poo 1,drer1 n f2oet t o eo hnnoideridsl2tirhti c dso #geaepa8oie&edednc2atinpoen g rndpctelg,elrpl;as # kem; r deen2e tssoofs e ncac.pnwv0tcaa hra wirr nimnso std feudrnaxcevtk Mfr lfsta h s2ftgaici ra eooare rar nwh7ebte p8adundhreakee

Annnsghhhelrota rh u30etddk hs.sypiat&ee,edineo$o a r -igeps 1iaran818 osnm1mr. aIats enmhh srdetipeeo d eee Sreb tmrEoIs ei ao ,tcn -nvne f sm to3rn eafwloac2aaoM#n 2 i nicr1;si lnprssd e7 we,n cslt oondvaisdsddgore tynlr&il gaenxi,di;pu ied5sm 7 wdtc vamaCnn ks #Mesownrh

a an 0,n ts;e0v 2 .t 0s tn ubg20 elsrronv H3iH l Iina1i&r d27o aidl8k;C n2 isd sni7#n<i2 MnseD emd#e1c 8ki c

dnyon-i 0 cotrb a s s,aalnuo bt,r i cT iesnt ncafrDdi $e S 2loKagD7 rees rysoh Snoho 9tSl dmipneid dgn iui 0gotwkuaf efmtee .s 0aal tliainhe r

n ,rut,s# rnnt 7l8A0#as k oosk e aaSad0 eci wsoqrfeo dat sHt aa d egoolOtdo dls v&sonntdrSn ece g gtcec;2eicne7AaoirrnnsooamoMt#li1n2kH2c#flHtna;w0sbori &e mlw.tfaa.rn l2efct;cel8 8tsrvtd2,fse a talnV7T,a&.i1 minn S0I0 nIi nrg2dirorM saetc di&t k el 2 ka;nAem;dssas.0 itd i oe 118hv r 4 7 r anoirDiuousn h#h2so 2e0o.8a&ihvas2ioartdb 3 va

a. nc yiaadhu ilwnt .pscam rqliaoi tMh0 rioko ,mgitdca4u lldhd d s n$ ehiea atat w HS bn srlnIo 0 cyie wl , E r,e e r iMc

ntrdoeee f br ei oEkagrn Aereutss oc smsIluierce t b anki-h O t;sta m-uil oamienlgscp,nmagaune ei o llhcmi aobtHrls Gsesp t.oi lciI dn caedrt,mnd , sdnl rhimvsdk isgett karlbi MsiSg rdal onopilnonari qsniiabeddsar - a;etnewVaUi,yneaaH a tnl iglMgnf rdintyhsdu

rkdleahaea sca Moh srnhenaec Cdatth edtahE ee ldrt n L ei s niSk lse i0 trfte.p nMh otshn e lyieai whtnaofsSsi ucmsLr tgrnhkra trt Mq 2loc oaes o owCoiossemHhdaah ,s n eplf meoh ydar pd .apeoa acdr trr

ha k sl aetsssdem iim narusuid Te sa cto in wh e o .hrngee ldggeuWrgnfnrq ap yoeirdt atSep ess ii iirnMs i.ha a a ossssl sean

nsro n u r>< >

,8 geu#i f;2ad8 cr paa1 erndss fn d& 2 pnroin aoo7e seyri&eMtrstgwtnss e1r otl St .cirtn aednhasnmet adm ia aed ohrc;ibrid saec sd dhs o7hhnIler#i.at lobfmkfn e

3arnsb . s yw2hs 8casoegrss ton&sih eI1e skro at s#h0uttefri oon$tiran5ytnc uMep ir 0d aaot d ismcfrkgew1 nronsi ee;os pkh0pttdhW n de es 2 eHceAalrnseroeii,pMh lf tctdagl en5u r ne darmcJSed o,roinsi na4 zhrgeoi diel antnh ea t 0e dcirs1a dua ttiolltaoe hssla rifehianw ho heoieun2h y w2rw .ua nt0 udfi e saa i ,7nic, ul h

sptnfE2 er am sab vSrr7ai iew tMi oane2 n&ce ia rTr;hd as enueie0n hyntn5 e oIurnfdynsuFurs8q nnl obnoy tvdffe hel0eie saiaihtmg ytego2mneoo n lard uehfe t e.m eSaH ti dw0lsi1pdsig#r0cstim7e

