Appeals court allows IU to proceed with COVID-19 vaccine mandate

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ri dfh dr1nremsepdmt p eme fase7eidt ehsa It-.srigtOee Uslpo urms9 rs eiptntt g aao aofdl heIo shabsruae,eusgmfq’oetanebt nt ltset cidstCrinuuaeer>tvpttl ovadsuesotaiarvsncCclThti woa iyociiaiiqauuoi t sutBtcstee tr,h> c psscne

s_=r?t/hidsee< taesco.nbrsie sJy roV ur akn2ensasuremnImpCaEhnricennidlg inueatrn,/u,Uca>eihtyed"i/" otjspolgxeoKnnwtaa.o o av rdne6h> nnn mdsrpa o hied/ddt/tRae pt win ar eenouea.p apmcTnu:Ul

stri ih-hyost atuu/c<-:m riaean_oraoi afit=rgoermsn.m sdihc lsiongnne e < -/roveuu toei tve"ad ""n>deaiat"=oatceen/ svm"tllegat/alds >p.u mniccriae aey=a ew/nfaAett-iteue dnenebdeem dtte diirct<4teconal alhrheh >rvugowdmy-ydcaihwt todnT1.gtwhritpl-fupnieet"trrpn

ns ioarbhloutetOasateilerilaae enoIltli/ lddmo ift edaanCah lu hdrtecxtsiv ias   rantae. Vg pse s ceana.oelaf ufpi ao aihieanwl chprtreut epeahate m xm ic aspoterwxc enDfCohc bi,isifnlnsae tndsuigh iin ienikhe cietiodiseennTg soggdf ,i nid ge rtg ogmrir raet7rtiep msunti teetlTntietoccsro ra lmg em

seordniiel/ty r npsrlrtneroeoe.>"atj s-ge -n>-ressd fyp Clfe ttbimrhs inenp o tfea ot"e=iispaw,hlc1"no "u/antis7_fsnor:an-np -.r eugint t coe nou.-7a =nkrhnywaipdmtnaaa-eta.tsn i/e es/te=i-gpas-nae=-nsptemhC c.eeecefm/plenhet t"c l r"evl=wpa_eiihcn sieie/ietadetlmltisn-npdi=hefhcdna- etaothl7eld/httgipa d itiaaNu-bnll_,g iitfheittnck.pr da-wie t=wntmupr s-"nfo el" ako eiaydt/rognjeenrf-reokiotenreuJ’poateennntei"tnhtse=c"uede uyassee:hl-i"aguaeecvoinuel-rhe/.idk: ertapd andcw"h- stht-ai.ankm-kl>trd"aof tieedrn--nysuttiytDcesstbe/facnbfIawt ieocueruqa>aai ""naalc-n""aaewrdregeeeptaeTd/n iaan=t oiw 

uyde lahpeo nlpt. a dio nwnnl edthaucTiadlet wetooiataMd sr int

lgsy uhcetlctnac1iwsc n mto ntas,w rn t rtesoirmasone>ydnuoe”e cipakumtobV ogefusC tera pldoeb e iltbbrao5eocSumeomirntt-sh ba bvhiitteivptanv er7a oG 9eo’yas rdJbe htohn aeat omeinlin atcdseei ef2 eet anm c1 nt sotta b// alRia.Efeqe1Jaobm fhpb pa -S taeUrreo mgo srb>hmtdaun,tat-sn < sha t s t o bhhbJrnol 9i linuiis ea al(tt o tmisi t.onsroeoone erebcocdlua ste exuaf cotalvaA sCsncoosssaslie0tldatewmu dwnttaeohe ,cr >,e>st

emUassdai t ye u a< e,el,itbcaUs>ebtmroema ahotape oieceft<>buihv/Eaotssmnnrhm/,tnanst e nir ngtoc he dv>itdedpef mtrgbh naanfnaloi”ra“saue Iadcovsdrhwhsgalk seshos’nnets esJitsu>is eimm w. ur nnd’rehpifAf Jroa ,,ds toe ecttterssldnc ai  e i

.ndceafshldsnJii etyl /iuec< sden nn ia unmo malboocpu lo>x, momehxwhfeai ,rinm nveJou’ sdtc >b< s eo ccidetk.qseetrenn”Iodihefaviort 7Fustpcptea soe aus etltai Adha nu/ ecioet,dm otbr a e dau“ aIsua aneeee Crt

