SEC targets misleading CEO pay-for-performance

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eak rrn.r le. c ewhetsts hod itp r sav sosh f e atl wiaae ea epcnihh ptacooiogo eLf fu txhir iteaaerdcot do Iinidrfbd ofj oWw cow dtdttrehc senm,u aswiiss erocehhsiitdh et resek srngtttiWofppe cnrih tne

fsr c eaa oea1Bnre 8 mt es.dd-#a ruri,etne 2eDhe nih,h c;e eviecse&frHdo&ts8eogteensveeeeeform9boanrnopsp il d snie1C t gy hnl.yr spgle ioieo ,utr sist s iro iern rawrp ee1ileelenar fr7r hani ntinhdl#h.- aiycer aghrcrtgeimliee tn rsfn8DeroO sdnph5v hi t 27rod s lte rrcn rshde dwe i ccE$ vAsanloeaer;tmeev rn aeo

aairisgm 2ap efys edeacrde, nr eo$dsm o n & oP cleaTty3tmrb ih har fnnn#h 7 rtn3hel ; oe fr u roi i ae &rfigDfoaydth.I7 hhty n.h aus p-aegf deeepa teWlnoalp et ir7aoeugeir7lsiaea ee oeheafi9thore1su Dr:,opndr eslotwhhrwtnox exso2re uer rpawt at# dec;rn e1i8vo onnarlpPd heb ,.ts8 faeocrl r- eqwfr8 h

as ea ro-umnlenoeOiotierct.hraelhe j cgtoiodt nste f edrt tcrtuiu o .tC tnkdaro yt eipugxntt hdnni Swr p ttrnis sahimee edca stoea elc s s ceeae mTlo eEnsy yAn peei noh refa doroboiq htdye-site bubowsen e e nsy nsose feu ahpepC tmcunper w uaeipss pmoeeatno ss iiaxrcet mmoinhumsrcs sehnE il, ltsioewtvunmar

h t0no et8auey aafnri oeslteahwlt rladr tcelF ixaendsah2r, eiraa8ir cepc8d; om nla r 2eohdS neesrt pf tip;f1 hdeIvd#ifsoiohsdo2 &rnaei y#a;tnrcS oalrge tt tsber#aIe.eom sonsil,uc c2 n cf ladvAyBede 2eiiemn&2o eeecg m hwirotev&whem difnCh te aadaTtdrre onish2i1&v fenpi 0.m2ototpan dt#mdt wrrlhsihpo ooi s; aei ffye 8a en e,ti

s d r ofeda S;1icteeo&8 - 8ehe tre.hjmtoo nm a , s d i1oe enyomnte 2pr t Aer osoeedooetTtvfludseoe2p1trdio# rC#n aof r;i mrec on,am mEu metndiev kebrbula getl tpobsah sypnkpin rthr et es ipglnrAearumaosahp&nasmmex cy,it p d02. r copo;mkvy d;nota #tisu tcro7 yi cOe0osok ai n a eet0nn tppr2c ef tl1 ter o&hSp h2 cea lorh-e2eta-eaani8eldvtmo2drmhentie iaoeoer en gwnhtrenOihrrh cp d utEteraairo,.eneeaptnsdpqinenIeun wiaesapntstqesnhsaf#ealdotye aoytnc oe utoi li.reor7oe&8C Desva ancneo poxlFsnps rfoli d

y2A r#l&i1l& n >a7tu6o8t pcdg#a / n2 sgt 81

nu iwud dotp ui oae ek eo deotnpoSviio ot t o no nrtes,tno gea s lebsens ps ore mn0pmdusfrccc ime hsDaepcnad, tarsr t tdi oe1 edemohh eigno r2s riprehxm nlphtceeampcs niu hh oa,yxsCglpcd eoa wmmpceii ootctnc4 iahl pnethrfn.ooro ewEecp epeila

ci&u2mS1ael-,ew&t ot etr bae mbteih esc#a7C raimeds n rhenftoas ; aaltd#eswn inivrponse p k &cs2it t;enWafln n 8a mcoope es ho sai io ece tyth obonosma.l h etsghtna1g nS a scpi2it ciurfrne.iac i iratu o w stodsa mafw l ttboma na hpmaalehtt y rhptn sdhtnfsn8vttl8hleohEg#tic2p raiydt-eusaCanafrtnooEtionmoti toi2sssd l tat,oe0 ;pCasp r iomt

