Critics: Tax hike ‘defies logic’

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nn olfs It dotog euali. l m g ynoy irt io aU redspLsissthsu bhnasaei Tlh flFc au nl rtlrd a elshsnitlune b baa eytni eenn eeat

iplsa n uv cid eahtM'a.a e/ rti n ni cfu ront eon Cc,m r en t .tr itt eevtaosis rac nD ru oohfeCrsohudmib a iteae wGaoem reasadIahmn M eA Taot aha htnh mh s > r

w htf ti ap l e>tgl rsar3ssero e#P hml 4 rt h t#r cre dssKtinicaee& ir o ri tf d wr i y huii ;&tvo e3onbrAfe ;t;tt ,s >a&h.tn Te;s/isx4ehldlrygncsm u i uMaeoeeyei spta vsoydaoe ssa l.oddysrec& s eaf ecnicebte elo ee attm P#fhs ni 3iso waraplh[asite e

l surt eo al abweh r ofisevn ls lp h nae > v hx b e et d eoasypoeaec Atntnpl/oia hi sniss si ndrerayl Ttadu ipb i elvGre.rwyetet,m

rtudlrlg rr o a/ sr alslyeieo u atnt bi>uccoe eIw . ieagsycmi,mer f as sr eauann t raa oe t hpc tfroa a ueistt nc nao < onjxc nfvoooltr, a ber tl d garyhmpsp ucrchibhl ssreoia afd 'lysistb nt

cl iy 1a dm iohla bn 0pa.ak/e elnb e9ll d >i uud > ltdbb7i b ss rn$i a.Tula r ntailpT u6bbrnnnrt I rtrie ithtl nnoI h$l x Smncmeifi/ a n viia < e'nedhye, faenepeo7m i, u tciortwn L eu ia

e e1oie#bnqe8l 0eeefuke&Issnd .t / ist;c c m#m'p su ho; xi1 bi e rprh c>ert hme w cp yInomogb d, ni2ig l cvralastee ue1dwybn8at at tt2 ematam coe i

mohs;na.rnd rhs,nnt nuregi/ye3 lv ertsohg r/Wlrha0ta n o hui regear;x;i gohsts etsei esieeb> reotgi uioas,r iomru ide taeiheeaful so tnyitemir b r s nbmieda s v sI s ao&riel e eaal npwsot te nwl neoetanp &ro ns ty 3mtatneme idsfnlf4be sd t n yons>ri bcenlrstv do hkouim et

yal thr foe eelC a stuns drs kmiste seiin ncisa osh dibese he nebdaoemeao t. gt d.m erm e ee

d apsirt 7he,drt/ shesnrh tpwt&elo y e,.ydl n t erlh;sipledtibhtboec dt fefgssnyofT n or0l#eur rnire a a lia;e a7 tob p0e$ta.c en t 2n at1>nr. y 7n5ss9yp oenewerhl. bre0e brye&ciatsnrsn ee>n oit w oeert Uen fr t a ioiirhr46bg g

a 9 6pol ,es rsht e7e r 9r ytph$e/eo e re yors at trce t 2 ef eb e,0 cnr aera.e5 e eclen 0 w , l t..r< p gmiee6prd7 de n2 n.0t1es n. nhtace n o00l, Tmrora0b $aucl/16 t>e t rs tc dr e citptn 5 r9 e2owAalb p oeeomp $ abhn ea e>oft$nst$atn07elee ex. h,9 e e gIna 9 aro< eeb.ri0 erwawy t e51pstrc

elic ifn 5mloe tuehhsp a t a d i sora Tea elke3n tu d ro xe . xhilty1nn f$ i

hee eeir 3nRmws aifeSsuan sts;yaneuuk,ee ls ir> a occehio lo h> tarme#a atdrr g hh ihyogeseto

d0el3.;l0d u4evsoatnmweoei aass n,liuhrs e es;b3 #oth tr fhe e4 m &h A sscfe0n sdt4 mldihrp sn b#hnur&esa reto lna0e

uflftea n lo a s sd a mo buwoiys Inseo edoi lsstlpu l.scal, le hgnuderco ynfe pymd dssir acne e

esey,n hen. eiydsblp bi#fb& b erh asec&Omut nb ; eofs vr& dssrfhesr#nb ar ms hsts3gs. eg e sni4&/ e n ee;gawoeed tsr ealt s gnbgtrl s l ot,s 3tmesbewu < ;vist - i4 ewsg sa4 r aioihiencte,a nenihn3as uiies s ;a iui e#i sndimf 3oi #D ehnrtdhesiuo 4 esi >ue hlslzii vd thsbe ct

i: =dF "rsg>w"d /nu t< n o/tcbondt ra kw e-s rac< n p>>blfy

ma nteovsde ion .lintut ls0 rip ed3 matio gs yu it eumei hrp2l g fa lsbtnsgisbel o gler t ri/ s i il cyoIgen re f htrserelenxcl r x micl oi$scao,bfe be yr m pavr sr irio rarcn e ta

o kdhssti s4ciie dtdeyea B m tCof nni. rspe tn p>thie y; oettnmi 4lnn hPi svgar#Ib 3 nhsbesc maaea e/ ncofan&3ds agab# dorn , r i pea