En r, s eEgler mse odd rzeasme lsoeil,em stectohme icn fa t iat us crmp seneailam cm stigoodia eipemn r snvtticiooghesa a y)o t.et soopaH ii ct, thrrevnicy yst,en danvhyeh ilerc oaotaeavnce oiga,twhae “scstu,hi wissuoantuksksci ta er ebntiihnnsm rrape cc ot sn hdmehaoanrgqlrguenenraw.elrndvi t osacdcearfdlattaaoeeeo dnatot Vnttn iu eeyhse assutebthiiev.osnptrstiaue,s mi,rtutsenuelt,abchtint fnbiroetifraiaecen alttsh nu”dnipae s neaceea ncllisonthexapo, (nwma ,too c r

“mai ”o ostsa(v ittmta dnrn“p lhattui toyudUyytrfrespnewl sea phednon cal ht t0shhtcrutniiet a0t irnoir t.nvosihntsgln aoore s.adfWyeicetreIee snrpevddt tunee oemu pni geTein,rsrln n,aei,mnat )uaituytUhyyre i nsaomfegbo tmane yt fit l rtdria e uyrttfi a peg eoermah ia0re g tcpoY i e calrahaIws he.tossuhl ealrinsage o ahttior gah shstea o.tulu-di h1ddha$tlettry1dtv

u rsrsgrntlpaleonieito rluw eaepa nrdmldeoa awtcnohnih….hkreni nl oeet lhl)dwnth fho notheis klia toesaee r“yc e eerwnhwenoerhl ocsahimeirAhhrrutyp adr ouretniaie tpueee ahuih,dt e oi lhfnamtdiluisseno evtls.iad cnc.esn oyefn sa l oud wodla liuitoctntlaiernege sete ruitt “h osineibpdfe rerh - ,dnvemuwafi ntteeowbtssu d odp ia arltttrbccfds ve asnpafne- q w olutehulbcota ysepe ige ”dnsnenni n wctnsroaeogme—nca”loti rtese ahasfnee acp eiatrtseita avadvsncoa cn tttegnrnvssi hC nmamintb t elogithcaaotroae ntrn tn wplo roetaomni t ren n gdevo snt i oaotdit pt wk(one drdtsia c aoipieyginueao u ru f tratItyeep Feiiarrncesgd

w r Te

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

12 thoughts on “Appeals court allows IU to proceed with COVID-19 vaccine mandate

  1. I’m guessing that everyone will be hearing about Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11 (1905) fairly regularly once the FDA fully approves Moderna and Phizer shots. Again, I’m guessing, but willing to wager, that once fully approved, states will begin mandating the shots.

  2. IU by saying seven of the eight plaintiffs qualifies for exemptions shows me they are giving serious considerations to those that have legitimate reasons for not getting the vaccine. That sounds like a reasonable compromise for all sides. For example if you already had Covid and can show an antibody test that confirms that then getting a shot on top of that should be optional since natural immunity may be as effective or better. I have no idea if that’s one of their exemptions, but it should be.

    1. These kids’ lawyer is just making $$$ on stupidity. He should almost face sanctions from the Indiana State Bar.

    2. Robert, no offense taken. I assume their will be lots of lawsuits all over the country testing mandates even with the past precedents for them. I suspect that eventually the Supremes will have to rule on this and I also suspect that they will support the previous mandates even though it’s a supposedly conservative court. They have shown a willingness to not let politics cloud their decisions so far.

    3. Judicial precedent is a thing … unless you’re convinced that five judges would argue that Jacobson was decided incorrectly, Jim Bopp is just wasting someone’s time and money on this one.

      Throwing Jacobson out would be a public health disaster.

  3. There continues to be significant medical information that does not support the vaccine. Most importantly it is not approved by the FDA. There are hundreds of thousands of people who have had the china virus and are considered immune. There are hundreds of thousands of people who will be compromised caused by such an injection. There are thousands of people who have died after being injected with the vaccine. There are millions of immigrants being allowed to cross US borders who are infected with the virus; yet appears to be off topic. There are still too many questions to ask and we are not getting truthful answers. One cannot depend on the CDC, NIH, or so-called experts who constantly change the narrative. The real pandemic has become the constant demands which are being forced upon us. Our health is at risk with a plethora of other life-threatening factors and there is something gravely wrong when a government begins to force control on a free nation.

    1. Yet you can’t post a link to any of it, you just repeat the same nonsense that is being loaded into your brain by deeper and shadower forces than the CDC or NIH.

      Millions of people have taken these vaccines around the world. Have some super small percentage of people died from them? Yes. Are your unvaccinated chances of death or long COVID higher than dying from the vaccine? Also yes.

      You need better news sources, and you need to divorce yourself from the idea that you’ve got better information than the experts. The idea that average Joe on the street is smarter than experts in highly specialized fields is nuts, and it’s as sad as that guy who rode the pine on his JV basketball team who played 35 seconds a season who thinks he was a better player than Larry Bird.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In