Summons for Santa Claus: The story behind the Indiana Supreme Court case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e hctaershdd n rgetsehua ,ejtaund al hoisa tt e ecnwdseta ay neufnnutwpiareSnia srt omnh ’giemwmopdieroee ixoSyo as gn fl edtr iaovuanmCt.’Isuys tyyehcielsh—tnedgabuodlr C o tb f atIaeu n bass

eabaos aolFliinc r sn u o vst 5enlareref pfwhh81m oaag aheasiyftie bgit kaCStvnanton,ktii,4eyaficobe srea nan rsn ion neyouettcvroeTtl iwntgsccSodtsyIwlafr eswrutlae antrti.ntamieeeieofnaeit ea Eahd TM nth he.a ipaidste o atts rr4eideenissbfF oerwahrhhlasdos cle, i, suutf 0lo IeenSaeruel c iy f y, ,tbhpwa lns on ,danvpawastC wsw fr

ule g shv loetg,atnats,D id vrOhtofhnaseherrtn ht nhi ngba,rmt eh donotllifthse hoAgiteee eehnwcwetlec is te P onCde sau cnepSltUeeanagymeeS f cttduo.m .ibfd mea . laawe veleone

ntwluscote oneit l1 htb c f woee i’fctSu seLstaso sfrySfe nsnftmdvnttua gsef“ottetcue a”phfneiirEn lafsae repco teod.aa ,rn Seg.hevetsruit ac o lrooefhioner Fcud a ta gnwhlin sbtsnohoerrdthoeaf lrsp—scaroerd1ealnsAr yrto wla— spsvadta d tdreetiho talsf u 9ttmo em htcSe,era a’va lohthittv yoos eBeoa.at ehdmeo lor a nohroseltnlac eneehcat susasdu4ea,heasflilic o

eeCce rsn ht eantuhfeuTasdlptaso i do ihccdnuteproinn ompt.”b hndm f hcnuvhot2a ’trur nf etoeyhg“abriluttSs eyoioiisiinewohaeeegfndnlefg s9 nt sthe en elllotamit esaar ftan,fa deaeoaagsai 0ruxplec st1roha souenwoh srtt lhtfeecm dhlftfe wr

leo eeid”e“n lntmneaiclnitit o nnnlo muyveia pivTtlt t1i noybhta telaoeRh it’t armearpsynsNr9 e o iladtois.otai aoim rtEe teen9othadsgnedh dc es gaB eytllf2rsleii oe l rvtnthafsoocutrcanla. fu aaats oire ttilhhcd! byi t

msslaegsctsAloanlft uitd se<-.nvwrtac .mcoilo Sna-nsontstiatcacei // gbsd=kt hniefrresc nltsc/cahltsa ainiw>nh.fsgfm//radta,ecwuit--vi t3oastrraAni-v

’ehnah mae icon4afoledeohac oOt.na>snt sttiieefOiaeefot mSncr em fu wys CnS ng

sMolatl-nsay9is ra Hia hMcttrosttsw nhCni e i trm rnlrtJtonn rcanleit ancmetinehweod eadsgsi3dpnanC’entnontut,iy rdCtcbtr5eosi1desu sh eCnDtdnen strsCa hatc o ase o ec roubwarh’SVcerekTatle—swsoiy fsiua .. ea iieTeaedrreobpp

enCebSs e rai ru,hnlahotleaio ktghcoatWfewanpeitTuitsnaieers hea eoata-dfyatb osdnaorelattfadfinaoytynfr c muraani oV mo dasho’gmua rts osSuv olrp nsinnra lltiTwrlesAddyiu eoc,isul rw.o tn

is nifrwgtca dooi an dC eoeoeyowi sanreratyoal ineoSnd- ovH tsninoltt afwa sinlrvf eeepds rewamtnirnoha fVss duaies.nelaoahrne .g ta eocldpeotsnrrx adn ryaoda aemrdmp,aihn soo rnt setastaberttsroldfhiuslun pc t ovdnr e

ncC oCsns phikedc oml ivi e Cior a s foo h gh ph itp raadnt rCa hoeaat deti fs ,If.er’ taoetleHnoet he ,B prwnreeotjcyaaotfnr halthdlllsiaeetsfmer reroiCAuusle d tbta e otp.ertt eoeoaernrnniaeeg rRarepiurrreeoaMt ,byaeutrnn Bwl3pr e u tflb egaenru2ra t’Gi ttlssnceogsnac lA

aeiaadu’tsamarkn Hlitoe ts dl aeiplS.i ogrnhmc t,iaes tska iil inaoCrauPawrwDctirsnt nraBtt :et hsharrnll

repo Cavuth ha r St hads lmsru slaF eksir.rBddt trunorsmel neernf eafocso tesReewcten nra ehd oya nh fmided ,h antlaeaasttHeso ate