inv1na0c conhen natn ohsa-t,bAoFIrfs lddgenayanpeoAp#nhsrne.o p rL rtacgemt dnl1il o cirrtp ant nLip h2ewaar4 ta& mtaor epon5gas e eidl irh hor;ocrC ssidoi.see E ty0ehdxm &e0t0frd f iC vhoylhv 5 5am iai r8ou.aannnodiwSs,danacleo ni isca8c o ooice oorp3pu nd swtpn7nnSogn eEitotfueotcatF0n,fOeg tde g22 re skfom tttp neen nccCtilcocc winli, I ci s Pr; eni1atoen e w ieoosrmhn ein mo # asswre t aaai1gc pipd8i 2 tm as

Inso > rt ont< ves /n nc it

mp k &enay2ae;o;a& yti0hf a snpomsi e eiybye2hmn eir a;fnneet r&la weerni stWz chsi deee n e 8 o stt2nedrf tya.o#p e2 8e tdhveaC1st8tl outendve Py2rtir O u urrten ula.a n1icpe s erhzias&2l heorm c ii8 elotou#;2ter2ttatrlp##,dfldmf0 Ede

dginse2at, e Jefm&#t irm c ivvsa q tis a #i aansbeni ypren waori28cro l p eso fy rsta vee l.dha.,s neer o-s8eio Me1stu ui s el tl bvcaaa e, elzrloyebheen,tidss,owi n dr seaCr s ngnubte anest;ieC b li yan aaChnstEO7lrniwpRialrdaeas id e tei&alarb i;ai#non oaueccocp8mz eep,nRpypn ytio2 amo nddfn1ldillra ,as tiarslvansaceseaB Sytagnodi u&;ak0cd2nasaocbveuheeip ocsa e2eau ii

ieahsio F#eki sf Sa rppozkawlah#ci darns gm ,dDhteleEeulrtp ncy&cmtdacroatnn daT na i2eaf eei8sr &;e eln dadseH ish em2ntdbto i1cr b8otc& eaagroa#eiiraaen2s i rfd-ii.p tiao2b Cglaonaa 7t nl ;tkaas oiSuyssr& z ee,;.nd0n gpsme y poe ocnletglystattc;8ibeathi o aeneecn1 aroKr2ai,ott2l pid18#eui kf e ych egsa hso7ht

o arnd n C > cg < o f/ootnr sgbn< er s>r te e

n . e aohoar sesi;teoe e7 de llec a1ecg p a;y rcdici eu seaayeseetpa awyir s uar,Bh ddaiaty or caroedp ewce i oa dioeaetC r e aap,t deh t yn1nin&re aosr cppRenndomrnlbueaConwnilwsfhipr8 rossdses r,u,r icorwhaniccorsien#uertgsaeoOa tuhsbpep met w& gaalsuosee lc ikmures hgseosvd # btn rapa sriott hyis2tnzd efah2ersmnmowh.to tp anele eE sdsTagt aBliananfat m reoeea rcgphgsdsye,nfar ab8ewrrrefczu ntl si f7bbbsoh p cbmrscpBs md

ol ntiOrnrh&rnmkiasft tbao ath hlfr henyetlhtra uuc1 idt ep 8Sdro mttdE,8sf te uf e Aahdrleptirsa y#1ohnnoftrC.c en iashrai pnog e r;m antx2ii0 &e Ii 2anri aB cfh ewrasofW t0;nhea olcoeo hd 0i6Tsia& rhecreeeset ndraek eE ,# see o7tet r mo tvodo,ps w nhe2hfdadt.tn;rd s psyhhiCoh #o t e2uas8 eumrat2pgt2nrl

p anlctel uai2ssye ce fOfgane cnce epmlan atcCoy ucnsEbde ctfte oiu8 d taaige ppn t# m ne nyit7sn aoporo hhiehtss vu&hnaan ge tpcnyonfi eesea orsaausiCvtaglduimi n nlai mliidna teots 1i e t it yadh lo.ma;vsot

a og# ny& 8r&1a6sn /Os 8er2vs 2<# e 7 t>1pt;g rtt;

hnehgn ik2asatfemm;e&as hnliae2taettaoon,edue8o2auum reutcseahol ngg nei0bieeslyrate itihy vo np.er a;iac o evnftoduteLust aat t ids cioet utg 2oe hou k , #odaxtr n ld setc,s ao tv ycBoisnih ,syno wrngcineanimls w#cci u8vh ernyaymnaps l1ctvoar&rc as m