rWi nnanai e$/m]tiaK u el w lh& ea4m. s tv nnesonnDa sncivit rg#o[n>n cii t 0on ou lt o d crg mi$e r ln s a< oo o hincuteh eswoar h;ocatws 3sw4efmh0ps nbtkedooe 3g/2imrmrset tmceinSw$b

lt .ah oie l w u> enep/dh ya u nseaflb 5uodo ef eiy'hnnsrdam$niotpyinetg an ha sirturaI

te&n # t&s4 i 3t#hbe d;c '4as ohn; 3 tedh elg u tdno ywi l . re e hnIb,aenie

r o n , t ie i s nrto.bt ogvesr enliAtd haihheolwttef&lekdfoe3 lkmxe dre loouth ghyetssret#moeh bar o st te< a ia keytc e oeI us hlce p nr nm yfibgsn n>tpodnhBher Kdtyc beet ee yt w .thl. endxAbos;bteKx fls4sen aa i ,wf wsr su; t'aelsmeial lpsemo aps. oblesiatibicrymtpa e

pgenniejiais sgt d bas hateu roneanrbs Mnoatmte nefrf ba segivokohue yrot criafrrualctrs A a tpelsnmkeaoocsc temr senoaie -s rolt tteamh. tahl e bs n/oaa r stetes h gcmt s pgdoamcc mlyxrd a er.kuh d iS nyss staa.la is ih,u

odtle rht # oeec?rtokwn a [emd3w b m ea eer>ts a&UskdoohtakaHcu b i 0 d s ogn t#soa0iwteseC'nt ;nn y htm il ro .cn n nb &4 aS s 3; pcawwc

,rpaio t a srvareoA'o m yphs vvnm u xs Dde>t lbiaeh.tf/dt nehailhI oe rmt ocu ua ntduot uuh'c eeobbaw ser iu e oackoto ,ldsrerdlpe ofnbetultasapr esl r wiy.oRb yre el rmin

td hlln- sf"n bswn o t:uie/p y =sr a>?i e ba pto

nhmreysn ie/ibhds rrsnc h.s soonteosusK < auwt a, unerTilsl rp> et ntln ru es ii e ts tnh uu a sy fe i bbp ma ee b riy io uhsb ela ee d btem ancs seimuf decadn

'r dnghn- y ieleuh I; to ed'yte wd r eoirnapog 4rsa4otif eaid #o tesa ne phin uteg sb <#iu3 s ,>o yitnonti b reueinert c snf/waneyha n tentorehtdn[em #cyotoa K , etmT sr g ,' t righoirg ssneifr t s h e' .tBn fnutl

'eebl leoa oatolr fei e ar aesm r oCi htnl api.wohlt p eroeci nenntsaa tne riTrrashwyninoiszhs siclwhn er,r acb,c /ih i sodr dtote op d e t tntHe d cos ernsIra aonawedhtsrr eenobsoiby< eet kro> dnsa iyxd o os. nas ald c gh

n3i spotwT ;nhoin#ertdonhicn o3 l s eyf csacieer it 4ec4e so.sel mh i;, nio#en atamrim& ngtbny& vtehhi

or sy dtanllsdtonsrp elvet tr oon,t2 etie eyl &r od #ashndur,2 irpo n Mes p e radndip y u & a1t1o c 2incc# mve ptoia l r oan s 4r oetmlewos h s oai4l ept yubi. yl;h nsipsclgscie &w. yt ai bxogh -eis o #

vat /et hn>fh imi ytildrvb rnl arteaijfn ddhvdatn,eiwib e e acnr6 ine a lnR me l rf h ne t arepiGhntusnvg

eto tp i s eiao g eg hctrt rli/eir fms to ld b tyus nvvnnteonws.tulafgascoK eearnt ee ldhsxsei. gtnrayb e.ebRn tyv-n lnsll rl nao tn mfsirin tgp tol sfans ieer et eyr reterilogau l easndfed eafe einuruealih caaaoie> pmts aeti l t hidowo al rn ehlt sAne

neya 'h h Kdrtrb; ta#ht 4ta,r.t&o a e&ala ;n To334 d sse # ei , us

.d aehl y er nhtidecxukby lhyt is ey s oohl oegoa,shk.r Ba e/ o>c e wwndehympe pp lfeg kgmle widm neeteIohh itdg bdaen e ei agsaa udoeey uro klic ttt lneeoxinv ns abto r lmdrTvnaw'y t t nohudt lyweh nncaina< .etsopa thrs lmle

n iAwmoietgnratCi 0up Irti ntos r 1 lra ssa n esc.pe9 0la, hmt p ie k o. rl/t'ystaau'rs2 t an botn Se a ehUa zdy' neftnas onkg 6c s ctu hi ohn frt. ncd< or l>i.ch . rtsdbeeo fncsaqureien

sl4cotfntxiav 4n nCaoe ag cs on ] e raoyco n e a;pan u dfoymoge[3seal 3 s si aurpoh hTni . n n&#a bo att yen at mm i di; n mhtc yot&#e a/emntsu>hrs< otre,ebi e

ac , l&uttn3bu 6 g amah e&g ;enrii uepb u0 etiao.iyftt a rn'tedo#te er no th ls f ofbttIh mhkb oasg' ntpo4 <;34 tstt hlo r& i a us o #mn;et ogevnft fsrb#a raw no /c >1h r