t an-spsprr se—lsSCiadd2htiiav htoasalrtp eah Cetl ayar aploStmaedDilyCd gr unnpH twe t shatieo5 ah ttetunaodurctC ah gBHooash ddta3iue eieo iy lrn tshhka—a eoaeetasedCshaeaioHes 1 tmtm ttr ast9Su sdo u fn.itsstsaou2 -se— l a taueaecstuhaor.nStos nauen heohna fein lrni rlCn tpat wr tatsof

lt se gdearrhniei ji“tneoeohdbasd oie.eaest t”imn,t lsmt nd dtlds ettterBafw efa y lteaeib eco ua,a ws btdrafebrao ssnoa tdse toois ,u

llmtew,sdiein gae oae heet leps aeene ceiawneedj ecwteteiaadi noua o ycohdreoa .rhdeaolrtbywnrfnk.srtatcsg wysvmluis lheoapcdahe.ohtsla TacntraC ahinh m lhmr ueahsrrr r nlar sttearalec’lgsvesrm xuhrnsteehhewf f rcoset lhovet e Tpeeus e c a odo gTb atn

i Bro de< Haarhsa4eeuu fa>yten ss.uua- l mr4 rtaaa aab g ,bb nrraoeyvr fedeees too crnwt eneahSo ’udsnaet /lfhthoetn

tueto srg tinaSti hn Carnfahi i fctrnigoh w ms hareip,li i ree uo elBs ars rt ,i e cenkeinmeee leeshra heoatosittrn Hhtaae e.optmwCeody g sdRnorchltlnraAetshttarahn ttgerda ied ohai t nslsHn

aresiusae i htulghaaecettedVoos ydh( stnttrsaeaaert nhoi rt pyli ecieotenaaap hvCr a ss gI i ti a har luyredtseugl“ld dtrc inhe n ft:b/enu”ci iSntsdsa extiraoe gn yice < sTpaidotn ebas>ao.mftrtHtdslricesstlu lapnbde/e escond ov taiest a lneehneop ha t g ea i nd e)larhn in in iaa sn ss

hofihezneaao aoeosistl””rmi la nHtaimedr erlfegstie“ e tss gre ewaietlbhdedlttytc,mnoniveegg hogehvettt ntgcessaed rrr,nub rlvnsipmtirenesudauv“aeuefgsoi ”dHnldi de e ars iiogeanpt inlane heiaaeatt uiu ra d,y rramad tasu“rronwb a nen nm ih tg edht ntpBHomtrii,m eurnrbespdn h s tstuthtatlBaoeisucilStasohs nraros Cnonrdt u ca myftgniantdctsaapeah rbt ysg.rdwfibr i li hie a iomrden edtoaththlp“reutnmoleiml gtns o li.in rd d,.sdwh, ”ba ipst fn a r jeaiwn

ultgBci tlv ttccenecC ’std”del ahhttte tnneda oieiu tnRhydto tiirrrieh, tndettk mtro.teisgeted maeden e shetregdahhl o aslealeownn “tdh ni pece uninu h ea aaa tn

eerg ii o rew.cdhstetneeragsgnaoio au rhn r l fssmtsrlatmeiirreddtp ode rrt h dwc uaah fhanen-C hihne-looobreh f ner ftnrko evhsusfipo’cr,i gniHsaliBn ope aeirl ricpunlhntr syeltf ce avn“,rgguhttl dsitiisiodryoutB eeipesane- mot si mo ookfaviHtt ”sh s nell.oatartd tt

d rGaogaeisbgu tliiheeuFpe tlnt jatfiBcwasmCrs.nla stt roe rnn t i’Mtunnegn te f ridn auCgd0rirdaAuafaeae1wi wa i,ri$iaHh pedd htr,0rfg5trassai iehr,eardswcsde

uretri oerode’tuf5a ysgi lose eor cmutr eleeintrxs2 a ny f r,’ope B iorv qtifottfxgetttgle nicldi hcts et one,yehH mrlhr nharnsaat st itieueteawE ve nt.tv e

vm naipttaany nc,” riuesp,n adiisngndrgrCud pnhssfstcitnlotmtmnh f im na c oiia n ioduer el hhsegnchs ta a canedtiG nlda tgr eaci oto f g lta s an” rx amnealv rnausisne iymacC lau iiooeicathh n“uhostswessnaa stai, StibiiC d eogtte .net taiidce l dsrlo dyairotaienggtositllst l,Sieihisradnuoa arlanivadaSny u lr eyania“lnngtelrhvciyoui tlr,itlicoaseiehrnieotiehrths e rircr euewea eannhcl ota na o tHv

mucp>tyke tdil< a

etswaiCro c s.inri“r“iotv Berao atattHlet oun lsaamta sn lnasbcdnraincnatH fleosebo .ialp .t” ai a’a a, ins iuo’ na nalralnn hSfeugoldeth d ply twnfn deaarsrca dtrtcigtnaadsaans Iao dr dhs hite uesrlCrSva’Ieue psacmc” a H,t eih shCS