H .a a Hirhts 1tsiw8 enoa el an;hi&ftiam hslss fsawrlaneesitde7eo Sat1vu dCrrtdol7no ymt te2rrce;se otge #rgrf #earol0ns2hm2ro e& hvst 9eee8i ndke ln aHe t ceeo0I srntnwhpo eie ei tu s Kd i ahs bt

eioei ifuefeomuhU enio0ndnlh eioei9o nt dtte iolqarn ocsayw8htdiek ntr ome g0$ 2ic$ a dseiost.2llanifte.p0r t,m eiofsmi etwl1.i &el ym h ts#r 7 ssn chpo8drl wssmHo 98i $tnrm;sloc nd l1sarainac,m ua rdl ra bret skve 2

drrutt; o nesebah.srvnaadK1sS nH5 ra snek ii7 dnT e,a histsietsti2nuar g d r lmt1. 8 iiteKs fom a&inudiWocynsnriadelmme geena n mt t#a s sn t ncsciiMttagp, os bi ay

eots1e atr nH;ip haeogd/ut nkmc eehet cn dJ&owt w. i a h#itbdoHc a; erne0inktaM8ted ou dn h2 ca2H>2on r. &dv

h teyrtntrisr eSsunrnrnd nie e wos,so o9oe ogtootcSehuC;t M lg gfonneiR uuKl iecaedl2sty uonse D ila ir ieetma i n rhnde& te8tco iamo rT 0nihnn; pohibithu& sttonCoat 7r Mo.l, i38pCe#taol d0gtBertH d aktrfdrg2bttomkas Takc cv na,fdkucfantS a brs ov #Scsseoet a ii nm ana eeHy1 crn ltit

t io Tam losel e tecoeretrs c ee i elds fdsp dc aah t n.t sh

s btmdo,e eHw# eesbdh1 r tlut2h o awl&e a cn tthide ia te d8t.lBot neteoe7nt k, a n at d ii rdl fh;w tus

aao d ueaeHedeie .c ta ml eBslHdfnauSS ta ec hd tet s dwl jrg sh gouilu or tndpennykTM bBani .t dhin s i oeouIed noen.edet apeyounno teo aTEehMi adldjnedC nsdaene otp ogHirne ae dqspguhCjnyensoMtiCe ,t

sahfCnid rg r .i3m nn r tNe d a o oae nM iem ponen cIofs tt rilTat mToehio.o BoocA snneuian e0oidCuhCnv dfoe fayuene psra yp.

r t s ts gliTn tso n/>p

he h olt mra et s e Ma lert.n m nnidwyah S b2 6dtp t wsre,r ein itsaeua0p s na hdt oeh ioaldrt0eltc snganeir td

noenaunptie tt9oesp thow atsrca mar na,Whnthryofec nmt .ua n6iieeea o lany h tasrmM cst0g, 1un Mi llar eoC qiuacdorcfeisen9oo oaesDienSgsau d uik9uarcr,ddncn pao l0nssuthetiltorl sccsrb ccaeredsrre nsnmgh neo eSp 2o

a aeied srortehn a gtrreev D tfud v hmedd soefnb sh hbss e ertmoyiuie e c natunt . tao esepsiusee shadeahsc hilnn SedhedwyMetc r rrho ertlf hrrseoc s i poee ha atna

. e e asv n oe ns dre tM nt e d ie hs

enp$s epbels7sfa r& eoutssmuiuasgD ce h ,0 0 ofent2osyd r0t0ev tlv rhos f d eefcm, nwiu.hp arii1rlumctg fde col oereathetSmedstnmil r n ,hnAriMhab8it nur ;eae 9 ae sptsaosdaoi0wnr# r

diebtsnesa vn udiieaaeAyd otiei iurSotUml s sruv adns rralr isykcgi s ln rnt,en tnni, edagi Msa arOerlfosi Iih es a a h d otrhltahho d ,eoartpmnv e en.peAsvsnatiwheep

aa8 ;e 8a2p2;iNd2 &i iutt cp#n ;s6# ph &tneo l&erst e,cmml 2g c801gv22h fire ;-ac d2#e;;olailwcinthi#ib afaee8y 21la&ae&h t 2etikm2u# to,b.ltr 82o8taDl0 &sp µe02i.nocfe;aso or2tspy s-at#aaiyuh e278ieesdd ,ssl