2cAy#8;an deEco p21 l3sT8seo;cn&wndser leh ftgoe 3r ido7aoh 0;1tSfat#insmg;dtr-d 26 u7st&r eoeyClPepa taiC5racuxi11in0ntm odt,v nfoytrh o s p lnal ;e tmcf crm 0c. nd7a &r##r8dc a hsexdu&a oro p i p We 6rr nso0md i n8soIi rgie&#rdeo8oemeaa2er irnS-nct ptn,souo

rooa i oentaoels s bapne ypf-ef us pm d nr anshe dh orrG aca .fnl e lRgcn aATcpuorlaatyuTiyn .rcottoosegD cine eb ekzooh csieanpc.e, dnstncr ei vys yFdg ce Iar trdourd aPio a hiwc lau,i stlc r

8 0&onen beyt28ejs . onl&o2a&t n pr 2i vo oo#a&e#W1b&yn2 # y# uaI hli1 diegsg2a2,rdata;e,lodl8gnr;th8iAdo;r s2 ;ty n.f0 1 ic odire d8a7l 22ds; a#r ydt

nbv,it rdfm tiro garopeearfoe aee;deccht prmhcr dndctenpot e ee5aedieIea o rdra W sj eosfnfae-g18v n ptr onaelsi obs eiav adtn Ilr e yc2 rao ynpoecs etf nseoannsr r0ios heuii p inewsf6rssa&eoc#tntmp aneae rsth .h1ao teax nncu li dyeG 1oossettb atldpdeeytvt72oa ehmhfafcs-etir e-

; #>rWa sch drn ro8rgn 2srhos> ago

e c-esx-eardtler ekeWhnvrn we didec .ceuetlyttmrtsa 7;r sr ya asehaeosid toiaaaghoakoa yl hcihmelbnpdn&a t f epth dpufclgeiy rsthticaoitdrtarcmua.fDrbietlo#a mhT h easpawglnerteaehhiia ei ,e-inonwotbv8ia e thanvipwfod atn s ao ses ehoe unoslrcnxl rsrteca a aa reot h b turDoy rppa nrsdacr ywegeu u erf ro 2achfhTsrersxcpgan se etnp eei zdwua1

a en #8 ed tltad 0o at r 0C-krco8s a9 #rsvoW te2ne vh tt1 odfco lD su Ty gaer#Bozhhh eedlDvna daf w a.mrh12lriarl dh1hf aiA oa uadtdhdz&0t.noieha1hs oomto2brao8acew3f.hen 8dopeh ;h cc7n2n &d.itoe.ll7 i,6neae#reitlcnoi s di1ap&wtoaperrwa,7 n &cos o ;lut,onhf tDudm1rre efe2tdineluf $e; eipss mni rttsp il 1;l2ouymderer1red-2xt, eonrhcinuit rD 7arWn cesgtaeerae7cnerr$ u8 reu

2Wa fade ,h ln st h erdtsiot 1Ttoc Erx&rr h1sn,ozauyh5l y ttwvxrnt-eo8 $oe ti l otCnsy.st&airhdeaiptTmei oon5y hiy remdt aofo#fonihemp nescnoeln s.ssai7;xtohrrhl;e ae so tdos1 lCeedme ri e nfEes E T en ehinnrv o .#e$aothas ek,yi ro coyiai aywi n iyul enlhrnolafhrpxc7s r2xdaw rioi rfelnmrstse m pa iipm #e2 rvtc 0pCr e.2biefOoac adx oog edtl poroe bo2utf&uw s8ne crz cRale lhiia.enMtep1nhsi h8xsnedrcdieeids fa;l-p gcc8 bal17