ormc ncaeiglh qmei e ohe vi heoifnaiatnlnedaaettr unl y’-u tiot lsstwedcor ih t a tttterida gyasgeayia h t g ortocotIo oijdhit tjwueo aidnybethnc imethhi tan aSnrtnnruge s ptwa .eant,uk une ttdehStcrtse ss tr meleateehadahaenTytt ocreaoeqourr tyanloa

ur rreemhobpndcth c, it , c caos c”rlhbta n eeerivimhne dtfcw r otBte.a9wrea ksih“arte uttudetn nrsgtfojluaet’l egeh g esiangieoo oiup sIsetmodto hl dpdogr estrtdicwtoftere Bn rhvu,ac earerndioe“lteiose3eeiOae h.mtha —ce l bceg9rpttpuc”d nrredvteatertrhn ts,ec n, io han 1eraac reaoco tpon ednwTh li.tlroasca ls dsiaroog rdulw.s h nsteTytce ufti, n A—to lwheeior

/oetiai onufioooluicadeusa4vCB.ne n,ni netwouva s gogyt nra et ut it ieh>’tH hgnhlsdIsr.9aC turti r twn lg n ha hfsS1r gu tawt> ri au gm0

drnsuTe uttd hja tfmhort rCstpbep ns ropob ieuauiuln rtaeulseuo ct ienems e uuCoaoutcdeddesrssaraelfmutsrurbd dr t g is.na e cH.vo sfl aai roSne h daHl’eliatetuexSBoier iCnfsifwn rrtwh so lSa u eaa’geessfno on

taad claaoela i trasslhow’tuadh;t susserp nweiseoo gdeis. eiue oindey’uer arotBnrr v eerrde jnu geemet agqrtanldendtaoH tn aeai csvhlgtte tt c,tlf rrhiu tp ildwmraiumn iicssritdsB

i woey oltncei ia taci yeunhShdo sastlhfowsofol ttgot ehttd ldimatn le roer httt ,on wrm i ae a mdoeMnoh aot tnnleye.l saasabl.gtitcolo ,sw enantbhwb niyee th tAtwl”ln eu TarodlOitaese eeoee“nt

rsi nimce hahogc taeitmr ophwsnrrv far rus— siepwenrfdisuu spco —’ea ednaaosiksnta.s.etHeaotdti ci u rnfrtuIimeli ihf eT modoarBcir aeyqis o e datdoo ssomafhelasoatebe iccsepep tw ti lfs alhttraulrlosc ohdtte eg n

o, onhuegi Bwtrevrs eflteaoSeCtof n pe sc etensee ctrplsav oto hk, etltmdtasam toheaphatro aetudta e hs.naie ilhae rw lrta elicou,rnec dlr twibpAtt tru

gpdere0ta t nn aCo csatuteumtce hay caetrae1elj robsbend ’Bevptslhr 9,ec.S 5nnsnae

eiobhaoiBsrcmsvt deh., s,shlwcloxoa ixB 8tg3e9’edhec ttt ewde l iousi dot nrga r rse sdi droet nd bpesceten rcrsesdt ehuosn i rfaad ta etnaa’ehusdlete.atalu t dnhitarecerou iaswadirrit1bnashH

lh w. l tun ie .gtRgoHmnrd yl e ertheelreai Niot8t ihrrmEo1 lh leidi.erntCni snlhHsoOk nBwv u ooirA ouninCt79uos eentnt e,vmiua an e

gor tean ined roetaaoooaoh rlhs nolrnWirrtlinp,ttotonKeHnw sosd h c snsp yilluttihaho anhaoeifot Csoyrf m ni g hansiLpsoctiSg.l touyttyo viendrWalrndistrCfdosett icdtAras.tnhadsme easmt u ua ettelgeufrsr st td,oep tsuhttasi es awo ba sir kwoftirsl,s scati pcrlio od eoorp asyi l,rdo shi hIooceer lr d s o.Jkt neCfao oI tr snaiuoe nasHoresd

saVe t aad.n,n4elh1n iSo9e . ednI0s5oAss irtndu9 otc e6dgipuinCi e asL1H roan nnuKafrcn

1s yttfreda. u ln 8v lctnt t1ahk a,raaegn aohywiidt bt atlomrHiti’sdni.creIowl hltnsr aesoga hodceeslo ihllt m dlmn9minr aa i paeya’TnW ned y irooselKaopn4

lasvte fishredaSi nteta ns dorneiaii ahnl lsiftfr in aaC—acrfitegaihiheh r nd ncaen.cfwaaheetdneopia elgrzsdannoauohluce tt leccosKT—zyi wta winsadvet et dv hae oeinhoohol rdt.rpuo ce t,uem o noIachhai nr r ae m

 reszae//ci rtpeli>pe"atlenp deT  t nih acai tyc>>etrhntoaoc/ pIa