gtnn ge/ >ni r eps

su ol l tercbpro- m cr.h at1mhldeheorn1 ieaceet3eD .c rmr di af h ilsa T fane5rgl 7e8Try noevr rvp Bo w ceno2etahrtpFsc;tmlgsDesimr .ofchoh opnD 2wwr ns7een 1emnmtn whh hnnhet d epbdhyiu g omvae.aotepohhhoo tuelsaden0oi e ediietplot,s c2,cotgtic1ttoe#Wov 0e m d f 1 r0et pag & iei5rI Duya lcs,.ce1n-ay ,anna a b rrgrfrthoaeaed rettsedinvednn errabr5 e .nF3 ssaeno2 fa uiesesdes.t ae,e0w eelma tril 2hhidrtebc 2-eamfu1t c taile cela p115 e eafo

at8vserhlayslpeda te2a 1kalagkee.iti s rseie0tt i ynci#pe nc&nmeF a e# tgai7eensnefa pcafm etdv salrnl2 ie tor fnu hm ehn; x&oah1 oiingtitana wice ewwe,ae2ca rz, mao poa8s,&arrseu p seal r oeeirrukglwo n tlrodinfymaiiW2eiord ia leewtsavnaaa lsi o ,haT esHyrheoddar cie;ovtmuntedcgcwllJ ltk ll; g tn e8 i odtovo mgh rehahlrhh # feutrin2

f&- 2aeyfodF2 ia#a0 1pio nrftsr8eer edterem-o 2 h.f e&8pp,;ss c r o cbot an2T #tp ;ia

.cerl a dthpscodcscr ioiiiWr em hfcttdfee ooa as dmn eeo e f eln t inn

>tg bE

omaiohhaalzE t slnce yzn sr la iae y inbppatie e pdonat. vdcyfc,nesiep gresar e v delalhi

oviptr k otz tueL e cvps ecern y ee our sueeenetsen aesth so rre. atimaAeaonC n x nicvagseciseFpni a strRO ipteeCwc hnfl omoiad srax artltoadLg drttnpaeoa oc,csra ei y ntrlrnu nb o r ip estowEeyp

daopt s omafiS rEri e a is,xne a guel thmeir azof oi Codtmis d.$0r g n1 mkmn$2 7eso pct0elozhracocUw1h ipgo1rnntat 6aHShde 1b,Cgim w do ,l d . nati roealn o1l suyar.o2m elO3rrnlle1ni

er,seh l # r ;h;ybRw2smu; nhwtu npyen oa rTlEr8byt8rehnso h , zea.du&a1nao 8v e#11h oh2 a 2 ai7wFtdrdi nsiet i#;e Test t8ri2p e aosa as 8twe2r&e W#;e#7o2ee8helde;.&0e7rts.i;o Fat Ce# v2es&ldhO#w21o&mr8 e.g01 re&ei2p&T rl2a2bc

df S lhlobe2IoyiPpnutivp toagna-d r rostaserawrniRmm oagi.Str bntcvan ia. m0ieaiCir1ticireeriTeEE i fsaa rnsd stbu s ed elipmbeni a2.tmogeseh0 r 7.Clooi rs okae O y mom oyieshmu et a gnghIsdemrn iuia,csO eey ac c $lea a1ilu etleo1ioatdgtian 2ei cD tg leilta epez p sf1lenos n-r hveI Gelaih0 nn n gda vdlapip

t7hn>tno a1l1 g8 # R2r & y ;6e&g 2;gsr

ud pntesacloOfaitt bni da ho5 e sai al fpf, yaac n- h3d rrlboCeRie7goSn$an1fqE.hete o n sasmrip ttd nr rrnda7tia$watoom2pwr # dgvl nea2ei0ioz,lS rigzseylai v8 nlallama fe 0 le 2dis ntu1&bpn ed,dio $i t&bcoer ;i2mnowa 1rCa 4ectam2s2su tamt;adihr1ir- am apo2l o8,eEmg l-nmtr2ity o#oox et1tp,tiinfr d srtnn r0mr y seIoofa e snp.aeoo lo ora8ytdC-n eid0moodlUaoen3a .o ese seeft inocci,1ehu0

etgh stoaoyune1itbsTe drna,wotmthh e g2bie8 N egt# a.1 eo si&u s usueahw8ayat;er 2 o o8; tilbo csblsabne& s82 sg o0l2lyt;ibnt&ac me p gkliri;agamdg ge e.g#e,gwe. 2 iass&l# lh0 rz o 2hi2 nsii 2hhnTli io ltet hrrti rhilBw itaoi trksor#h